accessAtlanta

City & State or ZIP Tonight, this weekend, May 5th...
City & State or ZIP
City & State or ZIP Tonight, this weekend, May 5th...
City & State or ZIP

5/19: Who won “Dancing With the Stars”? Gilles, Melissa or Shawn?

Shawn Johnson, the gymnast, edged out actor Gilles Marini in a bit of a surprise to win season eight of “Dancing With the Stars.” Less than one percentage point separated the two in a very tight race for the cheesy disco ball.

Melissa Rycroft, the “Bachelor” gal who came in as a replacement, finished third.

Shawn’s athleticism helped her pick up the technical parts of the dances. It took her time to get comfortable as a teenager to be a good performer. But she improved over time. Gilles was arguably the leader from early on and he continued to be that studly French man all the way through. Shawn somehow snuck up and got the votes to just beat him out.

So did the voters and judges pick the right winner?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

The finale show is always packed with filler with 10 seconds of actualy news. Lady Gaga, a review of past episodes, etc.

They each get to do one more dance to get points from the judges. The 50/50 split of fan votes and judge totals decide the winner of the trophy. Yes, the contestants are paid a decent penny too. The final three all make $365,000, based on the contract TMZ got of Johnson, who is a minor.

Shawn Johnson’s cha-cha-cha to “P.Y.T.”: she brings great moves and sexiness and a great last move. Len: “The longer you go, the stronger you get.” Bruno: “From cute to sexy and sassy. Your technique is always spot on.” Carrie Ann: “You’ve powered your way to the top and deserve to be here tonight.” She gets a perfect score of 30 and 88 over two nights.

Melissa Rycroft. She’s a natural dancer and is certainly deserving to make it to the top 3. Bruno: “She’s got a body made for dancing.” Carrie Ann: “You’ve really come into your own.” Len: “That samba was just fantastic.” She was third in the leader board. She got perfect score of 30 and 86 over two nights.

Gilles Marini. He’s graceful, warm and sexy across the board. This Argentine tango smolders. Carrie Ann: “You’re our very special performer… you bring such an amazing artistry to your dancing.” Len: “You have brought me the most pleasure to watch.” Bruno: “This was an Argentine triumph!” Yet another perfect score of 30 and 88 total. So he’s tied with Shawn with the judges. It comes down to people’s vote who wins.

The finale is always fun because we get to see the eliminated contestants yet again. Belinda Carlisle definitely did better than she did when she was eliminated the first week. Denise Richards? She had a very low level of difficulty with her quickstep and was adequate. Holly Madison: still not a good dancer. Stiff.

And now onto Steve Wozniak! He gives hope for all us schlubs who can’t dance. And they let him dance his entire routine while the others got shortened versions. Love him! David Alan Grier? He’s not bad but he left at the right time. Steve O? He ended up doing far better than anybody could have imagined. He took this seriously! Is he a particularly good dancer? No. But he makes up for it with moxie and a Pee Wee-style exuberance.

Lawrence Taylor, the football player of this round, wasn’t quite as good as Emmitt Smith or Jerry Rice, but is certainly respectable. Chuck Wicks, the next one eliminated, improved quite a bit though I guess he lacked the aw-shucks nice-guy modesty of Ty Murray, who far outlasted him.

Lil Kim? She could have easily made the top 3. Ty Murray got better and better but had no prayer of winning. I think his sweet personality got him the votes past Lil Kim and Chuck Wicks.

The pro dancer who won the mini-competition to be on the show next year is Anna, who will dance with a celeb this fall.

Best lines from Jeffrey Ross’ roast. “This is the first season when no actual stars made it to the finale. This isn’t a who’s who. It’s a who are you?

“I didn’t know this show was called, ‘Dancing With the Vaguely Familiar.’ ”

He later dubbed them “the underaged, the unwed and the unpronounceable.”

Gilles, he noted in the “Sex and the City” move, “may not have had the biggest role but he had the biggest part.”

Melissa: “You’re so beautiful. What can I say? Can I marry you? Ironic if she came in second on this show, too?”

“Lil Kim–she was just here for community service.”

“Belinda Carlisle. I like how you’re dressed like a hooker from ‘Battlestar Galactica.’ ”

“Holly Madison. She didn’t do well on the show. Every time the director yelled action, she started taking her clothes off.”

19 comments Add your comment

TORI

May 19th, 2009
11:18 pm

THATS BULL…. SHE ONLY WON CAUSE WHO SHE IS… GILLES SHOULD HAVE TOOK THAT

Terri

May 19th, 2009
11:24 pm

Who Cares? I know I don’t.

Josie

May 20th, 2009
7:37 am

Gilles moves were so sexy and sensual too bad didn’t won it

policewife

May 20th, 2009
8:03 am

Sure would like to have seen Tony and Melissa win. He deserves it.

liz hughes

May 20th, 2009
8:23 am

i tried to vote for Gilles, couldn’t get in.

