A few years back, when I was in the US Congress, I took the Army to task for permitting the practice of Wicca on its bases, including at Ft. Hood in Texas. After speaking with a number of officers and military leaders, and meeting with several former military who adhere to the practice of Wicca, I was convinced that a belief in or practice of witchcraft, was not necessarily incompatible with the good order and discipline essential to a military lifestyle. However, one might legitimately wonder just how far such tolerance should extend.
The US Air Force, at no less a prestigious location than the Air Force Academy in Colorado Springs, has taken the notion of religious tolerance to a new level, in creating an outdoor worship area for pagans. The site, apparently sacred to pagans, consists of an inner and an outer circle of large stones. I’m sorry, but this truly is hilarious. Don’t get me wrong, if someone “has little or no religion and delights in sensual pleasures and material goods,” which is the definition of a “pagan,” then I say live and let live.
But I have to tell you, if I were in the Air Force and was being commanded by an officer who practices hedonism as a religion (another part of the definition of “pagan”), and who dances around a circle of stones in the woods carrying a lighted candle, I would be more than a little worried about following him into battle.
330 comments Add your comment
Sean Burke
February 17th, 2010
6:14 am
As opposed to a belief that a great man in the sky produced a human son through virgin birth who can be consumed every seven days in the form of wafers and wine? The fact I voted for you in 2008 now embarrasses me.
Adrian Shadowmoss
February 17th, 2010
6:30 am
I agree Bob Barr and believe the blogger above most likely got up at 0500 hrs and began his usual daily habit of “Nine Before Noon.” That’s tokes to the uninitiated. He’s probably a Scientologist. Wait a minute! This blogger IS L. Ron himself posing as a blogger.
BTW: Second
drb
February 17th, 2010
6:30 am
I first heard of this a few weeks ago from someone actually IN the military. His concern was exactly as you say, and it seems that the grest majority of those he has contact with in the military agree. Based on that, I am inclined to think that this effort may be undermining our best military efforts and I don’t think that the military is a good place for division, not for the military itself, and not for the individuals within it. These young men and women signed up as a part of a military entity of “One Nation Under God” and I believe it reasonable that they should expect that special interests NOT under God, would be discouraged, or at the least not encouraged.
Paul
February 17th, 2010
6:32 am
I am shocked at your position on this. Who is to say what religious practices can be openly practiced? If you allow open worship of a zombie god/human, why not other beliefs?
John Duncan
February 17th, 2010
6:37 am
I think you’re confusing the dictionary definition of “pagan” with those who practice earth-based religions who refer to themselves as pagans. I’ve known a few and, outside their religion, they’re really just like anyone else. I would have no problem at all “following one into battle”. In the heat of battle, I could honestly care less who or what someone worships – I just want a good CO. This isn’t a Christian nation, as many on the right seem convinced – various resolutions to procaim this to be such have been attempted throughout our nation’s history and have been soundly defeated every time.
Anthony
February 17th, 2010
6:38 am
I see you’ve dropped libertarian ideals and are back and redwing rebpublican bigotry, Bob. Guess its time for me to unsubscribe. Peace.
Winfield J. Abbe
February 17th, 2010
6:46 am
The CEO of the public hospital in Athens reportedly, in the Athens Banner Herald a year or so ago, located the point on their property to drill a well during the drought. He did this with dowsing rods or divining rods. The noun divination is defined in my Webster’s dictionary : “The act or practice of trying to foretell the future or the unknown by occult means.” A divining rod is defined as : “A forked stick allegedly useful in discovering underground water, minerals, etc.” Of course it wouldn’t matter where one drilled since water is everywhere in most areas especially if you have enough money to drill deep enough as does the public hospital. This individual is paid about $ 1 million per year and you can be sure he won’t return telephone calls if your loved one is a victim of medical malpractice at Athens Regional Medical Center, Inc. which operates in secrecy like most police departments and district attorneys in Georgia.
Dave Briggman
February 17th, 2010
6:53 am
Now, Bob, you’re seeing why the LP can never succeed in our country. Anthony, John Paul, and Sean, and those like him in the LP will never recognize that this is a Christian-based nation.
Sean Burke
February 17th, 2010
6:56 am
Shadowmoss, first off, cute name. I find it ironic that someone with such a name as Shadowmoss would be critical of pagans. Anyway, I’m not stoned, but if Barr was in fact a Libertarian, he wouldn’t care about that, or about the personal religious beliefs of our soldiers. The fact that he was a drug warrior until he “saw the light” and ran for President, and the fact that he’s willing to trash some of our soldiers for their personal religious beliefs, shows me just how un-Libertarian he is. He’s shown himself as a meddling bigot just like his former Repugnantian colleagues, and he’s finally lost the last little bits of my support.
Also, I’m not a Scientologist. If I was, this post would be full of references to psychology being a Nazi science, and praise for that guy’s crappy writing (seriously, have you tried reading Battlefield Earth? Zzzzzz…)
And BTW, what the hell is the appeal of indicating you’ve posted first or second? Who the hell cares? First! Second! Shotgun! I’m going to work, have fun.
Wakey
February 17th, 2010
6:58 am
Bob, this sounds like like something you chuckle at over a beer with friends. Easy for me to say, I have no deadlines but..
Blarney Stoned
February 17th, 2010
7:09 am
The destruction of mankind thru-out history by the follower’s of Christianity and Islam is awe-inspiring. Lennon said it best, “Imagine there’s no countries It isn’t hard to do, Nothing to kill or die for and no religion too, Imagine all the people living in peace” …..
A
February 17th, 2010
7:09 am
Bob, you are being close-minded as usual. Pagans don’t worship the devil and molest kids. They see the divine in nature and (just like Christians) realize we are part of a larger universe. How would those qualities diminish a commanding officer…one who probably would value human life at least as much as, if not more,than someone who follows a “traditional” religion. And speaking of traditional religions, we see how well that’s turned out with the situation in the Middle East, Israel, you name it.
Captain America
February 17th, 2010
7:10 am
What? No whine about how bad it is that they are having parades in New Orleans celebrating Bacchus the God of wine? He was worshiped long before this new age Jesus ever came around.
Aquagirl
February 17th, 2010
7:12 am
I’d rather follow a pagan than follow a cannibal (catholic) or demigod in holy underwear (mormon.)
Religion: when your crazy beliefs make perfect sense, and other people’s crazy beliefs are obviously crazy.
Captain America
February 17th, 2010
7:14 am
A ~ of course pagans don’t molest children. That would be the province of christian pedophile priests and ministers.
Bob
February 17th, 2010
7:20 am
You’re right, Bob. Not to mention the fact that entering combat alongside the sworn enemies of God is never a good idea.
You have obviously stirred the Christ hatred in many readers. He who sits in the heavens laughs.
Captain America
February 17th, 2010
7:21 am
Briggman ~ If this is a christian nation, why are the words “christian” or “jesus” no where to be found in ANY of America’s founding documents? You’d think if you were basing a country on a religion you would mention the religion at least once in your founding documents.
A
February 17th, 2010
7:28 am
Captain America–good point, because we are *not* a Christian nation. It doesn’t take much research to find out that George Washington, Thomas Jefferson and Benjamin Franklin were vehemently opposed to merging church with state. It’s the religious right of modern times that has corrupted the original reasons for the founding of this nation. And like another poster said above, I too would rather be led by a pagan (most of whom value human life and all life on this planet) than a Christian zealot who can’t think for himself.
Blarney Stoned
February 17th, 2010
7:29 am
What if God was one of us? Just a slob like one of us-Just a stranger on the MARTA bus-Trying to make his way to Decatur….
A
February 17th, 2010
7:30 am
Bob, just because some of us are open and accepting of all religious beliefs and don’t blindly follow doesn’t mean we are Jesus haters. I’m sure Jesus would be the first to respect anyone with other beliefs. How conveniently people forget that Jesus loved all humankind, no matter their financial situation, station in life or anything else that people who follow him today would persecute people for.
Isaac
February 17th, 2010
7:35 am
It is April 1st already or did a supposed Libertarian just piss all over the 1st amendment?
DonsBlog
February 17th, 2010
7:42 am
Just the point I was going to make Isaac. Not my cup of tea, but since when did we require all religious people to worship like Christians? I don’t think libertarian is freedom as long as you agree with me.
As a matter of fact, the Air Force Academy has quite the record of forcing cadets to accept Jesus as their one and personal savior.
Blarney Stoned
February 17th, 2010
7:49 am
jesus was the most-famous medical marijuana dealer in history, cannabis was a heavy ingredient in his holy oil…
Todd
February 17th, 2010
7:50 am
I thought the post was a good one Bob.
Christian Nation vs Pagan Nation are missing the point. I believe most if not all the founders were Deists and envisioned ALL having the opportunity to worship however they choose.
I don’t see Bob’s post straying from that founder’s vision at all.
kitty
February 17th, 2010
7:51 am
I guess our men and women in uniform are not serving to protect their right to practice whatever religion they choose? Good grief, Barr, your right wing nut propensity is showing. Thanks, now I know what kind of phony libertarian you really are.
kitty
February 17th, 2010
7:52 am
Actually America’s religion is greed…isn’t that one of the seven deadly sins? I suspect Jesus wouldn’t recognize much of this place at all.
Marine
February 17th, 2010
8:01 am
Is this a sign that Bob ran out of ideas?
interested observer
February 17th, 2010
8:02 am
I am a Christian, but I can think of a number of so-called Christians I’d hate to have leading me into battle. I don’t see religious philosophy as particularly important when the bullets are flying and the bombs are falling. There are nutcases and zealots in every religion (and political party), and none of them should be leading anyone.
Lisa
February 17th, 2010
8:05 am
Thank God, Gaia, or Whoever! All is right with the world. I was starting to really doubt myself because lately I’ve actually (to my horror) found myself agreeing with most of what Mr. Barr has written. Along comes this bit of lunacy and that goes right out the window! Thank you for reminding me of your true colors. North is once again north, the sky really is still blue and the world’s not about to end!
Reality
February 17th, 2010
8:10 am
No wonder the USA is decaying so fast!
PS. Just a historical fact: the Continental Congress opened every meeting with a prayer to God as did the Constitutional Convention an wrote this fact in their meeting minutes. And for you unintelligent, God is a deity!
sharecropper
February 17th, 2010
8:13 am
And all this time you have posed as a Libertarian. The fact is, whether it is the AF Academy or anywhere else, religion or the lack of it is none of our business. (And you will recall that the academy is infamous for foisting its version of The Word, a flatly unconstitutional act.) A reasonable case can be made that all “religions” are hoked up and phony: water into wine? raise ‘em from the dead? Golden tablets and heaven in Missouri? You should worry, as previous posters have written, more about whether these people can lead and less about whether they “worship” their shoe laces or some such. You must remember, certainly, that Jefferson made reference: if it doesn’t break my leg or take my money, it is none of my business. Jeez. Get a life.
how2fish
February 17th, 2010
8:13 am
Bob I’m not much worried about which God warriors follow..the Roman legions follow Mitra for hundreds of years and that worked out pretty well…War is its own religion.. “It is well that war is so terrible –lest we should grow too fond of it” Robert E. Lee
Loren
February 17th, 2010
8:13 am
I do not understand how feeling connected to Mother Earth the way others have for thousands of years is any less battle worthy than believing in some almighty, loving, spirit-man who produced a son via virgin birth who later was killed which magically wiped away all of mans’ sins – thereby allowing men to commit horrendous crimes against man and Earth because forgiveness is a just prayer away. As was said previously: I am truly embarrassed to have not only voted for you in 2008, but actively & financially supported you!
CJJScout
February 17th, 2010
8:15 am
As a Christian, I could care less what you worship. But the AFA taking steps to actually build a wicca worship ring or whatever you call it… That is what is disturbing to me. Not that you’d passively let it happen, but that you’d actively encourage it.
AnhydrousBob
February 17th, 2010
8:22 am
Since the issue seems to be “battle worthy” or not, what about another example? Aren’t Native American religions considered “Pagan” by definition (non-Christian)? They have been both formidable enemies and formidable allies in battle – obviously “battle worthy”.
And another thing, I can’t see how you libertarians missed the biggest issue here – a standing army! Where is your indignation on that as the root cause here?
dewstarpath
February 17th, 2010
8:24 am
- I agree with Sean Burke and Captain America (Marvel fan since
the age of five).
The “folk” that seem to think that America is exclusively a Christian
nation, in my experience, are clueless about our military.
Chaplains in the service branches cover several denominations –
Christian (who would have to cover Baptist, Pentecostal, Catholic,
Mormon, etc.), Jewish, and Islamic. The gravesites of fallen soldiers
at every military cemetery reflect these denominations as well.
Whether you think paganism is a religion is open for debate.
But religion itself is not a “one size fits all” belief, as many fringe-right
zealots seem to be convinced of.
jconservative
February 17th, 2010
8:27 am
See the following new article, it may help explain what is happening at the AFA. It appears we have gone from officers using their position of authority to promote their religion to the Academy now allowing Wicca
displays on campus. I suppose if you allow a Christmas tree you must allow a Wicca display.
Published: June 23, 2005
WASHINGTON, June 22 – An Air Force panel sent to investigate the religious climate at the Air Force Academy in Colorado Springs found evidence that officers and faculty members periodically used their positions to promote their Christian beliefs and failed to accommodate the religious needs of non-Christian cadets, its leader said Wednesday.
