
A makeshift cemetery to all the skills and classes sacrificed to testing at the Save Our Schools rally. (Amy Dees)
I didn’t get to attend the Save Our Schools rally in DC a few weeks ago, but Coweta school board member Amy Dees sent me a note that she attended. I asked her to share an account with us.
She sent this essay a while ago but the news events of the last three weeks have delayed its appearance. Amy Dees also gave me some of her photos to post here.
By Amy Dees
I have been an advocate of our public education system for years. I am a product of the public school system and all four of my children attend public school. My name is Amy Dees and I currently hold the District One Board of Education seat in Coweta County.
I became actively involved in public education when my oldest daughter started kindergarten in 2000. I was a room mom, school volunteer, PTO Officer, and later PTO President. I ran for my local school board because I saw a need for better communication between our classrooms and our board room. My goal is to bridge that gap.
I have been writing about education for years. I have written promotional material, PTO policies, and numerous articles on education, but I lacked the one element that Michelle Rhee obtained….Oprah. ( I am positive that no one has ever heard of me.)
I know many of you have heard of the movie “Waiting for Superman.” This is a film that smears our public educators and promotes the privatization of our public education system. Well, let me just say, congratulations, you no longer have to wait. He has arrived!
I honestly want to tell you that he has never actually been here and that your public schools are full of hero’s that fight for
your children’s education every day. They always have. I am talking about our educators.
I believe that everyone that interacts with your child at school on a daily basis is an educator. Bus drivers aka educator, custodians aka educator, cafeteria workers aka educator, teacher aka educator and here is the most important one of all…PARENT aka EDUCATOR. Parents need to stop blaming our educators and get up and get to work educating our children. In order to do that, we need to abolish AYP and put an end to standardized testing. You can wait around for superman or you can do something about it.
I chose to do something about it. I had the honor of meeting Diane Ravitch, education historian, at a conference in Savannah
this past June. She invited me to attend the “Save our Schools Rally” in Washington last month. A rally? To Save our Schools? Count me in. My 16-year-old daughter and I headed to DC. We arrived the morning of the march and my brother-in-law (who lives there) was kind enough to drop us off and go park the car. My daughter and I, along with my 17- year- old niece, jumped out and headed toward the lawn. We were standing in the shadow on the Washington Monument and I could feel my pulse soar. We are at a march…in Washington…to save our schools! ( I can cross that off my bucket list!)
The reality of the day made us all giddy. We made our way toward the stage weaving our way in and out of the crowd. I wanted to catch a glimpse of Diane and let her know that I had arrived. (Not that she really knew who I was, but it was important to me.) A few moments later, I did exactly that and she gave me a “thumbs-up” before making her way to the media tent. We walked around reading all of the posters that the protesters had created. One read :”No behinds get ahead!” Another read: “Teaching is an Art, not a business.”
The heat enveloped us like blanket so we took the free water offered by the organizers of the event and found a shady spot under a tree. Near our new found oasis, we saw the reporter from Reason.TV asking questions of the protesters. We saw the CNN cameraman trying not to trip as he walked backward trying to film the events. We saw a huge, over-sized poster of President Obama’s face marked with a Hitler mustache with the words “Impeach Obama” printed in bold print at the bottom. It was attached to a long pole so that it could be carried around. A few of Obama’s supporters tried their best to walk in front of the sign to hide its message from view. We noticed several teacher unions and watched several state groups march in matching shirts all heavily soaked with sweat. One of my favorite things at the march was the “No Child Left Behind” mock cemetery. Inside a make-shift fence were small, painted headstones that read “In loving memory of Critical Thinking” and “Here lies Art, PE and Music.”
I was here. I was making a difference or was I just sweating profusely? I do not agree with teacher unions and I was surrounded by several. I was hot. I debated fleeing to the air conditioning of the car. My temper flared along with my body heat as I listened to these union folks talk about their “rights.” My daughter summed it all up quite nicely. “What about the students?” I was grateful that no one near us had actually heard her say that, but I had to agree. We were here merely to lend a voice in helping abolish AYP. I don’t actually know a lot about the unions, but that is not why we were here.
