accessAtlanta

City & State or ZIP Tonight, this weekend, May 5th...
City & State or ZIP
City & State or ZIP Tonight, this weekend, May 5th...
City & State or ZIP

Wisteria Restaurant review, Atlanta

$$$

$$$

My grandmother grew wisteria in her front yard. Through meticulous care and attention, she trained this beautiful purple-flowering vine to develop into a tree. Her highly prized ornamental became the symbol of our extended family’s weekly Sunday suppers.

Review by Jenny Turknett

Review by Jenny Turknett

While the kids invented chasing games around the wisteria tree and the adults swayed on the porch swing watching, my grandmother assembled a large spread to fill her 20-seat kitchen table. The meal was always an eclectic mix of the week’s garden harvest and a smattering of requested family favorites. As numerous dishes loaded with Southern specialties traveled the length of the table, everyone was sure to find something to their taste.

I’m reminded of these weekly reunions while at Wisteria Restaurant in Inman Park. When the restaurant opened 10 years ago, chef Jason Hill hoped to create a place that appealed to everyone from his grandmother to his girlfriend. He succeeded. The glow of the lights set against the singular bricked wall warms the cozy space, enveloping and comforting with a sense of home. The wait staff, described as family on the restaurant’s website, welcome you without a trace of pretension.

Just as in my grandmother’s home, Wisteria’s menu incorporates a mixture of seasonal offerings and family favorites. Both the Southern contemporary fare and the beverage program play to a range of tastes. The bar offers both classic and craft cocktails and an approachable wine list serving numerous wines by the glass and custom flights.

Iron-skillet fried chicken (photos by Becky Stein)

Iron-skillet fried chicken (photos by Becky Stein)

As the family gathers together to break bread, family food quirks emerge. Only Uncle Clive would pass up the chilled organic carrot soup ($6.50). This refreshingly cold textured carrot soup adorned with a zippy sweet radish granita and bold bits of peanut brittle would be too avant garde for him but perfect for cousin Lulu, who is a vegetarian and craves that playfulness. No, the icy embodiment of radish alone would be too foreign for Clive.

He would prefer the iron-skillet fried chicken ($17), dipped in buttermilk and dredged in a flour mixture containing ancho powder, white pepper, cayenne and paprika. That sounds more like it. The chicken’s crispy, well-seasoned batter yields its perfect crunch to the mushroom-herb broth lining the plate, making it all the more homey. Throw in the slightly sweet bacon-braised collards with dashes of champagne and apple cider vinegars for the home run.

Beef carpaccio

Beef carpaccio

And what family gathering would be complete without deviled eggs ($6)? Wisteria blends traditional versions of deviled eggs and pimento cheese together for an ultra-smooth sharp-cheddar-and-egg filling. A helping of brassy pickled okra cuts the eggy richness and provides a crisp, textural contrast.

Our slightly more adventuresome eaters savor the Kobe beef carpaccio ($9), sourced from Buckhead Beef and Halperns’. Though carpaccio may be too exotic for some in the family, the version at Wisteria combines the classic flavors of well-marbled beef, nutty aged Parmesan and a piquant arugula salad. Crunchy fried capers strewn over the chilled beef add a shiny brininess.

The meat-and-potatoes set will devour the moist and perfectly cooked herb-crusted rack of lamb ($28, two chops) or the sweet molasses-rubbed pork tenderloin served with smooth sweet potatoes ($18). The pork, so juicy and tender from a salt-and-sugar brine, will surely become a treasured family recipe.

As for me, I’ll take the trout ($20). I relish the surprise crunch from bits of panko mixed into the fragrant toasted almonds and the sweet-but-light bacon vinaigrette that marries the trout to the dance of soft fingerling potatoes, sweet corn and tart tomatoes beneath.