But the panel said it had found no “overt religious discrimination” – only “insensitivity” – and praised the academy leadership for working aggressively to confront religious problems in the last two years.
Lt. Gen. Roger A. Brady of the Air Force, who led the 16-member group, said in a news conference at the Pentagon that the academy and the Air Force as a whole were struggling to define the boundary between acceptable and unacceptable religious expression in a government institution, a reflection, he said, of a debate under way across the country.
We believe that people were doing things that I think were inappropriate,” General Brady said. “They had the best intentions toward the cadets. I think in some cases they were wrong.”
He said his panel had referred seven cases of questionable behavior to the Air Force for further investigation but declined to elaborate.
Source: NY Times
neo-Carlinist
February 17th, 2010
8:28 am
I’m pretty sure the Air Force Academy also has a chapel and come to think of it, a football stadium. Are you suggesting cadets need only worship certain gods? the irony in this non-issue is so amusing. the year-end “Christian” celebration of the birth of Christ has its orgins in the solstice rituals of norther European pagans. in short, Pope Leo (or was it Gregory) “took” the holiday from the pagans and claimed it as Christian (it is accept that Christ was born sometime in the Spring). but, as with all (OK, most) zealots and “people of faith”, why let the facts (science, physics, history) get in the way of a good story (and ANY relgion is just “a good story”). frankly, the idea of warriors praying before battle concerns me. next thing you know, Army recruiters are going to be “pitching” recruits with promises of 73 virgins…
BlackAirForce
February 17th, 2010
8:29 am
I was in the Air Force and I would much rather follow any other religion than the one which used whips to beat your christian beliefs into the backs and souls of my ancestors! I lost respect for christanity when a military priest asked jesus to guide my bullets into the head of my enemies…my aim would have did the job just fine…I didnt need his two cents.
The Barr Tab
February 17th, 2010
8:39 am
Okay Bobby B, I don’t have a problem with the rocked out amplitheater Pagan church but this thing with human sacrifices will require more thought before I can enter a critical review. Another double Jack please!
Rufus
February 17th, 2010
8:43 am
What’s even worse, Bob, is to find your commander, operations officer, and first sergeant dressed in black robes, standing around a big, boiling cauldron chanting as they throw in bits of bat and frog. I think that’s how they’re working assignments now in the Air Force.
neo-Carlinist
February 17th, 2010
8:48 am
oh, and one more thing for the “we are a Christian nation” crowd. there is no question our European ancestors were Christian (and pagan before that – see my earlier post). there is not question the Bill of Rights is dervied (in part) from the Magna Carta, which drew from the 10 Commandments. Christianity’s influence – the good and the bad – see BlackAirForce – cannot be ignored. BUT, despite the influence, our Founding Fathers saw the need to documment the importance of religious freedom/tolerance (the 1st Amendment, no less). the superstitions, beliefs and rituals of our forefathers have NO bearing on the 21st century. if you listen to some, we are fighting a “war” against a foe that seems to be “stuck in the past” when it comes to theology and social mores. I don’t know enought about Wicca or pagans, but what I do know suggests that they favor a “less is more” approach to worship.
Kramer
February 17th, 2010
8:51 am
Well, Sean, I’m agnostic and I’m not embarresed by Barr. Agreing with a religion and tolerating a religion are two very different things. I don’t agree with Judeism, Christianity, Islam, etc. but chaplins are allowed in the military, why can’t you extend a similiar courtesy to a religion that’s a little “goofy”?
itpdude
February 17th, 2010
9:12 am
I like Mr. Barr and voted for him in ‘08 and would vote for him again. However, this Christian thinks Mr. Barr is putting the emphasis on the wrong syllable. Whether this nation’s military should install shrines for small religions is not the issue. The issue is whether we should have a military so huge that it enables formal attention to small religions such as Wicca or paganism.
Really. Our military-industrial-complex is SO huge that they can spend time installing religious facilities for one of the less popular religions in the US. THAT fact is far worse than the practice of a religion some may consider goofy. Our worship of the war-machine gives me far greater chills than some smelly hippies dancing around a rock-circle.
Former Fan
February 17th, 2010
9:13 am
Well, guess I’ll catch you on the flip side Bob. Unsubscribed.
Ostrich Racer
February 17th, 2010
9:17 am
Methinks Bob is engaging in a little good-natured rabble rousing. Context is the key to this thing. Everyone recalls the AF Academy has been in the spotlight for some rather aggressive proselytizing by faculty and students. The Academy not only has a Chapel, it’s huge and beautiful (in a modernist sort of way) and the centerpiece of the campus. Letting the fringe put rocks in a circle, somewhere in the half-million acres of woods around Colorado Springs, to dance around or sit on or whatever sounds like a clever compromise on the part of the school administration to mute counterculture grumbling about the Chapel, etc. No big deal — certainly not the weirdest thing going on in Colorado.
And for what its worth, I served with a lieutenant in Afghanistan who claimed to be a Wiccan. He drew strange graffiti, but was pretty much unobtrusive, otherwise. It struck me that he did it to get attention which, ironically, he didn’t get, because we had more important things to worry about.
Nothing to see here; move along.
Azazel
February 17th, 2010
9:17 am
But would Bob follow Gengis Khan or Julius Ceasar or Alexander the Great into battle? Or, those pagan warriors who forced Hadrian to build his wall?
MANUEL URIBE
February 17th, 2010
9:21 am
I find your lack of religious respect for a major religion of the world, disheartening. But I do agree expressions of any religion in a military setting are not to be fostered, or condoned.
Chris
February 17th, 2010
9:24 am
I am currently serving in the U.S. Army. I have served for over 10 years, and have deployed to war twice. I am also a practicing Pagan. I have been a Wiccan for over 23 years. I find your comments rude and ignorant. I vote Libertarian, and in 2008 I voted for every Libertarian candidate on the ballot EXCEPT Bob Barr. I cannot support someone who wants to discriminate against me. Pagans can and do serve honorably in our armed forces.
Salt & Light
February 17th, 2010
9:27 am
“Tolerance” means you “tolerate” someone else’s beliefs or opinions. It never means you elevate them to the same level as you own.
This “pagan worship” at the Air Force Acacemy is just one more nail in the coffin of a once great Republic.
“Blessed is the nation whose God is the Lord”.
The Tar and Feathers Party
February 17th, 2010
9:28 am
We atheist got rights too, just like you jesus freaks. If people want to worship the sun, or the almighty american dollar, what business is that of anyone else?
The Tar and Feathers Party
February 17th, 2010
9:29 am
The largest religion on wall street: Worship of the Almighty American Dollar
The Tar and Feathers Party
February 17th, 2010
9:31 am
The largest religion among lawyers is the Almighty Contingency Fee….Gimme 1/3rd of your award or settlement, and you pay all legal expenses out of YOUR 2/3rds, Amen. Holy, Holy, AhhhMeeen
The Tar and Feathers Party
February 17th, 2010
9:33 am
Bob’s a chicken Shiite, imho, he would only engage in a courtroom battle, no blood or guts for him.
Fix-It
February 17th, 2010
9:45 am
Bob, get real Wicca is a religion that has been around longer than Christianity, do you believe that Islam is a religion?
neo-Carlinist
February 17th, 2010
9:46 am
Salt & Light, with all due respect to your views, “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free excercise thereof…” You see, I don’t seek to “elevate” pagans to the same lofty level of Christians. Our Founding Fathers did. OH, and you are most certainly entitled to your opinion, but “elevate” is a subjective term in this instance.
Pagan worship at Air Force Academy | The Barr Code | Tailspin
February 17th, 2010
9:49 am
[...] the article here: Pagan worship at Air Force Academy | The Barr Code Aviation [...]
Marcos
February 17th, 2010
9:56 am
I don’t know what is more shocking… the reports of pagan worship at the Academy or the reports of evangelical officers shoving their extremist Christian views down the throats of their students.
Tony Knight
February 17th, 2010
10:18 am
I spent 14 years in the Air Force. As an agnostic, I suffered through prayers offered at various official functions. I believe that, instead of adding worship places for all religions, that religion should be removed from military bases all together. The chaplaincy program is nothing more than government sanctioned proselytizing, and that worries me more than what a commander’s religious beliefs are.
Bob's A Cherry Picker
February 17th, 2010
10:25 am
Bob!
An excellent example of Cherry Picking today. You’ve really outdone yourself, digging so deep.
Can you dig up some numbers for us relative to this? Some stats perhaps? A little perspective about the numbers involved here?
My guess is that you won’t, nor could you. Once again, you’re taking an isolated occurrance and generalizing it across a huge system as an example of a real problem.
Why? Dunno. That’s just how you think, I guess….still scared of the thing under the bed that never comes, yet willing to invest massive amounts of time and energy worrying yourself and others about it.
wil
February 17th, 2010
10:29 am
I don’t really have an opinion on the circle pro or con–but Barr’s blog is simplistic uninformed crap.
Kevin C.
February 17th, 2010
10:42 am
Mr. Barr:
Please remove the Libertarian party link from your blog if you are going to keep on sullying its name with bigotry.
Clamrock
February 17th, 2010
10:43 am
Libertarianism: freedom for me, but not for thee! Great philosophy Bob.
Common Sense
February 17th, 2010
10:44 am
They’ll probably get shot down. I don’t think the USAF has foxholes, but if it did, there would probably be “no Wiccans in a foxhole.”
Every service has its crazies; these are more of the same. They’ll fall to the back and wash out.
joe matarotz
February 17th, 2010
10:45 am
I remember when naval aviators celebrated pagan rituals. It was referred to as Operaton Tailhook.
Bobolink, how about a useful report as to how many college fraternities in the nation celebrate pagan worship? (Don’t worry, folks. Just humor the old Bobster until his nap. He really isn’t dangerous. Really.)
Rod
February 17th, 2010
10:45 am
An excellent example of why Libertarian beliefs work on paper but often fail in practice. The fact that you’d feel safer having one dilusion lead you rather than another speaks volumes. Myself personally, I’d rather be lead by someone who thinks the same way 7 days a week, not 6 + 1 mulligan of rational thought.
Another Republican Einstein
February 17th, 2010
10:48 am
For the on-line AJC, Bob Barr’s sole purpose is to write a 300 – 400 word opinion on ANYTHING controversial, with the simple goal of provoking people to blog an opinion. Reading these blogs, I conclude that once again he doesn’t disappoint.
His AJC job is to piss people off by authoring outlandish opinions about virtually anything, because that seems to be one of the simpler ways of provoking people to spend more time on AJC’s website.
The Tar and Feathers Party
February 17th, 2010
10:52 am
This just in: Yale University’s “Skull and Bones” secret society has been declared anti-christian and pagan by the right wing jesus freak nut jobs. No more drinking red wine from Jeronimo’s skull you guys, or U R gonna go to hell!
neo-Carlinist
February 17th, 2010
10:57 am
sorry, I had to got to church to have some dude, but more likely homosexual or pederast) smear ashes on my forehead. what were we talking about, again?
how2fish
February 17th, 2010
10:58 am
Chris thanks for your service !
neo-Carlinist
February 17th, 2010
10:59 am
I agree with Einstein Republican. I think Bob “jumped the shark”. C’mon Bob, you’re better than that. Who do you think you are, Glenn Beck (Morman, by the way – talk about your pagan rituals).
Steve0
February 17th, 2010
11:08 am
Now that it’s no longer 2008 I guess Bob can give up that whole Libertarian charade.
The Tar and Feathers Party
February 17th, 2010
11:11 am
Hmmm, I got a fire place, and I got ashes, so to save time and git full credit, ah kin smear ashes on mah forehead, and infiltrate the right wing jesus freak nut jobs!
The Tar and Feathers Party
February 17th, 2010
11:12 am
and you thought the Mossad was good, ha, the Tar and Feather Party’s got their own ashes fer ash wednesday!
FlightLines - Air Force Times blog for airmen – Bob Barr vs. the pagans
February 17th, 2010
11:13 am
[...] what does Bob Barr have to say? On his Atlanta Journal-Constitution blog, the oh-so-cleverly-named The Barr Code, he states that “if I were in the Air Force and was [...]
Jefferson
February 17th, 2010
11:14 am
Jesus just left Chicago…
Mike
February 17th, 2010
11:15 am
You couldn’t even pick up a dictionary? From dictionary.com
Pagan:
1. one of a people or community observing a polytheistic religion, as the ancient Romans and Greeks.
2. a person who is not a Christian, Jew, or Muslim.
3. an irreligious or hedonistic person.
And kneeling before a statue of a guy nailed to a piece of wood is sensible, but a circle of stones is just crazy!
Salt & Light
February 17th, 2010
11:15 am
T0 The Tar and Feathers Party : As I said, “Blessed is the Naitin whose God is the Lord”. The reverse of that would be “Unblessed is the nation whose God is not the Lord.” That’s the direction we are headed ………………
To Fix-it: Christians believe in the Trinity (a Triune God – a concept the human mind cannot really comprehend anymore than “eternity”).
“In the beginning God (Father, Son and Holy Spirit) created the heavens and the earth.” Therefore, Christianity predates everything because Jesus in God incarnate !
“Jesus, the same yesterday, today and forever”.