Brat

May 20th, 2009
8:28 am

Gilles should have won! I was so dissapointed that he didn’t win.
Shawn Johnson sure didn’t do the best job. She was a bit too fat to move like the other contestants. It’s not fair, she just had more call ins.

azcat225

May 20th, 2009
8:37 am

And yet Terri, you deign to post on a blog about the show. Hmmmmm…

Brat, comments like yours about Shawn are the reason so many women—and yes, some men—suffer from eating disorders. The only fat is between your ears.

My 87 year old mother wanted Shawn to win so everything worked out well.

Shalom!

Too Easy

May 20th, 2009
8:45 am

Brat: Blame liz hughes for not voting. In reality, Shawn peaked at the right time (athletes do that). Any of them could have won, and any of them would have deserved it. It was that close, so don’t diss the winner – congratulate the finalists.

On another note, my 5th winner selection in a row after 3 straight first-loser selections (I had John O’Herly, Stacy Keibler and Mario Lopez in the 1st 3 shows. I was OK with Kelly Monaco and Drew Lashey (sp?), but Emmitt Smith? Please.)

Emjay

May 20th, 2009
9:35 am

Maybe there will be enough public outcry over Gilles not winning that they’ll have a do over like season one, when people were mad that Kelly Monaco won over John O’Hurley, and so the had a “dance off” in which – big surprise – John won the trophy.

And – who actually thinks it is appropriate or funny to allow Jeffery Ross to insult (oh, excuse me – “roast”) the contestants during the finale?

You're just not getting it

May 20th, 2009
9:46 am

“It’s not fair, she just had more call ins.”

Hahahahahaha! You’re kidding, right? That’s the format of the show. As with all of the other competition shows, it’s never been about who “deserved” to win. I the most deserving won, that would just be a nice bonus.

Emjay

May 20th, 2009
9:52 am

I’m hoping the sarcasm in the first part of my 9:35am post comes through :)

Based on the format of the show the appropriate person won! Congrats Shawn – I hope they don’t take your disco ball away like they did to Kelly!

Turbo from the movie "Breakin"

May 20th, 2009
10:01 am

I think Rerun from “Whats Happening” should have nabbed the title..

DB

May 20th, 2009
10:05 am

I thought Shawn was a bit stiff and didn’t flow as gracefully as Melissa or Gilles, but hey, I didn’t care enough to bother voting, so whatever. Gilles is just so gorgeous to watch, period. But as my son commented, though, during the tango — “he’s not really dancing, he’s just standing around looking studly and letting his partner kick up her heels!”

SummerG

May 20th, 2009
10:43 am

Gilles won hands down!!!!! I was outraged to say the least. Shawn’s had no personality and there is NO excuse just because she is a teen, if anything, they should have had to calm her personality down a bit…but that was NOT the case. Don’t get me wrong, she is adorable, moves were on point, but overall, Gilles was the better performer, dancer and so on! Gilles’ burst with personality through and through and he should have won hands down! I mean Shawn finally shows some personality in the free style segment and now she is a winner?! I beg to differ! I am so disappointed, you just don’t know! Gilles is the winner as far as I am concerned!

Too Easy

May 20th, 2009
11:04 am

Well, SummerG, Gilles didn’t win hands down. He and Shawn had the same judges’ points, and she had more votes. She won. Facts, not opinion. Again, she peaked at the right time. You, perhaps, need to broaden your horizons.

BravoFan

May 20th, 2009
11:41 am

If you are outraged over a D list reality show winner, then you are a loser.

Jeff

May 20th, 2009
1:21 pm

It’s simple people: those of you who are WOMEN wanted this actor dude to win (never heard of Gilles anyway – what the crap has he been on?) Most females just swooned at him and THAT is why they wanted him to win. I’m a guy, I want the hot women with the great body to win, because they are on TV more and dance more. So I was rooting for Shawn or Melissa, and in past years I rooted for Stacy Keibler, Kelly Monaco, etc. (Oh, and to the MORON who said Shawn looked “fat?” Are you kidding? That girl has a SMOKING HOT, beautiful, toned, athletic look that many women would love to have!) Shawn also had a great personality and was a very “tough minded” performer – she may not have had the perfect routine every week but she competed hard and gutted it out. I think she’s a very deserving winner, AND she’s the kind of girl you’d want your daughter or sister to turn out to be – beautiful, smart, talented and sweet.

It’s a fun show – let’s not get all bent out of shape about who “deserved” to win. It’s reality TV!!!!! Any show that relies on votes by the public – the same public I see at grocery stores and malls every weekend, who have the intelligence of coleslaw – well, it’s not a “true” competition, so enjoy it for what it is: entertainment!

Spoiled

May 20th, 2009
1:30 pm

I have to give credit where credit is due! You didn’t spoil the winner of DWTS in your headline! THANK YOU! Please keep this up! Your articles are great I just hate having the results spoiled by headlines on the front page. Thanks again and keep up the good work!

classywoman

May 28th, 2009
9:59 pm

I was soo upset Shawn won! she did not deserve to win. Gilles did. Not because of his looks but yes he was hot but because he was a better dancer! Shawn needs to lose some weight yes but i love her personality so sweet. but still….Gilles deserved to win for sure!