About the story

For those of you who turned in after the game ended, an interesting thing happened on the blog after I posted my first version of the story. Let’s just say that a handful of posts on the blog questioned my mental acuity and my fitness to cover the team, in large part because the story did not mention the shot-clock situation that happened with about two minutes left in the game. (I don’t think it’s up anymore, as it has been replaced by the later version.)

In the interest of transparency, and because you might find what we do on our end interesting, I hope I can explain what happened.

Basically, I missed it. Here’s why, and hopefully this comes across as an explanation and not me making excuses:

The first story that I posted has to be filed right as the game ends, or shortly thereafter, before I go to the locker room. It’s called the “running” game story. We write them and post them online immediately to give readers the news as quickly as possible before going to the locker room to get comment. It isn’t meant to be the paper’s final word on a game, but the first edition of the news. Generally speaking, I’ll file a second story, with quotes, which is ideally written with a little more perspective and thought, about 90 minutes after the game ends. That’s called the “write-through,” and it’s the version that goes in the paper (provided the game ends in time) and replaces the originally posted online story.

Given that it has to be written as the game is going on, the running game story is generally not the most insightful account of the game, at least when I write them. A lot of times, running game stories end up being a recitation of plays, but what I try to do (though not always successfully, as we’ve all learned) is provide some sort of picture of why the Hawks won or lost and what that means.

In a game like Wednesday’s, whether the Hawks win or lose isn’t known until the very end. So, Wednesday, I was piecing together a “Hawks win” story and a “Hawks lose” story as the game was finishing. In addition, I was trying to follow the action and take notes. And, the kicker, in this instance, was that I was seated a good distance away from the court with no television nearby for replays.

(This is an aside. Please skip if you’re not much for asides.) I don’t know if you’d call it an inefficiency or ironic, but, at least as I’ve found writing a game story on deadline, I often don’t get a complete picture of what is happening at the end of a close game – which is generally the most important part – because I’m trying to write, take notes and observe all at the same time. I think the best example of this that I can give you is a Tampa Bay-Indianapolis Monday night game I covered in 2003.

It started out perfectly for a writer trying to make deadline, as the Buccaneers took leads of 21-0, 28-7 and 35-14, and I started writing by halftime about how the game re-asserted Tampa Bay as the best defense in the NFL, having shut down mighty Indianapolis in Tony Dungy’s return to his former home.

However, Indianapolis chipped away and finally scored 21 points in the last four minutes to force overtime, where the Colts won on a field goal. As you can imagine, all my material about Tampa’s mighty defense didn’t make the final version.

I don’t want to say I have no idea what happened, but I can tell you I didn’t see much of this comeback, because I was having to write, re-write and re-write some more. I am quite sure my story did very little to capture the essence of the game.

(End of aside)

So, anyway, Wednesday, I flat-out missed what happened with the shot clock. When 6the Hawks called timeout and Mike Woodson argued the call, I was probably using that time to write. As I’d mentioned, there was no television near me so I could follow what was being highlighted on the broadcast and, to make matters worse, I wasn’t sitting next to any other writers who might have clued me in, either. The first I realized what had happened was in the post-game interviews. I am grateful for a lot of people helping me understand what happened.

I imagine if you’ve been to a game, you might have experienced something similar, where you come home, or listen to the radio in the car, and everyone who watched on TV is talking about, “Can you believe what happened?” and you have no idea what they’re talking about because you didn’t have all the replays of the botched play or blown call at your disposal from your seat in the stadium.

If you haven’t, maybe you should look into covering an NBA team. (ha ha)

So, that’s it. I sincerely hope this doesn’t sound like me asking for your sympathy, because that is not my intent, as I don’t warrant sympathy. I get to do something I enjoy (most days) for a living, a true blessing. And I also hope I don’t sound like I’m making excuses, because I don’t think I am. I’m trying to explain what happened.

I’m going to say a better deadline writer – someone who can more efficiently do the multi-tasking required for this particular task of our job – would have caught the malfunction. Hopefully the next time, I will.

Hope all this makes sense.

226 comments Add your comment

Jenious

December 31st, 2009
7:33 am

first again?

Jenious

December 31st, 2009
7:35 am

No problem Ken. You’re doing a great job.

Jenious

December 31st, 2009
7:51 am

I stated yesterday that the Hawks would lose this game because it was a big game on a big stage. Well, they lost. But I am proud of them.

There is no way that the Hawks could have won this game. The Cavs had 8 players on the court at all times (3 refs included) and one operating the clock. This game is an embarrassment to the NBA. I am not one for conspiracy theories but these refs should be investigated for payola. They obviously made EVERY attempt to insure that the Cavs won this game. Even though shoddy performances by refs have become the norm this year, this performance by the refs stands out as blatant intentional game fixing. Woodson should include in his protest a clause that these refs not be allowed to ref any more Hawks games.

If there were another decent B-ball league I would never watch another NBA game.

Malachi

December 31st, 2009
7:56 am

You ATL fans are a joke. Sure there was a shotclock malfunction, but how come no one on the Hawks team called timeout when they noticed it was off? If they saw the shotclock was messed up why didn’t your coach call a timeout and have them reset it? They only complained after Josh Smith was stripped of the ball and the Cavs won. Ya’ll are some sore losers.

octo

December 31st, 2009
8:02 am

Malachi – did you see the game? I doubt it,,when bibby saw the clock at 5 seconds, they tried to make a play.
To bad the donahahe lookalikes didn’t call it the same on both ends. If the NBA wants to regain credibility the last 2 minutes of this game MUST be replayed.

Afraid of that?

Dan

December 31st, 2009
8:06 am

Malachi,

Just stop it. I mean, really, just stop it. There is no bigger fraud team in this league than the Cavs. The Cavs are like Duke basketball, they live and die by what the officials will give them. Not only do they get the break with the shot clock, but have a 38-15 free throw advantage. That’s right, 38-15! In a game that physical and with so many drives to the bucket….38-15! Can’t wait to read your rationalization as to why that is ok.

I can’t decide which team I hate more, the Cavs or the Celtics. Don’t like the Cavs because they are a complete fraud. Take the officials away and they are 4th best team in the east, at best. Celtics are just the biggest collection of d-bags (not counting Ray Allen) that I have ever seen on the same team. It’s a tough call.

Here’s hoping we see the Cavs again in the playoffs, minus their 8 on 5 advantage (8 because I am counting the officials as members of their team). Would be nothing sweeter than sending that fraud of a team and their King home for the season.

Keep your heads up, everyone. The Hawks are still good and the sky is not falling.

Jenious

December 31st, 2009
8:08 am

Malachi – Last time I looked it was not the coaches OR the players job to insure that the clock is not being operated unfairly or incompetantly. It is “your” refs job.

Secondly, the shot clock debacle was the LEAST of the blatant cheating that went on in this game.

But I dont want to be a sore loser so let me wish the king a happy bday. I wont be giving him a gift because he already got tons of gifts from the officials.

Dashizz357

December 31st, 2009
8:17 am

The refs are all crooks….Hawks got robbed not only on the shot clock but there were alot of fouls not called….As Donahey said on 60 minutes there are refs out there that are bias to certain players & coaches…the Hawks, Josh Smith & Coach Woodson (like his mentor Larry Brown) are target’s… Wake up the officiating this year so far sucks….bottom line….half of those old @ss refs needs to retire….do they have a retirement plan?

GeeMack

December 31st, 2009
8:18 am

This loss is on the Hawks again. Shot clock malfunction or not, you still had almost 2 minutes to play. If the Hawks use that as an excuse it shows where the team is mentally. Meaning we are not ready for prime time basketball.

octo

December 31st, 2009
8:24 am

geemack – did you see the game? I doubt it, the teams were trading basket for basket when the cle shot clock mgmt and the donahaheslookalikes screwed the hawks at the most critical point of the game. How does any team grow like this? Oh unless your cle and you have 8 team members, is that how they are growing?

Sure hasn’t helped CLE in the playoffs, huh?

Jenious

December 31st, 2009
8:24 am

GeeMack – Of course you are correct. Any team that cannot overcome (in the last 2 minutes) 46 minutes of blatant cheating by ALL GAME OFFICIALS deserves to lose.

Fritz

December 31st, 2009
8:24 am

Ken,
Even if you missed the controversial shot clock episode, you still had to see the tremendous disparity in free throws, yet you didn’t comment on that. Not newsworthy that LeBron went to the free throw line more than the Hawk team in a hard fought game?

c-town fan

December 31st, 2009
8:37 am

Has anyone noticed that prior to the shot clock issue, Atlanta gave up a 17 point lead? I’m thinking the momentum was changing prior to the last two minutes of the game, about the time Cleveland became aggressive, offensively & defensively.
LeBron gets to the foul line because he drives more frequently than most. Watch a game without a dislike of LBJ or the Cavs and see who the games are called. It’s pretty much a wash when both teams attack the rim. The refs do not wear Laker blue when in LA, Celtic green in Boston or wine & gold in Cleveland.

Malachi

December 31st, 2009
8:38 am

You guys obviously don’t understand the game of basketball then. The reason the Cavs had more freethrows was because they were taking it to the rim ALOT more than the soft Hawks. Its called DRIVING to the hoop to create contact. Also, how many of those freethrows were hacks on SHAQ? You can cry and whine all you want, but the Hawks mental breakdown coupled with the Cavs great defense in the 4th quarter is what lost ATL this game. I mean you can’t blame this loss on the refs when your team blows a 17 point lead. If Josh Smith hadn’t been stripped on that possession when they had the shot clock malfunction ya’ll wouldn’t be whining now would you?

Jenious

December 31st, 2009
8:42 am

BULLCRAP!!! When the Hawks drove the ball they were HACKED and got no call. YOU watch the game without your head up the kings azz and maybe you will see it more clearly.

TFarr

December 31st, 2009
8:43 am

Good stat; JJ and Lebron both made 15 field goals, yet Lebron has 13 more points at the end of the game. JJ 2-2 free throws Lebron 14-16.

octo

December 31st, 2009
8:43 am

whiners? I think it is clear that CLE is the “king” of the whiners. I’m sure if the game had played out in reverse the LEAGUE would have already issued a replay game to made up when the cle based refs are avaialble.

Jenious

December 31st, 2009
8:44 am

And oh yeah…There was quite a momentum swing. The momentum was a result of the refs calls.

NC Braves Fan

December 31st, 2009
8:44 am

Ken – I missed the kerfuffle about the clock, and I didn’t get to see the game. Nice explanation of how things work – and I think you’ve done a great job the past several weeks.

Turning to Malachi, I think it’s a bit rich for a fan of the team with the player who won’t shake hands with an opponent after a loss to call anyone else “sore losers.” (Not to mention that nitwittery about the supressed video clip of the kid who dunked on LBJ over the summer.)

Some “king.” :lol:

Malachi

December 31st, 2009
8:47 am

TFarr

JJ had less points because he took so many damn jumpshots you idiot. Lebron drives to the rim which creates contact. Show me one video where he drove to the rim and didn’t get legitimately fouled… I know there were a few times were he drove to the rim was fouled and there was NO call.

Also, Octo…Josh Smith is the biggest damn whiner in the NBA

Ken Strickland

December 31st, 2009
8:48 am

MALACHI-Although I have no doubt about Lebron being an upstanding individual off the court, he’s an egotistical premadona on it. As a result, his ego is just too big to allow him to remain in Cleveland. Besides Lebron, your beloved team is comprised of a bunch of castoffs, 2nd raters and past their prime jocks.

I have no doubt the NBA would love to see him in a city that actually has both a pulse and an identity. Considering the way your fans were completely silenced while we were whipping Cavaliers butts, until the officials and clock operator bailed them out, you could have called your arena the city morgue.

Your boys had everything going for them last night. They were at home and coming off a solid win against us the night before. Yet, it took everything Lebron had, plus help from his friends in stripes and the local clock operator, to squeek out a win. YOU CAN BET ON ONE THING. AFTER WHAT WE SHOWED LAST NIGHT, AND WHAT IT TOOK FOR YOUR TEAM TO BEAT US, COME PLAYOFF TIME, WE’LL WHIP YOUR BELOVED CLEVELAND’S ECONOMICALLY DEPRESSED A$$.

Anthony

December 31st, 2009
8:49 am

Cavs are the better team. They showed a lot of heart coming back from being down 17 points. The Hawks offense folded for 2 nights in a row. They can only score against bad teams.

doc

December 31st, 2009
8:51 am

ken, not sure this needed to be a blog unto itself, could have been contained in last blog on one game essentially. a lot of broken continuity with three blogs now about the game.

games like this will make it easier to say no thanks to season tix come this spring.

yeah, cleveland folks it sounds like petty gripes but there were so many bad no calls that so many here saw it was shameful. stupid of you to come and try to defend it, that only makes it look like you agree it was indefensible and needed more shaded and jaded commentary. it was beyond belief and only emphasizes how shady nba bball is. sad but true. josh well set twice blown over by a mack truck no call shoot one was through two set players and i have never seen that before, williams grazes a player and gets called taking points away, v boy pushing off with both hands almost in what could have been a continuation and no call. so many it was unbelievable. anyway, enjoy, it maybe the last of the lebron years in 2010 because with everything else irrelevant in cleveland he is going to turn out the lights when he exits through the door to anything else cleveland might have. a dying industrial town and worse spots town than atlanta with the browns and indians and the bron brons. yeah, you guys are good front runners,crybabies when your efforts are disputed or when you lose.

ken, did you see any of these plays or were you that far out of the site lines? is it against policy for the beat reporter to not say the team he is watching and covering got jobbed? man where were you, nose bleed section? you need to go back and re-watch the game because it seemed in all your writing you missed it. it further betrays the integrity of your product as you try to explain it away. sorry, hard to accept it and it only makes it worse in my opinion. you would have been better off saying yes you missed it instead of saying you miss important parts of games as you write the summaries. i know you are a fill in doing a fairly credible job, leave it at that and just give it up to experience as we all make mistakes. no one is perfect including the guys so critical of you. report what you see or how you interpret things as that is what we are interested in; that is the reason we read it because we didnt see it or want someone else’s view point.

TFarr

December 31st, 2009
8:52 am

you either didnt watch the game or were not paying attention. Joe made a good number of floaters in the lane. Its just Joe usually ends up getting knocked to the floor with a no call while Lebron gets an and 1 on any driving shot he makes with someone near him. Josh is a big whiner but he had some legit beef on a lot the calls last night.

Lowenbrau

December 31st, 2009
8:53 am

Wow….I posted on this board last night and the Hawks fans seemed to be very classy. Now all most of them are doing is complaining about the refs. Why wouldn’t you complain about the fact that your team was up 17 points and blew it? Referees can’t turn around a 17-point game, even if they wanted to (which of course was not the case).

I don’t mean to criticize the Hawks, ’cause actually I’m very surprised at how well they played in the first half. I figured the Cavs would roll over them last night. But to call the Cavs frauds or to say they always have the refs on their side…..those are comments made by people who only watch a few Cavs games a year. We Cavs fans constantly see LeBron get hacked every time he goes to the basket. He gets a whistle maybe one out of every three times.

By the way, how about Anthony Parker’s circus behind-the-back shot late in the game? The foul there was so blatantly obvious, but the refs let that one go. Maybe in your perspective the refs didn’t see it because they were too busy daydreaming about the next opportunity to screw the Hawks over. (In reality, it was a game with playoff atmosphere and the refs were letting things go on both ends.)

As far as the shot-clock thing goes, look who’s talking. The Hawks’ scorers have messed up games on multiple occassions. Plus, it’s not as if this was a game-deciding play. Bibby or Smith should have noticed the problem, picked up the ball, and told the ref. The refs always make things right when they see the shot clock isn’t working. Atlanta would’ve gotten the ball side-out, and all would’ve been fine.

