In my six-point plan to fix the Hawks, Josh Smith stays but Joe Johnson goes. (Curtis Compton/AJC)
It’s the offseason. I’m cracking open a six-pack for the Hawks – not for celebration but for reconstruction.
The Hawks don’t need to strip everything down after getting swept out of the second round for the second year in a row, but they clearly can’t thrive as currently built.
Here goes:
♦ 1.) Make a coaching change. Hawks general manager Rick Sund has doubts about Mike Woodson. Otherwise he would not have given him only a two-year contract two years ago, or he would have extended him before (or during) this season. The Hawks have improved in many areas under Woodson, most notably the win total. But the team’s half-court offense has been an issue throughout Woodson’s tenure. Creativity is not his strong-suit. It also became clear in this postseason that players have stopped listening to him. Being stretched to seven games by Milwaukee (which lost its best player, Andrew Bogut, three weeks before the playoffs) was a warning sign. Getting smacked by Orlando by embarrassing margins reaffirmed either poor preparation by Woodson or that players were tuning him out. A head coach needs to get a team to play a certain way, with a toughness and resolve that we saw from the Bucks. Woodson hasn’t done that. Conclusion: This is as high as the Hawks will go with him. If he gets fired, don’t be surprised if he is replaced by assistant Larry Drew. There will be a push for a high-profile replacement, like Jeff Van Gundy, Avery Johnson or, in a dream world, Doc Rivers. But if the Hawks can’t lure one of them, and if ownership is resistant to spending big money, hiring Drew can be easily rationalized. He is liked and respected by players. He would bring more creativity to the offense. He is in-tune with the team’s problems, its strengths and weaknesses. The risk is that Drew never has been a head coach before. But regardless of who would get the job, a new voice is needed.
All of the Hawks' problems are not Mike Woodson's fault, but a new voice is needed to get team to the next level. (AP photo)
♦ 2.) Sign-and-trade Joe Johnson. I thought it was at least 50-50 Johnson would re-sign with the Hawks until his comments after Game 3. He has proven himself to be in that second tier of stars, which is fine. But his lack of leadership and three years of mostly dreadful playoff performances have damaged his reputation. Even worse, Johnson seems to have checked out mentally. He still has value on the open market. There are enough teams out there who are looking for a scorer and have money to spend. A sign-and-trade could net a nice player in return: whether a shooting guard, point guard or starting caliber center. Among the backup options at shooting guard, one name that already has popped up as a possible replacement is Milwaukee’s John Salmons. He obviously isn’t the scorer Johnson in, but he averaged nearly 20 per game in Milwaukee after a trade from Chicago this year.
♦ 3.) Don’t trade Josh Smith. Yes, this postseason was a microcosm of what’s wrong with Smith. He took over Game 2 against the Bucks, just as he took over so many games during the season. But he was awful in too many games and justifiably was criticized nationally for loafing it on defense. During a time out in Game 4 Monday night, Smith was paying more attention to the “Kiss Cam” on the Philips Arena scoreboard than Woodson during a time-out, and a fan yelled, “Pay attention, Josh!” But remember two things: 1) For most of this season, the commentary about Smith was positive – how much he had matured and how he deserved to be in the All-Star Game; 2) He has had only one head coach since leaving high school: Woodson. There’s a great danger in trading Smith if another coach in another city helps him become the player he can be. Even after six seasons, it’s too early to give up on him. His potential is too great.
♦ 4.) Acquire a center (or Chris Bosh): A strong defensive center would give the Hawks the physical presence they desperately need in the post and allow them to move Al Horford to power forward and Smith to small forward. Marvin Williams can take a seat on the bench, or on a plane out of town. Bosh, who will be a free agent and also could be part of a sign-and-trade, is a tantalizing alternative. First, he would love to come back to Atlanta (where he played at Georgia Tech). He is not a true center but he is 6-10 and would bring some offense to help compensate for Johnson’s loss. A front line of Bosh, Horford and Smith certainly would rank among the league’s best.
♦ 5.) Bench Mike Bibby: There’s no nice way to put this: He got his new contract and then took a significant step back this season. His scoring average dropped from 14.9 to 9.1, his shooting percentage from 43.5 to 41.6, his assists from 5.0 to 3.9. Woodson correctly chopped down his minutes (34.7 to 27.4). Bibby is too much of a liability defensively. With two years left on his contract, he’ll be difficult to trade. But at worse he’s a shooter to bring off the bench. Who to start? If Sund can’t acquire a veteran point guard and leader, take a look at Jeff Teague. He was mostly buried on Woodson’s bench, averaging 10 minutes a game, but we know he can bring speed to the lineup. Leadership? Those answers will come. But he can’t possibly be worse.
♦ 6.) Get tougher: This sort of goes back to coaching and a team’s identity. “Talent” doesn’t pertain only to a team’s skill level. Talent can be intelligence and physical and mental toughness. Talent can be heart. Too often, the Hawks have lacked that. Horford called out his teammates for it and he was dead on. Those intangibles can help a team overcome injuries and adversity. Milwaukee was a difficult team to play against. Charlotte was a more difficult team than the Hawks for Orlando to play against — not because of “skill” talent but because of the other kind of talent. There needs to be an in-house mandate by the Hawks of playing to a standard. If that exists now, they’re clearly ignoring it.
♦
Follow me on Twitter @JeffSchultzAJC and on Facebook.com/JeffSchultzAJC
♦
Recent Hawks posts
♦ Hawks make quick exit against Magic, and change is needed
♦ We’re LIVE from the Hawks’ . . . final game?
♦ Johnson, Woodson get hammered by national media
♦ Hawks quit on season (and Joe doesn’t care what you think)
390 comments Add your comment
SDM
May 11th, 2010
9:39 am
Could it be? First?
Keith Thomas
May 11th, 2010
9:41 am
What…Keep Woody. Let Joe go…Trade Josh to Minn. for Al Jefferson and let the good time roll…SDM if you are first say something.
First to say something worthy.
SDM
May 11th, 2010
9:41 am
Ok, on to the serious stuff.
First of all, can Josh play the 3? Do you really want him on the perimeter taking jump shots or, even worse, 3-pointers?
That sounds like a really bad idea to me.
Jimmy
May 11th, 2010
9:42 am
Could we resign JJ and add on a Marvin Williams to get a Paul from NO or DWade from Mia?? I would hope we’d be able to fleece some team for that deal.
DP
May 11th, 2010
9:42 am
Jeff, I mostly agree except that Josh Smith can’t play the 3 on either end. He is effective around the basket but not out in space on either offense or defense. Horford and Smith are both 4’s, but there are no more of a handful of legitimate 5’s in the NBA. If the Hawks could somehow get one they’d need to move Smith in the trade or subsequently trade him for a legitimate 3 or a point guard.
mike G
May 11th, 2010
9:45 am
do idiots actually go around to different articles just to say “first”? Man u need to get a life!
Ok, you were dead on with these fixes. Problem is…we have non-basketball minds running the organization. I would add Josh to the trade mix, because there are better players out there, and honestly, when looking at the strides the other draft picks around him have made..I think he’s reached his ceiling.
Section 303
May 11th, 2010
9:46 am
I agree with just about all of this.
Except, I would look into trading Josh Smith. I am just fed up with him. How is he going to respond to a new coach? I think you will see major problems if a new coach comes in and benches him for shooting his stupid jump shots or not getting back on D because he had to argue with a ref. Josh Smith is Josh Smith. This series proved that. There is a market for him. I think the Hawks should take a look.
I hope they can find a way to trade Joe Johnson to the worst team in the league.
Agree that Woodson needs to go. But, I put this debacle on the players. They are the ones who should be most accountable. Complete lack of effort. No pro athlete should ever have that problem.
Juan
May 11th, 2010
9:47 am
Definitely get rid of Joe. He forgot who pays his salary: the fans. He deserved to be booed off the court in hopefully his last game as a Hawk.
Wesley
May 11th, 2010
9:48 am
Everything but #4 is spot on. We definitely do not want Josh Smith to be moved to small forward, where his poor shooting habits will be maximized and his ferocity in the paint will be minimized. Rather than focusing on bringing in a new center, a position where we’ve already got a starting all-star, we should start exploring our trade options for a new small forward. Perhaps by packaging the rights to J-Chill and maybe a draft pick or two along with Marvin, we could bring in someone with a pulse. Marvin needs a change of scenery to get out of Chris Paul’s shadow in ATL anyways.
Section 303
May 11th, 2010
9:50 am
Jimmy, let’s just stop the D-Wade stuff. He isn’t coming here. Not today. Not tomorrow. Not ever. Don’t waste your energy posting about it.
3DawgKnight
May 11th, 2010
9:50 am
Do you have specifific info that ‘Bosh’ would love to come back?
-or-
speculation?
Dr. Kenneth Noisewater
May 11th, 2010
9:53 am
sounds about right- start handing out the pink slips today
allan in texas
May 11th, 2010
9:53 am
Jeff, the rumors are out there that Tony Parker may be available as well as Darren Collison. Would either of those guys be a good fit here. I would like CP3 as well as the next guy but I think that a lot would have to be given up to get him.
Hockey Fans in Atlanta
May 11th, 2010
9:57 am
Guffaw, chuckle, chortle, guffaw!
Hawks…you suck!
Don’t let the door hit you on your entitled backside Mr. Johnson!
Adios!
dtc
May 11th, 2010
9:58 am
Woodson does not need to be fired, his contract is up, just do not rehire him. He should be respected enough to not fire him, for what he HAS done. He definitely has talent to coach, but not at the playoff level. Kind of like Bobby Cox in that format. Neither one of them knows how to raise their coaching level, to the next level, to win the big games.
Trade Joe Johnson? Definitely, either for a center, or for draft picks, so we can move up in the draft to get a center. Joe Johnson is no more useful to the Hawks than tradebait. Mike Bibby, say bye, he is not an elite player at his position, good, yes, great, no.
Josh Smith, Al Horford and Crawford stays. Build the team around them. If one of them goes, fire the one who made the decision to trade him.
Fact. No team makes it past the second round without an outstanding center, and with a forward who stops going forward in the playoffs. We have no natural center, Joe Johnson stops at the gate entrance when it comes to the playoffs. Just imagine how good Al Horford will be when he can play his natural position fulltime, without having Joe Johnson around. Al Horford is a phenominal player. Some people have “it” to play at a high level during regular competition. The great ones have the ability to raise their level even high, that is Horford and Crawford, time will tell on Josh Smith, when he matures into his talent.
Remodel this team – do not tear it down and rebuild it. BUT, who is the coach to take this team to the next level. I have no idea. Suggestion Do not renew coach Woodson’s contract. Put out a statement “all who are interested in this job, please send me your resume. It is time to take the next step. We just do not know that man’s name today.” Ask the great coaches who are active, but not going anywhere “who would hire if you were me?”
Just now re-read your comments on Chris Bosh. If you are just replacing Joe Johnson, you are not upgrading. GET A REAL CENTER.
Marcus
May 11th, 2010
10:00 am
can’t argue with any of those points, Schultzie.
I admittedly don’t know a lot about the NBA trade rules, etc. but can we package the rights to Childress, the 2nd round pick (our natural one or the one acquired from HOU in the David Andersen trade) and our natural 2010 draft spot to move up in the draft with a lottery team to snag an instant starter at a position of need?
I know it sounds very NFL-like (it is), but if we could do that, SHOULD we do that?
I guess it all depends on who becomes the new coach and his philosophy regarding our existing line-up, including retaining/re-offering JJ.
Hockey Fans in Atlanta
May 11th, 2010
10:01 am
Oh yeah, don’t get your hopes up about Jeff Teague…watched him for two years playing for my alma mater. He’s a whiny, spoiled brat who can’t play defense. Darren Collison, hell he might make Chris Paul expendable due to his salary point, is definitely a better option.
Too bad y’all won’t be able to afford Chris Bosh since you paid Mike Bibby 4 times what he’s actually worth! The ASG would be much better off spending $6 M for Sergei Gonchar or $5 M for Anton Volchenkov. If the Habs can play lockdown D with the stiffs they have on the blueline, then the playoff revenue future for the Thrashers should be bright.
Just Being Real
May 11th, 2010
10:02 am
GO HAWKS!!!!!!!!!!! into the offseason and work on ya game.
Rock Preston
May 11th, 2010
10:03 am
Sign Rudy Gay to offer sheet. Trade Joe to Spurs for Parker.
Dr. Warren
May 11th, 2010
10:03 am
Why make the assistant the head coach? Bring in a proven winner, if possible. If a company is sick and the morale is low, the idea is to bring in a new CEO with a fresh voice, not promote from within. Also, like the Falcons, they should get rid of any bad attitude or lazy players. Make it a policy that they must behave like winners all the time, not just some of the time. That means Josh and Joe and Marvin should all go. Josh could bring a great player in return. And Josh Childress, who played the best of any Hawk in the Boston series, is a smart, strong character Stanford guy who plays hard. Do what it takes to bring him back.
sam
May 11th, 2010
10:03 am
I agree with all of this, except the recommendation for the new coach. It needs to be someone with head coaching experience and a successful track record. The fans are not going to be happy about giving the job to an untried assistant from a failed regime.
JJ
May 11th, 2010
10:04 am
Elite PGs in the league:
Chris Paul
Deron Williams
Jameer Nelson
Rajon Rondo
Derrick Rose
Steve Nash
What do they all have in common? They didn’t sit on the bench “learning to play the game” for a year or two. So what does that say about our man Jeff Teague? Either Woody really is an idiot that wouldn’t play a legit talent or, more likely, Teague isn’t the answer.
Navigator
May 11th, 2010
10:07 am
Jeff: You got it right, all right, and Joe Johnson is the prim a dona type that holds his own value higher than anyone else does. A center is an absolute necessity if the Hawks will ever have a chance to beat Orlando.
German accent
May 11th, 2010
10:07 am
Very good, Jeff. Wake me up when Sund has that to-do list accomplished.
Dozer
May 11th, 2010
10:09 am
Josh Smith is a loser – can anyone ever imagine any of the greats loafing like he did in the middle of a PLAYOFF series??
Time for a new coach – the players have stopped listening, and there needs to be some sort of a half-court offense other than clear-outs.
Find a way to replace Joe Johnson – he can NEVER redeem himself here after playing so small…..
Marcus
May 11th, 2010
10:09 am
Agree with building around Josh and Horford. To me, it seems like we stagnated on offense because Horford and Josh haven’t been allowed to expand their roles and maturity due to the teams continued deference to JJ even after we have grown and gotten more talented.
That deference, albeit necessary when JJ came over from PHX due to the youth and talent deficit, now serves as a crutch for the entire team.
It took me all season to see it, even with the few games I caught on national TV (by virtue of not being in the ATL viewing area). Even though JJ came through in many games this year and years past, the the long-term prospects of the still mid-20-something core of the team (Al, Josh, Marvin, Teague), JJ’s departure may be the best solution.
Mr. Phil
May 11th, 2010
10:10 am
In case Rick Sund is reading this
Here are some options I saw online @http://www.onlinebasketballbetting.net/what-the-atlanta-hawks-can-do-if-joe-johnson-wants-out/
No.1: Hawks get Devin Harris and Courtney Lee, Nets get Joe Johnson.
No.2: Hawks get the draft rights to Ricky Rubio and a future first round pick, Timberwolves get Joe Johnson.
No.3: Hawks get Monta Ellis and CJ Watson, Warriors get Joe Johnson.
No.4: Hawks get Michael Beasley, Miami’s 2010 first round pick and a couple of future first rounders, Heat get Joe Johnson.
All of these are great ideas as Far as I am concerned
PMC
May 11th, 2010
10:10 am
If they really want to sell tickets and fill the arena they need to at least make some offers to Wade, Bosh…. various other superstars etc.
The building isn’t filled due to the lack of a true superstar that would garner some national interest.
Unfortunately there were too many strike outs at the top of the draft under Billy.
Taco Bell
May 11th, 2010
10:11 am
Can someone explain to me “sign and trade?”
I thought Joe could walk after the season?
Mr. Phil
May 11th, 2010
10:11 am
BTW: Agree 295% Jeff.
Mike Jay
May 11th, 2010
10:11 am
dtc,
I believe the Celtics just one it all without a ‘outstanding’ center. It can be done and is not our most glaring need. If we let joe go we have got to get a good, tall, physical PG who can defend. We can not start Crawford without a good defensive PG it would be a ugly and we would need to score 120 pts a game to win.
Mr. Phil
May 11th, 2010
10:12 am
@taco bell
Joe can walk. But in order to get max money, he would have to sign with the Hawks and be traded to another team. (salary cap stuff)
Mr. Phil
May 11th, 2010
10:13 am
The Devin Harris trade option would solve both the Joe Johnson and defensive PG problem
Jeff Schultz
May 11th, 2010
10:13 am
SDM — I understand the downside to Josh at the 3 but playing the 3 doesn’t mean he needs to fire up jumpers.
PMC
May 11th, 2010
10:13 am
Rajon Rondo took quite a while to round into an elite point guard so we can hope for Jeff Teague… though sitting on the bench and not playing at all I’m not sure has worked much for him because he’s going to have to take another year to learn on the court but Woody is the coach….and that’s his philosophy.
Marcus
May 11th, 2010
10:14 am
the only problem wioth the new coach scenario is that the ASG seems not to have the $$$, desire or inclination to get a respected, high-profile (and high $$ ) coach that will get the remaining core (JJ or no JJ) to get past this level of being 2nd round playoff roadkill.
Having said that, what *available* coaches qualify for that role, even if they would consider it?
Michael Scharff
May 11th, 2010
10:14 am
The Magic have a Superstar center who basically sets the tone for the rest of the Team. There are not very many big men available, unfortunately. It’s a lot like the Dawgs – we had three big men this past year, but none of them were above average talent. In modern basketball in either D1 or the pros, you have got to have strength and power in your inside game. Travis Leslie is an extraordinary talent, but once the best teams in the SEC figured out that his game is to try to go the rim, they were able to blunt much of his attack (the dunk over Kentucky notwithstanding). His size hurts him when he trys to “muscle it” inside. Not only that, but the Hawks have no reliable outside shooters that you can count on for 20 points a game (and no,I don’t think Joe fits the bill – he has shown time and again in the playoffs that he does not have what it takes to be a true leader).
Ethan Benoff
May 11th, 2010
10:14 am
Atlanta, once again welcome to sports infamy!! The single worst NBA Playoff series of all-time… I’m not kidding…look it up! Woody is definitely gone, and J-Johnson is defintiely gone! Where do we go from here? I don’t think it’s going to be as “rosey” as some of you think around here for the next 3 years. We are going to be bad for several years as we totally restructre our team (which by the way is the right and only decision). We are not an attractive market for basketball players, so don’t think we are going to acquire Bosh, Wade or anybody in Tier 1. We will only be able to build through the draft or do a sign in trade, both of which are options that exclude the players having a choice. Bye Bye Hawks, as you once again slip into sports oblivion!!
Mr. Phil
May 11th, 2010
10:14 am
@Rock Preston I agree with you. With Rudy Gay, plus trading for Devin Harris and Courtney Lee, we are actually an improved team.
Jeff Schultz
May 11th, 2010
10:16 am
Allan in Texas — Interesting about Parker. Spurs getting swept out could lead them to make changes. But team’s GM is denying he would deal Parker.
pmuckle
May 11th, 2010
10:16 am
hawks do not have a leader on the team! Need team leder(s) not a team with egos!!
Mr. Phil
May 11th, 2010
10:17 am
I think the Nets will make the deal, hopefully leaving enough money to offer Rudy Gay. Check this quote:
“If the Nets can get the number 1 draft pick (and John Wall), this is a mutually beneficial deal. The Nets get Johnson at 2 and automatically form one of the most lethal backcourts in the league – add Brook Lopez to the front court and you have a playoff team right there. Plus, they can even sign another big name – imagine a Nets lineup of Wall/Johnson/Williams/Amar’e/Lopez with Chris Douglas-Roberts, Yi Jianlan and a couple of veterans off the bench. That’s a contender in the East.”
Jeff Schultz
May 11th, 2010
10:19 am
Marcus — yes, Childress’ NBA rights could be traded, and yes draft picks can be traded. Not sure who this team would be zeroing in on in the draft though. Too many other things have to be settled on first before the draft priorities are set.
Najeh Davenpoop
May 11th, 2010
10:19 am
Of all the dumb ideas that get floated about the Hawks, plYing Josh Smith at small forward is consistently the dumbest. Small forwards have to spend a significant amount of time on the perimeter. What part of Josh’s perimeter game do you like? His shooting? His dribbling? His lateral quickness?
Josh should be in a system that puts him within 10 feet of the hoop at all times. That can be accomplished with him at power forward.
Mr. Phil
May 11th, 2010
10:19 am
If the NETS really think Joe will help them form a “lethal” backcourt. I say let them have at him and we will be better off. If the NETS get the number one pick, no way they keep Devin Harris. I think we need to get on this deal ASAP.
DirtybyrdATL4life
May 11th, 2010
10:19 am
I hope the issue TRULY isnt money, b/c if it isnt, lets spend some & get some talent to surround our young players with. With our current roster we will always be a 2nd rd and done team. I 1,000,000% agree with you Jeff, its what Ive been sayin to my friends, coworkers, random ppl etc.
Simon says he has a new identity system | ZDNet
May 11th, 2010
10:20 am
[...] moves were anticipated as much as that of Simon Phipps (above). You might call him the Joe Johnson of Sun open source. So far he has gone all Matt Asay on us with a blog, and announced he is joining [...]