Jay
February 17th, 2010
11:19 am
From Bob:
“Don’t get me wrong, if someone “has little or no religion and delights in sensual pleasures and material goods,” which is the definition of a “pagan,” then I say live and let live.”
Citation?
Woodrow
February 17th, 2010
11:21 am
I’m confused Bob. Since we (yep, military here.) already have churches that fit your obviously narrow views of acceptable religions on ALL military installations, where do you wish to draw the line? Catholic and Baptist ok, Methodist bad? Perhaps Islam ok, Buddhism bad? Perhaps you could take your sorry used to claim libertarian wishy washy and keep it to your self? That’d be great, ok? You embarrass the rest of us who actually believe in liberty.
The Tar and Feathers Party
February 17th, 2010
11:21 am
Dear Salt & Light: Actually, in the beginning there was a minute in-balance in the infinite fabric of nothingness that resulted in the big bag. All that U see, and all that you are is a mere imbalance in the fabric of nothingness, a mere microsecond in the immensity of Eternity.
Bru
February 17th, 2010
11:24 am
I don´t have any issues with pagans in the armed forces. But I don´t see why any body that´s not pagan has to pay for their house (ring) of worship. As for battle worthy leaders, well I would imagine and hope that they´re fighting for The United states of America, and their freedom to worship as they please.These people in our armed forces did not join to fight for their specific religions they joined to participate in the defense of the greatest idealogical country in the world´s history. And if they achieved a leadership position through merit, then I would follow them or fight beside them. Bob, you got this one wrong, I think if you reconsider, you may feel compelled to retract.
Master of Disaster
February 17th, 2010
11:25 am
If Andy Warhol had said “In the future everybody will be respected for fifteen minutes”, your time would be up.
MinneMama
February 17th, 2010
11:29 am
I’d be more concerned about depending on a group that had unsuccessfully tried to convert me. I wouldn’t want to have to rely on someone who thinks I’m evil because I won’t join his church. It’s that whole fundamentalist “if you ain’t one of us, you’re against us” mentality.
St. Honest John, Nephew of Mary
February 17th, 2010
11:36 am
Salt & Light
February 17th, 2010
11:15 am
BLAAAAA, BLAAAAA, BLAAAAAAA !!! And Earl Paulk was not doing his brothers wife either!!!! ROTFLMAO
Heather
February 17th, 2010
11:38 am
Bob doesn’t seem to recall a story a few years back how cadets were being forced to attend Bible study classes by their commanders. I guess this would be OK, because it is Christianity.
BTW, look up Patton’s religious beliefs.
Kevin Keeney
February 17th, 2010
11:38 am
“These young men and women signed up as a part of a military entity of “One Nation Under God””
Perhaps they should have read the Constitution of the United States first, then, instead of mindlessly repeating a loyalty oath that was modified by the Knights of Columbus — a Catholic fraternity — in 1954.
somewhereinga
February 17th, 2010
11:44 am
The Air Force is letting Wiccans in? Damn! Next thing ya know they’ll be letting in Jews and blacks….Huh?
Bob Barr Questions Tolerance of Pagans at Air Force Base
February 17th, 2010
11:50 am
[...] Barr Questions Tolerance of Pagans at Air Force Base Pagan worship at Air Force Academy Originally Posted by Bob Barr … if I were in the Air Force and was being commanded by an [...]
Ralph
February 17th, 2010
11:51 am
Sucking the bloof of a god, wearing funny robes and swinging a smoking mace, failing around on the floor like a snake and babbling incoherently. And your laughing at people walking around two stone rings. HA HA HA HA jerk.
Boss Host
February 17th, 2010
11:53 am
Mr. Bob apparently forgot the success of past military greats. Of course the Mongolians adhered to the strict policy of *insert arbitrary religion* or when the Romans conquered the Mediterranean, while following a strict reasonable religion. Of course the Centurions or Julius Ceasar himself practiced the fine art of bull sacrifice or consulting the sacred chickens for the will of the gods.
Max
February 17th, 2010
11:58 am
I’m embarrased that I voted for you.
Mitchell
February 17th, 2010
12:04 pm
Yeah, because this is SO much sillier than worshiping a bronze age carpenter who sent himself on a suicide mission to save humanity from the fate he damned them to.
Tod
February 17th, 2010
12:05 pm
I see another libertarian has now joined the Christian right wing.
John
February 17th, 2010
12:06 pm
The “hedonism being another part of definition of Paganism” comment is really lame. Equivocate much, Mr. Barr?
Anyway, the Pagan has to go into combat with people who engage in simulated ritual cannibalism; if he can take it, so can they.
Jeff
February 17th, 2010
12:12 pm
Pagan (noun) -
1. one of a people or community observing a polytheistic religion, as the ancient Romans and Greeks.
2. a person who is not a Christian, Jew, or Muslim.
3. an irreligious or hedonistic person.
Please do not cherry-pick the definitions of words in order to justify your rants. It should also be pointed out that Wicca is not necessarily an historical pagan religion but is in fact a relatively new form of nature worship incorporating elements of several different pagan religions.
Gerald West
February 17th, 2010
12:14 pm
Silly stuff, Mr. Barr. Religion is religion, to each his own, stay out of it!
Jeff
February 17th, 2010
12:18 pm
Damnit Bob, what kind of Libertarian would write an article like this? You don’t believe all people should have religious freedom? Just people who have beliefs close enough to yours?
Jeff
February 17th, 2010
12:20 pm
Addendum: You note in your op-ed piece here the following:
“But I have to tell you, if I were in the Air Force and was being commanded by an officer who practices hedonism as a religion (another part of the definition of “pagan”), and who dances around a circle of stones in the woods carrying a lighted candle, I would be more than a little worried about following him into battle.”
I’ll admit the scene you paint is somewhat hilarious and somewhat accurate regarding Wiccan ceremonies I have seen with the exception of the hedonism, thus highlighting the fact that you do not know what you are talking about. That aside, is such a scene any more bizarre than a Pentecostal who starts “speaking in tongues” and then falls to the floor having a “seizure” because he is “moved by the Holy Spirit”. I had a first sergeant in the Army who used to do that on occasion when the chaplain would do a prayer with the unit.
Singling out a single religion you know nothing about because some of their ceremonies seem silly is the height of arrogance. Every major religion has rules or rituals that others may raise an eyebrow at. Some Baptists requiring their adherents to not drink or dance. The incredible gala event that is the Catholic Church (and as a gay man let me just say the hats are FABULOUS!). A group of Shintoists conducting Misogi by a river in Texas. Buddhist throat chanting. The strict social codes of Islam….etc…etc.
John K
February 17th, 2010
12:21 pm
Bob, you must be considering another run for office! Looking to get donations from the far right?
What makes one man’s myth better than another?
Glenn
February 17th, 2010
12:23 pm
If he was able to pass the screening , make it through bootcamp , & work his way up to an officers position one would have to assume he’s qualified . As far as following him into battle I wouldn’t be very concerned since its the air force . Maybe you should be concerned the next time you get on a commercial airliner .
Jeff
February 17th, 2010
12:31 pm
@ DRB: Let me address your points as you raise them.
“I first heard of this a few weeks ago from someone actually IN the military. His concern was exactly as you say, and it seems that the grest majority of those he has contact with in the military agree. Based on that, I am inclined to think that this effort may be undermining our best military efforts and I don’t think that the military is a good place for division, not for the military itself, and not for the individuals within it.”
As a former member of the military, an adherent to a non-Christian religion and a defense contractor, let me say that making such an assumption based on a discussion you had with someone who is “in the military” is a ignorant as Mr. Barr’s decision to use a partial definition to justify his argument. If such were the case then the military command would not allow such activities on post. The only people I know who get truly upset about this are civilians who hold to Christian beliefs.
“These young men and women signed up as a part of a military entity of “One Nation Under God” and I believe it reasonable that they should expect that special interests NOT under God, would be discouraged, or at the least not encouraged.”
I most certainly did not sign up for a military entity of “One Nation Under God”. Just because Eisenhower can convince Congress to add that little piece of jingoism to the pledge in the 1950’s does not make it a national policy. Even were that the case, whose God? The God of the Abrahamic faiths? The Kami of Shinto? The Asgard of the Astaru? The Bodhisattva of Buddhism? The Deva of Hindi? Members of those religions can be found in the military today serving their country. Are you telling me that we should violate the Constitution by denying some of them their faith in order to raise one God above the others?
Joseph
February 17th, 2010
12:33 pm
This joker doesn’t have the balls to respond to the comments. HA!
Woodrow
February 17th, 2010
12:37 pm
Oh yeah. On a side note, the other houses of worship(on base) were paid for with tax dollars. Why not this one? Who get to decide who is worthy? Bob Barr?
John K
February 17th, 2010
12:42 pm
I wonder how many of the authorized grave markers at Arlington National Cemetery are “Bob Barr Approved?”
http://www.arlingtoncemetery.org/funeral_information/authorized_emblems.html
David L. Oringderff, PhD
February 17th, 2010
12:44 pm
That was 1999, Mr. Barr. And you TRIED to take the Army to task for supporing religious pluralism (which is a mandate for the military chaplaincies). In your ignorance our our faith and practices, all you did was stir up a sensational flurry of bigotry and hatred. I find it hilarious that you claim to be a Libertarian. And the fact that you are a consultant on civil rights for the ACLU has influenced me to drop my support for that organization. Just an historical oberservation: Our Fort Hood Open Circle (SWC) is still alive and thriving. Who is occupying your former seat in Congress right now?
BSI
February 17th, 2010
12:47 pm
I’d like to think this story is nothing more than a poor attempt at comment-baiting, but sadly, it would seem this “Barr” person is serious…. And so here’s further proof that there is NO resemblance any longer between the USA I read about in school and the one populated by these hate-spewing nightmare people. Fine, take away the Wiccan circles but then please remove and/or destroy any religious items, including those dedicated to that bearded white man that SEEMS so popular in this country.
Darth Snowshoe
February 17th, 2010
12:47 pm
The food was great, the tree plugged in, the meal had gone without a hitch
Till Timmy turned to Amber and said, “Is it true that you’re a witch?”
Don't Eat People
February 17th, 2010
12:54 pm
Bob I agree. I also heard about how the Air Force build a whole worship area for another weird religiion. These weirdos take alcoholic beverages, pray and make motions over the beverages, and then believe the benerages are turned into blood. Then they drink the blood! That’s right, their whole twisted religious ceremony involves intentionally drinking what they believe is blood. Then they take crackers, pray a bit, and *poof* they believe they turn them into human flesh. Then they eat that too! Can you imagine? Can’t they tell it’s still alcohol and crackers? And why do they need to bring alcohol into their religion, just to get an extra high I suppose, or maybe their magic doesn’t work on water? I think the Air Force called the worship area a “church”. Weird.
Aquagirl
February 17th, 2010
12:55 pm
Mr. Barr is pretty pompous. Apparently the cadets can spare time to break the record for most air guitar players.
“Apparently, the people over at Guinness World Records take the playing of imaginary instruments quite seriously, or so found the Air Force Academy Athletics department as they planned their most recent and rather wacky promotion: Rock for the Cure, an attempt to break the world record for largest air guitar ensemble during half time of the Air Force Women’s Basketball game against New Mexico on Saturday”
http://www.gazette.com/entertainment/air-94261-world-force.html
MiHi
February 17th, 2010
1:09 pm
So, you like it when people make torture porn videos of pets being tied down and trampled to death (we still haven’t forgotten how you supported the “Crush Video” industry when you were still in office, Bob), but find offense at someone who’s practicing a religion even older than Christianity?
You have a very peculiar set of values there, Mister Barr.
Loonesta
February 17th, 2010
1:12 pm
Isn’t war all about human sacrifices? Whether we’re dealing with goblins and ghosties or just your typical Christian soldiers trudging onwards, the military is all about the killing of other people. And the Christians are far more insufferable.
Kathryn
February 17th, 2010
1:17 pm
Mr. Barr, who are you kidding? I served with honor and even a small amount of distinction in our military decades ago, when I had to hide my religious preferences because of idiots like you. Oh, I was allowed to die for my country, but not to admit I was a Pagan. Sworn enemies of God??? Where are you getting your information? If you would do a little reading instead of spewing your vicious nonsense, you might not sound quite so abysmally ignorant. I doubt if you would know any form of spirituality if it bit you on the – well, on whatever you’re using for a butt these days. Libertarians are about freedom for everyone, including freedom of religion. If you aren’t one, don’t call yourself one.
Grasshopper
February 17th, 2010
1:17 pm
I just want to set the record straight on two things here.
First: The Air Force Academy is not funding this construction. The project is being undertaken by a Wiccan Airman, who has already had to tear down one circle that he built because it had gone through the appropriate approvals process. This new circle has gone through the appropriate approvals process for its location, and is being entirely funded by private citizens.
Second: God is God, in whatever form you believe that to be. For Christians, a triune god is a requirement (though there is no mention of this in the Old Testament – thank you, second College of Cardinals c. 1400s) For some Wiccans, God is a dualistic force (the Goddess/God), for satanists (yes, I mean satanists, not luciferains) – they are their own god, for luciferians – God is Satan. But whatever name you give to it, or pattern of approach you use to understand the divine, it is incumbent upon you as an individual to make your own choices. No one can tell you what to believe or how to practice those beliefs.