To end the meal in family potluck style, Wisteria offers samplings of decadent Southern-inspired desserts (three for $10). Chocoholics will salivate over the fudgy chocolate tart and chocolate orange ice cream with surprise chunks of candied orange peel. For everyone else, there’s the soft sweet potato praline cheesecake and the moist spiced carrot cake with sweet coconut-pecan filling. You must try them all to avoid hurt feelings, right?

Gather the family, young and old, adventuresome and safe, to reconnect at Wisteria. Hill and the staff will welcome your family as part of theirs. Intelligent menu development and skillful execution ensure that no one will leave disappointed. Over its 10-year evolution, Wisteria has blossomed into a treasured component of our culinary landscape.

WISTERIA RESTAURANT
471 N. Highland Ave., Atlanta. 404-525-3363.
3stars5Food: Contemporary Southern
Service: Friendly, professional servers, many of whom have been at the restaurant since it opened 10 years ago
Best dishes: Molasses-rubbed pork tenderloin, almond-encrusted Georgia mountain trout
Vegetarian selections: Chilled carrot soup, vegetable plate, salads and assorted sides
Credit cards: Visa, Mastercard, American Express, Discover
Hours: 5:30-9:30 p.m. Sundays, 5:30-10 p.m. Mondays-Thursdays, 5:30-11 p.m. Fridays-Saturdays
Children: Yes, older or well-behaved best
Parking: Yes, valet
Reservations: Yes
Wheelchair access: Yes
Smoking: No
Noise level: High but doesn’t preclude conversation
Patio: No
Takeout: Yes

ratings_key_febUSE

10 comments Add your comment

Mark

October 6th, 2011
8:59 am

Jenny: don’t you have a sense of deja vu at Wisteria? We used to be regulars there but have drifted away over the years. It was always good food, but don’t you crave some sense of new and aadventurous? Fried chicken, herb crusted rack of lamb, breaded trout–this is pretty well-trodden turf. Cheesecake and carrot cake?

Certainly there is a place for a restaurant where you can count on a well done version of “the standards.” Houstons is a good example. But when I can get more interesting takes on the classics, at places like Empire State, Miller Union, Woodfire, Cakes and Ale, Abbatoir, Local Three, Holman and Fitch, etc, the lack of risk taking at Wisteria begins to pale. Great comfort food, noisy room, decent wine list, a great neighborhood option, but maybe not quite in the same league?

Jenny Turknett

October 6th, 2011
9:39 am

Mark, I think the food is solid and I think there is some playfulness here and there, the best example being the chilled carrot soup with radish granita. While I do crave an element of surprise, I also appreciate well-executed food whether it is playful or not. Wisteria may not be an innovator, but does everyone have to be? Do you avoid places like Busy Bee and Carvers because they have been cooking the same menu for countless years — the same menu our grandmothers prepared? We have to consider the restaurant’s goal and that is to prepare good food that everyone (foodies and non-foodies, grandmothers and twenty-somethings) can enjoy. I think they are achieving just that.

James

October 6th, 2011
9:41 am

@Mark. I’d say Wisteria strikes a nice balance – new and adventurous is in the eye of the beholder, I suppose (and since when is beef carpaccio “comfort food”!). I’d actually choose Wisteria over almost all the places on your list there. To each his own ;)

PJ

October 6th, 2011
9:51 am

I’ve only eaten there once, but my meal was amazing. I started with the Crab Bisque. I am a connoisseur of crab soups having vacationed in the Low Country for my entire life and having a father from Maryland where the take on crab soup is a different kind of delicious. Wisteria’s take is truly good stuff. It is rich & creamy with the goat cheese adding extra creaminess and richness to the crab base. I tasted other’s starters and enjoyed the carpaccio – I want to make fried capers to go with everything. I scored big when I ordered the beef tenderloin. I was craving red meat and the perfectly-medium-rare-cooked steak melted in my mouth. Almost upstaging it on the plate was the macaroni & cheese studded with braised greens. It was kind of like when you are little & your mom tries to hide those veggies you don’t like in your mashed potatoes, but I’m a grown up now and those greens gave a new depth to a classic dish. I tasted another friend’s shrimp & grits, something I normally wouldn’t order, but this was yummy. To save room for dessert, I took home 1/2 the steak & 1/2 the mac & cheese – wow did that make an amazing lunch the next day. I was glad I saved room because the sweet potato cheesecake was divine. I don’t like sweet potatoes on their own, but would run a few extra miles each week for this cheesecake.