Jeff Schultz
May 11th, 2010
10:21 am
Hockey Fans — kudos for working Sergei Gonchar into a Hawks blog. You get bonus points for that. … On Jeff Teague: I want to see him play. On Chris Paul: I keep hearing this about how he might be traded. I’ll believe it when I see it.
Jeff Schultz
May 11th, 2010
10:22 am
German accent — I’m guessing Sund will have everything wrapped up in the next 10 days.
S Hawk Fan
May 11th, 2010
10:22 am
Jeff…. I am so glad that you are saying that Woody needs to go! I was beginning to think that none of the AJC writers were going to say this! My question to you Jeff is what do you think of Larry Drew? He is not another Woody is he? And what coach would you go after if you were the one selecting the next coach to lead the Hawks?
Jeff Schultz
May 11th, 2010
10:24 am
Taco Bell — Joe can walk. But in complex NBA salary cap world, there’s a chance he can actually make more money if the Hawks sign him and deal him than if he goes somewhere else and signs as a free agent. So you tend to see more sign-and-trades than guys just walking.
Jerry West
May 11th, 2010
10:25 am
We’re complaining about guys giving max effort, but then want to acquire Rudy Gay? Gotta love it.
Hawks 2010
May 11th, 2010
10:25 am
I agree with this whole article and do need to keep Josh I just think Josh isn’t really trying because of the fact that their coach was Woody and he and Woody have never really got along so this is pretty obvious that a new coach will push him and Josh is young and has a lot of potential as fans I want someone who is young who has talent Josh just needs heart and a new coach can do that as far as Joe, I think his time has come & it’s time for him to go…
El Bravo
May 11th, 2010
10:25 am
Woody has to go but I think you try to resign JJ. Josh can’t play the 3. You need proper spacing to effectively run an offense in the NBA. That being said, I agree that you do not trade Josh. I think he can be a great piece on an outstanding front court rotation. You do need is to add a solid center to split minutes. I’d say you try to trade Zaza and Bibby and bring someone like Brendan Heywood (UFA). He can provide the size needed to guard against the bigger centers in the league while you distribute minutes between Al, Josh, Marvin, Brendan and Maurice at the 3, 4 and 5. I think Marvin can still flourish in the right system. He was asked to stand around too much in this offense while running ISOs or pick and rolls for other players. He was the last option on the floor at all times and it’s tough to develop any offensive rhythm that way. Finally, you hand the point to Teague and bring a veteran backup such as Luke Ridnour (UFA). Now you have two points that will push the pace and play aggressive defense.
Mr. Phil
May 11th, 2010
10:26 am
Ok. Here it is one more time for those who are not seeing the genius.
Starters
Devin Harris
Courtney Lee
Rudy gay
Josh Smith
Al Horford
Bench
Jamal Crawford
Marvin williams
Mike Bibby(if not dropped or traded)
Jeff Teague
ZaZA P
and spare parts
Coach
Avery Johnson.
German accent
May 11th, 2010
10:26 am
“Josh Smith is a loser – can anyone ever imagine any of the greats loafing like he did in the middle of a PLAYOFF series??”
See Jabbar, Kareem-Abdul
Rufus1
May 11th, 2010
10:26 am
Trade Josh
JOSH is a QUITTER, he has proven it on multiple occasions. Mental toughness and focus are what you develop as a child…NOT 6 YEARS INTO YOUR CAREER!!!!
KEEP JOE
6′7 240 lbs 21pts 5rbs 5ast and our best perimeter defender…YOU DON’T GET RID OF GUYS LIKE THAT. GET YOUR HEADS OUT OF YOUR BUTTS!!
PLUS…If Josh leaves Al will assume he place as the leader of this team..JOSH WILL NOT BE LEAD…we have 6 years of proof.
JOSH TRADE…could equal Monta Ellis, Devin Harris or Tony Parker. My choice is Parker…Contract is shorter and the(Spurs) may have to take Bibby to get it done.
Tweets that mention Fixing the Hawks: fire Woodson, trade Joe, keep Josh | Jeff Schultz -- Topsy.com
May 11th, 2010
10:28 am
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Andrew Rosenberg and freehawk, Jeff Schultz. Jeff Schultz said: My six-point plan for fixing Hawks starts with firing Woodson, dealing Joe, keeping Josh. http://bit.ly/bo4q85 [...]
lazydawg
May 11th, 2010
10:29 am
Hawks Suck!!!! Fire,trade everyone time to start from the begining and by the way, Joe will not help any team in the NBA,so over rated.
Mr. Phil
May 11th, 2010
10:29 am
@Jerry West
I am saying Gay from a talent perspective and luckily because of his reputation of not being an effort guy he can be had comparitively cheap.
But I think the right Coach can change that about Gay (the same type that can get the most out of Josh). If we assume Avery Johnson is that kind of coach. We have to believe he can get maximum effort out of both of them. Remember Gay is still very young.
MarkS
May 11th, 2010
10:30 am
Wow – Bosh would be a fantastic fit. I loved watching this team develop the past few years, but I have to admit that they’ve gone about as far as they can go without some major shape ups. I also don’t think I can stick up for Woodson much anymore. I think the lack of creativity hits the nail on the head pretty well (along with not being able to get these guys motivated).
jojosunshine
May 11th, 2010
10:30 am
Do you see what Orlando did? They have a young nucleus of talent and then brought in Vince Carter. The Hawks need to sign and trade for the #1 draft pick and get John Wall. They need to package Bibby and Williams and whoever else not named Horford and Smith and get the #2 or #3 draft pick and get Evan Turner or Demarcus Cousins (Turner because he can score and will be the next Kobe or Demarcus because he is big and plays great defense and can score around the basket). THEN GO GET TRACY MCGRADY. Imagine a team with the line-up of:
1-John Wall
2-Evan Turner
3-Tracy McGrady
4-Al Horford
5-Demarcus Cousins
2nd Group
1- Teague
2- Jamaal Crawford
3- Maurice Evans
4-Marvin Williams/Josh Childress(if we could get him back it would be nice-he has great bball IQ)
5-Zaza
WOW that would be a great team.
Jeff Schultz
May 11th, 2010
10:32 am
S Hawk Fan — I don’t know Drew real well, we’ve spoken a few times. Definitely a different demeanor than Woody. … Who would I go after? Jeff Van Gundy.
BBgenie
May 11th, 2010
10:32 am
Damm! Hurt Don’t It? Yes!!!
Just Being Real
May 11th, 2010
10:32 am
keep Josh Marvin Teauge Crawford Horford & ZaZa, Put Horford at the 4 spot, let Josh and Marvin have the three together, let teauge start, and bring Crowford off the bench, find a center and a shooting guard and put them all on ten day contracts.
Mr. Phil
May 11th, 2010
10:33 am
@jojo There is no way in God’s green earth the Hawks will have the first three picks in any draft in ours or anybody else’s lifetimes.
Jerry West
May 11th, 2010
10:33 am
Also, Najeh makes a great point, Josh is NOT a 3. If you’re gonna slide Al to the 4, Josh has to go.
To that end, if I talk to Golden State, I’d see if I could do Monta for Josh. Or maybe Josh for a package including Anthony Randolph (along with Turiaf, Biedrins or whatever contracts to make it work).
In all honesty
May 11th, 2010
10:34 am
I totally agree. I said before this series that Zaza should be moved to center, Horford to power and Josh to small. There is no chance you can beat Orlando leaving Horford at center. Josh is a definite starter in this league with a lot of potential. Woodson is not that coach. I am an ex-season ticket holder moved to the 15-game package. I have watched them since Woodson got here. He yells at the players like they are children. There’s obviously nothing in his playbook because they do not run plays. He misuses timeouts. He certainly can’t handle a strong personality like Josh Smith has. The objective is to win a championship. It has to go through Orlando, a team they cannot beat. Adjust!!! Woodson is slowly growing. Do you want to wait? Don’t just settle for being better than the previous season. Actually, since they were swept in the 2nd round both this season and last, technically they were not better. The team doesn’t suck; they’re almost there.
Mr. Phil
May 11th, 2010
10:36 am
@Schultz: You stealing my ideas? I said Jeff Van Gundy over a week ago.
And now you suddenly want to get rid of Joe Johnson days after I register the domain number2sucks.com? I am flattered.
Now if I can get you on the Devin harris, Courtney Lee, Rudy Gay train we will be just peachy.
Mr. Phil
May 11th, 2010
10:36 am
Enter youAlthough I did switch to Avery Johnson from Van Gundy. Keep up will ya.
clay
May 11th, 2010
10:38 am
I agree on not signing woodson and letting joe walk and even also keeping josh. I just think josh needs a different coach, the right coach to straighten him up a little bit more. look how far he has come, he will only get better. Statistics have proved that. I would love to see tony parker come in because we are missing that superstar at point. We wont be able to get cp3 because we will have to give up to much. The one thing that I do not agree with is signing chris bosh and not getting a legitamate 7 footer. If we sign bosh we are still in the same boat we are in now and thats nobody to guard howard or any other big man in the league. That means you still leave horford at the 5 spot. Everyone needs to give sund a chance because as any true atlanta hawk fan would know we are still trying to overcome all of the bad moves that billy knight made. Sund is on the right track and this will be his 3rd season coming up so this one is very important since there are some key moves that need to be made. He knows just like we all do what needs to happen with some things, im sure he gets on here or hears some of the stuff that we say on here. Trust Sund, he will make the right moves.
#1 Falcon Fan
May 11th, 2010
10:39 am
Hello HAWKS..look at what the Cavs did last year after they loss in the eastern conf finals..they brought in Shaq because they had no answer for Dwight Howard. We had no answer for Howard either, so we do need a true center. Horford needs to be moved to the 4 spot, fire Woodson, let Johnson go…sign Ray Allen (he is a free agent at seasons end), and then offer a big contract to amare stoudemire (he can opt out with the suns after this season) Stoudemire can be your true center and he can deal with Dwight Howard. we are not gonna get Lebron or Dwayne Wade so we can stop dreaming. My starting 5 for the 2010 season would be Crawford, Ray Allen, Horford, Josh Smith, and Stoudemire with Bibby and Marvin Williams coming off the bench! Bring in Avery Johnson or Jeff Van Gundy as the coach!
ATLborn
May 11th, 2010
10:41 am
Get a new coach get rid of Woodson. Joe can sign and trade. “No.4: Hawks get Michael Beasley, Miami’s 2010 first round pick and a couple of future first rounders, Heat get Joe Johnson.”
Dr. PHil dont do it Beasley has no work ethnic. Keep Josh see if a vetern coach can get something out of him if not look to trade next year mid season. As for point guard sit Bibby look to develop Teague also bring in a guard but its a known fact Woodson doesnt like playing rookie. We are the four best team in the east but it is a large gap between us and the top 3. Start with the Head coach and when you hire a new one let him help you decide what we need to do. But go for a vet first whos been in the league and knows basketball. not a group of people that just tired of us losing
S Hawk Fan
May 11th, 2010
10:42 am
What type of coach is Jeff Van Gundy? How would the players relate to him? And I am fine if he kicks them in the butt! But he has to be able to relate and get across to them!
The Larry Drew thing just seems too close to Woody! Afterall he did work for him!
MannyT
May 11th, 2010
10:43 am
You skipped the real first 2 steps.
Sund needs to figure out the best style of play for this team. Then he makes roster assessments on who is a keeper and who is the subject of well placed trade rumors within the media.
After that, you get your new coach.
Personally, aside from Al, I doubt I would say anyone is untouchable. However, some are more likely to stay than others. Keep in mind that Joe didn’t play ISO Joe until he met Woody. They didn’t play all dribble no drive in Phoenix.
Somewhere in your plan, you need to allocate space for a shooter. If Joe leaves, while Bibby & Marvin hit the bench, then you either need an Okur type shooting center or a new SG who has range. Otherwise, everyone will pack it in and let Josh fire up 3s.
FUZZUP
May 11th, 2010
10:44 am
74th ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ
Kelvin
May 11th, 2010
10:46 am
I agree with a lot of the comments already posted. Josh Smith cannot play the 3 position. NO seems to have fell in love with Darren Collison, so they may be open to trade Chris Paul. Al Horford needs to be moved to the 4 position. Josh Smith will either have to come off the bench or package him in a trade to bring in a Center or PG.
MannyT
May 11th, 2010
10:48 am
…and if Jeff van Gundy and that 68-66 final score style of play comes here, they can have my season ticket. These players are not physical enough to play that wrester defense. You eliminate the value of being very athletic. Sund would need to do a major overhaul of the roster. People don’t buy tickets to see defensive scrums in most pro sports. I see no revenue improvement and ugly basketball if JVG coaches here.
He’s much more interesting as a TV personality.
Tweets that mention Fixing the Hawks: fire Woodson, trade Joe, keep Josh | Jeff Schultz -- Topsy.com
May 11th, 2010
10:48 am
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Tony Simmons. Tony Simmons said: Fixing the Hawks: fire Woodson, trade Joe, keep Josh http://bit.ly/b2e6Rd [...]
christopher palmer
May 11th, 2010
10:49 am
dont trade joe thats just stupid
Casual Basketball Fan
May 11th, 2010
10:51 am
Let Joe go and sign Wade. Then sign Allen Iverson for some major scoring punch! Mutombo could be coaxed out of retirement for a bargain. Trade Josh Smith + Jeff Teague for Dwight Howard and Marvin Williams for Brandon Roy. Package Bibby, Randolph Morris, and Zaza for Nowitzki. Get Marbury back to the NBA. Steve Smith still works out and practices at small forward now, so we might as well take advantage of that. Penny Hardaway is probably cheap now too and he can come off the bench. Then get Viliu Roskanovich from the Russian League who has been lighting it up. Keep Jason Collins who showed some great D in the playoffs. Brad Stevens will come here to coach and get control of these players.
Iverson/Marbury
Wade/Roy/Penny
Steve Smith/Roskanovich
Nowitzki/Collins
Dwight Howard/Mutombo
Coach Brad Stevens
Is no one else seeing the genius in this?
Jerry West
May 11th, 2010
10:51 am
Folks, we ain’t getting Chris Paul. The Hornets new owner is a billionaire La. guy who is not letting his franchise player go. He actually has the $$$ to exceed the luxury tax and try to get CP3 more help. The more realistic option is Collison, maybe for the rights to Childress or a resigned Childress and a bad contract (MoPete or James Posey).
ATLborn
May 11th, 2010
10:52 am
MannyT if that is the case about Sund if he does it the way you said then when a new coach comes in his hands is tied as to how to run his offense and defense. and that will put the hawks behind a year. Bring coach in first and coach and Sund sit and decide together whats the next step.
Clay
May 11th, 2010
10:52 am
Jeff, wouldn’t you like to see Doc Rivers taking charge of Teague’s development? Maybe it’s not dream world for it to happen. It’s now or never for Doc to win another title with the Celtics. After this season he may tire of the pressure Ainge is heaping on him…
If not Doc, maybe his top assistant?
clay
May 11th, 2010
10:52 am
just read a rumor on espn.com nba’s home page that joe johnson might be doing a sign and trade with dallas which would be great. If they want him bad enough dallas will give up some pieces. That means you get a legit 7 footer in brendan haywood and a good scorer in caron butler. That would be a great trade. You answer one of your holes you have and everyone will get to see horford go to his natural 4 position.
clay
May 11th, 2010
10:55 am
as far as the coach goes I dont see why doc rivers is out of the ? why would he be a legitmate shot for the coaching spot. Look at some of the great things he did here as a player. Now imagin what he could do as a coach.
JSS
May 11th, 2010
10:55 am
@Jeff Schultz…
OK, I told you last night I wanted to hear “specifics.” There were some, but I still see a lot of “ifs.” That is not a criticism, it is a point.
So let me go through this, from the bottom to the top, so indulge me…
You call it getting “tougher.” Michael Cunningham calls it “basketball intelligence.” I call it “athletic accountability.” Self awareness is the most liberating thing in the creation. It keeps one from lying to one’s self… This team lacks this in truck loads. If they had it, they would have been driving to the basket, cutting through the high and low posts and having 4 players crushing the defensive boards from the opening tip of game 1. It is no secret why this team has regressed as Mike Bibby’s skills have deteriorated. He (and Horford) is the only player on that roster who have inkling of on the court basketball sense. Unfortunately, he is now Craig Hodges, Steve Kerr, Sidney Moncrief at the end of his run, just a shell of what he was, a 19-20 min. hired gun who should float into the offense but can not defend any more. In the best of all worlds, you have a Lamar Odom at 3/4 or Derek Fisher that can stabilize you when your star is off the floor. Childress can’t do that, Flip Murray can’t do it and sure enough Marvin Williams has never warmed to it… Only two players on the current roster have any basketball IQ, and they both over the hill (Bibby and Joe Smith).
Coaching is study, preparation, teaching and in-game execution. Look, Al McGuire couldn’t coach offense to save his life. He was a demon of a defensive coach but his offensive accoutrement was zero. He had the good sense to hire Hank Raymonds who was this side of Tex Winter a offensive flow genius. Players must become extensions of what you plan. This team has never appreciated that driving to the basket is an art. There 3 things that Hawks GM and owners need to demand of whoever they bring in as a coaching candidate. 1. Have them sit in a 1 hour tape session with Jeff Teague, Josh Smith and Marvin Williams individually and collectively. In that session make those players breakdown what is happening on the floor and their responsibility, their teammates job and what went wrong or right on those plays. After that, if that coach can’t tell you how to work with those 3 players, move on to the next candidate. 2. Any candidate must have a bench coach with NBA head coaching experience or extensive D-1 head coaching success. I don’t care if it is Terry Porter, John MacLeod, anybody but Fratello. A great candidate would be Ritchie Adubuto simply because he knows the Magic inside/out since he been doing radio color for them. 3. Hire Mark Price as your full time shot coach, no outside consulting, strictly Hawks and make him your offensive asst. head coach.
Finally Organization….
This team must reevaluate, what are we? How did we fail so badly? Where do we plan to be at the end of 1st mini camp?
There is so much more, but that is where I’d start…
bigboi
May 11th, 2010
10:57 am
77th zzzz
Let him Joe
May 11th, 2010
10:58 am
Coach – Doc Rivers, he said he is leaving boston.
Center – Horford he is a future Tiny Tim almost as good size matters only against Howard
Power Forward – Josh Smith, Maybe being beat by a friend and seeing how listening to a vet (Ewing) and working on his game has taken that friend to another level may wake him up. (Howard did’nt listen at first) OIA shh noly in Atlanta.
Small Forward – Marvin Williams, If Kobe only got 10 shots a game and no plays his avaerage might be the same.
Shooting Gaurd – Jamal Crawford, let’s get someone that can be groomed to start and let them come off the bench for at least half the year.
Point – If we can’t get a pure point that can start let Teague try it.
Bench – Pa P’U’ la must go and find a real center to back up Horford and play alongside him in certian situations.
Spot up shooter like Mark Price and Kerr to stretch a defense (deadly accurate)
Defensive specialist and banger.
These are your tools to succeed
GT Alum
May 11th, 2010
10:58 am
OK, Jeff, yeah, playing Josh at the 3 doesn’t mean he has to jack up jumpers, but it will move him further away from the basket, which will put Josh in a position to take more outside shots, and I think the only way a coach could keep Josh from hoisting a bunch of jumpshots if he plays on the perimeter is if he uses a cattle prod on Josh every time he launches a shot from out there.
Plus, moving Josh away from the basket would also have a negative impact on his blocks and rebounds. I’m beginning to think that moving Josh to SF would turn him into Marvin and agree with the school of thought that the Hawks need to trade Josh to open a spot for a true center. The problem is how do you get even value back for a guy who still has as much unrealized potential as Josh does.
Hockey Fans in Atlanta
May 11th, 2010
10:59 am
Too bad the ASG doesn’t have enough money to actually afford guys like Rudy Gay or Devin Harris to play with JJ and J-Smoove. They’d be better off getting rid of JJ and letting Crawford play the 2. Teague, while defensively weak, can push the tempo and get teams on their heels, which will open things up on the perimeter for Crawford, Evans and Bibby off the bench. Bring in some defensive minded types who will commit to playing an up-tempo, pressure the ball style of b’ball. Force teams to play at your speed and hope for the best. Dwight Howards and Stoudamires don’t grow on trees so you’ll be forced to do things a different way. But the Orlando Magic don’t exactly rely on Howard to dominate a game. The biggest difference is their commitment to defense and the ability to SHOOT THE BASKETBALL CONSISTENTLY.
So, in other words ASG, you are better off in investing in a quality puck mover like Gonchar and a true pivot like Plekanec to take your team to the playoffs and get yourself some of that NHL playoff money. You will have guaranteed sell-outs without having to discount your lower level seats…hardy har har!
tidog
May 11th, 2010
11:00 am
This problem dates back to the quierky draft strategy of Bill Knight. The sequential drafts of 6′8 to 6′9 guys with the same abiltity. Now if one or two of the guys had Magic Johnson skills it makes sense but the don’t. So you have this log jam at the 4 position with Josh and Al, good young talent that you don’t want to leave your team. It’ll be interesting to see how Sund goes forward with the team. He’ll probably send a well liked player or two packing. A new coach may need to have a current starter come off the bench if a true post man can be found.
