Maybe it’s global warming, I don’t know. But you can almost hear the ice beginning to crack and melt around us. It may be the sound of things finally breaking free, the sound of movement.
The first sign of thaw came last spring with the decision by the 10-county Atlanta Regional Commission to redirect $25 million in federal money to MARTA. That not only represented a tangible, financial commitment to transit, it marked an equally important commitment to the concept of metro Atlanta as an entity that has shared needs, obligations and resources.
The elected officials on ARC, many of them far removed geographically from MARTA’s service area, acknowledged by their vote that the ability to think regionally and act regionally has become critical to competing in a global economy.
It was, you might say, metro Atlanta’s Declaration of Interdependence.
As MARTA officials made clear, though, that $25 million was only a temporary fix. The agency’s looming budget crisis began long before the economy cratered, and its causes have little to do with mismanagement, corruption or other issues. The truth is that broad-based transit on the scale required by a major metro region simply cannot be sustained through local sales tax revenue and federal dollars, as Georgia tries to do. No other state in the country takes that approach.
If transit is to play its necessary role in metro Atlanta’s future, either direct state financial aid or a regionwide funding mechanism will be essential. And with the state budget already under enormous strain, the regional approach to financing transit seems inevitable.
The importance of finding a solution was driven home earlier this month in Clayton County, where budget woes forced the county to end transit operations by March 31. If carried out, that move will strand thousands who need transit for access to school, jobs and shopping, and it makes the prospect of severe cuts in MARTA operations look a lot more real.
The most recent sign of a possible thaw comes from state Rep. Fran Millar, a Dunwoody Republican. He has announced an effort to abolish MARTA as an independent agency and put it under the control of the state Department of Transportation. Unlike similar efforts in the past, Millar’s proposal is not intended as a punitive step or as a way to posture against Atlanta. Instead, he sees it as way to facilitate MARTA’s incorporation into a true regional system that operates beyond DeKalb and Fulton counties.
Millar’s idea may be less important than where it comes from. As a rule, Republican legislators in metro Atlanta have tended to resist transit as a solution to the region’s problems. They oppose state involvement or assistance in transit, but they also tend to distrust calls for giving the region the authority to solve those problems on its own.
Taken together, those three “no’s” — no to transit, no to state subsidies, no to regional authority — slam the door on just about every possible solution to Atlanta’s congestion problems.
Millar, however, suggests that may be changing.
“I’m a lifelong Republican, and as Republicans we have not addressed our transportation problems,” he said Monday. “Of course, the Democrats didn’t do it either, but this is our chance and we better take it.”
This legislative session will be Sonny Perdue’s last as governor, Millar pointed out, and it offers Perdue a final chance to be remembered as the leader who found a transportation solution.
In another telling sign of the seriousness of the crisis, neither MARTA general manager Beverly Scott nor board chairman Michael Walls oppose the general thrust of Millar’s effort, although both express qualms about some of its specifics. They, too, understand that dramatic changes are going to be required and soon.
“It’s not like the water issue,” Millar said. “We don’t have three years to do something. We have to do something now.”
19 comments Add your comment
Swami Dave
October 27th, 2009
2:47 pm
Here’s some good news……
Reid / Lieberman
-SD
stands for decibels
October 27th, 2009
2:57 pm
Hope you’re correct.
an effort to abolish MARTA as an independent agency and put it under the control of the state Department of Transportation.
Got linkee to this proposal, Jay?
jconservative
October 27th, 2009
2:58 pm
I live in a county that does not have any traffic lights. Last Friday there were 5 cars at the 4 way stop sign, at the same time! Do we qualify for any Federal aid? State aid?
Jay
October 27th, 2009
3:00 pm
Link now embedded above in Millar’s name.
Bud Wiser
October 27th, 2009
3:02 pm
I take MARTA to all of the Falcons home games, the worst part being the drive up from the south side; and the Dome…….well, it sure is good to have if Sundays are like today.
stands for decibels
October 27th, 2009
3:03 pm
Thanks, Jay. From Millar’s piece:
Furthermore, per Georgia State University, metro Atlanta (10 counties) pays 53 percent of the state’s taxes and receive 37 percent of the state’s spending. If metro Atlanta’s physical infrastructure cannot allow further growth and/or our competitive position deteriorates, then the balance of our state will not continue to receive this additional funding over what they collect.
This alone should be the necessary incentive for non-metro legislators to support the creation of this public transportation division under DOT and a regional transportation solution with a sales tax component.
No great city in our country (New York, Chicago, Washington, San Francisco) relies only on highways. We either seize the initiative now or in the not-too-distant future explain to our children why Atlanta is no longer the capital of the South. Remember when we were the financial headquarters of the South?
Dang. Got that right at least.