We were here for the STUDENTS. We were here to be their voice. We rose to our feet and made our way to the front of the crowd and then I heard His voice. (Not HIS voice…I was hot, but not close to dying). The voice of . John Kuhn, the superintendent of Perrin-Whitt Consolidated Independent Schools from the great state of Texas. ( He was on the stage and he sounded a bit like a Southern Baptist preacher.)
He asked if our government had to answer to annual yearly progress. He asked if our government would have all of our citizens employed by the year 2014. (That is when all of our schools are to pass AYP with 100 percent). He talked about immigration and much to the delight of my daughter…he talked about STUDENTS. I do believe he is my new hero ( I am not waiting for you-know-who).
We went around to the media tent to shake his hand when we spotted the media frenzy that surrounded Matt Damon. Matt
was kind and was enduring the heat with the rest of us. He is a supporter of public education and for that I am grateful. His mother is an educator. I opted not to ask for an autograph or a photograph. I was a bit sweaty and didn’t feel that I should be getting up close and personal with the celebrity that came to support our cause. He respects education so I respected him.
I was able to shake the hand of the man that I now call “SUPERMAN!” John Kuhn was excited and very friendly. He thanked me for my involvement in education and I did the same to him. I mentioned that I was born in Texas and he smiled. I was more star-struck with this amazing educator than I had previously been with Matt Damon. ( Still a big fan, Mr. Damon.)
The day continued with the temperatures soaring near 100 degrees. I actually saw an old man sporting the hippie look holding a sign that read “Education NOT War!” I did not agree with the man, but that made my march on Washington DC complete. This lawn had seen many protesters through the years and now I could leave my own, sweaty footprints behind.
I was once told that we all make a difference, but we must ask ourselves what difference is it that we are going to make? I believe that our nation’s greatest natural resource is our children. I believe that it is our duty as parents to stand up and parent our children. I believe that super hero’s exist only in the comic strips, but if you want to witness a true, honest all-American hero, step into a classroom and watch a teacher. We need stop bashing America’s education system and get to the true root of the problem. TESTING. The federal government can change it. Will they?
I don’t know, but that is no excuse for us to sell our children to the highest bidder and give our public tax dollars over to private corporations and say, “Here, you try.”
The answer is simple. The answer is our parents. The most important person in any child’s education is their parent. Are all parents involved? No, that is why it is so important for those of us who can be involved to GET involved. Mentor a student if you don’t have one. Ordinary parents can become extra-ordinary leaders in our school system and we need you.
Don’t sit around waiting for “superman” because our nation can’t afford to wait. We are wasting valuable time that needs to be invested in our children now. Be the kryptonite in your school. Let your emerald green light shine through! You don’t need one hero. You are surrounded by many.
–From Maureen Downey, for the AJC Get Schooled blog
73 comments Add your comment
Once Again
August 31st, 2011
12:35 pm
A certain bit of unappreciated irony in having a headstone decrying the death of individuality at a public school rally especially since one of the clear goals of the modern public school movement appears to be to destroy individuality. Conformity, complacence, dumbing down, psychoactive drug control of individuals, etc. are all a part of today’s government school experience. Restore the parents and children to their proper place as consumers in the business exchange that education should be and maybe individuality can be restored. Continue with the socialist structure that underpins government education and that will never happen.
Observer
August 31st, 2011
12:37 pm
@ Good Mother. Just a reminder that the author of such an op-ed piece cannot hide behind anonymity. If you notice, nearly all of such pieces on “Get Schooled” come with pictures….and yes, I do believe that, given the racial demographics of metro Atlanta’s public schools, race can make a difference in perspective. If you doubt it, just go read all of the past blog-threads regarding the new DeKalb County School Superintendent! As to “credentials”…listing them will also help the readers understand the perspective of the writer.