Hockey Fans in Atlanta
May 11th, 2010
11:00 am
Jeff Teague should’ve taken care of his own development…
…BY STAYING IN COLLEGE FOOL!
Then again, Gaudio couldn’t coach is way out of a paper bag.
K-Dub
May 11th, 2010
11:03 am
No way can Josh Smith play the #3 SF..Can you imagine him chasing around the Paul Pierces, Vince Carters, and Danny Grangers of the world? LOL..
SaintsLSU
May 11th, 2010
11:03 am
The Hawks are a nice young athletic team with no real center. Al Horford would be a great PF, but to put him up against D-Howard is not fair. The Magic was the worst possible matchup for the Hawks. The Magic are for real, and the Cavs/Celtics better beware.
MannyT
May 11th, 2010
11:04 am
@ATLborn–Do you really think that Sund would not factor the style of play into the hiring decision?I think that some of the questions he uses in interviews will give him insight into the style of play that the new coach will use.
Thus I can make my Jeff van Gundy comments. If he (or someone who uses his style of play) is the choice, you have much more roster overhaul to do.
The planning happens first, but I would expect the coach to be hired before the draft. Thus the player movement probably comes after the new coach is hired. The feelers for some of those moves can happen before the coach is hired.
ladyhawksfan
May 11th, 2010
11:07 am
I like most of the ideas here.Bringing in Haywood and Ridnour would be good moves.I love the idea of Bosh coming here,but there is o way Josh can play the 3.We dont have the cap space to sign Bosh.The only way to pull that off would be sign and trade.Who should we give up Josh or Joe.Jeff says let Joe go and keep Josh.If Josh could play the 3 i would agree,since he cant u have to keep Joe.Therefore trade Josh,Bibby,and Childress for Bosh and Calderon.If that cat be done then maybe they should put together a package and go after a pg like Harris,Parker or Paul.It is not time to break the team,but a few tweaks cant hurt.
JSS
May 11th, 2010
11:07 am
I said it last night, I’ll say it again, NO Jeff Van Gundy, Avery Johnson nor Byron Scott! If sitting in front of a teleprompter or monitor made you wiser, Mike Fratello would have developed into John Wooden! It ain’t gonna happen!
SCAR Fan
May 11th, 2010
11:09 am
New coach, No more Joe, Give Josh another chance with a new coach, bench or fire Bibby, Bosh would be SWEET and definitely give Teague his shot at running the team. Nobody has any idea what he can do yet because Woody didn’t let him play. At least give him the ball and see what happens. It can’t get worse at the point than what it is now!
MannyT
May 11th, 2010
11:11 am
@tidog–BK’s drafting implied a style of play that was similar to Illinois in the late 1980s with (former Hawk) Ken Norman & Kendall Gill. Similar sized players that had physical advantage on the perimeter and quickness, but not size on the inside.
You can disagree with it, but there was a stream of thought that matched the drafting. Over time you have to make adjustments, but put Chills back on this team and you have a guy that provided good movement w/o the ball and got most of his points due to his activity and offensive rebounding. That would have been very useful while other guys were watching Joe dribble.
If we don’t run and use that athleticism, you are not taking advantage of the personnel. That is another reason why Woody got himself in trouble. When this team was more active, they played better. If you don’t move, it cuts the value of being athletic.
DP
May 11th, 2010
11:12 am
Amare Stoudemire can’t guard centers and he gets most of his offense off of great passes from Steve Nash. If Al Horford and/or Josh Smith got the chance to play with a great point guard like Nash or Chris Paul or Deron Williams, they’d look like much better offensive players than they do when they’re standing around watching iso-Joe.
And K-Dub, Najeh and others are right about Josh Smith. He can’t play the 3 on either end. The TNT crew pointed out last night how his shot blocking had been taken away in the Orlando series because they pulled him away from the basket. Not that he figured out how to go out as far as the 3 point line to defend Rashard Lewis. Josh can’t guard a perimeter oriented 4 like Lewis or Nowitzki and some people actually think he can guard 3’s?
hawkfan
May 11th, 2010
11:12 am
This article is HOGWASH!!!!!!!!!!!
cloudy
May 11th, 2010
11:13 am
Jeff I’m not sure this ownership group will be able to get us to the next level. The Hawks have improved that’s for sure but they haven’t been too open to opening their wallets to buy some proven talent. I remember well the Falcons and what it took to generate a winning team and mentality-new ownership.
Jeff
May 11th, 2010
11:14 am
I agree with most of your suggested changes. Problem is the Hawks did not hussle one bit. My son and I laughed at their effort. It was from the first game against Orlando. Hawks literally walked around and could never complete a fast break. We need a big talent/money elite center and same elite point guard. The Hawks never have spent the money. The last big time player we had was Dominique. That was 20 years ago. Not one franchise player since ‘Nique!
n2u1989
May 11th, 2010
11:14 am
first hire head coach who can coach. Sign Dwayne wade.trade bibby for point guard. if we cant sign D wade go after A.Stoudemire or Bosh. then find some pure shooter to come of the bench.
tom
May 11th, 2010
11:15 am
Hiring the asst coach is a major mistake. Get someone who has been a head coach and has credibility. Spend some money.
shannon
May 11th, 2010
11:15 am
I say keep johnson and get devin harris.. Get Avery Johnson who has coached Harris in the past.. Add Brandon Haywood and you might have a better team!!!! Trade Bibby and Marvin for Harris
BBurch
May 11th, 2010
11:16 am
Spot on in this article. Hawks need some major changes to get away from this pure talent and nothing else team and move towards a team that has heart and can go deep into the playoffs.
tom
May 11th, 2010
11:17 am
When Woodson was hired he was a nobody and still is. There were three coaches available at that time that had Championship experience. They went the cheap route. Yes Hawks have gotten better. To get sweeped two years in a row. Hello, wake up. Get a real coach.
Hollywould
May 11th, 2010
11:18 am
I just heard the ASG is hiring one coach to coach the Thrashers and Hawks. No free agents in either sport will come here so the rosters will stay the same. Might as well lose with one coach than 2. Save some money and maybe fix some t’v’s at Philips.
John Koncak
May 11th, 2010
11:18 am
ok….ok….ok….i got it….here we go….
1st: IMO get a new management team…ASG just sucks big time.
2nd: Get rid of Sund. Horrible GM so far… The Jamaal signing was a GIFT from an old friend.
3rd: Get rid of Woody. Nuff said.
4th: Joe has got to go. Obviously.
5th: Marvin’s time has run out.
6th: Bibby’s days are numbered. Release him.
7th: Josh is the only player with any trade value. Sorry Josh. See ya.
8th: Everyone on the bench is worthless except for Jamaal and Teague. Get rid of the rest.
9th: KEEP AL!!!!
So…..lets see….that leaves Jamaal and Teague and Al and infinite possiblities.
GO HAWKS!!!!
Now you see em, now they burnt off!
May 11th, 2010
11:18 am
Maybe Potato Head can shave his eyebrows off again and everything will be fixed.
Paul Hewitt
May 11th, 2010
11:20 am
Hey, I can coach both. We run the same offense.
AG
May 11th, 2010
11:21 am
I agree, Josh at 3 does not work. Also, take a couple of days to determine the type of team you want. People keep saying get a big center, but they slow you down and don’t make you better (except for Howard, no good centers left in playoffs – second best Bynum.). We are a running fast break type team and you need a point guard to push the ball (Teague) and an athletic small forward who will dunk in your face on the break (Dominque)…oh my bad, anybody but Marvin. I would love Amare here and can be the answer. I would love Devin Harris here and Courtney Lee.
CRACK HEAD
May 11th, 2010
11:22 am
YEAAAHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!
96!!!!!
WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!
Najeh Davenpoop
May 11th, 2010
11:22 am
By the way, if the Hawks get Bosh like many of you want, Horford will still be guarding Dwight. Both in terms of skill set and body type, Bosh is a lot closer to Smoove than he is to Horford. Don’t get fooled by his height. Bosh is rail thin and Dwight would dominate him. Sh-t, even Horford dominates him.
K Dent-
May 11th, 2010
11:24 am
I think the Hawks should keep Woody he is a great coach and you need consistancy with the coaching staff and get a Center. Get rid Joe Johnson and a real team leader who can tell thst young team some on the court toughness in the 4th quarter. AGain KEEP WOODY!!!!!!!
Hatfield Geoff
May 11th, 2010
11:25 am
This sounds good Jeff.
Definitely fire Woodson, I am glad the Hawks gave him the last two years because he did coach this team when the talent wasnt there and he deserve a shot when the talent developed a little. But the Milwaukee series is all I needed to be sure the coaching was not good. To have a team vastly outmanned and still be taken to 7 games is bad coaching. If Skiles had been our coach I’m sure the Hawks would have swept the series. If a sign and trade could be worked out fine, but it if can’t don’t sign Joe even for the $60 million they have already offered. He proved in the playoffs that he is not a player that can lead the team to the 3rd round or a championship. Joe needs to be on at team that already has a superstar whose shadow he can move in and out of, scoring 25 one night and not showing up the next. I don’t hold his comments after Game 3 against him; he was frustrated. But the Hawks need to let him go and use his salary to help acquire a star that can be a leader as well. As for Josh Smith I still think the right coach could harness his skills and make him a great player and not just a great athlete. And the one need above all others is a strong point guard. Someone to drive the lane and dish off to Smith and Horford for dunks and pass back out to Crawford for 3’s. Bibby on the bench you bet. Marvin in a package deal with Joe Johnson would be nice. (That Billy Knight, what if we had Chris Paul instead of Marvin Williams and Brandon Roy instead of the ghost of Sheldon Williams. As Furman Bisher would say, Selah!
HAWKS FAN
May 11th, 2010
11:26 am
@K-Dub: I totally agree with you…That would be horrible to see Josh out there chasing the Paul Pierces, Vince Carters, and Danny Grangers of the world. It is obvious that Josh could NEVER be able to play the 3. I mean, there is real problem, when, you’re on the perimeter, no one is even attempting to go guard you because they know you’re not going to make it and the whole arena is yelling “NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO JOSH!” LOL. You would think that, for someone who has been in the league as long as he has, he would have developed some kind of jumpshot…It’s time to trade Josh.
Tha Real Hawk
May 11th, 2010
11:27 am
Everything here is what I posted 2 days ago. Glad someone was listening. Not if only the ownership was…
Yup!
May 11th, 2010
11:31 am
Exit: Woodson, Bibby, Mo Evans
Enter: Avery Johnson, Travis Outlaw, Brendan Heywood, and A.J Price
Draft: Gordon Heyward or Gani Lawal
Re-Sign: Joe Johsnon
GET ER’ DONE SUND!
ntrigue
May 11th, 2010
11:33 am
I agree with everything except move Josh to 3. I would put Bosh at 3 when josh and Al are both in but would move him to 4 if 1 of them are on the bench!
Here and Now
May 11th, 2010
11:34 am
Since Atlanta won’t want to spend money on a big name coach, if they were smart they would look down the bench of the team that just smacked them upside their heads. Patrick Ewing has been waiting for a head coaching spot for years and is chomping at the chance. Plus he’s the one that works with Howard on a regular basis. What better seneraio could you ask for, you get a cheap coach that knows your main divison competition inside and out, and you get to cripple that team and their best player. Sounds like a no brainer to me.
moorman
May 11th, 2010
11:35 am
i agree with what marcus said. johnson stagnated the growth of the post players. its plain to see. couple that with bibby not being a true point guard, you have the half court issues the hawks have.
Larry
May 11th, 2010
11:36 am
.
.
.
#7) Disregard #’s 1-6 above and cease to participate in this madness!
Really, does anyone reading my words right now truly believe that in today’s modern world we need to be financing a bunch of illiterate, tattooed goons run up and down a wooden floor to put a round ball inside a larger round circular device in exchange for millions upon millions of dollars? Hey, I’m all about free enterprise and all but buying tickets to sit in tiny little chairs and contributing to this silliness just doesn’t strike me as an intelligent use of my time and money.
The answer for this is the same for most of us reading this. Stop awarding these uneducated and ungrateful taller men and their sleaze agents with enormous, guaranteed multi-year contracts and place all of them on a $100,000 base salary with performance incentives that could yield up to $500,000. All of the same players you watch would still be there as none are capable of or smart enough to make this anywhere else and never again will you have to watch a player loafing or staring at something other than his coach during a timeout. If they get it, they will have earned it!
ntrigue
May 11th, 2010
11:36 am
Forget Avery and Jeff Van Gundy both don’t have coaching styles fit for our team. Hire Steve Smith as our new coach!
Jeff Schultz
May 11th, 2010
11:38 am
Mr. Phil — Pretty sure folks have been bringing up JVG’s name for a while, but I’m not holding out much hope. … I haven’t seen that website. I’ll check it out.
Sam H
May 11th, 2010
11:39 am
Loved everything you suggested. I definitely think Johnson and Van Gundy are great choices but I don’t think there is any chance Drew gets the job. A back up center is definitely a big need, similar to how the Magic have Gortat and giving Teague a chance is big issue. Otherwise he will turn out like Acie Law.
BASH
May 11th, 2010
11:40 am
I agree with the decision to get Doc Rivers… He could develop Teague into a Rondo-esque player. Not to mention his demeanor of actually caring would help gain the confidence of his players. The only thing Woodson developed was that nasty looking goatee.
Joe missed his big pay-day by turning down Atlanta’s offer earlier this season. He definitely won’t get the kind of money he was looking for now; especially going “O”-for…
I say we keep Josh Smith and just have Doc busts him in the mouth the first time he whines or has an outbursts. Woodson was so passive that disrespect and discord was obvious on the team. These guys are young men and boys and they need leadership that sometimes calls for tough love.
I like Zaza because of his work ethic and hustle, but he needs to develop a jumper in the off season. Horford could also practice his vert in the off season. I’ll never understand why someone that big will settle for a 1 foot jumper??? Trade Marvin Williams, M. Bibby, Jason Collins, and Joe Smith for a true center (Tyson Chandler??).
Blue
May 11th, 2010
11:40 am
The ASG is broke so Amare, D-Wade, Chris Paul, Bosh or any other prized free agent is not walking through that door.
There are rumblings in Dallas that the Mavericks could look into a possible sign-and-trade for Joe Johnson. They want more offensive punch to help Dirk. However, I would not do that deal unless they were willing to part with Caron Butler and Brendan Haywood.
Either way, Joe has to go.
DO NOT …………. I REPEAT …….. DO NOT offer the head coaching job to Larry Drew. Drew seems like a nice enough guy, but hiring him would be more of the same. We need new blood … And it doesn’t have to be a big name. Just someone who can design a REAL half-court offense, teach fundamentals, and DEMAND respect (Scott Brooks anyone – OKC Thunder head coach). No one even knew who this guy was prior to last season. This next coaching hire is a huge test for Rick Sund.
Lastly, I would offer up anyone on this roster sans Al Horford for possible trade. Sometimes, it’s imperative to take a step back before moving forward.
Spud Webb
May 11th, 2010
11:41 am
All good points, nice blog. I think a new coach = Josh Smith being a better player. He hates woody & so do I!! Lol, what a freaking train wreck that series was. But the Hawks are NOT that far away, have talent but need exactly what you said Shultz. Now the reality of actually doing a sign and trade with Joe, in my opinion, isn’t likely. I think he has KILLED himself with this post season.
Jeff Schultz
May 11th, 2010
11:41 am
Clay — Would LOVE to see Doc here, and I’m sure vast majority of fanbase would love it too. And yes, Celtics associated head coach Tom Thibodeau is getting some attention. Read where Hornets are interviewing him.
Bobby Cox
May 11th, 2010
11:42 am
Shultz, Van Gundy is a loser in the playoffs also why would we want him? Maybe he can hold onto Howard’s leg to slow him down?He also had one the 50 greatest players of all time Mr. Patrick Ewing, who is helping Dwight Howard to be a player and still lost in the playoffs. Woody needs to change his staff up, get a big man and a point guard coach to work with the team Woody has loser assistants around him what have they won on any level, I think we’re find as far as a coach but If we do need a new coach I think it should be Mo Cheeks, he has won a title as a player, he could bring in Moses Malone(winner) to work with the big men, and Andrew Toney(winner) to work with the wing players. Drew can’t lead this team, nor could Van Dummy! In closing when Terrence Moore call Bobby Cox’s job years ago the rest of you guys (media) swept in under the rug. Bobby Cox had the best pitchers Money could by for 10 yrs or longer, know ones was calling for his job but Mr. Moore! Stop asking for a new Coach, we need a 1 and a 5 in The ATL.
Scoots
May 11th, 2010
11:42 am
Some of the proposed trades on this blog are laughable. I don’t think we’re going to see a wholesale replacement of the team – that’s unnecessary and hard to pull off. I think you look at who you want to keep for sure – which should be Smith, Horford, Crawford and Teague. That’s a good base of young or fairly young to build the team from.
Signing and trading JJ for a center/Bosh and a good, veteran point guard that can split time with Teague and mentor him would hopefully take care of the rest. And you’ve still got Marvin, Mo, ZaZa, maybe J-chill as reserves.
Oh yeah, and a new coach.
Simon says he has a new identity system | Find Tech News
May 11th, 2010
11:43 am
[...] moves were anticipated as much as that of Simon Phipps (above). You might call him the Joe Johnson of Sun open source. So far he has gone all Matt Asay on us with a blog, and announced he is joining [...]
Jamar
May 11th, 2010
11:44 am
I love how everybody wants to point to coaching. Basketball and baseball are two sports where coaching matters the least. And this is coming from someone who has coached 5 state champions. Talent wins games. Coaching makes a little difference, but it boils down to talent
John Koncak
May 11th, 2010
11:45 am
Larry: I’m all for it as long as you force the executives of all the major corporations do the same. You see, they have ripped the American people off for BILLIONS AND BILLIONS of dollars.
Jeff Schultz
May 11th, 2010
11:48 am
JSS — Terrific post. You particularly nailed it on Marvin Williams. For the last two years we’ve heard whispers about him being soft, or whatever word you want to use, and I agree. It’s unfortunate because he has great skills. … Also good call on the bench coach. I would think if Sund hired somebody inexperienced, a wise vet in the mold of of a Tex Winter would be ideal. I think we agree this postseason was revealing and there are a lot of big picture issues that need to be addressed.
Paddy
May 11th, 2010
11:48 am
Jeff, all great points. Will you be addressing the ASG as part of the equation in upcoming articles? Maybe there is nothing left to say about this merry band of owners that the fans of bb & hockey have not already figured out.
Scoots
May 11th, 2010
11:48 am
Jamar, it seems to me good coaches get the best out of their talent by motivating them. I saw a Hawks team that completely gave up in the playoffs. To me, that falls to the coach. You being a coach know better than I do, but that’s my take.
JC
May 11th, 2010
11:48 am
Jeff, whose team does this become if Joe is traded for role players, draft picks and/or expiring contracts? Is it possible for Josh Smith or Al Horford to be the man in ATL?
Nate ArchiBALL
May 11th, 2010
11:49 am
On moving Al to the 4 spot – Move Al Horford to the PF and he still isn’t going to drive to the basket with Dwight Howard in the middle. Plus, Al will not get the same open 15 foot jump shots at PF that he gets playing center. (Shots he didn’t make in the Orlando series)
Last night, the Hawks played the entire first quarter without scoring one basket in the paint.
Jeff Schultz
May 11th, 2010
11:50 am
Let him Joe: For what it’s worth, Doc said he was considering stepping away from coaching in general for a year, he didn’t say specifically he wanted out of Boston. But I understand that position can change, and Atlanta gets him closer to his family (in Orlando).
Larry
May 11th, 2010
11:51 am
…and I meant to add…take the 75 million or so save in absurd player’s compensation and agent’s commission and use this money to retrofit all arenas down to about 5000 large, comfortable leather seats with built in massage and equipped with a personal monitor for TV and instant replays. Combine this with superior food and drink with in seat service and your well on the way to pampering those individuals who are responsible for funding the game, not just those goons running up and down the wooden floor.
Scoots
May 11th, 2010
11:52 am
I think Horford should be the captain/leader of the team. He’s showing he’s not afraid to be vocal, and he’s the most consistent and level-headed of the starters.
rickyRook
May 11th, 2010
11:53 am
For all the crap they put us through in this so called Playoffs run, I have five words for the Hapless Hawks – AL HORFORD DESERVES MUCH BETTER! I’m sure this just has to chap his @$$ coming from such a winning background. Above winning, there was effort in Gator land. Where’s the effort been in the last eleven games? Huh? Gimme a freakin’ break!
hawkville
May 11th, 2010
11:55 am
Bosh at center, he’s a power forward, that’s the problem now. How about coaching the two they have, Haywood was giving a chance to play and he’s improved. Coaching and a chance to play could do wonders
Jeff Schultz
May 11th, 2010
11:55 am
Ntrigue — There you go on Josh to 3. Guys can move around. People shouldn’t get so caught up on “He’s a 3, he has to do this or that.”
Larry
May 11th, 2010
11:56 am
Jonh Koncak,
In either case, the NBA or Executives from major corporations, we can excercize the choice to support their businesses or not. What is your choice?
Besides, I know of no “executive” that has a 6 year contract for 20 million a year to play about 40 minutes of round ball 3-4 times a week! Do you?
Jeff Schultz
May 11th, 2010
11:56 am
Ntrigue — I don’t know that Steve Smith wants to coach. Always considered him more with GM potential.