Woodson is grasping at straws on this one. It’s very simple….outplay the other team and you’ll win.

Malachi

December 31st, 2009
8:58 am

Yep. Its totally a conspiracy. I’m sure David Stern called the refs as soon as he seen the Cavs were down by 17 and said “They’re down by 17 boys do something about that”!

Man you ATL fans are seriously delusional.

Anthony

December 31st, 2009
8:59 am

Malachi… The fans are just trying to make an excuse because the Hawks choke against top flight teams. The Hawks are 2nd rate team with 2nd rate talent.

newkid

December 31st, 2009
9:03 am

When ‘the story’ becomes the story, we’ve lost our way.

I, and I’m sure I’m not alone, really appreciated Jason Collins’ contribution on the floor last night.

Hold your heads up guys, you played well. Keep evolving.

Malachi

December 31st, 2009
9:03 am

Anthony…I couldn’t agree more. I’ve watched that play with Bibby and Josh Smith several times and they didn’t seem rushed one bit. In fact, when Smith got stripped of the ball there was still several seconds on the shot clock.

ATL fans think they can hang with the big boys, but the Cavs just showed them they’re still nobodies. I hope the Cavs meet them in the playoffs so we can sweep them again and send em home crying.

Jenious

December 31st, 2009
9:04 am

@lowenbrau – You said ” Referees can’t turn around a 17-point game”. The refs can turn around ANY game they want to. They have ULTIMATE power and they know how to use it. And once again it is THE REFS JOB to insure that the shot clock operator is not CHEATING. But the refs just wanted to see the king have a happy bday. Mission accomplished.

You have absolutely NO CREDIBILITY if you wont admit that at the very least this was a HORRIBLY CALLED GAME, and more likely further evidence that the NBA instructs ite refs to manipulate the outcome of games.

Benjamin

December 31st, 2009
9:07 am

You need to watch that play again, Malachi, because the play didn’t get started until there were five seconds left on the clock. Bibby dumped to Smith, who looked up and went to the basket with three, at which point he was stripped.

Sure, the Hawks fell apart after that play, and credit to you guys for taking advantage of the situation and winning the game, but you’d be doing the exact same thing Hawks fans are doing this morning had the shoe been on the other foot.

And time will tell on how things wind up in the playoffs. We’re just starting to get good, and sometimes good teams go through things like this and come out on the other end a better team. Regardless, good luck the rest of the season and in keeping the Franchise around beyond the summer.

Mike is Back

December 31st, 2009
9:08 am

I want waste my time expressing my disdain for the officiating in that game…yeah the Hawks gave up a 17 point lead, BUT THEY WAS IN CONTROL OF THE GAME WITH THE LEAD…BEFORE THAT SHOT CLOCK VIOLATION…plus the replay SHOWED it was a foul on LBJ on that play when he scripted the ball from Josh.

The game is over with…I have moved on…great game by LBJ…TREMENDOUS EFFORT BY THE HAWKS. I hope the DISAPPOINTMENT of this loss…GALVANIZE this team and PUT A CHIP ON THEIR SHOULDERS for the remainder of the season. Then we can seek revenge in the playoff.

WOODY, I like the counter with Collins and going with big guards on MO Willian and JWest. Now ya coaching. Can we see more of that???????????????

GO HAWKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Benjamin

December 31st, 2009
9:09 am

I don’t think the “shot clock operator was cheating, “Jenious. It very well could’ve just been a user error.

Either way, we did blow a big lead in both games — that much is known. I’m not as mad about it as some Hawks fans seem to be this morning. It was a bad call on a night where we still should’ve won, but we’ll go through this experience and come out a better team down the line for it. (It will be interesting to see how the NBA rules on the protest, though.)

Ken Strickland

December 31st, 2009
9:11 am

One more thing. Since when did expecting professional quality officiating and clock management, and complaining about not receiving it, make the offended party a whiner or sore loser? You clowns come on these blogs and act like the inequities of last nights gm represents something we should expect when it comes to the Cavaliers and their employees. This sense of entitlement and arrogance you’re displaying is the very reason Lebron and his mates handled themselves so poorly and unprofessionally after they were embarrassed by Orlando. They simply couldn’t handle not being able to compete without the on court amenities they’ve become accustomed to receiving.

THE INCOMPETENCE WHICH LED TO THE EVENTS THAT DECIDED LAST NIGHTS GAME, AND YOUR INDIFFERENCE TO WHAT HAPPENED, IS REPRESENTATIVE OF THE LACK OF AWARENESS AND SENSE OF FAIRNESS THAT SEEMS TO BE PREVELENT AMONG YOU CAVALIER FANS.

Lowenbrau

December 31st, 2009
9:14 am

Jenious,

If the only way I can have credibility is to say that NBA refs are instructed to fix games, then I’ll be happy to not have any credibility.

A couple Hawks fans have it right on here. Don’t hang your heads, keep playing, keep pushing forward. You’ve got a good team this year, a team that I think can beat out Orlando for the Southeast division and the 3-seed. (In fact, I’m hoping they do.) These kinds of things happen, and if your team is in the right mental frame of mind, you’ll grow from it. If your team is in the wrong frame of mind, you’ll let it affect you and it’ll drag you down.

And hey, the Celtics lost last night…..that’s something everyone on this forum can be happy about.

Jenious

December 31st, 2009
9:15 am

Malachi- I dont know how often you visit this blog, but if you have been here much then you know that the fans here are EXTREMELY critical of the Hawks. If anything too critical. I myself predicted thgat the Hawks would lose this game because they would choke on the big stage. There is haedly ever any whining about the refs. This one is different. This one was so blatant that even the most critical of us must cry out at the obvious abuse by the officials. Like I said, the view is different from outside lebrons azz.

Anthony

December 31st, 2009
9:15 am

The hawks lost and Lebron won. That’s it.

Jenious

December 31st, 2009
9:19 am

Lowenbrau – Dont twist my words beerboy. I said that you have no credibility if you wont even admit that the game was HORRIBLY CALLED.

Benjamin

December 31st, 2009
9:20 am

Well said, Mike is Back. Couldn’t agree more.

Tough call. Tough crap. Great game by Lebron. Great game on the road by Atlanta. We’ll get ‘em next time…

Ken Strickland

December 31st, 2009
9:21 am

MIKE IS BACK-AMEN TO THAT! All most of us Hawk fans what to see from Woodson is consistency when it comes to doing the things that make us a better team. We’re frustrated and tired of seeing this team end up reverting back to the same crap that hasn’t worked and doesn’t make the team better. When we live by the jumpshot, we usually end up dying by it as well. We’ve got to come up with a more structured and imaginative OFF set that involves everyone when we are playing down the stretch.

WE JUST CAN’T SUCCESSFULLY AND CONSISTENTLY COMPETE AGAINST THE ELITE TEAMS, ESPECIALLY DURING THE FINAL MINS OF GMS, ALWAYS RESORTING TO ISO JOE AND RELYING ON LONG RANGE JUMPERS(WOODY BALL).

Benjamin

December 31st, 2009
9:22 am

Anthony/Malachi, what’s the real word among Cleveland fans as far as Lebron returning? Are you guys worried he’s going to New York or something along those lines next year, or are you pretty confident he’s going to return?

Malachi

December 31st, 2009
9:25 am

Hawks choked.

/end of story

Benjamin

December 31st, 2009
9:26 am

See previous question, Malachi.

Are you guys bringing Lebron back this offseason?

Malachi

December 31st, 2009
9:28 am

Benjamin

Most people in around CLE aren’t worried about it. The only thing we’re focusing on is winning our first chip.

LeBron’s not going anywhere, and thats about the only response opposing teams fans can come up with when their teams choke against CLE.

HawkATL

December 31st, 2009
9:31 am

Fellas – Im a Hawks fan so as to provide my bias.

Now, here is how I see it. First, the point that the Hawks were up by 17 and couldn’t hold on does suggest that the Cavs outplayed our boys down the stretch. And, that is where games are won and lost. The Cavs are a great fourth quarter team, a point that is hard to dispute. They are that way because of one great talent, a former great talent who takes up a lot of room which creates even more opportunities for the great talent, and a bunch of guys who understand their roles. Nothing wrong with that.

The Hawks are arguably among the best “nine deep” teams in the NBA and that will serve them well over time. This team has the potential to go deep in the playoffs and will if they continue to mature as a team in 2010. Don’t forget the win in Boston. They led, were challenged and game back and pulled it together. These Cleveland games – albeit disapointing – were great learning experiences for the team. Like him or not, Woodson has done exactly what he said he would do and he will get this team ready (as a 3 or 4 seed) for the games when they count. The fact the Hawks didn’t roll over after a tough loss in Atlanta should be encouraging.

Now, a comment about the officiating, coming from the perspective of someone who officiated at the high school and collegiant level for 10+ years. NBA officiating is as much about show as it is getting it right. While there are a number of very good NBA officials, there are also a number of average to downright sloppy officials who are more interested in being on the court with giants for ego’s sake than getting the call right. No doubt, NBA basketball is likely the most difficult sport of all to officiate because of the “compact” nature of the playing surface and the continually increasing size of the participants. Yet, the mechanics of officiating and the demeanor of officials should be consistent and it simply is not. We can argue all day about whether James, Garnett, Bryant etc. get the benefit of being stars (I beleive the answer is yes…largely because it is subconciouos human nature that the “stars” are better than others) but what cant be argued is that officials should have consistent control of the mechanics of the game and their own demeanor.

The shot clock issue was an official error. . .while you can say that Josh Smith, Mike Bibby or Mike Woodson should have done something that misses the point that the officials (and the table) blew it. And, while that wasnt the only thing that cost the Hawks the game, it created an artificial advantage for the Cavs.

Moreover, officials demeanor makes a big difference. Case in point during the Cavs game in Atlanta on Tuesday. Ref 51 (I believe that is Leroy Richardson) was clearly trying to get his 15 minutes of fame by chumming up with Labron in the Josh Smith battle to the point where it led to one of the most egotistical technicals of the season on Mike Woodson. Egos like that have no place on the court.

Officails should have one goal in mind – letting the outcome of the game be decided on the floor by the players. The clock issue and, especially, the Richardson T on Woodson are examples of errors and egos that interject officiating in the outcome formula for the game.

For the NBA game to be more pure and, candidly, more entertaining, offcial ego check should be Stern’s number one priority.

Two great games – the best team (especially in the fourth quarter) probably won. And, both teams should be proud of the back-to-back that may have produced some of the best basketball played in the league this season.

Just my opinion. Happy New Year, all!

doc

December 31st, 2009
9:33 am

this game is just a building block and leave it at that. good game, well played.

Benjamin

December 31st, 2009
9:34 am

Good call, Hawk. Agreed.

Lowenbrau

December 31st, 2009
9:43 am

Benjamin,

Most Cavs fans (I’m guessing 60-70%) think LeBron will stay. Almost everyone (probably 90+%) in the local media thinks he’ll stay. Me, I’m 50/50….I said three years ago that the only way we’d get him to stay is to win a championship. I felt last year was our best chance, and we epic failed against Orlando. In my view, it all comes down to this season.

As long as we get a championship — just ONE — I’ll be happy. Haven’t experienced one in my lifetime in any of the big three sports.

MsDee

December 31st, 2009
9:47 am

Granted, this game was offciated poorly, but there are 2 very important things the Hawks just should have known better to do..

1) If this was Kobe and the Lakers or even Doc and the Celtics, a time out would have immediated been granted once they noticed a shot-clock error. They would have done whatever it took to have the ref notice it as well b/c that was a very important possesion.

2) Josh Smith really needs to learn either how to talk to the refs, or learn to say nothing at all, esp in the 1st half of any game. I truly believe Josh costed us foul calls on them b/c he had most of the contact from the Cavs in the later part of the game.

So all in all, this should be more a learning experience than anything cause we will see the Cavs again and other great teams to come, just Josh learn to shut-up, and Hawks learn to observed and take care of every possesion!!

J.J.M.

December 31st, 2009
9:48 am

It was a very odd game. As I remembered Lebron had more free throws then the entire hawks team. I mean come on! Josh Smith drove the ball and got bump so many times. I think it’s because Josh is not a super star and has a bad attitude, so the refs didn’t care. As for the clock that really ruin the hawks flow in the game. They were up by one and was force to take a rush shot by Josh Smith which cant shoot jumpers that well. The rush shot lead Lebron to drive the ball and of course to get foul by like always. I will just say hawks should keep their heads up and lebron should thank the refs for the birthday gift.

darrell starks

December 31st, 2009
9:50 am

REFS GOT PAID WAY 2 GO LEAGUE OFFICIAL.
GO HAWKS!!!!!!!!

darrell starks

December 31st, 2009
9:51 am

HAWKS TOOK 15 FREE THROWS CAVS 38 WOW!!!!!!
GO HAWKS!!!!!!!!!

Benjamin

December 31st, 2009
9:53 am

If I were a Cavs fan, I’d probably be 50/50 myself, Lowen. You make very good points in your post.

I don’t know if you were around in the Browns/Broncos days of the 80s, but I actually suffered right there with you if you were. (I was a HUGE Browns fan when I was little, because of Kosar, Slaughter, Langhorne, etc.) Earnest Byner’s fumble was one of the most distressing moments of my childhood. lol

I know the city of Cleveland needs LBJ to return in terms of financial need. Sad as it is to say, he’s a lot of your local economy right now, and being in the business world, I can understand how valuable he is to you guys. I’d rather him stay there than go off to NYC to form a super-duo with Wade, Bosh, or some other player, to say the least….

darrell starks

December 31st, 2009
9:56 am

I WONDER IF TIM DONAGHY NO ANY OF THE REFS ESPECIALLY THE 1 WITH HIS HAIR SLICK BACK.
GO HAWKS!!!!!!!!

lacsho

December 31st, 2009
9:58 am

First and foremost I want to say I am very proud of this team. They played on helluva game last night. As me and my wife watched the game, it was painfully obvious the NBA had an agenda for Lebron’s b-day. It was utterly disgusting watching NBA TV, and listening to the commentator’s analysts of the game. It’s clear they didn’t watch the game, and they definitely didn’t have a clue. Thank you once again NBA for confirming all our so -called conspiracy theories.

Secondly, I think Woodson coached an excellent game, and the Collins substitution was big. Finally, we have Woody making good in game adjustments.

Lastly, the reporting on this game from all of the media sources was flat out horrible. If the shoe was on the other foot, the NBA and the media’s reporting would have been vastly different. As a long time Hawks fan, I’ve witnessed this for years. Wow, I’m on board to buy Tim Donaghy’s book; his statements no longer seem farfetched.

Happy New Years !!!!!

GeeMack

December 31st, 2009
10:00 am

To all my Hawks fans

We can blame the officals, Lebrons ego, Shaq etc….the bottom line is we lost a game in which we had a 17 point advantage. We had a nice 7 point lead in the 4th that we could not hold. This happened in Chicago as well. This loss was on the Hawks. We need to develope a killer instinct.

J.J.M.

December 31st, 2009
10:00 am

hmmm lets see if first take talks about it

Lowenbrau

December 31st, 2009
10:00 am

Benjamin,

Yeah, I experienced The Drive and The Fumble. I was 9 when The Drive happened…..that still remains the worst of all the Cleveland disappointments for me. The Fumble and last year’s Cavs are right behind it. Then you have Jose Mesa in Game 7 against the Marlins, Jordan’s “Shot” in ‘89, and on and on and on. I guess Atlanta is a pretty tortured sports city too, since besides the ‘95 Braves (which beat us….lol) I can’t recall a major title there in the last 30 or so years.