And finally, in passing: God doesn’t care whether you believe in Her or not. Just as I don’t care whether or not you agree with me.
Grasshopper
Bob Barr doesn’t like freedom of religion « FemBot
February 17th, 2010
1:18 pm
[...] 17, 2010 Well, gee, and here I was thinking he was some kind of libertarian, or something. I guess Wicca doesn’t count? “The US Air Force, at no less a [...]
Malvond
February 17th, 2010
1:20 pm
This article is almost too dumb to be offensive. Any valid opinions he might have (not that I really saw any) are null and void because of his obivously and severely limited understanding —and arguably his unwillingness to understand— a broader meaning of “pagan” and of the Wiccan religion.
Barnaby C
February 17th, 2010
1:20 pm
I would rather be led into battle by a pagan than a fundamentalist like General William G. Boykin who sees the War on Terror in apocalyptic terms.
Jay
February 17th, 2010
1:23 pm
From Bru:
“I don´t have any issues with pagans in the armed forces. But I don´t see why any body that´s not pagan has to pay for their house (ring) of worship.”
Who do you think pays for the academy (christian) chapel? As a taxpayer, I do, and I’m Buddhist. Is somebody going to reimburse me? Of course not.
Bob Barr very concerned about witches — seriously « Some Country for Old Men
February 17th, 2010
1:23 pm
[...] Former Republican House member and Libertarian presidential candidate Bob Barr apparently writes a blog at the Atlanta Journal-Constitution. His latest subject: witches! At the Air Force Academy! A few years [...]
Alternative Sources
February 17th, 2010
1:23 pm
I always marvel at the performance of an atheist in the arena of his written words. The temerity of his doubt, gnawing away at the wooden cross like mutant termites immune from pesticides, ant-eaters and those chimpanzees that fashion tools out of sticks and plunge them into termite nests and have a nice lunch.
Monkeys don’t have souls. Atheists don’t have souls. Monkey see, monkey do. See no evil. Hear no evil. Speak no evil.
Hear, Hear! A barrel of monkeys typing on a million typewriters for a million years could produce the gospels, you know.
So enjoy your moment of self aggrandizing theology. We’re all impressed! Some of us are converted. Some are praying for your soul.
Me? I’m grinnin’, and knittin’ a shawl, and every now and then I cry out, “Guillotine!”.
No wait, that was for Marie Antoinette. never mind. If the truth be told, at 59, I’m considering renouncing my catholicism and joining the pagans. I wonder if any of the pagans who join hands and dance around the circle of stones naked have an older sister for me? Um, sir? Um, Tell your sister that I like long walks on the beach, chick-movies, and world peace. (I’ve got beads too. So hush hush. I owe you one bro.)
The Tar and Feathers Party
February 17th, 2010
1:30 pm
So R they burning live sheep on stone altars waaay out there in Colorado?
The Tar and Feathers Party
February 17th, 2010
1:31 pm
Mmmmm Mmmmm roast mutton, food of the Gods. Pass the mint jelly please.
Salt & Light
February 17th, 2010
1:31 pm
To all who responded to my posts … thank you.
Enjoy any paper currency you spend today …….. “In God We Trust”.
I didn’t ask you to believe in the Trinity………I just stated I did. It’s between you and God.
For those who were a little to flippant (not toward me but God) please remember “God is not mocked.”
I wish you well …………………………..
Jeffrey Paul Zacher
February 17th, 2010
1:38 pm
I would die to defend there beliefs as much as I would whatever yours are…the Bill of Rights, and this was the first thing written in response to the Constitution, clearly states “Congress shall make no law respecting an Establishment of Religion” So I assume that whoever wrote that believed that whatever religious belief or practice one held in private was of no public concern.
I’ve never been in the military, but I would hope in a life or death situation the private affairs of my CO would be the last thing on my mind. I mean if all I could think about in such a situation were things about my CO’s personal life then I would have a defect as a solder.
Bob
February 17th, 2010
1:40 pm
LINO? Don’t tread on me, Bob!
Advocates for Liberty
February 17th, 2010
1:47 pm
Why do we always miss the forest for the trees. The actual question should be why a tax funded university should be catering to ANYONE’S faith. There are surely several places of worship near the Air Force Academy. While I do not share the spiritual views of pagans, I respect their right to worship what and how they choose. However, I do not think that special considerations or meeting places should be created for ANY faith–Christian, Jew, Muslim, Pagan, etc.
No one is making these students attend the Air Force Academy. If your faith clashes with the lack of worship accommodations, choose to go somewhere else for a college education and career.
Libertarian philosophy does not align with forced acceptance of any faith or lifestyle. Nor does it align with the condemnation of a faith or lifestyle. Live and let live also means that you don’t give favor.
Grasshopper
February 17th, 2010
1:52 pm
Advocates for Liberty:> Are you suggesting that the Air Force Academy tear down their Christian Chapel?
I’m all for equal treatment for everyone, but I think that suppression of all faiths is just as bad as suppression of any one faith.
Nick C.
February 17th, 2010
1:52 pm
Shame on you, Bob. There is no room for this sort of bigotry in my view of Liberty. The “Barr 2008″ sticker will come off my car, and if you ever get the nod from the LP again, that will be the last time I renew my membership at either the state or federal level. This isn’t the sort of principle I want espoused by my Party of Principle.
Woodrow is Right
February 17th, 2010
2:11 pm
I believe the tab for the multi-faith chapel at the USAFA was roughly $4 million (and that’s 1964 dollars). The bottom line is, far more people have died in the name of (choose one) god than have been saved.
Stef
February 17th, 2010
2:33 pm
Mr. Barr:
I am a pagan priest. I’m rather disappointed by your characterization of the Neo-Pagan religion. It is sad that you feel the best way to judge a religion is by looking in the dictionary and choosing the third or fourth definition of the most general term describing it.
The term “pagan” is derived from paganus, a Latin term meaning “country dweller”. It refereed to the fact that people in the country tended to keep the old ways longer than than the more sophisticated members of society who adopted monotheism. It’s sort of a synonym for “hick” used this way; ironic since, in Western society, that negative connotation has been transferred to Protestant Christians.
It is also sad that connotation equally misrepresents both pagans and Christians, not just in the validity of their religious practice, but in the thought with which they approach that practice.
Pagans are not necessarily hedonists, though I’ve known a few who are. Very few have “little or no religion” but have strong, deep seated beliefs concerning the nature of the gods and of ethics and of how we should treat one another. Certainly, some self professed pagans match the description you present. Lumping all pagans into that category, however, is akin to lumping all Muslims into the small pool of suicide bombers; it looks good in the headlines, but is a fallacious bit of slander, nothing more.
If you believe that I and my fellow pagans are nothing more than a few chuckle heads who like to party and pass it off as a faith, I fail to see what setting up a couple of circles of stones in any way is an gross over-accommodation. If you see us as members of a valid, First Amendment protected religion, I understand your objection even less. In any case, I would encourage you, should you have to sum up the beliefs of a group of faithful worshipers in a few words, that you look at the first accepted definition or perhaps even ask one of those worshipers how they would define their own faith.
Peace.
Chris
February 17th, 2010
2:51 pm
Well if they are willing to serve in the military then they can worship whoever they want!
Byron Mathison Kerr
February 17th, 2010
2:51 pm
Oh, please! Why so many thick skulls when it comes to the military?! The main concern one soldier can legitimately have about fighting alongside another soldier is if that soldier is an EFFECTIVE soldier. Surely, sexual orientation, race, gender, nationality, etc., and especially religion matters little if that other soldier can save your @$$!
The Tar and Feathers Party
February 17th, 2010
3:01 pm
Mr. Bar: A VooDoo priest is even now waking zombies to follow you through all your days….booowaaaahhhhh, sleep tight with the night lite on….What is under the bet….
Joseph
February 17th, 2010
3:06 pm
I knew the libertarian schtick wouldn’t last too long; you’re just too much of a Christian conservative ideologue, wanting to tell other people what Gods they can and cannot worship, based on nothing more than your own personal bigotry and prejudice.
RobW
February 17th, 2010
3:20 pm
Well, this wouldn’t be the first time Bob Barr went on a witch hunt.
I find it interesting that someone who’s never actually followed anyone into battle would have such strong opinions about who he’d “follow into battle”. Typical armchair warrior.
Tim McDonald
February 17th, 2010
3:21 pm
Huh what?! Pagan=Hedonism? Only if you’re using the term in a slanderous, ethnocentric tone. The etymology is a rural civilian connected to the gods of pre-christianized Roman. Pickup a etymological dictionary at your local bookstore or library before heading onto the Internet with the big boys and girls.
I also fail to see what is any more hilarious about a nature-based religion worshiping outdoors, than a death-cult (Christianity) singing and praying to the effigy of a dead guy on a cross indoors. Let us know Mr. Barr.
jim
February 17th, 2010
3:21 pm
So building multi-million dollar chapels to monotheism is OK, but put a couple thousand into a place for nature worship is wrong…..
The more I hear from fundamentalists, the happier I am I became a witch.
We promote self healing and care for others, not hatred because someone is different. Sure it takes a little getting used to, real freedom is not easy to understand when you are used to repression.
It takes a lot to say “Do what you wish, as long as it does not harm to others, or yourself.” We learn very early to want to control others. This article and some of the reactions are a perfect example.
The Tar and Feathers Party
February 17th, 2010
3:30 pm
Ra is out today, shining brightly in the blue sky….All bow before the glory of Ra.
Kimberly
February 17th, 2010
3:41 pm
@drb and to others who do not know the “One Nation Under God” history.
In 1955, with President Eisenhower’s support, Congress added the words “In God We Trust” on all paper money. In 1956 it made the same four words the nation’s official motto, replacing “E Pluribus Unum.” Legislators introduced Constitutional amendments to state that Americans obeyed “the authority and law of Jesus Christ.”
The efforts to bring God into the state reached their peak during the so-called “religious revival” of the 1950s.
Rev. George M. Docherty, the pastor of the Presbyterian church in Washington gave a sermon that Eisenhower attended. Docherty urged the inclusion of “under God” in the pledge to denote what he felt was special about the United States.
The legislative history of the 1954 act stated that the hope was to “acknowledge the dependence of our people and our Government upon … the Creator … [and] deny the atheistic and materialistic concept of communism.” In signing the bill on June 14, 1954, Flag Day, Eisenhower delighted in the fact that from then on, “millions of our schoolchildren will daily proclaim in every city and town … the dedication of our nation and our people to the Almighty.”
—-
Therefore, our Founding Fathers, although very devout men, were advocates of freedom for all religions – a principle and a guaranteed right sadly forgotten in our modern time.
chronkite
February 17th, 2010
3:43 pm
Hey, Mr. Barr, which is more insane?
Dancing around some rocks or sending a bunch of young guys to their deaths for whatever trumped up purpose your politician bosses decided was “worth it”?
I wonder how many people have gone to their deaths because their commander held crazy beliefs that were in the norm, like, oh, I dunno…Christianity…
Is it safe to say it’s in the billions?
Seems to me that rock-dancing is just pissing in a hurricane at that point.
The Tar and Feathers Party
February 17th, 2010
3:50 pm
Eisenhower got credit for stuff he never did, like defeating the Germans. Ivan did the dirty work, and Ike took the credit. If Ike had face the top 2/3rds of Hitler’s armies, rather than the weakest 1/3rd, he would have wet his panties.
Laura Roberts
February 17th, 2010
3:51 pm
You know this little article is full of misinformation and an biased opinion. Regardless of this mans’ opinion we are guaranteed freedom of religion as stated by the Consistitution. My greatgrand father, grandfather, father, my self and now my Pagan Army SSGT with four combat tours under his belt serve and fight to protect this mans right to post ignorant statements, as we also fight/fought for our rights to practice our religious beliefs as we see fit as long as they harm none.
So, Mr Bar, when spouting your opinion, kindly do some research and get the facts straight so you don’t sound so misinformed. Bigotry is bad enought without being ignorant of the FACTS.
Blessed Be,
Laura
Pagan USAF Vet
Tim McDonald
February 17th, 2010
4:01 pm
@Laura Roberts – Amen sister!
Ok, now enough rewarding this guy with some attention. Time to move onto other articles with merit in providing contributions.
Bob Barr and the military pagans « Nanobots Will Enslave Us All
February 17th, 2010
4:01 pm
[...] Libertarian Presidential loser Bob Barr wrote in the Atlantic Journal Constitution a hilarious piece of commentary about how he is shocked SHOCKED I TELL YOU that the military still allows pagans to serve openly in [...]
Alternative Sources
February 17th, 2010
4:04 pm
Pagans are a motorcycle club, man, and if they find out you pansies are dissin’ them on this blog, (which I’ve already made that phone call, pals), then woe is thee.
Go into hiding. Stop commenting here. You may get through this. But don’t tempt fate by commenting anymore. that goes for all the repudlickan pudwits on this blog.
I’m only trying to save your lives. Don’t blame me for the Pagan’s evil doings, man. Not my baggage.
I’ll try to hold them off 4U.
Distemper Flea
NY TIMES BIG DAVID PATERSON STORY NOT REALLY BIG, ABOUT DAVID PATERSON » MEANINGFUL DISTRACTION
February 17th, 2010
4:07 pm
[...] tide you over till then, check out this article on the pagan witches and warlocks running the US military. [...]