Nate ArchiBALL
May 11th, 2010
11:57 am
Most ex coaches sound like John Wooden when doing game analysis on TV. Remember all of them that you hear on TV were fired several times (Jeff Van Gundy, Hubie Brown, Mike Fratello, Doug Collins) and usually for good reason). Hell, if Mike Woodson was on TV we would probably want him to coach the Hawks.
Jeff Van Gundy – his offenses in New York and Houston were as predictable as Woody’s.
Hubie Brown – besides the fact that he damn near 80 years old, I don’t think most of the bloggers here remember when Hubie coached the Kentucky Colonels, Atlanta Hawks and New York Knicks. GREAT X and O guy but he has some major personality issues.
A little Hubie history….. http://lexnihilnovi.blogspot.com/2009/11/hubie-brown-bill-russell-is-moron.html
Jeff Schultz
May 11th, 2010
11:58 am
JC — As it stands now, Al is the only leader in the locker room.
rickyRook
May 11th, 2010
11:59 am
JC, my money would be on AH, if (and I mean IF) Sund is smart enough to see that a true BIG man is needed in the worst way. That would free AH to return to his roots as a power forward where I happen to think he could do some damage. The kid has skilz! And JS ain’t no leader man! He’s unfortunately suffering from the hometown disease. He’s got way too much on him. I think you do something with him too while he has mad value.
Yup!
May 11th, 2010
12:00 pm
Wee need a coach who uses the Read and React offense or the 7 seconds or less offense…
John Koncak
May 11th, 2010
12:03 pm
You’re right Larry. The Execs steal more like 20 million a month for having cocktail parties and giving themselves bonuses for making their bonus.
Greg
May 11th, 2010
12:05 pm
The biggest change is going to be the head coach and I don’t like the idea of promoting someone from the existing staff. I don’t care if the Hawks particularly like him. These guys need someone to inspire them and push them. Promoting a guy who was under Woodson is too much of the same. Maybe the new coach could keep Drew around as an assistant, but it would be really disappointing if we can’t get someone who is a clear upgrade to Woodson. I don’t think that’s asking too much.
Dillon
May 11th, 2010
12:05 pm
Three players the Hawks should pursue this offseason:
Chris Bosh- A true center who is a proven leader and a defensive presence. Too long have other teams (Boston, Orlando, Cleveland, LAL, etc.) bossed us around inside with little if any shots contested. Bosh would love to come back “home” and play for fans willing to embrace him.
Dwayne Wade- This will probably not happen, but Rick Sund owes it to the fan base to entertain the idea of a true superstar coming to town. He would replace JJ and go beyond the offensive and defensive capabilities JJ has shown. Perhaps most importantly, Wade has proven that his level of play only increases in the playoffs (something JJ could not figure out). Just tell the fans this idea is being entertained.
Ray Allen- A veteran presence. The last “pure” 3-point shooter. This guy can still get it done. He’ll be an unrestricted free agent after this season. He’s been on a championship team in the past, so he knows what it will take. Not the player he was five years ago, but will still put 20 points/game when given the opportunity.
Sund– please just tell us, the fans you are interested in these options. We need proven players here to put us over the top.
Simpdawg
May 11th, 2010
12:06 pm
Jeff, I agree that Rick Sund needs to replace Mike Woodson with Bill Laimbeer, Avery Johnson or Byron Scott. I also agree that this team needs some minor reconstructing, but I wouldn’t dismantle this team completely. The Hawks need a coach that knows how to make adjustments during the regular season and most importantly the playoffs. Secondly Rick Sund needs to sign players with a high basketball IQ, heart, desire and a will to win.
MustangSalley
May 11th, 2010
12:07 pm
Ive been saying all along that the Hawks had their chance to win a title this season and they blew it. The things that got the Hawks in trouble in the series, could have been fixed; and Ill always say that they could have been fixed. During this past offseason, Rick Sund blew a golden opportunity to fix the Hawks by bringing in or signing two free agents who were available for anyone in the league to sign. The Hawks felt they didnt need those guys and the window of opportunity for the Hawks has now officially closed. Those two guys are no longer available AND those particular needs are now going to be quite costly to fix and address. Two of the issues that were hurting the hawks this year; #1) not having a great point guard to run the team and #2) stagnant offense that is very predictable; either joes iso plays; jamals iso plays; josh smith launching ill-timed and ill-advised jump shots #3) blown leads late in games #4) players throwing up untimely shot because the 24-second clock was about to expire (bad clock management), etc. All of those needs could have been fixed had the hawks signed Rafer Alsten and Heidu Turkelu, formerly of the Orlando Magic after the end of last season. Both of those guys could have been signed for pennies on the dollar. Could Rafer Alsten run the Hawks? Yes he could. Rafer ran the Magic when Jamir Nelson was injured at the start of last year and filled in so well that Rafer felt he should be a starting point guard. Rafer led the Magic to the NBA finals and we should have signed him and brought him in to run our team, replacing Mike Bibby, moving Bibby to the bench. In addition, by bringing in Heidu Turkelu a proven commodity at forward, a skilled guy who can not only pass, shoot, score and rebound on a very high, all-star level, Heidu is skilled enough that you could have your entire offense run through him, the same way that the Cavs run their offense through LaBron James. So by bringing in Heidu and Rafer, the Hawks offense would never go stale, which means no blown leads late in games, no problem keeping the offense running smooth, getting the ball to the right open guy to deliver the shots on time, and having two fabulous players would could keep your offense fresh all the time. THE HAWKS PASSED ON THOSE GUYS THINKING THEY WERE A BETTER TEAM WITHOUT THEM. Last night the Hawks set a record for being the team that has gotten blown out the worst in NBA history over a 4-game sweep. WHAT A DISTINGUISHED HONOR TO HAVE. The team we had, with the additions of Rafer Alsten and Heidu Turkelu would have given the Hawks the GOLD TROPHY, even having Mike Woodsen at the helm. The Hawks would have gotten the Gold Ball despite having Mike Woodsen as their head coach. Its unfortunate that Im not running the Hawks because I know that if I had acquired those two guys, the Hawks would have won the title this year. Now the Hawks will have to blow up the team and start over from scratch. I wish we keep Joe Johnson, though, because in my mind hes the third best closer in the game behind Kobe and LaBron.
Carlos
May 11th, 2010
12:08 pm
Jeff, I love your six point plan. I hope Rick Sund reads your articles. If he follows your suggestions he will look like a genius. Maybe you could become the next Hawks GM? Nice article.
LLL
May 11th, 2010
12:08 pm
I have serious questions about this team’s mental toughness and how they prepare. Hard to know how much of this is the coach and the comment from JJ makes me wonder if he is part of the problem. If you remember a couple years ago Childress complained about some issues in the locker room and you wonder if they have come home to roost. He may be more likely to return if JJ and Woody are gone. He could be part of the solution.
rickyRook
May 11th, 2010
12:09 pm
Just listened to JJ saying “it’s still open”. Somebody please tell me why we would want to keep him. He’s not lived up to billing. Don’t give a crap what he says about the fans, we’ve said much worse about him.
Yup!
May 11th, 2010
12:11 pm
Avery Johnson uses a controlled Nelly-ball style offense….I think he will be a good fit. He will also give this team the leader it desperately needs! He’s serious Defensively as Well!!!!
Reid Adair
May 11th, 2010
12:11 pm
Well done, Jeff. I agree with all six steps. As long as Mike Woodson and Joe Johnson aren’t here in 2010-11, things will be better.
John Koncak
May 11th, 2010
12:12 pm
You are right Larry. The Execs steal more like BILLIONS under the guise of giving themselves bonuses for making their bonus.
All I'm Saying...
May 11th, 2010
12:14 pm
Schultz: I agree with you 100%! All of your ‘6-Pack’ suggestions are thoughtful, spot-on, and make total sense. One other thing I’d add is that I firmly believe Doc Rivers could be lured to the Hawks as his family lives in Orlando so he would be much closer to his home (plenty of Delta flights from the ATL to Orlando and much shorter duration), he has a championship ring so knowing that his core is getting past their prime while our window to win is still much larger could intrigue him to consider leaving, and we are not in the Atlantic division so not a direct slap to the Celtics by leaving for another NBA Eastern Conference team.
Also, another coach would more likely be creative on offense and exploit the options presented by signing Chris Bosh. I think Bosh’s game would work very well with Al Horford (and J-Smoove) because Al wants to play low post (and we all want J-Smoove to stay down there) and Bosh could draw the Center guarding him out of the lane creating space for Al.
I also agree that we have seen the upside for JJ and as much as like him as a person, he does not possess the attitude we need from our highest paid player in terms of taking over offensively and defensively and has not elevated his game statistically at all in the playoffs which is required.
Don’t know Larry Drew but if he will at least sit J-Smoove when he gets out of bounds on the court (figuratively speaking) in terms of, say, benching him when he refuses to get back on defense then that would be a major step up.
And finally, will the last person to jump off the Hawks bandwagon take your lily-livered, no-loyalty seat cushion with you because I still believe in this team and this franchise and I don’t think we need to ‘blow it up’ — we just need a new coach, sign Bosh, and do a sign-and-trade with JJ and get good value (not necessarily comparable) in return.
LET’S GO HAWKS!
Just Being Real
May 11th, 2010
12:14 pm
if I was in charge I WOULD get Bryon Scott, only cause you could use that to sway Chris Paul from N.O.
Yup!
May 11th, 2010
12:15 pm
Question: Why do TV personalities say “You know what to expect from a Jerry Sloan team. They play hard”
Why is there a double standard in Atlanta??? Whay are the players being blamed when they are just executing what they were taught and told to do!!!!!??????
Woody is a soft, unimaginative, Inconsistant, bad offensive coach and his team took on his personality!!! End of story!!!!
JSS
May 11th, 2010
12:16 pm
People cry about Josh, but Marvin is the biggest enigma I’ve ever seen. Is he “soft?” Maybe… Is he just Rasheed Wallace wondering aimlessly waiting to be pushed by the right coach in the right direction? Probably, people need to get off of where he was picked (like Jamal Anderson). What in the heck can we do with him is the question, and the answer is very important… Why? Because next summer Jamal Crawford and Horford contracts are up!
Gary
May 11th, 2010
12:18 pm
Jeff,
Are you sure the Hawks can trade Chills’ rights? I was under the impression that it would have to be via sign aand trade.
And if fans are not coming out consistently to watch this team, do you really think they would come out to watch JVG and his style of play?
Jeff Schultz
May 11th, 2010
12:20 pm
FYI, I mentioned the possibility of Josh Childress coming back to the Hawks the other day. John Hollinger of ESPN has picked up on that and wrote this. Your thoughts? .. From his blog:
“The Hawks are looking at [Joe] Johnson’s situation in tandem with that of coach Mike Woodson. He just completed his sixth season and the Hawks have improved their record in the past five. But the past two postseasons have shown, it seems, the limitations of his isolation-heavy offensive approach, and his team’s collective basketball IQ has always been a sticking point. Under a different general with a Johnson-less roster, Atlanta might decide to start Jamal Crawford at the 2, bring back Josh Childress, acquire a speedy point guard and play a much more up-tempo game.”
StingerSplash
May 11th, 2010
12:21 pm
Two moves years ago rendered the Hawks irrelevant on the NBA landscape (which they reaffirmed this past week).
Having Cliff Levingston take the final shot (you hear that laughing in the distance? That’s McHale and Bird still chuckling about that one).
Having a team with Moses, Dominique and Reggie Theus. Praytell who was going to pass the ball enough for two of them, let alone three of team.
And the downward spiral’s escape of the past 2-3 years was only a mirage. Be prepared for the Hawks to revert to 15-67 soon. And quietly be packed up and moved out of town.
Jeff Schultz
May 11th, 2010
12:21 pm
Gary — Same difference on Childress. A team would only trade something for him if they were certain he was going to sign for next season obviously, so the Hawks just do that first. If all parties are in agreement, we’re talking semantics.
Jeff Schultz
May 11th, 2010
12:24 pm
JSS — Remember when Marvin wouldn’t play through an injury in the playoffs vs. Miami last year? That raised warning signs with some in the locker room.
PlusSizeModel
May 11th, 2010
12:24 pm
I don’t know what on earth makes anyone think Josh Smith is worth a dime. Other than the fact that he’s a basketball moron and has no heart, he’s great though.
Larry
May 11th, 2010
12:25 pm
Jeff Schultz at 12:20 PM:
But how will this address the inability to cover D. Howard, the primary culprit of the Hawks four game slaughter?
LarryShaeffer
May 11th, 2010
12:25 pm
Josh Childeress is not the answer for the Hawks. He was good when he was here five years ago but time has robbed him of his game. Hes good if the Hawks were in Greece or overseas, but in Atlanta Chills game has gotten incredibly cold and we dont need him anymore. We can find an adequate replacement for Chills. We need to trade Josh Smith because Smith will never be anyting more than a wannabe basketball player. Smith will never get any better than he is now, who has the game of a stubborn mule who will not listen to coaching. Joshs three highlights of the playoffs this year #1) repeatedly throw up ill-advised, untimely BRICKS; #2) dribble the ball down the court like a guard and promptly turn the ball over; and #3) SULK when you dont get your way and walk down the court, crawling at a snails pace, TEMPORARILY SHUTTING THINGS DOWN, completely indifferent to coaching, fans or anybody. JOSH SMITH SHOULD BE KICKED OFF THE TEAM.
Yup!
May 11th, 2010
12:27 pm
Hollinger is an idiot. Nuff said. We won’t win 40 games without Joe Johnson and everybody knows it.
Stop blaming Joe AND BLAME MIKE WOODSON FOR COACHING JOE!!!!
If I was the coach theres NO WAY I would allow Joe to take 20 seconds off the shot clock before initating the offense NO WAY. I also wouldn’t allow himto take so long to get into his Iso moves. He’s only helping the defense out by moving so damn slow. THATS ON MIKE WOODSON. HOW CAN HE WATCH TAPE OF THAT NONSENSE AND IT NOT BE AN EYESORE!?
JOE NEVER DID THIS NONSENSE IN PHX UNDER MIKE D’ ANTONI!!!!!!
PASSING UP WIDE OPEN JUMPERS JUST SO YOU CAN ISO????? D’ ANTO WOULDA BENCHED HIM?????
IT’S THE COACH NOT THE PLAYERS!!!!!
OH AND CHILDRESS SUCKS!!!!!
John Koncak
May 11th, 2010
12:28 pm
I can’t wait for Josh Smith to be traded so he can get with a REAL COACH and come back and CRUSH the Hawks. It will be UUUGGGGLLLLYYY!!!
You Are So right
May 11th, 2010
12:29 pm
YEs Jeff YOU are so right!!!! So correct, i stand in awe of your common sense!!!! Are you interested in purchasing said franchise! If they follow these 6 steps I will be first in line for season tickets.
Simpdawg
May 11th, 2010
12:29 pm
Rick Sund now is the time to hire Mike Woodson replacement. If you wait to long, all the good coaches will be taken. You have Bill Laimbeer, Avery Johnson, Byron Scott, Sam Mitchell and maybe Glen Doc Rivers, but before the Hawks make any player movement they need to hire a new head coach first!!!
PlusSizeModel
May 11th, 2010
12:31 pm
Also, I find it hilarious that anyone thinks Doc Rivers is some sort of chosen one when it comes to coaching. The guy hasn’t done sh!t other than screw up teams or ride the coattails of three hall of famers. Does no one recall what a stupid point guard he was? Why do you think he’s smarter now?
tp
May 11th, 2010
12:32 pm
Great blog Jeff.
Just for lack of leadership alone, Johnson needs to go. Unfortunately, unless Sund is a miracle worker, I don’t envision a huge return, simply because GMs must leverage a sign and trade as a desperation-type move. Also, it’s not like the Hawks would be picking the team – Johnson has the leverage too.
We know the Knicks covet him. If they offered David Lee, a handful of picks that weren’t lottery protected, and a bag of doughnuts, I’d take it. At least we know we’d be getting an ‘effort’ guy!
Chris
May 11th, 2010
12:33 pm
Doc Rivers has talked about not wanting to coach anymore to spend time with his family. I think even if by some miracle he decided to come to Atlanta, I wouldn’t imagine he would stay for more than 2 years. I’d rather get someone who will stick around for 5+ at least.
PlusSizeModel
May 11th, 2010
12:33 pm
“I can’t wait for Josh Smith to be traded so he can get with a REAL COACH and come back and CRUSH the Hawks. It will be UUUGGGGLLLLYYY!!!”
Funny for two reasons: a REAL baller doesn’t need to blame poor coaching for being an lazy idiot, and it’s “Jon”, not “John.”
You Are So right
May 11th, 2010
12:34 pm
and Chris Bosh is not a center, your main focus is signing anyone that can slow Dwight Howard, Shaquille O’neal, Bynum, Yao, one on one, anyone that can slow any other centers down without requiring a double team. Dwight howard is not going anywhere, so as long as he is in the Eastern conference, and we are without a solution, we are without a ring.
BrianFlannery
May 11th, 2010
12:34 pm
FOR SOME REASON, Joe wants a max contract and we will never see the Joe Johnson who is the third best closer in the game until Joe inks his max contract. Joe will continue to HOLD BACK HIS SKILLS AND NOT PERFORM until him and his agent gouge some team for maximum money.
Disappointed ATL fan
May 11th, 2010
12:34 pm
You could only find 6 Jeff? I say clean house, keep Horford, Crawford, Smith, and Smith. Teague is young so he needs a chance and Zaza plays with hustle when he is in there, as for the rest of them, they can join Joe Johnson on a Greyhound bus out of here.
Disappointed ATL fan
May 11th, 2010
12:35 pm
I meant only one Smith, Josh, not Joe.
Yup!
May 11th, 2010
12:36 pm
Head Coach: Avery Johnson
Top Assistant Coach: Sam Mitchell
That is all….we’ll never have another j-smoove effort problem again….
boiler up
May 11th, 2010
12:36 pm
Good article and very interesting and I agree with most of your comments.. But we really need a small forward that is a consistent scorer.. Marvin Williams is just not good.. He’s average at best. Teague is going to be great.. He’s raised in Indiana and has played against the best through his high school day’s to college to now.. He’s confident and if the right coach comes in.. He could be a future All Star.. Go Hawks and bring a coach in to get these guys to Play Hard all the time..
Jesse
May 11th, 2010
12:36 pm
I would actually consider trading Josh Smith for Kendrick Perkins, a first-round, and salary filler. Smith is more talented than Perkins, but Perkins is a bruising defensive center who can guard bigger guys in the post and still move his feet on pick and roll defense, and he could allow Horford to move to PF – give us a more traditional power team.
I would also explore trading Marvin and Teague for Devin Harris if the Nets get the No. 1 pick. Harris would give us speed, youth, and defense, and allow Bibby to move to the bench.
Devin Harris
Jamal Crawford
Joe Johnson
Al Horford
Kendrick Perkins
JSS
May 11th, 2010
12:36 pm
@ Simpledawg
You only have Laimbeer (if you’re lucky) and Mitchell… Johnson is just craziness waiting to be unleashed again… It could be a new show on PBS: “Young Nellie Revisited!”
clay
May 11th, 2010
12:36 pm
great job schultzy. thanks for the comment back. It would make since for doc to come back here, more since than any other head coach that everyone is putting out there. They do need a proven winner though. Also I read from hollinger on espn that they could do a sign and trade with san antonio to get parker for johnson and go out and sign salmons from free agency but that still leaves a big hole at center position. Then I seen a rumor talking about a sign and trade with dallas and joe johnson which would make it seem that we would get haywood and caron butler or a bench player. What do you think about these scenerios?
HawkKingBibby
May 11th, 2010
12:37 pm
I stopped reading when you said your dream world coach was Doc Rivers. Have any of you ever heard of a salary cap by the way ?
FL Boy
May 11th, 2010
12:39 pm
Way too many scrubs on your team ATL. Spend some money a la Orlando Magic and get you some good players and a good coach (for the next level). Don’t be CHEAP….haaaahaha
John Koncak
May 11th, 2010
12:40 pm
@PlusSizeMode: Funny for two reasons….1. WTF does a “plus size model” know about “a real baller”? 2. Who the fck are you to tell me how to spell my name?
S.C.Smith
May 11th, 2010
12:40 pm
I agree Jeff,
Doc Riv ers would be my first choice if he would come home. Then Johnson or Van Gundy, all are NBA proven. Let Joe go ,then go after Bosh if he comes you can then trade Josh for point guard and or small forward. Keep Crawford, Teague, ZaZa, and Evans. Then flip the rest maybe keeping Marvin or Bibby for the bench. Then you can start Horford, Bosch, Crawford with new point guard and small forward.
Fed Up Fan
May 11th, 2010
12:41 pm
We need to bring Thibodeau down here to prech DEFENSE! Also the Spirit Group needs to stop being cheap and get a free agent.
JSS
May 11th, 2010
12:41 pm
@Jeff Schultz…
If it took the Miami 09 series to raise “red flags” on Marvin within the franchise, these guys are doomed!
Yup!
May 11th, 2010
12:42 pm
Josh is the player. If he can’t act like a man and own up to his mistakes then he will get benched nuff’ said. If he wines about getting benched the he STILL won’t play……IDK whats so hard about that.
It’s PPL workin’ their azzes off tryna feed their families on minimum wage paychecks and you mean to tell me this fool Josh smith should be allowed to step foot on the court with the wrong atttitude???? Making 10mill a year???? F-outta here!!!!