Well if the Cavs choke this year, I’ll be rooting for Atlanta over Boston or Orlando. I hate those two teams.

J.J.M.

December 31st, 2009
10:01 am

we lost a 17 point lead because the game was slowed down by cavs shooting more free throws then the hawks.

Lowenbrau

December 31st, 2009
10:02 am

As far as LeBron goes, the economics of the game are in Cleveland’s favor. They can offer him more money and more years in his contract. I don’t think the “big market” lure of New York really carries that much weight anymore. I mean, the guy is already the biggest star in the league playing in Cleveland. I’m not sure how much bigger he can get. Plus, the Knicks are garbage and he’d have to start all over with them. I figure if he goes anywhere it’d be to Miami to play with his buddy D-Wade.

willgolf4food

December 31st, 2009
10:04 am

17 point lead…Control of the game…Cavs should not have won this one, but the Hawks lost it more than the Cavs won. Can’t blame the refs on this lost after blowing 17 point lead…Cavs turn it up on the Hawks and they could not respond. After most games, we can always point to Refs blowing calls when our team loses…Overall it was a good NBA game…

Lowenbrau

December 31st, 2009
10:06 am

JJM: “we lost a 17 point lead because the game was slowed down by cavs shooting more free throws then the hawks.”

The Hawks offense became predictable down the stretch. When games get tighter, they tend to rely on a lot of one-on-one play — with Joe Johnson in particular. When you play that way against a Cleveland team that turns up its defense late in games, the Hawks become much easier to defend. It happened two nights in a row.

J.J.M.

December 31st, 2009
10:10 am

im just sayong from what i saw the hawks clearly kept trying to drive the ball but didnt get no foul calls….so as for coach woodson he probably thought well “thats not working lets go with the iso joe”

octo

December 31st, 2009
10:17 am

It is clear to me with all these comments, the Hawks were screwed and CLE is worried. Lots of rightful venom on the Hawks side, lots of BS from the real whiners in CLE.

JeJe

December 31st, 2009
10:18 am

FIRE MIKE WOODSON

ClevelandBob

December 31st, 2009
10:18 am

You Atlanta fans are a joke. How about you run out to your nearest store and get some cheese and crackers to go along with your WHINE!! You got your but kicked two nights in a row by a better team. Just like you got your but kicked in the playoffs last year. Get a better coach and better players and try again next year.

JeJe

December 31st, 2009
10:19 am

These next 3 games are a must-win. New York, Miami, and NJ

JeJe

December 31st, 2009
10:20 am

Cavs have a joke schedule ahead of them for January

octo

December 31st, 2009
10:25 am

Atl is no sports capital, although the BRaves won it all thanks to the mistake by the lake, have you ever won anything?

GeeMack

December 31st, 2009
10:31 am

JJM

The Cavs shot more FT because they took the ball to the hole. While the hawks settled for jumper just like the night before. Thats not officiating thats effort, the Cavs had more than us both nights.

ClevelandBob

December 31st, 2009
10:33 am

Come on Atlanta fans. Next time Lebron is in your house cheer MVP,MVP,MVP,MVP,MVP!! Maybe he will take pity on you losers and throw his headband into the stands after kicking your butt!

Big Mone

December 31st, 2009
10:35 am

Good break down of the behind the scenes to your articles Ken. We appreciate your candor and the fact that your final version did set the record straight. I think a lot of fans were steaming after a tough loss where there was at least one major error and the anger seemed to channeled towards you. Keep working hard Ken. Your efforts are appreciated.

Volman

December 31st, 2009
10:35 am

It’s funny to see any “Cleveland Fans” on here trying to justify anything from last night. Every NBA fan knows that the game was HANDED TO Cleveland last night. The foul calls, the no-calls for Cleveland, the shot clock..Everything.

That was a joke last night.

Volman

December 31st, 2009
10:37 am

Geemack, you’re an idiot. The Hawks drove to the lane on MANY possessions in the 4th quarter and got no-calls. You seriously don’t know what you’re talking about, dolt. Quit trying to justify the preferential treatment by the referees last night. I guess IGNORANCE is bliss.

Lowenbrau

December 31st, 2009
10:41 am

Volman,

You’re right, the Cavs did have it handed to them…..by the Hawks.

ClevelandBob

December 31st, 2009
10:44 am

When you have a team that can go 9 minutes without scoring a basket on the first night, blows a 17 point lead on the second night, I’d be pretty angry also. How do you guys even watch these losers?

Time

December 31st, 2009
10:44 am

ClevelandBob – you are a joke. The Cavs rival the Celtics for on court whining and just like the Celtics it pays dividends for them.

Anyone who actually watched the game last night, biased or not, has to come away thinking the fix was in. If it was just one thing, say just the massive difference in FT attempts, then I’d tend to not agree with with a “fix” theory. Now combine that with the fact that the Hawks were screwed with the shot clock and the fact that the refs were more than willing to go back and “fix” the clock for LeBron after the Smith goaltend at the end of the 3rd but turned a deaf ear to Woodson saying they didn’t know what he was talking about.

And all you Cavs fans running your mouths in here about Atlanta fans. I really can’t wait to see you guys cry Cleveland into a Katrina level flood when LeBron leaves for NY. Stern and his cronies will ensure that will happen. Just watch.

J.J.M.

December 31st, 2009
10:45 am

im guessing you didnt read what I said. Hakws drove the ball and had no CHOICE but to shhot jumpers. whats the point of driving the ball if the reds wont call fouls. Hawks basically drove the ball for no reason. anyways good luck the rest of the year.

Happy New Years everybody

J.J.M.

December 31st, 2009
10:45 am

RLP

December 31st, 2009
10:50 am

I was out of town and have not yet had an opportunity to see the tape of the game so I cannot comment on the refs or the shot clock. But from my perspective a regular season game played at a playoff level against one of the elite teams can have either a positive or negative effect on the psyche of the Hawks. Some of us have been claiming that the team is on the cusp of becoming one of those elite teams. It is now tine to find out where this team really stands based on their response to this adversity.

I agree with those who call Josh a whiner. But I also love his game BECAUSE any who watches how he plays can feel his passion for the game and his team. Now is the time for this team to stand up and show that they are capable of responding in a positive manner.

As far as the Cavs and their fans I think we should all remember how classless that team was when they lost to the Magic in last years playoffs. Some of their fans have been classy in their comments and some have not. The same can be said for our fans. Let’s try to show them how ATL fans respond – with class and dignity. To Cav fans your team was better last night.

Big Mone

December 31st, 2009
10:50 am

GeeMack

December 31st, 2009
10:31 am

JJM

The Cavs shot more FT because they took the ball to the hole. While the hawks settled for jumper just like the night before. Thats not officiating thats effort, the Cavs had more than us both nights.

===============================

GeeMack, I’m not sure if you watched the game but Atlanta took but Atlanta took 31 shots in the paint (9 in 4th alone) and Cleveland took 33 shoots in the paint (only 6 in 4th) so your theory about Cleveland driving so much more than Atlanta doesn’t hold water. Cleveland took only two more shots in the paint than Atlanta overall and in the decisive 4th quarter where Atlanta took more shots in the paint by a 3 shot margin Cleveland shot 8 more free throws than Atlanta (11-3 edge and one of Atlanta’s 3 was for a defensive 3-second call against Cleveland). So it doesn’t seem to me that Atlanta was settling for jumpers, but they were aggressively driving to the bucket but the refs did not see fit to make any calls. Of course on the other end, Cleveland was less aggressive and settled for more jump shots but somehow managed to shoot 8 more free throws than Atlanta. Go figure.

ken

December 31st, 2009
10:52 am

Bottom line. The NBA is a star driven league and it will continue to be that way because this is what the fans pay to see. Anyone who does not accept this truth will become fustrated to no end by NBA games. There are certain teams and certain players the league gives preferential treatment too because they bring in the big dollars and that’s the bottom line. At this point, the Hawks are not one of these teams and J Johnson is not one of those players. I have known this for many years which is why I don’t pay my hard earned money to go to NBA games. Its like the steroid scandal in baseball, everyone knew the players were using but it was kept inhouse. This is the key reason certain teams keep winning championships and others don’t. Its all about the players and teams that bring in the most money for the league. The NBA is a business first whether you want to believe it or not.

Astro Joe

December 31st, 2009
11:04 am

David Stern may choose to handle this differently given the Donaghy stories. Let’s face it, there is an “integrity cloud” that hangs over this year’s NBA season. The shot clock issue coupled with the free throw disparity may lead Stern to handle this differently. If not, the Hawks are still learning and progressing. We are no better than the 4th best team in our conference and that will be true with or without 1-2
more wins.

On a separate note, I wonder when (or if) the Hawks will begin to view the Cavs like they do the Heat and Celtics. I was disappointed that we did not seem to have that “anger” that we show when facing those other teams. It feels like we wanted to “test ourselves” against the Cavs but we want to beat the ish out of the Celtics and Heat. Maybe last night’s game will get us closer to having anger management issues with the Cavs.

CJA

December 31st, 2009
11:07 am

Hawk fans, you are starting to sound like Wizard fans. This is mental now.If you have any question why you lost this game tonight, or any of the last 8 you have dropped to Cleveland, you can look directly at the fourth quarter. This hawks team can not close out games. When the pressure is on, this team abandons it’s offense and reverts into 5 guys playing one on one. The ball stays on the same side of the court and it actually becomes easier to guard them. In the last 6 losses to Cleveland, Atlanta has scored over 20 point one time, that was garbage time in a blowout. 4 quarter in Cleveland is winning time, in Atlanta, it’s “oh sh*t here we go again time.” Winners find ways to pull out games even when they are not playing well. Losers try to find someone to blame when they lose. With that being said, the shot clock was not reset. I seen it happen at least three other times this season. Twice the refs didn’t catch it until the coaches/players pointed it out. The league will review it and I’m sure they will rule that Smith was stripped of the ball before a shot clock violation would have been called. As to your other grevence, in 6 of the last 8 games that the Hawks lost to Cleveland they when to the free throw line more than the Cavs did. This included a 19 to 26 disperity on Tuesday night, which if my memory serves me right was still a loss to Cleveland. In last nights game I think one play really illistrates why the Hawks WILL not beat Cleveland. Late in the fourth quarter of the game. Josh Smith gets the ball near the base line, He is wide open, the Cavs are out of position. Instead of driving the base line hard he settles for jump shot that everbody in Cleveland was hoping he would take and missed. In the NBA game, in the fourth quarter the calls always go to team that is pushing the action and no Atlanta, you who had a 14 point lead, will not get bailed out by the officials when you settle for jumps shots.

khao$

December 31st, 2009
11:09 am

Anybody who thinks Donaghy was lying is in denial like MLB fans were about Canseco. Call me a conspiricy theorist or whatever; I’ve seen crap like this go on in the NBA since Jordan was in the league…hence the Jordan rules. There is absolutely no accountability amongst the refs. Is it a hard job? Sure. That said fouls are fouls regardless of Mike Wilks commits them or Lebron James. Cleveland fans can yell “whiners” all they want. Doesn’t faze me a bit. I know what my eyes saw. If the Hawks lost because they took bad shots (ala the Orlando game) I can admit that. If they Hawks lost because they underestimated an opponent (see the Knicks loss) I can admit that. If the Hawks loss because a team was better than them that night (see the Denver loss), I can admit that. If the Hawks loss because the other team made plays at the end (the first Cleveland loss) I’ll grant you that. I’ll even grant that our very own Josh Smith whines on every call (even though he’s guilty most of the time). However, when we go to the paint 30 plus times, the refs turn the other way, blow the whistle if someone so much as breathes on Lebron James, and gives us a short clock WHILE WE HAVE THE LEAGUE AND THE GAME IS IN BALANCE, nah, I can’t go with that.

And for those who want to argue “the Hawks blew a 17 point lead”, get out of here. This is the NBA. Great teams make runs. The Hawks made a run to build the lead. The Cavs made a run to reduce the lead. If this were the Clippers, I’d go with that argument. The problem comes into play when both teams are playing well, all things equal, and the refs start giving calls to one team. That’s what happened last night. If I weren’t a Hawks fan, I’d say the same thing. The refs impacted the game and anybody saying something otherwise is in denial.

keith

December 31st, 2009
11:13 am

PLEASE MR SUND……TRADE MARVIN WILLIAMS NOW……..PLEASE?
At this stage of his professional basketball career, i can not quantify why he is a starter. Points, rebounds, blocked shots, defense, and intangibles, he gives us nothing! I will say that he shoots a pretty
high precentage from the free throw line, however, he hardly gets to the line enough to make a
difference. We cannot quantify his 7 milllion dollar salary. WE ARE IN A RECESSION.
I refuse to pay for NBA league pass if i must watch a number 2 pick, MARVIN WILLIAMS, not get it.

FRESH

December 31st, 2009
11:13 am

KEN, YOU’RE GOOD MAN…EVERYONE WAS JUST HEATED AFTER LAST NIGHTS “DEBACLE” AND YOU JUST GOT CAUGHT IN THE CROSS-FIRE.

CHRIS SHERIDAN OF ESPN POSTED A STORY ABOUT LAST NIGHT’S ISSUE:
http://espn.go.com/nba/dailydime/_/page/dime-091230/daily-dime

I GOTTA ADMIT, THE NBA KNOWS HOW TO CREATE CONTROVERSY. I CAN REALLY SINCE A HAWKS-CAVS RIVILRY COMING TO A COURT NEAR YOU SOON!!!

Lowenbrau

December 31st, 2009
11:17 am

Excellent post, CJA. Your words will get through to the few Hawks fans on this board who are being objective. The homers won’t see it because they won’t allow themselves to see it.

If the Hawks would have called a time out there, or even just let the shot clock run down, play would have been stopped and the refs could have been alerted to the error. Then the Hawks would’ve gotten the ball out on the side, and their timeout (if taken) would’ve likely been given back to them.

The truth is that the Hawks had plenty of opportunites to win before and after the shot clock issue. An unusual and out of the ordinary mistake? Yes. But not a game-clincher. Mike Bibby missed an open 3, Josh Smith missed open shots, Joe Johnson airballed a floater from 3 feet away…..like I said, plenty of opportunities for them, but they couldn’t execute.

FRESH

December 31st, 2009
11:20 am

WOW!!!!!

READ THIS:

There is an NBA procedure for instances such as this. A pool reporter is permitted to question the lead referee about a rule interpretation, and the referee is obligated to answer so long as it does not involve a judgment call, and the pool reporter is obligated to share the referee’s answer with all other media.

Pretty simple, no?

Well, lead referee Kenny Mauer would have none of it, relaying two words — “no comment” — when a Cavs public relations official informed him a pool reporter wished to question him about the play in question.

Mauer could have explained that he was acting within the rules as they are written, and that there is no recourse for going to a video review on a malfunction such as this.

“I think we should have won this game, and I think they know that, too,” Bibby said. “I was bringing the ball up, and that’s why I started to go because the clock was down. I didn’t know, it was the middle of the game, I thought it was kind of quick. You look at the shot clock, you see the shot clock down, and you play.”

Said Smith: “Malfunction? I thought one official was supposed to check the clock.”

This is the second time this month that a lead referee has refused to explain a critical rule interpretation — even though the league office has encouraged them (but not mandated them) to do so. A league spokesman said Mauer was within his rights to decline comment, and so all we have for an explanation this morning is the video of the play, the video of Woodson’s ire and the pending protest (which seems almost certain to be turned down).

bigdave

December 31st, 2009
11:21 am

Stro Joe…

i think they already have a little hate for the cavs… it started last year w/ all the talking in the closing minutes of the game 4 cav win. they kept it up tues night, and yesterday the Hawks came to play and you could tell. that game last night reminded me of a Bos/Atl home playoff game. its a shame though, b/c the cavs seem to have police protection. it will take that effort to beat the cavs. though we clearly can, you have to know what you’re up against.