To Observer from Good Mother
August 31st, 2011
2:20 pm
I don’t need your patronizing “reminder” that op/ed pieces cannot hide behind anonymity. I know what a by line is.
However, when you require a picture to validate an author, you are being out of line. That’s racisim. You do not judge a person’s thoughts by their race. By showing one’s race, one cannot help the readers understand the perspective of the writer because not all blacks are liberals. Not all whites are conservatives. Not all blacks are this way or that way.
Provide a by line. Certainly. No one would advocate otherwise. Credentials? Of course. But show your race? That’s just ignorant.
Observer
August 31st, 2011
2:29 pm
@ Good Mother. Why don’t YOU write such an op-ed piece in favor of standardized tests? No picture. Your credentials would be those you’ve noted on various blog-posts here: you’re the mother of 2 children still in our public school system, you’ve graduated from high school and gotten–was it 27?–on the ACT test, you now work in an employment agency and evaluate applications from APS graduates, and so on.
I don’t mean to be ironic or condescending when I note that you compose many posts on these blogs, and clearly enjoy writing. You seem to have a definite, consistent position on education.
Go for it!
www.honeyfern.org
August 31st, 2011
2:48 pm
@Good Mother, I appreciate you taking the time to lay out your ideas. I agree with many of them, and disagree on others. Have you considered writing the other side yourself?
Theresa
August 31st, 2011
10:20 pm
Good mother, I would respectfully suggest that you step into a public school classroom since you appear to have found the solution to al of our problems:
students who talk throughout instruction and argue when asked to stop; parents who cuss at teachers, parents whho cuss at administrators, parents who won’t allow their child to stay after school to make up missing classwork due to sports practice, little girls dressing and behaving like streetwalkers with their parents’ blessing, students who fill a water bottle with vodka, students distributing prescription drugs to classmates, insufficient funds budgeted to ensure every student has a textbook, shortage of soap and toilet paper, children who are hungry because there was no food at home all weekend, teenagers up all night babysitting the little ones while mom is othewise occuppied, the hold of gangs on kids who find approval and acceptance nowhere else… need I continue?
To Theresa from Good Mother
September 1st, 2011
11:00 am
Theresa, I step into a classroom every day. Although I work full time, I am a room mother. I don’t get paid when i am at the school. I’m also at every principal’s meeting, every PTA meeting. EVERY meeting.
I am not rich. I make huge sacrifices to give up my earnings in order to participate in my child’s edcuation. Just this morning I handed the teachers two gift cards to buy more supplies…while I eat a pbj sandwich and a boiled egg and water so that i can afford to do so.
Regarding the string of comments where you describe terrible behavior. I don’t see it. If you are a teacher, why would you put up with a student talking while you are talking? You don’t allow it. As far as a parent cussing out the teacher, call the cops. Grow a spine.
I get the shortage of toilet paper and soap — bring your own. I am constantly supplying the teacher with every personal item and more you mentioned including buying her red pens and items for her personal use. No one buys my expensive hardware and software required for my job. It’s my expense.
I have the gangs and the thugs in my neighborhood with teh $4500 taxes. Jsut last week a prostitute and her drug addict dealer showed up on my doorstep wanting a handout and I got out my baseball bat. Life ain’t easy living in Atlanta.
The other things you mentioned…sports practice — take it up with the principal, then the board, then write the State Superintendent as I already have.
What I don’t hear from you, though, is any admission that teachers and schools are at fault. If students are dressed like streetwalkers the SCHOOL should not allow it. If alchohol is at the school the SCHOOL should suspend and expel the student.
If the boys are missing classwork to go to sports practice, the SCHOOL is at fault because they allow it.
And many APS teachers, not all, but MANY are ignorant. Many cannot write a coherent sentence and wouldn’t know a singular verb if it kissed them in the mouth.
“Your lunch box (go) here. He (need) to sharpen his pencil. Everyone (have) to turn in their homework.”
Shudder.
The teacher NEEDS an education.
