Atlanta Hawks: Video: Hawks at the break

Orlando–I talked Hawks with CineSport’s Noah Coslov here at All-Star weekend.

Michael Cunningham, Hawks beat



298 comments Add your comment

Grandmaster JeJe (GM)

February 26th, 2012
1:11 pm

Great stuff, MC.

FIRE SUND

TMACfan

February 26th, 2012
2:13 pm

Nice MC!

If we don’t make a move, we really don’t care about winning.
We need to make a move because our post-AllStar break schedule has a lot of home games and we NEED TO capitalize on those.

Just Joe

February 26th, 2012
2:45 pm

I’m with MC. Don’t really see a move out there that gets us equal to, or better, than Chicago or Miami. Make moves for the future. Trade Joe Johnson and Marvin Williams for worse players on shorter contracts. Trade veterans like McGrady and Hinrich for draft picks and/or young players.

TMACfan

February 26th, 2012
2:54 pm

I know we want the best picks/young players available, but don’t screw the vets over.

MattP

February 26th, 2012
3:10 pm

Just Joe,

I do agree, I don’t think they can make a trade to put them over the Heat and Bulls but I do think they can make a trade to make them about equal talent wise. The main problem is the coaching, that is what will keep putting the Bulls and Heat over the Hawks. I also do agree about starting to rebuild but we really need a GM that knows how to draft.

Just Joe

February 26th, 2012
3:46 pm

A team like Dallas could use a vet like TMac. They have several assets we could use as well: Roddy Beaubois, Dominique Jones, and Golden State’s 2nd rd pick.

beone

February 26th, 2012
3:46 pm

New GM, New Coach, Trades & Build for Future. Unless we can land Dwight, we have missed our window. Just Do It!

Grandad

February 26th, 2012
4:16 pm

Dwight ain`t coming – that dog has sailed.

IUPUI

Grandad

February 26th, 2012
4:50 pm

I CVD`d; CVS`s; DVS`s; RSV`d; DVR`d; VMI`d; sumthin`;;
shoot;;;I taped the kansas game yesterday
and just finished watching it * `while ago:
*[Southern for just got finished]

Reasons Why Hawks Must Position themselves to;
* Draft Thomas Robinson:
1. He is a Natural Born Winner;
vs Mizzou tie game Mo. has the ball in regulation;
under 14 sec, plays for the last shot … gets a lay-up …
T.R. comes out of nowhere and blocks the shot to send game to OT
** Winners make Winning Plays ! = Kansas Wins in OT !

2. Measureables = 6-10; 240ish; looks like Tarzan – plays like Tarzan.
However the measureables are not freakish;
wing-span; vertical leap; standing reach; not a pure shooter; etc.
Th.Rob`s. measureable`s are gonna` be his heart & character.

3. he will be listed as a [4] ; power forward; but,
I see him as a Basketball Player.
Not only that – but – the Best Basketball Player in the Draft.
*[not the most talented]

4. He Rebounds / I am going to repeat – He Rebounds !!
He’s the Best;
Rebounder … Rebounder … Rebounder … Rebounder … in the draft.
____________________________________________

Save Josh Smith for Now;

Be Patient;

Then trade Josh [to get] into the lottery.

Will need to get between 4 & 6.

GA PEACH

February 26th, 2012
4:51 pm

Obviously we knw we need a TRUE center but I think the talent is here. Drew seems now not to know what to do with it. If use effeciently we have one of the best benches in the league. All this blowing up the team how about we blow up the coaching staff and get a younger GM who is not so old school and will make a risk here or there. I am not willing to wait another 10 yrs b4 we make it to the playoffs again. Because reguardless of popular belief around Atlanta the falcons and braves aint bringing us a champonship yet either they cant even make or win in the playoffs. Get a new coach b4 we go to the lottery seriously. We have already shown we dont know how to scout or draft.

Grandad

February 26th, 2012
4:54 pm

Prediction:

SA Spurs try to trade up to get TR

Euh

February 26th, 2012
5:14 pm

MC,

I’m following your work from Paris, France. I’d love to be able to watch the videos you post but it says ” The video you are trying to watch cannot be viewed from your current country or location”.
Can you do something about that ?

KevinM

February 26th, 2012
5:40 pm

MC, a B- is about as good a grade as you can give them. The schedule hasn’t been that tough, the only team over .500 we play well against is Orlando. Our talent level is 2nd level compared to Miami and Chicago has Rose and Deng, which are big mismatches for us.
Theres not a potential playoff team out there worried about us.

I see no moves being made because Sunsd has no vision going forward. The only relief we get is letting Kirk expire…..2 more years of Marvin will be painful and if MC has given this team a B, then expect our coaching staff/GM to remain as least a couple more years.

O'Brien

February 26th, 2012
5:48 pm

“For some reason, the Hawks think Collins could be more than a just a specialist, but I don’t think so”.

Well said, MC. I don’t know why Rick and LD feel that way. Dude is a 3rd string center, but they think he can be a solid backup?

As for making moves for next year, Rick has done a bad job managing assets, so the only move they can make (imo) is to trade Kirk. And I don’t know if they are willing to pick up extra salary for next year (based on their track record).

Najeh Davenpoop

February 26th, 2012
6:02 pm

B- sounds about right. I’d probably give the players a solid B+ because they have exceeded the expectations I had for them after Al got injured. I give the organization a C- for sitting on their hands the last month and not proactively acquiring a big man, and LD deserves a D for screwing up the rotations by handing Kirk minutes for no reason and insisting on playing small ball against bigger teams. All of that probably averages out to a B-.

TMACfan

February 26th, 2012
6:13 pm

In all the games that T-Mac has played 20 or more minutes the hawks are 8-3 for all the games under 20 minutes the hawks are 8-10.

#FreeTMAC

terrell

February 26th, 2012
6:26 pm

KevinM

February 26th, 2012
6:34 pm

Good stat TMfan……that one might be a better one to follow than Joe scoring 20.

And that BBVA commercial they’re showing tonight give Marvin big pub…why wasn’t he a shooting star instead of Stack? Man, after Joe, our shooting stars are limited at best.

Seriously, do you think our record would be better with Al? I say maybe one more win, but I think we wouldn’t be as good vs. the Magic as we have been.

Joe D

February 26th, 2012
6:35 pm

Unfortunately, there are not any exciting trades for marginal players which could help the Hawks. But what you should not do are trades which include Josh this year. JJ and Josh are clearly the two best players. Any trade this year should include players like Marvin and Kirk. Kaman is still the most likely, but one of the Hawks’ two 2nd picks or may be two will be needed for NO to take Marvin! Marvin like Bibby will require giving away assets for someone to take them. Sund did a very poor job evaluating both.
However, a still don’t think the Hawks should take on debt (a bad contract). Again, Marvin and Kirk to Milwaukee for Jackson and a filler would help this team without straping them with a long term deal. Jackson only has 1 year left at 10 mil. Next year, he would be tradable if his second tenure does not work out.
Also, next year is when can truly focus on redefining the team. Al, Josh, Jackson, and maybe JJ because solid pieces to trade.

Just a Thought

Shoot the Messenger

February 26th, 2012
6:47 pm

It very clear that Al doesnt fit in with the hawks and his heart is not into the role the hawks have given him, center. In fact his constant whining and statements about playing Josh’s position, caused internal friction in the locker room.

Al is our best trade piece that can be used with out destroying the core, Josh and JJ. Further our most pressing need is a center not a power forward or a point guard.

Al has positioned his self for the trade. My thing is that we will need to add a piece or two to get a quality center.

One thing for sure This is Al’s season with the Hawks. If not it lottery in 2 years.

northcyde

February 26th, 2012
6:54 pm

Blowing up the team is unnecessary. Trading one of The Core, however, may be necessary.

Melvin

February 26th, 2012
7:32 pm

Grandad,

Thomas Robinson is 6-8. He’s smaller than the Morris twins from a year ago. He’s a tweener and the Hawks have enough of them. I say we pass on him….

Slimjr

February 26th, 2012
7:35 pm

0-46 ECF visits, The streak will certainly continue…Sad just sad….

YAWN………

Slimjr

February 26th, 2012
7:37 pm

4-8 in February thus far= crickets………………………………………………

Slimjr

February 26th, 2012
7:40 pm

Trade the Core for picks and upgrades..

But first Sund must retire!

Slimjr

February 26th, 2012
7:56 pm

Doug Collins for COY thus far……

Double Zero Eight

February 26th, 2012
8:16 pm

I concur with Slimjr posts.
Especially the one that indicates the Hawks will
not make it to the ECF again this year.
The truth hurts,

O'Brien

February 26th, 2012
8:33 pm

northcyde,

I agree in trading one of the core. The team needs a shake up, because they have already peaked. I dont think anybody wants JJ for at least 2 more years, so Hawks would have to trade either Josh or Al.

The risk with trading Al is you dont know if Josh will resign next offseason when his contract is up, and I would hate to trade Al, and then have Josh sign with somebody else.

Can we just trade LD?

The Truth

February 26th, 2012
8:49 pm

“Again, Marvin and Kirk to Milwaukee for Jackson and a filler would help this team without straping them with a long term deal.” – Joe D

On the surface, this trade seems reasonable given Jackson skill set. However, there are some things about Jackson history that may undoubtedly give the Hawks front office a reason to pause.

On one hand, he is no different than any other NBA player; he wants to get paid well for his services. But Jackson is well known for using unprofessional tactics to get the things he wants. Currently he is unhappy with the Bucks because they refuse to discuss a contract extension with him at the beginning of this season. But why should they since he had become a rogue player with nearly 2 yrs left on his current contract. Among other things, he displayed bad conduct detrimental to the team because they won’t yield to his demands. This is a repeated pattern with Jackson on other teams. His preoccupation is limited to his ego and getting paid. Team work and pursuing greatness is not in his DNA. If he’s not getting an extension with Bucks, I seriously doubt he’ll get one with the Hawks.

Not only that, but given his ego and quest to be “the man”, I also doubt he would fit well as Marvin’s replacement becoming the 4th/5th scoring option, really the role of a utility player. Jackson yearns to just shoot and score to pad his stats, nothing more. I can see him going rogue early against the Hawks and clashing with LD if asked to do other things besides his normal touches.

Fundamentals

February 26th, 2012
9:03 pm

Just stop it with the Stephen Jackson talk. Why not add Isaiah Rider and Big Dogg Robinson back to the team if you want to return to those dark, dismal days. I’d rather go with what we have or go with young talent. Even if it’s NBDL scrubs before going back to adding someone like Capt Jack back to this team. Sadly, history does repeat itself…..

Slimjr

February 26th, 2012
9:13 pm

As usual the East is getting their azzess handed to them by the West!!!!!!!!!!! What else is news?

Sorta like our Hawks when they match up with 4/5ths of Western Conference teams…

Embarrassing? Giving up 88 pts. at the half??????????????????? Yep….

doc

February 26th, 2012
9:22 pm

undersized from the beginning an dhow josh was left off for any competitive balance is unreal. he was the only guy that payed defense with a modicum of size among the choices they made. this was an indication of how flawed the process was to call it a game. rondo cant come close to measuring up with the size in the west.

Joe D

February 26th, 2012
9:34 pm

The Truth, your concerns are valid. Fundamentals, what realistic trade options can you think of which will help the Hawks this year? No doubt, Jackson has issues, but he would be a short term issue. Marvin has been the biggest problem for years not just underproducing, but jogging up salary which has kept the Hawks from making moves.
Trading Al is not realistic this year and trading Josh would be foolish. Marvin, simply has to go and the Hawks have no options other than packeting him with someone else. Kirk’s value at this point is really his expiring contract. Sund created this monster by resigning Marvin. Should the Hawks stay the course and lose in the 2nd round, again or attempt to do something to hopefully create Hope!

Melvin

February 26th, 2012
9:40 pm

Joe D,

Cosign

Shoot the Messenger

February 26th, 2012
9:46 pm

“The risk with trading Al is you dont know if Josh will resign next offseason when his contract is up,”

I can see the risk of losing Josh but I can see the point in trying to keep Al as some how logic as a fail safe in case josh should leave. Al is mediocre at best and as being prove by the hawks play with out him. Al does not “impact” our play and is serviceable and is easy to replace. So keeping Al and trading Josh because of some esoteric reasoning that Josh is going to leave so keep Al doesnt fly. Al is not that kind of player. Josh >> than Al. Undoubtedly.

Al nonacceptance of his role and his limited talent level is why we are in this situation in for first place. So keeping his non reluctance attitude along with his me first demands is not something we should salvage but purge.

Our goal is to get better by upgrading not to go status-q with the mediocre player movement.

Shoot the Messenger

February 26th, 2012
9:47 pm

*I cant see the point in trying to keep Al as some how logic as a fail safe in case josh should leave.

Shoot the Messenger

February 26th, 2012
9:50 pm

Trading Teague for a Point Guard who has a clue may be a realistic and doable move to make.

TMACfan

February 26th, 2012
10:00 pm

Al is a really good POWER FORWARD! Get an actual center and Al will be a star at the PF.

Shoot the Messenger

February 26th, 2012
10:09 pm

Al played power forward alot and hasnt proven much,except that his an average Al.

Al is so limited offensively and is a no show defensively, injury prone… did I mention he a greater disappearing act in the playoffs than Houdini ?

Trading Al for a quality player will only make the hawks better….

Slimjr

February 26th, 2012
10:13 pm

Ask your self this question? QUESTION:

Does All NBA have handles to say crossover his opponent so he can stop and pop on a dribble drive and shoot off glass?

Enough already with Big Al at the PF! See a “real” power forward operate like LaMarcus Aldridge..
LaMarcus also has a post game, the other guy not so much….Yawn…………..

NEXT?

Slimjr

February 26th, 2012
10:15 pm

Carmelo always seems to miss the “BIG” shot? Hmmmmmm…

Jody

February 26th, 2012
10:26 pm

After this season, the Hawks have two options as far as Josh is concerned…1) Overpay him to keep him in ATL or 2) Watch him leave for nothing to go play with Dwight. Neither is a good option for this franchise. The Hawks will never be a title contender with Josh as one of the main players. His bi-polar style of play just won’t allow it. This may be the best time to move on.

TMACfan

February 26th, 2012
10:47 pm

Did they give Joe any recognition at the All Star game?

soullrenaissance

February 26th, 2012
10:48 pm

Lebron chokes again – what else is new? Where was Dwight??? His presence was not felt in front of his home crowd at all.

Slimjr

February 26th, 2012
11:15 pm

“Lebron chokes again – what else is new?”

Cant let Lebron close games out! Let Wade do it!

Najeh Davenpoop

February 26th, 2012
11:36 pm

The All Star game was bogus without Josh. Deng and Hibbert combined for 1/5, 3 points, 3 boards, 2 assists in a combined 15 minutes. Politics.