FRESH

December 31st, 2009
11:22 am

Lowenbrau,

IT WAS CLEARLY A FACTOR!!!!! AGAIN READ BIBBY’S RESPONSE:

“I think we should have won this game, and I think they know that, too,” Bibby said. “I was bringing the ball up, and that’s why I started to go because the clock was down. I didn’t know, it was the middle of the game, I thought it was kind of quick. You look at the shot clock, you see the shot clock down, and you play.”

FRESH

December 31st, 2009
11:28 am

THE ENTIRE ARTICLE:

1. Hawks Livid After Shot-Clock Malfunction
By Chris Sheridan
ESPN.com
CLEVELAND — Sure was a happy birthday for LeBron James, eh, what with the 48 points and all?

And Anderson Varejao couldn’t have picked a better time to turn into a latter-day Oscar Schmidt, wouldn’t ya say?

Yep, those were the things the Cleveland Cavaliers, an assortment of rap stars and other major moguls were undoubtedly discussing over drinks in the wee hours of this morning as they attended James’ birthday party at a local nightspot. (Note of the night: All invitees were required to wear all black clothing.)

But what about the other side of the story?

What about all those Atlanta Hawks fans? They sure would like an explanation as to why their team was the victim of an egregious shot-clock malfunction that prompted coach Mike Woodson to announce that the Hawks would file an official protest with the league office over their 106-101 loss to Cleveland on Wednesday night.

Employing due diligence — one of commissioner David Stern’s favorite phrases, along with that absurdity he keeps repeating: “referee transparency” — I went to the referees’ locker room acting as a pool reporter, something I have done at least a half-dozen times in my career, to ask what the rule interpretation was on that particular play.

To review: Atlanta was ahead 99-98 when the Cavs missed a shot in the lane with about 16 seconds remaining on the shot clock. But the shot clock did not reset, and by the time point guard Mike Bibby dribbled upcourt and looked at the clock, it was ticking close to zero. Bibby passed the ball to Josh Smith in the lane, he had it stolen by LeBron James, and the Cavs came downcourt and scored for a 100-99 lead.

Woodson was apoplectic, arguing his case vociferously to the referees while also screaming angrily at the 24-second clock operator. But to no avail.

Atlanta tied the game with 41.5 seconds left when James goaltended a shot by Joe Johnson, but Varejao hit the first 3-pointer of his career with 17.2 seconds left, as the shot clock expired, to make it 104-101 (the shot was originally called a 2, but it was changed to a 3 during the ensuing timeout, which made Woodson even more livid since he appeared to be diagramming a 2-point play in the huddle to go for the tie).

Instead, Bibby had to try for the tie on a corner 3-pointer. He missed, the Cavs locked it up with two free throws, and the Hawks angrily stormed off the court — Woodson twice had to be turned back by his assistants and redirected toward the locker room — before cooling down enough to utter the following:

“I’m not going to comment on it at this time. We’re just going to file a protest, without a doubt let the league review it at the two-minute mark, and then see what they think.”

Did he see that as a game-changer?

“Well, we’ve got a one-point lead and with the ball going our way, and we’re rushing to get a shot because the clock is not in our favor? You figure it out.”

There is an NBA procedure for instances such as this. A pool reporter is permitted to question the lead referee about a rule interpretation, and the referee is obligated to answer so long as it does not involve a judgment call, and the pool reporter is obligated to share the referee’s answer with all other media.

Pretty simple, no?

Well, lead referee Kenny Mauer would have none of it, relaying two words — “no comment” — when a Cavs public relations official informed him a pool reporter wished to question him about the play in question.

Mauer could have explained that he was acting within the rules as they are written, and that there is no recourse for going to a video review on a malfunction such as this.

“I think we should have won this game, and I think they know that, too,” Bibby said. “I was bringing the ball up, and that’s why I started to go because the clock was down. I didn’t know, it was the middle of the game, I thought it was kind of quick. You look at the shot clock, you see the shot clock down, and you play.”

Said Smith: “Malfunction? I thought one official was supposed to check the clock.”

This is the second time this month that a lead referee has refused to explain a critical rule interpretation — even though the league office has encouraged them (but not mandated them) to do so. A league spokesman said Mauer was within his rights to decline comment, and so all we have for an explanation this morning is the video of the play, the video of Woodson’s ire and the pending protest (which seems almost certain to be turned down).

For fans of Atlanta, it doesn’t matter that the Hawks eclipsed 100 points for the first time in their last 16 games against Cleveland. It doesn’t matter that Atlanta’s string of being held below 85 points by Cleveland ended at five in a row. It doesn’t matter that Joe Johnson was superb, scoring 35 points on 15-for-25 shooting. It doesn’t matter that Jason Collins, of all people, actually had a three-possession sequence in which he took Shaquille O’Neal completely out of his game.

What matters is the L — and the fact that the Hawks didn’t have a fair chance to come away with a W in what they themselves described as a two-day litmus test of their strength in playing the Cavs on back-to-back nights.

“It was a great game. If you’re a fan or you were watching on TV, it was great. Both teams fought and didn’t want to give an inch, and it’s unfortunate it had to come down this way, but as an organization we have to do what’s right for our organization and our basketball team,” Woodson said. “It’s a shame it had to come down to that, and we’ll figure it out when the league reviews it.”

Have fun swallowing that along with your morning coffee, Hawks fans, while also remembering this: All those black-clad folks at LBJ’s birthday bash were feeling such good vibes, too, at your team’s expense. And just a guess (our invitation was apparently lost in the mail), but if the words “conspiracy theory” were uttered, the James Gang all had a big ole belly laugh over it.

Chris Sheridan covers the NBA for ESPN Insider.

SMDH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Lowenbrau

December 31st, 2009
11:29 am

Fresh,

Of course that’s what Bibby’s going to say. He could either be telling the truth or he could be saying the right thing to support his coach’s protest. Who knows. But a heady, experienced player like Bibby should have recognized the error.

And I didn’t say it wasn’t a factor…..I just don’t think it decided the game. Like I said…..the Hawks had many opportunities, before and after this “error”.

terrell barron

December 31st, 2009
11:30 am

We should have a game #83 this year. Tonights game should be made up. Did’nt we have one of those with Miami a couple of years ago?

rusty

December 31st, 2009
11:41 am

we just need to get rid of woody & iso joe johnson

Justin

December 31st, 2009
11:41 am

Ken,
Thanks for the explanation. It was more than I needed but I understand that otherrs don’t give you as much of the benefit of the doubt and might think you waffled after the game based upon their comments. I give you a mulligan on this one, but agree with others on the blog that your blog posts can be more opinionated than your game reports. People want to know what you thought about the free throw disparity among other things.
The game was well-played by the Hawks, a test of their mettle on the road after the train wreck that was the 4th quarterr of Tuesday night’s game. The comments about the Hawks needing to diversify their offense so as not to be predictable in crunch time are valid. That doesn’t unermine the fact that the Hawks had one of the best offensive nights of the season for a Cavs opponent. The shot clock violation didn’t decide the game, but it came at such a crucial point that it definitely did have an effect and the protest should receive real consideration.
For the Hawks players and staff, hopefully they will just be more motivated by this game instead of sulking and letting the Knicks show them up at home again.

rusty

December 31st, 2009
11:42 am

sick of them both, its not the right way to play basketball

Benjamin

December 31st, 2009
11:42 am

Just to be honest, I wouldn’t be that surprised if the league at least took a hard review of this game. Atlanta’s biggest mistake in all of it was that they lost focus after the play happened, but to be fair, I’m not sure a lot of teams wouldn’t have done the same.

Regardless, got to give it to Cleveland, as I said earlier. They saw what happened and took it home for a win. At least for the time being, it registers as an L on our stat sheet, with three games to go between now and our Boston-Orlando-Boston matchup (two of them on the road). We need to take care of business against the teams playing the meat in the sandwich of that schedule and put this stuff behind us….

Big Mone

December 31st, 2009
11:43 am

Lowenbrau,
Whether or not there were opportunities for the Hawks to win this game before or after the error is moot. What is relevant (at least according to the precedent set the league when granting Miami’s protest against Atlanta) is if the Hawks were placed at a “competitive disadvantage” (Stern’s wording) by an “grossly negligent” error on the part of the Cleveland Cavaliers timekeeper and when notified of the error they failed to remedy the situation. Whether or not the Hawks blew other chances is irrelevant.

FRESH

December 31st, 2009
11:50 am

HOLDUP!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

THIS IS GETTING TOO GOOD!!!!!!!!

SOMEBODY DO A QUICK SEARCH FAST!!!!!!!!!

SOMEBODY TELL ME IM TRIPPIN…

SOMEBODY TELL ME THAT THE LEAD OFFICIAL OF LAST NIGHT’S GAME “KENNY MAURER” IS NOT A CONVICTED FELON!?!?

MAN THIS IS CRAZY!!

Lowenbrau

December 31st, 2009
11:52 am

Big Mone,

I believe in that one specific instance, Atlanta may have been at a “competitive disadvantage”. But I don’t believe it prevented them from winning the game.

Boobie Gibson canned a 3 late in the game but they only gave him 2. (Replays showed it was a 3.) Anthony Parker basically gets intentionally fouled on his circus shot but no call was made. My point is that these types of officiating/scorers gaffes happen all the time in games and they affect both teams. But the team that executes better always wins. That’s what it boils down to.

Big Mone

December 31st, 2009
11:53 am

Not sure if he is a felon, but the official’s name is Ken Mauer or I guess Kenny

FRESH

December 31st, 2009
11:55 am

WOOWWW!!!!!!!!!!! THIS IS ON THE LEAD REFEREE OF LAST NIGHTS GAME:

“In 2000, Mauer was convicted of a felony, three counts of tax evasion, and one count of obstruction of justice for not reporting downgraded airline tickets as income to the Internal Revenue Service.”

SMDH!!!!!!!!!!!!!

NBA…YOU GOT TO DO BETTER.

Big Mone

December 31st, 2009
11:56 am

Link to story about his conviction ~~~> http://static.espn.go.com/nba/columns/hughes/1141856.html

Looks like this is tied to the airline ticket scandal a few years back with the refs.

TDawg69

December 31st, 2009
11:59 am

Yes, ATL fans have so much class, booing LBJ everytime he touches the ball! Wake up, Hawksfan. This type of “preferential treatment” has been around in the NBA for decades. Jordan got it, Magic got it, Bird got it, Kobe, Wade, Lebron, Howard all get it. It happens and you know it. The Hawks have a decent team, better than 80% of the league, however, they do need to learn how to close out games, AND how to overcome games like last night when the officials are not on your side. It is not impossible. If Lebron gets such favorable treatment from the refs, why have the Cavs not won anything yet? Because other teams (Orlando last year, for example) overcome these favorable calls by MAKING SHOTS and EXECUTING THEIR GAMEPLAN! The Hawks, and their coach, let it get in their heads, and they lost again.

Even after all the non-calls, AND the shot clock issue, it still came down to a 3 point shot by a player who has never hit one before. Once the Hawks learn how to keep their composure, these types of games will be wins. Until then, you will continue to lose to the elite teams.

Big Mone

December 31st, 2009
12:00 pm

Lowenbrau,
I will agree that there were opportunities for the Hawks to win the game after the error, but an error such as this goes beyond the traditional missed call. The initial error occurred by a member of the Cavs organization (timekeeper) and was subsequently ignored by the refs. There are clear parallels to what happened here and in Miami. As I said before, Atlanta could have won the game in spite of this error, but that fact does not mitigate the effect of the error on the game.

FRESH

December 31st, 2009
12:00 pm

Lowenbrau,

I PRESENT YOU WITH FACTS:

1. The lead official of this game is a convicted felon.

2. There was an egregious error during this game. Protests by coaches and players were ignored. Questions about the error by a pool reporter, Chris Sheridan, were ignored.

3. The Cavaliers had a +23 free throw attempted margin in this game.

4. The NBA itself has acknowledged publicly that they will “protect their stars.”
4a. Lebron James shot more free throws than the entire Hawks team.

5. Lebron James is a global icon. It is in the league’s financial interest to have him (and his team) do well.

bigdave

December 31st, 2009
12:02 pm

2 words of wisdom never trust anybody with a big mustache (see the old Ron Artest stache/Arthur Blank) or one that wears their hair slick back like that….

this excludes Hawks trainer Wally Blase when he rocks the do…

Karl

December 31st, 2009
12:05 pm

I don’t understand why you Hawks fans are surprised. This is after all the NBA, National ‘bron Association. I’m sure David Stern will deal out some severe punishment to those ref’s. They had the nerve to call a goal tending on their King. I also saw one of the Hawks breath really hard on him, a flagrant 1 foul should have been called. Face the facts, the commish wants the King vs Kobe finals this year. He won’t let what happened last year happen again. He can’t have the Queen sulk off the court after a loss in the conference finals again.

RealSquawk

December 31st, 2009
12:05 pm

The Hawks should have won this game despite the shot clock and the free throw disparity they were right there in the game with all that stuff happening in Cleveland and lost. They should have won despite all of the stuff that happened. And I hope they know that and are more worried about that fact than anything else.
That being said Lebron James took more free throws than the Hawks. During the comeback there was a good portion of the game where Lebron James drove the ball and got a foul call… stat check…WITH UNDER 8 MINUTES TO GO IN THE GAME THE 7:54 MARK SPECIFICALLY THE HAWKS ATTEMPTED TWO FREE THROWS FROM A FOUL. LEBRON JAMES ATTEMPTED 8 EIGHT 8 FREE THROWS THE CAVS ATTEMPTED 10 AS A WHOLE.

That’s a problem. If the NBA has not figured it out already a way not to increase your revenue is by highlighting a few teams and driving home a few superstars. Favoring Lebron and then having all these post about how HAppy he is on his Birthday with this performance only increases the amount of conspirators. I have tried hard to push it to the back of my mind, but outcomes like this push it to the forefront.

The Real Deal

December 31st, 2009
12:30 pm

I know that everybody is sick of Josh Smith complaining to the refs whenever he is called for a foul. My best guess estimate is that Josh complains about the fouls called on him at a rate of about 90% of the time. Well .. if Josh is at 90% then Labron must be around 98%. Labron not only complains about the fouls called against him, he is quick to play the crowd so they can help him work the refs. Once the whistle is blown and a foul is called on Labron, he frequently sprints down the court with a look on his face as if to say, “Can you believe they just called a foul on me without consulting with me first?” One thing we have to give Josh credit for is, he doesn’t show the players on the other teams the mistakes they make when they are called for traveling. Just like the other night when Jamal was called for traveling as he took that extra little hop to the basket. Labron showed Jamal why he was called traveling. What a gentleman and class-act! As a matter of fact, last night Labron demonstrated that same extra little hop to the basket but the refs dare not call traveling on the King (especially on his birthday). The more that I watch NBA games(like the last 2 games that I saw with the Hawks playing Cleveland), the more that I realize how much NBA games are like reality shows. People get into the reality shows because they want to believe so badly that none of it is scripted. It was obvious to anyone watching the Hawks game last night that Labron’s team would not lose that game on Labron’s 25th birthday. Hail to the King and his 48 points! Happy Birthday Labron! By the way .. the script calls for Labron to be the “next” Michael Jordan. Thank God Michael Jordan didn’t need a script.

