
Dale Chihuly canopy at the Bellagio
As we return to “Top Chef” land after a special two-week palate-cleansing hiatus, we find our six remaining chefs showing signs of stress. At the McMansion, Robin roots through the drawer of Glad Flex bags with an untold purpose, possibly the intention to smash a piano into bits. Jen is sallow and wild haired. I mean really wild haired. She looks like she has just suffered a botched electroshock therapy session. Bryan pines for his wife and young son back home in Maryland. Everyone seems ready to get on with it.
Soon, the chefs find themselves in the bowels of the Venetian hotel, in a kind of kitchen catacomb. A phone rings, and a disembodied voice comes crackling through the line. Is it Charlie looking for his Angels? No, it’s Padma demanding food.
Cut to our hostess, who is upstairs splayed out in a guest room bed, and she’s not alone!
Padma is having a slumber party with erudite British food sensualist Nigella Lawson. These two recumbent gastro-beauties lie side by side in their beds wearing matching fluffy terry robes. What a sight! Fellas, this hotel room is a double queen, and it’s smoking!
Guess what? Our ladies are famished for breakfast, breakfast and yet more breakfast. Oh, chefs, it’s time for the:
QUICKFIRE CHALLENGE: Room Service Breakfast in Bed (or: Come On In, the Door’s Always Open)
Our stressed chefs have 20 minutes each to root through the kitchen for vittles, trays, cloches, flowers — all the niceties our ladies want for their six-course breakfast in bed. Then they have to run up to the room.
First up are Robin and Eli, whom I’m beginning to think of as the chef versions of Sharon and Jack Osbourne.
Robin makes a huge mess putting together her goat cheese blintzes with caramelized pineapple and blueberries, while Eli reimagines a Reuben sandwich as Eggs Benedict.
“This would be a great hangover breakfast,” says Nigella as Eli slides the gooey pile of eggs, toast, corned beef and hollandaise onto her tray.
As Nigella chews thoughtfully on Robin’s flavorless blintzes, Michael V. is storming through the kitchen cleaning up Robin’s mess. He’s in a state because he has only 20 minutes to make his huevos cubanas, which involve banana puree, crispy rice and bacon.
I think this qualifies as the “hangover nightmare” breakfast. You don’t want that awful feeling of eight shots of Jägermeister sitting in your stomach? How about some eggs piled on banana baby food?
Nigella and Padma, who are both as fresh as flowers after three breakfasts, actually seem to like it well enough, but they melt for Kevin’s smartly updated steak and eggs with green onions and crème fraîche.
How’s our girl, Jen, doing? No worries. “I work in a hotel and we do room service from our kitchen all the time.”
She decides to serve the ladies good old creamed chipped beef on toast, which she informs us no fewer than three times is properly called “bleep on a shingle.”
Nigella does turn up her nose with that typically British “Is this a plate full of excrement?” expression, but she gamely gives it a try. The oven-roasted tomatoes help.
Bryan serves the caboose of the breakfast train — a dish of eggs over polenta with King crab, asparagus and a vanilla beurre blanc that gives Nigella the vanilly-willies.
So Bryan gets singled out as a loser, while Eli earns the win for his witty Reuben eggs.
“The tang of the sauerkraut slapped the jet lag out of me,” says Nigella to a beaming Eli, bringing a blush to his cheek. His winning dish will be immortalized for all eternity in the Top Chef Quickfire Challenge cookbook.
Padma and Nigella, now dressed and upright, give Eli no time to savor his accomplishment before they announce the:
Elimination Challenge: Create a Dish Based on a Casino (or: Thighs a-quiver).
The chefs draw knives that send them on a romp through various casinos to inspired bite-size yummies for a big party. Before long, Jen is watching a jousting tournament at Excalibur and drinking a firkin of beer. Kevin pets trained dolphins at Mirage and gives a shout-out to Georgia Organics (that’s our boy!). Robin wanders through the Bellagio, her eyes as glassy as the Dale Chihuly canopy above.
Not one of the chefs chooses to hang out with dead-eyed tourists planted in front of nickel slots or visit the $2.99 buffets for inspiration. Funny, that.
When they head back to the McMansion after a long day of Convention and Visitors Authority-approved activities, the chefs are all bubbling with ideas. Lying on their beds, they all share stories of their fun, fun days in the casinos.
Bryan, who visited the Shark Reef exhibit at Mandalay Bay, will cook sustainable seafood. Mike, who romped through New York New York, will dress like the Statue of Liberty, hold a torch filled with peanut sauce and wear a crown of chicken satay. Or, maybe he’ll just make some wings. New Yorkers love their wings, right?