TMACfan

February 26th, 2012
11:38 pm

Grandad

February 26th, 2012
11:43 pm

Melvin

Thomas Robinson’s listed hgt.
sources:
*NBADraft.net / 6-8
*DraftXpress / 6-9
*espn / 6-10
*Kansas official site; roster / 6-10
*Thomas Robinson profile; Kansas offical site; / 6-10
*Bill Self: quoted article by Nancy Newberry / ‘`6-10`’
____________________________________________

My guess is;
when official measurements come out;
Thomas Robinson will measure out to be 6-8+ sock ft.
Accordingly, will measure 6-10+ in shoes.
Final listed hgt will be 6-10, literally, give or take an inch.

I believe he can guard some [3's] and most [5's]…much like Horford.
He will be a better low post scorer than Josh or Al.
He will be a better Rebounder than anyone in the draft.
Rebounder is why the Hawks should make a move to get him.

Fussball fan

February 27th, 2012
1:06 am

No offense to anyone, but to those individuals who believe that they are moves that the Hawks can make that will make them equal talent wise with the Heat, name me one Hawks player that could start on the Heat? The ONLY guy who MAY have a chance is Horford. The Heat beat the Hawks at home without Lebron James or Dwyane Wade and emasculated them by almost 30 again at home. If you believe that they are any moves within the salary cap to bring the Hawks even within the same universe as Miami, you are delusional. There is nothing wrong with supporting or hoping that your team does well, that is a part of being a fan, but the main problem with Atlanta sports fans,is that they believe that their teams are better than they really are, while the rest of the nation knows the truth.

Najeh Davenpoop

February 27th, 2012
2:16 am

“the main problem with Atlanta sports fans,is that they believe that their teams are better than they really are, while the rest of the nation knows the truth.”

Not regarding the Hawks. If anything, Atlanta sports fans believe the Hawks are worse than the rest of the nation does.

But regarding the Falcons, you are right.

DREABABY

February 27th, 2012
3:48 am

LOL FUSSBALL FAN,I AM 100% SURE AL WOULD START BEFORE JOEL ANTHONY.

vava74

February 27th, 2012
4:45 am

why not take a flier with Marcus Lewis?

Yes, the guy is undersized at 6′8” – 245lbs but he is 25 years old and is snatching 13 rebounds per game on the NBDL

http://www.nba.com/dleague/playerfile/marcus_lewis/

I am sure that he would be effective in spot minutes when we need a rebounder on the floor.

Just Joe

February 27th, 2012
5:58 am

Marvin Williams, Kirk Hinrich and Vlad Rad to Minnesota for Michael Beasley, Martel Webster, and Brad Miller. I’d even throw in a future pick if needed.

Minnesota needs shooters on the wings with Rubio and Love running the offense.

Atlanta gains the flexibility of waiving all 3 players at year end if they want to. The Marvin Williams years would officially be over.

Ms. Jones

February 27th, 2012
6:41 am

@vava74-We have a rebounder that LD leaves sitting on the bench as we get beat on the boards game after game. His name is Ivan Johnson. It appears rebounding is not an important factor in LD’s coaching schemes.

vava74

February 27th, 2012
7:34 am

Ms. Jones,

Ivan is a pretty decent rebounder but he is not a rebounding monster by definition (he averaged 9 per on the NBADL).

Lewis is a rebounding monster by definition with that average. Also, he is a guy who only flourished this year, so he still under the radar.

His good FG% and poor FT% indicates that he is probably nothing more than a dunker and a rebounder and sincerely, I like that. We have too much jump shooters and this guy could be a true Reggie Evans.

Dawg

February 27th, 2012
7:56 am

The hawks still say that Collins is a specialist although we have beat Orlando twice he got hurt. He has no numbers to say he is a specialist in anything. This team has obvious shortcomings yet we take up a roster spot with a “specialist”.

The Hawks organization is horrible. It is poorly managed, it is poorly coached and horribly constructed.

It is time the whole organization is called out.

doc

February 27th, 2012
8:15 am

i agree withms evans andhaeemphaticaally said it before, LD doesnt care about rebonds. that is the distinction between woddy and him.

Dawg

February 27th, 2012
8:35 am

Maybe we can wait on the draft. Perhaps Sund will sell our #1 pick for a trade exception and then with the number 2 pick, we can draft a player who would not have been drafted by anyone else.

We will then NOT use the trade exception and we can cut the drafted player. We can save money. Then next year, we can keep our precious core together and hire who ever is left over after free agency.

Our players are growing increasingly frustrated at having such inept management. Any of them would be happy to leave.

Grandad

February 27th, 2012
8:41 am

doc

The organization top to bottom does not care about rebounding
nor size.
The Hawks have been undersized for two ownership groups;
and two general mgrs; now two coaches.
This is a small organization.
*small minded; *small thinking; *small players; *just small.

vava74

February 27th, 2012
8:49 am

Dawg,

Collins is not the problem. If we match up with the Magic again in the playoffs, in 7 game series we will need Collins.

Also, you can bet your *ss that Zaza’s recent success against Howard has been a consequence of Collins example and some guidance.

Hawks Fan Down Under

February 27th, 2012
9:06 am

There is only one move to make and that is firing the coach and bringing in someone GOOD! Doesnt matter who you trade player wise because they will still be coached by a guy who simply cannot manage the rotations and units on the floor.

You could also move the GM but the coach is the major issue right now.

The Hawks will remain in neutral until LD is gone.

BTW people dont actually sit down and watch the ASG do they? So boring.

Astro Joe

February 27th, 2012
9:33 am

Hawks are a 3-game winning streak away from a igniting a hopeful fan base.

Grandad

February 27th, 2012
9:36 am

All-Star weekend;
every team in the League has some sort of news goin` on.
New Orleans maybe getting a new owner, Sac-town…relocating;
[now that would be a story]
Dwight getting traded everywhere but here; Linsanity, shoes;
LeBron whining about, whatever; Bosh’s baby momma;
even Charlotte creating cap space for crying out loud !

Here in the ATL … chirp … chirp

The Hawks [Sund, whomever] act as if they are guarding some big secret.

No news; no buzz; no interest; no fans; no appeal;
no fannies in the seats; no outlook; no prospects;
no plan; no pride; no self assurance; no chance; no hope.

Sautee

February 27th, 2012
9:42 am

Grandad, that all adds up to Ka-Boom!

Grandad

February 27th, 2012
9:53 am

The Hawks just lost 8 out of 11;
for the month of Feb.

This is a business:
* cut somebody
* fire a coach
* sell the team
* bring K.Benson back
* put J-Lo’s nipple @ mid ct *[image of course]
* (not the actual nipple)
* sign Dennis Rodman – what for; I’m not certain
* suit up Nique
* * * anything … something … show you care * * *
Sund – you must rattle the cage ! Shake somebody up !

Shoot-Fire / Hire Charles Oakley to be the Head Coach;
if nuthin` else, he`d whup their ass if the team didn`t try !

vava74

February 27th, 2012
10:04 am

Bill Laimbeer

O'Brien

February 27th, 2012
10:08 am

There are so many moves (or lack thereof) that we can reflect on where the Hawks made a bad decision, which has resulted in us being stuck where we are.

Maybe the Hawks need to take one step backwards, in order to take 2 steps forward.

Astro Joe

February 27th, 2012
10:13 am

Trade season doesn’t officially begin until march 1st.

Rasheed may sign with the Lakers. Before anyone suggests that he will have an impact, let’s wait and see. He may have the same on-court impact as his former Tar Heel teammate… Stackhouse.

vava74

February 27th, 2012
10:20 am

AJ,

Wallace will certainly have an impact on the Lakers, but I can tell you, it will not be positive.

The guy is only looking for a pay check. He probably already ate all the money he got from BOS and will turn up at 300lbs+.

vava74

February 27th, 2012
10:22 am

AJ,

Stack did start on the third quarter on the other day and scored 7 points in 12 minutes…

SteveW

February 27th, 2012
10:40 am

This beat writer never takes any time off? What? The dude shows up maybe 2 days in 7. He’s great when he’s here, but he’s got Viviamore doing most of the writing/reporting the last 2 or 3 weeks.

How can the AJC not have the money to send MC on some road trips, but they have enough for him to have an assistant who also covers the Hawks?

Oh well – MC, not a knock on CViv – but you can tell your bloggers want YOU!

Now back to basketball

SteveW

February 27th, 2012
10:46 am

Before folks start nominating Collins for Coach of the Year, realize they just lost 5 straight and 7 of 9, while playing one of the easiest schedules in the NBA with a bunch of Home games.

Let’s see how they do in the 2nd half with a much harder schedule and more Road games.

SteveW

February 27th, 2012
10:54 am

If Grant Hill can still produce some quality minutes at age 38, I would think Stack could at 37.

I wouldn’t mind a 3 spot composed of Vlad Rad, TMac, and Stack – If we could get anything of value for Marvin.

Vava – A tweak on your above trade – Marvin and Hinrich for Ridnour, Randolph, and Miller. Miller and Randolph are not playing, and would help inside, while Ridnour is expendable with Barea and Rubio there.

And we save some cash, always an important point with ASG. Works on Trade Machine.

SteveW

February 27th, 2012
11:11 am

Grades 1st half of season:

Teague B-
JJ B-
Marvin C
Josh B+
ZaZa B-
TMac B
Vlad Rad C
Green B+
Ivan C
Pargo B
Hinrich D+
Stack/Collins/Dampier – Incompletes
Coach B-

The above grades are for season long, not just current stretches or anything. A big part of me wants to put Josh at A-, but then I remember his J’s, and some bad passes on the break, and I go back to B+. But make no doubt, on most nites, he’s carried this team. His best, most complete season by far.

And JJ is aging just a tad.

And I want to put ZaZa at B+. But then I remember the botched entry passes he can’t handle, and a few games he’s looked overmatched out there, so down he goes to a B-.

Marvin I wanted to put a C- at least, maybe D+, but then I recall some good games the first 10-15 games of the season, and some good D he’s played, and just leave it at a C.

TMac at B is how he’s looked when he’s played, not so much when LD won’t play him. Just my eye test, if I just turned the tube on and looked at the Hawks not knowing anything about them, I would say TMac is our best halfcourt player on O. By far.

And LD’s B- – I gotta give the guy props – we’re are 20-14 playing the toughest schedule out of the Top 8 in the East, playing more Road games than Home Games. And he’s kept it together since Al went down. So as much as I disagree with his rotations many times, and how he closes out games most of the time, 20-14 is 20-14 especially with some of the disadvantages he’s had.

SteveW

February 27th, 2012
11:13 am

I feel like the Lone Poster right now…

SteveW

February 27th, 2012
11:16 am

Giving Green a B+, same as Josh, doesn’t mean I feel like Green has played as well as Josh. It means I think he’s fulfilled his expected role as well as Josh. Josh is a much better player. But Green, and to a lesser extent Pargo, have really shocked me how good they are, and how much they have contributed (Pargo when given a chance).

BIG DOG

February 27th, 2012
11:23 am

Let’s keep it real, this Collins stuff is the most retarted thing MC could say, Collins is far from the problem of the Hawks, when your coach continue to starte the worst SF in the NBA then that put more pressure on the rest of the starters, this is the biggest issue but coach LD is blind just like his uncle Woody, Joe get hurt and miss the final 2 games and your boy marvin score 2points in 48min.
This has to be the most ludacris thing i have seen from a coach who continue to starte a non productive SF JUST DAM.
BIG DOG IN THE HOUSE

doc

February 27th, 2012
11:25 am

interesting article i read over the weekend from cbc sports about how the lakers front office is now run by buss’ children who have no clue. when phil left all the memories of him were swept out with him including first class personnel and evaluators.it even said one of the members of the scouting department was a former crony who was a bartender of one of the sons. good bartender but now so good in evaluating talent.

under the circumstances, if they pick up sheed it probably wont matter unless brown and kobe can make it work. their problem is not necessarily size off the bench though losing odum hurt they still dont have a point guard. we dont need him or jackson either as he will only bring more of his me first stuff and tmac might supply enough of that. neither one are true winners doing things to help their team win over the long haul. it was a wonder that skiles and jackson lasted as long as they did without locking horns. i could have won money on that bet when i saw those two together. what were they thinking?

BIG DOG

February 27th, 2012
11:25 am

FIRE LD

MARK MY WORD THE HAWKS WILL NOT MAKE THE PLAYOFFS.

BIG DOG IN THE HOUSE

SteveW

February 27th, 2012
11:31 am

1 guy we missed out on, who I think may have went undrafted (or late 2nd round) is Isaiah Thomas, the Kings PG out of Washington. He has been beasting it lately.

I remember alot of our fellow blogpeople here wanted him. Seems like he’s the real deal.

Dawg

February 27th, 2012
11:32 am

Granddad: You have the post of the year. That sums it all up.

Astro Joe

February 27th, 2012
11:39 am

vava, exactly. In about 30 games, his impact has been a good stretch of a single half. I suspect that Rasheed will mostly be asked to be a designated low-post defender. It will be interesting to see if he is able to do more than produce 6 hard fouls in relief of Bynum & Gasol.

SteveW

February 27th, 2012
11:49 am

So for the Hawks not to make the playoffs, we have to lose a whole lot of games in the 2nd half. If .500 gets you in the playoffs, which it would now, all we have to do is go 13-19 the rest of the way. I’m thinking Boston tanks before the Hawks do. And will the Bucks or Cavs get it together to make a push?

But now if we decide to blow it up, and trade Josh for a draft pick or something, yes, we probably miss the playoffs.

Looking at the schedules, I’m thinking the Pacers, Sixers, Boston, Bulls, and the Knicks are all going to have a tough 2nd half of the season.

Ask me again March 16th, and I think we’ll all have a better idea where most of these teams will be – after the trade deadline.

northcyde

February 27th, 2012
11:51 am

@ SteveW

Those are fair grades, and I pretty much agree across the board. Maybe give Vlad a X-ray or D+, but the rest I agree with.

northcyde

February 27th, 2012
11:52 am

Lol @ an X-ray

His jumper and defense needs an X-ray, but I meant a C-.

vava74

February 27th, 2012
11:57 am

SteveW,

The trade was not mine.

But I would certainly go for the trade you proposed and, honestly, maybe Minny would too.

Hinrich is bigger than Ridnour so he could help at the SG position and Randolph and Miller would certainly add length to our roster.

But the biggest upgrade would be on the bench if by any miracle we fired LD.

Maybe we could get Larry Brown to come in to close the season.

BUT, that will not happen.

LD = C – - in my opinion

We could have easily avoided 3 to 5 losses if LD had not pushed Hinrich into the rotation like he did.

Those losses cost us being respected in the league.