The Wild Hunt » The Kids Are Alright and other Pagan News of Note
February 17th, 2010
4:08 pm
[...] politician-turned-pundit Bob Barr thinks about the Air Force Academy building a Pagan worship area, wonder no longer! “A few years back, when I was in the US Congress, I took the Army to task for permitting [...]
Brandon Longcrier
February 17th, 2010
4:14 pm
I just wanted to thank all the Pagans and non-Pagans who support us here at the USAF Academy. Freedom of Religion is a great thing to have here in the United States of America…even if former Congressmen don’t believe in it.
Obtaining the Stone Circle was a great victory and we can’t wait to dance around our circle of stones in the woods carrying lighted candles.
Many Blessings to you All,
Brandon Longcrier -
Phoenix Blue
February 17th, 2010
4:27 pm
I had been Pagan for about four years when I joined the Air Force in 1999, just as then-Congressman Bob Barr went on his ill-educated rant about the Fort Hood Open Circle.
I’m *still* in the Air Force … and stationed at the Air Force Academy, no less. He’s no longer in Congress. I guess that makes my gods more powerful than his, huh?
oldfart
February 17th, 2010
4:30 pm
Christian nation? From the founding fathers themselves:
It always helps to look at the words of those who were the actual founders and creators of this nation two hundred and twenty six years ago. Witness the truth of the matter.
I have examined all the known superstitions of the Word, and I do not find in our particular superstition of Christianity one redeeming feature. They are all alike, founded on fables and mythology. Millions of innocent men, women and children, since the introduction of Christianity, have been burnt, tortured, fined and imprisoned. What has been the effect of this coercion? To make one half the world fools and the other half hypocrites; to support roguery and error all over the world …
The clergy converted the simple teachings of Jesus into an engine for enslaving mankind … to filch wealth and power to themselves. [They], in fact, constitute the real Anti-Christ.
Thomas Jefferson
The Christian god can easily be pictured as virtually the same god as the many ancient gods of past civilizations. The Christian god is a three headed monster; cruel, vengeful and capricious. If one wishes to know more of this raging, three headed beast-like god, one only needs to look at the caliber of people who say they serve him. They are always of two classes; fools and hypocrites. To compel a man to furnish contributions of money for the propagation of opinions which he disbelieves and abhors, is sinful and tyrannical.
Thomas Jefferson
Accustom a people to believe that priests and clergy can forgive sins … and you will have sins in abundance. I would not dare to dishonor my Creator’s name by [attaching] it to this filthy book [the Bible].
Thomas Paine
For here we are not afraid to follow truth wherever it may lead, nor to tolerate error so long as reason is free to combat it.
Thomas Jefferson
It does me no injury for my neighbor to say there are twenty gods, or no God.
Thomas Jefferson
Question with boldness even the existence of a God; because, if there be one, he must more approve of the homage of reason, than that of blind-folded fear.
Thomas Jefferson
Whenever we read the obscene stories, the voluptuous debaucheries, the cruel and torturous executions, the unrelenting vindictiveness, with which more than half the Bible is filled, it would be more consistent that we called it the word of a demon than the Word of God. It is a history of wickedness that has served to corrupt and brutalize mankind.
Thomas Paine
I do not believe in the creed professed by the Jewish Church, by the Roman Church, by the Greek Church, by the Turkish Church, by the Protestant Church, nor by any church that I know of. My own mind is my own church.
Thomas Paine
My country is the world, and my religion is to do good.
Thomas Paine
Let us with caution indulge the supposition, that morality can be maintained without religions.
George Washington
Of all the animosities which have existed among mankind, those which are caused by difference of sentiments in religion appear to be the most inveterate and distressing, and ought most to be deprecated. I was in hopes that the enlightened and liberal policy, which has marked the present age, would at least have reconciled Christians of every denomination so far that we should never again see the religious disputes carried to such a pitch as to endanger the peace of society.
George Washington, letter to Edward Newenham, October 20, 1792; from George Seldes, ed., The Great Quotations, Secaucus, New Jersey: Citadel Press, 1983, p. 726]
There is nothing which can better deserve our patronage than the promotion of science and literature. Knowledge is in every country the surest basis of public happiness.
George Washington, address to Congress, 8 January, 1790
Religious controversies are always productive of more acrimony and irreconcilable hatreds than those which spring from any other cause.
George Washington, letter to Sir Edward Newenham, June 22, 1792
…the path of true piety is so plain as to require but little political direction.
George Washington, 1789, responding to clergy complaints that the Constitution lacked mention of Jesus Christ, from The Godless Constitution: The Case Against Religious Correctness, Isacc Kramnick and R. Laurence Moore W.W. Norton and Company 101-102
If they are good workmen, they may be from Asia, Africa or Europe; they may be Mahometans, Jews, Christians of any sect, or they may be Atheists….
George Washington, to Tench Tighman, March 24, 1784, when asked what type of workman to get for Mount Vernon, from The Washington papers edited by Saul Padover
To give opinions unsupported by reasons might appear dogmatical.
George Washington, to Alexander Spotswood, November 22, 1798, from The Washington papers edited by Saul Padover
…I beg you be persuaded that no one would be more zealous than myself to establish effectual barriers against the horrors of spiritual tyranny, and every species of religious persecution. George Washington, to United Baptists Churches of Virginia, May, 1789 from The Washington papers edited by Saul Padover
As the contempt of the religion of a country by ridiculing any of its ceremonies, or affronting its ministers or votaries, has ever been deeply resented, you are to be particularly careful to restrain every officer from such imprudence and folly, and to punish every instance of it. On the other hand, as far as lies in your power, you are to protect and support the free exercise of religion of the country, and the undisturbed enjoyment of the rights of conscience in religious matters, with your utmost influence and authority.
George Washington, to Benedict Arnold, September 14, 1775 from The Washington papers edited by Saul Padover
—-from http://www.anotherperspective.org
planetspinz
February 17th, 2010
5:26 pm
Who you should be concerned about are the Christian cross-burning white supremacists in the military, unless those are your voting base http://www.splcenter.org/images/dynamic/main/SPLC_letter_extremists.pdf
Daedalus
February 17th, 2010
5:26 pm
Given the recent practices at the AFA: anti-semitism, racism and sexual assaults on female cadets (I now refer to the AFA as the “Christian-Rapists Flight School”) a little tolerance of pagans is a trend in the right direction.
Now if we can only get the cadets to keep their anti-semitic comments to themselves, and to stop sexually assaulting the female cadets, we might be on to something.
Bianca Bradley
February 17th, 2010
5:43 pm
Dear Mr Barr.
I’m sorry but you are sadly informed of the definition of the word Pagan. I have met you and know you to be an intelligent man. I would encourage you to research further. The Airforce letting the circle stay there is no more worrying then having a space in the CVN 72. There were various Pagans(Wiccans, Discordians, probably even some reconstructionist faiths)there. I know that some were enlisted and some were officers. If they did their job, why would you worry about being commanded by an officer?
Why would the open air circle be any different at the Air Force Academy then a Jewish temple? Would you worry about officers that adhere to the Jewish, Muslim, Buddhist, Hindu faiths? If so why?
Pagan by the way is an umbrella term for various faiths. It encompasses Wicca(Btw and non BTW), Asatru, Greek, and Celtic reconstruction, Dianic, Druids, and a host of other paths I can’t name. It does not mean someone who worships hedonism. Pagans use the term Pagan because it hearkens back to the Roman name Paganus.
If you have any questions Mr. Barr I would be happy to answer them to the best of my knowledge, or at least point you in the direction where I think the answers may lie.
I wish you the best in your political endeavors as I believe our country needs more politicians like you.
Bianca Bradley
Lianna Costantino
February 17th, 2010
5:44 pm
Good grief. Well, tables are slowly turning. I just gave a lecture at 3 different universities on Christian Intolerance, and Mr. Barr was one of the stars discussed. I’m Pagan, part of that definition being Cherokee, and I agree with Black Air Force as well (think missionary schools, Trail of Tears, etc.). Historically, Christians have never played well with others. It’s difficult to be tolerant of others while your heel is pressing down on their necks, and you have the one and only “truth” and only YOUR God is “real”, etc. Common sense, common courtesy should rule, but as the saying goes, some people have just enough religion to hate. Where’s the love of Christ, Bob? Who is your neighbor? And if non-Christians can pay for Christian chapels, Bru, and Christian chaplains, etc., non-Pagans can support Pagan Circles as well. Fair is fair. One or the other, all or nothing. And when ANY prayer that holds one religious tradition over any other is forced upon anyone who is not of that tradition, and no consideration is given equally to others – not fair. Not equitable. People like Bob Barr should stop trying to legislate intolerance and ignorance, stop trying to legislate personal beliefs, and focus on legislating behaviors instead. As an ex-cop, I arrested people for what they did, not what they were thinking of doing. I know, I’m ranting on several topics raised in these blogs a bit erratically, but the bottom line is that Christians like Mr. Barr have none of my respect, and just as he was utterly impotent to stop Pagan practice at Ft. Hood when he came up against Dr. Oringderff, Christians in general have no power over us in general. As John Morley once said “You have not converted a man by silencing him”. Some Christians are nice, but many need to get a life. I have NEVER been so arrogant, presumtuous or bored as to meddle in the beliefs of others. Many Christians cannot say the same. The inherent arrogance of being “right” and owning the only “truth” there is gets in their way. We’ll not be silent any longer. And we are everywhere. Get used to it. Lianna Costantino
LibertyOrDeath
February 17th, 2010
5:57 pm
How can bob barr call himself a libertarian? He has and always will share the ideology with right wing republicans. Please stop calling yourself a libertarian bob. Libertarians belief in freedom of religion without restriction with no exeption.
Mike Hale
February 17th, 2010
6:03 pm
God damn…I’m disgusted that I actually voted for you. If I wanted a close-minded fundy for president, I woulda voted for Palin.
*shakes head*
Bob Barr’s new Atlanta Journal-Constitution article on paganism causes a stir | Independent Political Report
February 17th, 2010
7:07 pm
[...] The original piece by Bob Barr at AJC: [...]
Kristy
February 17th, 2010
7:38 pm
I feel his comments about the stone circle divisive. I feel that the soldiers should be able to practice openly their religion. I don’t say this because I happen to be Pagan myself. I would be just as upset if it were someone with the believes of Mr. Barr. This is not the first time he’s come out against Pagans. Like John K. says, what makes one man’s myth better than another. Mr. Barr’s attitude is exactly what the founding fathers were trying to avoid. For those of the “this is a christian nation” crowd, Jefferson was a deist. Futhermore, what if it were your beliefs that were being treated as second tier?
Linda
February 17th, 2010
8:01 pm
man, and I voted for you? what WAS I thinking? And, no, I’m not pagan. But, I do have a lot of respect for their beliefs and practices. I don’t see that a wiccan AF officer is any better or worse than a Baptist, or a Catholic, or a Mormon or a Jew.
Rev. Michael Engelking
February 17th, 2010
8:14 pm
Bob, you make me sick! It was a pleasure seeing your ass get the boot out of washington. your career in politics is dead. no one gives a sh&t what you think, Wiccans still worship in ft hood 10 years later, now wiccans have a place in the AF, wicca also has their pentacle used on graves stones for wiccans who lost their lives fighting for the freedom for you to write this bigoted letter. when supporting the troops doesn’t mean support christians troops only it means actually what is say support the troops all troops of all faiths, wiccan soldiers aren’t putting their lives on the line to be discriminated by ignorant idiots like you.
GSROBIII
February 17th, 2010
8:22 pm
I see that the bigotry that got you in trouble several years ago is still with you. I am an openly serving pagan and my Soldiers have no problem with what I believe. Obviously you don’t know much about Soldiers or you only talk to the fringes. I have honorably served this nation for almost 25 years and there has never been a question about my ability to lead based on my religion. I have served with Soldiers of a wide variety of religions and with very few exceptions, none cared about my beliefs any more than I cared about theirs. I have always ensured that, mission allowing, my Soldiers got the opportunity to get the the religious service of their choice and our Chaplain was/is always welcome to address my Soldiers. I have never heard a pagan Soldier say the they could not go on mission due to services, but I have certainly heard Soldiers of other religions say this. I could continue and poke holes in your statements above, but I will not lower myself to the level that you have attained. I choose to follow a path that makes me think, not follow the rules and dogma of someone who has never and will never walk the same path as I.
Blessed Be.
Todd
February 17th, 2010
8:35 pm
Mr. Barr’s error is the logical fallacy of equivocation, where the inappropriate definition of a word is used; in this case substituting the contextually incorrect definition “has little or no religion and delights in sensual pleasures and material goods” and “who practices hedonism as a religion” with the contextually accurate definition “a person who follows a polytheistic or pre-Christian religion.”
Todd
February 17th, 2010
8:37 pm
Mr. Barr’s error is the logical fallacy of equivocation, where the inappropriate definition of a word is used; in this case substituting the contextually accurate definition “a person who follows a polytheistic or pre-Christian religion” with the contextually incorrect definition “has little or no religion and delights in sensual pleasures and material goods” and “who practices hedonism as a religion.”
