
Bravo
By now we all know who won:
Yes — sob! — that guy.
I know, I know. I’m here to recap, not to curse the stars, so let’s whip through this recap in a disgruntled hurry, shall we?
As the show opens, Kevin is sitting at the table in his luxurious resort and spa with a Voltaggio sandwich.
“I wonder what Jennifer’s doing?” he asks.
“Probably detoxing,” quips Michael.
The dudes talk, they button their jackets (”for the last time,” says Kev), they pack their knives and they report to a vineyard.
Padma the Banged (I am, of course, referring to her hair style) and Tom greet the finalists with meaningful looks. They are to prepare a three-course meal — the first course to be constructed from a box of identical ingredients; the second from whatever they like; and the third a dessert. They will serve this feast to a who’s who of the nation’s top restaurateurs at Cyrus in Healdsburg — a restaurant that has earned two Michelin stars.
“This meal can make your career,” says Tom.
But, wait, there’s more. Do the chefs need help? Suddenly all the defeated contesting come filing out of their hiding place among the rows of vines like escaped prisoners to American tank drivers on V. E. Day.
There’s Eli! And Ron! And Ashley! And Robin! And that girl who had all those scabby lip piercings! What was her name? Jesse. And she’s a blonde! Cool!
Jen, as the last to go, gets the honor of carrying the Knife Block of Destiny. The chefs must each pick two knives bearing the names of the defeated, and these will be their sous chefs.
“I might just slit my throat with the knife if I end up with a couple of these people,” Mike says sotto voce. Mean, but can we blame him?
Bryan draws Jen and Ashley. Score.
Mike pulls Eli and Jesse. Partial score.
Kevin? Preeti and Ash. Uh oh.
Not only that, but Kevin is not at all pleased with his mystery box. Pacific rockfish, Dungeness crab, Meyer lemon, kabocha squash and matsutake mushrooms? All in one dish? Puh-leeeeeze.
The chefs install themselves in the Cyrus kitchen. Fumblefingers Preeti cannot cut the kabocha into the shapes Kevin wants fast enough, so he has to take on the lion’s share of work. “I lost half my prep time,” he grumbles.
Mike looks at his mystery box with some alarm. What can I make with all this hoo ha, he wonders. Fish-crab-squash-mushroom squiggles? Wait! What about deconstructed fish-crab-squash-mushroom squiggles! The judges will love that.
The three finalists head back to the resort and spa to plan their second day of cooking when there’s a knock at the door. Is it “Padma with a curveball,” as Kevin guesses?

Kevin's mom, Cathy
No, it’s mom. And…mom. The mamas Voltaggio and Gillespie are at the door. Kevin lets loose with a few tears when he sees his mom, Cathy.
Mama Volt has to carefully show her battling boys that she doesn’t prefer one over the other. There are equal hugs for good boy Bryan and little Mikey who, we find out, wouldn’t eat anything as a child. No broccoli, no Life cereal, nothing.
Come morning, Mom Volt buttons her boys into their jackets an says, “It’s like sending them off to their first day of school again.”
Mom Gillespie tells her anxious son, “Be the real you. Be the real Kevin.”
Okay, and…pause…sniff…verklempt!….just a moment….better.
We see some family pictures and then it’s back to the fleur de sel mines.
But before the chefs can get going with their menus, Tom appears to throw the anticipated curveball. Now that the moms are here, create a dish based on a childhood favorite.
It is also a super-high-stakes challenge, and Padma will be naming her child after the winner. Good luck!
Bryan goes for tuna noodle casserole, which he reinterprets through the magic of “Top Chef” as sardines with potatoes.
Li’l Mikey hated broccoli, so he commits the ultimate crucifer violation and dehydrates it for some fancy prawn dish.
Kevin recalls that his mom loved the skin of fried chicken more than the chicken itself, so he makes sheets of it to be set over squash casserole sauce and roasted tomatoes.
The rest of the meal? It has already been so thoroughly dissected on this blog and elsewhere that I feel no need to rehash it.
The show ends with Michael — his eyes as inexpressive as ever, his voice that pitchless monotone we know so well. He turns to the camera and says, “I didn’t know you could feel every single emotion at the same time.”
So it ends.
Here’s to you, Michael Voltaggio. Now, will you please be nice to your brother?
And here’s to you, Bryan Voltaggio. And Kevin Gillespie! Jen! Other Jen with the seitan! Eli! Hector! Pin-mouth girl! Maligned Robin who is not Eli’s mom! Pretti of Google! Eve from Planet Michigan! Ron of the tropical fish piles! Ash and Ashley, boy and girl! Monsieur Mattin who cornered the market on kerchiefs! Various other cooks I no longer recall!
I want you to know you’re all Top Chefs in my book.