He can sit his butt on the bench or get traded. He sould be thanking God for the position he’s in!!!!!
If I was his coach he’d learn real quick! MIKE WOODSON IS SOFTER THAN COTTONELL TISSUE PAPAER!!!!!!!
OpenMinded
May 11th, 2010
12:43 pm
Woody accepted lazy play and Josh just never developed the self discipline on his own to become an elite player…. he has real good talent but lacks the elite status talent that hustle could have at least pushed him towards… Woodson has to go, Johnson may do better with a coach who has talent for strategy, unfortunatley Woodson and Bobby Cox cannot manage/ strategize a game for hell.
heartofdarkness
May 11th, 2010
12:43 pm
I shall forgo, for the moment, the obligatory call for burning the city, plowing the fields and sowing them with salt, which is an old Atlanta tradition after yet another sports disaster [another old Atlanta tradition], Watching the Hawk’s season “augur in” [in Tom Wolfe's nice phrase] brings the franchise to a point where conclusive proof has been offered that fielding a team of undersized front line players with oversized guards is not a recipe for post season success.
In a perfect world, there would be a Chinese real estate billionaire looking to get his money offshore before things blow up in the Middle Kingdom, and he would be a big basketball fan. With a generous supply of his [or her] money, many of the excellent suggestions offered above might actually be possible to execute.
Accepting for a moment, that the world might not be perfect [nor conform to our expectations for it], the Hawks might accept that Georgia is a low middle tier market for professional basketball and that the basketball equivalent of “Moneyball” would be the most appropriate match for its reasonable expectations of revenue streams in the future. The ideal leader for this franchise would be a Billy Bean-like professional who focussed on undervalued productivity in the league, and assembled his team to be coached in a manner that maximized the talents of the players and exploited the weaknesses of the competition. The Utah Jazz are the closest NBA team to this organizational philosophy, and they have been competitive and watchable since the ’80s.
Watching the Hawks over the years has been like trying to catch the pea being palmed before it gets placed under the shell, or observing the deckchairs being re-arranged on the Titanic.
Mr. Phil
May 11th, 2010
12:43 pm
It Just came to me. My most inspired idea to date (but should only be resorted to if both Avery Johnson and Jeff Van Gundy are not available).
Marc Anthony Jackson as the new coach of the Atlanta Hawks. (bear with me)
1)No one is better qualified to teach Teague to play the point guard position (with or without athletic skills)
2)He must have learned something from Van Gundy about the profession having sat next to him at the broadcast table so long.
3)Nobody saw it coming.
We load up the team with the best outside shooters (as opposed to what we have in the most willing outside shooters) at every position and have Marc Jackson tutor Teague in the art of the pass ( an NBA skill he would have had no one demonstrate for him thus far). We run and gun the rest of the league to death and if we happen to play some defense that would be great too.
(Schultz: if we see this idea repeated anywhere then we will know it is stolen)
Dr. Warren
May 11th, 2010
12:44 pm
Jeff–I made the Tony Parker suggestion 36 hours ago near the top of a previous column…just sayin’, my friend.
Some Sense
May 11th, 2010
12:46 pm
This is truly complex, but these are my observations…for what they’re worth:
Joe, on sign-and-trade, and Woddy to go.
Al Horford is probably not a 4 (Power forward).
Josh Smith is most certainly not a 3 (Small forward).
Marvin Williams still has an upside.
Josh Childress would be an asset.
Teague must “man up” this summer.
New coach can’t be a retread…tight, tight fraternity, though.
Quick(est)action essential.
Tmac
May 11th, 2010
12:52 pm
How can a team give Mike Woodson a two year contract and he be held accountable. And give Marvin Williams a 4 year contract and Mike Bibby a 3 year contract?
While I don’t care for Woody as a coach for the very reason JS states above, his contract doesn’t kill this team. Marvin’s and Bibby’s 5 year contract last year and 3 year deal before this season (for the money) respectfully, straps this team down and restricts improving the team.
So Woody’s is just money, but doesn’t limit the team. I would say goodbye to Woody and thank him for improving the team… But i agree with Jeff, the players have tuned him out. Unfortunately, I think it reflects more poorly on the players than Woody.
JSS
May 11th, 2010
12:53 pm
@Mr. Phil…
There have been a quandary of bloggers calling for Mark Jackson since last Spring. Go check the archives of the Hawks Fan Nest… Also, see my post about TV commentators too… It didn’t help Rick Carlisle nor Mike Fratello one bit!
Eric C.
May 11th, 2010
12:56 pm
Webb, Nique, Ehlo, Blaylock, Steve Smith…guys with heart!!!
Sam Snead
May 11th, 2010
12:59 pm
Please quit saying that we can sign D-Wade.
He would never sign with Atlanta.
No superstar wants to play here. We haven’t had a superstar since the Great Mike Vick
Jeff Schultz
May 11th, 2010
12:59 pm
All I’m Saying is… Thanks. And any question involving J-Smoove is the million dollar question.
Tmac
May 11th, 2010
1:00 pm
My solution:
1. bring in a coach who specializes in developing talent. (this was a negative for Woody)
2. get rid of Marvin Williams for a small forward who can SHOOT and score.
3. get a true point guard. (Teague might be that guy, but who knows. see #1)
4. get a big man who can play defense. (you can adjust lineup with new small forward, JS, AH and new center, 3-4-5 positions)
If they do these things, the Hawks will get better and compete against the likes of Dwight Howard.
But for god’s sake do not give players with limited skills long-term contracts!!!
Jeff Schultz
May 11th, 2010
1:01 pm
Larry — It won’t, unless you get another center as good as Dwight. But Hawks didn’t get SHELLACKED this series because of Dwight Howard. They might’ve lost the series regardless because of him but they got shellacked for all the reasons previously addressed.
DeepDiver
May 11th, 2010
1:02 pm
Jeff, a few issues:
1) Mike Woodson’s contract is up — he doesn’t need to be fired.
2) Josh Smith is a nightmare at the 3, particularly on defense.
3) The Hawks can’t sign Chris Bosh. They are capped out even if Joe walks.
4) No, they cannot trade Josh Childress’ rights. He is a restricted free agent and is not under contract. The only way to deal him is to do a sign and trade, and if they do that they won’t get much back.
I really wish you and Bradley would be locked in a room with a copy of the CBA for a few days. Leave the NBA to Cunningham and stick to college sports, Thrashers, Braves, occasional feature on Falcons. Thanks.
Yup!
May 11th, 2010
1:03 pm
I mean, it’s not like Woody was saying anything important in those huddles anyway. Josh has been hearing the same thing for six seasons “Defense, Rebound, Play harder, Switch, Iso-Joe!, Come on guys!, we gotta get a stop right now, Play!, we need some offense!”
No real strategy…..just weak general motivational statements. Josh KNEW woody didn’t have any answers, so did the rest of the squad. Face it people, Woodson reached his limit.
Doc Rivers
May 11th, 2010
1:05 pm
I heard all guys buzzing that you want me to be your next coach. The only problem I have is that you guys don’t know how to treat a good coach. Mike Woodson brought you guys from the bottom to almost the top, and all you can do is talk bad about him. I will take Timberwolves job before I take the Hawks. No way Hosea!!!!
Sam Snead
May 11th, 2010
1:06 pm
@Jeff Schultz
Problem is, there is no center as good as Howard. You have to do what the Bobcats were able to do to him. Have a bunch of big bodies that can give you a couple of putbacks at least (the hawks bigs cannot do that), and hope for the best. Perimeter players have to stay on the shooters.
The only center that can somewhat guard howard one-on-one is Andrew Bynum, because of his size. I think Bynum can be had, we just have anything good to give up for except Josh Smith, who we should not trade
Jeff Schultz
May 11th, 2010
1:06 pm
You Are So Right: Thanks for the comments. My American Express is pretty close to the limit but let me check it and I’ll get back to you about buying the Hawks.
j
May 11th, 2010
1:06 pm
That Bosh thing is pure speculation. I have never heard anything about him wanting to play in Atlanta again. He played at Tech for 1 year and nothing has indicated he has loyalty to our city. He is from Houston and I heard ESPN a few days ago talking about how the Rockets have all but locked it up with him
Jeff Schultz
May 11th, 2010
1:06 pm
TP — Thanks.
Jeff Schultz
May 11th, 2010
1:08 pm
Clay — Yeah, a Dallas writer through out the possibility of Joe playing for Mavericks. That’s fine, but I would like to know who’d come back here in a sign-and-trade.
Jeff Schultz
May 11th, 2010
1:09 pm
JSS — Let’s just say it really hit home then.
MoreHeart
May 11th, 2010
1:09 pm
The main thing the Hawks need, first step is to have HEART and a Competitive Nature. Larry Drew as head coach, good grief. Get Fratello back or Ty Corbin in Utah. Someone that won’t put up with Josh Smith watching Kiss Cam during a time out. As Barkley said last night, this team is as good as it is going to get and they need to break them up.
Ced
May 11th, 2010
1:10 pm
First off Josh Smith doesn’t need to go ANYWHERE!! Josh was the heart of this team ALL season and for the playoffs. He displayed to me heart and passion, the one person that didn’t display either was Joe. It hurts me to say that but the truth was right before our eyes. Im not 100% sold that Joe has to go, although his comments and his demeanor in the Orlando series seemed like the first steps towards the door. I believe we could make it without Joe and I would be ok with a sign and trade, just as long as we get something back. The one thing that I absolutely believe HAS to change is Woodson as the coach. For too long we have looked like a team without plan on the offensive side, against Orlando it was just embarrising. The Magic out played us, not just because we were over matched in the talent department but because we were out coached in every area. A discrepency in talent shouldn’t result in a blow out EVERY SINGLE game, especially when your team is as talented as ours. The new focus should be on bringing in a new coach who actually believes in BALL MOVEMENT, preaches the fundamentals, and the players actually LISTEN TO!
Sam Snead
May 11th, 2010
1:11 pm
There’s no one from the Mavericks worth having except Dirk and J.Kidd, which the would promptly veto a trade to the Hawks
niremetal
May 11th, 2010
1:11 pm
Wait? Jeff Schultz hates Joe Johnson, loves Josh Smith, and doesn’t know a damned thing about NBA salary cap rules?
I’m shocked! Shocked, I say!
Jeff Schultz
May 11th, 2010
1:13 pm
Deep Diver:
1) Fire = Don’t re-sign. Semantics.
2) Disagree.
3) Sign-and-trades. Things can get done. They’re just more difficult. Space can be created. Open your mind, my child.
4) If Chills agrees to play for a certain time, he can be signed and dealt. It’s all semantics. Obviously no trading partner is going to make a move for Childress if he’s not going to play next season. Semantics.
5) You may now go cuddle with your copy of the CBA.
Gilley
May 11th, 2010
1:13 pm
I agree 100% Jeff. Great story!!
Feudfinder
May 11th, 2010
1:13 pm
Mr.Schultz, I have a suggestion: Let’s trade the whole team to Orlando for the ATL native, Dwight Howard. Then we can sign some CBA players who are willing to listen to their coach.
Jeff Schultz
May 11th, 2010
1:14 pm
MoreHeart — Might be a good call on Ty Corbin.
niremetal
May 11th, 2010
1:14 pm
And hey Jeff: There’s more to basketball than reading the box scores and looking at the players’ heights on their ESPN stat pages.
Jeff Schultz
May 11th, 2010
1:17 pm
Niremetal — I understand I’ll never be as smart as you, so I greatly appreciate you imparting your wisdom. Thank God for you and ESPN stat pages or I’d really know nothing.
Eric C.
May 11th, 2010
1:19 pm
Jeff, LMAO…great comeback to DeepDiver
Mr. Phil
May 11th, 2010
1:21 pm
Did someone say Ty Corbin?!!
If he comes back to Atlanta in any capacity I will move.
And no, that is not extra incentive.
Sam Snead
May 11th, 2010
1:22 pm
Sign and trade JJ…get rid of Marvin Williams somehow, or lay him down on the bench, and get rid of Bibby.
problem solved
Mr. Phil
May 11th, 2010
1:23 pm
BTW….the Marc Jackson idea was a joke.
Ted Striker
May 11th, 2010
1:23 pm
Ted Striker agrees on every single point in this column. Each suggestion Jeff makes addresses either attitude, effort, or technique (or some combination). Thomas has done rubbed off on you.
DawgDad
May 11th, 2010
1:24 pm
It’s no good to have an up-tempo athletic team if the players aren’t willing or able to play up-tempo and be an effort team. You can’t play half-court unless the team is willing to work half-court offenses. This roster has reached a plateau, and status quo will likely lead to a significant back-track in performance. This roster needs to be blown up. Sign-and-trade Joe for a center, if that’s possible, trade Josh, if that’s possible, and bring in some new guards.
The Hawks almost have to trade Josh Smith, but they have to decide if Woodson lost the team or whether it’s just bad apples no coach could control. Maybe they play it safe and move both of them.
Might be this team will struggle to get back to this level, but they might need to step back to be able to make a deeper run in the future. In the NBA it seems you can’t think championships unless you have one of the handful of great players. Nobody on this roster is in that category.
Eric C.
May 11th, 2010
1:28 pm
Josh Smith needs a real hard-a$$, spit in your face kind of coach…no doubt.
Hoops
May 11th, 2010
1:29 pm
Jeff,
You have some interesting points. This is what I would do if I were Rick Sund:
1. Don’t rehire Woodson. Go after the best available coach. Possibly Doc Rivers if he is serious about leaving Boston. Talk to Avery Johnson as well.
2. Sign and trade Joe Johnson. He has value. Get what you can for him. Devin Harris and Courtney lee is a start.
3. Use any player we have except Al Horford in a trade for the best center available.
4. Josh Smith is not a small forward. If we can get a center then use Josh Smith as trade bait to improve the team. I have said many times – Josh for Bosh!
This is possible-
PG – D. Harris, J. Teague
SG – J. Crawford, C. Lee
SF – J. Childress, M. Evans
PF – A. Horford, M. Williams
C – Bosh, Zaza
Head Coach – Doc Rivers
Deewight Howard
May 11th, 2010
1:34 pm
Josh Smith for player-coach!
JSS
May 11th, 2010
1:35 pm
@ Swingin’ Sam Snead
Bynum is not going anywhere… Where this team needs to look is for either one of the European UFA centers. Portland will have to make a move once July comes around. Our team needs quality bench players as well as a true star leader (or someone to accent Horford’s evolution to team leader). A player like D.J. Mbenga with the Lakers, no more Randolph Morris’s! A backup PF/C that can still run like Ronny Turiaf with the Mid level exception. We need tough hustle players who dive and chase.
Big B CH 99
May 11th, 2010
1:36 pm
Doc is retiring for now, he’s not looking to leave Boston to get another coaching job. He’s got yound kids that he wants to spend time with. His son is gonna be a Sr. PG at Indiana, & he also has a daughter playing a sport, he wants to be able to go watch them. But it would be great to get him, & would keep the fans interested.
houstondawg
May 11th, 2010
1:37 pm
Excellent article, I wouldnt like to see Mr. Drew in here coaching because we really need an experienced NBA Head Coach here, enough time of the training mode. JVG or Avery Johnson would be a good match. I think JVG is a better fit because he has alot of successful NBA knowledge under Riley and as a Head Coach. The pieces are here just need to lose Johnson and pick up a quality center Bosh would be great!! then pick up a few more free agents, don’t forget about Carl Landry excellent scorer and Tony Allen has alot of upside. We also need to find a better than average two guard to replace Joe Johnson. Also Draft a 7 footer in the draft or the forward from Kentucky.
niremetal
May 11th, 2010
1:37 pm
Jeff,
If you paid attention to the Hawks for more than 10 games per year, maybe your posts would reflect an ounce of basketball common sense. But since you won’t, let me give you some sound advice on how you could make sure that your posts don’t make a mockery of basketball writing.
Please, find me a professional scout or analyst who has watched Hawks game tape this year and who says that Josh Smith can play the SF. Or find me someone who thinks that the Hawks have the pieces to S&T for Bosh AFTER we S&T Joe. Or find me someone who has read the CBA who says that we have rights to trade in Josh Childress (we don’t – he’s a free agent, and we have NO rights in him except the right to match other NBA teams’ offers).
Or how about this – email your piece to Charley Rosen, Hubie Brown, or Sam Smith. Ask what they think of your half-assed attempt at basketball writing. At least pretend that you have the desire to learn 10% as much about the NBA as you know about the Braves and Bulldogs training camp machinations.
Spend time doing stuff like that instead of talking out of your ass. Then you won’t be a laughingstock on blogs where the fans live and breathe NBA basketball year-round, in contrast to people like you and Bradley who only skim the box scores and watch when the Hawks are on national TV.
Just because you know something about some sports doesn’t imbue you with knowledge of all others. Stop acting like it does.
Feudfinder
May 11th, 2010
1:37 pm
Everybody is pointing fingers at Woodson,everybody is bashing Joe Johnson, but I’m yet to see somebody blame the Unspirit of Atlanta for not giving Mike Woodson a complete team (reputable center).He has had to convert Al Hoford as a center. And you expected Hoford to contain Dwight Howard. Are you seriously kidding me?
DeepDiver
May 11th, 2010
1:39 pm
Jeff – thanks for responding. Easy to sit on your smarmy perch and rain conjecture and generalities.
The fact is, there is no feasible scenario in which Bosh or Dwayne Wade (whose signing here you and Bradley often speak on as if it were at all possible) can arrive in a Hawks uniform, unless they want to take substantially less money than the max (or if Miami or Toronto wants to do a SNT for JJ – ha!).
I am a fan of yours generally but your six or seven Hawks articles a year are so blatantly misinformed it drives me up the wall. Thanks again for taking the time.
niremetal
May 11th, 2010
1:42 pm
And you know – if you spent as much time trying to gain basketball knowledge as you do making snarky comments to those who question your basketball knowledge, maybe you’d actually have passable basketball knowledge.
Long Time Blogger
May 11th, 2010
1:43 pm
Jeff, I would advise you to do what other long-timers do on this blog….skip niremetals posts.
JSS
May 11th, 2010
1:44 pm
@ Jeff Schultz…
See i knew you missed the “bad old days” when Truth-serum, Niremetal and I would come in here and scream all forms of vitriol at you! You almost went back! I said “almost!”
Oh, take a gander at this one day…
http://www.netsdaily.com/2010/5/3/1455677/euroleague-scouting-trip-focus-on
Mr. Phil
May 11th, 2010
1:45 pm
@niremetal
First, find me a professional scout or analyst who has watched Hawks.
None of them really seemed to have watched Hawks games prior to these playoffs. Most work on stats, measurables, and rehashed catch phrases.
JSS
May 11th, 2010
1:48 pm
@LTB…
Stay out that, that is for grown men to settle…
Ced
May 11th, 2010
1:49 pm
Marvin W. a PF?? What are you smoking my friend?!???
Let him Joe
May 11th, 2010
1:49 pm
Bosh is not a good fit unless Josh or Horford leave and I think he will team up with LeBron. All we need are scrappy players with heart and a true point to run the show. a 15 point a night guard could replace Joe. We have a balanced team that needs an offensive minded coach that can create mis matches and put the talent we have in their comfort zones. Marvin can be good if he gets the touches. We could have 5 players that average 15 points and a bench that gives 15 to 20 and play strong D.
pt
May 11th, 2010
1:50 pm
1.trade marvin,za za,a first round pick and the rights to j.chill for mr.bosh.2.keep joe.joe we can’t max you if you want to win big.that would give us teague,joe,yes josh at the 3(bosh can play some one the outside that helps josh from being a traditional 3)al at his correct postion(all star).and bosh.you now have a true running team with nice size everywhere you need it.i do think the team loves woody as a coach.he makes all kinds of bets with them at his expense(remember the afro and no eyebrows).players love a coach like that.everytime in the last three years(atleast five times)woody was as close as one game from being fired.the team always play its best ball.that being said.woody has taken them as far as he can.he has taught them how to win but he hasnt given them no offenssive idenity.what type of offense do we run anyway?i know we run iso.isn’t there suppose to be more.
Numb2daGame
May 11th, 2010
1:50 pm
I think it would be very beneficial if we could get CP3 here. He is ultra-competitive and would try to embarrass Teague in practice until he improved. A lot of the former ACC guys get together and hoop over the summer. Chris Paul was quoted as saying that Jeff Teague is the best pure scorer (not shooter) that he has ever tried to guard. I am a UNC fan and the year that UNC most recently won the championship, the ONE point guard who clearly outplayed Ty Lawson (though I was ticked off at the time) was Jeff Teague.
clay
May 11th, 2010
1:50 pm
Yeah thats why im saying schultzy that if we do a sign and trade with dallas we could get haywood and butler from them. what do you think?
Mr. Phil
May 11th, 2010
1:51 pm
Oh yeah…let’s I forget. Josh Childress sucks(only slightly less than Marvin Williams). Bringing him back to the team solves nothing
Long Time Blogger
May 11th, 2010
1:54 pm
@JSS ditto
Mr. Phil
May 11th, 2010
1:57 pm
@Clay Haywood and Butler works. But then we have to hope someone takes Bibby and Marv off our hands. Maybe we can package them to NJ for Harris and Lee.