Justin

December 31st, 2009
12:34 pm

For all of the talk about the Hawks not executing down the stretch, we should point out that Cleveland won because Andy Verajao hit his first career three as the shot clock expired. Every team in the NBA wants Andy Verajao taking a 3 as the shot clock expires. That’s a succesful defensive possession. To expect a 6′11 who has never hit a career 3 to hit one in that situation is optimism. It’s not what the Cavs wanted, it’s exactly what the Hawks would want. This time it went in. If he misses it, as he usually does, and the Hawks grab the rebound (a bigger if, but Verajao was on the perimeter, giving the Hawks a rebounding edge), the the Hawks hold for one last shot to win the game and if they miss it’s overtime. It’s really hard to score against a good defense when they know that you have to take a 3 to tie it. It’s a lot easier when you can settle for a two.

Benjamin

December 31st, 2009
12:36 pm

….and neither does Lebron, Real Deal. He is, like it or not, an amazing athlete.

(…and if you don’t think Jordan got calls, you’re either nuts, blind, or don’t know anything about basketball.)

Hawks73

December 31st, 2009
12:40 pm

I can’t understand how any reasonable unbiased fan can say that a 38 to 15 free throw attempts isn’t a disadvantage. How can any team play with that a stacked deck against them? It’s why I have trouble buying what the NBA is selling. It’s not about teams, it’s about marketing and how they can get their “superstars” as much of an advantage/exposure as possible. The Hawks are a very solid team, but they have no chance because they don’t have a “superstar” on our roster.

CDWoods

December 31st, 2009
12:45 pm

Where’s the sense of fair play? Maybe the Hawk bench should have pointed out the discrepancy the moment it happened, but it’s the job of the shot clock people to keep track of the time, and of their mistakes. The Hawks put out such a strong effort, they absolutely deserve the benefit of the doubt. I don’t like to see anything “handed” to anyone.

As far as the whole “Labron”/Jordan comment, two things: First of all if you can’t spell someone’s name correctly then maybe it’s time to stop the critical comments and finally achieve that 3rd grade education you’ve been thinking about. Second of all, if the misspelling is meant as an intentional slight, then you need to find your head, because LeBron doesn’t slight people (certainly not you).

It’s time to call this aggression out for what it is: jealousy. I’m sure that if the Hawks have the opportunity to sign LeBron sometime down the road, the fans wouldn’t slight him in the name of spite. This goes for any team and for any player. If the Cavs were to sign Dwight Howard, I wouldn’t go to every game to boo him off the court. So let’s all be a little more pragmatic with our language and a little more honest with ourselves.

Benjamin

December 31st, 2009
12:48 pm

I’ll agree with the Cavs fans — and some Hawks fans, as well — in regard to last night’s free throw disparity. Having watched the game, I didn’t see as much “bad refereeing” as some are alluding to. The clock situation aside, it was just a game where we didn’t do enough to win it down the stretch.

I also believe we need games like last night. I know that sounds silly, but teams often have to learn what it takes to win in those situations, and while some are viewing it as a disappointment we lost — which it is disappointing — I kind of like the trial by fire aspect of the past couple days. Besides, we’ve shown we can play with the Cavs. It’s not like they dominated either game, particularly last night, when we went into their place after shutting down late the night before and took them to the limit. I view it more as a stepping stone than anything…

We’ll see what tomorrow holds. The main thing is we’ve got to build on it and not have a letdown against the Knicks and co. between now and our Boston, Orlando, Boston trifecta next month.

MyView

December 31st, 2009
12:56 pm

Don’t worry about it Ken. Everybody’s got an opinion, but 90% probably could not do your job. They would just like to act as if they could.

As far as the blown call, anybody who does not think that taking a possesion away from the Hawks in the last minutes of a tight game is “game changing” is kidding themselves. Lets see what the NBA thinks. I’m willing to bet that which ever official was in charge of monotoring the shot clock in that game will probably be suspended. Also, I believe that given the circumstances, the NBA will make the two teams replay the last 1 1/2 mins. In any event, its funny how the fans of other teams always think that blatant missed calls should not be mentioned in the final discussion of a game, until it’s their team.

MyView

December 31st, 2009
1:03 pm

As far as the free throw discrepancy, people always say that the whistle is not unfair, the more aggressive team tends to get the calls. Well that no longer holds water with me because the Hawks were every bit the aggressor in the first half at least, and there was still a 20-7 free throw discrepancy then. In the last two seasons, I have “witnessed” LBJ getting treated like a “King” by the refs. Literally. Even I may start calling him King James.

maconga

December 31st, 2009
1:08 pm

I snet the following email to Stu Jackson today. It probably means nothinh but at least it made me feel better.

Dear Mr. Jackson

I am a XX year old white male and CPA that lives in Macon, GA (a demographic I suspect the NBA is happy to have). I have been an underground Hawks fan even when they went 13 & 69 five or so years ago. I have enjoyed watching their steady progress towards respectability and now hope they are close to being a top 5 team with an outside shot at reaching the Conference finals.

Having said that, such a task will be VERY difficult given the current state of affairs with the referees. I went to the Hawks vs Cavs game in ATL Tuesday night. There were a half dozen or so close plays that all went against the Hawks or were “no calls” against the Cavs. THEN last night in Cleveland the Hawks went to the free throw line 14 times vs the Cavs 38 times. There is an obvious slant towards Cleveland, Boston & the Lakers that is VERY frustrating for a fan of another team to deal with. The Cavs with Lebron are hard enough to beat in a fair fight, much less when the fight is not fair. Not to mention the Home Court shot clock malfunction in the last 2:30 minutes of the game in Cleveland. It just seems like 80% of the close calls went against the Hawks, not the Cavs.

I can go on and on about what is traveling for the rest of the league but not Kobe and Lebron. Anything you can do to level the laying field would be greatly appreciated.

Stu Jackson

December 31st, 2009
1:15 pm

Dear maconga,

Play better and the playing field will be leveled in your favor.

Sincerely,

Stu Jackson

Wabe

December 31st, 2009
1:21 pm

Driving to the hoop to create contact? To say the Cavs were physical and the Hawks weren’t when the Hawks were up double digits throughout the game doesn’t seem to mesh with me. I can buy into the fact that the more aggressive team gets the benefit of the whistle. But, how can people suggest the Hawks weren’t aggressive last night when they came out and outplayed Cleveland for 3 quarters?

The Hawks were up the entire game. They were UP 1 WITH THE BALL UNDER 2 MINS when the shot clock debacle took place. I can name a couple of bogus calls right off the top of my head right now.

1 – Bibby drives and hits a layup with plenty of contact – but no foul (watch highlights).
2 – Marvin Williams leaner in the middle of the paint at the start of the 4th quarter – they called an offensive foul – bogus.
3 – Lebron James “blocks” Smoove’s shot – go look at the replay and tell me how many times Smoove got hit upside his head – no call.
4 – Lebron James should’ve been called for an offensive foul in the paint. Smoove had his feet clearly set outside of the restricted area – Lebron still gets the whistle + bucket.

There were so many suspect calls, it wasn’t funny. Despite all of that, the Hawks managed to hold a double digit lead for most of this game. Sure, they lost. But 9 times out of 10, that Varaejo shot clanks and the Hawks are coming back down the floor with 17.2 seconds to break a tie game for the win. As said before, the Hawks played the Cavs tough enough to pull out a W. It’s not fair to completely put everything on the shotclock, because the fact still lies we blew some healthy leads. But, with that said, to deny that the officiating was something that the Hawks didn’t have to overcome is BS.

As hard as it is to put this one behind us, we’ve got to take care of business against our next 3 opponents. I believe we play the Knicks, at Miami, then the Nets. 3 W’s would be great, because that would take us into that Boston-Orlando-Boston stretch with some momentum.

Davis

December 31st, 2009
1:22 pm

By the way, how about Anthony Parker’s circus behind-the-back shot late in the game? The foul there was so blatantly obvious, but the refs let that one go. Maybe in your perspective the refs didn’t see it because they were too busy daydreaming about the next opportunity to screw the Hawks over. (In reality, it was a game with playoff atmosphere and the refs were letting things go on both ends

Like the clock?

RealSquawk

December 31st, 2009
1:27 pm

What’s Stu Jackson’s email?

SWAT Native

December 31st, 2009
1:34 pm

Ken,

Thanks for writing this. I’ve been wondering how an article on a game can be posted a few minutes after it ends. I tink you can see by the responses that people last night weren’t really mad at you but mad over the calls in the game. It’s also good to see that there are so many people passionate about the Hawks now, and I don’t think that was the case a couple of years ago.

This is why I like the online version of the AJC better than the print edition now. It’s real time and interactive. People didn’t like your story, you got immediate feedback from the readers, and you were able to respond within a few hours.

Back to the Hawks, I think these two games may be good for them in the long run. They’re still a very young team, and I think they’ll learn a lot from these two losses. I think we’re going to see a very exciting playoffs this year.

Mz. Hawkdafied

December 31st, 2009
1:35 pm

Enter your comments here

Mz. Hawkdafied

December 31st, 2009
1:39 pm

Dang this blog literally ate up my comment about 2 hrs ago. Is it safe to comment now?

Astro Joe

December 31st, 2009
1:52 pm

Hey Cleveland fans, go check out LeBron’s sneakers that are a tribute to the NY Knicks and y’all have a really nice day. And when there is a controversial play in Orlando, remember everything that was said today.

Astro Joe

December 31st, 2009
2:03 pm

When I look at the shot chart from last night, I find it hard to see how the Cavs were much more aggressive than the Hawks. I see a ton of shots in the lane (where presumably a more aggressive team would drive the ball). If anyone knows where we could find the “points in the paint” stat from last night, I’d be interested to know if that justifies the free throw atempt disparity.

http://scores.espn.go.com/nba/shotchart?gameId=291230005

Ufo wanna be

December 31st, 2009
2:10 pm

I think all the people of Cleveland Ohio and NBA refs love to ride Lebrons dick.

Sad but true, thats why Cleveland is a gay city and they will never win a tittle even if they have Lebron, just sad.

Volman

December 31st, 2009
2:16 pm

The “Cleveland fans” obviously are a little worried and know they pretty much got a game handed to them… That’s why they’re all on here.

They probably aren’t even from Cleveland or have any ties. They’re poor people in Atlanta that know no better than to cheer for a superstar who gets the treatment.

Get off your knees, bandwagon fans.

And to the ones who put Lebron in Kobe, D-Wade, or JORDAN’s shoes…. LEBRON HAS NOT WON A THING!!!!!!!

Cleveland will be irrelevant when LeBron is gone.

doc

December 31st, 2009
2:18 pm

Truth-Serum
December 31st, 2009
10:49 am

HAPPY NEW YEARS! HAWKS FANS!

truth, here is right back at you, been nice getting to know you and the newer folks that came to the table with the surge in interest in the hawks. nothing but respect though not agreement, heh heh. i feel safe you can take my disagreements, hopefully the respect as well.

i continue to admire the thoughts of my old band of merry men. AJ really glad to see your comments each and every day. offer still stands dude, you dont even have to sit with me.;-)

be safe all, stay awake, be conscious and especially stay away from the amateurs tonight.

Volman

December 31st, 2009
2:18 pm

Another thing…you moronic “Cleveland Fans” who claim that Candace Parker was fouled on that layup…Mike Bibby has a circus shot where he was knocked to the ground and made the layup with no foul… so shut up about that one play.

No matter how many excuses any of you dolts make, the Hawks got screwed over. That’s why you idiots are here trying to defend this whole situation. Quit being so ignorant.

MAD-DONNA

December 31st, 2009
2:27 pm

As pissed as I am about the blatant job of officiating last night, I feel that it was only 25% of the problem the Hawks had! Tell me what you think of this.

1. Woodson is not good at developing talent, e.g. Josh Smith and Marvin Williams!

2. The Hawks only run one set play; the alley oop from Bibby to Smith!

3. The Hawks have absolutely no killer instinct, which is needed to be an elite team! Whole team is
too nice!

4. Woodson will never on a consistent basis, go deeper than the 8th man!

5. At the end of the year, ISO Joe has got to go (along with Woodson)!

6. Bibby can’t defend a blind man in a wheelchair (defensive liability)!

7. The Hawks don’t have a floor general…that take charge guy, that won’t take no for an answer!
We have that in pick-up b-ball!

8. Marvin Williams…nuff said on that!

9. The Hawks are the worst, “good team” in the league!

10. Did I mention Marvin Williams?

doc

December 31st, 2009
2:32 pm

aj we had a significant number of points in the paint by the second quarter something like 28 or so when the cavs only give up 36 a game. the announcer brought that up as an interesting stat. i dont think the effort went south though we only scored ~40 in the second half. good points there. sometimes we dont make as many as we should once in there remembering a couple that joe took within 2 feet that he tried to float in rather than bank. one in particular he made more difficult by his patented maneuver and i cringed. look cavs use iso lebron so it is not unheard of to put it in someone’s hands, just need to get the calls. the cavs were down so they had to do something just call a foul for lebron. he certainly was above his avg on shots at the line is my guess as most stars avg 8-10max.

rather than our not going there or not scoring there was more a function of them playing better or the refs not calling it the same on both ends. i think it was the latter. my opinion. again too many examples of our guys getting trashed and them going scott free to comment otherwise, plenty of examples already given. if you want to say they are fixing games then i am fine with it. i wont say another word.

i dont see that much when we are on our court but i dont have time to check and see if there is any true home court advantage for our guys by a discrepancy of free throw shots. some folks state the thoughts as stats but dont have the ammo to back it up. thanks for your comments.

jerrywest

December 31st, 2009
3:04 pm

Cavs played defense like football players and Hawks played defense like soccer players. That’s how the refs set the rules. The Hawks almost won an unwinnable game.

Rod from College Park

December 31st, 2009
3:05 pm

The referees did have a major effect on the game last night, but as long as we keep trotting this starting lineup with a bum at the three this will be our fate. The Lebron calls are mothing new, it happened in the playoffs all last year against us and agianst Orlando. I don’t expect much more from the NBA. Remember the Jordan rules? I will post this for two of my biggest supporters who continue to throw darts at me anyway they can. These paost were after the first Cleveland game. Shout out to JeJe. Marvin sure can shut down Lebron. LOL.

Mychelfromatl
December 29th, 2009
10:33 pm
JUST GOT BACK FROM THE GAME….
FIRST AND FOREMOST..HATS OFF TO MARVIN WILLIAMS..WHAT HE DID MAY NOT SHOW UP IN THE STAT SHEET, BUT THIS DUDE PLAYED ONE OF THE BEST DEFENSIVE GAMES AGAINST LEBROM THAT I’VE SAW ANYBODY PLAY..NICE WORK MARVIN..AND FOR THOSE WHO WILL SOMEONE GO ALONG WITH THEIR MARVIN RANTS..GO HEAD BECAUSE IT WILL FALL ON DEAF EARS.

Ken Strickland
December 29th, 2009
10:52 pm
ROD FROM CP/SAMUEL-did you see that DEF gem Marvin put on Lebron? THAT’S WHY WE SAY HE’S ONE OF OUR TOP MAN TO MAN DEFENDERS. Lebron was unsuccessful whenever he tried to drive by him or post him up. He finally started passing the ball when Marvin was on him and attacked the basket only whenever Marvin was forced to switch off. Imagine how much worse this loss would have been without his shutdown DEF.

JeJe
December 29th, 2009
10:57 pm
Give me a break on Marvin’s defense. He is not a “great” defender. LeBron wasn’t even trying to score 90% of the time. He forced 2 shots in the 4th. Besides that, he was looking for teammates (10 assists). He knows he can go off on our team any time he wants. He had 6″5 skinny Jamal Crawford on him for 10 minutes for crying out loud.