To Honey from Good Mother
September 1st, 2011
11:09 am
No, I wouln’t be a guest columnist because I would have to identify myself and that would spell retribution for my children who are both at APS.
Observer
September 1st, 2011
11:12 am
@ Good Mother. I’m not a K-12 teacher, but I’ve been reading many comments on these “Get Schooled” blogs from them; and over and over they say that the administration in their schools does not back them up on discipline problems. What should teachers do then?
(They probably yearn to give corporal enforcement to the offending students, but would get fired very quickly.)
Again, as I suggested above, why don’t you write an op-ed essay to Maureen summarizing your position, which other parents seem to share? AJC states that such essays should be no more than 600 words long. You might hit a chord among your fellow bloggers.
Observer
September 1st, 2011
11:16 am
@ Good Mother. Yes, I have since thought of problems if you do identify yourself. This would of course be up to Maureen. But if you do identify yourself to her only, perhaps she could make your column anonymous for the powerful reason that you fear retribution to your children.
In a curious way, this reminds me strongly of the reasons some of the APS teachers feared being whistleblowers on the widespread cheating……..
To Observer
September 1st, 2011
11:27 am
RE: “In a curious way, this reminds me strongly of the reasons some of the APS teachers feared being whistleblowers on the widespread cheating……..”
I see your point. Some honest teachers feared retribution for blowing the whistle on the cheating, lying thug teachers and adminsitrators.
I’ve had to stand up for my principles and I have lost employment because of it. I refused to lie and bill my customer for more work than I actually did. They gave me a demotion and I left and got another job.
If a teacher is good and they blow a whistle, they can find employment elsewhere. They shouldn’t fear losing work.
We need integrity in our schools. We need teachers to be honest and we need to allow teachers to be honest by hiring honest administrators.
The more I read about APS the more I am convinced that we need to divide APS into several smaller districts with much smaller salaries for overhead employees such as the superintendents.
If a superintendent had only one high school or perhaps two high schools she or he could not hide behind the lie of “I didn’t know about the cheating.”
With a much smaller budget in a smaller district there will be fewer opportunities to rob it and less of an incentive.
With smaller districts we would not have to put up with a superintendent gettting the job simply by her sorority membership and her race.
I’m tired of the same old song that black kids cant’ learn. Of course they can learn but they need to be taught by some black teachers who can write and speak English.
Tonya C.
September 1st, 2011
12:01 pm
@To Observer:
Incorrect. If you are non-renewed in one school district fro ANY reason, it is near impossible to find a position in any other district in the state of GA. A few have had luck, but most do not. That is why the situation in APS became so widespread. And if a teacher chooses to walk out on the school, the district can have his/her license revoked for non-completion of contract. Just an FYI. I now support competition in education for this reason alone. Teachers are not much better than indentured servants in a great many ways, with contracts written that give them no leverage and a licensing commission that leaves them little recourse.
Observer
September 1st, 2011
12:06 pm
@ Good Mother, 11:27 am. “If a teacher is good and they blow a whistle, they can find employment elsewhere.”
Not true, usually! Haven’t you heard about all the teacher layoffs throughout the metro Atlanta area?
Scroll down to the bottom here and click on “older posts.” These past blog topics might interest you.
Aug. 3, 2011: “When Teachers send home notes riddled with errors, should parents worry?”
July 24, 2011: “Any jobs out there for teachers? Who is hiring?” Some bleak entries in this one, of first-hand experience.
Observer
September 1st, 2011
1:02 pm
@ Good Mother. One other similarity between your (justifiable) fear of retribution for your children if you write a truthful op-ed piece and the APS teachers fearing to whistle-blow the cheating: many teachers said they were supporting families. I think you both feel that you personally can stand any retaliation, but will not risk involving your innocent children in it.
To Observer from Good Mother
September 1st, 2011
1:42 pm
A good teacher can find employment in another district. Many of we working professionals drive an hour or more to get to work. To hear many teachers on a previous blog, there is a mecca of opportunity (pun intended) in Dubai for teachers. Great benefits, high salaries and lots of respect for teachers, so they say. I wouldn’t give up my freedom of speech and freedom of religion for those benefits but apparently others are.
