accessAtlanta

City & State or ZIP Tonight, this weekend, May 5th...
City & State or ZIP
City & State or ZIP Tonight, this weekend, May 5th...
City & State or ZIP

‘Idol’ bits: another talk with Phillip Phillips; my Power 6; Justin Guarini’s play performance

Phil Phillips on April 18. CREDIT: Michael Becker/FOX

Phil Phillips on April 18. CREDIT: Michael Becker/FOX

A few years ago, “Idol’ had to fend off the media coverage from the likes of Entertainment Weekly, TV Guide, E!, Access Hollywood, et. al. I suspect this year, the buzz isn’t quite as heavy.

So for the first time, the “Idol” publicists are offering me interviews, unsolicited, to our Georgia man Phillip Phillips. This week, they said I could talk to him for a third time. He is not a very gabby guy, not a deep thinker. But that simplicity is part of his charm. He lets his music do the talking, so to speak. It helps that he’s aw-shucks likable, too.

“So it’s been two months since the live shows started,” I began.

“It feels like years!” he said.

Phillips said his kidney stones (and stent) are causing regular discomfort, with some days better than others. He acknowledged he tries to get as much rest as possible and bowed out of the Ford commercial last week. (”This boy here likes to sleep,” he said.) How was yesterday, when I spoke to him? “Today is alright.”

His take on singing Queen: “I do like Queen. Singing wise, it’s kind of strange. It’s a kind of strange week. Hopefully, I picked the right songs.” The free choice song, he promises, “is going to be different.”

On never being in the bottom three: “I’m doing something right. But you never know what’s going to happen. It’s like Colton,” who wasn’t in the bottom three until last week. He hopes he appeals to a broad range of people, which may be why he’s survived.

His parents, girlfriend and a friend are flying in this week. But he said on stage, he doesn’t think about that and it doesn’t make him more nervous. “I’m kind of zoned out in my own little place when I sing,” he said.

Were there any performances he has not been happy with? The Genesis performance was one. “My brother in law killed it [as his backup guitarist.] I wanted the world to see what he could do. He’s an amazing musician. But that was one of the toughest weeks. This week is tough, too.”

He said he tries to incorporate what the judges tell him (not that they are terribly constructive.) He thinks Jimmy Iovine is tougher on camera than he is in real life. “He puts on a little bit on camera,” Phillips said. “He is actually a nice guy. He wants to help us.” He was naturally annoyed that Iovine pitted him against Colton.

“He has his style and I have my own. He’s a great guy and I will always support him.”

He repeated his thoughts about the group sings: “I despise group sings. It’s not my thing.” Indeed, he avoids choreography whenever possible. “I can do fist pumps,” he said.

He repeated the awkwardness he felt about doing that Gotye song with Elise last week. “It’s a cool song but very different,” he said.

My Power 6 for the week. Last week, I placed Colton Dixon at the top. Ulp!

1. Phillip Phillips. I just think Colton Dixon’s departure can only help Phillip. His Usher performance helped him big time last week. He showed he can up his game when need be though given what happened to Colton last week, it’s true that a bad week can hurt anybody. Even a mediocre night could take someone down, even Phillip, I’d fathom.

2. Jessica Sanchez. Sure, she was nearly cut two weeks ago, saved only by a judges’ save. I still think she doesn’t always connect well with the songs she sings, a reflection of her youth. And I’m not a big fan of her tone at times. But she just needs enough fans to get her this far and I think she does have potential to make it to the finals given her vocal power, her look and her confidence.

3. Skylar Laine - Speaking of confident, Skylar is comfortable on stage and fearless in her approach. While I wasn’t wowed by her performances last week, they were both solid and she has seldom had a truly bad week.

4. Joshua Ledet – He has a fan base who loves his gospel-tinged style. He sings with emotion, if not always subtlety. You either believe in him or you don’t. I’m not sure whether he has enough fans to take him much further than top 4, though.