ReddJonn68
May 11th, 2010
1:57 pm
This needs one solid thing before any changes are made “Leadership”. Joe Smith was brought in for exactly that reason( he’s at tail end of a decent career) + the resigning of Bibby who was thought 2 also establish himself as a leader ,has failed. I have no earthly idea why we signed Marvin 2 any type of deal, he has been given 2 much time 2 prove his worth, I even think that Josh Childress contributed as much as Marvin has. This league is now being built on guys who play solid D at the 2 or 3 spot & still can hit a three if needed in key situations. Guys like Ariza,Barnes, & Artest have particular roles on their squads. Look at Rashard Lewis he’s not a true 4 but he plays hard &under control which make up for his shortfalls at the 4. Look I don’t know or care what management does with Woodson, they are 2 blame for Hawks present state, by not leaving yourself any type room to improve your team by trades or free agency you will not keep a loyal fan base.It’s a shame though, with all the youth on this squad, the Milwaukee Bucks future looks brighter than ours !!!!!
HAWKS#1FAN
May 11th, 2010
1:57 pm
@RUFUS1, @SDM,@KEITH THOMAS
Y’ALL ARE IDIOTS!!! AND CLEARLY YOU KNOW NOTHING ABOUT BASKETBALL. IF YOU DID THEN YOU WOULDN’T BE MAKING SUCH CRAZY AND ABSURD ASSUMPTIONS ABOUT JOSH SMITH. WHY IS IT THAT EVERYONE IS SAYING THE SAME THING BUT YOU THREE. CLEARLY IF YOU HAVE CUTS AND BRUISES ON YOUR BODY EVERY GAME AND YOU GET BACK OUT THERE AND PLAY, YOU ARE NOT A QUITTER. HE AND JAMAL CRAWFORD ARE THE ONLY ONES OUT OF THE STARTING SIX THAT GAVE THEIR ALL THROUGHOUT THESE PLAYOFFS. WHEN YOU ONLY TOUCH THE BALL MAYBE 12 TIMES IN 40 MINUTES OF PLAY, YOU CAN ONLY DO SO MUCH AS FAR AS SCORING. BUT IF YOU LOOK AT THE STAT LINE THAT HE PUTS UP, THE ONLY OTHER PLAYER THAT DOES THIS IS LEBRON. WOULD YOU RECOMMEND THAT CLEVELAND TRADE LEBRON…NO!!! SO WHY WOULD ATLANTA TRADE JOSH. I AM SO THANKFUL THAT YOU GUYS HAVE NOTHING TO DO WITH THE NEGOTIATIONS OF THE TEAM, BECAUSE SURELY THEY WOULD SUCK ALL OVER AGAIN AND THEIR WOULD BE 1500 FANS IN THE STANDS ALL OVER AGAIN.
Max Money
May 11th, 2010
2:00 pm
The Hawks need to get D-Wade, Bosh and give max money to JJ, for his leadership. With those 3 and Josh, the Hawks can go deep in the playoffs in 2011! Hawk owners—pay up—it will take $20 mil plus per year for D-Wade, plus a ton of cash for JJ, Bosh and Smith will want a bunch more money to stay around too.
JSS
May 11th, 2010
2:04 pm
Folks, Harris and Lee are 10 million in salary, you can’t make it match even in a 3 way deal…
ryan
May 11th, 2010
2:07 pm
Here are 3 players big men the Hawks should target in a sign and trade Boozer,Chris Bosh,and Dirk Norwinzki. I am hearing that Joe Johnson could be traded to Dallas.
BRAD
May 11th, 2010
2:08 pm
1.) Sign and trade Joe, along with Marvin, for Chris Paul or Tony Parker. (Philips would be packed every night knowing that Eva would there). 2.) Sign and trade Joe for Chris Bosh. Move Teague to starting line-up. Trade Bibby or bring off the bench. 3.) Aquire Matt Barnes. Magic got him this year for chump change.
BRAD
May 11th, 2010
2:10 pm
Dirk may also be available through a sign and trade. If you could turn Joe and Marvin into CP3 or Parker. Then, turn Smoove into Dirk. Well, now your talking contenders.
Trade Joe!
May 11th, 2010
2:14 pm
Joe Johnson, trade bait? Funny stuff!!!! Who wants that overpaid loser, who quit late in the season????
jfreak13713
May 11th, 2010
2:14 pm
No secrets about the Hawks issues and those issues start with the coach and end with Joe Johnson. Woody has earned his firing by because he could not adjust his style to fit his talent, but nobody can say that Woodson did not have something to do with the Hawks overall turn around. Good luck Woody and thank you for the time and effort, but it’s time to move on.
Joe Johnson is much like Woodson in the fact that he could not lift his game or the game of those around him in the playoffs. Joe you too gave Altanta winning basketball and for that I thank you, but as with Woody its time to move on.
I like I’m sure most in Atlanta love the idea of Chris Bosh and I hope the Hawks will attempt to make that happen. John Salmons is also an interesting idea and may fit this club? The big issue is getting a coach that demands respect and has an idea how to make this team see its fully potential. I like Jeff Van Gundy, Avery Johnson, Marc Jackson, or Byron Scott. The Hawks really need to make a play for a big name coach to get some street credit from the players.
Overall, I give the Hawks a B- grade this year and that could have easily been a B+ or even an A had they really played with heart in the playoffs.
Hordford: A
Crawford: B+
Smith: B
Johnson: B-
Bibby: C
Williams: D
ZaZa: D
Woodson: D
Couple of changes and some inside help with leadership qualities “Horford” the Hawks should be fine going forward.
allan in texas
May 11th, 2010
2:16 pm
You bring in another coach and you give him a chance to work with Josh Smith. The main reason for that being that if you trade him away and he truly blows up into everything that you thought he would be, it will be the biggest mistake since trading away Dominique back in 1994. I am glad that I do not have to make that call!
KidMagic
May 11th, 2010
2:18 pm
They need to gamble….it was a huge deal for us to let Hedu go and it looked real bad until we knew we had Vince and the giant bonus of Anderson in that deal. We took a chance years ago on a young Tracy McGrady who got no playing time in Toronto. Choosing Dwight over Okafor was a gamble….roll the dice.
Ron Roberts
May 11th, 2010
2:19 pm
I’m no basketball fan, but I know a bad half-court offense when I see it. Rushed shots, lack of passing, panicky hurls to the hoop… the team doesn’t PLAY intelligently.
JSS
May 11th, 2010
2:21 pm
@Brad
Hmmm, Dirk is $20 million… Josh $10.8… How?
GaPeach
May 11th, 2010
2:22 pm
Joe Johnson can kick rocks with open toe shoes….how are you gonna compare yourself to Kobe or Lebron when you don’t know how to take over a game. Let’s get Bosh he will be a great fit, bench Bibby and let Teague play the point.
Steve Belkin
May 11th, 2010
2:26 pm
I told you so…
Will
May 11th, 2010
2:28 pm
People need to forget about DWade coming here. It ain’t gonna happen. Period.
Solutions
May 11th, 2010
2:30 pm
1. Get D-Wade —- pay whatever he wants–he’s worth it
2. Get Bosh
3. Fire woodson
4. Get rid of johnson and josh smith—two losers who have quit the team (they are just collecting paychecks)
5. Find a real point guard
Hope 4 the Hawks
May 11th, 2010
2:31 pm
Jeff, thought provoking article obviously. Here’s a couple quick ones. Who’s responsible for all of the “Isolation plays” the Hawks run. Is it Woody or Joe J.? Whichever is the answer to the question, is the one that has to go. I think the Hawks fix a lot of their problems if they can get a better and more consistent motion offense. From there, I think we need a more consistent defensive force in the middle. I love Al Horford, but he will be even better as a Power Forward. I love Josh Smith and the improvements he has made this year, but I’m not sure he is a good fit as the consistent “3″ man. Maybe, on a rotational basis, but again, Al and Josh fit nicely into a motion offense, as would Marvin Williams, the enigma. Marvin can not be guys off the dribble, but he can be an outstanding ’spot up’ jump shooter and a wing on the break. I love Joe J., but we have tried to make him our ‘Centerpiece’ and that is just not his best role. He will make someone an outstanding ’sidekick’, but I don’t think it is possible for him to fill that role as a Hawk. A change of scenery is necessary for Joe. The backcourt is then, a dilemma. I love Crawford, but the jury is out on Teague. Somehow, the Nuggets got a better glimpse of Lawson’s potential than we did of Teague’s. Why is that? The ‘crystal ball’ will have to tell us whether or not it was Woody or Teague. Bibby is no longer a lead guard, but that’s OK. Now that we know it, we don’t ask him to do what he is no longer capable of.
Lastly, we have come a long way since 13-69. Let’s not get so radical, that we return to those inglorious days. An embarassing 2nd round elimination is bad, but there’s only 8 teams out of 30 that got to where the Hawks have 2 years in a row. I want to get to the next level as much as anyone, but I don’t ever want to get where we were 5 years ago.
BRAD
May 11th, 2010
2:37 pm
JSS.. Marvin and Smoove should work out pretty even $$ wise. Joe and Marvin would definately work. Then maybe Smoove straight up for CP3 or Parker.
Yeavis
May 11th, 2010
2:37 pm
John Salmons?! You mean the guy that was shut down by Joe Johnson in the playoffs John Salmons?…come on Jeff …that move is niether exciting OR effective…if anything it puts this team in a worse position…I Love the enthusiam that Atlanta now has for the Hawks but let’s not rush to get back to where we were 8yrs ago. Joe Johnson and cast, are in need of a different voice from the coaching position…I love Mike Woodson but “the writting is on the wall” …This offseason will test Rick Sund’s commitment to this orginazation and CITY becoming a winner!
JSS
May 11th, 2010
2:39 pm
Steve Belkins was going to give Billy Knight additional draft picks to work with… No thanks!!!
Billy
May 11th, 2010
2:42 pm
What ever happens, Johnson’s A$$ needs to be GONE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
bdawg1968
May 11th, 2010
2:46 pm
I cant understand the people wanting to trade Josh. Yes his gets upset at times on the floor. But its mostly when he is helping on defense and his team mates dont rotate to cover his man. It makes him like bad most of the time. Joe does need to go. Sign and trade or straight up letting him sign with another team. Take that money ang get a center and hopefully through trades/signings bring in a PG(s) and SG(s). As for the coach…Woody has done all he is can do for this team. People, This team is not far from completing for a conference title over the next few years. Just a few changes is all thats needed. It will happen!
JSS
May 11th, 2010
2:46 pm
Nope, you still another piece and they already have Caron Butler. Joe and Marvin is over $22 million… Chris Paul is $13.5 million… Tony Parker is $12.6 million
Sick & Tired Of Being Sick & Tired
May 11th, 2010
2:49 pm
AJC HELP WANTED —– EMPLOYER – The Atlanta Hawks (positions must be filed before the start of next season)
NEEDED – A New Coach (NBA experience preferred)
– A New Center (a stud that clog the lane and be successful in the paint)
– A European Shooting Guard (must be able to consistently hit 3s…..
country of origin….optional….name doesn’t necessarily have to fit on
the back of a jersey)
ReddJonn68
May 11th, 2010
2:56 pm
Look all of U keep talking bout changes & I agree it never hurts upgrade your frontline. But have U been watching the networks & reading any other newspapers online. I love my Hawks, Falcons, and Braves. The truth is the truth no matter who states it.” The Hawks just gave up” Bottomline is this Disease we have Quitting, Lack of Desire, & Frustration needs 2 be eradicated ASAP. For example Utah Jazz were overmatched by 3 bigs in the Laker series, but they competed every single game. Phoenix is not really tall up front(Channing Frye shoots 3s all day) & we saw first hand how Milwaukee fought tooth & nail.So don’t give me that crap about being small up front we won 53 games with that same frontline. Thats why every single Hawk player, Coach, & member of Management needs to step back & look deep within. I don’t care what quick fix you bring in the new coach better get rid of this Disease
Tweets that mention Fixing the Hawks: fire Woodson, trade Joe, keep Josh | Jeff Schultz -- Topsy.com
May 11th, 2010
3:02 pm
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Mohammad Ridwan. Mohammad Ridwan said: Fixing the Hawks: fire Woodson, trade Joe, keep Josh http://bit.ly/aLdLHZ [...]
BrianFlannery
May 11th, 2010
3:17 pm
Heres an easy fix for the Hawks: Trade Marvin Williams for Chris Paul straight up. Trade Joe Johnson for Dirk Norwinski. Then trade Mike Bibby for LaBron James. Problems Solved. Hawks are now powerful.
Tale of Woe
May 11th, 2010
3:24 pm
The team looks like it has run it course. We will probably wait too long to do anything of significance and we will probably be hoping for the 8th seed in 2 years….
1. We need to trade Joe (he dribbles more than anyone in the league).
2. We need Josh to take a maturity class.
3. We need Marvin to take a basketball class.
4. We need Bibby to take a class on how to turn the clock back to 2004.
5. We need ZaZa to gain 30 pounds and become a dominate force in the middle.
6. We need Teague to become Chris Paul.
7. We need Childress to want to play for Atlanta.
8. We need someone stupid enough to give us something awesome in return for Joe.
9. We need Hawks ownership to pony up some big bucks and get a decent coach in here.
10. We need Horford to transfer his energy to the other 12 guys on this team.
Bonus
11. Crawford needs to have a better season in 2011 than he did in 2010 for the Hawks to be in contention.
Ryan
May 11th, 2010
3:24 pm
Hey guys as being someone thats originally from Atlanta that now lives in Toronto, I have watched a little bit of the Raptors for a while now and all those who want Chris Bosh next season Ill just say this..
Chris Bosh=Joe Johnson- Dont get your hopes up thinking he can be some kind of vocal leader. He’s also just an ideal # 2 option on a team. He is not a max contract player.
And is it just me or does Woody always looks like he has gas or constipated every time we are getting blowed out in a game like we were in Orlando. Somebody give this due some Mylanta or Tums.
S
May 11th, 2010
3:25 pm
Enter your comments here
SuperStation 17
May 11th, 2010
3:27 pm
Send the Hawks back to St. Louis please.
Shoot for the Moon!
May 11th, 2010
3:32 pm
make sky high offers for Lebron, Kobe and D-Wade, the Hawks will reach the NBA finals! Bank on it!!!
mike
May 11th, 2010
3:36 pm
Shultz-
You’re getting slammed on the Hoopinion blog for this article.. and its not just being mean, they have a point about your theories:
http://www.hoopinionblog.com/2010/05/off-season-speculation-can-only-get.html
northcyde
May 11th, 2010
3:36 pm
1) Let Woody Go . . . OK. But if the ASG goes the cheap route, and simply hands over the reigns to Drew, this fan base WILL NOT BE HAPPY. They want a big name coach. But you’re right. I could easily them simply hiring Drew at 4 yrs – 8.5 million
2) Trade Joe Johnson . . and replace him with John Salmons? OK. Decent player. Nowhere near a replacement for JJ though. In this scenario, whomever is the PG must play well right out of the gate. Otherwise, the new coach is going to be forced to go with a Crawford – Salmons backcourt. A backcourt that consists of two shooting guards that look to shoot first and not pass to our developing young forwards. And a backcourt that would be weaker defensively. But we have to get SOMETHING I guess . . . so OK.
3) Don’t trade Josh Smith . . . OK. His potential is definitely not one to be given up on. He’s still very young. He’s the face of the Hawks. He’s also the box office attraction. But his tweener status is part of the problem with this team. The team is “out of balance”, due to the lack of a true center and lack of a true leader-type PG. Smoove needs to play PF to maximize his effectiveness in the NBA. Putting him at SF reduces his impact on a game tremendously, because you take him away from the basket on both ends of the floor. If you sent him to the bench ( to balance out the team if we acquired a center ), but still got him his minutes, who knows how he’d respond to that.
4) Acquire a center ( or Chris Bosh ) . . . now we’re getting into the meat and potatoes of the issue. The only way you can do either of these things, is via a sign and trade. Going into next year, the only chips we have that people would possibly want, is to trade Jamal Crawford or Josh Smith. You’ve already traded JJ for Salmons, so these are the only chips left.
No one wants Marvin, especially with his long contract. Bibby still has 2 years on his deal, as well as Zaza, so no one wants them either, unless in a package deal involving one of our core. So if you’re Toronto, you’re trying to do the exact thing that Atlanta is trying to do in a JJ sign and trade. And when you’re talking about a sign and trade for Bosh, you’re also talking about trading a high salary core player ( Jamal or Josh ), plus a filler to make the numbers work ( like a Zaza or a Bibby ). You just don’t acquire a player like Bosh out of thin air, especially if you’re a team with no cap room, unless you give up something significant.
As for the acquisition of a center, that situation has turned ugly. Jermaine O’Neal is garbage, but would still be better than any backup center on the squad. But he’s garbage. Mement Okur re-upped with Utah, and is hurt. Camby ( the guy we could’ve desperately used ) re-upped with Portland. Shaq will be available, but will probably retire before he comes to ATL. Big Z re-upped with Cleveland. Tyson Chandler probably won’t exercise his player option to become a free agent. So our hope for a center will be some journeyman bench center, more than likely.
5) Bench Mike Bibby . . . ah yes. Bench Bibby to play the “savior” Jeff Teague. We pretty much have no choice in the matter now. Bibby has fallen off significantly. But if Teague is our only option at PG . . we . . are . . screwed.
We’re still going to have to either draft another PG, or sign one via free agency, just for insurance purposes for BOTH Bibby and Teague. I sincerely hope Teague proves me wrong, but with his inability to shoot the ball or finish in traffic, I seriously have doubts on whether this guy can even be better than Earl Watson. ( Earl is a UFA this season by the way ).
6) Get Tougher . . which takes us back to #3. The guy whose toughness is questioned frequently ( both physically and mentally ), is Josh Smith. So if the new coach can make him tough, then everything will be all good. If he can’t, this team will still have the same problems that plague them.
And don’t get it twisted about “toughness”. The Bucks had to get rid of A LOT of players, in order for them to get “tougher”. Remember, this was a team that had Charlie Villanueva, one of the softest, non defense playing players ever, getting major minutes. Michael Redd wasn’t “tough”. Richard Jefferson wasn’t “tough”. Ramon Sessions wasn’t “tough” ( although he had a pretty good year in 08 – 09 )
The truth is that the Bucks pretty much turned over their ENTIRE ROSTER, in order to get rid of those high non-productive contracts. In turn, Skiles brought in the guys that would make this squad “tougher”.
- drafted Brandon Jennings
- Kurt Thomas
- John Salmons
- Jerry Stackhouse
- Ersan Ilyasova
And in turn, those moves helped make Andrew Bogut a lot tougher than he’s ever been in his career. So the Bucks toughness didn’t come about with the same players that were heartless during the 08 – 09 season. No . . Skiles had to bring in those tough guys, both physically and mentally, in order for the Bucks to be the type of squad he wanted.
The same will reign true for the Hawks. If you want the squad to get tougher, you’re going to have to bring in tough players and maybe get rid of a few who aren’t tough. Bringing in a guy like Salmons may not be enough. You may have to bring in multiple “tough guys”. Bosh sure isn’t a “tough guy”.
***************************
Your plan is workable. A “stop gap” to see if our frontline can step their games up and become better players. But I believe the Hawks will take a step back in your lineup, mainly due to the fact that we’d still have the same weaknesses in the same areas as a team. I say that’s a 42 – 47 win squad. Good enough to make the playoffs as a 5 – 7 seed, but nowhere near being a viable threat to get to the next level. Defense would still be a MAJOR ISSUE with that team. And Crawford and Bosh will be taking most of the shots.
*********************************
Schultz’s Atlanta Hawks
PG – Teague
G – Salmons
F – Smoove ( at SF )
F – Bosh ( impossible without a sign and trade of either Smoove or Crawford )
C – Horford
Bench
G – Crawford
G – Bibby
F – Marvin
F – Evans
* 1st round pick
* 2nd round pick
* free agent center acquisition
Gary
May 11th, 2010
3:44 pm
Raise your hand, who would like to see Josh Smith chasing LeBron, Paul Pierce, Carmelo and the other good SFs around? Raise your hand, who would like to see Josh Smith playing outside the paint on offense?
Thats just not his game. He can’t dribble consistently, and he can’t shoot consistently. And his best asset on defense is help defense. If he is playing SF, then he is more likely to be guarding someone away from the basket (like he had to do against Rashard).
Josh at SF is a bad idea. We need him inside the paint.
Paddy
May 11th, 2010
3:55 pm
niremetal….if you live and breath NBA basketball 24/7 I think that is great for you because you enjoy it. You are a dying breed nonetheless. Most casual fans, those who might attend 3-5 games a year have been lost forever. Not just in Atl but in many markets. For most of us it is just not much fun to watch anymore. I am sorry because I used to be a hugh fan.
northcyde
May 11th, 2010
3:58 pm
Gary . . most fans that watch this team understand this. Moving Smoove to SF would DESTROY his status in this league, much like what happened to Andrei Kirilenko in Utah. Boozer was better than AK47, even though Kirilenko’s best position was probably PF.
Sloan tried to turn him into that hybrid F, much in the way Woody did with Smoove, and it worked for a while. But as Boozer, and then Deron got better, AK’s offensive game didn’t get any better. The offense then went away from trying to feature AK, to featuring the new “Stockton and Malone” in Deron and Boozer.
So he started to sulk and eventually became less effective as a player on both ends of the floor.
Something is going to have to happen. Either Horford is going to have to prove that he can play center at a high level on both offense and defend the position defensively . . or we’re going to have to make a decision on which one to keep . . Smoove or Horford.