Robin will transform the Chihuly glass flowers at the Bellagio into stained sugar glass decorations for a panna cotta. Except she’s never worked with sugar. And she’s never made panna cotta. And she doesn’t know how to stir. But, dagnabit, she’s giving this thing her all.
Only Eli remains verklempt. He visited the (strangely fitting!) Circus Circus casino, and found it no circus at all but rather a drab, depressing, neon-lit, room filled with clanging machines. (”He describes it like a really sad velvet painting,” says Kevin, our trippy poet.)
Think, Eli, think.
Well, okay, there was one stand selling circus treats, like peanuts, caramel apples and popcorn. I love this stuff. What if I mix it all together into a kind of beige, grainy, chalky, malodorous soup and cover it in a pink raspberry dome so that it looks like a scooped out chicken embryo? Surely the judges will stand up and notice that!
The chefs toast their perseverance with Korbel Brut (a wine-like substance), go to bed, and report to Top Chef kitchen the next morning. They have only 3 1/2 hours to get their yummies on the road.
Here’s where they stand:
Jen is still squirting one of her three wine sauces onto a plates when Padma arrives, looking ravenous in red. Her 175 guests line up behind her, demanding medieval meat chunks.
Jen’s meat is hard to swallow, but everyone digs Kevin’s cured salmon with compressed slaw and a juicy liquid that he calls “spicy cucumber broth” and Tom calls “tomato water.” Whatever it is, it’s fantastic, and everyone is tipping back their bowls to schlurp up every last drop.
Kevin is also quite the wit, and tells guests that he almost served bowls of sand along with a displayed picture of his dish. Mirage, get it?
Kevin, of course, gets called to judges’ table along with Bryan and his sustainable fish, which is yet more halibut. But Baby Volt, Mike, gets the win for his crispy boneless wings served with a witty disk of blue cheese frozen on a reverse plancha. His reward is a big bottle of wine and a “three night, two day vacation” at the Napa winery.
(Is it just me, or are these prizes seeming very circa-1982 “Let’s Make a Deal?”)
Jen, who is looking like she really wants to be done with this stupid business, has to hear Toby the Twit call her beef chunk “more Spamalot than Camelot.”
Not to be outquipped, Nigella informs Robin that good panna cotta shouldn’t bounce but rather “have the quiver of a 17th Century courtesan’s inner thigh.” (Preferably one with cellulite.)
As for Eli’s clown vomit, Nigella could barely bring it to her lips, Padma hated the flavor, and Tom called it a “total failure.”
Eli may have concocted the most vile item to date this season, but it’s — gulp….really? – Robin’s time to go.
Yes, folks, at precisely 10:59 Eastern Standard Time, an explosion of gleeful schadenfreude shot through the “Top Chef” universe as Padma told our plucky cancer survivor to pack her knives, her henna and her vast stores of gelatin, and hightail it out of town.
Robin wept, she hugged everyone (even Eli!), and she kicked herself for not preparing more of the comfort food she makes back home. Love her or hate her, she kept the show fun.
31 comments Add your comment
uberVU - social comments
November 12th, 2009
8:24 am
Social comments and analytics for this post…
This post was mentioned on Twitter by jdkess: RT @AJCFoodandMore Slumber parties and clown vomit soup: it’s a Top Chef recap. http://bit.ly/37bVmh #topchef…
Lisa
November 12th, 2009
8:33 am
OK, I am willing to admit that I cheered. My husband came into to the room to see what I was so happy about. I was way past time. I don’t think I will even try to find out where she cooks.
Needabailout, too!
November 12th, 2009
9:18 am
I’m with you, Lisa. Way past time for Robin to go, and what took so long? I’m thinking Atlanta is the home of this season’s next Top Chef. I’m sensing the next order of elimination is Jen, then Eli, then Mike and then his brother Bryan. I’m predicting that Kevin wins it all. I say that because he has been the most consistently praised by the judges, the most consistent winner of the challenges, and the least flappable, able to take the heat of a long, stressful cooking contest. I think we all should head to Woodfire Grill and check him out for ourselves.
Jessica (First Bite)
November 12th, 2009
9:22 am
I loved Nigella’s criterion for a good panna cotta, but my fav was the Brit judge on Top Chef Masters (can’t remember his name) who was met with uncomfortable stares when he mentioned panna cotta “should quiver like a woman’s breast”.
I think the judges were just making up for lost time by kicking Robin off. Was her dish really worse than Eli’s? Nigella said she had a hard time swallowing his.