SteveW

February 27th, 2012
11:58 am

When you have Troy Murphy and Josh McRoberts, why would you get ‘Sheed? Trying to corner the market on all the 6-10 240 Bigs who can shoot outside?

SteveW

February 27th, 2012
12:05 pm

I mean if your trying to replace Lamar Odom with ‘Sheed, your about 4 years too late on Rasheed’s part. Why not just keep Lamar instead of trading him for a 2nd rounder and a big Trade Exception?

TMACfan

February 27th, 2012
12:09 pm

Ra'mon

February 27th, 2012
12:15 pm

SteveW, Murphy and McRoberts can’t guard centers in the post like Wallace can. If Wallace is remotely in shape, he will be able to at least handle Duncan or Perkins in the post for 10-15 min a game.

Just Joe

February 27th, 2012
12:28 pm

SteveW…My opinion is that we could sell off a member or two of the core and still make the playoffs (my guess is that playoff revenue is a must for this ownership).

Joe Johnson & Marvin Williams for anything!!! Clear cap space for a new GM & Coach this summer (and hopefully new owners).

Astro Joe

February 27th, 2012
12:37 pm

Perkins in the post? Surely no one is worried about a 5 point/game scorer. My guess is they want another big body to defend the rim against Blake Griffin and probably Duncan as a secondary target.

Ra'mon

February 27th, 2012
12:39 pm

AJ, I’m not saying guard Perkins in terms of offensive threat. But keeping him off of the boards. And also stretching him out on offensive end to open up the penetrating lane for Kobe. And also have to remember Memphis is a threat to beat LAL in playoffs. So Rasheed can get good minutes against M. Gasol.

vava74

February 27th, 2012
12:45 pm

The Lakers lesser problems – if any – are in the post.

Bynum, Gasol, Murphy, McRoberts are more than enough.

The Lakers problems lie on the PG and SF slots with Fisher’s legs gone (he could still be a valuable back up but they are running him down) and with MWP in complete disarray (and apparently needing a new shrink).

BIG DOG

February 27th, 2012
1:13 pm

Trade Rumors make it happen Sund.

Marvin, Hinrich and 1st for Session, Jamison

make it happen baby.

BIG DOG IN THE HOUSE

BIG DOG

February 27th, 2012
1:16 pm

Teague, Joe, Josh, Jamison, Zaza

Session, Green, Tmac, Ivan, Dampier

Pargo, Vlad, Stack.

BIG DOG IN THE HOUSE

SteveW

February 27th, 2012
1:19 pm

Same way with Linsanity. Give me ’till about the 1st week of April, and we’ll see how he’s doing, after the grind of the NBA schedule sets in. My guess is we’re looking at a slightly below average NBA PG in Lin, at least right now. Maybe a 4.5 on a scale of 1-10.

But we’ll see come the 1st week of April. By then we should know alot more than we know now.

BIG DOG

February 27th, 2012
1:20 pm

Make that trade happen the Hawks become a bigger team..
And better on defense and rebounding.
BIG DOG IN THE HOUSE

Slimjr

February 27th, 2012
1:21 pm

5-8 in the Month of February and Larry is satisfied?

Larry your becoming a joke before your eyes…

O'Brien

February 27th, 2012
1:21 pm

doc,

Saw you on the GT blog. As a Tech fan, I think the shine is wearing off CPJ. He won big the first 2 years with Chan Gailey’s players, but he has not shown me much when it comes to 1) getting good players to come here and 2) Maximizing the talent that we do have.

And he seems stubborn (or arrogant) when it comes to his offense.

Rusty

February 27th, 2012
1:22 pm

SteveW I know that you only gave LD the grade of B- for our record. I believe that this team would be vastly improved under a good coach. I think he really deserves a D . It is apparent with just about everybody on this blog that we need a new coach for many reasons.

BIG DOG

February 27th, 2012
1:27 pm

If Al comeback by the playoffs.

Teague, Joe, Josh, Jamison, Horford

Session, Green, Tmac, Ivan, Zaza

Pargo, Vlad, Collins

Stack assit coach.

BIG DOG IN THE HOUSE

BIG DOG

February 27th, 2012
1:33 pm

Rusty i agree Coach LD deserve D-

BIG DOG IN THE HOUSE

SteveW

February 27th, 2012
1:41 pm

Ra’mon – I agree with that

Rusty

February 27th, 2012
1:43 pm

I am watching the last 4 games on my dvr,was out of town last week.I can see that JT can get to the basket any time he wants to. I see him making a lot of good passes that should have been assists & see him playing aggressive defense.,what I see is him not shooting the basketball. I see LD jerking him out of the game for an ineffective KH. I swear LD must be telling him not to look for his shots but try to get every one else shots. What other reason could there be.

Rusty

February 27th, 2012
1:48 pm

I love Josh for his hustle & all around good game but he really hurts the team by taking a lot of long jump shots. I wish he would go back & watch these games.

KevinM

February 27th, 2012
1:57 pm

Without Teague, this team is a shambles. He has brought ’some’ life back into the fan base, all except for one blogger, who has an agenda with him.
I don’t think for one minute Sund or the ASG is going to replace Al. They are content with competing some nights. They now have a built in excuse for losing this year. Al will give us very little if he even tries to come back.
So no magic wand is bringing us another difference maker in this lineup. LD will continue to start Marvin because of what he earns. Along with that, 2 feel good 1/2 court shots that Marvin made this year keeps him in good graces with Sund. Wouldn’t you want to be an agent and negotiate with Sund? He has made mediocre become the standard for Atlanta Hawks basketball.
Because of the shortened season, because of Al’s injury, because Joe has too many minutes on his body, the ASG will stand pat and keep what we have on our current roster, GM and coaching staff.
The frustration continues into 2012-13 despite then wrath we hurl at the ASG.
Much to their depression, this is the year we lose in the 1st round provided we can string together a .500 record the rest of the year.

newkid

February 27th, 2012
2:00 pm

Enter your comments here

KevinM

February 27th, 2012
2:02 pm

Rusty, OB, SteveW, Najeh, G-Dad, Terrell, could you envision Josh hurling up long jumpers lie, D12 last night?
Well, Stern couldn’t, and I’m still waiting for Josh’s pts/reb to go up with Al being out. There is no excuse for Josh not to be posting double/doubles….Kevin Love does it every night and he lost Al Jefferson and has a less then physical Beasley helping him.

newkid

February 27th, 2012
2:02 pm

Sessions and one of Cleveland’s two 2nd rounders for Marvin gives Cleveland a young but experienced wing with whom some in Cleveland’s front office are familar.

doc

February 27th, 2012
2:08 pm

o’b yes to cpj. i think gt fans dont get it at all about expectations. braine was right though old timers with money were delusional to think otherwise. the hey day for tech was before ‘64, their entry requirements and limited areas of study work against them. i laugh that the guy they brought in has shown braine to be true even with a losing year with his first group of grown up recruits including a loss at kansas. i give him next year then a year where the ad says it is either now or never. gailey played close to the vest but usually the team was competitive. not sure that can be said for cpj and he still is not concerned with special teams?

Rusty

February 27th, 2012
2:11 pm

Watching the knick game with the score close LD takes JT out & inserts KH & scond team.KH makes 3 or 4 turnovers in 3 min.& the score is 30 to 16 by the end of 1 st quarter. He then starts the same unit to start the second quarter. Is LD retarted or just stupid.

Dept. Of Unintended Irony

February 27th, 2012
2:23 pm

“Is LD retarted or just stupid.”

Like shooting fish in a barrel. No irony quite like a misspelled insult.
Over and over.

pointguardslim

February 27th, 2012
2:31 pm

Josh Smith isn’t Kevin Love. Kevin Love is a 6′10 240lb naturally hefty strong power forward. Josh Smith is a 225 Small forward who matches up against power forwards (and centers).

Its not that hard to figure out. Kevin Love is built like a tank even after becoming 240-250 lbs. Smith tried to bulk upwards to 240-250 and had knee speed and stamina troubles.

Josh Smith is a small forward.

pointguardslim

February 27th, 2012
2:36 pm

Knicks Max money man, Carmelo Anthony tries his best but can’t guard Josh Smith. Smith would’ve worn the injured anthony out. Landry Fields as well. True or false?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QNtumdunjcM

Rusty

February 27th, 2012
2:36 pm

Nothing like being an idiot over &over.

Rusty

February 27th, 2012
2:48 pm

Just like LD.

pointguardslim

February 27th, 2012
2:49 pm

Rusty, seems like you’re intimate with the idea. Only championships PFs who were under 6′10 this last decade played with Shaquille O’Neal.

If you want to win you have to account for Size. Those are the breaks.

Furthermore, if Josh Smith played as much of the 3 as he has played center he would be judged differently and have made the all star team over either Iguodala or Luol Deng.

They’re the same size as Smith. Compare Smith to their stats not Kevin Loves.

drmaryb.[*_*].

February 27th, 2012
3:02 pm

Blacked Out!

“No news; no buzz; no interest; no fans; no appeal;
no fannies in the seats; no outlook; no prospects;
no plan; no pride; no self assurance; no chance; no hope.” -G-Daddy-
____________

And, no scoreboard, center, heart …

honest_abe

February 27th, 2012
3:23 pm

was there an argument in here last week about kevin love’s outside shot compared to josh’s? one word…. idiot.

Ra'mon

February 27th, 2012
3:26 pm

KevinM, Josh averaged a double double all of February, and is having a career season in rebounding. So what are you concerning? And he lead the team in assists since midway point in January.

Ra'mon

February 27th, 2012
3:33 pm

By the way KevinM, Josh shot 38% from beyond the arc in February also.

Slimjr

February 27th, 2012
3:36 pm

Jhonest_abe

February 27th, 2012
3:23 pm

“was there an argument in here last week about kevin love’s outside shot compared to josh’s? one word…. idiot.”

Josh would have made 1 and air ball 6 at least Saturday night! LMAO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Rusty

February 27th, 2012
3:37 pm

We need rebounding & LD gives Ivan Johnson very little playing time.

Slimjr

February 27th, 2012
3:41 pm

Kevin> All NBA at the PF slot….Huh? Yep..

FYI, MC was on 790 The Zone with the Two Live Stews about an hour ago and said Big Al is still in a sling, no time table for rehab..

Stick a fork in this dude for the year.. He’s done…

The Streak will continue (0-46) ECF visits…….Yawn….

Just Joe

February 27th, 2012
3:44 pm

There’s no reason to fool ourselves in to thinking we can compete in the playoffs with or without Al Horford (any by compete, I mean for a championship, not a 2nd rd appearance).

McGrady & Willie Green have been great for us, but these are exactly the types of players that contenders will be looking to trade for. Draft picks and/or young players should be our asking price.

Kirk Hinrich’s $8M expiring contract has value even if he’s playing poorly. He’s got a little over 2 weeks in which to heat up and build some trade value. Otherwise, we’re trying to package him with Marvin and take back mediocre players on bad contracts. Worst case scenario is we hold his rights and keep the option of a sign-and-trade in the offseason.

I keep praying that a team like Cleveland, Minnesota, or the Clippers will offer us something for Marvin. He’d be a decent role player on a team that already has 2 or 3 proven scorers.

My only hope for a Joe Johnson move is something that goes along with Dwight Howard (Orlando or New Jersey).

I’m OK with keeping Jeff, Josh, Al & ZaZa unless we can bring in an allstar in return.

Slimjr

February 27th, 2012
3:45 pm

Larry Drew=Wade Phillips, Coach Mike (Deer in Headlights) Smith: round peg-square hole

pointguardslim

February 27th, 2012
3:58 pm

Just Joe praying for what? A decent big man on a good contract for 3 years of Marvin on a bad?

We’d have to pay to get rid of him. Only one with value is Al Horford. And I trade him for deron WIlliams and a big man last season or Rajon Rondo and Kevin Garnett this season. Its no comparison.

He’s average at PF and always saying how others need to carry him. Didn’t he say Josh Smith carries this team as far as it will go?

Just stop it.

If We get a Duncan (expiring) + Tony Parker or Garnett (expiring) + Rondo. For Horford and Teague and Hinrich and Marvin.

Who the hell wouldn’t take that? Boston’s GM says Boston isnt a contender. We are with that team and we pack the highlight factory everynight if we make that Boston trade.

Look at the positive matchups with Miami or Chicago that we’d get.
http://espn.go.com/nba/tradeMachine?tradeId=842rv4m
*cant sub Horford for Smith in the trademachine until March 1st but salary works

pointguardslim

February 27th, 2012
4:02 pm

Rondo vs Chalmers
Johnson vs Wade
Smith vs Lebron
Garnett vs Bosh (go either way with Garnett’s lockdown length IQ and defense)
Pachulia vs Joel Anthony (Pachulia has advantage here)
——-Stand Pat——–
team lose
Teague vs Chalmers
Johnson vs Wade
Smith vs Lebron
Horford vs Bosh
Pachulia vs Joel Anthony
team lose
Teague vs Chalmers
Johnson vs Wade
Duck vs Lebron
Smith vs Bosh
Horford vs Joel Anthony

Ra'mon

February 27th, 2012
4:14 pm

Here’s a trade that will make the Hawks better in the Playoffs, and a very tough out in my opinion.

Hawks Receive:
Rajon Rondo
Pau Gasol
R. Artest

Boston Receives:
Jeff Teague
Al Horford

Lakers Receives:
Joe Johnson
Kirk H.

This deal gives the Lakers a new big three who can compete and beat OKC, and possibly Miami. Boston gets a replacement for Garnett if he leaves this season, and if he stays, they get Al to play center for them, along with another Rondo like point guard in Teague who is much cheaper.

Atlanta gets a brand new identity on the team. And gets to team Josh with Rondo and Gasol to make them only one shooter shy of being title contenders. Also the Hawks are no longer under Joe Johnson’s long term deal. If Josh doesn’t work out with this lineup, trade him in the off season or let him walk next season and replace him. Willie Green and T-Mac can man the SG position for the remainder of this season. And you have the option of amnestying Marvin for the duration of his contract.

Ra'mon

February 27th, 2012
4:18 pm

G’Dad, Barbosa is available. Kirk for Barbosa straight up? And Toronto buys out Kirk?

doc

February 27th, 2012
4:18 pm

yeah i wanted to pipe up that for some reason love was chosen and it may be legit for him to take as many as he does though that was what folks were arguing and comparing josh. no josh needs to stay inside and work to keep his fga to 55% or better to get into the all star game next year. simple formula and one that will make sure politics stay out of it anything less than that leaves him on the sideline possibly. it is really up to josh and that is always been true, just his hard head gets on the way.

Just Joe

February 27th, 2012
4:26 pm

pgs…no, I’m sending up reasonable prayers. Marvin for an expiring contract or at least a shorter term contract. I don’t care what position the guy plays. Just get rid of Marvin.

