Eleven years ago today, Don Waddell was announced as the first general manager of the newly founded Atlanta Thrashers. There has never been another such announcement made by the team since then.
Since that day he has been the man behind the desk of each and every move made by the franchise. From the selection of Patrik Stefan with the very first entry draft pick back in 1999… to drafting Ilya Kovalchuk and Dany Heatley… to bringing in Marc Savard, and then watching Savy depart…to the tragic event leading to the death of Dan Snyder…to the Hossa/Heater trade…to the Zhitnik/Coburn deal…to the Hossa drama of 2007-08…the naming of three head coaches…and now the decision to bring in Rick Dudley to be associate general manager…one thing has been a constant in the organization.
That one thing being… Don Waddell as general manager.
As for the man himself, Don Waddell is indeed a likable person. I’ve spoken directly with him just a few times and he’s been nothing but polite and courteous to me and my sons. One thing that has impressed me about him is how he never has cut the conversation short…citing his schedule or where he needed to be. Instead, he has waited for me to say “Thanks for the time, Don…good luck with the rest of the season”. Maybe those of you have similar stories.
But the job of a GM is to ice a competive team and run the front office. So…just how well off is the Thrashers’ organization after 11 years with on the job for Waddell? Well, I guess that all depends on your “glass half-full” or “glass half-empty” viewpoint.
First off, the cold, hard numbers. The overall record for Waddell and the Thrashers is 273 wins, 367 losses, 53 overtime losses and 45 ties. The team has averages 71.5 points in the nine seasons played. In between coaching hires, he has stepped in behind the bench to coach the team he has assebled for a total of 86 games. His record during those times is 38-39-1-8.
The last two seasons have ended with 76 points…just slightly above the average.
One playoff appearance…zero playoff wins.
So, obvioulsy there have been some sour times in Thrasherville over the course of the past decade…even Don would admit that. To that point, after the 2007-08 season, I was firmly of the belief that his time was up as GM and a change had to be made. Many of you felt the same way…some even thinking he should have been let go before.
But he remained then…and remains still.
Regarding the past two Thrashers’ seasons… even though 76 points are 76 points any way you slice it, last year ended on a much better note than the one before. 2007-08 was a very tumultuous season… what with the terrible start, Hartley firing, Hossa drama and the poor showing down the stretch. But last year, although the team took a while to get things going, they played to a winning record down the stretch.
Personally, I prefer to look at where the franchise is now and what is in store for the future of the club and I think next season holds a lot of promise for this young team. I base that a lot on the way they played since the middle of January to the end of the season… and the fact that the starting roster next fall will be filled with much of the same players as those who took the ice then.
Over the course of the last year or so, a few good moves have been made by Waddell and the team. Starting with the hiring of John Anderson as head coach, then the acquisition of a very solid centerman in Marty Reasoner, to the waiver-wire pickup of Rich Peverly and then the trade deadline moves in which some fairly decent returns were obtained for the players departed. Oh…and drafting that Bogosian kid certainly didn’t hurt things.
So…you can’t call my viewpoint of the team “hopefully optomistic” regarding the future. Then again, I said the same thing last summer.
The most recent big news from Waddell and the Thrashers…that of Rick Dudley’s hiring… seems to have most fans smiling. One reason for the happy faces is that the acquisition of new associate GM Rick Dudley brings with it the speculation that there is a re-org about to happen in the Thrashers’ front office. As I’ve opined previously, I just find it difficult to think that he would leave an assistant GM job with the Blackhawks to make what really is a lateral move to come to Atlanta…not unless there is some sort of understanding that there is a promotion in his future here.
Such a move, of course, would likely mean that Dudley takes over as general manager and Don then wears only the hat of Executive Vice President. I, for one, would be in total favor of that.
But until/unless such a move is made, Waddell is set to go into yet another year as the general manager of the Atlanta Thrashers. And because of that, it is simply inevitable any such discussion of him will eventually lead back to one basic question… “How many years can any GM remain in place given such a record”?
Ummm…well, I don’t know about others… but this one goes to eleven.
At least, so far.
TJ’s Draft Party Update!
