accessAtlanta

City & State or ZIP Tonight, this weekend, May 5th...
City & State or ZIP
City & State or ZIP Tonight, this weekend, May 5th...
City & State or ZIP

Fox 5 banned from Nathan Deal immigration bill signing

Fox 5/WAGA-TV’s Justin Gray was blocked by state troopers from a public immigration bill signing held today by Gov. Nathan Deal at the Gold Dome. Why? Deal’s press office was angry about an unrelated, unflattering story Dale Russell had done the night before about Deal.

VIDEO: Governor Deal’s Office Bans FOX 5 Reporter from Immigration Bill Signing: MyFoxATLANTA.com

Below is the story that upset Deal’s office. The campaign had paid $90,000 to a fund-raising company the I-Team had never heard of called Southern Magnolia Capital. Russell discovered that company was connected to Deal’s daughter in law Denise Deal. Phil Wilheit, identified in the story as Deal’s campaign manager, told Russell the transaction was “transparent” but Russell said the firm has no website or any obvious public information or direct link to Deal’s name.

Fox 5 news director Mike McClain sent a statement today at about 5:30 p.m. to me: “FOX 5 Atlanta stands by our I-Team investigation and Reporter Dale Russell. The barring of FOX 5 cameras from the bill signing today was unacceptable and obviously an emotional reaction to our I-Team investigation. We’ve voiced out concerns to the Governor’s Office and hope that they will reconsider that decision.”

Deal’s spokesman Brian Robinson, when I called him, was still hot under the collar. He said the campaign never hid the fact Denise Deal ran the governor’s fund-raising campaign and having a family member do so is not illegal. He challenged me to Google the name “Southern Magnolia Capitol.” There was one site that immediately came up with her name attached to it: the Georgia Chamber of Commerce. (It was added, however, on May 10, just days before the report aired, so when Russell was first working on the piece, indeed, there was no sign of Deal’s connection with Southern Magnolia online.) He said she was compensated at a market rate. A P.O. box number Fox 5 identified as connected to Southern Magnolia was a clerical error, not a way to hide anything, he noted.

The person identified as campaign manager in the story Wilheit was the chairman, Robinson said, not the campaign manager, and he didn’t know all the details Fox 5 had showed him. Robinson thought they had “ambushed” him. The governor chose not to talk to Fox 5 about it because he didn’t want to be ambushed either, Robinson said.

He said the reason they blocked Gray was not anything Gray did but the fact the station did “a shoddy piece of journalism in which they should be embarrassed.” He is demanding an apology. He felt this was one way to punish Fox 5 because “we don’t have a TV station. We don’t have the power of the airwaves.”

Ironically, he said Deal has developed a good relationship with Fox 5 before this, noting the governor has has appeared on “Good Day Atlanta” since coming into office. “We’ve given them incredible access,” Robinson said. “That’s why this was so particularly upsetting to us.”

He said the story has “lots of innuendo but no context and very little facts.”

Judge for yourself:

I-Team: Gov. Deal Campaign Funds: MyFoxATLANTA.com

Join my Facebook fan page and Twitter.

By Rodney Ho, rho@ajc.com, AJCRadioTV blog

263 comments Add your comment

N. Nixon

May 16th, 2011
3:12 pm

That a legitimate news organization was barred by Nathan Deal from covering a public event is disgusting! How dare this man and his thugs take such an un-American action. Not only is Deal’s actions a violation of the constitutionally-guaranteed freedom of the press, it is also an illegal use of government employees (the GSP), which is in direct violation of Georgia law prohibiting use of Merit System employees for personal purposes. I hope the AJC, WAGA and other news organizations investigate and report on this matter fully.

Shame on you, Nathan Deal, for taking such an awful (and unlawful) action against the press who, ultimately, represent the people. You may be governor for present but you, in no way, represent my interests as a citizen and a voter in Georgia.

Shame on you.

1911A1

May 16th, 2011
4:44 pm

First of all, this was NOT a public event. Bill signings are private affairs and the guvna can invite – and disinvite – whomever he pleases. (Hat tip to Live Apt. Fire for that tidbit of knowledge.)