And Boston is at least saying that they’re not interested in giving up cap space for the summer. They’re taking on an extra $12M or so in your deal. And the Hawks are risking the chance of Garnett walking at year end, with only Rondo & cap space to show for Horford, Teague, Marvin & Hinrich.

O'Brien

February 27th, 2012
4:29 pm

pointguardslim,

So despite Josh having shaky handles, and an inconsistent jumper, you think he is a SF? You can’t go by size alone. You have to look at skill set too, and Josh does not have the skill set to be a good SF.

Kevin Love is a 6′10 240lb naturally hefty strong power forward..

Who also won the 3-pt shootout…

O'Brien

February 27th, 2012
4:31 pm

KevinM,

I think Josh’s rebounding is up since Al went out. But I think once we got into the tough stretch, he has had some struggles (like the rest of the team).

doc,

If Josh wants to be like Kevin Love, he needs to emulate him and his rebounding, not his jumpers.

Ra'mon

February 27th, 2012
4:34 pm

Or Another deal is:

Hawks Get:
P. Gasol
M. Barnes
D. Ebanks

Lakers Get:
Joe Johnson
Kirk Hinrich
2nd Round Pick

Grandad

February 27th, 2012
4:39 pm

Ra’mon

I like Barbosa – always have.
I like him as a pg.
Use Teague as a trade chip / bring in LB to play the [1].
I like that.

I just realized;
Teague is Barbosa:
That is Teague’s game.
* speed; * not really a [1]; * not a great shooter; * a [1] and a half;
* a slasher looking to score.

Dawg

February 27th, 2012
4:40 pm

If the Hawks decide to blow up the team and start over, perhaps they will draft all of the upcoming lottery picks for “tween” forwards. That is an excellent way to build a team. Great teams are always built upon swing men. Centers and point guards are over rated. Minimum contract vets can fill out the roster.

We can get a “core” of swingmen.

O'Brien

February 27th, 2012
4:49 pm

Even though Josh deserved to be in the AS game this year (imo), he needs to take it upon himself to leave no doubt next year. Go out and average 18 pts, 12 rebs, and 2 blocks per game (even with Al playing alongside him). If he puts up those numbers consistently, he gets in (imo).

However, he has to be more consistent too. 9.6 rpg this year is definitely a step in the right direction. But there have been 14 games where Josh collected 7 rebounds or less. 14 out of 34.

There have been 2 games this year where Kevin Love played, and got less than 10 rebs. In those 2 games, he had 8 rebs, and 7 rebs. Consistency.

Similarly, there has been 9 games this year where Josh scored 9 points or less. Kevin Love has scored at least 10 points in every game this year (not counting his suspension). Josh is having a good year, but he has the potential to have a great year.

To those who have been given much, much is expected. And Josh has alot of talent. But his head gets in the way.

Mike C

February 27th, 2012
5:00 pm

@Ramon

Ah nice trade ideas but the question is who is going to take that contact of Joe on?

doc

February 27th, 2012
5:02 pm

o’b out of context was directing that to honest in regards to love in 3 pt exhibition relative to a discussion around osh shooting 3 and how love did it more so we should not be too hard on osh.

SteveW

February 27th, 2012
5:03 pm

KevinM – Agreed about Teague. He’s got potential written all over him. I still think if he’s healthy, a 15 and 7 max for him for a few years is not out of the question. I think he’s still adjusting this season and probably next before he hits his best years. And his D is above average to almost well above average also.

Josh vs. Kevin Love – Josh’s standing reach and wingspan are longer than Love’s. Love is 0.75 of an inch taller than Josh w/o shoes. Josh has a much higher vertical than Love. Love is down to 240 this season. Josh is down to 225.

That being said, Josh is beasting it. On D we know he’s good. But even on O, he’s averaging a double/double for Feb. 17.3 ppg, 10.4 rbg, 2.3 blocks, 4.4 assists, and 2 steals per game. Those are phenomenal numbers.

KLove is better at offense and rebounding. Josh is better at defense. Really all there is to say.

Ra'mon

February 27th, 2012
5:11 pm

O’brien, You’re correct with Josh and the rebounding. But on the scoring comparison to Love, how many games have Love had shot attempts under 11? And how many have Josh had? Love’s is Minny’s number 1 option every night (some games, their only option).

SteveW

February 27th, 2012
5:12 pm

Hats off to ZaZa also – in Feb. his numbers for assists, blocks and steals have really jumped.

1.6 steals per game – up 4x from .4 January

Double the amount of assists per game – 1.8 from 0.9

Double the blocks per game – from 0.4 to 0.8

That’s in 8.5 minutes more per game – but still pretty good, considering it’s been against the toughest schedule in the League during that stretch basically.

6.8 ppg and 7.3 rbg in Feb. also. Decent numbers. His athleticism really fits with the team also. He gets up and down the floor really good for a big guy.

Ra'mon

February 27th, 2012
5:14 pm

Mike C, the Lakers would take Joe’s contract. Do you remember Glen Rice’s contract when they traded for him years ago? When you think about Joe playing alongside Kobe and Bynum, Kobe gets 4-5 more seasons of high level added to his career. Joe is able to guard the best perimeter player, and still average 18-21 ppg unlike Artest. And Joe will get multiple open looks a night from double teams.

TMACfan

February 27th, 2012
5:16 pm

Guys, hate to break the news but ASG WILL NOT TRADE JOE JOHNSON! No other team is going to take up his contract and if they do, Sund will not make the trade because the player/s we get in return won’t be equal.

ASG screwed up big time on this one.

SteveW

February 27th, 2012
5:20 pm

I’m really trying to be realistic. But i’ve got some things to be thankful for on the Hawks.

Josh is playing the best ball of his career to my knowledge.

Green is playing way better than I thought he would

Pargo is better than I thought.

ZaZa is playing a little better as a starter than I thought he would.

With our schedule in the 2nd half, I really see us as being viable contenders for the #3 seed if we play hard and together. We’ve shown we can beat the Magic. The Pacers schedule is about to get alot harder. Same with Philly. Boston is looking at a dismal 2nd half. The Knicks are still below .500, and their schedule is about to get more difficult.

I even think the Bulls are going to struggle a bit in the 2nd half, but still keep the 2nd seed.

But alot depends on trades and injuries, as we all know.

And about Al – It has been reported all along that his arm would be in sling for 6 weeks after the January 17th (?) surgery – So we’ve been looking at the 1st week of March all along before he could begin rehab. I don’t think ASG will bring him back as a C. They’ll either trade him, or move him down to 4 after this injury I’m guessing. So they’ll either move Josh to 3, or move him for what they can get for him. We’ll see. Could be wrong on all accounts.

SteveW

February 27th, 2012
5:22 pm

The above post last line is if they do not trade Al. And I doubt they do – can’t get much for a guy with an injury like he had.

Ra'mon

February 27th, 2012
5:25 pm

O’Brien, Love has only one game where he shot 13 attempts this season, the rest or 14 or more. Josh has 10 games where he had LESS than 13 shot attempts thus far this season. And don’t forget, Josh is STILL shooting higher percentage than Love. But I agree, there is no reason for Josh not to have more games where his rebounding numbers are better like they have been the last month.

Ra'mon

February 27th, 2012
5:28 pm

SteveW, for the Hawks, depending on the Bulls, it may be better to be the 4th seed instead of the 3rd seed. The Hawks need to matchup against the Bulls in 2nd round, to have any hope of winning 2nd round. Short of Wade being hurt, there’s no chance the Hawks beat Miami. But they have a 40% chance of beating the Bulls.

SteveW

February 27th, 2012
5:30 pm

ZaZa as a starter – 20 games, 30.0 mpg, 7.8 ppg, and 7.5 rbg. Not bad from your backup. And he’s stayed pretty healthy to this point also. I think ZaZa would be starting for quite a few teams in the NBA. I would like to see how we run with:

ZaZa
Al
Josh
JJ
Teague

I think that may be a good starting lineup, and help us with rebounding. That’s when Al gets back of course.

SteveW

February 27th, 2012
5:38 pm

Ra’mon – I think the Heat will be the #1 seed, so we need the #3 seed to avoid the Heat. But I think if healthy, we can beat either the Heat or the Bulls. I would rather play the Heat actually, because of the Bulls depth, especially up front, they just seem to kill us. The Heat have an older bench, no depth at C. If we get Al back and healthy, I like our chances.

Depending on Dwight and the Magic, I think the Sixers may drop down to the 6th seed. I would be very concerned about that matchup if we were a #3 seed. Pacers also. It ought to be interesting nonetheless.

But we did play the Heat and the Bulls pretty good earlier in the year when we played them.

doc

February 27th, 2012
5:39 pm

stevew the only problem with that is i dont think the hawks have a center to come off the bench if we did that. not sure of it though, seems like i remember reading it, maybe here, that someone suggested they needed another big.

Astro Joe

February 27th, 2012
5:43 pm

Sorry, but when a team has a disappointing month, does it really matter who is king of the pigs? I don’t know, it kind of sounds like someone bumping up whoever is the stat stuffer in Charlotte. Someone has to lead a team in various categories. No one too much gave Love credit when he was putting up record double-doubles on a horrific squad. He is only getting respect this year because the team is playing solid ball. Josh has had some stretches when he has been at his career best but overall, I’m not sure that this season is much different than previous years. If there are three tiers of All-Stars (the no-brainer, fan-elected guys who are marching toward the HOF; the guys who are consistent year-after-year like a Steve Smith, Dikembe or JJ; bubble All-Stars like Kevin Willis who may make an All-Star appearance or two over a long and productive career), then I think Josh is clearly in the third tier. But that has been tru for the past 2-3 seasons. A “bubble All-Star”.

TMACfan

February 27th, 2012
5:54 pm

I really hope we make the move to get Ramon Sessions and Antwan Jamison. Would get rid of Marvin and Kirk, and help us offensively.

Slimjr

February 27th, 2012
6:01 pm

The Hawks are 5-11 against the winners!

WORST IN THE NBA….PUT DOWN THE PIPE… THIS TEAM AINT LEGIT…

Slimjr

February 27th, 2012
6:03 pm

LET ME QUALIFY: WORST IN THE NBA FOR TEAMS ABOVE .500…

Slimjr

February 27th, 2012
6:04 pm

Wade did break Kobe’s nose? Wow…

Atlanta Celtics

February 27th, 2012
6:21 pm

Sub Al’s salary for Josh’s:
http://espn.go.com/nba/tradeMachine?tradeId=842rv4m

Rajon Rondo
Joe Johnson
Josh Smith
Kevin Garnett
Zaza Pachulia
——–
Pargo
Green
McGrady
Ivan Johnson
Eric Dampier

pointguardslim

February 27th, 2012
6:24 pm

Al Horford said he hasn’t begun his rehab yet and that was 3 weeks ago. Then again today he has yet to start and still has no timetable.

Horford is still in the recovery phase from his surgery. He’s not expected back until mid-April at the earliest.

He’s not coming back this year man.

doc

February 27th, 2012
6:53 pm

six weeks on a sling from date of surgery mandatory and no person csn hurry these things up short of marvel comic book status. physical reparation if muscle tears that require surgery not possible without tearing it again.

Wink

February 27th, 2012
7:21 pm

Hawks should just hope to finish 8th, which is what management wants, to get into the playoffs healthy. Our best chance is for the Hawks to feel like they have no chance against Miami or Chicago, whichever finishes as the number one seed.

Remember when we as a fan base felt like the Hawks had no chance against Boston. What did they do, they rose up to take the Celtics to 7 games. The areana was sold out for those games. All we as fan want is for them to play that same way again…reality of now is that they are not a good playoff team and no one fears them… which could be our only real advantage.

Unless they drop out of the playoff picture all together, which they are capable of doing!

Just Joe

February 27th, 2012
7:32 pm

TMACfan….that trade has us taking on about $4M in salary over the luxury tax. Don’t think this ownership is going there.

BIG DOG

February 27th, 2012
7:34 pm

O'brien

February 27th, 2012
7:36 pm

Ra’mon,

Fair enough. But whose fault is it that josh has so many games with so few attempts?

Just Joe

February 27th, 2012
7:36 pm

Atlanta Celtics…..are Joe, Josh, and ZaZa that much better than Allen, Pierce, and O’Neal? Because Boston’s bench is probably better than ours.

Just Joe

February 27th, 2012
7:38 pm

I like these ideas though. Both include us getting rid of Marvin Williams.

BIG DOG

February 27th, 2012
7:40 pm

Just Me but next years you have Jamison 15mill of the book plus 4mill less than Marvin contract in Sessions.
BIG DOG IN THE HOUSE

Just Joe

February 27th, 2012
7:51 pm

Big Dog, but to get there you pay a prorated portion of $4M this year, then pay it again for the luxury tax, then factor in that you don’t get a share of the luxury tax dollars that other teams are paying. You just paid somewhere from $5-$10M this year just to save $4M next year (and have a backup PG rather than Marvin).

Joe D

February 27th, 2012
7:54 pm

Newkid,
The Sessions and one of Cleveland’s 2nd round picks for Marvin sounds good and makes sense. Cleveland has shown interest in Marvin and maybe still wants him. With this trade, Kirk becomes even more valuable for trade. What about Kirk and Sessions for Kaman?
The Hawks would rid themselves of Marvin and his contract. Rent Kaman for the rest of the year and between Marvin’s and Sessions’ contracts the Hawks would clear up 8 mil for next year’s cap!

Sund, help us out and make the trades!

pointguardslim

February 27th, 2012
8:13 pm

http://espn.go.com/blog/boston/celtics/post/_/id/4690248/oneal-to-see-hand-specialist-in-boston

Look at Jermaine’s numbers advanced #s True Shooting%, rebounds, and then injuries. He’s been injured for 2 years. And you can see why Ainge wants to blow it up.

Maybe both KG and Dwight would want to come here for a cut in pay?

Rondo ($11mil)
Joe ($18mil)
Smith ($12mil)
KG ($8.5mil)
Dwight ($18mil)
Smith is due an extension. Give him $12 mil + incentives. Seriously. Every round we make it out of = incentives.

pointguardslim

February 27th, 2012
8:16 pm

Bring home the Atlanta Celtics. That idea makes too much sense in a trade. Trying to rebuild around Horford in the same conference as MIA? Makes zero sense.

Horf will be 30 in a few years. Will he be a 20ppg scorer by then? What are we pinning our fortunes on this guy for. Look at his skillset. He’s Odom minus the handles and 3 point shot. Houdini act every year and somehow gets injured every year.

Melvin

February 27th, 2012
8:28 pm

Grandad,

Kansas will play Okla State tonight at 9pm on ESPN. Make sure you get a good look at Thomas Robinson when he stands near his teammate Jeff Withey who’s is 7ft. The only way Robinson is 6-10 is when he’s wearing high heels….