Rod from College Park
December 29th, 2009
11:14 pm
Was at the game tonight and here are my thoughts…..
I will agree with some of you that Marvin had a good defensive game tonight but that’s not the point. I will say this to all of you who think that Marvin shut Lebron down. Lebron and a couple of his teammates were partying hard at 3am last night at a very infamous club in the A. I left at 3am and they were still going hard. . Lot’s of Patron and bottles of Champagne that I can’t afford anymore were still flowing at 3am. Lebron looked very sluggish and actually looked like he was trying to get his teamates involved as opposed to taking over the game. I would not get to excited about Marvin’s defense tonight as he will have to face Lebron tomorrow on his birthday in Cleveland, with a star studded party planned for tomorrow night. I have made this point for two years. If Joe is off, no one in our starting lineup can create their own shot. Lebron was checking Marvin and leaves him wide open in the corner and is free to roam and help out on Joe. We have to have someone else on the floor who is a scoring threat at the 3 to open the floor up. WE WILL NOT WIN IN THE PLAYOFFS BECAUSE OF DEFENSE. We will have to outscore the Boston’s, Cleveland’s and Orlando’s of the world. They are too big inside, and we can not match up with them in a half court game. Woodson will have to play Teague if Bibby can’t hit the wide open jump shot.

Rod from College Park
December 29th, 2009
11:19 pm
JeJe ,
“Give me a break on Marvin’s defense. He is not a “great” defender. LeBron wasn’t even trying to score 90% of the time. He forced 2 shots in the 4th. Besides that, he was looking for teammates (10 assists). He knows he can go off on our team any time he wants. He had 6″5 skinny Jamal Crawford on him for 10 minutes for crying out loud.”
I would have to agree JeJe. These clowns just can’t see the forest for the trees. Our problem in the playoffs last year was that we could not score. When the game slows down, that three position is vital, and we can never expect more than 12 points from a guy who is not guarded.
EXACTLY, Rod from CP.
We need Antwawn Jamison or Josh Howard at the 3 — players who put the ball in the basket. Marvin was actually trying to take LBJ off the dribble — LOL.

31 Marvin 4-5 0-1 0-0 1 6 7 1 1 1 1 2 -3 8

23 Lebron 15-23 4-6 14-16 3 7 10 6 2 2 3 3 +7 48

jerrywest

December 31st, 2009
3:11 pm

http://www.hoopdata.com/boxscore.aspx?id=291230005

Both teams had 38 shots from less than 10 feet.
Hawks had 15 and Cavs had 17 shots at the rim.
There was no significant aggressiveness difference subjectively or objectively. Data supports what your eyes had seen.

T-Mac is available

December 31st, 2009
3:14 pm

Rick, please go get Mr. McGrady from the rockets. PLLEASE!!!

T-Mac is available

December 31st, 2009
3:17 pm

Start Jason Collins and give Teague more Playing Time.

T-Mac is available

December 31st, 2009
3:18 pm

T-Mac= 13 points in under 30 seconds=BEAST

T-Mac is available

December 31st, 2009
3:20 pm

NOW RICK! RIGHT NOW DAMMIT! DO IT NOW!

Rick

December 31st, 2009
3:22 pm

Look, I’m not one to point fingers at the ref’s… seldom do because I’ve played the game at a high level and know even though ref’s miss calls and make bad calls the balance of the game still must be played and you just simply play harder… finish your play’s and keep the destiny out of the ref’s hand. But last nights game was not winnable for the hawks. They were playing against the Cav’s and an obviously bias group of ref’s caught up in the awe of “King James”. The Hawk’s were the agressor’s and leaders for most of the game and went to the hole as effectively as the Cav’s, but yet the Cav’s were sent to the stripe 38 times compared to the Hawks only 15 times. Go figure that one? If Joe Johnson’s nick name was “King James” he would have lived at the stripe and torched the Cav’s for 40 plus too. But Joe despite all the times he went to the hole and got hacked only gets to shoot 2 free throws, mean while King James gets sent to the stripe a whopping 16 times. Go figure that one out too? Now the shot clock controversy was significant. To me it show’s and illustrates just how deeply the ref’s were bias and caught up in Cav’s provada. You have 3 ref’s and a host of official folks at the clock and scorer’s table and know one see’s the shot clock error at such a crucial moment in the game. Come on give me a break? Every possesion is valuable in a close game down the stretch… don’t believe it, just look at the Hail Mary lucky shot Varijao made. It changed the game and practically sealed the victory for the Cav’s. That possestion should have been stopped then and the shot clock set at the correct time remaining before play resumed…. bottom line! Every possestion is crucial and the ref’s job is to make sure the game is played correctly. There is no greater time than close games like this one when they absolutely have to get it right down the stretch. It’s the only way we know who the true winner is. King Jame’s greatest birthday present did’nt come from his team mates as stated by Lebron. It came from the 3 ref’’s calling the game. Can’t say I’d call them the NBA’s finest.

Botham

December 31st, 2009
3:23 pm

We probably shouldn’t be complaining considering we did it to the Raptors THREE times.

jgsbirds

December 31st, 2009
3:52 pm

Cleveland Bob you are an idiot! The Hawks have a very talented team that is very close to your bunch from Cleveland minus the officials. I hate to blame any loss on the refs but last night was definitely the case. The Hawks drove to the whole a lot last night–especially Josh and Joe–and I don’t think Josh shot ft’s on any of his drives. As for JJ he goes to the goal a lot now-a-days probably more than he shoots from the perimeter. Still no free throws!

Take these two wins and be proud of them–Remember however the Hawks are getting real close, I mean real close to taking the Cavs’ spot in the East. Time and probably officiating will eventually tell–but don’t be surprised if this is the year it finally happens. We have a pretty good team and surely the refs can’t change the outcome of a 7-game series.

CJA

December 31st, 2009
4:07 pm

Hawk fan, make sure you copy some of these post. It might save you some time the next time you need to bring them out after the Hawk choke in the 4 quarter against a quality team that plays defence. You should probably be thanking the clock operator. If not for his error, you Hawks fans would have to explain why on back to back night you got your collective butts whipped in the forth quarter. Instead of protesting the shot clock maybe you should lobby to have games reduced to three quarters so that you can hang with the championship caliber teams.

CJA

December 31st, 2009
4:09 pm

Honestly, I think had there been another 10 seconds on the clock, the Hawks would have still come up with a BS shot.

BYC

December 31st, 2009
4:13 pm

Can’t wait for Cavs-Hawks in the playoffs… it’s gonna be heated

Rufus1

December 31st, 2009
4:32 pm

I WAS HAPPY

I was happy to see a team with pride play last night(Hawks).
I was happy to see the Hawks play suffocating DEFENSE.
I was happy to see them shut Delonte West DOWN.
I was happy to see JJ play like a superstar and take the ball to the rim.
I was to see the team maintain their composure after they lost the big lead.
I was happy to see Bibby be aggressive on the offense.
I was happy to see Woodson do something different buy playing Collins. I WAS HAPPY TO THAT IT ALL HAPPENED IN CLEVELAND…

I was not happy about the refs..BUT
IN THE PLAYOFFS THE WORLD WILL BE WATCHING.

MAD-DONNA

December 31st, 2009
4:53 pm

…and to all the idiots that claim the refs miss and make calls for both teams, please explain the 38 to 15 free-throw difference!

Keep it Real!

December 31st, 2009
4:59 pm

Poor Hawk Fan’s that was a very good game against Cleveland last night.
The must feel better about this game then the last game!

THe Hawks will do some damage in the play-offs as long as Woodie don’t blow it!

The Hawks need to push the ball up the court on every play. They also should press they are 10 deep. Use the bench Woodie, Use the bench!

Keep it Real!

December 31st, 2009
5:00 pm

@Madonna…. The Cavs went to the basket and the Hawks settled for Jump shots! Simply!

truly1

December 31st, 2009
5:03 pm

I wish the team would have brought that effort the night before. I told you guys we were not going to get any calls. WE GOT SCREWED i wonder if the officials we going to lebrons party

NUNNA YO BIZNEZZ

December 31st, 2009
5:03 pm

OK,SO WOODY DOES NOT WANT TEAGUE TO PLAY IN TIGHT GAMES AGAINST ELITE TEAMS(NOTICE I DIDN’T SAY,”OTHER ELITE TEAMS”),UNLESS WE ARE BLOWING THE OTHER TEAM OUT BECAUSE HE DOES NOT WANT TO LOSE THE GAME..

WELL,WE LOST THIS ONE AND THE ONE THE NIGHT BEFORE..

IS IT TIME FOR COACH WOODSON TO RE-EVALUATE HIS COACHING PHILOSOPHY WHEN IT COMES TO DEVELOPING HIS BENCH AND YOUNG PLAYERS??

OTHELLO HUNTER-BEEFED UP,PLAYED BETTER IN THE PRE-SEASON,AND LOOKED AS THOUGH HE MAY GET SOME MINUTES AT LEAST EVERY OTHER GAME..SO,NOW DO U THINK THAT ROOKIES THAT WE DRAFT WILL WANT TO PLAY HERE IN ATLANTA?
OTHELLO HAS TO BE ASKING HIMSELF,”SELF,WHY DID I EVEN COME BACK HERE TO WEAR A SUIT..I COULD HAVE DONE THIS S— AT HOME”..

RANDOLPH MORRIS-YES RANDMO GETS IN GAMES,BUT ONLY WHEN IT COMES TO IT BEING A BLOW OUT OR HORFORD,JOE SMITH AND ZSA ZSA ARE ALL IN FOUL TROUBLE..WELL,HE TRIMMED DOWN,SHOWED HE HAS SOME OFFENSIVE SKILLS,AND IS NOT BAD ON THE DEFENSIVE SIDE..BUT,YES,HE NEEDS TO BE MORE OF A BEAST ON THE BOARDS..BUT HE DID ALL OF THIS FOR WHAT??????
NADA..ALL THE LOSING WEIGHT,AND THINKING HE WAS GONNA GET THE CHANCE TO PLAY,IN AT LEAST EVERY OTHER GAME?? NOW,IF A PLAYER IS LAZY AND DOES NOT CARE TO GET IN THE GAME,THEN ATLANTA IS THE PLACE FOR HIM..I DON’T THINK THATS RANDMO..

AND LAST,JEFF TEAGUE-HE’S A ROOKIE WITH FULL OF POTENTIAL..WE SAW WHAT HE DID IN COLLEGE AND WHAT HE CAN DO WHEN HE STARTED IN PRE-SEASON,AND WE SAW THAT HE HAS SOME GROWING TO DO IN GAMES HE PLAYED THIS YEAR BUT HIS PRO’S FAR OUTWEIGH HIS CONS!!

AND WITH THE HISTORY OF YOUNG GUARD MINUTES PLAYED UNDER COACH WOODSON,EVEN IF WE WERE TO HAVE GOTTEN A CHRIS PAUL,AARON BROOKS,DERRON WILLIAMS OR EVEN A YOUNG MAGIC JOHNSON,DO U HONESTLY THINK THEY WOULD BE WHERE THEY ARE TODAY UNDER COACH WOODSON??
I DOUBT IT..BUT,I HAVING SAID ALL OF THAT,I WILL STAND BY OUR COACH TODAY IN HIS PROTEST OF THE SHOT CLOCK SO CALLED MALFUNCTION IN LAST NIGHTS GAME..

THAT GAME SHOULD BE REPLAYED,RIGHT FROM THAT MOMENT..AND I BELIEVE THAT THE NBA WILL SUPRISE US ALL,AND…………
NAW,NO THEY WON’T..THEY DON’T WANT TO UPSET THEIR POSTER BOY #2,LEBRON JAMES..WE’LL JUST HAVE TO GET OVER IT,MOVE ON,AND I HOPE THAT PUTS A NOW OR NEVER FIRE IN THIS TEAMS BUTT!!

GO HAWKS!!!!!!!!

NUNNA YO BIZNEZZ

December 31st, 2009
5:12 pm

RUFUS,AND THE REST OF U,WE ALL BETTER HOPE THAT THIS IS NOT AND WILL NOT BE A LET DOWN IN THE CONFIDENCE OF THIS TEAM..IF SO,WE’RE SCREWED COME FRIDAY,AND WE PLAY IN NEW YORK TOO??!!!

WE’RE ALREADY 0-2 FOR THE NEXT 10 GAME STRETCH,LETS JUST HOPE WE CAN MAKE AN,8 7 OR 6 GAME WIN STRETCH OUT OF THE NEXT 8..

BUT,IF THEY LOOK AT THIS GAME AND ARE 2ND GUESSING THEMSELVES THEN WE WON’T SEE THE PLAYOFFS..

I KNOW THAT THESE GUYS ARE PRO’S,BUT EVEN PRO’S CAN BECOME DOUBTERS…

Clyde

December 31st, 2009
5:32 pm

I’m gonna stop knocking the Hawks for a couple of weeks. They showed a lot of heart in Cleveland and I think they are another scorer and 3 offensive sets from challenging for a NBA championship.

doc

December 31st, 2009
5:34 pm

jerry, good info there, no bs there, just facts. yes, we were not as aggressive because we didnt lower our shoulders and run over folks.

as far a lebron, he avg 9 shots from the line this year and in his career. um high but he has the ball in his hands a lot. yup jj does as well only he only avg 4 a game this year and for his career. anyway lebron number of shots from the line has exceeded last nights only once this season. so he gets to the line seven more times than usual and they end up winning by five. ill take that out of the mix along with the 6 points they either gave them by not calling lebron on drives to the basket or the soft call on marvin to remove the 2 and we win going away. not good for the nba.

here it is for your perusal:

http://sports.yahoo.com/nba/players/3704/gamelog;_ylt=AmLM421KTZEHQH8gJ62UgZfJPKB4

doc

December 31st, 2009
5:37 pm

jbird yes the refs can. ask mark cuban who spent a lot of money to witness it from his court side seat. ask steve nash as well.

jlewis

December 31st, 2009
6:11 pm

Some of you guys scream about ISO Joe, tell me what team in this league where there best player is a guard or small forward where everytime down the floor is not an ISO? Cant say Lebron, D-Wade or Kobe, and before Kobe got Gasol and he wanted to leave the Lakers, that’s all they ran. If you don’t force a double team in the NBA, they don’t respect you and you are a losing team.

Jay

December 31st, 2009
6:47 pm

Here’s the real reason why the Hawks lost last night:

Bibby 1-3, a 3 point shot
Horford: 0-2 with 2 FTs
Josh Smith: 0-2
Crawford: 0-3
Williams, Pachulia, Evans, Joe Smith, Collins-no shots

While Joe Johnson shot 50% (5-10 with a FT)—and actually outscored LeBron James in the fourth quarter (11-10)—the rest of the team went 1 for 10 with 2 FTs; a total of 5 points for the entire quarter! No points scored over the last 6 minutes of the quarter! You can’t beat any team with scoring like that let alone one of the best teams in the league—in their building. And, if the team (aside from JJ) is only going to score 5 points, then the team must become extremely stingy on defense. You can’t give up 29 points and you definitely can’t let Anderson Varejao, of all people; outscore the entire team (aside from JJ) by 4 points!!

If you’re a Hawks fan, you have to love the effort given by the guys in both games but you also have to be concerned about the lack of offense late in games.

All of the other things that some are grumbling about (the referees, the shot clock, free throw disparity, etc.) are simply stumbling blocks that test the team’s resolve and maturity. When they can overcome those types of challenges to win the game is when they will have the mental toughness necessary to win a championship. Will that happen this year? Only time will tell.

Jody

December 31st, 2009
6:54 pm

After watching last nights game and then reading the Chris Sheridan article, how can anybody NOT question the integrity and credibility of the NBA and it’s officials?

