The man who did the right thing. (AJC photo by Curtis Compton)
That a day too long in coming has finally arrived probably shouldn’t touch off a celebration, but somehow this does. There was never a good reason for Augusta National not to include women among its membership. There was no reason beyond the stubbornness that human beings — both male and female, let’s stipulate — can sometimes mistake for “tradition.” But now the famous private club has admitted two women into its green-jacketed ranks, and that’s one less reason to regard Augusta National as the tin-eared old coot it has often seemed.
Yes, went the hollow argument, Augusta National is a private club and as such could admit whom it chooses. But Augusta National is a private club with a ragingly public face. It invites outsiders — at least those fortunate enough to land tickets — onto its premises for a week every April, and through television and the Internet and even iPhone and Android apps it invites the rest of us to partake of the Masters. It sells merchandise (lots of it) bearing the club logo. Given all that, could it reasonably argue that its membership rolls were of no concern?
Confronted by Martha Burk, former chairman Hootie Johnson sought to dig in his heels and succeeded only in digging a deeper hole. There was no way Augusta National could, in the 21st Century in these United State, remain stag much longer, and everyone who wore the green jacket had to know. Hootie held fast while Burk, who overplayed her hand, eventually went away, but the issue never did. It was raised again this spring, and Billy Payne chose to dodge the question during his annual Masters week briefing.
Say what you will about Billy Payne, but he is not tin-eared. The man who brought the world to Atlanta in the form of the 1996 Summer Olympics always figured to be the man who would admit women to the club on Magnolia Lane, and sure enough he was. Condoleezza Rice, once the Secretary of State, and Darla Moore, a financier known for philanthropy within her home state of South Carolina, are ideal choices, and having Rice, who is African-American, as one of the first women members of a club that not long ago included no African-American men is a most encouraging sign.
And, by adding Rice and Moore, Augusta National hasn’t just welcomed a woman. It has welcomed women, plural. “A joyous occasion,” Payne called it, via a press release, and it is. It should have been done long ago, but we take our breakthroughs where and when we find them. More Payne: “It will be a proud moment when we present Condoleezza and Darla their green jackets when the Club opens this fall.”
Some may see this as the fall of one of the last bastions of male-dom, but here’s what we say to such folks: Come out of that cave, men. Nothing is the way it used to be, and a lot of what used to be wasn’t right and/or proper to begin with. Credit Payne for realizing that there’s a world outside the gates of a golf course. Credit him for being the man who finally made happen what needed to happen.
So long as Augusta National was men-only, the question would have been asked: “Why is it men-only?” There was no good answer to that, and there could never have been a good answer. The only right response was to render the question moot. Billy Payne has, and Augusta National is better for it. And so, in a small but significant way, are we.
By Mark Bradley
213 comments Add your comment
Hamad Meander
August 21st, 2012
11:01 am
DeShaun Sanders – beautifully done. Exactly what Dr. Martin Luther King would have said, and you might have even said it better.
Van Jones
August 21st, 2012
11:13 am
“Why is it men-only?”
None of your or my business. It’s a private club.
Rolo
August 21st, 2012
11:25 am
Nice PC BS there Bradley. The ANC does what it wants, it didn’t bow down to PC BS or whiny liberal “men” like you. They simply made their OWN CHOICE to invite successful woman. They many never invite another, or they might invite nothing but. But it has nothing to do with pressure or a tin ear. Its a private club. Maybe you should look up the defination of private
dawg tired
August 21st, 2012
11:39 am
Augusta can invite as many old, rich women as they want but last I checked your paper, no cure for cancer was found, no war was stopped and the unemployment rate was not lowered.WGAS.
RobinVa
August 21st, 2012
11:46 am
“… Augusta National is a private club with a ragingly public face. It invites outsiders — at least those fortunate enough to land tickets — onto its premises for a week every April, and through television and the Internet and even iPhone and Android apps it invites the rest of us to partake of the Masters. It sells merchandise (lots of it) bearing the club logo. Given all that, could it reasonably argue that its membership rolls were of no concern?”
Yes. Of no concern to non-members.
“Some may see this as the fall of one of the last bastions of male-dom,…”
And some are foolish. It is a golf course. It’s not a government. It’s a golf course.
“So long as Augusta National was men-only, the question would have been asked: “Why is it men-only?”
The question WAS asked and the answer was, “Because that was how the members wanted it.”
I personally believe that keeping the club all-male for all of those decades was silly However hailing this change as a great leap forward for humankind is sillier. One sad fact about this whole affair is that the concept of private associations-people choosing to be with whom they wish for whatever reason or purpose they wish-without being hounded by the public at large has suffered. And in a free society that is not a good thing. That was once as important a principle as free speech.
PonGT
August 21st, 2012
1:55 pm
You are wrong Mr. Bradley. You and all of your emasculated ilk do not understand what has truly just happened … we aren’t witnessing the evolution of Augusta National but the demise of the last sacred vestige of male freedom in the world. Who was it that caused Adam to fail? A woman. Who was it that caused Samson to fail? A woman. Who was it that caused King David to fall? A woman. The downfall of men since the beginning of time has been the woman. Wait and see….the demise of the Masters has begun.
RAB1482
August 21st, 2012
4:31 pm
Well gee Mark, using your reasoning here, my 12 yr old SON should be able to join the Girl Scouts of America–I mean, afterall, even though they are a private group, they sell their cookies all over the world, therefore inviting us into their organization! Good grief, if men want to have a PRIVATE place to gather with their friends, play golf, have some drinks and tell dirty jokes, then they should be able to do that! I mean, this is America…..or at least it USED to be!
BulldogBen
August 21st, 2012
7:24 pm
In a state like Georgia, I honestly can’t believe this happened.
Good on ya Augusta National. Bout time.
BulldogBen
August 21st, 2012
7:33 pm
RobinVa, what you say would be fine if this “private association” wasn’t also the BIGGEST GOLF TOURNAMENT IN THE WORLD. This isn’t some local cigar club or something. They court worldwide attention. It reflected poorly on the entire South.
Paul in NH
August 21st, 2012
10:31 pm
There are some amusing comments on here. I really like the ones that say it is Augusta National’s right to invite who they want and then say that Augusta National shouldn’t have caved to “political correctness”. Some people really don’t get irony.
monroe
August 23rd, 2012
12:19 pm
this racist golf club needs to admit more african-americans. There are too many white people in the club. I’m tired of all this racism in the south.
zilla
August 24th, 2012
1:19 pm
It requires far more effort to give a fuzzy rats a** about this than I am willing to put forth.
zilla
August 24th, 2012
1:21 pm
What reflects more poorly on the South is that for some reason we believe that we are in some way inferior to the rest of the country, which couldn’t be further from the truth.