Art
November 12th, 2009
9:24 am
Funny stuff John! Perhaps your best ever… No surprise to see Robin go although Eli clearly had the worst dish… clown vomit… love it. Is it just me or is Nigella… capital H, HOT? I thought all of the casino inspirations were just weak… New York, chicken wings and fire fighters? Gimme a break! They were in casinos and not one did anything related to gambling? And what the heck is Mike going to do at that winery for 3 nights and 2 days?? I love wine but really Monty Hall….
Lisa Jill
November 12th, 2009
9:27 am
Oh, how I look forward to this every Thursday morning. Jen’s hair is a hot mess. What was up with the Mike V’s outburst about putting his personality on his plate? It was precipitated by Tom saying that the dish Mike prepared was slightly feminine. I so haven’t seen that side of Mike. He acts like a spoiled little boy. That said, he should have clobbered Robin when she came in to clean up during the 20 minutes he had to cook.
Mr Dealbreaker
November 12th, 2009
10:04 am
Hi John – Mr Dealbreaker here from Tomo (Metromix) To set the record straight – I do like sushi, cooked sushi that is. : )
Great blog, and we love top chef, but the shameless product placement gets annoying sometimes – I guess they have to pay for the show somehow. Interesting how many of the chefs turned against Robin given her pleasant nature.
Kevin is THE MAN.
Troof
November 12th, 2009
10:28 am
Nigella and Padma having a slumber party!!!! Please tell me this episode will be coming on again!!
gernblanski
November 12th, 2009
10:32 am
Actually I think it will come down to Kevin and Mike V. While Bryan cooking seems very centered, his brother Mike has won more challenges and appears to have wowed the judges more ofen.
Also the editing seems to hinting that Mike V has a cooking style rivalry/envy of Kevin.
My wife and I went to Woodfire last Friday – it was awesome. All of the dishes are thoughtful, complex, flavorful but not pretentious. It is really good food, sustainable food, “Southern” food and Atlanta is lucky to have it.
Dr. Johnathann Rose
November 12th, 2009
10:44 am
Outrageous ouutcome! True Robin is not as skilled as others but her dismisal last night was not judgment but rather collusion.Eli’s dish according to the judge’s comments was the requisite “Pack your Knives” equation -but clearly the tabel had earlier decided that Robin needed to leave for other easons.
Sad, this transparent move does cast a shadow of fairness on the entire production.
Rob
November 12th, 2009
10:47 am
Kevin is my pick. His food has beem more consistent, he competes without tearing down the others and he has great imagination.
superfan
November 12th, 2009
11:01 am
It’s about time Robin went home. Eli may have had the worst dish this week, but Robin has been in the bottom week after week…what 10 times now? Time to pack her knives.
Rana Cash
November 12th, 2009
11:09 am
Thank ya, lawdy. Man, I’m so glad to see Robin leave. Now, one by one…Jen, Eli, Mike, Bryan (sadly)…and the winner is, ELI!!! I hope you’re preparing to give us the heads up on the local celebration when our homeboy wins.
TBizzle
November 12th, 2009
11:21 am
Kevin might fall into the Richard Blais trap. Blais was the most consistent throughout the season yet he was outperformed in the finale.
It would be interesting to see a points based system – points for being in the top and for a win, deduction in points for being in the bottom group
About chef:, top chefs, nigella, ‘top, vegas, robin, las - Find me About
November 12th, 2009
11:33 am
[...] As we return to “Top Chef” land after a special two-week palate-cleansing hiatus, we find our six remaining chefs showing signs of stress. At the McMansion, Robin roots through the drawer of Glad Flex bags with an untold purpose, possibly the intention …Read Original Story: Top Chef Recap: Episode 11: “More Spamalot than Camelot” – Atlanta Jo… [...]
Madge
November 12th, 2009
12:08 pm
Just to clarify – it was Toby that called Mike’s cooking effeminate, not Tom. So glad to be rid of Robin, and still hoping Jen can pull it together next week. Maybe a visit by Eric Ripert could cheer her up? GO KEVIN!!! (Enjoyed a wonderful dinner at Woodfire Grill last Thursday.)
About vegas, chef:, top chefs, robin, las - Find me About
November 12th, 2009
1:31 pm
[...] As we return to “Top Chef” land after a special two-week palate-cleansing hiatus, we find our six remaining chefs showing signs of stress. At the McMansion, Robin roots through the drawer of Glad Flex bags with an untold purpose, possibly the intention …Read Original Story: Top Chef Recap: Episode 11: “More Spamalot than Camelot” – Atlanta Jo… [...]