Ra'mon

February 27th, 2012
9:30 pm

O’Brien, its LD’s fault in my mind.

pointguardslim

February 27th, 2012
9:45 pm

http://www.draftexpress.com/profile/Thomas-Robinson-5496/

He was measured before guys. Its easy information to check. Those numbers puts him close to Chris Wilcox/ Jeff Green. Nothing special unless you’re looking to draft “a bunch of nice guys”.

pointguardslim

February 27th, 2012
9:49 pm

Josh has few attempts? He shoots too much. On a contender he’d be a SF and get touches in transition a couple post ups, & on the boards.

Remember this?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yajcf-RCaZ8

Josh Smith is not a go to scorer people. Hes a monster do-it-all cog at the wing position or a unconventional PF with passing skills.

pointguardslim

February 27th, 2012
9:50 pm

I also posit that the Hawks are infinitely more exciting with a big lineup.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QNtumdunjcM

Melvin

February 27th, 2012
9:51 pm

pointguardslim,

Different sites have different heights. We are going by the Eye test tonight.

pointguardslim

February 27th, 2012
9:51 pm

and harder to guard. Here’s Lavoy Allen making Josh look foolish. Too big for Josh to get by and he ends up committing a cardinal basketball sin. Getting pushed/stuck under the basket.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=–0JWiMbo8A

Astro Joe

February 27th, 2012
10:03 pm

Melvin, how tall is he in flip-flops?

Melvin

February 27th, 2012
10:05 pm

Astro,

6-6….lol

Melvin

February 27th, 2012
10:06 pm

Astro,

I will give him 6-7 if he’s wearing the thick beach flip flops….

Grandmaster JeJe (GM)

February 27th, 2012
10:19 pm

TRADE MARVIN ALREADY

AND FIRE LD

Astro Joe

February 27th, 2012
10:26 pm

LOL @ Melvin. Imagine a player at the NFL combine trying to run the 40 in flip-flops. Sounds like a stupid skit from In Living Color.

Speaking of dim bulbs, so Gerald Green may have another shot at the NBA, huh? Somewhere Rashard McCants is angry like a mo-fo.

O'brien

February 27th, 2012
10:47 pm

Ra’mon,

Didn’t josh tell ld to not worry about him, and he will find his own offense (or something like that)?

If josh would be in the post more, I think he gets more shots (despite the fact we don’t have a pg to get him the ball consistently).

For one, he may get more offensive rebounds and put backs, plus be in better position overall to take shots.

IMO, josh is his own worst enemy.

Point Made

February 27th, 2012
10:51 pm

Al is not trying to get well. He is not a hard worker, did very little in the off season(s). Disappears in the playoffs and is a “me ” oriented player. His skill set? what skill set? After all these years we still have to stop the fluid motion of the offense to get Al involved. Al is mechanical, Slow and predictable.

Defensively? Al’s best defensive play is to wait for Josh to block or alter a shot while applying defense , then scoop up the rebound that was the result of an effort from Josh on another hard worker.

What Al brings to the table? A persistent whine about playing Josh’s position.

Career numbers?
12pts 9rbs 1blk
Playoffs?
10pts,7rbs,1blk

Al would help the hawks best playing on another team. Thats a given.

Rubuen Herrera

February 27th, 2012
10:55 pm

Al is good for escorting the opposition to the rim to watch the dunks up close

Ra'mon

February 27th, 2012
11:13 pm

O’Brien, if your kids suggest something to you, at the end of the day, is it not your decision if its done or not? Also, I don’t think Josh would get more attempts if he was in the post more. Woody’s last season, Josh was in the post more, and still didn’t get many shot attempts, because this franchise have an infatuation with shoot first guards (pg and sg’s). And also against teams such as SAS and LAL, if Josh gets the ball in post, compared to on the high post, or perimeter where he can use his quickness, he’s going to be at a disadvantage. As I said, despite Josh’s jumpers, he still leads the team in field goal percentages, and has NEVER approach Antoine Walker or Al Harrington’s numbers in that area. If we had a Steve Nash or even D. Williams who knew how to get 9 assists a game, Josh would have no excuse not to be in the post more.

Ra'mon

February 27th, 2012
11:19 pm

I don’t know why, but in such a short season, the fact that Al came to camp out of basketball shape (compared to the rest of the team) speaks volumes to me. One thing about Joe or Josh, is they’ve never came out of shape and not ready to go. Josh was heavy the past two seasons, but it wasn’t because he wasn’t in shape. He was heavy to play the pf position with more strength (a common mistake, thinking more weight means more strength). And Joe would hit the weight room some summers too much also. But the two of them were always in good shape. However, the 3rd captain reports in a season where he had even more time than normal to get in shape, out of shape. And the fact that he got married doesn’t mean anything, because a work out only takes 3-4 hours a day total. In my mind, that made him more than trade-able to me.

Ra'mon

February 27th, 2012
11:21 pm

The Wizards are trying to give away Blatche. Should the Hawks bite, if the Wiz would accept Marvin? That’s a hard decision. But I may would take Blatche, but not put him in the starting line up.

Grandad

February 27th, 2012
11:23 pm

Melvin

I tried to catch the two of them standing beside one another;
but I was only able to see the tail end of the 2nd half.

The sizes I listed were from all the sources I could find.

The only reliable measurement will be DraftXpress
after the combine.

I must admit Withey looks lanky running around out there.
He moves well for a 7 ftr also.
Gonna keep my eye on him.
He was moving alot better on that ankle tonight.
____________________________________________

Final Thought;
Thomas Robinson is a Player !
6-7; 6-8; 6-9; 6-10; 6-11… it don`t matter.
The kid can play.
T.R. goes after and collects Rebounds !
That is what we need.
Yes::::
myself as much or more than anyone;
We Need a Big – Legit – 7 ftr.
But; not just to have one.
We need a Legit Big / Center that can Play / Produce.

In the Draft; in my opinion; Thomas Robinson;
is the most NBA ready player available in this yrs draft.
Regardless of size.

One more thing.
I believe Josh will be traded.

With Thomas Robinson we would not miss a beat.
* [not as many highlight reels]
* (not near as many headaches)

Ra'mon

February 27th, 2012
11:31 pm

G’dad, when do you think Josh will be traded??

If they do trade Josh, I hope its to a good situation for him, also. Want to see what Josh does with an established front office/coach.

Grandad

February 27th, 2012
11:55 pm

Ra`mon

blog monster

Grandad

February 27th, 2012
11:56 pm

well that got through

Ra'mon

February 28th, 2012
12:05 am

Lol, happens all the time.

vava74

February 28th, 2012
7:11 am

Ra’mon

February 27th, 2012
11:21 pm

The Wizards are trying to give away Blatche. Should the Hawks bite, if the Wiz would accept Marvin? That’s a hard decision. But I may would take Blatche, but not put him in the starting line up.

HELL YES!!! WHY THE &%$#$& DOUBT???

O'Brien

February 28th, 2012
7:25 am

Ra’mon,

I don’t know why, but in such a short season, the fact that Al came to camp out of basketball shape (compared to the rest of the team) speaks volumes to me.

In my mind, that made him more than trade-able to me..

Even in college, Al was always thought of as one of the hardest working guys on the team, and the same thing since he has been with the Hawks. Never any issues, never any blowups, just a blue collar guy who shows up to work everyday. But he shows up to camp in shape (just not basketball shape), and that makes him more than trade-able to you?

I could not disagree more. Plus was he not ready to go game 1? So what’s the issue here?

vava74

February 28th, 2012
7:43 am

OB,

Al’s blue collar stance is no longer a guaranteed thing.

Last year he was given so much space that he completely fell in love with the jumper and had a generally soft approach to the game.

This year I was actually encouraged with the fact that he seemed to be realizing that his open looks from the elbow were not there and was looking a bit more interested in banging.

However, we did not have enough of a sample to be sure.

Dawg

February 28th, 2012
7:53 am

Go get Pal Gasol. He is available, he is tall, he can shoot. Hinrich is a pg that is needed by LA.

Just Joe

February 28th, 2012
8:14 am

vava74…you talk like Al “falling in love with his jumper” was a bad thing. didn’t he improve his FG%? yes, he should defend the paint more aggressively, but i can’t tell him to stop taking open set shots, especially when he’s making them. this is not a josh smith situation.

Layups R Us

February 28th, 2012
8:16 am

Hawks need to do whatever it takes to trade for a legitimate power scoring center. That’s the foundation to winning.

Layups R Us

February 28th, 2012
8:17 am

Gasol,Bynum,Howard,Kaman,get a center Hawks !!!

vava74

February 28th, 2012
9:07 am

Just Joe,

Last year was an aberration: Al was left free due to poor scouting during the regular season.

In the playoffs neither ORL nor CHI gave him the same space and since his mechanics are slow and without any lift, those easy shots quickly became massive bricks.

This year EVERYONE had caught up with Al’s jumpers and stopped giving him the space he needs to hit those so he was back working down low (at least that is what I saw).

The harsh reality is that anyone that thinks that Al is anything more than an average PF is kidding himself.

Al’s game is to be an undersized, mobile and active C who makes up for his average D at the rim with good rotations, closeouts and pick ‘n roll D FROM THE C slot.

DeeDog

February 28th, 2012
9:16 am

Najeh Davenpoop

“B- sounds about right. I’d probably give the players a solid B+ because they have exceeded the expectations I had for them after Al got injured. I give the organization a C- for sitting on their hands the last month and not proactively acquiring a big man, and LD deserves a D for screwing up the rotations by handing Kirk minutes for no reason and insisting on playing small ball against bigger teams. All of that probably averages out to a B-.”

Finally!!! Someone speaks the truth. I can’t stand Kirk H. He slows the game down, he can’t make a open jumper consistantly, and his defense does not balance the rest of his game. Pargo was playing great before he came back and Larry Drew just move Pargo to the back of the bench and stuck Hinrik in. We are much better with Pargo. I like him alot and think he is getting screwed!!!! Trade Marvin and Hinrik fast.

Astro Joe

February 28th, 2012
10:03 am

Wasn’t Horford like in the top 2-3 bigs in the league shooting from the 16-23 foot range? I think he was up there with Dirk. I don’t recall any issue with his overall FG% last year.

And I am pretty sure that he spent the off-season playing with the DR National Team. He wasn’t exactly chilaxing on the beach eating butterscotch krimpets.

Lastly, if anyone believes that Horford is incapable of evolving his game, then why have I never read the same concern for Josh? Aren;t they the same age? If there remains eternal optimism that Josh can either improve this skill or that skill, then why can’t Horford likewise evolve?

Najeh Davenpoop

February 28th, 2012
10:10 am

Hawks have the toughest strength of schedule over their last 10 games in the league. They are 4-6 over that time. The Nuggets, Blazers, and Sixers have also struggled over the last 10 against tough schedules, but the Magic and Grizzlies have managed to continue winning.

Najeh Davenpoop

February 28th, 2012
10:13 am

Also, the Pacers and Bulls are the only two Eastern Conference teams whose home/road games played splits are more unfavorable (the difference between number of road games and number of home games is greater).

With all the Hawks’ struggles, maybe as they play more home games and the schedule gets easier they can move back up in the standings. They are only 1.5 games out of the 3 seed.

Ra'mon

February 28th, 2012
11:01 am

O’Brien, I disagree so much with your view of the Al being in shape. And on the first game of the season, it didn’t appear Al was in great shape then either. It just seems all of the things that got Al the contract, is what Al stopped doing AFTER signing the contract. You speak of blue collar. But we haven’t seen blue collar Al since 2-3 seasons ago. Blue collar Al wouldn’t have gotten out worked by Noah (remember Al used to OWN Noah at Florida, but not in the playoffs?). You say Al was in shape but not in basketball shape. But isn’t he a basketball player? Why wouldn’t he (a team captain) be in the best shape to do his job, when not around the team? Especially after Sund and Gearon says this is a make or break season for the ‘core’? Even Marvin was in great shape.

Ra'mon

February 28th, 2012
11:17 am

AJ, before this season, the problem with Al always looking for his jumper too much, is it took him out of position for any offensive put backs. Before this season, Josh wasn’t allowed to hit the offensive board as much, because both LD and Woody gave the transition defense responsibility to Josh. So when a shot goes up, Josh would have to get back on defense instead of crashing the board (partly because of Bibby and Crawford). Al’s rookie season he averaged 3.1 offensive rebounds a game. Al’s contract season, before the extension, he averaged 2.9 offensive boards a game. Last season, Al averaged 2.4 OR per game. that .5 and .7 is a huge difference in the course of a season.

And last season, Al committed 2.5 fouls a game. Dwight and Chandler were both over 3 fouls per game. I wouldn’t want my starters to commit LESS than 2.5 fouls per game for an entire season. How unfairly the referees treat the Hawks on an average day, you could barely swat at the ball or be outside of the restricted area, without them calling the foul on you. Yet Horford only committed 2 fouls a game even though he’s undersized or had to switch on point guards for most of the season? If you are coming into the fourth quarter of a close game with only one foul, you have to know ‘Ok, I have 3-4 fouls I can give to protect the rim, even if I can’t block the shot.’ But not Al, he go sit down in the locker room committing 1-2 fouls, after a loss thinking he did all he could do. Every since Al seriously injured (was it TJ Ford?) in Toronto, he’s been giving up layups in the lane more frequently.

Trojan

February 28th, 2012
11:29 am

How can it be all star break, be so close to the trade deadline, have a team with such obvious needs and shortcomings and there is still absolutely no rumors or rumblings on trying to improve the club.

How can there no acknowledgement from management on the search for help of these obvious needs?

Strange.

Dallas won the NBA championship last year and you constantly hear how they are trying to do more to win. LA is a very good club, yet you don’t hear that they are complacent, they are trying to keep a sacred core together.

It’s hard to be a Hawks fan.

vava74

February 28th, 2012
11:48 am

AJ,

Al was indeed deadly from mid-long range last year BUT that only happed because opposing teams took the WHOLE season to adjust their scouting reports.

Come playoff time, Al was crowded and could not get his shot off comfortably and bricked them.

Dirk shoots with elevation and fading so he can overcome adhesive defenses, making his shooting percentage from the same range incredible (also, he has been doing it for years and years with defenses focusing on him).

Al only shoots effectively when he is clearly open. His shooting motion is slow, low and mechanic.

There is nothing wrong with that, it’s very good that we have a big who can knock down the open jumper BUT that is completely different from Al being a dependable face up scorer.

COMPLETELY DIFFERENT.

As for Josh being able to improve his game more than Al:

Josh is physically more gifted and more explosive.

Al is solid physically – good speed for size, good strength – BUT he is not explosive.

Al’s first step is substantially slower than Josh, his jumping ability substantially weaker, his overall length is subpar when compared with the players he has to face.

So, there is no question that Josh can be a much more reliable scorer in the block.