And this is a decision that we all knew that we’d have to make at some point. 2010 is probably not the time to make that decision. 2011 is DEFINITELY the time to make that decision, with Horford being a restricted free agent.
CPHawkfan
May 11th, 2010
4:19 pm
Sign and Trade Joe Johnson to New Jersey for Devin Harris and Brooke Lopez
Hawks - Jsmooth= improvement
May 11th, 2010
4:20 pm
Woodson needs to go….thanks for getting us this far but byebye. Jsmooth is a team cancer.. i don’t care how athletic someone is, if you do not have motivation to play after getting paid millions every year, it’s time to find another team….How about this…Josh smith and another for Chris Paul… CP3 to Atlanta with Crawford & Horford…. Oh yeah, and Avery Johnson as the coach. Problem solved
Slimm K
May 11th, 2010
4:20 pm
I agree the Coach has to go, Sorry Woody. J. Smoove stays, Jamal Crawford stays, Marvin bench him or trade him, he hasnt lived up to the hype being drafted where he was drafted. Avery Johnson can lead and is all about defense. Jeff Van Gundy maybe he will fit maybe not. We need a Coach who will command his players attention all year long. I’d rather watch fishing than the Hawks next year if Johnson stays or Woodson, or Crawford leaves, honestly.
smh
May 11th, 2010
4:21 pm
Hockey Fans in Atlanta you lost credibility when you said Teague cant play defense and he is whiny. Kid didn’t complain the whole year although the guy in front of him was flat out terrible. Not one time did he complain about minutes or his opportunities.
Eric Daniels
May 11th, 2010
4:23 pm
Final answer. Get rid of JOE and WOODY. And some of the comments being posted are just straight dreams. We will not be getting Wade or James. We won’t be getting Iverson. So lets put an end to all that rubbish. Hire Avery Johnson before the draft so he can have input of the make up of the team. And once again Get rid of JOE and WOODY. While you are at it make sure you pay Crawford his worth. And for the record a true Hawks fan would have said we lost not the Hawks lost.
Ted Striker
May 11th, 2010
4:26 pm
Whatever JSS says, I ditto. Dude is solid.
Emm. G
May 11th, 2010
4:29 pm
You are so on point with the intangibles! That’s goes for teams across the board but definitely a good point on the Hawks… To me the Hawks over acheived this year. They have several people playing out of position with sub-par coaching. Joe Johnson isn’t going to be happy hear after making that statement. Woodson isn’t head coach material. So there has to be some changes on the floor and the bench! Should be interesting to see what moves are made! Chris Bosh? Hmm, I don’t think we need 2 power forwards. We must think bigger!
JSS
May 11th, 2010
4:32 pm
Thanks Ted Striker… Be careful, talk like that will get you cursed out by a Crack Head or a Bayou Dawg
It’s going to be a LONG SUMMER!
ben
May 11th, 2010
4:37 pm
Van Gundy is the right choice. But, it sounds like you don’t have any idea what this team is all about. That’s tough after a 50+ win season to want to get rid of everyone. But, Van GUndy will instill a defensive mindset and never lose by 40.
HAWKS#1FAN
May 11th, 2010
4:50 pm
@JEFF SCHULTZ- PLEASE EXPLAIN TO ME HOW SOME OF THESE PEOPLE COULD SAY THAT JOSH SMITH IS A TEAM CANCER OR HE GAVE UP? PLEASE ANSWER THIS BECAUSE TO ME HE WAS THE ONLY ONE THAT BROUGHT ANYTHING TO ALL THE GAMES. I NEVER SEE HIM BAD-MOUTHING HIS TEAMMATES AS JOE OR SOME OF THE OTHER PLAYERS HAVE DONE PUBLICLY. I REALLY DON’T UNDERSTAND HOW THESE PEOPLE COULD PUT THIS UP THAT ARE NOT CREDIBLE AT ALL. TO ME THEY ARE SHOWING THEY KNOW NOTHING ABOUT THE GAME OF BASKETBALL.
AND FURTHERMORE, HE STARTED OFF HIS CAREER PLAYING THE 3, YES HE HAD A PROBLEM GETTING TRIGGER HAPPY WITH THE THREE-POINT SHOT, BUT HE HAS SHOWED THAT HE CAN BE DISCIPLINED ENOUGH TO NOT TAKE UNNECESSARY SHOTS BY HAVING A BETTER FG PERCENTAGE; SO THAT WOULD TAKE CARE OF ANY QUESTIONS REGARDING THE FACT THAT WOULD LAUNCH NOTHING BUT THREES. BUT I DIGRESS COULD YOU PLEASE ANSWER MY INITIAL QUESTION AS BEST AS YOU CAN PLEASE SIR.
kb
May 11th, 2010
4:57 pm
Trade Josh Smith for a player with a brain.
Ken Strickland
May 11th, 2010
4:58 pm
Before everyone gets carried away with JEFF SCHULTZ’S idea of Smoove playing the 3, remember, he played it his rookie yr. Also, while I understand your sentiments about his jump shooting issues at the 3, it can be overcome. Let’s say we acquired CBosh in a sign and trade for JJ. With the outside shooting ability of Horford @ PF and Bosh @ C, Smoove would be one hell of a load down low for most of the SF’s in this league.
And before you start crying about him having to defend other SF’s on the perimeter, don’t forget, he was forced to defend PG’s and SG’s on the perimeter the last 2yrs in Woodson’s switching DEF. Some of you are thinking just like Woodson, and focusing almost exclusively on what you think a player can’t do, rather than what he can do.
Besides, what makes you think his jump shooting will be more of a liability playing SF than PF? One thing is certain, his post ups will certainly improve playing against smaller, shorter and/or weaker SF’s. Also, with the jump shooting abilities of Bosh and Horford, there will be more room in the paint for Smoove to operate at SF than he’s had at PF over the last 2yrs.
Add PG JTeague’s speed, quickness, athleticism, penetrating and DEF ability, along with Salmons’ solid overall gm, and you have a team with a solid combination of OFF and DEF. A front line of Bosh @ C, Horford @ PF and Smoove @ SF would certainly be a load for most teams on both the OFF and DEF boards.
Smoove can pull it off, provided we surround him with the right players and talent. Bring JCrawford, MWilliams, MBibby and Zaza off the bench, and you have the makings of a solid experienced bench.
JFF SCHULTZ-your suggestions are valid, and I embrace them wholeheartedly.
Agree with Barkely
May 11th, 2010
4:59 pm
I think Charles Barkley said it best during the post game show on TNT… This particular group of players have peaked as a unit. They’ll be no better then a 52-win team and 2nd round playoff exit. That’s fine, I can accept that. We need to make changes to get better, but I’m a proud Hawks fan and the city should be proud we’ve maximized the talent we have in the last 5 years. It’s time to change though and build a team that can win a championship. Congratulations to Coach Woodson and Joe Johnson, as they started with nothing and turned our franchise into winners once again. Now we need to take the next step and build a championship caliber team
Agree with Barkley
May 11th, 2010
5:00 pm
And now someone shoot me for actually agreeing with Charles Barkley…
robdawg08
May 11th, 2010
5:01 pm
Why can’t the Hawks get a premier star player ? We once had Dominique Wilkins. Why wouldn’t Bosh,Stoudamire,Wade,or anyone else not want to come to Atlanta and play alongside Horford and J.Smith ? Use J.J.’s money to sign either a point guard or center. Woody is a memory I hope.
robdawg08
May 11th, 2010
5:02 pm
Zaza is useless…
Steve
May 11th, 2010
5:05 pm
Please lord no. NOT Chris Bosh. Stay far away from him.
He is another Sharif Abdur Rahim (sp? .. just go with SAR for short), maybe a fraction better, bit a small one. I know, all you Tech fans will disagree, but a few years ago everyone loved us getting SAR and he turned out to be a major flop. Bosh is VERY similar. He is a very good complimentary player (just like Joe Johnson whom everyone wants to leave town). He is not the ANSWER, and I will be willing to be that he never plays for a championship team because he will soak up too much money and too many shots for whatever team he plays for to be able to build a strong team around him.
Just say no to Chris Bosh. I would much rather give a younger Marvin Williams the opportunity to become the man on offense without Joe Johnson and Mike Woodson blocking his growth.
Mitch
May 11th, 2010
5:09 pm
1. New Head Coach: Tom Thibodeau, Defensive Genius, Boston Celtics. Want to finally slow down the Magic and one day overtake them? This guy is the answer. Defense wins Championships and he’s already helped the Celtics win a ring and now has incredibly found a way to slow down LeBron and Mo (man, have the Hawks ever guarded him? Does he ever miss against the Hawks? LeBron is one thing…but Mo is lights out every time we play him…how Woody allowed this guy to shoot is mind-boggling) and Thibodeau is doing it with a lineup as ancient as the Rolling Stones.
2. Trade Josh Smith for a center who can muscle Dwight Howard off the low block…like Al Jefferson, for example. We’re set with Horford at PF. He will dominate there.
3. Bring back Childress. He’s a defensive coach’s dream with his length, tenacity and smarts. No more easy three for Lewis and Pietrus.
4. Trade JJ in a sign and trade…John Salmons would be nice.
5. Go with Jeff Teague as the starting PG. Thibodeau will make him our version of Rondo….maybe not as blazing quick, but close, and Teague will be a stronger defender and deep threat.
6. Draft the best perimeter defender on the board—or the best defensive big man.
King of Stone Mountain
May 11th, 2010
5:11 pm
Any reason why RANDOLPH MORRIS can’t get any playing time??? Dude was a BEAST, every year he played for UK. Just consider the talent they let slip away…A.C. Law, Salim Stoudamire, etc., & for what…the likes of Bibby & Marvin Williams? You GOTTA be kiddin me. Tired of seeing ZaZa Pachulia out there too, with his Rocky Balboa lookin self. He has NO GAME either. Just like the 2010 Braves (minus Heyward + a select few), they just plain ole SUCK.
John Smith
May 11th, 2010
5:15 pm
Keep Woody!
JSS
May 11th, 2010
5:16 pm
Acie Law is lucky to still be in the NBA, he has absolutely no self motivation to get better. Salim, what do they say, if you don’t have anything good to say… Randolph Morris was a college star, enough said…
Hmmmmmm
May 11th, 2010
5:20 pm
Ken Strickland,
“And before you start crying about him having to defend other SF’s on the perimeter, don’t forget, he was forced to defend PG’s and SG’s on the perimeter the last 2yrs in Woodson’s switching DEF.”
Yeah, and we all saw how well that worked out.
eturn
May 11th, 2010
5:20 pm
Ok ppl here is the deal..I was born in Atl. Have been a fan of Atl sports for 30+ years. Have you all noticed that the teams in Atl wait till you can get nothing for a player, then want to release them. Here we go with the Hawks. Its time to get rid of Joe… Bibby..Marvin.and probably Josh while we can get a good return. And bring motivated team players who want to win. Instead of just getting a paycheck. Josh never got the college experience to hone his game..he is straight out of high school…he dont know any better.
Jeff Schultz
May 11th, 2010
5:21 pm
Mike – Oh no! Slammed on Hoopinionblog? There goes my career.
Einstein
May 11th, 2010
5:24 pm
Jeff you’re correct about everything except keeping Josh Smith. The Hawks have too many “projects”…Smith, Williams…they need players. Let another team try to coddle a complete game from these bums, especially when there is no financial incentive.
lou hudson
May 11th, 2010
5:25 pm
Jesse!
Your trade suggestions have most logical and sensable written. First, in any trade the money has to be correct so all these Wade, Lebron, or Bosh trades make absolutely no sense. The Bosh deal is the most doable, but also, the worst because it weaken the Hawks. The Hawks have three main issues: No true center, no scoring from the 3, and no lead point guard. If the Hawks are to improve and have a chance to win a championship, they address the above mentioned areas. Perkins is a solid big defense/rebounding center, Devin Harris is a lead PG, and JJ can score at the 3. Moreover, Al is a future HOFer at the 4. People forget how solid a player Chillz was. Also, resign Filp for off the bench scoring.
Perking
Horford
JJ
Crawford
Harris
Bench
Bibby
Flip
Chillz
ZaZa
draft pick PF
This is a team who can compete for a champsionship!
truthspitter
May 11th, 2010
5:45 pm
Blow it up, simple and plain, plus the only way it will really work in the long run
DeepDiver
May 11th, 2010
5:46 pm
You are really showing your unsightly backside today Schultzie.
John Smith
May 11th, 2010
5:51 pm
Bob Weiss
C. Moore
May 11th, 2010
5:51 pm
What is up with all the hoopla over Jogn Salmons? The guy who hasnt done anything in the league untill now…which is his contract year? Not to mention he is 30 or 31…I am not a big Joe Johnson fan however he is 29 and a better scorer than Salmons, Salmons is a good peice but to replace Joe with Salmons is not an upgrade. Joe has trade value that can give us a “solid” big man and another player or draft pick.
Hawks face uncertain future after blowout loss
May 11th, 2010
5:52 pm
[...] Fixing the Hawks: fire Woodson, trade Joe, keep Josh Atlanta Journal Constitution (blog) – May 11th – 09:32 [...]
jo
May 11th, 2010
5:58 pm
100% agreed with everything you said Jeff. Spot on.
C. Moore
May 11th, 2010
5:58 pm
Eric Daniels- Avery Johnson? We are talking about a Hawks management team who dont want to spend money! I am sure they dont want to spend more than 2mil on a coach. The ownership group does not show the motivation to win a championship….POINT…BLANK…PERIOD!!!
Matt "Choke" Ryan
May 11th, 2010
6:09 pm
“FIRE WOODSON, TRADE JOE”
The same should be said about “Smitty and the CHOKE”.
I’m all for taking out the garbage.
At least the Hawks are consistently making the playoffs.
truthspitter
May 11th, 2010
6:11 pm
It’s easy
Woody stay or Fire doesn’t matter, If he goes get Laimbeer, Mark Jackson, or Patrick Ewing. You absolutely need young blood to intrigue the fanbase. I like the Tom Thibodeau idea but he has never played in NBA and you think a team full of guys who don’t listen are gonna listen to a guy who they can always push aside by saying he has never played in this situation is gonna work?
1. Sign Rudy Gay to a contract similar to Josh and Granger, you will have the money. Best case scenario Memphis takes Marvin and a future 1st round pick in a sign and trade.
2. Resign Joe Johnson. Yes it can be done because the rule states you can go over salary to re-sign your own free agent. On the other hand, if he wants more than 5 yr 75 mill, let him walk, Carmelo makes 5 yr 80 and Joe is not Carmelo.
2B. If Joe wants more than 5yr 75 mil, let him walk free unless you can get Devin Harris and a piece or maybe Rudy Gay and Conley for Joe and Teague or Joe and 1st round pick, but you must get a guy that could sniff or has already been a superstar in sign and trade situation or just let him walk.
3. Must draft really good and with a plan in place. For instance, you should already have under the table deals done with Joe before July 1st, so that you will know which way to go in draft. The 2nd round is important and treat it that way, I looked it up 15 of the 30 2nd round players taken last year made rosters. The great thing about 2nd round is you can offer them what salary you like and I dont think contracts are guaranteed.
4. Lastly, if we get Gay and Johnson resigns that will mean that we need to cut some payroll. So, management must earn there keeps in making shrewd moves like trading Jamal’s expiring $10.8 contract or ridding themselves of Zaza and Marvin for basically nothing in return.
5. Management must stop putting out a obviously flawed product then getting mad or giving away tickets when people dont show.
collegedude
May 11th, 2010
6:19 pm
Not too much to disagree with here, basically the same things I’ve been saying about the Hawks this year. Bring in Avery Johnson & Chris Bosh & see ya later Joe. That’s a major improvement right there.
Mystikal
May 11th, 2010
6:24 pm
truthspitter, I’m intrigued by your lineup
Jeff Teague
JJ
Rudy Gy
Smoove
Horford
Who do you think would be good coach for this group?
Mystikal
May 11th, 2010
6:42 pm
If Mark Cuban is tripping in Big D, how bout we try to get Haywood on a 2/3 yr deal or maybe Jermaine O’neal if he’ll take a cut. Trade Marvin away for draft picks and cap space. Either resign Chillz cheaper than Marv, or get Ronnie Brewer or Travis Outlaw.Then trade Bibby for whatever we can get (if anything) and sign Flip Murray for cheap.
Starters:
Teague
JJ
Smoove
Horford
Haywood
Bench:
Murray
Crawford
Chillz/Brewer/ Outlaw
Zaza
Best case scenario of course.
Mystikal
May 11th, 2010
6:52 pm
Bibby and Marv are good guys and ppl you want on your team. But both are too inconsistent and make too much for what they do, or should I say don’t do! Someway, we have to get rid of one or both of them to free up some money.
messin with sasquatch
May 11th, 2010
7:01 pm
hire paul hewitt
chile..boO
May 11th, 2010
7:21 pm
dtc has the most logic point….
tony
May 11th, 2010
7:22 pm
This is what I would do if I was in Rick Sund’s shoes. I’m going to draft and sign high IQ basketball players only. No more low IQ basketball players. I will hire a hc who has played on a championship team or someone who has had some kind of connection with a championship caliber team. I will not do the same thing that the hawks organization have done in the pass. They should at least have won 1 championship since moving to Atlanta. Below are 6 things I will try to do to make the team better with the resources that were handed to me by the owners.
1) Avery Johnson – He played on a championship team and he helped the Mavericks get to their first nba final. He has a wonderful demeanor which I believe will help him connect with our young men.
2) Andre Miller – I am sending Marvin Williams and Jeff Teague to Portland for Andre Miller. Andre has a very high basketball IQ and he is a true facilitator.
3) Brendan Haywood – I will push hard to get Haywood to come to the ATL. He will give us a true center so that Al can move to his natural position.
4) Nate Robinson – I really like Nate. He will give our bench a huge boost.
5) Gordon Hayward – I know this is a long shot but I am going to draft Hayward. This has a very high basketball IQ. He plays smart fundamental baskball. If he doesn’t slip to us I draft Paul George or Luke Babbitt. Both of those guys have a very high basketball IQ.
6) Omar Samham – I am taking Samham in the second round if available. This is a smart kid. He will created havoc in the paint against the opposition. He is a true center.
I couldn’t afford to bring Dwyane Wade to Atlanta and I didn’t resign Joe Johnson but I was able to convince Josh Childress to come back to Atlanta. Starting lineup for the 2011 season.
1) Andre Miller-pg…………………….Nate Robinson
2) Jamal Crawford-sg………………..Mike Bibby
3) Josh Smith-sf……………………..Josh Childess
4) Al Hordford-pf……………………..Joe Smith
5) Brendan Haywood-c……………..ZaZa
If JS doesn’t work out at the 3 he will get bench and Josh Childress will take over.
truthspitter
May 11th, 2010
7:23 pm
Mystikal: I have no idea, I like the possibility of Laimbeer but that does not look like his type of team, neither does it look like a Ewing team, that’s a newblood coaches team, such as Mark Jackson, or maybe a PG like Avery, Coach Cal would be good for that team, but he makes more at Kentucky then we would pay. Maybe even a guy like Mark Price if he wouldn’t to jump into it full fledge or if Mike Dantonio gets booted he would be good for that team.
ListenUp!!!
May 11th, 2010
7:30 pm
We were the 3 friggin seed in the EAST. The only way you get BETTER is to grab some of the players that are STILL in the PLAYOFFS. That means no Bosh Wade Gay Salmons. That Also means no has been coach. Scott Johnson Del Neggro Mitchell. If you cant get BETTER… CANNN Josh
Marvin and Bibby. There is no way you can OVERLOOK they way Josh acted during this post season. Bring in a new coach and he gets BENCHED SUSPENED anddd TRADED all during NEXT season, BET ON IT!. The Hawks should BREATHE Stoudemire until he signs another CONTRACT. S/T Amare for Josh n Marvin. Bibby and Zsa Zsa for Billups. Get Ray Allen for 1 year 8 mil and Shaq for 1 year 8 mil. Fill in the gaps with min. deals. Billups Joe Amare Al Shaq Jamal Teague Evans – he is not opting out West J oneal Leon Powe anddddd Tracy MCgrady he could be our answer at small forward. Yeah these are some big names. But there is no way these guys get more than the vet min after making 20 17 18 21 mil this season. Damn do I have to do everryythinng???
WJ
May 11th, 2010
7:31 pm
Fire Woody. Resign and trade Joe. Keep Josh. Sounds like a plan to me. For those who are suggesting trading Josh at this point I suggest to you that he is a player that ATL needs defensively. Keep him. If he can’t adjust to a new coach then there is time to trade him before real damage could be done. Oh, yes, get rid of Marvin. He just isn’t consistent enough to be a difference maker. If keeping Marvin then let him come off the bench only.
WJ
May 11th, 2010
7:33 pm
ListenUP: Are you serious?
Dooley
May 11th, 2010
7:33 pm
These Blog cats on these comments dont know what there talking bout.Josh was a 3 when he came in the lead.And anybody can improve there shot.Where are the Die-Hard Fans?Getting rid of Joe is another thing because he is selfish.But look at offense and defense wise and joe is the best thang we got.These fans don’t know what they want.If we can get a Coach to use the hawks as there strong points and run the floor josh wouldnt have to shoot.Yall are crazy.Josh is young and has a lot of potential.He wants to wen bad and they don’t listen to Woody because he talks crazy.If we get a team we wouldnt have to worry bout a superstar.Like the Pistons wen they were good.That was a team not about one person.GET AVERY JOHNSON
Kem
May 11th, 2010
7:37 pm
Too many fantasyland comments on this post.(especially the John Wall/Demarcus Cousins proposal made by some crackhead earlier) No ,Chris Paul is not on the trading block. D-Wade nor any top tier free agent is coming to Atl next year. Micheal Beasley??? WTF. Do I need to continue?