Normal
October 27th, 2009
3:05 pm
The best way for MARTA to save save and maybe earn money is to get those two person see saw cars. You know, the ones you and your partner manually push the handle up and down to make it go. Rent them out by the mile. MARTA saves on energy and the passengers get healthy. Cobb county might want in then…they love healthy…
Mrs. Godzilla
October 27th, 2009
3:07 pm
This is good news for those poor Shriners.
Keep a look out for those stolen clown cars.
jt
October 27th, 2009
3:09 pm
There is nothing wrong with NOT subsidizing mismanagement and corruption.
The Republican state leadership is just tactfully giving the Atlanta city Democrat leadership time to honorably yield.
It is called class.
professional skeptic
October 27th, 2009
3:13 pm
I appreciate the increased focus Mr. Millar has placed on the Metro Area’s transit woes, but I have to admit that I’m worried about what would happen to MARTA under state control. However, I’m also worried about what will happen to MARTA of nothing changes, given the state’s long-held three-tiered “mentality of no” that Jay mentioned:
(1) NO to transit: Only roads are worthy. More roads. Bigger roads. Wider roads. Future maintenance costs be d@mned!
(2) NO to state subsidies: We’ll take, take, take from Metro Atlanta, but refuse to give back.
(3) NO to regional authority: Why should we allow Metro Atlanta to pool its resources to fund sensible transportation solutions? That just might make the place more livable, and then there would be less to ridicule and look down our noses at!
Right now, MARTA’s hands are tied. It can’t use its own money as it sees fit, it isn’t allowed to expand geographically to increase its ridership, and it can’t rely on regional funding because the state says NO.
Exactly what will happen if the state assumes control? Positive change, or just bigger government for the sake of bigger government? I’d love Mr. Millar to provide further details.
Maria Saporta is skeptical. Here’s a link to her most recent transit-oriented article in case anyone missed it:
http://saportareport.com/blog/?p=2268
stands for decibels
October 27th, 2009
3:18 pm
Another plus that Jay is too much of a gentleman to point out (and which has slipped my mind because, well, quite frankly, who pays much heed to the whiny coot’s Friday bullet-list mashups any more?): mass transit-loathing Jim Wooten thinks it’s a terrible idea.
TnGelding
October 27th, 2009
3:21 pm
Good news. Maybe Millar and Perdue can leave a legacy of which to be proud. What’s good for Atlanta is good for Georgia and vice versa.
Matilda
October 27th, 2009
3:22 pm
“This legislative session will be Sonny Perdue’s …….. final chance to be remembered as the leader who found a transportation solution.”
HAHAHA! Yes, perhaps Goobernor Sonny will finally get that elusive “transportation” badge or “leadership” badge for his Boy Scout uniform. Hahaha! Welcome to Georgia: The State where a do-nothing GOOB cashes tax-funded paychecks to make himself and a couple of friends rich and do nothing else whatsoever to serve the public interest. Elected by goobs who never learn. Let’s bring in the next one!
Redneck Convert (R--and proud of it)
October 27th, 2009
3:28 pm
Well, we’ll get around to thinking about MARTA just as soon as they build that entrance ramp from Simpsons Trailer Park to GA 400. It’s only fair, you know.
Have a good p.m. everybody.
Kamchak
October 27th, 2009
3:52 pm
He has announced an effort to abolish MARTA as an independent agency and put it under the control of the state Department of Transportation.
I dunno about that. The idea of giving that much money and power to a commissioner who owes his position to the State Transportation Board and not a state wide election brings to mind the days of Tom Moreland.
Brad Steel
October 27th, 2009
4:55 pm
hallelujah!
giving the state a stronger position in MARTA seems to be an appropriate measure to insure the state’s participation in MARTA’s success. the past seems to indicate they are dedicated to MARTA’s mismanagement, under-funding and failure.
JohnD
October 27th, 2009
8:57 pm
Umm, does anyone realize that GDOT can operate anything? Between their enron-style accounting and the feds dinging GDOT for failure to account for federal grant funds, why does the GOP think this is a good idea?
A 10-county metro area supporting transit? Great.
Letting the State of Georgia manage the money? Not so much.
GoingBroke
October 27th, 2009
9:03 pm
Well.. at least it is some level of progress? Now if we can only do something with the other Atlanta Jobs Bank (aka Hartsfield) You would think the busiest airport in the world wouldn’t look like such a trash heap compared to others.. but this is the ATL.. sigh
El Jefe
October 28th, 2009
1:57 pm
Marta seems to spend money in the worse ways – and never is it to expand.
If I wanted to go to the Airport, I have to drive or take a bus to a Marta Station, transfer at 5 points and then go to the Airport, it is much easier and quicker to drive.
Marta, like all the lefties thinks people only want to go downtown. I neither work or live in downtown.
Therefore, Marta is worthless to me.
But, then again, isn’t that the image of Atlanta?