
Credit: Bravo
SPOILER ALERT!
It seems like only yesterday Atlanta watched with bated breath as Richard Blais finally took home prize in Top Chef All-Stars, but here we go again! Thats right, the new season of Top Chef is underway.
This season takes us to one of the biggest culinary towns in the country, the Mecca that is driving all of the great chefs from New York, London, and Chicago: San Antonio, Texas. Yipee-ki-yay!
Ok, so Top Chef Texas will also visit Dallas and Austin, but the majority of the episodes film in the home of the Alamo. I’m sure that it seemed like the most appropriate and logical choice to the producers….
The show opens with Padma greeting the swarm of cheftestants in front of the San Antonio landmark. Instead of the usual 16 contenders, this season starts with a dizzying 29 young chefs. Since this seems to be a recurring theme for this season, I’m just going to get this out of the way now: “Everything’s bigger in Texas!”
There, that will be the last time you read that from me all season. If I slip up, you have full permission to crush me in the comments.
In addition to Hugh Acheson joining the judge’s table this season, replacing Anthony Bourdain as the “will he be there this episode?” judge is culinary behemoth Emeril Lagasse. We all know that Hugh has some lip on him and will make for an entertaining judge, but I’m looking forward to hearing the surprisingly gruff Emeril drop the hammer on some fools this season. Queue the BAM! jokes.
With so many faces in the crowd, it will take a few episodes to feel out the players and personalities. There is a lot of pedigree and nominations to go around this group, and I’m impressed they could still maneuver around the kitchen with all of the names they dropped scattered around the floor.
Knowing that 13 of them will get the axe in the first two episodes isn’t helping me to get invested in any of them at this point, but I’m obviously keeping my eye on the Georgia crew. Janine Falvo of Briza Restaurant in Atlanta and Whitney Otawka, recently named executive chef of Farm 255 in Athens, represent the Peach State this season. Go home team!
Not surprisingly, most of the chefs – who, it seems, up until this point were under the impression that they had already “made it.” – aren’t terribly thrilled to discover that they still have to fight it out for a spot on the house.
Thankfully, even the massive new Top Chef kitchen couldn’t handle 29 bumbling chefs running all over each other, so the herd is split into three groups, each with their own challenge (we only see the first two groups, group three is saved for part 2 of the opener next week.)
The first group enters the kitchen to find a whole hog broken down into the primal cuts, and each chef gets a different cut with which to create their dish. I wonder if it was pure chance that landed bearded-vegan Colin Patterson in the whole hog group? (Spoiler alert….he doesn’t do very well.)
Group 2 gets an array of ingredients to choose from, and they must settle on one for all of the chefs to use as the focal point for their dishes. If two of the three judges think the food is up to snuff, the chefs earn a blue jacket and a spot in the house. Similarly, it only takes two thumbs down and knives get packed. And just to keep the drama going a little, the third option is “the bubble” (seriously…couldn’t think of a better name than the bubble?), where chefs on the cusp of greatness get a second chance to get it right and claim their spot on the roster.
However, 13 contestants is a lot of fat to trim, and who wants to wait until judges table? I can think of one guy that doesn’t have that kind of patience. (Hint: He’s bald)
Within the first five minutes of the episode, I was already giddy about one contestant: Stone….Chef Tyler Stone. This 22-year old chef displayed delusions of grandeur, lack of humility, and complete lack of self-awareness. I couldn’t wait to see what happened next, because I’m sure it would be priceless recap fodder. Seriously, watch his audition tape. Pure gold.
And 12 minutes into the episode, he was gone. Dude didn’t have time to pre-heat an oven. Apparently, Tom Colicchio doesn’t take too kindly to self-promoting, fame-seeking celebu-chef wannabes that can’t butcher their way out of a paper bag. Weird.
You’ll be slightly missed, Tyler.
Alas, there are too many dishes and chefs to recount, so here are the stats and some highlights:
Winners:
Chris Jones – Moto (Chicago)
Sarah Grueneberg – Spiaggia (Chicago)
Nyesha Arrington – Wilshire restaurant (Los Angeles)
Richie Frieda – Moto (Chicago)
Heather Terhune – Sable kitchen and bar (Chicago)
Whitney Otawka – Farm 255 (Athens,Ga) WOOT!
Keith Rhodes – Catch Restaurants (Wilmington, NC)
Dakota Weiss – W Hotel (Los Angeles)
Ty-LöR Boring – Spasso (New York)
Chris Crary – Whist Restaurant (Los Angeles)
Chuy Valencia – Chilam Bilam (Chicago)
Losers:
Stone…Tyler Stone – cooking for many celebrities, politicians, and media personalities (National level)
Simon Pantet – Twenty-Two Doors (Seattle)
Colin Patterson – Sutra (Seattle)
Nina Vicente – Spur Gastropub (Seattle)
The Bubble:
Molly Brandt – Allure of the Seas (Royal Caribbean)
Grayson Schmitz – between gigs (New York)
Edward Lee – 610 Magnolia (Louisville, KY)
Janine Falvo – Briza Restaurant (Atlanta)
Highlights:
-Was Molly seriously that surprised and mad that she had to actually compete for her spot on this COMPETITION SHOW?
-Someone tell Chris Crary not to name drop Blais and Voltaggio when describing his style. It just makes him seem like a fanboy. A pompous fanboy.