Mark just contacted me to let me know of another prize that will be raffled off at Friday’s draft party. It includes 4 premium seats to a game this coming season plus a Zamboni ride in between periods!!!
Remember, the fun starts at 7:00 pm.
116 comments Add your comment
LAC
June 24th, 2009
5:06 pm
On NHL live today on NHL network what a JOKE tandem they had, this STUPID girl from MSG and some idiot from Nesen,they were too enamered
with each other to interview Rick Dudley, saying “We missed Rick Dudley,we’ll call him back later this week.”
If I were Dudley I would say SCREW YOU !!!!! This channel has ZERO respect for The Atlanta Thrashers !
Brendan
June 24th, 2009
5:54 pm
No wonder Phoenix turned that down. I like Kaberle. But he’s not worth the 6th overall pick. The teams drafting tomorrow will own these players’ rights for many, many years to come. I’m not even going to look at how many years left Kaberle has on his deal.
So, Gionta, eh? I’m intrigued. Oh wait, it’s Eklund. Nevermind.
Did Custance happen to mention if contract talks were ongoing with category VI UFA’s like Crabb and Oystrick? It’d be nice to at least keep them in the system, if it’s at all possible.
Tony C.
June 24th, 2009
6:46 pm
Yeah I liked Oysterick’s game…man was he horrible the first time I saw him in a Thrasher’s sweater, but last season-what was the word bandied about “Oysterick’s been a revaltion”…I’d agree. But I dunno if the choice came down to Oysterick or Salmela, I think I’d take Salmela.
R. Stroz
June 24th, 2009
7:49 pm
Actually, Crabb, Oystrick, AND Clay Wilson(the player the Thrashers received when Jason “Creme Puff” Williams was traded) are VI UFA’s.
World Be Free
June 24th, 2009
8:03 pm
Gotta stick with Antropov. Gionta is too small.
R. Stroz
June 24th, 2009
8:51 pm
If the Thrashers are going to bring in another undersized forward, I’d rather give Sterling a chance than a 30 year old like Gionta who will eat up alot of salary space.
Sara
June 24th, 2009
9:57 pm
I’d take Gionta over Sterling. He can play bigger than he is, he’ll crash the net (concept!) and he’s put up over 50 pts in the last 3 out of 4 seasons on NJ of all teams. He’s also a natural RW, versus Sterling who isn’t. And Sterling isn’t a proven commodity. While I’d like to see this team get bigger and grittier, in terms of facing the reality of beggars can’t be choosers, if Gionta is willing to come here, I’d be more than happy to have him.
Bob
June 24th, 2009
10:02 pm
I’d take Gionta in a heartbeat, but Brendan’s right, so meh.
“and play Thrash at kids functions”
ha!
R. Stroz
June 24th, 2009
10:26 pm
Bob & Sara agreed on something. It must be cold somewhere special.
Alan
June 24th, 2009
10:31 pm
Tomas Kaberle for the 6th pick AND Ed Jovonovski?!
Brian Burke must be a regular poster on the HFboards trade forum.
Brendan
June 24th, 2009
11:32 pm
Brian Burke’s interview on the “Hodge Stove League,” on the NHL Network, has been repeated several times now. But each time I see it, I pick up on something new that he said. One of the things that piqued my curiosity was this nugget, “Forget about trades. No one can make IMPACT trades anymore. Not with the cap.” Or words to this effect. I’m not sure I agree with that. I still think it’s possible to move a Top 4 defender for a Top six forward, so that each team gets what they NEED. (Wasn’t that R. Whitney for Kris Kunitz?, someone might say. Remember, you can’t hear me. I’m inside parenthesis. Ask your English teacher. Focus on the concept, not the players as you read.) To me, that’s the hallmark of a GOOD trade. It benefits both teams. When the cap was $39 million, and Boston traded Joe Thornton for Brad Stuart, Wayne Primeau, and Marco Sturm, we all thought this might be “the new NHL kind of trade.” If the cap had stayed at $39 million, perhaps it might have been. But the cap grew so large that $40.7 million became the floor. Would the Bruins have pulled the trigger on that Thornton deal if the cap were $56.7 million, back in 2005? I suppose if you believe that they thought Thornton was “The Problem,” then yes. Maybe they’d still do it. But I digress.