Again, there is nothing particularly wrong with Al IF – big if here – our expectations and HIS expectations of what he can and should do are not blown out of proportion like they were last year.

Al should go back to be a blue collar player, a more offensively polished but also less strong version of Ben Wallace.

The Hawks’ offensive pecking order should be:

JJ, Smoove, Teague (I would prefer a good balance between the 3), with Al getting the garbage points and the open looks from kick outs and with whoever played the SF slot (or the SG slot if JJ moved to SF) covered by a good defensive player which hopefully would be a true knock down shooter which, contrary to Marvin, also had the ability to slash and dunk in a crowd.

TMACfan

February 28th, 2012
11:49 am

Trojan, there is a rumor trade with Cleveland.

ntrigue

February 28th, 2012
11:59 am

Hawks rumor….We trade hinrich to lakers for 1st round pick and for sg darius Moore

Astro Joe

February 28th, 2012
12:01 pm

Ra’mon, it sounds like most of your points were relative to Horofrd’s utilization as opposed to his limitations. Hawks have focused on transition defense under LD at the expense of offensive rebounding. Likewise, LD’s offensive design is (supposedly) about getting players better looks. it is clearly a jump-shooting offense more than one that truly leverages a ton of screens and picks and back-door cuts (we see some of that but less than some of us expected from a motion offese). Again, a new coach may ask Horford to do things differently and I personally don;t know if he could or couldn’t make the adjustment.

vava, athleticism is very, very important but so is discipline, hard work and the ability to stay focused. All of those are very important when discussing a player’s ability to evolve their game. Al will never have the explosiveness of Josh, but does that mean that he could never be as or more productive? Of course not.

MistaGamer

February 28th, 2012
12:07 pm

vava74,

You have made my point perfectly concerning Al. Al’s advantage is that he is playing the center position. Not many C’s, if any, can run and move around the half court with Al. That is where is mismatch lies. There are plenty of PF’s that can and that’s why Al tends to disappear when playing the PF position.

Ra'mon

February 28th, 2012
12:13 pm

AJ, I don’t know if Horford has many limits. I don’t see him having the ability to create his own shot though. And I don’t see a true facilitator on the team who is a pass first guy. As I’ve said before, I don’t blame Josh or Al for many of their shortcomings, because their entire career has been under this organization and limited coaching. Al just doesn’t move fluidly to me on offense when he has the ball. He almost moves more like Robocop than a player. At the same time, who would’ve thought 4 seasons ago Zach Randolph would be the 2nd best PF in the game (when healthy)?

Ra'mon

February 28th, 2012
12:16 pm

Vava, I agree with your 11:48 Post.

Astro Joe

February 28th, 2012
12:17 pm

This is NOT a rumor, but an ESPN writer’s attempt at providing content for their website.

Here are five potential smaller deals that could have a big impact:

1. The Atlanta Hawks trade PG Kirk Hinrich to the Los Angeles Lakers for SG Darius Morris and a first-round pick (either the Lakers’ pick or Dallas’ pick from the Lamar Odom trade)

Why the teams should make this trade: The Lakers are in dire need of a point guard, and they’ve coveted Hinrich in the past. They possess a trade exception of $8.9 million acquired via the Odom trade, so they can absorb Hinrich’s salary. He is a versatile combo guard who is an excellent passer and can score. He owns a nice shooting stroke and would make teams pay for doubling Kobe Bryant or Gasol and Andrew Bynum in the post.

Hinrich also offers insurance if Steve Blake is injured again. He’s a tough, gritty competitor who would bring the defensive mentality Mike Brown loves. He could flourish in L.A. instead of languishing on the Atlanta bench, where he has lost traction as a result of Jeff Teague’s emergence.

The Hawks have to look around at their competition in the East and realize they do not have the pieces to beat the Miami Heat, Chicago Bulls or even the Philadelphia 76ers. Although they are currently 20-14, this team cannot make a deep playoff run with Al Horford out of the lineup until possibly April or May. The Hawks need a center, and by giving up Hinrich they would be able to either grab a big man in the draft or an asset they could flip to give them roster flexibility in order to trade for a big in the offseason.

Morris is a talented point guard who should have stayed at Michigan for another year. In time, however, he could be groomed for the starter’s role or serve as a valuable backup.

drmaryb.[*_*].

February 28th, 2012
12:23 pm

Ra’mon! Sup boy? I saw your three way trade with Rondo coming to the Hawks, however? Rondo ain’t going nowhere except for maybe CP3. Ain’t gonna happen, elite PG’s are NOT low hanging fruit and Boston will re-tool their new team around their best player at PG.

Move on Ra’mon … It was a nice dream though.

vava74

February 28th, 2012
12:26 pm

AJ,

“vava, athleticism is very, very important but so is discipline, hard work and the ability to stay focused. All of those are very important when discussing a player’s ability to evolve their game. Al will never have the explosiveness of Josh, but does that mean that he could never be as or more productive? Of course not.”

Wrong in all instances.

Discipline and focus will NEVER overcome certain physical and technical limitations.

Is Al, in theory, a more dependable player than Josh (due to Josh’s mental limitations)?

Sure, but it’s easier, IMO, for Josh to change his ways (with proper coaching) than Al to suddenly physically and technically evolve from where he is.

You can coach explosiveness and talent and Josh is both more explosive and more talented that Al.

Al, offensively, is mechanical, hesitant and that will never change dramatically.

As I said, nothing wrong with that IF he plays the C spot where others Cs are in general less mobile and less explosive than Al.

A good example is Hibbert who Al usually played well in spite of the 3” to 4” height differential.

BUT, when Al set his mind to play PF, that was a WRONG MOVE: he will never be a really effective PF in this league. NEVER.

Astro Joe

February 28th, 2012
12:27 pm

It seems to me that the judgment on Horford is coming based on a small window of performances this season and his inability to light things up in the playoffs. Personally, I wouldn’t cast him into a subordinate role based on those data points. Without elite athleticism, he is a highly skilled and productive player. Just like others wold benefit from a facilitator and improved coaching, so would Al.

BIG DOG

February 28th, 2012
12:29 pm

Hawks don’t need Sessions, only expire contract Jamison.

Share your trade

http://games.espn.go.com/nba/tradeMachine?tradeId=cv5un38

vava74

February 28th, 2012
12:30 pm

“a more dependable”

SWAP for

“a more reliable” which is slightly different from dependable.

My view is that YOU CANNOT DEPEND ON AL to win games for the Hawks (well, he did it once against the Bulls and that was it) but you can depend on Josh to win games for the Hawks.

Josh has done that repeatedly with both his usually consistent wrecking ball D and his unfortunately “up n down” offense.

The bottom line is: WE NEED QUALITY COACHING to maximize the talent and the characteristics of this roster.

We will not get it from LD.

BIG DOG

February 28th, 2012
12:33 pm

Teague, Joe, Josh, Jamison, Zaza

Pargo, Green, Tmac, Ivan, Dampier

Vlad, Stacks

Hawks would be better on defense and bigger.

BIG DOG IN THE HOUSE

drmaryb.[*_*].

February 28th, 2012
12:33 pm

Astro “Van” Joe! Sup sugar bunny?

Thanks for posting that kirk to Lakers article for us to chew on. I’ve lost my will to comment this past month, due to ASKG living up to the “K” in killer. I’m waiting for a real roster move to hop back on the blog band wagon.

Just grew tired of repeating myself daily and needed a time out from here. LOL! I’m ready for the next game though.

Ra'mon

February 28th, 2012
12:35 pm

Dr.Mb, according to Stephen A Smith (just spoke this on First Take at 10:30 this morning and 12:29 just now) that Celtics are looking to move Pierce and Rondo. Hoopshype has Boston moving Allen and Rondo. CNNSi has Boston moving Rondo and Garnett. The common factor is Rondo. Doc Rivers and Rondo reportedly have a bad relationship. And it became even worse when Perkins was dealt. So I don’t believe Rondo is untouchable. Not to mention, if they trade Rondo, then adding D. Williams at the PG slot becomes a great possibility when you factor in Garnett and Allen’s contract coming off the board this summer.

vava74

February 28th, 2012
12:35 pm

AJ:

“he (Al) is a highly skilled”

Wrong again: Al is not highly skilled. Dirk is highly skilled. Beasley is highly skilled, Garnett is highly skilled, Bosh is highly skilled, Pau is highly skilled, …

Al’s skill set is AVERAGE. What Al is – or was in the past – is a HARD WORKER which overcame his lack of skill with a no nonsense / blue collar attitude.

Last year’s aberration (too many open looks) heavily contributed to a decay in his main characteristic and THAT WAS EXPOSED IN THE PLAYOFFS.

Get Al back in the paint, fighting and using his superior mobility to overcome his height and length deficit and give him the OPEN looks that may come out of the offense as “left overs”*, not as programmed touches.

* which could still be something between 3 to 5 long jumpers per game.

Hawks Blog Legend Worldwide Clyde

February 28th, 2012
12:36 pm

Hawks aren’t good enough to beat Miami or Chicago in a series.

Ra'mon

February 28th, 2012
12:38 pm

AJ, I’ve felt this way about Al for over 2 seasons. Wasn’t it two off seasons ago that Sautee and myself battled about Al wanting to play PF instead of C for over a week. Also, I think Al is the Hawks best trade chip to get an all star player back in the deal.

BIG DOG

February 28th, 2012
12:38 pm

When AL and Collins comeback

Teague, Joe, Josh, Jamison, Horford

Pargo, Green, Tmac, Zaza, Collins

Vlad, Stack, Ivan

BIG DOG IN THE HOUSE

BIG DOG

February 28th, 2012
12:46 pm

Hawks has to become bigger and stronger on defense, with Teague and Josh on the Wing running could be scary.
Hawks are Rank 21 rebounding.
This must change.
BIG DOG IN THE HOUSE

Astro Joe

February 28th, 2012
12:48 pm

vava, and I disagree with you. I don’t hink either Josh or Al are elite. No need to compare either to a future HOF or perennial All-Star. Neither will get there for different reasons. They are both “bubble All-Stars”. But that doesn’t mean that either are unproductive. I am certainly not arguing that Al should play one position or another… he needs to play the position that his head coach demands him to play. I think we all get caught up using elite players as the measuring stick for our players. If you aren’t either a young KG, Shaq, Blake or Duncan then you aren’t worht keeping. If you aren’t Kidd, Nash or CP3, they you are trash. If you aren’t Wade, Durant or Ray allen… why are you playing wing in the NBA.

IMO, Horford is a very good big relative to other bigs in the NBA. Better than most. I can’t dismiss 15/10 in a player’s 4th year as quickly as some of you all. That ain’t bad, I don’t care how it is achieved.

Ra'mon

February 28th, 2012
12:56 pm

Another thing about Al is, if Josh went down instead of Al. I don’t think this season, the Hawks would have as good of a record as they do now. And to be honest, the only reason we have to consider trading either one of them is because of Sund’s mistake of giving such a long contract to Marvin (who didn’t test the market), and his deal to Bibby (who ended up costing giving up 2 first round picks, and a good wing man just to get injured ridden Kirk). Those two deals subtracted, gives the Hawks all they need to complete this roster and add great depth over the last 2-3 seasons. And I believe THEN the Hawks wouldn’t have had to give such a huge contract to Joe. They could’ve handled losing him and Jamal.

Jody

February 28th, 2012
1:12 pm

To suggest that a guy who’s made two all star teams playing out of position is “average” is laughable and quite absurd. Yet, folks want to hang there hopes on a guy who often plays out of control and undisciplined.

O'Brien

February 28th, 2012
1:15 pm

Ra’mon,

Please remember LD’s 2 foul rule too, which Al was a victim of on numerous occasions in the first half. And when he came back in the second half, he was out of rhythm

I do agree that Al is not the same Al from 2-3 years ago, and I wish he would get back to that. But he did average 15 and 9 last year.

We criticize Al’s playoff performance last year (and rightfully so). But he was not the only one who struggled in the playoffs. Jamal struggled in the second round, Josh had his bad moments too. Speaking of Josh, These are Josh’s playoff 3-pt attempts.

’07-’08: 3-18
’08-’09: 2-15
’09-10: 2-6
10-11:3-24

What’s his excuse for continuing to shoot so many 3’s?

But despite Josh being in his 8th year, you haven’t given up on him being a better player. Al is only in his 4th year. So why give up on Al so quick?

I do agree that Hawks may have to trade Al or Josh (because nobody wants JJ’s contract for at least 2 more years). And for me, determining which one to trade will depend on who brings back the better package.

vava74

February 28th, 2012
1:26 pm

Jody
February 28th, 2012
1:12 pm

Jody, Al was selected to the All-star game for TWO main reasons:

1 – He was playing C and there aren’t any really good centers, so Al was good enough to get in.

2 – Al is highly regarded by coaches who select the reserves and make their selections based on their perception of “COACHABILITY”.

Horford WILL NEVER be an All-Star at the PF slot.

Josh was not selected this year because he is perceived as difficult to coach, not because of his production or his numbers.

If correctly read my posts, I gave sufficient praise to Horford, but I framed that praise within two major and essential guidelines:

AL HAS TO PLAY C to be of real worth.

AL HAS TO GO BACK to being the blue collar guy.

The bottom line is simple: he will never be a really good PF and last year he benefited from open looks which once the league caught up with him disappeared.

Al’s SKILL SET is average, which does NOT MEAN that Al’s production is only average.

Al’s production as a Center is/was GOOD, close to VERY GOOD, without being excellent BECAUSE of his hustle (which is decaying), not because of his “offensive skills”.

pointguardslim

February 28th, 2012
1:30 pm

“I can’t dismiss 15/10 in a player’s 4th year as quickly as some of you all. ”

15 pts, 9.3 rebounds, 35mpg, 104 defensive rating (always several points behind the leader Smith)

He’s decidedly average.

Defensive roaming aside, the deciding factor why Josh Smith is worth anything is because he can be classified as a wing.

pointguardslim

February 28th, 2012
1:38 pm

Al wasn’t a blue-collar guy when he got injured vs IND?
Al wasn’t a blue-collar guy when he got injured vs MIA in the playoffs?

Seems like blue-collar = “play around the rim”. Have any of you considered Al doesnt play around the rim to avoid injuries/physicality? Guy just had his arm socket shredded and people are telling him he needs to do more of it.

Are we really that naive? He’s a good guy but he cant play the C position the way we want and he’s average playmaker at the 4 position. Doesn’t “beast” get to the paint/FTA at either position.

Why not try Smith at the 3 and see if he “beasts” and gets more FTA and commands doubles etc.
The funny thing is Josh Smith seems to shoot less 3s as a SF than at PF. It seems at the PF position he gets a pass to use his perimeter play and at the SF their is a concerted effort to use his size advantage.