Mark

October 6th, 2011
10:29 am

@James and Jenny: points well taken, and it is important to value quality food, whether traditional or cutting edge. And I agree, Wisteria does that well.

I think more of my frustration is with the ATL restaurant scene in general, not with Wisteria, which I agree provides really good food. For me it’s the fact that even among the restaurants I listed in my first post, there is an element of sameness that for me at least is becoming somewhat tiresome. Rather than just “seasonal local farm to table,” wouldn’t it be great to have a high end Vietnamese place like Slanted Door in SF, exquisite Italian like Babbo, authentic high end Mexican like Frontera, cutting edge molecular like Alinea (like I’m sure Richard Blais would really rather be doing instead of hot dogs), or classic French like Le Bernadin? Now we are fortunate to have good street level Asian and Latin cuisine in the Buford Hwy style, but I’d love to see a more mature higher end scene than we currently have here. So maybe that explains my pique, but you’re right, it’s not fair to point at Wisteria. I’ll go back now that I’m thinking about it!

Great sandwich!

October 6th, 2011
11:53 am

Jenny, is this really a review? All you did was list and describe some of the dishes that are served. As a review, why only 3 stars (Merits a drive if you are looking for this sort of thing) since you did not have a complaint or criticism about anything. Seems like it should be 4 stars (defines excellence in local dining).

MD

October 6th, 2011
12:26 pm

@Mark: I can understand your frustration with the ATL restaurant scene (esp. if you are well-traveled and/or a transplant, like myself.) Have you tried the One Eared Stag in Inman Park? Chef Robert Phalen is really pushing the envelope in these parts. I’ve eaten there on three separate occasions and have not been disappointed. That being said, I also enjoy Wisteria. It’s a good, solid and reliable place, as Jenny points out, and a great place to bring visitors from out of town. Cheers!

Mark

October 6th, 2011
12:50 pm

@MD: have not tried it, but based on the buzz recently we need to give it a try. Have also recently enjoyed lunch at 246 though no reservation policy and noise levels means I prob won’t go there for dinner. It’s not a wasteland, to be sure, and again, I agree that Wisteria merits a visit.

However…@sandwich. The dreaded star discussion. No, Wisteria is not a four star restaurant. Not in a system where Miller Union (one of Esquire’s best new restaurants in America), Local Three, and Woodfire Grill are all considered three star places. Lack of criticism does not equal excellence, and I think Jenny knows that while Wisteria is solid, it’s not a destination restaurant. And while others might disagree, there is no way that Wisteria DEFINES excellence in ATL. That applies to Bacchanalia, or Restaurant Eugene, or Aria in my mind. Wisteria is a great neighborhood place, but again, if I lived on the Westside, would I drive there when I could eat at Bocado or JCT or Abbatoir? Probably not.

Rebecca

October 7th, 2011
11:38 am

Well, this may be an issue of Eastside vs. Westside. I’m an “Eastsider”, and I think Wisteria is THE best restaurant in Atlanta. I would much rather a meal here than to drive to JCT. Food is good in both places – but for the price of the meal, the casualness of the atmosphere, the unpretentiousness of the friendly service (MOST consistently excellent anywhere) you just can’t beat Wisteria. AT LEAST 4 stars. :)

Betsy Gluten Freedom

October 12th, 2011
11:32 am

AND Wisteria has a gluten-free menu! It’s one of our favorite local spots.