Having said that, this has to score in the top 5 of political PR stupid moves of all time. Hopefully the media will do their jobs an rip the cover off of politicians’ malfeasance (as opposed to shootings, stabbings, apartment fires, and – really??? – celebrity goings-on) and keep We the People informed about what bad stewards of OUR money these goobers are.

As for Guvna Deal, we’ll see what comes out in the wash. One thing I can say about him, he seems to have put out more effort in five months than Sonny ever did in eight years.

One final thing – I’m from the Gainesville area, and you ain’t seen blind homer-ism until you experience how they love their Nathan in Hall County.

NoMoreKoolaid

May 16th, 2011
6:35 pm

Oh Dan, it isn’t nearly so much about what is done, it is about what is covered up. Nathan the anti First Amendment man wants to cover up his actions. The president hasn’t tried to hide his mother-in-law. By the way, your racism crawls out when you make a big deal out of a person’s name. Would you make a big deal if the middle name was Ettienne, Hebert, Jorge, Thor, Rigel? We can only hope that some day ignorant bigots will disappear.

rt

May 16th, 2011
7:46 pm

LEAVE THE GOV ALONE !!!!

Duke & Banner

May 17th, 2011
2:51 am

It seems to me that this Fox station opened up a big can o’ worms.

But that’s the problem: It’s Fox. I wouldn’t trust any news from any Fox station, period.

They might as well be asking if the governor has a birth certificate.

Michael

May 17th, 2011
7:37 am

Rodney – Shame on You.

A minimal amount of investigating on your part would have uncovered the fact that the Chamber of Commerce listing in the Google results was added on May 10. The Fox report clearly stated that they were investigating in March and were unable to find any evidence of Mrs. Deal’s affiliation to Southern Magnolia.

The governor’s office is using you. They knew you wouldn’t try to verify how recent the Chamber of Commerce listing was, and they were right.

The governor’s office caught wind of the Fox story before it was broadcast and pre-emptively had Mrs. Deal join the Chamber of Commerce (look into it, they list her’s as a new company).

Not good, Rodney.

smitty

May 17th, 2011
9:15 am

It look’s like fox 5 has bit the hand that feeds them.We have had a sonny & jimmy & Nathan in the governors office.that’s good old boy standing’s if i ever saw one.Please people Vote for the person that said it best for you ,not because he’s your color.will we “as people ever get ahead of the nation’s as leaders of the free world.(fox five is own by a russian imagrinte)

dan

May 17th, 2011
12:55 pm

Can someone please tell me what any other president before Obama did on illegal immigration? Why wasn’t anything done under Bush(es) terms, Reagan, Clinton, etc. Now it is all of sudden Obama’s fault. it is a ploy, by the GOP. They ruined the economy from 2000-2008, and now have to find a scapegoat. If these so called immigrant law supporters were sincere, then why didn’t they pass laws during previous presidential or governor terms?

[...] See the background here. The shut-out was in retaliation for a Fox5 piece by Dale Russell a day earlier, pointing to $90,000 in payments to the governor’s daughter-in-law, who acted as a campaign fund-raiser. [...]

[...] anchor **Ex-Ch. 9 anchor Merri Dee falls ill during speaking engagement **Atlanta market – Fox 5 banned from Governor’s immigration bill signing **Rick Gevers’ latest posting of news director and newsroom management moves **Chicago [...]

Amanda looking good

May 18th, 2011
10:51 am

As long as FOX News does not ban Ms. Amanda Davis with her hot looking self – who cares !

Assisted living

May 21st, 2011
1:56 am

Thanks for your publication on this weblog. From my personal experience, occasionally softening up a photograph might provide the photo shooter with a little an imaginative flare. Often however, that soft clouds isn’t what exactly you had planned and can often times spoil an otherwise good photograph, especially if you thinking about enlarging it.

Bell & Ross BR 02 Watches

weernMedesisa

May 21st, 2011
4:47 am

I have realized that of all forms of insurance, medical care insurance is the most questionable because of the issue between the insurance plan company’s necessity to remain afloat and the consumer’s need to have insurance. Insurance companies’ profits on health and fitness plans are incredibly low, so some organizations struggle to profit. Thanks for the concepts you reveal through this blog.

http://www.dmcathink.com