Smith at PF is a bad matchup. Here he travels and still can’t get scoring position and throws it away.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=–0JWiMbo8A

Jody

February 28th, 2012
2:04 pm

Al has all the ability and tools to be an outstanding 4 (his natural position). The excuses for him making the all star team are lame and weak. Bottom line, he made the all star team because he played his butt off the right way while putting up good numbers out of position on a winning team. And remember, the Hawks didn’t sniff the playoffs until number 15 aboard.

Josh is a good player, but he’s not on the all star team because he doesn’t play the game efficiently despite what some of his numbers say. The whole coaches don’t like him argument is also weak. When he learns to play to strengths and not with an approach trying to be more than he is, then he may get consideration. But, that probably won’t be a worry for the Hawks seeing as how Josh is sure to leave in free agency after next season if the Hawks don’t overpay him to stay.

pointguardslim

February 28th, 2012
2:16 pm

Al has all the ability and tools to be an outstanding 4 (his natural position)??

what? He has robotic moves in the post. He struggles to score outside of pick and pop…

Outstanding? No. That is the exact opposite of reality. Horford would not stand out at power forward.
———–
As for Smith being the most pivotal player on the Hawks, that’s apparently nothing new. Gearon remembers talking with players in December 2007, four months before Atlanta would make its first playoff appearance in nine years and take eventual champion Boston to seven games in the first round.

“It was the only time in my lifetime I’ve ever sat down with players alone and just sort of talked about stuff, and everyone back then was like, ‘Josh is the key (to the team),’ ” Gearon said of Smith, a six-year veteran who is 24 but was just 21 entering the month those comments were made. “Even then, people were like, ‘He’s the key.’ He does different things. The intensity rises for the whole team. It was interesting to hear that even back then.”

Gearon said he doesn’t mean to take anything away from Hawks All-Star guard Joe Johnson, who had a game-high 27 points against Milwaukee and averaged a team-high 21.3 points during the regular season. And one presumes he also doesn’t mean to take anything away from Atlanta’s other All-Star from last February, center Al Horford, when Gearon says Smith “deserved to be on the All-Star team as much as anybody on our team.”
—————-

drmaryb.[*_*].

February 28th, 2012
2:19 pm

Ra’mon

thanks for that info re: Rondo. I would have never thought he was touchable. Hmmm … I did hear Rondo was suspended from the team as he was named an AS replacement for Joe. i have heard that Rondo is very stubborn and had issues breaking into his starter’s role. Very interesting stuff becasue, he seems so Teague-Like personality wise.

Anyway, Ra’mon thanks for the inside scoop. If we can get Rondo, then i like your trade suggestion the best as opposed to the Lakers PG coming here.

Ra'mon

February 28th, 2012
2:29 pm

O’Brien, I lean more toward Josh than Al, because I’ve seen more progression in Josh’s game than Al since entering the league. You say Josh is in his 8th season compared to Horford’s 4th. First, this is Al’s 5th season, not 4th. Secondly they are the same age. And while Josh had Woody for his first 2 seasons, Al had Billy Donovan. Whom do you think had the better coach to learn from?

You showed Josh’s 3 pt attempts from the post season. But tell me this, if you consider a 3pt attempt by Josh as a bad possession (no matter the shot clock situation). So with all the defensive pressure Josh provides during the post season (i.e. 3 blocked shots on ONE possession under the rim, while Al stands there and WATCH against the Bulls) that’s less than 2 bad possessions a game. I don’t know any coach who would say a game was solely lost on two-four possessions. But I do know many coaches who would say a game was won, or remained closed because of CONSISTENT defensive pressure. Josh battles on the defensive end. If I saw Horford still battling on defense, I could care less about his jumpers. Majority of Josh’s mistakes occurs from effort, even though he may made a mental mistake, the effort was there. How many times has Woody or LD said that Josh’s energy is what make this team go? Why would Josh’s energy be required for 11 other grown men to decide to be energetic? How many games have we seen that Josh kept the starting unit in the game in the 1st quarter, because of HIS play? Now how many has Al done that with? The play of Zaza (who would’ve thought) makes me feel that Al is easily replaced for a lot less than $12 mil a season. However to replace Josh, you’ll need 3 players almost, one for the rebounding, one for the offense, and one for his defense. Al shows me the energy that Josh brings, and I’ll back off of him. But over the last 2-3 seasons he hasn’t shown me that.

Ra'mon

February 28th, 2012
2:30 pm

O’brien, also this is Josh’s 7th season, not 8th.

Ra'mon

February 28th, 2012
2:34 pm

DrMb, I think Teague and Rondo are very similar. The difference that I’ve seen is huge in the confidence. Rondo doesn’t seem to allow his play to be affected by other’s comments (even if teammates) or bench play (he’s had Cassell, Stephon Marbury, and Nate Robinson take away some of his minutes). Also, I don’t see Teague attempting to have the assist numbers that Rondo has.

I even wonder if Boston would take Joe, a first round in 2013 and Teague for Rondo and Pierce straight up.

Ra'mon

February 28th, 2012
2:41 pm

And DrMB, I totally agree with you about hopping off this bandwagon. It seems being a loyal Hawks’ fan get you nothing but complaints and laughter. Especially when you consider how many NBA players make Atlanta their home in the off season. And none of them want to come play for the Hawks long as this ownership is in town. T-Mac still has a huge voice among other players. And in his first season here, he’s in the media complaining. Jamal toasted the leadership of ownership and management the entire off season. And the crazy part is each of the top players (Joe, Josh, Al) have many friends among the players. Yet they can’t recruit anyone with ASG, Sund, and LD.

Sautee

February 28th, 2012
2:49 pm

“DrMb, I think Teague and Rondo are very similar.”

I disagree Ramon. I think that Rondo is MUCH more clever with his playmaking than Teague, sadly, will ever be. In my opinion, Teague is closer to Barbosa (Grandad’s comparison) with a game predicated FIRST on speed and drives to the hoop. I’m not saying that Teague lacks vision, but I’ve yet to see him be nearly as clever as Rondo when he probes the defense. Not only that, but Rondo is a tougher defensive cover than Jeff.

He DOES have a better outside shot than Rondo though.

Enjoyable convo re: Al this morning. I see both sides. If Al gets his ass back in the paint, he CAN be worth his contract. I’ll be VERY interested to see how willing he is to battle inside post injury.

But I’d trade him just like I would ANYBODY on the roster IF it made us a better, and more balanced team.

STRETCH

February 28th, 2012
2:56 pm

NBA Trade Rumors: Hawks Interested in Ramon Sessions?
February 28, 2012 By Scott

With Cleveland’s reserve point guard Ramon Sessions playing at a very consistent and productive level through the compressed 2011-12 campaign, suitors are rumored to be lining up to hopefully acquire his services prior to the mid-March trade deadline.

The latest rumor has the Atlanta Hakws — looking to move small forward Marvin Williams — in the mix as they would like to upgrade their backcourt in hopes of another playoff run. Their current point guard, Jeff Teague, is averaging 12.2 points and 4.4 assists in 34 minutes per game. Sessions is averaging 5.5 assists per contest in three fewer minutes. Williams is averaging 9.0 points and 5.3 rebounds per game.

A Williams-Sessions trade would reunite the wing with a man responsible for drafting him with the second-overall pick in 2005 in Chris Grant. The rub in this specific instance would be that Williams, an upgrade over Omri Casspi, albeit marginal, is making over $7 million this season and would require additional assets from the Cavaliers if a deal were to go down; Sessions is making just over $4 million and, despite the team being under the cap thus skirting dollar-matching guidelines, it’s difficult to envision a scenario where the team would be willing to take on additional obligation.

The Los Angeles Lakers have also expressed interest in Sessions.

pointguardslim

February 28th, 2012
3:00 pm

Kevin Love is shooting and making 3 pointers and making FTA. Its possible to take and make good shots and still have low FG%.
(Smith has less shot attempts because he isn’t that good of a shooter)
Reference (TS%) True Shooting % so we can stop contradicting ourselves here.
——–

Re: O’Brien
You really can’t find anything Josh Smith can do against SFs?

I don’t know what you are arguing when its clear that Smith is goaded into jumpers and using his “shaky handle” as a 4. For goodness sakes he leads the fast break just to beat his man.

Not that Smith skills are as bad as you say but, playing Smith at the 4 plays into all those weaknesses you listed. That’s why this team is so maddeningly insane.

Josh Smith at SF becomes a star. His handles are shaky yet we tell him to play smallball where he often handles the ball out of the break to create a mismatch.

I don’t see how Smith’s “handles” become worse against SFs who he can get around and score. Or taking issue with his jumper
* you have a smaller person contesting it instead of a taller PF
* he can back his man down
* you have a PF and C crashing the boards if all else fails.

honest_abe

February 28th, 2012
3:00 pm

sautee – spot on comparison. if i may add to that rondo is a leader while teague is not. rondo was in a situation where he was the pg of a team with 3 potentail HOF’ers. he had to lead as well as try to keep everyone happy. teague can’t even lead this group of misfits, can you imagine him being the floor leader of the 2009 celtics? shiiiiiiii

oldmike

February 28th, 2012
3:01 pm

Anyone out here in blog land know the name of the player taken with our traded 1st rounder in the Kirk/Bibby trade? I don’t.

O'Brien

February 28th, 2012
3:14 pm

pointguardslim,

A SF is supposed to have better handles than a PG. Josh handles the ball well for a PF, and does lead the fast break sometimes. But too often, it turns into a bad possession.

Also, Josh’s jumper from 16 feet out is terrible. So as a SF, wont be spend even more time on the perimeter? That is not where we want him to be.

If Josh would commit himself to staying in the paint, then I might be more open to him playing SF. But his jumper mentality, plus shaky handles for a SF (he leads the break, but is not good at beating his man off the dribble), and I dont want him chasing SFs around the perimeter, I want him defending bigs in the paint and helping on defense suggests to me he is a PF (although he does give up some size).

Why not try Smith at the 3 and see if he “beasts” and gets more FTA and commands doubles etc..

I don’t know if I want Josh taking more FTs. Dude is shooting 55% from the line this year :smile:

O'Brien

February 28th, 2012
3:14 pm

* I meant better handles than a PF.

KevinM

February 28th, 2012
3:18 pm

Based on our team’s limitations with the salary and creativity, if there was a way to move both Marvin and Kirk at the deadline, I would be thrilled. That is a lot of cap hit for what they have provided so far.
Stretch, that Marvin rumor sounds like last year’s rumor to a T after the Shaq deal was laughed at….and if Chris Grant was responsible for drafting Marvin, Cleveland should fire him immediately. What a shambles of a move and Sund trumps it by not using the market to set his value.
He did the same thing with Joe and Al and that was a huge mistake. Yes, I know they’re all-stars, but they are the most marginal all-stars in all-star history. I would say Kaman is as good an all-star as either Joe or Al.
oldmike, Chris Singleton of Florida State was taken by the Wizards at #17.

Sautee

February 28th, 2012
3:19 pm

oldmike,

The Wizards used the pick we traded to draft Chris Singleton out of FSU. Good defensive wing who can guard multiple positions.

KevinM

February 28th, 2012
3:22 pm

One thing that will not work in this league is D12 and Josh on the same team. Neither one can shoot a FT, yet, they can tally up a quantity of them….Can you imagine the opponent at the end of a game? They would be licking their chops at that option.

Seriously though, if there are any changes that are being considered of any significance with this team, Josh will have to be moved. Al and Joe aren’t going anywhere.

O'Brien

February 28th, 2012
3:22 pm

Ra’mon,

Josh is the energizer on this team. But isn’t it frustrating that he doesn’t bring “it” more often? I think he is the most talented player on this team (right up there with JJ), but Josh does not come close to maximizing his talent (imo). He is inconsistent, and is part of the reason why this team is inconsistent.

That being said, I think the ASG needs to shake up the core. Most big name players dont want to play for the ASG, but I think the problem is more than just ownership.

Does anybody want to play for Donald Sterling or Vinnie Del Negro? Nope. But yet, K-Mart signed there, and the Clips were also a finalist for JR Smith. Why is that? They have Blake Griffin and CP3. The Hawks dont have players who other players really want to play with (I dont count Dwight wanting to play with Josh, who is his long time friend).

Grandad

February 28th, 2012
3:24 pm

Mary Ellen

Rondo will get in KG’s face; Pierce’s face; Ray Allen’s face;
used to get in Perkin’s face; even had the nuggets to get in
Tony Allen’s face … that’s why the players respect his
fiery demeanor.
That and the fact: he is the QB; the one who has control over
who gets the ball and when.they get it.
A lesson that would be beneficial for young Teaguer.

I’m not sure that Doc wishes to trade him ?

Danny Ainge is the one who appears hell bent on trading Rondo.

O'Brien

February 28th, 2012
3:24 pm

KevinM,

If the rumor was true at the time, Hawks should have done the SNT of Marvin for Shaq. Marketing would have gone up, we would have had another big (although he got hurt and didnt play well), but most importantly, it would have saved us 2 years on marvin’s contract. But ASG is afraid to take risks.

pointguardslim

February 28th, 2012
3:26 pm

Anyone out here in blog land know the name of the player taken with our traded 1st rounder in the Kirk/Bibby trade.
—–
“We were able to acquire a proven, clutch leader in Mike, a hard-nosed veteran in Maurice, and an intriguing prospect in Jordan, as well as a first round draft choice to add to our own first round pick this summer,” said Grunfeld. “This trade continues our plan to build with draft picks and by developing our young players while staying financially flexible.”
——
Wizards selected the 6′9 (classic tweener) Chris Singleton, a soft tall guy that some ATLiens were clamoring for.

18 Chris Singleton
19 Tobias Harris
20 Donatas Motiejunas
22 Kenneth Faried
25 MarShon Brooks
38 Chandler Parsons
39 Jeremy Tyler (if he ever becomes a PF and gets mature watch out)
40 Jon Leuer
41 Darius Morris (lol)
47 Travis Leslie (shoulda coulda woulda)
48 Keith Benson

Grandad

February 28th, 2012
3:29 pm

vava

We should have taken Yi in the 1st round.
Horford is so devoid of skill and heart;
not to mention destitute of any athleticism whatsoever.
that we could have picked him up in the 2nd round.

O'Brien

February 28th, 2012
3:31 pm

Grandad,

How much of Rondo’s leadership can be attributed to Doc giving him the reins early on, and showing confidence in him no matter what (even publicly). Not to mention the fact that the Boston trio knew how to play the game the right way, and listened to their HC.

Hawks have 3 captains with much longer tenure than Teague, and at times they didnt listen to Woody or LD. Not to mention the Hawks culture does not compare to Boston’s (imo).

Also, LD was wishy washy on Teague last year, and if it wasnt for Hinrich’s injury, he probably wouldnt even be starting, so Teague had a confidence issue from early on, part of which I think is due to the Hawks culture (who ranks where).

