accessAtlanta

City & State or ZIP Tonight, this weekend, May 5th...
City & State or ZIP
City & State or ZIP Tonight, this weekend, May 5th...
City & State or ZIP

Attempting shrimp tempura

Last night, I pulled some uncooked shrimp out of the refrigerator for dinner and had no idea what to do with it. I ran through a medley of ideas that I thought would be relatively fun. Shrimp and grits came to my mind, but I lacked ingredients at home that would have comprised my ideal version. It was also chilly outside here in Atlanta, and I had no desire to run to the store.

So my next idea was to make a simple pajeon – a Korean savory pancake. But I made an onion one that morning so I said to heck with that. I’m a little ADD when it comes to eating similar meals back to back.

So my eyes started wandering around my room and they eventually landed on Shizo Tsuji’s Japanese recipe book, Japanese Cooking: A Simple Art. When I saw the book, it hit me – shrimp tempura. In the past, I’ve had decent results with deep-frying so I decided to give it a go.

skrimpFollowing the book’s recipe for shrimp tempura, the first thing I did was dry the surface of the shrimp. I then made four shallow and separate cuts alongside each shrimp’s belly, and then flatten them straight out with the back of my knife. See my illustration to the left for the recommended cut areas (this is my interpretation of the book’s illustration). The purpose of this is so the shrimp doesn’t curl and clump when cooking. This procedure sounds tedious and it initially was. However, it eventually gets easier and before you know it, they’re all straightened and ready for cooking.

StationAnd then like the recipe says, prepare/organize your station with the essentials for preparing and frying tempura. The batter recipe for 1 cup worth of flour is 1 cup of ice cold water (cold batter aids in crispy texture) and 1 egg yolk. You also use a little additional dry flour for pre-coating your shrimp before dredging in your batter. As seen in my picture, from right to left I have my bowl of shrimp, loose flour, batter mixture, about a quart worth of peanut oil brought up to around 340-350 degrees, and a bowl with an oil absorbent towel. So the idea here is to make the frying seamless going right to left.

Let me note, that the book states to not fully mix the batter all together into a smooth uniform texture. It really should be clumpy and mixed briefly with chopsticks – purposely according to the book, because they are not a good mixing tool, and the fried texture of the tempura will have a better chance of being crispy. According to further research into this, what happens is overmixing will activate the wheat gluten in the batter causing the tempura outcome to be more doughy. Also, the batter should be prepared last so the temperature of it won’t drop as fast (some styles call for placing the bowl of prepared batter in a larger bowl of ice, which I did not do here).

Fried skrimpsSo how did I do my first time? I definitely had a more dough-like outcome than that crispy heavenliness associated with well-made tempura. I also tried to do the whole right-to-left process all with cooking chopsticks so my initial tempura results came out more curled. From my picture to the left, you can see how the batch on the right were chopsticks-handled and the ones to the left were finger-handled. This made me think of something Sensei Kessler recently mentioned to me about tempura cooking “required a certain touch.”

The shrimp I used were also too small (about 3 inches when straightened), or “delicate” I should say for my skill level. Here in America I generally see shrimp tempura used with much larger shrimp. Last Spring in Kyoto, Japan, I watched a tempura chef effortlessly prepare and fry shrimp the size of the ones I had. I’m obviously not quite there yet.

No recipe this time because I wouldn’t even classify my version last night as tempura. In the meantime, watch this space and maybe I’ll eventually get that touch Kessler was talking about.

Gene-Lee-Tagline– by Gene Lee, Food and More blog

– Gene Lee writes about International Cuisine for the AJC Dining Team. He also publishes his own blog, Eat, Drink, Man… A Food Journal.

11 comments Add your comment

Maggie

December 8th, 2010
8:07 am

People think I’m a good cook (I think), but what they don’t see are all the trials and errors like yours before I perfect something. Sometimes I’m too impatient with myself though; I resist trying something new because I know it’ll flop the first time. The price we pay for good food and wowing our friends. . .

Reds

December 8th, 2010
8:23 am

Maggie, that is well said. I’m pretty much the same way, but I luckily have a bunch of guinea pigs that are great at providing feedback!

Gene – that’s why food is such a science. You gotta experiement! Rather or not you did it “right”, it was still probably tasty. :)

KoPP

December 8th, 2010
9:16 am

Try cold club soda or add a bit of baking powder and soda to the water,

[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by GL, Jimmy. Jimmy said: RT @eatdrinkman: My post on frying skrimps – http://blogs.ajc.com/food-and-more/2010/12/08/attempting-shrimp-tempura/ [...]

Nannia

December 8th, 2010
12:20 pm

Try using 1/2 water and 1/2 Vodka. I know it sounds crazy but I got this from a friend, and the batter was perfect the first time. The vodka evaporates completely and therefore a much crispier coating

KoPP

December 8th, 2010
1:01 pm

Nannia, Alton Brown’s tempura recipe calls for vodka and selzer. I’ve found that the club soda is usually enough to help with keeping it light and crispy. But it is important to keep the fluid of choice cold.

John Kessler

December 8th, 2010
1:17 pm

Sensei? Shucks…
But, seriously, I used to work in a Japanese restaurant, and the chef gave me some pointer on tempura to the point I made a couple of not-totally-wrong batches.
1. Add crushed ice to the batter. And, really, it’s not batter but rather a semi-amalgam of flour, water and ice with plenty of clumps and visible spots of unhydrated flour.
2. Use low-gluten flour.

You can also use Japanese packaged “tempura-ko” that seems to be a mixture of wheat flour and cornstarch. Guess you could just add your own cornstarch, but it’s a cool looking little bag.

Gene Lee

December 8th, 2010
2:37 pm

Thanks for all of the suggestions.

I made a really good batch of onion ring batter over the summer that was with beer, baking powder and I think a Korean tempura-ko John speaks of. The bite was crunchy and airy as if the frying locked in little molecules of gas (which probably did now that I think about it).

Frying is fun, but my home and clothes smells like a friterie.

HotlantaHobo

December 8th, 2010
3:36 pm

I have tried this many times but can never get them to look like the pictures on the bags of frying powder, no matter whether they are Japanese or Korean in origin. Since flour in the US isn’t marked for protein or gluten content, using the pre-mixed frying blends makes the most sense.

I know if the batter is beaten that gluten forms and you get the Varsity’s onion ring coating, which for sure, is NOT what is desired here. But how clumpy? How liquid? How does it stick?

The pictures of perfect shrimp tempura look like there is panko in the batter, with a very lacy cell-like structure and I’ve been in restaurants that make it look like this, but I don’t think there is any panko involved.

John, did you ever get it to look like those beautiful pictures? Do your tricks provide that final result?
Would love to get this secret down once and for all.

John Kessler

December 8th, 2010
3:47 pm

HotlantaHobo — Not quite, but close. Definitely not panko — it’s a batter rather than crumbs. Also, you need to dip your fingertips into the batter and flick it repeatedly to create all those crunchy bumps and crenulations. Also, skim the tempura-dama (little bits of fried batter) from the oil to keep it clean. You can use these to garnish soup or lighten okonomiyaki batter.

HotlantaHobo

December 8th, 2010
11:23 pm

Thanks John….I think fine tempura is probably the most difficult technique in all of Asian cooking. Would love to see a video of a tempura master in a place such as Ten-Ichi in Tokyo preparing it.