
AMERICAN IDOL: Hollywood: Over 300 contestants made it to Hollywood and only 70 will survive. The Hollywood round begins Wednesday, Feb, 8 (8:00-9:00 PM ET PT ) and Thursday, Feb. 9 (8:00-9:00 PM ET/PT) on FOX. Pictured: Contestants at the Hollywood round. The provided caption provides no identifying info. CR: Michael Becker / FOX.
Was this “American Idol” or “Contagion, Part II”?
The hour featured two doses crying, three doses whining and four doses regurgitation.
Patient Zero, the editors decide, is “Tent Girl” Amy Brumfield. A lot of kids get sick and she appears to be the one to blame as others have trouble keeping their dinners down.
And we find out what happens to Symone Baker, who is fine. It was dehydration and fortunately, she didn’t seriously hurt herself falling off the stage. As earlier bloggers noted, the producers wouldn’t have created such a cliffhanger if she were seriously injured.
[Before we get to the action, I also finally caught Monday's "The Voice" three days later and saw Jamar Rogers (season 10 of "Idol"), who gets the sob story big time. He actually used to live in Atlanta for a time and was a huge fan of Cee Lo, saying he saw him at Music Midtown. Cool local reference!
As for ratings, "Idol" drew 19 million last night and a 6.1 rating 18-49. That's down 20% from 24 mil a year ago for the fourth Wednesday and a 8.4 rating 18-49, down 27 percent. In other words, the comparable dropoffs will continue unabated unless something odd happens.
In comparison, NBC's "The Voice" on Monday drew its 6.6 rating, beating "Idol" in 18-49 ratings while "NCIS" with 20.8 million this past Tuesday easily beat "Idol" in total viewers.]
Anyway, we start the night with Symone Baker, who quickly regains consciousness, drinks a Coke and is taken to the hospital to get checked. Symone is put through because honestly, she deserved it.
We hear that neither Ethan Jones, whose father was in alcohol rehab, and the indistinguishably dull Lauren Mink are cut. Jeremy Rosado makes it through.
We move to group round! 185 make it to the next round. Almost half are going to be cut the next round.
The twist: day one and day two people have to intermix in groups. Cop Alisha Bernhardt and Amy “Tent Girl” Brumfeld (who is getting sick with the flu – perhaps from living in a tent) are have trouble finding groups. “Everybody is afraid I’ll get them sick,” Tent Girl said. Can’t blame them! She starts crying. “Inside is suffocating me,” she said. Which makes sense if she spends all her time outside.
Several others are trying to cobble together groups based on songs. Some are being picky, including Brianna-Marie Bell. There seem to be a lot of 1970s songs on the playlist. Alisha wants to sing “Joy to the World.” People keep thinking it’s the Christmas song, not the Three Dog Night song. Two others are trying to get folks to join them to sing Boston’s “More Than a Feeling.” Alisha loses her two group members because she refuses to sing Boston.
We hear snippets of Blu Cantrell. Brielle Von Hugel made it past group round last year with Pia Toscano. She’s back. She becomes leader of her group.
Symone returns after being dehydrated and finds a group.
It appears Tent Girl’s bug has spread quickly. We see someone throw up. Another guy has kidney stone issues. Richie Law, a dude with a cowboy hat is trying to teach the others choreography (including Mr. Cheerful Heejun Han.) “That kid is crazy,” Heejun said. “I don’t know how they do it in cowboy town. It’s not how we bring it down.” Whiner doesn’t even bother to know Richie’s name.
Christian has caught the bug and is throwing up. He returns from a break and someone hugs him. Why do these kids keep touching the sick ones? Cop Alisha is struggling with “Stuck Like Glue.” Christian can barely stand up. Heejun keeps on whining. Richie, who acts like Mr. Know It All, calls it a night eventually.
Jennifer is part of a group that wants to go to sleep. Brianna, the picky one, leaves, but comes back, not wanting to abandon her teammate. Jennifer helps Brianna learn lyrics. They leave at 5:11 a.m. (I’d be the one opting for sleep over rehearsing exhausted.)
Anyway, we get no real singing this week, just the build-up to next Wednesday. Presumably, we’ll get more fainting!
And over on CBS, Astro of “X Factor” is on “Person of Interest” in a rather meaty role.
Join my Facebook fan page and Twitter.
By Rodney Ho, Radio & TV Talk
220 comments Add your comment
Highlander
February 10th, 2012
6:05 pm
I didn’t think Richie (cowboy) was that wrong. Seemed to me like he’s more aware of what goes on during Hollywood week and how important a good showing in groups can be, so he was a bit more serious about wanting to give a real performance. (And a box step isn’t that difficult, BTW!)
I think he definitely lacked any sense of tact. Since we didn’t see everything (naturally), maybe they stood around for a while not getting anything really accomplished so he thought someone would have to take charge.
Funny thing is, if you remember back, he was the last to join the group simply because he was a “2nd day” singer (another stupy Idol rule!).
Highlander
February 10th, 2012
6:05 pm
Woooooo! Page 5!!!!
Seth T
February 10th, 2012
11:04 pm
Monday night The Voice will have a 2 hour auditions show, where the Mentors fight for what they want in “team members’, but the contestant gets to choose who they go with.
Wednesday night, Idol will have a 2 hour Hollywood show
Thursday night, Idol will have a 2 hour “performance challege” show
(anyway, that’s what tonight’s new t.v. guide said. I dis-avow any inaccuracies)
Carson Daly said the Voice will do well with it’s focus on “social media” voting and direct inter-action with the show through Facebook, Twitter, etc. Wasn’t voting like 24 hours for days last year through Facebook?