-“I think you should just leave now” – Tom C.
-By Jon Watson, AJC Food & More
20 comments Add your comment
Rodney
November 3rd, 2011
7:12 am
I must admit – I’m IRRITATED at this whole two-weeks-worth-of-auditions gimmick. I wanted my Quickfire/Elimination Challenge Top Chef last night and all I got was the format of So You Think You Can Dance auditions (where being “On The Bubble” replaces “Choreography Round”).
That said, I’m most excited about Nyesha, Sara and Heather. Nyesha’s got the pedigree, and both Sarah and Heather both look like they enjoy food (never trust a skinny chef, I always say) so I’m down for any of those three as my faves this season.
AJ
November 3rd, 2011
8:27 am
Not a good night for Seattle!
John Kessler
November 3rd, 2011
9:24 am
There’s a competitor named Ty-LöR Boring? Wow…
1164mgc
November 3rd, 2011
10:02 am
Am I the only one who can’t stand Padma’s denim dress?
Carla
November 3rd, 2011
12:26 pm
As a Top Chef addict, last night was a waste of weeks of anticipation. I don’t want to watch the 13 chefs who go home. I want it paired down to the final 16 I should care about. The whole American Idol rip off really disappointed me. I knew they had revamped the format..and I wanted to like it. The Tom moments were my favs and the only reason I’ll consider rewatching…except that I got so bored I really didn’t watch closely last night. Maybe once I care about a few people I’ll go back and rewatch this and next weeks to see how they do/did. Still, any NEW Top Chef is better than NO Top Chef at all!
SP
November 3rd, 2011
2:38 pm
Jon, your TC recaps make that show! Thanks!
sansho1
November 3rd, 2011
3:03 pm
I didn’t mind the new format. Two weeks of televised prelims, and then the show will go on as usual.
FMFats
November 3rd, 2011
3:44 pm
Jon, with what do your bait your breath and what are you trying to catch?
Rule .303
November 3rd, 2011
3:50 pm
I usually go to bed between Midnight and 1am. I seriously dozed off around 10:30pm last night trying to watch this crap. They destroyed a perfectly good franchise. So sad.
Sucks that Bourdain is gone too. As much as I like Emeril, he looked really tired and old. And Padma, with her robotic speech patterns just bores me.
1164mgc
November 3rd, 2011
4:03 pm
The new format didn’t bother me. I was pleasantly surprised when Tom told the tenderloin hacker to go home. Honestly, as a vegetarian I think I could have done a better job. The thing I’m not looking forward to is seeing Hugh, but I’m hopeful that this show will change my opinion of him. Time will tell.
Indian4Ever » top chef texas » Indian4Ever
November 3rd, 2011
4:10 pm
[...] watched with baited breath as Richard Blais finally took home prize in Top Chef All-Stars, … [Read More] Tags: top chef texasNo comments yet… Be the first to leave a reply!Leave a Reply Click here to [...]
GaPeachy
November 3rd, 2011
4:29 pm
UGH, r u serious, this new format made me highly upset last night. I have been waiting on this show to start since the end of summer and thats what they leave me with. I at least wanted to see the final crew! Anyway, I was cracking up when Tom eliminated mr. fancy pants. I knew when he was talking he would be the first to go with all that bull leaving his mouth. There are a hand full of contestants i see a lot of promise in though.
Jon Watson
November 3rd, 2011
6:40 pm
@FMFats Usually bourbon, which seems to catch the grammar police quite effectively. Corrected, and thanks for the heads up
Wino
November 3rd, 2011
9:28 pm
Jon, the one useless detail that you left out was the underage chef wannabes undressing Padma with their eyes…let them go write a blasphemous book and go into hiding for 10 years if they want a piece of her.
carla roqs
November 4th, 2011
9:13 am
not sure how the heck i missed this, hope i at least set it up to record a week or so ago. welcome back jon!!!!
Edward
November 4th, 2011
4:42 pm
I found the new format very entertaining. Seeing what the chefs would come up with during their hour of cooking, essentially given a free chance to shine, was informative. I can also understand “the bubble” situation, given that those chef’s work, while having some problems, did show some promise that warranted another look. The ones that didn’t make it, well, it was pretty obvious. I hope the cooking challenges this season remain more realistic.
carla roqs
November 7th, 2011
8:45 am
ok, i watched it, not impressed, soooooo glad hugh was not there yet. they’ve done something similar before where they had them cook outdoors and then get eliminated- or was that tc masters? ready to see what the final 16 can do.
MoHub
November 8th, 2011
9:55 am
Ty-Lör Boring is the greatest reality competition contestant name since Gunnar Deathrage, and Gunnar never even made it past the Project Runway prelims.
Top Chef Texas Premieres | Gluten Freedom Atlanta
November 8th, 2011
2:25 pm
[...] I’m not a quitter though, so I won’t give up on the season yet! Read what the AJC’s talented and witty Jon Watson had to say about the first episode:“Top Chef Texas Recap: Trimming the fat, part umlaut” [...]
Alexa4
November 9th, 2011
8:06 pm
Love this show! I saw one of the top contestants, Nyesha Arrington on a Food Network show over the weekend, Chef Hunter! It was good, she won! Can’t wait to watch tonight!