No one has to stay in the teaching profession either. If you can think and speak and write, you can get a job. It may not be the job you want but, hey, the one I am in isn’t either. It pays the bills. I don’t complain.
I’ll check out the other blogs, thanks !
Tonya C.
September 1st, 2011
3:15 pm
Good Mother:
NO THEY CAN NOT. You MUST have a reference from your former administrator to get a job. A good one. Anything less will jam a teacher up quicker than a wreck on 285 at rush hour. I have personally seen teachers of the year, standouts of the educational field, shunned like lepers. Retribution is alive and well if you are a teacher that wants to fight the tide.
Do you want good teachers or those that will shut up and collect the check? I being honest here. I wouldn’t teach for a million dollars a year due to what I saw from the inside (I’ve worked in the central office of a greater Atlanta school system). Those that can and do it well really get my respect.
To Tonya C.
September 1st, 2011
3:28 pm
Any educated, intelligent individual can get a job in the United States of America.
If a teacher cannot get a job she or he isn’t trying hard enough, doesn’t have the skills to look for a job or doesn’t have a real education.
I work with an intelligent, educated former high school teacher. I am not in the education field. Educated teachers can get jobs outside of teaching.
Lying about cheating, participating in the cheating or being complicit in the cheating is all the same.
If teachers stood up and refused to cheat or be complicit we would not have an issue here. If all the teachers had gone to the media and the police and told them they were asked to cheat, there would be no cheating.
We need honest people in government and that includes teachers. There is no excuse for the cheating. ALL of us have a fear of losing our jobs in this rotten economy but there is no excuse for lying and cheating. NONE.
Judge Not That Ye Be Not Judged
September 1st, 2011
5:34 pm
@ Good Mother above at 3:28 pm. I hope that you will read the entry in the blog “No Child Left Behind” by “Guilty APS Teacher and PROUD OF IT!,” September 1st, 2011, 5:01 pm. You probably will foam at the mouth; and when you come to, begin to self-righteously preach to us all as you do with every blog entry.
But remember the Atlanta Job Fair you described at length a week ago or so, as you ranted against the “whiny brats of teachers” who have a job. It sounds like “Guilty APS Teacher” does.
And you might Google the ancient Greek word “hubris,” if you don’t already know it….the person with hubris does not come to a good end.
Ghostwriter
September 1st, 2011
6:48 pm
Raise your hand if you think Good Mother is a blithering idiot.
To Judge NOt That Ye Be...from GM
September 2nd, 2011
9:46 am
Oh please. Hubris? Me? You’re funny. Thanks for the laugh this a.m.
It’s the “Guilty APS Teacher and PROUD of it” who has hubris…and you’re right. That guilty teacher who is PROUD of it will likely NOT come to a good end. In that, you are absolutely correct….and i can’t wait for judgement day when that guilty teacher and all other 178 of those caught cheating will have their careers ended, fines paid and are sitting inside a jail cell wondering was it worth it all.
Colonel Jack
September 2nd, 2011
3:09 pm
@Good Mother – I read with interest your comment that “a good teacher can find employment with another district.” You should know that a good teacher with 20+ years of service and a Specialist degree (i.e., me) most certainly can’t do that. You see, a school system could employ three newly-minted teachers for what they would have to pay me, with my experience and degree. I’ve applied to counties all over the area … only to be told by one superintendent that they simply can’t afford me.
To Colonel Jack from GM
September 5th, 2011
5:55 pm
Then work for less. I do. I took a 50% paycut. HALF. It’s a huge adjustment but I don’t whine about it. I just do with less and thank God I have a job. Government employees are just now feeling a tiny bit of what we in the private sector have been experiencing for ten years or more.
Colonel Jack
September 5th, 2011
9:16 pm
@Good Mother: “Then work for less.” Gee, why didn’t I think of that? It must be wonderful to be you.