Barring Logic
February 17th, 2010
8:43 pm
Yeah, dancing around stones is simply stupid. Waiting in line to get a cracker – now THAT’S religion! Kneeling down every 10 minutes – sounds like religion to me! How about being dunked in water – yep, must be religion.
Get the point? Or, maybe since this is a ‘conservative’ blog I will need to spell it out since you guys just don’t get the most obvious things….
Hank Williams Jr.
February 17th, 2010
9:10 pm
Send me lawyers, guns and money, the S#IT has hit the fan !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1
Christopher M. Smith
February 17th, 2010
9:22 pm
It really horrifies me that I voted for you. I won’t make that mistake again. You fake libertarian. I don’t vote on people based on opinion, but based on a candidates overall platform. However, the religious intolerance that you just spewed is completely unacceptable. My understanding of the libertarian Platform is the government has no place in religion. So why do you think you can dictate what religion our soldiers can be?
Smapdi
February 17th, 2010
9:39 pm
Wow. I had formed a soft spot for you, Mr. Barr. I had foolishly believed that you weren’t a terrible hypocrite. I no longer have to give you the benefit of the doubt. Mission accomplished.
Reska
February 17th, 2010
9:42 pm
To Salt and Light
In the beginning there was Muspell (full of fire and blinding light) and Niflheim ( fill of ice and snow), in between was Gin-nun-ga-gap. The melting snow formed the ice giant Imir. He feel asleep and from his armpit came the first woman and the first man.
This is the begininng of the world, makin the Asatru the “right” religion.
You should read In The Beginning, by Virginia Hamilton.
Salt & Light
February 17th, 2010
9:51 pm
Reska :
“God is not mocked.” I wish you well.
MP
February 17th, 2010
10:02 pm
Every one of you Libertarian party people who voted for Barr are sheep – the wolf only changed his clothes.
When I heard the LP say Barr was their candidate, I asked my friends who are members of the LP why, given his actions against the Ft. Hood Open Circle in 1999.
“Oh, he apologized, it’s all good, don’t worry about that!”
None of them were Wiccan or Pagan – they didn’t have to worry back then that Bobby-boy’s actions would endanger them.
Mr. Barr, you are a disgrace.
Bob
February 17th, 2010
10:31 pm
How embarrassing… The LP has reached an all-new low.
Brandon Longcrier
February 17th, 2010
10:35 pm
I can’t wait till the Associated Press gets a hold of this.
Brandon Longcrier
February 17th, 2010
10:40 pm
Or maybe they already have….. {raises pinky finger to lips}
kenneth
February 17th, 2010
10:53 pm
So just who would you follow into battle, Bob? You had plenty of opportunity to serve in the Vietnam years, when I daresay there were no Wiccan officers, and probably no Wiccan enlisted either. I guess you got too busy with the college deferrments and political theories and living on Dad’s dime. Like 99% of today’s chickenhawk Republicans, you’re military experts and your warriorhood only works remote control via other people’s kids.
ErmestPayne
February 17th, 2010
11:04 pm
Religion is all superstitious nonsense for the simple minded. It doesn’t matter if they worship a tree or an invisible sky fairy. Oh, and America is all about denying the next person their rights or equality and not about helping them achieve it.
Keltasia
February 17th, 2010
11:09 pm
Too bad the person who wrote this article doesn’t have the journalistic integrity to look up the etymology of the term “pagan”. What a joke to the profession.
Robert
February 17th, 2010
11:12 pm
I regret voting for you back in ‘08 after reading this. What kind of chastise the choices about another individual makes? What kind of libertarian doesn’t support freedom of religion? I might be an atheist, but I think people should be allowed to express their religious preferences in whatever way they feel fit, and to see someone call themselves a libertarian who thinks otherwise is appalling.
I used to think you could change America, Bob, but now I realize that you are just another Republican. I am sorely disappointed.
Frammis
February 17th, 2010
11:13 pm
I love Christians! Remember when Jesus rode the dinosaurs? That was my favorite part of the Bible.
aboch
February 17th, 2010
11:22 pm
Bob Barr is doing exactly what I have suspected of many Libertarians for the past couple of years. They still are Republicans re-branding to something more popular. Good PR move I guess.
Jane M
February 17th, 2010
11:28 pm
“But I have to tell you, if I were in the Air Force and was being commanded by an officer who practices hedonism as a religion (another part of the definition of “pagan”), and who dances around a circle of stones in the woods carrying a lighted candle, I would be more than a little worried about following him into battle.”
Nice to see your cultural sophistication, Bob. The use of pagan as a pejorative (as in hedonist) is not to define it in a way that’s meaningful to practitioners. Furthermore, if dancing around outdoors disqualifies one for military leadership, then I guess you’ll be purging all the Jews next, since at Simchat Torah, dancing outdoors in celebration is part of the religious ritual. And let’s make sure to ban the use of candles in all our churches and synagogues because they are “hilarious.”
One more demonstration that Bob Barr is an intellectual lightweight, a superficial grabber at publicity and someone who goes for the cheap applause line.
John
February 17th, 2010
11:30 pm
So if you dance around some stones in a circle, you’re weird. If you believe on Sunday that you’re eating the body and drinking the blood of a long dead Jew (who never existed), then you’re normal. Makes “sense.”
Starshadow
February 17th, 2010
11:46 pm
If you don’t know what neopaganism is about, don’t make up stuff and pull it out of your fundament, Bob. Ask a real neopagan. Ask a Wiccan.
I suppose any religious practice looks silly to those who don’t practice it. Muslims kneel and bow to their god. Catholics play with beads and light candles, and follow men in dresses. Pentecostals “dance in the spirit.” Buddhists do a variety of things in the name of their religion.
What do you do, Bob? If you have a ritual, would you like it ridiculed the way you’re ridiculing ours? Are you in a position to point fingers? I think not.
Bob, you don’t have to like anyone else’s religion–or nonreligion. But ridiculing it as you’ve just done is beyond the pale. You owe neopagans and Wiccans in particular an apology. This has nothing to do with political correctness, it has to do with manners, and the appalling lack of them you’re showing, as well as your own illogic. Grow up, Bob. Your myth isn’t better than ours. It’s just different.
Brandon Longcrier
February 17th, 2010
11:47 pm
“Religion is all superstitious nonsense for the simple minded.”
There are many people who blindly follow, but making a statement like that is no better than what Mr. Barr is spewing. I’m Pagan and (speaking for myself only) I know that the Gods and Goddesses that I hold near and dear to my heart and soul come from within my own psyche; not out there somewhere. I and many others who follow Earth-Centered traditions do not believe in supernatural beings in the sky playing puppermaster. Most if not all of us believe that we are in 100% control of our lives. The ancients gave life to the things around them by personifying them, giving them faces, and eventually turing those personifications into Gods and Goddesses. What makes Paganism spiritual is the connection we feel with the natural energies of nature, the Earth, and the Universe as a whole. You can explain those energies away all day with science, but we still feel that there’s a connection to be had with nature and that is what Earth-Centered spirituality is all about. There’s nothing “superstitious” about it you truly know that it all comes from within.
sjcr
February 18th, 2010
12:03 am
Fascinating how it’s expected that the non-christian officers are expected to not only tolerate Christianity, but also accept it, and yet non-Christians are not afforded even the slightest tolerance. There are more of us than many of you know. The USAF decision is to be applauded. It’s a victory for the thousands of Pagan men and women who serve our country.
MCH
February 18th, 2010
12:06 am
Read the Treaty of Tripoli, it’s on wikipedia. It proves that America is not and never was based on the Christian religion, or any specific religion for that matter. It is signed by John Adams. Our founding fathers were deists and Christians, but they were firm believers in separation of church and state. The armed forces are made up of all kinds of folks, so all religions should be honored unless they promote hatred or violence towards others. Of course the military means violence towards others, so it’s a no-win situation. Pagans should be respected like all other religions.
Brandon Longcrier
February 18th, 2010
12:06 am
Yes sjcr, and I hope the thousands of Pagans out there who are still in the closet will now decide to come out and stand up for their rights and demand what’s rightfully theirs.
Bugger-off Bob
February 18th, 2010
12:19 am
Alright, jerkoffs, here is a quick and dirty history lesson. Freemasonry is the basis of Wicca. This is the percentage of Founding Fathers who were Masons. Whether or not you profess this to be “One Nation Under God”, do you really think it was the intention of the Founding Fathers to ban practice/beliefs that they considered sacred, upheld and fought for? If you don’t want to be a Wiccan, Pagan, Mormon, or anything else, don’t be. It’s nobody’s business to tell anyone else if their beliefs are valid; Bob Barr be damned. Paganism has a large enough representation that it deserves to be recognized by the Military. If these men and women are good enough to die for their country, have the decency to allow them to practice their beliefs in peace. Bob Barr, you should be ashamed of yourself for being so disrespectful to members of our Armed Services. Until your old ass is ready to pick up an M-16 and do their job, SHUT THE HELL UP! It’s amazing that you would dare you criticize any member of the military, when you, yourself, are a draft-dodger. Any Pagan Soldier is a greater Patriot than you. As well as Christian, Muslim, Jewish, Hindu, Native American, Atheist, or soldier of any other religion.
Category Total Number Involved Number & Percent Who Were Freemasons
Signers of the Declaration of Independence 56 9 — 16%
Signers of the U.S. Constitution 39 13 — 33%
Generals in the Continental Army 74 33 — 46%
http://www.bessel.org/foundmas.htm
Aazari
February 18th, 2010
12:23 am
So, do you think it’s hysterical that a bunch of people gather up inside a building and pretend to eat flesh and drink blood? How ghoulish! I wouldn’t want to follow such a person into battle! And, yes, I’m Pagan. No, I don’t have a religion. Religions are for programmable robots. I have a spirituality and a code of ethics. That means I do the right thing because it’s the right thing, not because I fear some vengeful god punishing me for doing otherwise. No religion is more valid than another except in the minds of the people practicing them. In the end, none of them are totally right or totally wrong because they are subjective and shaped by the people in them.
Kirk C
February 18th, 2010
12:24 am
Bob Barr is jack-a**…. wicca does not equal hedonium. if he’d listened when he met with them he might understand this, rather than getting his definition of “pagan” from the Pope Benedict the Rotweiller Dictionary.. but more importantly, if he truly honored and respected our constitution, he wouldn’t be making arguments that the government should go about violating the Establishment Clause.
Kevin
February 18th, 2010
12:28 am
“The Government of the United States of America is not, in any sense, founded on the Christian religion…” – John Adams, 2nd US President
Michael
February 18th, 2010
12:57 am
I was amazed when Bob teamed up with the ACLU awhile back — part of me wondered if he was turning over a new (and better) leaf. Guess not.
There are a lot of silly things believed by a lot of religious and spiritual people. I won’t go on to insult all the mainstream religions with examples of such. Regardless, maybe the only thing sillier is not believing in anything.
Pagan (and mainstream) religionists are perfectly capable of functioning well in the military. One would hope a military organized to protect all would also allow all to worship.
Bob Barr never got more publicity than when he went after the Pagans. Maybe he misses the limelight.
Chiyo
February 18th, 2010
1:04 am
When I google; “Wiccan Terrorist groups” I get nothing. When I google; “Christian Terrorist groups” I get an entire list! Army of God, Christian Identity, Lambs of Christ, Ku Klux Klan, and many more. These people have been committing domestic terrorist acts, killing other Americans for years and get no publicity. But the lack of attention they receive has not kept every blind, some of us know how evil this religion can be. Some of us would much more readily trust a pagan commanding officer, than a Christian one who might turn around shoot down one of his own… Bigotry, hatred and exclusivity are a learned behavior, Mr. Barr. I was an accomplished seminarian, serving an internship toward priesthood, when a Christian Terrorist group threatened to firebomb my Church because they didn’t like the way we were running things. That was my first lesson. Your bigotted and hateful post here has been my latest lesson, but I’m sure it won’t be my last. Every day I see another reason to marginalize Christians out of my life.
Doug De Clue
February 18th, 2010
1:21 am
Congressman… As a life long liberal Democrat I used to not think much of you back in the 90’s but when you stood up for the Constitution against the attacks on it by the Bush Administration when that was clearly a very risky position for you to take in your political career so I was pleasantly pleased and surprised at your intellectual honest and courage at that point to take on your own party over a point of principle.
In that light, attacking people who have chosen to serve in the military because they don’t practice the same religion you do or because they don’t practice one period is really a tremendous let down for me with respect to my opinion of your integrity.
We aren’t all Democrats or Republicans. We aren’t all white or black. Some of us weren’t born here either.
We aren’t all Baptists, or Methodists or Catholics or even Christians.
There are plenty of people who are Buddhists, and Muslims, and Jews, and even Atheists and Agnostics.
How is being a “Pagan” or “Wiccan” any different than that?
Frankly what worries me would be an officer who didn’t respect and love the Constitution – that’s what we really all have in common in the first place and what soldiers (like Congressmen) swear to protect and defend. If they really mean what they say in swearing that oath then being tolerant and respectful of another man’s (or woman’s) religion is really the most basic thing they ought to be doing before they do anything else.