And for those who complain about Josh Smith complaining to refs, I admit that he needs to learn to restrain himself(and he’s been doing a better job of it lately), the young man takes a BEATING every game and gets minimal to no calls. To restrain yourself while the blatant bias, incompetence and ignorance of certain officials is on display for the world to see is not an easy thing to do for anyone and especially when they’re the victim of it. So, give the young man some credit on the improvements he’s made with that thus far.

MAD-DONNA

December 31st, 2009
7:01 pm

Keep it Real! apparently you didn’t see the whole game!

Mz. Hawkdafied

December 31st, 2009
7:58 pm

NUNNA YO BIZNEZZ the Hawks play NY in the Highlight Factory tomorrow night umkay.

Samuel

December 31st, 2009
8:40 pm

Ken,

Don’t mind these guys. You’re doing a good job IMO. These guys are experts at everything except “their” own jobs. Evident by the amount of time they spend on this blog.

On last night game:

Yes, it was an unfortunate mistake by the officials. I believe the game should be replayed from that point on. If not. oh well, move on.

The rest of the BS is a non-issue to me. The officials didn’t win it for the Cavs. We had the game but couldn’t hold the lead. It happens. I’m proud of the guys, I thought they would get blown out. They showed that they are right there on the verge of cracking the Big 3.

All these scrubbs continue to go on and on about the NBA being a fraud but continue to watch and spend countless hours blogging about it. What does that say about them?

Keep up the good work.

Woody=COY

Truth-Serum

December 31st, 2009
9:12 pm

Samuel, Shout out. Yes great job hawks, early season measuring stick!

Happy New Years every one.

Shout out to Ken Strickland.

Truth-Serum

December 31st, 2009
9:13 pm

NUNNA YO BIZNEZZ I think the Hawks heard you but felt you were a lunatic and better off shout on Ken S. blog page….what do you do for a living? LOL

Samuel

December 31st, 2009
9:18 pm

Happy New Year Truth. The Truth will set You Free.

Mike

December 31st, 2009
9:20 pm

Ok, I’m from cleveland, and i understand how you Hawks fans feel, getting the shot clock accedent and having about, 20 less free throws. Now let me tell a little story. You guys got cheated, thats true, but you have to understand, this is not an all the time happening accurence, the cavs havent shot 30 sum free throws in a while. At home, unless they suck *cough nets cough*, the home team will get a majority off the calls. The fact it was lebrons birthday had something to dowith it. Also, big franchises like the Lakers and Celtics and Knicks get most of the calls wherever they are. Why? Because there is a large population of people in those cities. Thats why the lakers and celtics have the most overall rings. The NBA wants a lot of viewers because viewers = $, so the slightlly rigg the games insuring that they get big ratings. Another thing is how meny stars are on a team, which is why Shaq and Kobe won 3 championchips so quicklly, they were in a big franchise and they were popular players. It took longer for Shaq to win one with Wade because Miami is not as populated as LA. Michael Jordan was not as fortunate with the calls, but he was so good it didn’t matter. Thats my opinion, i probrablly drifted off topic there…

Blast

December 31st, 2009
9:40 pm

Did not see the game, but saw highlights, saw Hawks Sports Live, read recaps and all blogs tonite and it is so dreadfully obvious that Hawks were screwed by NBA refs again. This is not the first time, and it won’t be the last. I understand that the league has this Star treatment quality from the refs, but I don’t understand why the Hawks seems particularly targeted. Hawks have been getting robbed for years and years. I have complained about it so long that it’s nice to see bloggers finally rallying to the call. And anybody on this blog that cannot see that Hawks were screwed is either stupid, blind, deaf or a Clevaland fan.

I’m happy Hawks are filing a protest. If Stern wanna play right, then the last two minutes should be re-played.

I love the Hawks, But I hate the NBA. It’s why I really only watch Hawks game except if it’s a big match-up going on. Most NBA games are boring, I mean, Spurs are playing the Heats right now, Spurs up 28 and the game is so boring I’ll rather watch TNA Wrestling!

ESPN, NBATV, TNT are all dogs of the NBA. They do what the league orders them to do. If the leagues doesn’t want them talking about bad officating, then they are not going to. Bottom line. It’s all about the dollar!

Believe this. If the NBA and it’s refs keep screwing up like this in the face of the entire world, then they gonna lose credibility so fast, that gate ticket loses right now will be nothing compared to what is to come.

I didn’t see the game, but screw the NBA for screwing up the Hawks once again!

Samuel

December 31st, 2009
9:46 pm

There you go. A wrestling fan who happens to watch the Hawks. Nuff said.

jerrywest

December 31st, 2009
9:49 pm

After Stern let LeBron cheat on the Hawks like he let Kobe cheat against the Sacramento Kings, I had to get Donaghy’s book.

http://www.amazon.com/Personal-Foul-First-Person-Account-Scandal/dp/0615306039/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1262306551&sr=8-1

Samuel

December 31st, 2009
9:55 pm

Last year wasn’t all you conspiracy theorists saying the NBA was fixing the games to get Lebron and Kobe in the Finals. Somebody forgot hip Dwight and crew. So who’s gonna win this year?

let me give my theory:

Since the Chinese are taking over America anyways and they bought the Cavs, it’s a No-Brainer. The Cavs over the Lakers in 7 of course.

Samuel

December 31st, 2009
10:00 pm

NBATV and TNT are “dogs” of the NBA. Duuhhh!!

doc

December 31st, 2009
10:21 pm

samuel, the cavs fell apart worse than we did the last two games against orlando. they got real weak after getting overconfident with their display of “mastery” against a depleted hawks squad. yup seem tougher now but we will see if they can keep from reverting to their form, pierce two years ago and orlando last. remember how they were punking and going off on the sideline as they slopped it on the hawks and couldnt get off the court fast enough after being thoroughly hammered by the magic?

i still am surprised how you think we cant compete against the cavs. i think we are much better from 2 through 12 than they are, except their number one guy is a freak. can you imagine what that team would look like say if we did a quick switch of marvin for lebron? it would be downright silly as they would have no chance. two lapses by our guys, one five minutes and four minutes, the last two games are all that separates them now.

mental toughness and focus is what we need as much as new players to fill a very small void between the two. the abyss is not as great as some have wanted to say it is along with you. i hope your COY and the players are able to prove you wrong. in the mean time as truth said, and i agreed, they have to be ready to deliver a knockout blow just like the magic did if they are able to move bron bron out of the spot light. they have to begin to see nothing less than that will suffice and that is the message of being ruthless will have to come out of them.

we all wait to see how they react to this. if woody is as good as you say he is, and i am beginning to believe, he will have them ready.

boston is hurting now and are streaking down as they lose some of their old guys pierce and garnett. that is what i have waited for just hope they are not healthy until after we play them so we can make some room between us and them. i think boston is the one of the big three most at risk to fall behind us over the course of a season if they have injuries. they are also the one that can be most imposing if they hold they’re aging bodies together for this year.

Blast

December 31st, 2009
10:25 pm

I don’t reply to dumbass posts from folks masking as Hawks fans.

Samuel

December 31st, 2009
10:31 pm

Doc,

That’s a pretty big “if”. Marvin for Bron. I did say the divide was wide and I have since admitted on more than one occasion that we have closed the gap. But we are not there yet.

I have also said since day one that while Boston may still have the best squad, they are the team out of the big 3 that we could beat in the playoffs. I still don’t think we could be either the Magic or the Cavs in a series. We’ll see. I hope they prove me wrong too.

Woody=COY

doc

December 31st, 2009
10:56 pm

samuel, just an illustration, not an if, of what the “problem” is, not that we are lacking something inside or outside. i also thought you would “appreciate” it. ;-)

happy new year!

Big Ray

December 31st, 2009
11:26 pm

Samuel ,

Good posts.

Happy New Year, everybody….

Samuel

December 31st, 2009
11:39 pm

Happy New Year Ray, Doc, Joe, Clyde and Ando (wherever you are) and all the ole cats who’ve been around since this thing started. Happy New Year to you new cats too.

Here’s to 2010 being as prosperous as 2009 was for the Hawks.

You are all BOYs in my book. You too Ken S.

Samuel

December 31st, 2009
11:49 pm

Bloggers of the Year

Ken Strickland

December 31st, 2009
11:54 pm

There’s one very good thing that can be said about the Hawks after that can’t be said about the Cavaliers. THE HAWKS ARE GOING TO GAIN MORE EXPERIENCE, CONFIDENCE AND GET MUCH BETTER AS THE SEASON PROGRESSES, BUT THE CAVALIERS AREN’T GOING TO GET ANY BETTER THAN THEY ARE RIGHT NOW.

Keith

January 1st, 2010
9:32 am

The NBA is a joke! The officials and referees are into building stars like Lebron James vs. being fair. I guess this game is a great example of what Donaghy has been describing about the refereeing!

bigdave

January 1st, 2010
10:45 am

lol @ Javaris and Gilbert drawing down on each other in the locker room on Christmas Eve…

now thats gangsta… hahaha…. wonder what they bet on…

BBgenie

January 1st, 2010
10:53 am

Hawks fans be HAPPY! We found us a center J. Collins!!!! I know that the Ref”s stole the game but, WE KNOW We CAN PLAY & BEAT THE CAVS THIS YEAR!!!! The Hawks were Kicking the Cavs ASS on the ROAD!!! DAMM!! For this group it speaks volume. When we went to our BIG Line-up it WORKED!!
Cavs had no answer!! So let’s just try to get the HIGHEST SEED as POSSIBLE in the PLAYOFFS and get ready for the BIG PAY BACK!!!!!!!!!! In JUNE @ THE EASTERN CONFERENCE FINALS!!!! REMEMBER THE BULLS had to go to DETORIT and KICK the PISTONS ASS & take the PISTONS CROWN!! The Hawks will need to do the SAME to the CAVS!! WE MUST BEAT them by (5)pts or more, this way the margin in points is to wide for the REF’s to CONTROL at EOG!!!! HAWKS in 777777777!!!!!!!!!

JeJe

January 1st, 2010
10:58 am

“They just didn’t have a clue of what was going on,” Woodson said. “Between the officials and the scorer’s table, there was a problem. I’m not going to comment on what Kenny said, because that’s something that’s got to be relayed back to the league.”

Go Woody!

LOL what did Kenny say? “What are you talking about, Woody?”

BBgenie

January 1st, 2010
10:58 am

Enter your comments here

JeJe

January 1st, 2010
11:02 am

What types of charges can Arenas and Crittenton get for that issue? What idiots. These guys have millions (Arenas). How can Arenas pull gun first, or at all, in this situation?

We gotta take care of business tonight. Can’t wait to see what antics D’Antoni is up to

JeJe

January 1st, 2010
11:03 am

I don’t know if it’s possible, but we should really consider a S&T with Joe + Marvin, Chillz’ rights, and a pick or two, for LeBron or D.Wade this offseason. They both know we are a player away from the finals. Why would they pick any other team? Time to get ATL back to the top of the media market or closer to the top. Is a S&T possible if it includes other plays with the signed and traded player? We have the players to pull off a deal.

And I agree with K.Strickland that Cleveland has no room to grow. They are eternally !@#$ed when LBJ leaves, or stays, and they will not improve at all or grow because THEY HAVE NO YOUNG PLAYERS

Truth-Serum

January 1st, 2010
11:37 am

Ditto on the Cleveland has no upside and Atlanta has lots of growth potential and flexiblity. We are in a very good position to make moves and grow. Great point.

JeJe

January 1st, 2010
11:51 am

Thursday, Woodson said that the officials could have first realized the problem when Smith crossed the halfcourt line with about 12 seconds left on the shot clock, which normally would constitute an eight-second

Wtf does this even mean? Shot clock would be 16 if it was an 8 second violation. Why would it be 8 second violation at 12 if the clock started at 15? Makes no sense at all.

Gbaby

January 1st, 2010
12:11 pm

The NBA will not replay the last 1:57 of the game, it would set a dangerous president. Imagine if this happened in the first quarter, would you be bound to replay the last three quarters? I’m a Cavs fan and I want to win fair and square, but, Woodson should have ran out onto the court like a screaming maniac at the point he noticed the clock hadn’t reset.Larry Brown would have! We have seen coaches across the league do the similar thing and get their point across without being assessed a technical foul. Most of the time the refs huddle and get it right and I think they can use video proof of that. In my opinion the flow of the game was not interrupted, and we arrive to the end of the game. Fair? no. Every NBA game has human error involved that you can’t hit the rewind button on. This one is in the books.

Non conformist.

January 1st, 2010
12:11 pm

northcyde

January 1st, 2010
12:36 pm

I appreciate Mr. Sugiura’s rebuttal for why his original article was written the way it was, but it still doesn’t excuse the reaction from the Atlanta sportswriters about this controversy. The fact that you had to create a 3rd blog ( in 24 hours ) about the Cleveland game on Wednesday night, speaks volumes about how upset this fan base was on Wednesday night.

My beef is still with these Atlanta sportswriters. Mr. Schultz couldn’t wait to rip into the team, JJ, and Woody after the debacle on Tuesday night. And I won’t even fault him for doing so, because that team, ( mainly JJ ) did sink it up on Tuesday night in that 4th quarter.

But where is the same amount of opinionated writing and criticizm ( or praise for the Hawks ), when we go up to Cleveland, damn near lead wire to wire, but lose it at the end because of poor officiating, a shot clock “malfunction”, and a lucky azz 3 by Sideshow Bob, of all people?

Instead, what’s the headline we get?

ANOTHER 4TH QUARTER FLOP

And what about the performance of our captain on that night? He went toe to damn toe with Lebron, playing brilliant basketball and keeping us in the game when other people weren’t stepping up. He couldn’t get a damn call to save his life, but he kept playing.

Yet, nothing is said about that ish. No opinion on the Cleveland debacle I guess. Just fluff pieces on the Falcons and a good Georgia football win.

I always challenge the fans to stand behind their team unconditionally. Well, it’s time for you sportswriters in Atlanta to do the same damn thing. But then again, I wonder how many of the writers in Atlanta actually root for the Hawks, and not some other team. Just because you work for the paper and cover the team, may not necessarily mean that you’re also fans of the team. So I guess I may be askiing too much.

Anybody who watched that game, knew what the hell was up, even before the shot clock “malfunction”. I STILL thought the Hawks were going to somehow pull out that game. But it wasn’t meant to be I guess, considering all that we had to overcome in that game.

I just want you, and your fellow sportswriters to step your game up. This was DEFINITELY a time when you guys should’ve acted like a New York or Philly or a Chicago sportswriter.

Because if one of their teams would’ve had happen to them, what happened to us, they would STILL be raising holy hell about it.

But in the Atlanta media, it’s . . “oh well . . the Hawks shouldn’t have blown the lead.”

I gotta call BS on that.

For you guys that live in ATlanta, let me ask you guys a question. Is this a big topic on sports talk radio down there? If so, what are they talking about more . . . the fact that we blew a big lead . . or the fact that we literally got robbed in Cleveland?

Or are they even talking about it at all.

In the end, that may be the real problem. Outside of the die hard Hawks fans, people probably just don’t give a damn. And that’s probably the reason why Stern will look at Woody’s protest, and just disregard it like he’s just some crybaby coach.

Ken Strickland

January 1st, 2010
12:45 pm

KEITH-that’s exactly what I was going to say. After Smoove got that tech, he didn’t get another call in his favor for the rest of the gm, and there were some blatant fouls committed against him. The most obvious example of officiating bias was the actual play that led to Smoove’s technical foul.