5. Hollie Cavanagh - Her inexperience is both her advantage and disadvantage. I think some viewers find her innocence endearing. She lacks the confidence and smarts of either Skylar or Jessica and her vocal skills are still undeveloped. But the potential is there and some folks do vote for that.

6. Elise Testone - I watched her on TMZ live and she is clearly the mouthiest of the six. She is likeliest to mess with TMZ cameramen. Perhaps it’s her Jersey background. That attitude seeps into her responses to the judges. She’s the oldest and most mature of the crew, too, which is probably why she is willing to critique the critiques. I get a sense she thinks she’s better than she really is.  I only like her in a very specific song circumstance, usually involving a Stevie Nicks song. I am shocked she’s still around.

- Last Friday, I attended “Ghost Brothers of Darkland County” at the Alliance Theatre, which featured Justin Guarini, who played one of the sons, who happened to be an embittered musician. The dark musical, created by Stephen King and John Mellencamp, focuses on a cabin and a father who, as a child, saw his two older brothers die over a girl in 1967. Forty years later, the father (played brilliantly by Tony winner Shuler Hensley) brings his family, including his two sons, to the cabin to reveal secrets about what happened. Justin plays one of those sons, jealous of his more successful brother who also happened to steal his girlfriend. It’s an echo of what happened 40 years earlier. The play runs through May 13 and is well worth going to in my mind. The music is mesmerizing, the stage production brilliant. The weakest point is the plotting but it’s not fatal.

Justin Guarini plays a failed musician in the Stephen King/John Mellencamp play "Ghost Brothers of Darkland County." CREDIT: Rodney Ho/rho@ajc.com

Justin Guarini plays a failed musician in the Stephen King/John Mellencamp play "Ghost Brothers of Darkland County." CREDIT: Rodney Ho/rho@ajc.com

Justin playing

justin closer up

Scotty McCreery is still pitching for his local high school team. And it sounds like he’s pretty good, too.

- Bo Bice had his fourth child, his first daughter Merrin Elizabeth Joy. The healthy baby girl joins three big brothers: Adain (7), Caleb (3) and Ean (2).

from Bo's Facebook page

from Bo's Facebook page

- Thinking of going to Branson, Missouri this summer? You’ll be able to catch lots of “Idol” contestants. From May 14 to June 16, the show in the Andy Williams Theatre will feature Lee DeWyze, Kimberly Caldwell, Blake Lewis, Elliott Yamin and Thia Megia. From June 18 to July 21, you’ll be able to catch Siobhan Magnus, Diana DeGarmo, Scott Savol, Ace Young and Alexis Grace.

- Carrie Underwood leads the CMT Award nominations with five.

- Clay Aiken just narrowly escaped getting fired on “Celebrity Apprentice” this past Sunday. He was the project manager who lost a challenge in which his team had to create a Macy’s display for a Trump fragrance called Success. Normally, that would mean curtains for him. But Donald Trump narrowly decided to dump Penn Jillette instead because the executives judging the competition hated Jillette’s slogan, “You’ve earned it.” Aiken’s track record, to date, has been very very good. Fans know whether he gets into the finals. Join my Facebook fan page and Twitter.

By Rodney Ho, Radio & TV Talk

84 comments Add your comment

Sam-A

April 25th, 2012
4:28 pm

D: yes Joshua did sing that song, and I’m betting he is stupid enough to do it again. Doesn’t promise to be a stellar night.

Unlike several of you, I’m actually more interested in hearing Philipx2 than the “blow your nose” twanger, and the “here I go – gonna scream again, then I’m gonna cry for ya” mess known as Joshua.

Hope Hollie does really well again this week. And hope Jessica redeems herself from the disasters of the past couple weeks. Elise too.

Deirdre

April 25th, 2012
4:29 pm

Please don’t JT…things are delicately balanced in this neck of the woods. ;-)

Deirdre

April 25th, 2012
4:30 pm

Sam, at least Phil will be interesting….and fun.