Scott
February 18th, 2010
1:41 am
i would love for the military to boot out every non christian, just so the waterheads who think that the military is a christian group would see just how few there really are in there in there, and then they should boot out the catholics, and then the mormons and then the lutherians, and then ,,,, and then ,,, and then,, and then,,,
i guess bob has no plans to run for office again because this kind of hate will insure that he never gets a seat in any office.
i am so glad to know that the 15 years i spent protecting your rights didnt count because i dont bow down to your god,
Chris B
February 18th, 2010
2:06 am
My first thought took me to the Navajo code talkers; a group of men sent to the Japanese battlefield in WWII under the command of the United States Military. Their language allowed the allied forces to communicate tactical information despite the Japanese attempts to translate the messages. The Navajo language couldn’t be broken.
So I ask you, Mr. Barr – where does it say a man (or woman) who communes with nature can’t be trusted on the battlefield? I can’t be certain of the religious backgrounds of all the code talkers, but I would think some held their old traditions when facing the enemy. Some danced under the moonlight, around a fire, and praying to the spirits for guidance and strength. It made them heroes. What have your beliefs provided you, Mr. Barr?
The L
February 18th, 2010
4:10 am
@Salt & Light: No one is mocking your triple deity–only those of his followers who insist that they are the only “right” ones, that they have the only spiritual truth, etc. Such arrogance and disrespect for others doesn’t exactly endear you to others.
I thought your Messiah taught humility and “the last will be first.” Not to BE served, but to SERVE. Is that missing from your Bible, perhaps?
The L
February 18th, 2010
4:27 am
@Mr. Barr: Considering that you don’t hold with religious beliefs that Jack Chick considers to be “evil,” I take it you’re also against Catholics, Jews, Muslims, Buddhists, Mormons, Freemasons, atheists, and anyone who uses any version of the Bible other than the KJV serving in our military.
After all, your simplistic and demeaning characterization of my religion sounds like it came from a Chick tract. Maybe the next time you meet with Wiccans and other Pagans, you should actually listen to what we tell you about our religion.
Here’s some references in case you ever wish to talk about Paganism again–after all, you don’t want to make any more embarrassing blunders. Most of them are on Wicca, simply because this is the most commonly practiced form of Paganism in the US and thus has the most information available on it:
http://wicca.timerift.net/wicca101/index.shtml
Wicca: For the Rest of Us–Wicca 101. A basic overview of who we are and what we believe.
http://www.religioustolerance.org/witchcra.htm
Articles on Wicca by the Ontario Consultants on Religious Tolerance.
http://witchvox.com/
The largest Pagan newsletter on the Internet, updated weekly since 1997. The archives are all available for your perusal and neatly organized by section, including a section that describes Pagan traditions and rituals to newcomers.
Scott Cunningham, 1988. The truth about witchcraft today. Llewellyn Books.
Margot Adler, 2006. Drawing down the moon: Witches, Druids, Goddess-
Worshippers and Other Pagans in America Today [2nd ed.]. Boston: Beacon Press.
I do not expect you to make such ignorant and bigoted comments again, given the massive amount of information at your disposal and the sheer number of Pagans who have offered to tell you about our religion. If you do continue to make such comments, I will assume you have lost this list of resources and will gladly send it to you again.
Kat
February 18th, 2010
4:54 am
“Say nothing of my religion. It is known to God and myself alone. Its evidence before the world is to be sought in my life: if it has been honest and dutiful to society the religion which has regulated it cannot be a bad one”. ~ Thomas Jefferson
Kat
February 18th, 2010
4:55 am
Arthur Shopenhauer: “Religion is the masterpiece of the art of animal training, for it trains people as to how they shall think.”
Kat
February 18th, 2010
5:00 am
Jose Rizal: “No one has a monopoly of the true God, nor is there a nation or religion that can claim, or at any rate prove, that it has been given the exclusive right to the Creator or sole knowledge of His Being.”
Kat
February 18th, 2010
5:35 am
Choose your battles. Is undermining another’s religion really a good use of your time or a credit to your intelligence? Is stirring up strife and dissension among diverse humanity a good cause? I say no. It does however speak volumes of your inability to think for yourself, your lack of intelligence, comprehension and knowledge of the many belief systems in place in this country. I revel in the following quotes from my president: “We do not consider ourselves a Christian nation or a Jewish nation or a Muslim nation; we consider ourselves a nation of citizens who are bound by ideals and a set of values.”
“Whatever we once were, we are no longer a Christian nation – at least, not just. We are also a Jewish nation, a Muslim nation, a Buddhist nation, and a Hindu nation, and a nation of nonbelievers.”
(Thank the goddesses and gods that we have the first amendment!)
Rodney Derrick
February 18th, 2010
5:49 am
Bob- Have you ever criticized the Air Force Academy or the military for forcing evangelical Christianity on the students? This practice has been repeatedly reported in the past.
Tracie Holladay
February 18th, 2010
6:28 am
Barr is an idiot. Do NOT let him define the word “pagan” for everyone else – which is what he tries to do, TWICE, in this article. He is not a theologian or a historian and he cannot act as though he is (which is what he is doing in attempting to TELL people what “pagan” means). He is the reason I will never be a Libertarian and why I will strongly discourage any pagans or Wiccans from voting Libertarian.
Lady Whitewolf
February 18th, 2010
6:29 am
I had to laugh at what Ralph said. I may not be in the military, but if I was I would rather work with the person who is the best LEADER, not the most religious OR christian. And as you can probably tell by mu name, I myself am Pagan. I think that all branches of the military should respect ALL faiths….
Laura
February 18th, 2010
6:51 am
WOW, someone invite these people to a seasonal celebration so that they can see what is really going on. Amazing that people that consider themselves learned are this ignorant of the actual facts. And really, what dictionary are they reading? The definition of pagan in my webster, yes an actual book, says “country dweller” or “practitioner of a poly theistic religion”
Dick Cheney
February 18th, 2010
7:09 am
this ‘wiccan’ thing should be stopped ASAP! and everybody should worship my main man Lucifer, heil satan!
The Tar and Feathers Party
February 18th, 2010
7:29 am
Jesus H Christ, Bob, Get a life.
Alternative Sources
February 18th, 2010
8:12 am
Dont forget that religion that has all those snakes on a plane thingie. What about that? Snakes would be a good thing in battle. You could scare the bediddle daddle out of a enemy captive and get him to sing like a canary.
Like a bunch of priest candidates at a retreat. The bishop asks them, “What have you been doing all night?” The reply: “Army Training, Sir”.
or something equally idiotic.
Ivy
February 18th, 2010
8:40 am
Enter your comments here
Ivy
February 18th, 2010
8:44 am
Enter your comments here Wow, such ignorance coming from an educated, worldly man. Shame on you, Please don’t forget that Freedom of Religion means ALL religions, not just the ones YOU recognize as religion. I respecy you right to free speech, but you would do yourself favor by showing a little tolerance and respect. People have died so that we may practice our religion the way we see fit.
Hadriana
February 18th, 2010
9:04 am
Julius Ceasar and Alexander the great were pagans, and they didn’t seem to have any problems with ‘battle.’
This is why no one I know voted for Bob Barr for President. He’s a dangerous man that stands behind his conviction, no matter how stupid they are. One day he’ll see the light….
for starts, he needs to get rid of the idea that pagans aren’t God believing people. The nature of paganism is very tolerant – one can believe in the possibility of pantheons of Gods, and God unknown – you can believe in Jesus and I can believe in Krom or Athena or whatever, and we an all get along just fine.
People have been brainwashed since Vacation Bible School that the pagan world was just a bunch of …I dunno…sex craved maniacs. History shows clearly that MOST of western thought was born in pagan civilizations. Democracy anyone? Bob Barr would do well to remember that he stands on the shoulders of GIANTS, and a lot of those GIANTS were pagan.
HidingintheDeepSouth
February 18th, 2010
9:15 am
I am pantheistic and Buddhist(which makes me pagan). I have 3 points to make to Bob and my fellow readers.
1st. My Air Force family members share similar views to mine. Their service to their country is as honorable as anyone elses. In a free country, like ours is supposed to be, anyone is free to their religious beliefs or lack of beliefs as they are comfortable with. (They ARE tired of Christian religion being shoved down their throat EVERYWHERE in the Air Force.)
2nd. If the US pays to build a place of worship for Christians, they should for everyone, if not it would mean that the govt. is endorcing one religion over others and THAT is unconstitutional. But seriously folks, do you think a circle of stones cost as much as a church building. Be glad they didn’t want a temple! BTW, Knowing pagans, I imagine that the cadets did the work on this themselves.
3rd. Buddhist and Native Americans are pagan, and yet are not known for their “silly hedonistic” religious practice. Also, by one of the definitions of pagan; Hindus, Taoist, The non-Christian or Muslim African traditional religions, etc. are pagan. They are not so much of a minority, even in this nation, when taken as a whole.
Lastly, Barr, (who is from my Religious Right neck of the woods), demonstrated more than once his bigoted REPUBLICAN, not Libertarian, ideas years ago when he wanted to remove Wiccans from the military. My Wiccan military (Air Force) friends all freaked. They swore to uphold the Constitution and felt as though they were being betrayed by Barr and his ilk.
I have read and agreed with much Barr has written here and in CL, but I have never quite believed that he really believed in freedom due to these religious bigotries that he has.
Meeeee
February 18th, 2010
9:16 am
And people wonder why I as a Libertarian refused to vote for this guy.. Not only does he still not have a clue.. He really does not understand it is not about what religion a person has in the military. It is how effective one can be at his/her post.
Arentyoulibertarian?
February 18th, 2010
9:20 am
I thought you were supposed to be a libertarian. Clearly you don’t understand the concept. Go back to the republican party and you can surely find some psychotic christians to join in your religion bashing. While you are at it why not start gay bashing too?
I cannot believe you were ever associated with libertarianism. You make us all look bad!
David A. Wade
February 18th, 2010
9:22 am
I am a Vietnam veteran and a Pagan and your total misinformation about the Pagan religion is hitting an all time high! Try reading a book called “The Pagan Path” by Janet Farrer and Gavin Bone. Your probably will not do this though because it would take effort on your part and you obviously are not able to do this. Our rights under the constitution of The United States is protected and I am one of those people who have fought for our rights. My family fought in the American Revolution and every war since them to protect our rights and, in this particular maner, will continue to fight for our rights as Pagans!!!!
David A. Wade
U.S.A.F. Vietnam Veteran
noah c
February 18th, 2010
9:36 am
Don’t get me wrong, if someone “has little or no religion and delights in sensual pleasures and material goods,” which is the definition of a “pagan,” then I say live and let live. – Barr
Where the hell did he get his definitions from? Paganism’s definition for those that actually own a book or have access to the internet these days seems a little different-
1. (Christian Religious Writings / Theology) a member of a group professing a polytheistic religion or any religion other than Christianity, Judaism, or Islam
2. a person without any religion; heathen
adj
1. (Christian Religious Writings / Theology) of or relating to pagans or their faith or worship
2. heathen; irreligious
[from Church Latin pāgānus civilian (hence, not a soldier of Christ), from Latin: countryman, villager, from pāgus village]
Ya know, you think that with age would hopefully come wisdom. Good to see Mr. Barr continues to set fine examples of ignorance and bigotry many others will no doubt continue to follow.
Ed Joyce
February 18th, 2010
9:40 am
Mr. Barrr, I’m truly disappointed in you. Religion freedom is for everyone. Where is you criticism of the Catholic clergy who parade around in 10th century costumes, burning incense, and reciting prayers in Latin that no one can understand. Many religious ceremonies that our society accepts as routine should be included in your critique of Wiccan ceremonies – but the Wiccans are different and you have trouble accepting their differences. Shame on you – your views are a step backwards to a dark time of religious intoleration.
Betsy
February 18th, 2010
9:49 am
Pagan: a person who does not belong to any of the major world religions. This too is a definition of pagan! You should really get your facts straight before you spout your impressions of ’sacred space’ and ritual practice. If you know anything at all about religious practice, you would know that all of the rituals practiced by ‘book religions’ have their roots in paganism (from that Latin “country dweller).
Andy
February 18th, 2010
9:59 am
What are these so-called “Christians” doing going into the military in the first place? “Love thy enemy as thyself,” remember? “Turn the other cheek.” What hypocrites.
Brandon Longcrier
February 18th, 2010
10:07 am
I’d just like to add a few more definitions to some additional terms that are very misunderstood today.
Many people associate Pagans with the Occult and/or Cult. Let’s define those terms real quick.
Occult: “beyond the range of ordinary knowledge or understanding”.
To believe in God, miracles, or anything else that can’t be explained by science alone is “beyond the range of ordinary knowledge or understanding”, which includes every single religion / spirituality on the planet.
Cult: “a group or sect bound together by veneration (or belief) of the same thing, person, ideal, etc…“
Anything (the military, your job, your religion / spirituality, etc…) could easily fall under the definition of “Cult”. So when you get ready to write your next blog, don’t be so quick to throw words around you don’t fully understand as you clearly did in this one.
Jessica
February 18th, 2010
10:11 am
Wow. Your definitions of Wicca and Paganism are falling very solidly into the “did not do the research” category.
Xavier
February 18th, 2010
10:18 am
Isn’t it just awesome that these guys are fighting and dying for you to have the freedom to call them hedonists and for you to belittle their religion?