16 comments Add your comment
prootwadl
December 11th, 2009
5:44 pm
The final three this year were super-strong, and I think any one of the three could have one on any given day. Too bad Kevin didn’t win, but it just wasn’t his day. But man, it was a good season…
prootwadl
December 11th, 2009
5:44 pm
“Could have one.” Nice typo. Won. won. wonwonwon. Sheesh.
KA
December 11th, 2009
6:21 pm
I’m going to Kevin’s to eat this weekend.
Fred
December 11th, 2009
6:23 pm
In the spirit of Atlanta unity I actually watched a freaking reality show. While i can’t say that I could ever be induced to watch the show again, it had it’s moments. I watched all three shows they aired Wednesday, (or was it Thursday, who cares). Oh the drama…….. brother against brother……… how contrived. Anyone who thought someone other than a brother was going to “win” is a moron. From the 3 episodes I saw they should call the show, the Volt Brothers cook off. oh well.
Personally I can’t imagine why Kevin decided to cook pork belly as his showcase dish, but I suppose some like copious amounts of cooked fat so who am I to say. I also agreed with whichever judge it was that said something along the lines of “Desert doesn’t scream BACON to me.” Not the best decisions to make, I would suggest, no matter how “perfectly” the two dishes may be cooked.
However I wondered about one thing. Was I the only one who thought it was completely insane to have a contest based however many weeks this was on a person showing THEIR talent and then for the finall test leaving them to the mercy of some schmucks who had already been found wanting? That was just plain stupid. I almost turned it off at that point but figured I had invested 2 hours already, why not stick around for the inevitable crowning of one of the brothers. Besides, M*A*S*H* was a rerun that night…………..
Kevin, everything I saw you prepare in those 3 episodes i watched had me salivating except for the final dish of pig fat, I can only assume there was no opossum belly in that there California kitchen?
Fred
December 11th, 2009
6:24 pm
KA, if you don’t already have a reservation you aren’t lol.
sansho1
December 11th, 2009
6:39 pm
Well, that was too bad. Done in by an unfamiliar ingredient and a knife block cursed by Fortuna. I admired Kevin’s resoluteness in defending his pork belly dish, though. Without being impertinent, he displayed an imperviousness to criticism he disagreed with throughout the season, and that often gave him the final word. I can’t be sad he lost — Top Chef would rightly seem to be the culmination of some careers, but it feels like just the beginning for Kevin.
My biggest disappointment was they didn’t find time for Ash to call anybody “amazing” one last time. It was his thing. He was the Ray J. Johnson of Top Chef. Then again, Ray J. probably got bumped a lot, too….
The “detoxing” comment confirmed what I had suspected about Jen’s uneven performance and dodgy health — the judges treated it as some great mystery, but I just assumed she was swilling wine and sleeping poorly. Not that there’s anything wrong with that. She seems fun.
Hey, did anyone notice whether the young woman who was ousted by the producers during a Quickfire (for being a basket case) was included in the returning group? I forgot to notice.
KA
December 11th, 2009
6:39 pm
Whatever Fred
Deanna
December 11th, 2009
6:59 pm
Best recap I’ve read so far!
GA Girl
December 11th, 2009
7:18 pm
Although it would’ve been great if Kevin had won, I thought Michael did a fantastic job. It was his desire from day one to beat his brother in every competition. This show had a strong finale! The strongest I’ve seen so far.
Blah
December 11th, 2009
7:53 pm
Padme is an adulter!!!!!!
sansho1
December 11th, 2009
8:39 pm
Who is a what?
Lisa
December 11th, 2009
9:44 pm
John, thanks for your attention to detail in your recaps. You can recap any food program for me but Sandra Lee. Can’t watch her. Not even for five minutes. Cheers to Kevin.
Lisa
December 11th, 2009
9:53 pm
I just read that Kevin made the semi finals in the Bocuse d Or. he’s still in the competition.
B. Thenet
December 12th, 2009
11:31 am
I think Michael was consistently the weaker of the two, but was pushed along because of his innovative nature more than his actually execution. And in the end his mistakes were overlooked due to his creativity.
Perhaps it was fitting since Top Chef has consistently rewarded traditional cooks in the end over risk takers, that they finally give the title to an not quite deserving outside the box chef.
Bryan has ever reason to feel let down by the decision, and I would hate to be at any family gatherings in the Voltaggio family moving forward.
jw
December 16th, 2009
12:27 pm
And here I avoided “Food and More” until after I watched the show. Then was disappointed when there was no recap. Now I end up spitting part of my lunch on my monitor. I should have know better. JK, those teenage daughters of yours must have all been taught about your double entendre’s by now (”Padma the banged”).
John Kessler
December 16th, 2009
2:08 pm
Thanks, JW…took me a while to get to that recap after posting/monitoring the news…