After Lebron got to his spot in the lane, he knew he didn’t stand much chance of scoring with Smoove positioned directly in front of him. That’s when he lowered his shoulder and cleared Smoove out so he could get his shot off. If Lebron wasn’t going to be called for a charge, at worst it should have been a no call, but instead they called a foul on Smoove.

The entire episode wouldn’t have been necessary if the officials hadn’t overlooked Lebron obviously traveled on the play. He had to change pivot feet in order to make the extra move of dropping his shoulder to clear Smoove out and get his shot off. You could see that was what Woodson was complaining about on the sidelines.

We’ve all seen this crap before, and on all levels. Officials will go after a player, players or team that makes an issue of the officiating. Often the official(s)knows they either missed an obvious call or made a bad call, but the complaints get out of hand before they get a chance for a MAKE UP CALL. At this point they’re either embarrassed, angry, or both, and have usually lost control of the gm.

It’s often magnified when it involves officials that are already under investigation for irregularities, like these are.

doc

January 1st, 2010
12:46 pm

gbaby they didnt use the video when it happened because there are restrictions as to what they can use it for and that wasnt one of them according to a report on the incident, maybe it was ken s that reported it.

jeje if the clock didnt reset is the problem. we gotthe ball with 16 seconds left on the clock so essentaill we had one second to get it acrsoo the line. the “24″ second clock read 12 when we went across the line as we were working with a “16″ second clock. if we are passing the line with 12 seconds left on the clock which is what woody is arguing that the refs should have picked up on this so they made TWO HUGE mistakes within 4 seconds. the first was there is a ref to check the clock to make sure it resets; the second is they didnt see the “8 second” violation as it was occuring because the clock didnt reset.

got it? within 4 seconds the refs made two huge mistakes on things that should be rote to their memory banks. these things should be done with each play and is a responsibility of one of the refs on EVERY possession. AGAIN, HUGE ERRORS OF THE OFFICIALS. these guys should get huge reprimands as it displays a huge amount of incompetence. maybe throw in a stupid insolent remark by the the former jail bird mauer and there might be no other way for the nba to get out of it unless they replay. the integrity of the nba is at stake and a precedent set last year in the redo of the miami game. somebody will have to take the fall, if no penalties or suspensions to the refs or no do over you got to wonder about quality control of the game. bad product in my opinion and one i might not want to buy in the future. it is kind of like buying a lemon car, you either sell it or dont buy another one.

northcyde

January 1st, 2010
12:46 pm

From G Baby:

((( The NBA will not replay the last 1:57 of the game, it would set a dangerous president. Imagine if this happened in the first quarter, would you be bound to replay the last three quarters? I’m a Cavs fan and I want to win fair and square, but, Woodson should have ran out onto the court like a screaming maniac at the point he noticed the clock hadn’t reset.Larry Brown would have! We have seen coaches across the league do the similar thing and get their point across without being assessed a technical foul. Most of the time the refs huddle and get it right and I think they can use video proof of that. In my opinion the flow of the game was not interrupted, and we arrive to the end of the game. Fair? no. Every NBA game has human error involved that you can’t hit the rewind button on. This one is in the books.)))

OK sir . . . remember this post if they DO decide to replay this game. Don’t whine and cry like we’re so-called doing, if the decision is that the short shot clock DID affect the game.

You Cavs fans are trying to rationalize a bunch of BS in my opinion. This was NOT a mistake. This was purposely done. How in the hell do you forget to reset a shot clock, when the defending team gets a stop and is going the other way? Even if they reset it kind of late, it still should’ve been done.

Your’re right on one thing. If it happened in the 1st half of the game . . or even the first part of the 4th quarter of a game, this isn’t nearly a big deal.

But this happened with under 2 minutes to play . . in a one point game . . in which both teams were basically battling back and forth. Don’t come on here and try to say that they play had no affect on the game. OF COURSE IT DID.

Hawk fans know good and well what play we were running with under 2 minutes. And it wouldn’t have been a damn pick and roll with Mike Bibby and Josh Smith. Not when Joe Johnson had 33 points at the time, and had scored 14 of Atlanta’s last 21 damn points in that game. We were going to give the ball to Joe Johnson, and live and die by him, like we always do.

The pick and roll that Bibby and Smith ran, would be the equivalent of Mo Williams and Varejao running pick and roll in that same situation. No way in hell would the Cavs do that. The ball would be in Lebron’s hands.

So tell me this Gbaby . . . if the Hawks had scored on that possession, and gone up by 3 points with around 1:35 to go, what play do the Cavs run?

Ken Strickland

January 1st, 2010
1:01 pm

TRUTH SERUM- thanks for the shoutout. I want to wish everyone a very happen New Year. I have a feeling we’re all going to end up offering some complaints, but let’s hope it’s for different reasons. Let’s hope the Atlanta Hawks start the New Year off by giving the NY Knicks a good old fashion butt whipping.

doc

January 1st, 2010
1:18 pm

the wiz may be shopping caron butler, anyone interested in having him maybe to send them a good guy like marvin to help settle down their locker room.

man, the story about how things have deteriorated with the wiz is amazing a arenas seems to have taken on everyone. man now why did they give him the money after serious reconstructive surgery. does he get the t mac treatment soon? sad to say, j crit is in the middle of it.

Ken Strickland

January 1st, 2010
1:19 pm

One more thing. I hope everyone understands that for me, all of the attacks and postering is just plain fun for me, and is in no way an actually representation of how I actually feel.

Not so casual observer

January 1st, 2010
1:20 pm

The official working the offensive baseline is responsible for seeing the shot clock on all changes of possession – he simply looks at the clock on top of the backboard at the other end. This official is also responsible for making the “8 second” call if the ball is not in the front court when the shot clock is on 16. TWO MISTAKES by one official on one play.

The officials do not use instant replay on shot clock questions but they have the authority and responsibility to refer to the “running play” ( an account of every event and the time that event occurred) to correct shot clock discrepencies and this is done often during games. In this instance the running play would have indicated the Horford rebound, and the time, as a reference point for the shot clock.

There is a long history of the Hawks being jobbed by the officials. Atlanta had a 28 point lead entering the 4th of a game in the Omni with Milwaukee and a veteran lead official, Joe Gushue, working the game. The Bucks used full court pressure the entire 4th quarter yet there was not one foul called against them, not ONE.

In the 4th of the Cleveland game Josh Smith went down the left side of the lane unimpeded until Anderson Verajao came running from the right baseline and collided with Josh as he shot the layup – no call. Just one of several instances.

The NBA knows which officials are likely to favor the home team (the Homers) and which officials favor the stars (the Jock Sniffers). The NBA keeps very detailed statistics on the officials and their calls. The NBA knows which officials are weak and the NBA sent 2 sets of weak officials to the 2 Cleveland games. Further, the league sends instructions to the officials to look for certain plays and also indicating which players and coaches are complaining and about which calls.

You should not think there was anything at all arbitrary concerning the game assignments for the officials. The NBA desires an outcome not just for the Finals but during the season for which teams have the best opportunity to reach the Finals. This is not about sport but about entertainment and David Stern micromanages the league through his assistants and sychophants.

doc

January 1st, 2010
1:30 pm

now ken, how do you actually feel about me? heh heh ;-) you ole softy.

doc

January 1st, 2010
1:43 pm

not so casual thanks for your “official” sounding input. glad you are reading and welcome to comment further. you are just following up on what the thread has been. i for one am sick of it as it has ben a gripe of mine for years and it quite frankly might hinge my decision of whether to support the nba. yes, i know withdrawal affects the hawks in some small way, others may finally throw up their hands as wel to the lemon i spoke of earlier.

yes, as i sated and no one including the press has alluded to is that two huge infractions were made within 4 seconds by some individual official or members of the official team. someone will have to feel it to begin to think this product is nothing more than a wrestling organization run by macmahon.

it was shameless both nights but particularly when they had to cleave 17 points down to give the cavs a chance. sorry, that is what happened folks. if you read dohahey’s book he suggests it doesnt take much for an official to “move” points. he made a lot of money perfecting it and maybe learned from the league how to do it to his financial benefit. after all 17 points is just 8 to 9 possessions. that is something that occurs easily in three minutes; then the game is always “in reach” if you start soon enough.

Big Ray

January 1st, 2010
1:53 pm

I want to see us beat the brakes off the Knicks tonight. We lost to them, and shouldn’t have. Gotta get after them hard, and leave ‘em gasping for breath, and wondering what happened.

vava74

January 1st, 2010
1:57 pm

Big Ray,

I have a post which is getting blocked. Do you have any idea on what is happening?

Mz. Hawkdafied

January 1st, 2010
2:10 pm

Happy New Year Atlanta Hawks Nation!

Cleveland may have won the back to back. Guess what NOW THEY KNOW it ain’t gonna be easy to beat the ATL Hawks when the team is at full force. Dats fo’ sho’! translation: That’s for sure!

GO HAWKS, CONTINUE THE RISE, ONE GAME AT A TIME! LETS MOVE ON AND GET BACK IN THE WINS COLUMN!

vava74

January 1st, 2010
2:11 pm

A simple example of the effect of bad calls: Marvin’s 2pt basket + 1FT which was “converted” into a offensive foul at the beginning of the 4th Quarter:

We were UP 85-77. If the basket counted and the FT was converted, we would be 88-77.

11 points up to open the 4th quarter and the team would be ENERGIZED to face the next defensive possession.

Instead, we stayed at 85 and Lebron converted a jump shot on CLE’s next possession (85-79) – lead down to 6 points…

Then the Hawks had another TO, Gibson blocked Crawford’s shot and on the following possession Varejao had a reverse lay up: 85-81.

Lead down to 4 WITHIN 61 seconds after the blown call against us.

So get real people!!!!

Mz. Hawkdafied

January 1st, 2010
2:13 pm

GET BACK TO COLLECTING WINS STARTING WITH THE NY KNICKS I MEAN!

BBgenie

January 1st, 2010
2:19 pm

Hawks in 77777777!!

BBgenie

January 1st, 2010
2:30 pm

Hey MAD DONNA. Get Your head out of your ASS. Stop the Hate. I know the Hawks are not doing anything right in your eyes, But I guess “If your dont have Haters” your must not be doing anything Right..

BBgenie

January 1st, 2010
2:42 pm

Hey Fans, If you didn’t know it .You have Red Necks, Blacks Necks and Yellow Necks down here in the ATL.. They love Bobby Cox Dirty jock straps. They Hate any Black Head coaches in the sports world who Win!! AKA. Mike Woodson, Hawks. Paul Hewitt G. Tech. Its the truth! And the truth will set you FREE>>> Someone must expose the Truth of the matter.

terrell barron

January 1st, 2010
3:02 pm

Rod, how would you feel if we started Bibby/JJ/Smoove,Horford, and Collins, and brought ya boy Marvin off the bench with Crawdaddy? If Smoove can play the 3, we’d be a lot bigger inside. Thoughts?

JeJe

January 1st, 2010
3:15 pm

How can anyone watch the Jamal Crawford crossovers, highlights, and gamewinners on YouTube and not tihnk this guy is capable of what Joe is? We need to let Joe go this summer and start Crawford.

Better yet, start Crawford NOW, especially vs. the good teams

terrell barron

January 1st, 2010
3:21 pm

Start Crawford now? You’ve got to be kidding? Do you actually think Woody would even consider bringing JJ off the bench, when he wont do it to Marvin? Please! Too many bloody mary’s perhaps? lol!

terrell barron

January 1st, 2010
3:25 pm

Collins looks to be in basketball shape. Sorta. Glad to see we’re finally using him. And you guys dogged Sund for signing him. Looks like Sund knows what he’s doing. Thing is, how happy is Zaza with Collins in the mix? He was pissed when he lost his staring job to Big Al, so I know he was unhappy about being the 3rd center off the bench the other night.

newkid

January 1st, 2010
3:30 pm

Sounds like quite a mess in DC. Irrespective of the veracity of what’s been reported, could Javaris have ruined his NBA career before it even got started? Without standout talent, what GM would now consider adding him to the tail end of his roster at this juncture? Sans degree, European basketball may have just become his best hope at a modest living.

Flash, you out there? What gives?

JeJe

January 1st, 2010
3:32 pm

terrell, it’s called starting JJ and Crawford together, idiot. It’s obvious Jamal has a much easier time scoring the baskeball on fewer shots than Joe

doc

January 1st, 2010
3:53 pm

newkid, it is more if richbrave is out there to update this one. surprised he hasnt, as he knows i have casually followed j crit since he left tech. j crit might have done better to season himself before he left.yes, he may have less money now but maybe a better game and chance to break in somewhere. i thought he was better than acie but since neither have done jack in the league that isnt saying much one way or the other. hard to compare fertilizer by smell. man, the top 15 of that draft class looks pretty bad now.

Truth-Serum

January 1st, 2010
3:59 pm

Yeah, we owe em one Ken.- Happy New Year!

newkid

January 1st, 2010
4:26 pm

doc, having lived in DC for several years and followed the then Bullets, I’m a big fan of Mr. Polin and the positive things he tried to do. It’s a tragedy to have this sort of nonsense befall his organization knowing how he felt about his franchise fostering an imagine sans gun violence. With too many of these young cats (especially after the money is in the bank) it’s one step forward, followed by 20 steps backward.

Sounds like Javaris may have needed more time in the different (read that ‘better’) environment of Coach Hewitt’s not just to improve his game, but perhaps to give himself a firmer foundation from which to distance himself from childish behavior and the immaturity of some of those who were sure to surround him in the NBA. One must wonder what must have become of the ‘positive’ influences of his time at SACA with Dwight and others. Let’s hope he learns much from this incident and moves on to bigger and better things in life.

Blast

January 1st, 2010
4:35 pm

Happy New Year, Hawks fans!

doc

January 1st, 2010
6:09 pm

getting ready to rumble soon. heading down to see a thrashing of the knicks i hope. man i hope al harrington isnt around to stick it to bk again. ;-)

Grandad

January 1st, 2010
6:37 pm

To all HAWKS fans:

“The Book of Basketball” ‘Bill Simmons !!!

Someone on this board recommended this book earlier this season.
Whomever that person was, please let me know who you are.
You said you were going to send Joe [Johnson] a copy.
Anyway; Santa left me a copy for Christmas. I am not even 1/3 finished
as I am savoring every morsel.

Why am I telling eveyone this ?
Because, if you are a b-ball fan [lover] especially NBA, then you ‘Want/Need’ to read this book. I would imagine everyone on this blog qualifies.

To my good friend and full time nemesis T.S.: I promise, you will love this book.

Bubba Crew: Same

Larry, Moe, and Curly; ‘whichever ones of us that are not me’ I honestly think you will enjoy this read.

Marvin Haters: Maybe you will gain a new perspective.

To all my new friends on this board,
(I would love to name ea. individually)
but I’m sure to leave someone out.
Happy New Year to All !

FRESH

January 1st, 2010
7:10 pm

On my way down to Philips, hopefully the Hawks win by 80!!

KevinA

January 1st, 2010
7:25 pm

We need to go low – JJ and Jamal reduce us to standing around. I see a new guard in our future. Besides who can thay guard. Torched by quick pt guards on a regular basis.

terrell barron

January 1st, 2010
10:11 pm

Way to adjust to Robinson Woodrow. Lawd have mercy!

terrell barron

January 1st, 2010
10:12 pm

Woody making excuses as usual. Wow!

Malachi

January 2nd, 2010
8:02 am

Hahahahahaha Hawks are just plain garbage. First you make up excuses as to why you lose back to back games to CLE, and then you get torched by a midget for 40 points.

I ask you this ATL fans, how are you supposed to hang with the big boys when you can’t even beat the lowly Knicks.

Losers