Burke said, “I’ve lost the element of surprise. They now know I’m coming.” I thought about that. It didn’t prevent the Islanders from gift wrapping Luc Schenn for them, at CONSENSUS pick at #5 overall, at the cost of the Isles choice of Toronto’s 2nd rounder that year and a 3rd rounder in 2009, or a 3rd rounder last year and a 2nd rounder in 2009. I forgot which option the Isles chose. Time will tell if those 2nd and 3rd rounders were indeed “throw away” picks they sacrificed at the expense of a high-end blueliner prospect, or if they actually blossom into complimentary pieces for their ultimate draft selection of Josh Bailey at #9. Who I thought was an appropriate selection for pick #9 in the draft. Would I have picked Josh Bailey at #5? No. I believed that thennnn, as I still believe it now. (And I’m still inclined to believe that defense wins championships in hockey, even in the “new” NHL. Even though there’s evidence that points to the contrary.)
It makes me think, though, if Kane really is the best possible pick at #4, why trade it? Make the pick. Brian Burke also said, “My scouts earn their pay in June. They worked all year for it.” Well, I don’t doubt, for one split second, that even Atlanta’s scouts have done more evaluating of this year’s draft class than we (bloggers) have.
I checked with Rawhide, this blog DOESN’T have a travel budget for scouting. So, I would hope … ESPECIALLY with the addition of Dudley, that their homework is complete. If it’s really Kane … who is the best selection, and a MISTAKE NOT TO SELECT HIM, then that’s what they’ll do, I plead. I can’t tell you that Kane is the best choice. I don’t think it’s that cut and dry. He ‘may’ be. I don’t know that. But THOSE SCOUTS should. They get PAID to know.
PJ?? Are you up in this house?? Can you craft a Draft Day prayer for the Thrashers? I ask PJ, because if the PRAYER is left up to me, it’d sound something like this. “Dear God. Please don’t let us (bleep) it up. Amen.”
R. Stroz
June 25th, 2009
12:01 am
Brendan – The word you’re looking for is “flub” it up.
Brendan
June 25th, 2009
1:06 am
Yes, that will do nicely, R.Stroz.
Tom Lysiak
June 25th, 2009
5:23 am
Don, please don’t trade this pick unless….
This is a great position to be sitting in. Say you assume what the “experts” say is correct and the class of the draft is Tavares, Hedman, Duchene. Say you assume there are no surprises in the actual selections other than the order they are chosen. You get to choose from every amateur player in the world not named Tavares, Hedman or Duchene.
Everyone knows that drafting players is an inexact science. There is no such thing as a “can’t miss” because of the human element involved. But, GM’s who have the guts to make that call live for picks like this. GM’s who have scouting departments with proven track records live for this pick. They know that one player who is sitting just below the annointed three. They somehow know the three who have separated themselves from the pack is really four, before “the dropoff”. Someone out there has a very clear evaluation and reason why Kane, MPS, Schenn or whoever is “the guy”.
These are the GM’s who scare me. They are circling the water, just waiting for the right time to strike. The type of GM who would say, “Don, we’ll give you Kaberle and our 7th for your 4th”. Unless someone like Lombardi says, “Don, we’ll give you Jack Johnson or Kopitar and our 5th pick for the 4th pick”, you say no thanks. It has to be a deal like that where everyone says “that was a no-brainer and too good to pass up”.
Otherwise, you better have done your due diligence and are truly prepared to make the right call. Hopefully, Dudley brings that insight and ability with him since the existing group scares the bejesus out of me….
dwayne
June 25th, 2009
6:19 am
LAC…I waited for that interview too….just strengthens my point that we/us/Thrashers get no ink/airtime/respect, what ever you wanna call it. I’m starting to like MPS more and more.
B. Thenet
June 25th, 2009
7:52 am
Gionta is small, but he also can pull Top 6 minutes AND kills penalties.
Not a bad combo