John Kessler
November 12th, 2009
2:01 pm
Madge: He did say “effiminate,” right? Twit…
tnsmoke
November 12th, 2009
4:36 pm
Tom says in his blog that he liked Eli’s dish and thought the conception was good, execution bad. He also said that the photo we all saw of Robin’s dish was not what the Judge’s tasted, there were 2 elements missing from her dish and she dish was not “inspired”. Eli at least tried to show something creative. I thought the guest judge was quite mean. I still love Kevin, Michael, Bryan and Jen and tho glad Michael won, was hoping poor Bryan would have won, he hasn’t won anything since his 3rd win in the 5th epidsode.
SP
November 12th, 2009
5:30 pm
So love this season of Top Chef! I really hope Kevin wins it all. I love the way he describes his dishes and how to eat them. Plus, he seems to have a good even-keel attitude. I can’t stand Mike V. What a jealous brat! And what’s up with all the banana puree in his dishes? Eww.
About chef:, chefs, nigella, ‘top, vegas, robin, las | Find me About
November 12th, 2009
7:32 pm
[...] As we return to “Top Chef” land after a special two-week palate-cleansing hiatus, we find our six remaining chefs showing signs of stress. At the McMansion, Robin roots through the drawer of Glad Flex bags with an untold purpose, possibly the intention …Read Original Story: Top Chef Recap: Episode 11: “More Spamalot than Camelot” – Atlanta Jo… [...]
melissa's mom
November 12th, 2009
8:28 pm
Eli is annoying and has a bad attitude (clown vomit – hilarious!!). He’ll go next, then Jen, then one of the Volts, then the other Volt, then Kevin will WIN!!! Yea! Go Kevin, you cutie pie!!:)
top chef fanatic
November 12th, 2009
9:05 pm
well mr. Kessler I have to say it was a good episode but i have to agree with the doctor , Eli had the worst dish by far! It was the worst dish i ever saw in the history of top chef , and clown vomit with sawdust dosent get you to the next round. Eli definetelly got a get out of jail free card and at this point in the competition they are hard to come bye. It was awesome when mikey V told robin (I want you to leave now …thats what i need from you) That kid got some nuggets and its clearly gonna come down to him and kevin. And i think kevin has got it together soo much more than richard Blais and dont expect him to choke like the laughing gas chef. Im kinda sour that Eli has been etched in top chef history quickfire cookbook that dish was lame . But hey it goes to show you that anyone can win in vegas. As far as the prizes they are getting more and more weak because its gametime and close to the finals. But i would take it in a flash! I will end with this….its been very steep competition this season, and i attended the casting for top chef next season at craft sunday. Just to see what it was like and dream a bit . And its gonna be another good reprsentation of the ATL! and we have consistently been represented in the past 2 seasons and we should feel blessed:)
I just wish i went to culinary school instead of slinging plaster all of my life , then i could be a top chef cheftestant or a food critic or something:( but dreams are for vegas and not ATL i guess.
Kat
November 12th, 2009
9:08 pm
“Blenders full of clown vomit.” Perfection, John… perfection….
Katherine
November 12th, 2009
11:55 pm
Technically, I think they had 30 minutes for the quickfire – Michael V spent 10 minutes cleaning after Robin and then had 20 to cook his dish. Go ATL!
@
November 13th, 2009
12:16 am
@ Top Chef Fanatic
STFU
Anna Burke
November 13th, 2009
4:32 am
Thank you for mentioning Nigella’s “courtesan” comment. I thought it made some of Toby’s nutty bon mots look positively relevant. I’m pulling for Kevin, too, of course. He is an amazing talent, and we gotta support our classy, supremely talented and charmingly unassuming ATL guy. Eli’s fun, but a bit bratty.
Carrie
November 13th, 2009
9:22 am
What’s with Nigella’s face lift?
P:
November 15th, 2009
10:53 pm
Speaking of Spamalot!!!!!!:
The above link ^^ is basically a portal to a very poorly done ad site, with a dim semblance of a Top Chef blog.
I wish they would IP block this cretin (Top Chef Recap).
Spammers = A very special place in Hell.
P:
November 15th, 2009
11:13 pm
OMFG It’s Foodiebuddah…………………..?
IT “Food Critic”……………………………………
Gregory M. Maddox
November 17th, 2009
6:07 am
Did anyone else see Eli and Robin’s banter and not have flashbacks to the 1990 Susan Saradon-James Spader movie “White Palace”? Robin Levanthal proved she has the “Cougar Potential” that would makeCourtney Cox-Arquette proud.