Gail
February 10th, 2012
11:35 pm
I do not usually get involved in blogs, but I have to speak up about Richie Law. He is from Atlanta and he got his start at 3 years old with Rhubarb Jones in Atlanta. He is a super nice guy and very talented. He has experience singing with an international a capella choir and he has also been trained in opera. I know his parents and grandparents. It is very easy to judge people from the small segments on TV, but it is not always the whole story. I agree that American Idol has been too much drama but I also know that Richie Law is a super talented and well liked person. He is not a “know it all” as you have suggested in this article.
Deirdre
February 11th, 2012
7:14 am
Gail, thanks for the info on Richie. Since we don’t know him we can only judge him by his behavior on the show and, the way Idol has edited his segment, his behavior does not look good. He comes across as bossy and inflexible.
I have little doubt that he’s a talented singer. He was chosen to go to Hollywood. You also need to keep in mind that the pressure of Hollywood Week does strage things to the contestant’s personalities.
And if this is not the way he behaved, then you should be upset with the producers of Idol who have left us that impression.
Deirdre
February 11th, 2012
7:15 am
Not “strage” things…strange things.
Deirdre
February 11th, 2012
9:28 am
Latest XF rumor is that Whitney Houston has been offered a job as a judge. She is considering it.
Gail
February 11th, 2012
10:38 am
Dierdre, Thank you for your response. I know they do it to build the drama, but all of my friends are saying there is too much this year. Hopefully American Idol will get back to a singing competition Wednesday.
JTesla
February 11th, 2012
11:30 am
I personally didn’t have a problem with Cowboy. I can see where he would come off wrong with the “music theory” stuff to peoople you are in essence competing with, but sometimes people need to be pushed a little in order to do better.
JTesla
February 11th, 2012
11:32 am
Whitney Houston? That selection would be made for the wrong reasons. She is untested at finding/developing talent. She may be talented, but putting together a panel of great singers does not make a panel of great judging.
Gail
February 11th, 2012
11:45 am
JTesla, Thank you for your comment. He was just trying to get them to harmonize and work together. We only saw small segments, but I am sure there is even more we did not see. Since I know Richie, I will tell you that he wears the cowboy hat, but he lives in the suburbs. He is around horses when he works with a charity that uses horses to help special needs children come out of their shell and be more mobile. There is so much to people we do not see on TV. Richie is one of those special people and he is also talented. I hope American Idol is better Wednesday.
Highlander
February 11th, 2012
12:42 pm
Thanks for the inside info, Gail. And I think most of us hope Idol is better on Wednesday!
Personally, another show like last Thursday’s and I’ll skip Idol until after the Top 12 (or whatever) is chosen.
Right now, The Voice is much more entertaining AND you actually get to hear people sing in a singing competition! Imagine that!
Jenny
February 11th, 2012
2:38 pm
Thank you, Gail… this is a good reminder that editing should always be taken with a grain of salt! There’s usually another side to the story… we sometimes forget that we’re only seeing what they want us to see for dramatic effect. Nice to hear more about Richie, and I will be interested to see what happens on the next show.
Unna Thurma
February 11th, 2012
3:01 pm
bring on the groups I have not watched american idol in a while they should also bring back winners as guest commentators and judges mix it up and let it shine baby
I still love Idol but im burned out till they try something new
http://occupyhiphop.wordpress.com
Jubie
February 11th, 2012
3:10 pm
I think Boyance is being considered as an XF judge as well.
Branch Loveless
February 11th, 2012
3:58 pm
Right now, The Voice is much more entertaining AND you actually get to hear people sing in a singing competition! Imagine that! – Highlander
100% right, good sir. I so agree with you. I have always despised group round and the 2012 edition has just solidified that position. Hopefully, when this crap is out of the way “Idol” will improve although no one has really captured my attention yet.
Jenny
February 11th, 2012
8:35 pm
I just got a CNN popup on my phone saying Whitney Houston has died. So sad.
Jenny
February 11th, 2012
8:43 pm
And I had meant to reply to Deirdre earlier today… I was going to say I thought she and XFactor would be good for each other. I am sad beyond words that she won’t get the chance. Such an amazing talent gone way too soon.
Seth T
February 11th, 2012
10:29 pm
All of us who love and enjoy music and Whitney’s contribution to the world of entertainment are sad to hear this news tonight. May her spirit rise quickly to the beauty of Heaven, in a new world of love and peace.
Sam-A
February 13th, 2012
9:13 am
My God, the irony that Deirdre and JT were talking about WH just a few hours before the news came out she had died!
Gail: is the kid you’re talking about the one with the bass voice that sounds like last year’s blunder (oops, winner)? Sure don’t need another one with a voice so deep you can barely understand the words, and definitely not another country winner!
Jenny: from you post on Friday, I too really appreciate and admire Taylor Swift, the young lady. She’s not a good singer, but her songs (especially the one about being 16) are great inspiration for young girls struggling with life and boys! And she has an adorable personality, at least on her many visits to the Ellen show. I also admire the way she dresses, especially on the red carpet. Her style is so much better and lovelier than most of the established, older, huge stars! And I understand she doesn’t use a stylist, but chooses her own clothes. And I do think her voice may have improved a little bit.
N. Minaj needs to, politely put, have her butt kicked for that “performance” on the Grammies last night. What a sicko, stupid looking thing. I only lasted aboiut 40 secs, fortunately I recorded, as I had Downton Abbey to watch last night.
Kelly looked and sounded great. And love me some Sir Paul!