Players Championship has haggles that won’t go away

PONTE VEDRA BEACH, Fla. — This is a golf tournament, The Players Championship, that has more angles than a Hercule Poirot movie. One year it’s the wind. Another year it’s the rain and the wind, and another year it’s the hard greens, or the rough. But since the powers of the PGA Tour have been able to switch the dates from soggy March to glistening May, happiness has taken hold. No more over-seeded greens, no more mud balls, which Tiger Woods deplored. “We caught mud balls all the time [in March],” he said, drawing from his memory bank.

But, just like the fleas on a dog and gnats in the summer South, two nagging haggles aren’t going away. The Players will never become a fifth major, no matter how gracefully it ages. One of the leading world-class players, Geoff Ogilvy, from Australia — and probably the best player not American — referred to it in a news conference the other day as “the best tournament in the world, not a major,” and never blushed. Nor did it set off a raging debate. The world turned on, and the Kingdom of Finchem never flinched.

The other nagging matter, the 17th hole, a hole with no fairway, is either the major attraction, or the major reason this TPC Sawgrass course would never be considered for major status. It’s more of a gimmick than a golf hole. It belongs at the county fair, where you tee it up and if you hit your ball inside the circle, you win a fuzzy doll, or a Ferris wheel ride.

Oh, it’s exciting stuff. That’s where all the gang gathers, clustered along the banks from morning until the last tee shot is struck. One television camera is trained on it all day long so the gluttonous patrons won’t miss a single calamity. They got double their money’s worth Thursday, when Steve Lowery, the portly Alabaman, went for an eight. I don’t know if there ever has been a higher number, but if so, I never saw it. Lowery dunked his tee shot, took his drop and plopped the next on the walkway to the green — something I’d never seen before — whacked that shot in the water, and by the time he was done, he had a fat “snowman” on his card. After which, he waved gregariously to the cheering gallery and waddled off, on his way to an 81.

It’s as exciting as a devilish curve on a race track, but without fatalities. Actually, it was a soft number Thursday. Twenty-eight birdies were made there, at last count, and only four “Others.” That is, catastrophic numbers, such as Lowery’s. As the day rumbled on, more bogeys developed on the first hole than 17. It was the combination of a narrow fairway and thick Bermuda rough that took its lineup of victims. For all that, only one double-bogey developed there, that by Scott McCarron, two-time winner of the now-stricken old Atlanta tour stop.

A string of names uncommon to Tour leaderboards began springing up as the shadows lengthened. Scott Verplank led off, followed by young John Mallinger; Richard S. Johnson, a Swede; Alex Cejka;  Jonathan Byrd, of neighboring St. Simons Island; and at the bottom of the list, a player named Brad Adamonis, ranked 300th in the world. But, this is early, like the first reel in an old movie.

9 comments Add your comment


May 7th, 2009
10:08 pm

Furman, Thanks for only mentioning Tiger once.
I’m a huge Tiger fan and I get embarrassed by the constant fawning over him by the TV talking heads.
There are others in the tournament.


May 7th, 2009
10:52 pm

Furman, Bob Tway posted a double-digit score on the 17th one year. I don’t recall the exact number; but, I’m sure an experienced sportswriter could research it rather quickly–or perhaps an intern. Do you have an intern? Do you need one? I’m not very busy right now. This economy is brutal. :-)


May 8th, 2009
12:24 am

Furman, Time to hang it up, buddy. Wally Butts and “the bear” are long gone, and you can’t just mail it in now…


May 8th, 2009
5:18 am

Players Championship is something I always keep a track of. It has the ability to spring some surprises and the unexpected. @Mikey I agree wholeheartedly. I am a big Tiger Woods fan. But seriously, there are other players. Give them due credit. I am a follower of Sean these days. He’s been rising in the PGA rankings (courtesy Trackle – and I think he has great potential.


May 8th, 2009
6:30 am

Good job, Furman-You’re amazing-I’ve been reading you for a 100 years and you only get better! Free Ferris Wheel ride-I love it!


May 8th, 2009
8:54 am

Furman, the TPC is my favorite tournament! I love the tournament and the Greater Jax area. To me this is the #1 tournament in professional golf. And I agree with you guys, Tiger is great, but there are many other players and the TV people should give all of them their due credit.


May 8th, 2009
9:22 am

We have never had 5 majors and never will.

All of you who mentioned “you know who” just helped the talking heads. The problem with the media (aka paper, radio, tv, magazine et. al.) in focusing so much on “you know who” their credibility as a trusted, objective, source of accurate information drops. They are clearly more interested in “stories” and making money, than in reporting the facts.

Furman is old school and I think he can be trusted but most can’t be trusted and we should all be wary of believing anything we hear or read. They are selling information and will do anything to do so.

cluett peabody

May 8th, 2009
9:56 am

Hey why not call every other tournament a major that way tigger would show up et. al. and the tour would thrive.


May 8th, 2009
3:31 pm

Furman, you raise a point that intrigues me.

I know that the 17th is considered a gimmick. But I don’t understand why.

What makes one hole a legitimate test of a golfer’s skill and another a “gimmick”? If the 17th had a length of grass between the hole and the tee, would it suddenly be considered a fair but easy par 3?

Other holes rely on treacherous water to intimidate golfers and sink their scores. Why would they not also be considered “gimmicks”?

I’m just curious why this hole is so maligned.