JTesla

April 25th, 2012
4:31 pm

Jenny: if they fart “Fat Bottomed Girls” I would like it, otherwise it doesn’t amuse me. I like “Baby got back” and “Rump Shaker”, so it’s not the subject matter for me.

Also, when it comes to Lauren I was indifferent, much like I was with Scotty. However, now I remember her doing the song and it was better than I thought it would be.

Jenny

April 25th, 2012
4:31 pm

Blah. Respectfully disagree. :-)

JTesla

April 25th, 2012
4:32 pm

Deirdre, as long as you know where I was going. In good fun of course.

Jenny

April 25th, 2012
4:33 pm

Oops, the “respectfully disagree” was meant for D and Sam and Phil… not you, JT! And yep, that’s pretty much how I feel about Crazy Little Thing. I feel your pain!!!

Jenny

April 25th, 2012
4:35 pm

Good call, D. Elise will almost certainly do Hendrix. I would bet the farm on it, as a matter of fact.

Mercedes S.

April 25th, 2012
4:37 pm

Sam-A, I actually liked “Fat Bottomed Girl” as sung by Mohawk Boy on “Glee” to his then crush, a FBG.

Suspect Joshua, not PP will get Colton’s religious votes.
Don’t people who sing “Crazy Littler Thing Called Love” get voted off?

I thought “I Want It All” was a commercial jingle…

Mercedes S.

April 25th, 2012
4:38 pm

Assume “The Climb” will go to Hollie

JTesla

April 25th, 2012
4:38 pm

I agree with you Deirdre on Hendrix and Miley being done by Elise and Hollie. If that is what happens, then I think these contestants are getting to be too predictable. Remember the good old days, way back when, when a David Cook or Adam Lambert would take a song that just didn’t fit them and surprise us with it? Yeah, those were good times.

Deirdre

April 25th, 2012
4:39 pm

JT. I thought it myself for a sec but then realized that wasn’t the reason.

Harriett

April 25th, 2012
4:40 pm

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4wl6EXxLP5U

Here is my favorite from his season singing “Ready For Love.” I still think he was the best singer that year. I know nobody agrees and thought he was cheesy, but his version of this song is one of the best I have ever heard. I bet Jessica sings it.

Sam-A

April 25th, 2012
4:41 pm

Or, was it big old Mama’s blubbery overgrown baby that sang Luther? These two dudes are so similar, other than size, with all the crying and screaming, it’s hard to remember which did that song.

Jenny

April 25th, 2012
4:42 pm

Mercedes… you may be right on the religious votes!! I didn’t think of that! Good catch.

Do people who sing “Crazy Little…” really get voted off? I can’t remember. Probably because if someone sings that song, I subconsciously block it from memory.

(now watch, with my luck, Hollie will sing it. :-| )

Deirdre

April 25th, 2012
4:43 pm

JT: Remember the good old days, way back when, when a David Cook or Adam Lambert would take a song that just didn’t fit them and surprise us with it? Yeah, those were good times.

This is what happens when they give the contestants a Free Choice. Have to admit however, that the Hendrix song is new to Idol(at least I don’t think anyone else has done it but 1 other may be possible.

Deirdre

April 25th, 2012
4:44 pm

Jenny, I was going to suggest that Crazy Little Thing would be the song that Hollie picked.

Jenny

April 25th, 2012
4:44 pm

I also think Jessica will do india.arie (does she still spell it that way?)

Harriett, I didn’t mind Big Mike! I liked him a lot the week he sang “In The Ghetto”.

Sam-A

April 25th, 2012
4:44 pm

Deirdre – I sent a post with same question, worded slightly different, ie maybe it was big old Mama’s blubbery whiny boy that sang the Luther. With all the crying and screaming it’s hard for me to separate these two (other than sizewise of course). The post was just ditched.

Jenny

April 25th, 2012
4:45 pm

Oh, D, no. Nooooooooooooooooo…..

Jenny

April 25th, 2012
4:46 pm

Sam-A, I saw it… it’s still there… at 4:41?

