accessAtlanta

City & State or ZIP Tonight, this weekend, May 5th...
City & State or ZIP
City & State or ZIP Tonight, this weekend, May 5th...
City & State or ZIP

Project Runway: The tide is high

Logan's avant-garde design (mylifetime.com)

Logan's avant-garde design

Surf’s up! More or less.

This week I have to start at the end of our ‘Project Runway’ episode and go backward: Has Nina Garcia said anything at all in the three episodes this season? Or is it just me? I don’t know, it seems like the usually mouthy Nina used to be much more opinionated in previous seasons. Now she’s being overshadowed by teenybopper stars like Lindsay Lohan and Rachel Bilson.

Still working our way backward, I was glad that Ra’mon won, ‘cause he’s sort of an underdog, but honestly, I thought the neoprene avant-garde dress was a mess. The dyed-blue smear looked like an accident, and I was sure the judges would penalize him – except they loved it! Go figure. On the other hand, Ra’mon/Mitchell’s swimwear look – the goddessy dress in blues and greens – was gorgeous. Too bad we couldn’t see the actual swimwear underneath (as in most of tonight’s designs)!

One dress that I thought deserved more than a passing grade was the gigantic pouf of a dress that was designed by Logan (above). Lovely! It possessed the right shape of bustle, the perfect swish when the model walked; it was well-balanced with a sleek top – even if it didn’t look anything like the product of the sea.

Mitchell was auf’d, and it’s about time, but I’m quickly growing tired of Qristyl’s overly defensive attitude. The runway showed too much bickering between Qristyl and Epperson; now that she’s been on the bottom twice, she may well be the next to go. And if she does, it will be because she spends so much time being sassy and not enough time being a designer.

NOTE: One more ‘Project Runway’ Web site you must check (if you haven’t already) is ‘Tom and Lorenzo,’ formerly known as ‘Project Rungay.’ It’s hysterically funny and is not limited to the Heidi Klum/Tim Gunn show, but is devoted to all things fashion.

10 comments Add your comment

PR Fan

September 4th, 2009
7:44 am

Weirdly, this season seems to feature a more consistently high level of skill and a low level of drama. Or surprises. Where’s the Life in Lifetime? There’s very little different going on here, which I suppose is because they producers didn’t want to mess with their formula. Hard to say. But these designers are really good and a bit dull. And yes, Nina needs to take off the duct tape and start harshing. And where was Michael? Zzzzz.
Great to see Mitchell gone pecan.
Having teams usually jacks up the tension and creates some fun moments. Last night provided a few. Maybe now we’ll see some more action. But I’m digging looking at the outfits. Last night had plenty of good ones.

Faith Dawson

September 4th, 2009
8:47 am

I was just reminded that Ra’mon is not really an underdog — he finished among the low scorers on last week’s “maternity chic” challenge.

Morgan

September 4th, 2009
8:53 am

I’m over the judges. Ra’Mon’s dress did not deserve to win. And Qristyl is a bit on weak side but Epperson was out of control. Type-A run amuck! Ditto on the pouf dress…goregeous.

And BTW, where is Michael Kors?

Debbie

September 4th, 2009
9:53 am

I fell asleep. Who was kicked off?

PRF2

September 4th, 2009
10:15 am

Mitchell was kicked off.

Ditto Faith…If one quickly flips through all the designs from last night’s episode on the Project Runway website, without knowing the inspiration source, one would be hard pressed to see the influence of sea, surf and sand.

The additional task of creating an avant-garde look, threw the designers off task and was a weak attempt from the show’s producers to add tension & drama.

That being said, I thought the dresses were beautiful and well-executed.

nypeach

September 4th, 2009
10:54 am

Loved Logan’s avant garde look was just lovely! But the highlight was watching Mitchell get the boot. What a loser…he just knew he was going to ride Ra’mon’s coattails to another episode. Qrystle is beyond weak, and I could really see why Epperson kept going off on her. She was just an albatross around his neck. She is way past her 15 minutes of fame. Sewing choir robes is one thing, designing for Project Runway is way beyond her capabilities.

Mercedes S.

September 4th, 2009
11:14 am

I too fell asleep before the boot-off. Is this season more boring, or what? That neoprene stuff would have shown up on the fashion police pages of US, had a celeb dared to wear it. Agree on Logan’s pouf dress, but wouldn’t call it beach/sea/surf inspired. Qrystle belongs on a diva show.

Ex-Northerner

September 4th, 2009
11:27 am

I loved Ra’mon’s neoprine dress which really used a san-n-surf material. He was one of the only ones to use actual surfing stuff. The blue smear reminded me of kelp which you do see in the surf or when diving. I also loved Logan’s ball gown and think he has something very special which I think we will begin to see more of.

The real drama came in the “Models of the Runway” show afterward. I prefer less drama in the “Project” show but get a real dose in the “Models” show. A real hoot.

amanda

September 4th, 2009
11:38 am

I didn’t like Ra’mon’s dress the best. I was much more impressed by some of the other designs. But it was supposed to be avant-garde and maybe that’s something I just don’t get. I thought the challange itself was boring and rather stupid. I like the avant-garde challenges of the past, but I didn’t really see how or why it should relate to designing a surf inspired look. It would be one thing if the first design was supposed to be a ready to wear look inspired by the ocean or inspired by surfers but the challenge was to create something that a surf girl would wear – to me those are very different concepts. To take something a surf-girl would wear and then create an avant-garde look inspired by that design doesn’t make sense to me.

[...] one should be surprised that Qristyl went home – Qristyl herself wasn’t, if you listened closely to the dialogue during the [...]