So I can understand Teague being leadership shy. However, going forward, he does need to come out of his shell, and not worry about what the vets think. Call them out. Run the team. Step up.

KevinM

February 28th, 2012
3:33 pm

Whoever was suggesting Andray Blatche, please..that isn’t helping us going forward….his deal is worse than Marvelous. He doesn’t look like he gives us anymore than our guy does….

We’re better off getting a min vet in place of Marvin/Kirk….I’ll take trade exceptions for both at this point.

Sautee

February 28th, 2012
3:38 pm

Grandad is getting trolled. Again, and I’ll likely be next.

The 3:29 post was definitely NOT Grandad.

Grandad

February 28th, 2012
3:39 pm

pointguardslim

That was not some Atlantians;
that was primarily me !

I’ll take the Heat – bring it.

I also said if we could trade Josh:
Take Kawhi Leonard.

Secondly; I changed to Faried after the tourney.
He [Faried] is still not a complete player;
but;
he -is- a Rebounder !

Singleton is a defensive Specialist:
Can guard the [1] through the [5]
yes;
all five positions.
No;
he cannot guard some [1's] nor all [5's]
but
he is a multi-faceted defender being wasted in Washington.

Would be a gem on a contender:
much like Kawhi Leonard in S.A.

Now – know your stuff before you come on here with some half -ass trash.

SteveW

February 28th, 2012
3:39 pm

As much as I like Pargo, and too a lesser extent Hinrich (liked him a lot better last season), I’d deal for Sessions in a heartbeat and ditch Hinrcih for whoever I could. Good teams need 48 quality minutes per nite from the PG position. We would have 2 very good young PG’s, both with a different skill set, who would set ATL at the PG position for the next 5+ years.

With both Teague and Sessions at PG, we would be very difficult for opposing teams to match up with, both on O and D.

I’d do that trade all day long.

Najeh – Man, you haven’t been reading my posts – been saying that schedule stuff for days.

Al had brutal surgery – drilling holes in his arm to put muscle thru kinda stuff. I don’t see anyway possible ASG puts Al back at the 5 when he returns. He was playing more down low this season, and got brutalized after less than 11 games.

Whether the solution is to move Josh to the 3, Al to the 4, and get a compliment for ZaZa at the 5 (Hinrich for Brad Miller and Anthony Randolph? Or Ridnour if we don’t get Sessions?) – Or if it’s to trade either Horford or Josh, I think Al’s days at the 5 are over, at least on a consistent basis.

I saw Josh some last season at the 3. But that was 30lbs ago. I would love to see what he does now. And forget about him shooting too many J’s from the 3 spot. He shoots too many from the 4 spot already, so that’s probably not going to change. If anything, he may feel he can post up opposing 3’s, and venture inside even more.

So is say trade Marvin for Sessions – give them Pargo if need be – even though I really like Pargo – better than I ever thought I would.

Trade Hinrich for Miller and Randolph. Move Josh to the 3, and give the man a new contract while your at it.

And play:

ZaZa/Miller/Damp/Collins at the C
Randolph/Ivan/Vlad at PF until Horford comes back, either late this season or next
Josh/TMac/Stack/And some Vlad at SF
JJ/Green
Teague/Sessions

If you’ve got to take Ridnour in the ‘Wolves/Hinrich trade – I saw they’re trying to move him – do it. Give them a 1st pick if need be – let Sessions and 22 year old Randolph be your 2013 1st pick so to speak. All the better.

I think if you get Horford back, you’ve got a stout team right there.

Now if you don’t think you can sign Josh, that presents a problem. I say you don’t let him walk for nothing.

I just see no plausible trades involving Josh right now. Unless you flipped Josh and Ridnour in the above scenario.for Gasol or something – but that’s a whole other story right there.

Let’s win a Championship!!! Quit competing for top 4 in the East, and let’s do this thing!

SteveW

February 28th, 2012
3:47 pm

Saw Pryzbilla re-signed with the Blazers – good – Heat doesn’t need anymore help. Their tough enough to beat as it is. Team to beat in the East in my opinion.

pointguardslim

February 28th, 2012
3:56 pm

Grandad, You really think you’re the only one in Atlanta who suggested Chris Singleton?
I think you’ve gone senile.

Melvin

February 28th, 2012
3:58 pm

I wouldn’t mind Session on this team. Send Marvin to Cleveland for Session/Ryan Hollins. We would get a serviceable PG and 7ft C for a mediocre SF. Get it done Sund…

Sautee

February 28th, 2012
4:06 pm

Melvin,

In a NY minute.

pointguardslim

February 28th, 2012
4:09 pm

OBrien. You’re pigeonholing him based on stereotypes instead of looking at the facts.
Josh Smith played the 3 last year against Luol Deng (playoffs) and Paul Pierce (regular season).

A SF is supposed to have better handles than a PF.
Tell that to Marvin Williams. Then tell that to Rick Sund.

Here’s Josh Smith 30lbs ago playing SF in a big lineup. Show us where any of these conjectures come into play?

O'Brien

February 28th, 2012
4:10 pm

Melvin,

The deal that should have been made for Sessions was at last year’s trading deadline (imo). And I dont think he would have required Bibby, JC2 AND a first round pick to get a deal done.

But the reasons I think Kirk was traded for instead of Ramon, is:
1) Kirk has a better jumper 2) Rick Sund has a crush on players he drafted or wanted to draft. 3)he ASG probably liked the fact that Kirk’s contract expires this year (I think Ramon’s expires next year).

Ra'mon

February 28th, 2012
4:14 pm

SteveW, I like your post.

O’Brien, Josh seems to ‘bring it’ more than any other player on the Hawks the last 2-3 seasons. Josh’s defensive consistency is better than anyone’s offensive consistency on the team. And Josh’s offensive consistency is better than anyone’s defensive consistency on the team, not named Joe (and Pargo, I love the pressure he puts on people). Josh’s rebounding consistency is better than anyone’s rebounding consistency not named Al.

Ra'mon

February 28th, 2012
4:16 pm

O’Brien, the deal that the Hawks missed was dealing Jamal last trading deadline to a Western contender, or even to Chicago.

pointguardslim

February 28th, 2012
4:20 pm

Melvin

February 28th, 2012
4:32 pm

OB,

In my trade scenario above, the Hawks would actually save 2 mil and they would still have Kirk expiring contract that could be flip maybe for another asset like SF Stephen Jackson or the Lakers TPE/pick…

Najeh Davenpoop

February 28th, 2012
4:35 pm

Darius Morris has looked like garbage every time I have seen him this year, but I’d gladly do Kirk for the 1st rounder. If they want to throw Morris in the deal, that’s cool too.

Ra'mon

February 28th, 2012
4:38 pm

Melvin, I’d rather have TPE compared to S. Jackson.

If you cut Kirk’s salary, and reduce Marvin’s salary slot to Sessions. You may have enough to make a run at Wilson Chandler! I’d be willing to sign Chandler for 4 years $30 million, knowing he’s a much better upgrade over Marvin.

Najeh Davenpoop

February 28th, 2012
4:41 pm

“He was playing C and there aren’t any really good centers, so Al was good enough to get in.”

I like Al, but this is true. Al made the All Star team for the same reason Hibbert made the All Star team — because the East really only has one great center.

Since Al’s best asset on offense is his jumper, and Josh’s size makes him better suited to the 3, maybe Leuer’s mom’s idea can be implemented with Al extending his range farther out and Josh posting up opposing 3s?

I still think the Hawks’ base alignment of Josh at the 4 and Al at the 5 can and does work fine against at least 25 teams in the league. But against the teams where it doesn’t, if Al extends his range and Josh plays inside, it could work to slide them down one spot.

Grandad

February 28th, 2012
4:45 pm

pointguardslim

No;
but I was the 1st on this blog & I took alot o` crap for it.
Senile – maybe ?

As for Singleton;
I’m gonna run point against your thesis a moment ago … ^above^.

Other than that; ‘`Have a Nice Day`’
sincerely,
G-dad
_____________________________________________

post script;
Marshon Brooks; admittedly, much better than I expected.

Najeh Davenpoop

February 28th, 2012
4:47 pm

” In my opinion, Teague is closer to Barbosa (Grandad’s comparison) with a game predicated FIRST on speed and drives to the hoop. ”

Barbosa is selling Teague a little short. The entirety of Barbosa’s NBA success came under D’Antoni’s system. Teague right now is a better point guard than Barbosa has ever been.

Teague is a more athletic Tony Parker. Look at Parker’s shooting percentages, assist/turnover per 36 minutes, etc. from his first few years, and they are very similar to Teague. I agree that Teague isn’t the playmaker Rondo is and probably will never be, but that doesn’t mean he is doomed to be a scoring combo guard like Barbosa. Teague is capable of developing into a good point guard.

drmaryb.[*_*].

February 28th, 2012
4:50 pm

Tweeners!

Boy do we have a team back loaded with tweeners. The only poition that is solid is: SG. Everyone else is a combo player. If we had a Real GM and a Real Coach, perhaps these players would know their defined roles and game plan night in and night out. We have never had a great coach for this core! See ASKG.

Do we re”ly know what we have and what they can re”ly do in a bonafide offensive/defensive structure.

Fantastic blog today, all these comments are stellar. Nice.

Najeh Davenpoop

February 28th, 2012
4:51 pm

“Wizards selected the 6′9 (classic tweener) Chris Singleton, a soft tall guy that some ATLiens were clamoring for.”

Singleton’s skill set is limited, but from what I have seen he is nowhere near “soft”.

Regardless, judging a traded pick based on who the other team picked with it doesn’t tell the whole story. The Hawks missed out on every player that got picked after Singleton, like Leuer’s mom points out. I would have taken Faried, who is basically a more talented, more athletic version of Ivan with much greater upside.

drmaryb.[*_*].

February 28th, 2012
4:53 pm

Greyhound!

Put Marvin on the next Greyhound Bus headed towards the downtown connector and the Grady Curve. Bye! The last time I saw Marvin, his butt was so big, I thought a crowd of people was chasing him. It looked like he was headed towards the airport. LOL

Najeh Davenpoop

February 28th, 2012
4:57 pm

“If you cut Kirk’s salary, and reduce Marvin’s salary slot to Sessions. You may have enough to make a run at Wilson Chandler!”

I don’t think so. Even if the Hawks do that, they would be either over the cap or right at the salary cap line (which is different from the luxury tax line). Can’t sign anyone to more than a mid-level ($2.5m/yr) deal unless you are under the cap.

Najeh Davenpoop

February 28th, 2012
4:59 pm

I wouldn’t mind doing Kirk for Stephen Jackson and Marvin for Sessions+Erden in two separate trades. Jackson’s contract expires a year before Marvin’s, Jackson is a better scorer than Marvin, Sessions is a better backup PG than Kirk and Pargo, and Erden is at least as good as any backup big man the Hawks have on the roster. I’m pretty sure both those trades are doable.

Najeh Davenpoop

February 28th, 2012
5:02 pm

Here we go.

http://games.espn.go.com/nba/tradeMachine?tradeId=8xnlfeh

I realize Jackson is a risk, but the Hawks need another scoring option other than Joe, and Jackson is a hell of a lot better at that than Marvin.

The big problem with this is that Marvin has consistently rebounded well this year and trading him for Jackson weakens an already weak area for the team. The solution to this, in my opinion, has to come from coaching. LD has to send Joe and maybe even Teague to crash the boards. At Joe’s size at his position he is fully capable of being an above average rebounder, and part of the reason for him not getting more boards is probably scheme related.

drmaryb.[*_*].

February 28th, 2012
5:02 pm

At this point, and for the love of basketball – just make a TRADE damnit!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I need someone new to pick apart … I’m so tired of beating these same old second round horses! LOL

Ra'mon

February 28th, 2012
5:07 pm

Najeh, the Hawks would still be over cap if they cut over $12 million from the books this season? Lol, that just prove how bad of a gm Sund is, lol.

Melvin

February 28th, 2012
5:09 pm

Najeh,

We are basically making the same trade except you have Erden coming back with Session instead of Hollins. I would prefer Erden but I thought the Cavs were high on him and he’s being paid less than a mil so I was sure if the Cavs were willing to deal him.

drmaryb.[*_*].

February 28th, 2012
5:11 pm

Wilson Chandler cleared by FIBA to return to the NBA. Lamar Odom has requested a buy out from Dallas, he is not happy there. We need some ballers man … We don’t need no more losers! I’m tired of bits and pieces being drug in here.

Where is the BEEF? And, don’t say The RED Restaurant either. LMBAO!!! Rondo, Pierce, Garnett? Come on do something splashy.

How many of yawl believe TMac might be packaged with Marvin? I sure hope not. It’s time for Drew to join the UE line. We need a great coach, man! Call Fratello, Larry Brown.

pointguardslim

February 28th, 2012
5:21 pm

did blog monster just eat my post

Najeh Davenpoop

February 28th, 2012
5:25 pm

“We are basically making the same trade except you have Erden coming back with Session instead of Hollins. I would prefer Erden but I thought the Cavs were high on him and he’s being paid less than a mil so I was sure if the Cavs were willing to deal him.”

Yeah, I was just combining your trade with the Jackson trade. I’d prefer Erden too.

And really, if the Hawks agree to take on Jackson, the Bucks are trying so hard to get rid of him that it’s not out of the question that they may throw in a pick. Maybe not a first rounder, but even a second rounder is a valuable asset. A second rounder would give the Hawks 3 second round picks, including two near the top of the second round, which may allow them to trade back into the late first round if they find someone they like.

pointguardslim

February 28th, 2012
5:26 pm

Al isn’t ever becoming a stretch 4 capable of hitting 3s btw. He’s been working on that for 2/3 years.

pointguardslim

February 28th, 2012
5:28 pm

#Hawks C Al Hoford out of sling. Could be cleared to start rehab Wed. Hopes to return this yr. “That’s my expectation.” How about this season?

KevinM

February 28th, 2012
5:28 pm

Najeh, if that was the best option, then yes, go get Jackson in place of Marvin.
If that will put Josh back in the paint, I am all for it.

This would be a major move in Sund’s eyes, and I’m not even sure he would go for it….

Najeh Davenpoop

February 28th, 2012
5:30 pm

“Al isn’t ever becoming a stretch 4 capable of hitting 3s btw. He’s been working on that for 2/3 years.”

Why not? If Ryan Anderson can be a stretch 4, why can’t Al be a stretch 4? Ryan Anderson isn’t any more athletically or height advantaged than Al.

Grandad

February 28th, 2012
5:39 pm

I remain steadfast.

I like Barbosa.

Therefore; a comparison of Teaguer to LB;
would represent a compliment in my eyes.

Michael Cunningham

February 28th, 2012
5:40 pm

new blog posted. shutting down this thread.