Sam-A

April 25th, 2012
4:47 pm

And there you go – suddenly my first post turns up out of nowhere, about 5 mins after I sent it!

Getting near that golden time of day – everyone enjoy (or try to) the show tonight.

Jenny

April 25th, 2012
4:49 pm

JT, I remember when the song spoilers came out with Adam singing “Mad World”. On some blog (I don’t think it was here)… he was absolutely getting CLOBBERED for “all the great 80s songs and he picks this horrible boring nothing song, what is he thinking, what a stupid move, blah blah blah.)

And look what happened…

Yeah, I miss those days too. :-(

Jenny

April 25th, 2012
4:51 pm

Sam, please think of me covering my ears during “Crazy.” And covering my cat’s ears too.

(Now I’ve REALLY just guaranteed for Hollie to pick it, haven’t I?)

Sam-A

April 25th, 2012
4:58 pm

If she does, Hollie will at least have a pleasant sounding voice! I just cover up or flip channel every time Joshua the screamer comes on.

Rickster

April 25th, 2012
5:05 pm

As much as I like “Queen” – I’m just not looking forward to hearing any of their songs sung by any of the contestants.

Have a good evening, everyone.

♥ kelly&carriefan ♥

April 25th, 2012
5:11 pm

Hi y’all,

I know I tend to have preconceptions just by reading the spoilers, but I think tonight should be fun. I’m hoping that we’ll get some surprises, but we’ll see. As far as The Climb, a capable singer can make it work (See: Kelly’s cover of it with her backup singers). I know that Dance With My Father screams Joshua…but I’m pretty sure that Hollie’s done The Climb before. Perhaps for last year’s audition? Based on that, if I had to guess I’d say she’d doing it. I can’t very much argue with Rodney’s Power 6 as basically how I see it.

If anyone is interested, Carrie’s album is available for streaming online ahead of it’s release next Tuesday. http://tasteofcountry.com/carrie-underwood-blown-away-stream/

JTesla

April 25th, 2012
5:12 pm

As a corrollary to Ricksters last post: I’m just not looking forward to hearing any of the judges commenting on these songs or these contestants.

Jenny

April 25th, 2012
5:24 pm

My guesses, though I think Hollie and Jessica could do several of the Queen songs.

The Show Must Go On – Jessica (or possibly Hollie)

Fat Bottomed Girls – Twangler

Bohemian Rhapsody – Joshua
 (slight chance: Hollie)
Crazy Little Thing Called Love – Phil

Save Me – Hollie (or possibly Jessica)

I Want it All – Elise

Dance With My Father – joshua

The Climb – Hollie
india.arie – Jessica

Hendrix – Elise

Tattoos on this Town – Twangler
Dave Matthews – Dave Matthews

Mercedes S.

April 25th, 2012
5:26 pm

I looked up “Crazy Little THing”… Tim Urban sang it on Idol, and did his infamous slide with it, something that made Simon call Tim’s perf. pointles and silly. Randy hated it, called it karaoke, to Ellen it felt like auditioning for a high school musical and the non-Paula woman (I CAN’T REMEMBER HER NAME) compared Tim to Zac Ephron in “Hairspray” – “you’re not a star and you’re behaving like you are one”.

Rougher than I remembered.

Jenny

April 25th, 2012
5:28 pm

Mercedes… right! Tim Urban! and it was AWFUL, as I recall.

Jenny

April 25th, 2012
5:31 pm

oh, and I think it was Kara. (was she still on at that point?)

you remember Kara. “You’re an ARTIST. A true ARTIST. But I’m still not sure who you really ARE. You haven’t DEFINED yourself. We need to understand who you REALLY ARE…..(voice fades away into the Charlie Brown teacher voice.)

magiccyclopsh8er

April 25th, 2012
6:02 pm

The ladies don’t like the wgwg for their brains Rodney!

Mercedes S.

April 25th, 2012
6:03 pm

Everybody have fun tonight – have meeting to attend during first part of “Idol”.