WJ
May 11th, 2010
7:43 pm
Aren’t we just great at fixing what is wrong. What don’t we all apply for Sunds job. Maybe between us we could really screw everything up.
King of Stone Mountain
May 11th, 2010
7:45 pm
Whatever it takes to bring in an elite CENTER, get the deal done…asap. What we’re witnessing is the result of drafting far too many FORWARDS from the entire DECADE: 2000 thru 2009.
Shawn
May 11th, 2010
7:47 pm
What the Hawks need is a proven coach, BYRON SCOTT, then we need to get CHRIS BOSH, and start developing Jeff Teague to be the point guard he was at Wake Forrest, or (better option) go get COLLISON from New Orleans, this is how we can keep up with the rest of the league and P.S. Somebody go get Josh Childress from Greece we need him back desperatley. Thats the gameplan, somebody forward this to Sund.
smoove over....
May 11th, 2010
7:55 pm
The lack of energy was incredible during the Orlando series…including that of the fan base. Anyway, it probably is shake up time. Joe Johnson, the quiet leader, just doesn’t ignite passion; and his offense lacks a certain dynamic quality (eg = Kobe ??). Marvin Williams is not a 2 or a 3….so what is he? If Bosh would sign with Atlanta, and Avery Johnson came in as the head coach, perhaps we are moving in the right direction….but if Cleveland doesn’t make it to the NBA finals, Lebron will be in NY….and so will Chris Bosh. And a Knicks dynasty will be built. But Orlando looks pretty bad-ass right now…they are the team to beat.
ListenUp!!!
May 11th, 2010
8:03 pm
WJ yep. It will never be the exact same. But thats the general idea. There are A ton of GOOD UFA coming up next year. Amare is the main target. Will Denver part with Mr.Big Shot?? the play of Ty Lawson says yes. Josh Marvin Zsa Zsa and Bibby are the outgoing targets. Get those two then maybe just maybe you can lure a few of the others at bargain prices for a chance to win and win another Ring. Oh yea somebody got spend some money!! Lux tax baby. But if you are putting an Allstar lineup on the floor guess what…. seats are filled money is made and maybe just maybe a RING is WON!!! And after the worst BEAT Down in Playoff history, Yeah you need something drastic.
Gary
May 11th, 2010
8:40 pm
Ken S,
I agree with you on a lot of things. But moving Josh to SF is not one of them.
Not Drinking the Kool - Aid
May 11th, 2010
8:46 pm
You clowns are crazy, I would not trade Josh. I repeat I would not trade Josh S. You guys must not have seen this kid play all season. First of all the kid can score consistently, against bigger guys inside Josh is quicker, stronger, and can jump over most bigs except Dwight H. Josh is an excellent passer from in the post and outside. Many of Horford’s easy baskets are because of him. At times and I watched 95% of their games this season Josh is a quadruple threat, with scoring, assists, blocks, rebounds, and even steals. The problem is like any young talent he got frustrated in the playoffs. Josh all season has had to cover defensively for Bibby, Crawford, and J.J. lack of defensive effort on the perimeter. When your being killed inside and being told to stay at home it is hard to get blocked shots and when your killing yourself on defense how hard are you going to play with prima donnas jacking up shots and playing no defense and not passing the ball. Under the right coaching Josh will be fine and will probably be better. I agree with Schultz sign and trade joe for a quality player – J. Salmons. Sign Brendan Haywood to play center and Luke Ridnour to mentor J. Teague and run play up and down basketball. Please get rid of M. Bibby trade him for 4 lug nuts and a cup of coffee. Quit hating on Josh Smith you playoff arm chair coaches!!! He is an emotional player but not a bad guy or player!!! Just needs a good coach!!!!
Atl Resident
May 11th, 2010
8:49 pm
Ownership? What ownership? They have they own issues to deal with first, so how they going to have a say about the Hawks? Now its Sund who’s the only one who really knows what’s going on, just like with Knight when he was the GM. And that’s why Knight resigned cause he knew what was up.
glw
May 11th, 2010
8:50 pm
Listenup!!!,
Thats a nice fantasy, but what so many posters fail to realize is, the Hawks have no cap room to sign any of the major players.
And whats up with all these crazy sign and trade scenarios people are coming up with. Why would a team who has cap space and is willing to sign Joe Johnson want to give you one of their important pieces? Sure they would part with a draft pick or a role player, like the Hawks did when they sign Joe from Phoenix, but thats about it.
Maxx
May 11th, 2010
8:53 pm
Damn Jeff, well said. You hit the nail directly on the head in this one. Woody has got to go, we need a new voice and new schemes on both ends of the floor. If we signed Bosh and traded Joe for Salmons, we would be ready to truly contend in the East. I agree about trading Marvin and about Bibby needing to ride the pine or go. Worst-case scenario, if we don’t get Bosh, and release Joe outright, we could trade Marvin and/or later draft picks to acquire a Center and a 2 guard in the draft. I also agree about Teague. We saw a glimpse of the Rondo-like ability he has in the last game of the season against Cleveland. You couldn’t have said it better about Joe not being a leader. Whatever happens, there will not be another offseason like this one for a long time in the NBA, and I think the Hawks should approach it aggressively. Bosh should be our biggest priority
Harry The Hawk
May 11th, 2010
8:54 pm
Jeff;
Thought your mention of Larry Drew was an interesting one…definitely see your points in his favor. However, my sense is moving in that direction breeds trouble, especially with the age and psyche of this group. The implosion over the last three-four weeks suggests there may be deeper problems regarding chemistry than just x’s and o’s. In fact,many of us already have alluded to our concerns relative to leadership (or lack thereof) throughout the Hawks entire organization. Bringing in an unproven commodity may look good on the balance sheet but I can see it being a real problem down the line given the youth and obvious quirks within the Hawks locker room.
For these same reasons, it seems a coach who wields a strong hand, has a pedigree beyond reproach and a history of winning would be ideal. Certainly, rapport with the players is an important consideration. In this scenario, Avery Johnson seems like the best choice.
Before any of this can happen, it seems ASG has to have a clear vision as to what they’re ultimately trying to accomplish. Are their goals—both player and coach-wise—short or longer-term (especially if JJ is a non-factor next year)? Coaching costs/needs will certainly play into this.
While I know you couldn’t cover everything, there was little reference to basketball IQ in any of your player scenarios. Except for Horford, this is an area where the team is SORELY lacking. Even with the right coach, tipping the delicate balance here the wrong way could be a minefield. Although he’s a veteran and plays hard, one could argue John Salmons leaves a lot to be desired in this area (shot selection, crunch-time decisions).
Lots of room for discussions among your suggestions…will be interesting!
glw
May 11th, 2010
9:01 pm
As far as the Josh issue. I think he should be kept too. HE does a lot for the team and his versatility and energy is very important. But his presence does hamper the situation of playing Al Horford at the Power forward position. The most creative situation would be to play both of them their.
First the Hawks need to find a serviceable big man, not that high on Haywood, but maybe him or my preference….draft the big man from Florida State. Insert him in as your starting center, slide Al to the power forward, and bring Josh off the bench. Alibi or whoever could start give you 6-8 minutes at the start of each half and with Zaza in reserve, you could get you 30-35 minutes a game out of that rotation. YOu then play Horford at center only in limited spurts, usually in the 4th quater. I figure Al can get about 15-20 minutes at center and 15-20 at power forward and Josh could come off the bench and still get his 30 minutes a night. His energy would also improve a lackluster bench too.
Move it along
May 11th, 2010
9:10 pm
Hopefully, these worthless hawks and thrashers teams leave town soon—they are an embarrassment—go spew this trash in some other city with a bunch of chumps willing to pay for this “entertainment.” Good riddance!
Ken Strickland
May 11th, 2010
9:17 pm
HMMMMMMM-I don’t know whether you’re being sarcastic or you’re just clueless. Under Woodson, Smoove was our PF and was far too often required to defend against PG’s and SG’s on the perimeter. However, those PG’s and SG’s weren’t required to defend against him. At SF under and playing under a HC with a clue, Smoove would be able to do a much better job of defending SF’s like Granger and CAnthony out on the perimeter, without drawing fowls. On the other hand, those same SF’s would have a very difficult time trying to defend him in the paint without drawing fowls.
Teams would most likely have to double team him in the post because of the match-up problems he’d create. And as far as your point about his issues defending PG’s and SG’s, there are very few, if any, SF’s that can match the speed, quickness and penetrating ability of the average PG or SG.
We’ve seen how devastating it can be when a team has, or can create, match-up problems(Orlando). Well, at SF, Smoove would automatically creates match-up problems that favor us, for most teams. CBosh’s outside shooting ability can pull Howard away from the basket and both Horford and Smoove can post-up and out muscle anyone else on their team at their respective positions.
robdawg08
May 11th, 2010
9:50 pm
Chris Bosh is a force on offense. He won’t disappear in the playoffs like JJ did. I think you’ve got to sign a good free agent to get a second good free agent to sign. JJ & Woodson need to go period. Who wants any player like JJ on their team that takes shots at fans for HIS sorry ass play ? What does he expect home fans to do when he goes 3 for 15 shooting ? Applaud ?
robdawg08
May 11th, 2010
9:54 pm
JJ is supposed to our top scorer. But he wil score 25,32,then 8 & 12. Kobe,Wade,LeBron,etc. don’t dissapear in games like he does. If you tell me ‘he ain’t either of those players” then why is he getting paid like those players then ? You can get a lot more for that money than JJ.
Tweets that mention Fixing the Hawks: fire Woodson, trade Joe, keep Josh | Jeff Schultz -- Topsy.com
May 11th, 2010
10:03 pm
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Brandon the Barber. Brandon the Barber said: How to fix my beloved #Hawks: http://bit.ly/aroNbX [...]
Keep JJ
May 11th, 2010
10:18 pm
The hawks need to give max money to keep JJ happy–they will need his leadership next year, since the team will still be young. Woody will be looking around for jobs without a big raise, so the hawks owners need to step up with a big cash raise, ASAP! With D-Wade next year and a point guard, this hawk team will be challenging cleveland for the east title. Mark it down!
Yup!
May 11th, 2010
10:30 pm
Exit: Woodson, Bibby, Mo Evans
Enter: Avery Johnson, Travis Outlaw, Brendan Heywood, and A.J Price (gotta snatch him from Indy, next Mo Williams for sure)
Draft: Gordon Heyward or Gani Lawal
Re-Sign: Joe Johsnon
GET ER’ DONE SUND!
Lineup/depth chart (15 players)
Jeff Teague>>>>A.J Price
Joe Johnson>>>Jamal Crawford
Gordon Heyward>>>Travis Outlaw, Marvin Williams, Mario West
Josh Smith>>>>>Zaza/Travis Outlaw/Randolph Morris
Al Horford>>>>>Brendan Heywood/Jason Collins
We can win a title with this (Coupled with the right coach). Some of you are making too many changes to a 53 win squad. Half of it is nonsense/impossible moves. Be realistic please. PG was a huge problem. With Price and Teague you get twp big PG’s Teague at 6′2 and Price at 6′3 and poth play solid D and can stay in front of their man. With a new coach we wont have to worry about that stupid switching anymore. Gordon Heyward gets the start because he’s a beast pure shooter and More athletic/coordinated than Marvin. He will space the floor for us. Teague needs to dominate he ball and keep ito ut of JJ’s hands. He just moves too slow (it’s so annoying, but this might be b/c of
Woodson) he just needs to catch and finish quickly. I see Teague turning into a combination of Tony Parker and Rajon Rondo (somwhere in between).
Price is an exellent shooter who can play off the ball with the second unit since Jamal is at his best with it in his hands. Price is a good Ball handler as well. All of the Wings will be neede in the future (i’m assuming LeBron will stay in the East). We also have size up front with Heywood and others.
bonquesha
May 11th, 2010
10:47 pm
Just my thoughts – there is no way Joe does a sign and trade to a losing team. He already made it clear that he is not willing to take a step backwards. So the whole CBosh idea is some BS because JJ is not going to Toronto. Josh cannot play the 3. He is a horrible jumpshooter and on the ball defender and would struggle against most 3’s in this league. I know he played the 3 when he first entered the league but the Hawks didn’t win many games then either. Al just doesn’t have the size to play center consistently and effectively and much of his success this year was due to help defense from Josh. Crawford cannot replace Joe. He had one of his better years in shooting percentage but historically, he’s been streaky and averaged 20ppg once in his 10 years. He has bad habits and a propensity for ballhogging so it gets the Hawks nowhere. He’s fool’s gold. For the record, DWade is not coming to Atlanta so people need to start setting realistic goals.
Well Its Ova
May 11th, 2010
10:49 pm
Mikey G just put the Nails in the coffin on Woody according to interview with MC. I think Woody ends up in Carolina or Philly. I also think the Hawks miss the playoffs next year too. Just get ready to go backwards, this dude actually said Teague Collins and Joe Smith should have played more in this series, Yeah that would have changed things…. Clueless
fayncdawg
May 11th, 2010
10:58 pm
BOSTON IS BEATING CLEVELAND BY 23! IS DOC RIVERS A GREAT COAGH OR WHAT? THAT’S WHO THE HAWKS NEED! GIVE DOC AND BOSH TOP DOLLAR, KEYS TO THE CITY, AND TEAM OWNERSHIP! SIGN AND TRADE JJ FOR EITHER TONY PARKER OR SALMONS. A front court of Josh, Horford, and Bosh will be no worse than the frontcourts of Boston and the MJ Bulls. SIT BIBBY DOWN! IF DOC CAN MAKE WILD CHILD RONDO INTO A GREAT PG THEN HE CAN DO THE SAME W/TEAGUE! BTW, IF CLEVELAND LOSES THIS SERIES, YOU THINK LEBRON IS RE-SIGNING?? NO WAY, AND THE HAWKS WILL HAVE A SMALL CHANCE OF GETTING HIM. BUT THE MOST LIKELY CASE SCENERIO FOR LEBRON IS “SHOWTIME.” YES, THE LAKERS! I HAVE NOT SEEN SHOWTIME IN YEARS! KOBE GETS TRADED TO THE TEAM W/ THE #! PICK. LAKERS SIGN LEBRON AND DRAFT JOHN WALL! IF CLEVELAND GETS ELIMINATED, THIS WILL HAPPEN!
fayncdawg
May 11th, 2010
11:24 pm
Another good addition for the Hawks would be Tayshaun Prince. Matter of fact trade JJ AND Josh to the Pistons for Prince and their 1st round pick. IF the Pistons win the lottery, trade the aforementioned AND Marvin for Prince and John Wall. PLEASE SIGN CHRIS BOSH!! PLEASE CALL THE DOC!!
northcyde
May 11th, 2010
11:24 pm
Smoove @ SF = current day Andrei Kirilenko
His jumshot has NOT improved in the 6 years he’s been in the league.
His offense is based on him getting out in transition and taking slower PFs off the dribble. He cannot take quicker SFs off the dribble.
People who want to move Smoove to SF, want to limit him back to what he was back in 2005. Playing him at SF takes him away from the rim ( like what happened in the Orlando series ).
Rikki
May 11th, 2010
11:31 pm
Fire everyone even slightly associated with the Hawks. This isn’t a team, it’s an undisciplined bunch of lazy loafers collecting obscenely huge paychecks.
Then run them out of town on a rail.
D'yunta
May 11th, 2010
11:36 pm
You people who think the Hawks will ever win with a loser like JJ are living in some dream world. Send the guy packing now.
Don
May 11th, 2010
11:42 pm
I feel bad for Woodson. He has actually done a great job with the Hawks. He elevated them from a lottery team to a playoff team. I think this team needs a change in personnel more than it needs a change in coaching. This team has reached its ceiling. The Hawks in their current form will only manage to make the playoffs but never seriously contend for anything.
LeBron James goes cold again, Charles Barkley takes a shot | Jeff Schultz
May 11th, 2010
11:48 pm
[...] ♦ Fixing the Hawks: fire Woodson, trade Joe, keep Josh [...]
Fred
May 11th, 2010
11:55 pm
We need a new coach, get rid of Josh smith, he’s a loser.Always has been ,always will be.
TaD
May 12th, 2010
12:18 am
Let Woody go. Hire Jeff Van Gundy or someone else with a lot of head coaching experience. Sign & Trade Joe, along with Bibby (& maybe a 2nd Rounder) to New Orleans for Chris Paul. Trade Josh Smith & the rights to Josh Childress to Phoenix for Amare Stoudemire (who could actually opt out this year). Phoenix would sign Childress to replace Grant Hill, who might retire or he could also opt out after the season. Use this year’s 1st Rounder to take someone like Lance Stephenson, Greivis Vasquez, or Quincy Pondexter to add some depth to the SG/SF spot. Have a starting lineup in 2010-11 of Chris Paul, Jamal Crawford, Marvin Williams, Amare Stoudemire, and Al Horford.
Get D-WADE
May 12th, 2010
12:22 am
D-WADE is the answer, the missing piece! It will cost a ton of cash, but D-Wade is the key. The Hawks need to break the bank and pay D whatever he wants, even $25 mil per year! Get D and bosh and it’s lights out baby!!!!!
Hawks 2011 Roster
May 12th, 2010
12:56 am
This should be the team for next season.
PG Steve Blake/Rafer Alston
SG John Salmons/Jamal Crawford
SF Chris Bosh/Josh Smith
PF Al Horford/Udonis Haslem
C David Lee/Brad Miller
Prison Mike
May 12th, 2010
8:18 am
Josh smith is the face of the franchise and 24, going no where. Joe johnson is well past his prime and his asking price is to high for a 2 option.
It’s no point giving all that money to a second tier guy when you still need to acquire a true star to compliment him with yet another maximum pay scale.
We actually tried building around Joe back in 05 and it hasn’t quite worked out, now we have to compliment our young/dynamic front line excluding williams!!!!!
dub366
May 12th, 2010
8:37 am
r u all crazy talking about trading Josh do you realize how many games he won by his defense,block shot, put back how soon u forget. JJ sign & trade M William to the other end of the beach, maybe the next coach can get him to play to his strength. Bibby a three min role player i don’t know what Rick Sung was thinking when he gave Bibby three years. shouldn’t have never got rid of Flip Murray.
Josh
May 12th, 2010
10:01 am
I wish half of you people had a clue! Josh Smith is a cancer and no matter what team he is on his team will fail if he is a center piece. Also, what is the deal with Childress? He was at best an average player. Marvin is not worthy of a 3 pick but, he is a solid player. He doesn’t have plays ran for him or does he get the attempts that others get. Let’s package Smith and get a sign and trade with Johnson and get us a Center and a true point. This team is only a couple of players away from being a contender. But, listening to half of you people talk about bringing back Chillz and throwing Marvin away have really missed the boat. But, the biggest thing is getting rid of Josh Smith!!!! He is a cancer and all you will do is be drawn to being lazy and sorry because that is the kind of player he is.
Ralfy the hawk fan
May 12th, 2010
12:08 pm
Jsmoove has always been my fave player, but I must admit that he is one of the most unbalanced players in the league. Only good coaching will work to make him play well at the 3, and I do actually believe Larry Drew is the best option for that spot, because during the games he would always be the one talking to Josh during TOs and holding him back from the refs. Drew is the one person Smoove respects and if he becomes the head coach,
MrHughes
May 12th, 2010
12:22 pm
TaD,
You’re spot on with what i was gonna say
with a starting line up of:
PG: Chris Paul
SG: Crawford
SF: Marvin
PF: Horford
C: Amare Stoudamire
that would get us to the ECF at the very least.
MrHughes
May 12th, 2010
12:24 pm
Why haven’t you guys talked about getting rid of Zaza, I love his heart… but the guy is a idiot. I’m sorry. We need a center with an actual brain.
Jeff
May 12th, 2010
12:53 pm
Jeff,
Why not try a sign and trade with Charlotte and get Captain jack and Tyson Chandler? That one with johnson
Thhen trade Marvin, Bibby, draft picks, and money for Bosh?
Furman Bisher
May 12th, 2010
12:54 pm
We’d be better off with Horford at the 3 than Smith!
What a dummy Schultz is! Every other comment points out how stupid this idea is!
Has anybody seen my bedpan?!
Rod
May 12th, 2010
6:14 pm
This is the exactly what the hawks should do this offseason. Its a shame that an NBA coaach cant establish a half- court offense. I Work at Philips Arena an i’ve been preaching this exact samething to the fans all season long: get rid of joe johnson cuz he has no leadership skills an he buckles under preassure, get a ligit 7 ft. center, and finally fire Mike Woodson an hire sombody that the players respect an listen to.
SCHULTZ IS THE MAN!!
May 16th, 2010
3:57 am
Simply, Bless you Jeff Schultz you are saying things that people overlook, (smith’s progress) and things people won’t say (Joe’s gotta go). Johnson, great player, not vocal enough leader. Period.
lets get
May 19th, 2010
2:11 am
ricky rubio… i bet t’wolves trade him now since they have 21348127983412341234 young pgs
Air Zaza
July 1st, 2010
1:21 pm
You got it wrong, keep Joe, trade Josh, I could care less about the coach for now.