Brandon Longcrier
February 18th, 2010
10:42 am
Wikipedia:
“Christian Hedonism is a Christian doctrine current in some evangelical circles, particularly those of the Reformed tradition. The term was coined by Reformed Baptist pastor John Piper in his 1986 book Desiring God. Piper summarizes this philosophy of the Christian life as “God is most glorified in us when we are most satisfied in Him.” Christian Hedonism may anachronistically describe the theology of Jonathan Edwards.”
Thought that I should point this out.
John K
February 18th, 2010
10:58 am
Bob must be gearing up for something. He knows the Fundies will throw money at anyone who can convince them that their Jesus is under attack.
Iaintbacchus
February 18th, 2010
11:11 am
Saying that Wicca or any other panthiestic religion is incompatible with being in the American military is just plan wrong. It’s Monothiests who shouldn’t be allowed to serve. Every one of you, if you really believe religion also believes that the US government should be relpaced by your favorite flavor of religious law. Biblical, Sharia, Talmudic, it doesn’t matter. No one can be both a “good” Christian, Muslim, Jew or Mormon and also believe in a secular Democracy.
And the eight or nine of you who have already put forward the “one nation under God” cannard, which has only been in the pledge of allegence since the 1950s and doesn’t appear in the Constitution or any other officially sanctioned document at all, have proven my point. Get a clue. The Constitution starts out “WE THE PEOPLE” it does not include the phrase “IN THE NAME OF JESUS CHRIST”.
Panthiests: Budhists, Hindus, Wiccans, Asatru, Shintaoists, Unitarians; and Athiests/agnostics are the only true Americans and the only ones fit to serve in our military because they are the only ones who don’t think they have a lock on the “ONE TRUE FAITH”(tm). The rest of you just want a Taliban under a different name. Well you can’t have it. And the sooner the military gets rid of the rest of the Christofascist fanatics at the the Airforce academy the better.
Skwurl
February 18th, 2010
12:09 pm
F*** you Bob Barr.
One persons belief system does not determine their combat abilities.
To all you people who agree, F*** you too. Just F*** you.
You’re the reason people kill each other. You’re the reason why this country isn’t progressing.
You people need to get off you’re f***ing high and mighty holier-than-thou attitude and accept the fact that people, y’know, think differently than you!
Get out of the f***ing 1600’s people. Welcome to the 21st century, where blacks can own property, women can vote, and you can be any religion you want.
And by the way, to all you moralfags who are too sheep-like to look up the definition of ‘Pagan’ for themselves, Bob Barr strategically uses the SECOND definition listed of pagans.
In the Webster definition, the FIRST one is: 1; especially : a follower of a polytheistic religion (as in ancient Rome) http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/pagan
So yeah. F*** you. And don’t bother responding to this, I most likely will never look at this page again, so just rage at it.
And yes I’m Pagan- not Wiccan- and i’m going to pray about you to the devil while I’m sacrificing babies tonight.
If you didn’t realize I was joking about the devil and babies, f*** you for being an idiot.
Inuko
February 18th, 2010
12:19 pm
As a pagan serving in Iraq, one who is well on his way to earning his certification to being an ordained minister in the Sacred Well Congregation, as an American Citizen, as a human being, and above all, an organism with a cerebrum, I kindly ask you to know what on this green earth your talking about. I nearly threw up when I read this article. Since you’re too lazy to even hit up Wikipedia to find out what the heck you’re talking about, let me put this in the most simplified terms possible. I’ll try to walk the path of the enlightened, like Jesus Christ or Buddha, and try and teach you and alleviate your ignorance rather than bash you, insult you, or so forth (make no mistake, I’m no saint, but at least making the attempt to emulate such people is what most religions aim for, no?).
A “Pagan” refers to someone who follows a nature-based religion. It usually refers to most non-abrahamic religions (Judaism, Christianity, and Islam, if you’re not going to take the effort to find out what that means, and think I’m talking about some religion based on the worship of President Lincoln). These religions include, but are not limited to: Celtic, Norse, Greco-Roman, Shamanism, and Egyptian pantheons. the actual word “Pagan” come from latin “pagani” meaning ‘country folk,’ due to when Christianity became the ‘primary’ religion of Europe, most Urban areas were predominately Christian, whereas many people in Rural areas still held to their ancestral religion.
Oh, and talking about materialism in religion, ever heard of the Sistine Chapel (spelling?) in the Vatican. You know, the place with the Papal Throne? Where the popes commissioned the greatest artists of the time to do things like paint magnificent murals on every wall, craft chairs and thrones with gold inlay, et cetera.
Your ignorance and close-minded hatred of others’ religions reminds me of some pretty well known groups. Like, say, the crusaders, the Jihadists, the Al-Qaida, the Taliban, the Nazi Party, the Spanish Inquisition, I could go on for hours.
They say that more people have died in the name of God(s) than for any other reason. This is untrue. More people have died due to religious prejudice than any other reason for wars, because, after all, a good Christian, Jew, Muslim, Pagan, Buddhist, Hindi, or follower of any other religion would not condone violence out for other reason than for self-defense or defending the life of someone who cannot protect themselves.
Skwurl
February 18th, 2010
12:20 pm
One more comment-
He thinks Pagans can’t fight wars?
Who does he think ruled the planet until ‘Jesus’ was ‘born’?
The Barbarians, the Celts, the Vikings, the Goths, the Vandals, the Greeks, the Romans, the Egyptians, the Mayans, the Aztecs, the ancient Chinese. Some of the most war-torn savage people. They ruled the planet until Christianity came along.
They were all Pagan. And they liked to frolic naked in the woods with candles and rocks and with whatever other misconception people have.
And before people comment about how they’re gone now and how Christianity won- they didn’t BEAT the Pagans. They force-converted them.
Dawn
February 18th, 2010
12:21 pm
Wow, an incongruent rant by an obsolete man with old ideas. A libertarian? Not even close. This is a piece written by someone who agrees with people I work with — right-wing Christians. This guy is not for liberty. As for my opinion, the government shouldn’t be spening any money making an religious worship sites at all! And let’s get rid of the evangelism in the military as well. I am so tired of right-wing “Christian” nutjobs talking like their word is the word of their God. (I’m a deist btw, so go ahead and slam me…yawn.)
Dawn
February 18th, 2010
12:22 pm
ugh, couldn’t edit but spening=spending and the word an shouldn’t have been in there.
Michael Shanklin
February 18th, 2010
12:29 pm
Young kids who are thinking about dying for this socialist/fascist government….
DON’T SIGN THE CONTRACT!
Other than that….all religion is crazy to me. I won’t die for any of these “Gods”….that would most likely be pissed that humans are tarnishing their name like this…..bombing hundreds of thousands of innocent children overseas just to create more blowback. What the heck is wrong with these neocons and Keynesian liberal nation builders?!? This is NOT libertarianism, this is a discussion over the military industrial complex and most people on here disgust me with talk about how the military is somehow different than any other government program….
True libertarians reject statism, the military industrial complex is sucking away wealth faster than most programs….over $1 TRILLION a year! Complain about that instead……
It doesn’t matter who is directing troops when the troops are at home with their families……on our soil, defending our land! We should be complaining about the police the world state, not about who will control the police the world state! Our founding fathers and grandchildren would be glad they are not seeing this!!!
LibertyUnleashed
February 18th, 2010
12:30 pm
How did Bob Barr ever get the libertarian nomination? He is a neo-con and this article is nothing but lame. Imagine how the world would be if Bob Barr got to opportunity to outlaw anything he doesn’t like or in this case understand. Way to respect freedom of religioun Bob, get out of politics or at least go back to your neo-con republican party and stop pretending to be a libertarian.
Maggie
February 18th, 2010
12:35 pm
Lets hear it for the prejudiced bigot! Keep your opinions to yourself unless you know what you’re talking about Bar.
Maggie
February 18th, 2010
12:46 pm
And by the way even my atheist friend thinks you’re an idiodic, self centered, prejudiced, unenlightened prick. His words not mine but I agree totally.
lovelyliz
February 18th, 2010
1:04 pm
When I was in the military, ther ewas plenty of hedonism practiced by my fellow Christians in uniform. Just ask aboout Subic Bay, Clark AFB, any where a detachment lands or pulls into port, etc.
emo
February 18th, 2010
1:32 pm
“if I were in the Air Force and was being commanded by an officer who practices hedonism as a religion (another part of the definition of “pagan”), and who dances around a circle of stones in the woods carrying a lighted candle, I would be more than a little worried about following him into battle”
Interesting comment from someone who, as far as I can see, has never followed anyone into battle, or even onto a parade field…
Vandreyer
February 18th, 2010
1:42 pm
Yes, what a shame religious tolerance is taken to all new levels. By all means let’s go back to being intolerant bigots who make blanket assumptions and squeeze everyone into neat little stereotypes for easier target practice. God forbid (yours, that is) that you actually get to know someone and learn about him. You might just find you’re not so special after all.
Steph Reisner
February 18th, 2010
1:46 pm
I think it’s unfortunate a Libertarian has joined up with the far right wing Evangelical fringe on this one. I guess if we want to know who the bigots are we need to really pay attention to voting records and public comments like this when it comes time to vote. Party affiliation seems to be something one can change like clothing depending on the look they’re going for to attract the most money or voters. For the record I’m Pagan and proud (and really dislike your ignorant remarks about Pagan religions) and I’m sharing your ignorance and bigotry with all my pagan friends.
JTex
February 18th, 2010
1:58 pm
Bob,
Neither you nor any person agreeing with you on this topic deserves to live in this country. You have no respect for our Constitution, all your whinging about guns to the contrary. How dare you presume to be the arbiter of what religion is and is not “acceptable” to you. Religious freedom does not end because your comfort zone is impinged upon.
Shame on you, and shame on every single person who agrees with you. You have far more in common with Islamic extremists than you’d like to admit.
Eric
February 18th, 2010
2:36 pm
Well, I guess I have to ask then, Mr. Barr… Who WOULD you follow into combat? Seems to me like you were the right age to serve in the military in Viet Nam? Especially when there were all those good, upstanding, white Christians leading troops there. How was it that you managed to get out of serving? Since when does being a coward qualify you to criticize the brave? Since when did you earn that right? How many coffee machines did you have to shoot in order to rise through the ranks of the CIA? How many bags of weed did you have to burn up in order to survive college? I find it ironic that those that tend to speak up the loudest concerning things like religious tolerance toward religions other than their own are ALWAYS the people with the biggest doubts about their faith… Those who speak loudest about morality and decency are ALWAYS the most immoral and disgusting people. Congratulations, Mr. Barr! You are no exception!
As a 21-year service member (who is STILL serving, by the way,) AND a practicing Pagan, I’ve served in some pretty scary situations and followed some very good leaders and some very bad ones. And let me tell you that RELIGION makes a difference in terms of leadership ability. Most “religious” leaders I’ve encountered, simply don’t understand the difference between right and wrong from an objective viewpoint, and are incapable of rational decision-making, unless they are capable of setting their religious beliefs aside (which MOST are decidedly NOT!) Nearly all of them have no understanding of the freedoms that are guaranteed by the Constitution of the United States… And these are supposedly the leaders of those of us that are sworn to support and defend it! Several times, I’ve questioned the leadership abilities of religious types, who simply couldn’t understand that the “welfare of their soldiers” doesn’t mean trying to forcibly convert them, no matter what their religion’s doctrine says…
As a member of Congress, you supposedly took a similar oath. Judging by all the hard work you have done stepping all over basic freedoms and Constitutional Rights, it certainly shows how little your oath has meant to you.
JEWGAN
February 18th, 2010
3:57 pm
Yes, as my “name” implies “JEW” as in Jewish and “GAN” as in Pagan. I am an Army (National Guard) Jew working on starting a “Wiccan” (pagan) Open Circle on an Air Force Base. Why, do you ask, am I doing this? I am doing this because I am a Non-Commissioned Officer (NCO) and one of my duties is to take care of the “troops” well-being. I veiw “taking care of the troops” as looking out for their physical, emotional, and SPIRITUAL well-being whether or not I agree with them as long as they are not breaking any laws or regulations. The Air Force Base near where I live is in the middle of the “Bible Belt” and there is very little for non-christians. I, too am fighting the Bob Barr attitude, as the chaplain I am working with will NOT let us meet in any of the chapel facilities. This is very frustrating and I will soon be taking his actions to a HIGHER authority.
JEWGAN
Florence
February 18th, 2010
4:29 pm
“Shall we suffer a Pagan to deal with us and not suffer him to pray to his god? . . . . It is the refusing toleration to those of different opinion which has produced all the bustles and wars on account of religion.” – Thomas Jefferson
Brooke
February 18th, 2010
4:31 pm
I’m sorry that Mr Barr doesn’t seem to believe in one of the tenets of our democracy – freedom of religion. If someone is Pagan and chooses worship that way what business is it of mine? If they are Christian and worship that way what business is it of mine?
It’s funny that Mr Barr mentions people unwilling to follow a Pagan into battle? First, they would be following a superior officer and a fellow American. Second, I don’t think the soldiers of Julius Caesar or Alexander the Great minded following a Pagan into battle.
Brandon Longcrier
February 18th, 2010
4:53 pm
JEWGAN,
If your Chaplains aren’t accommodating you, then you definitely need to take it up the Chain-of-Command, but keep in mind that there may be better and more private places for you and your group to meet other than Chapel facilities. If you have office space near where you work, then that might be an option for you. Here at the Air Force Academy, we meet in a conference room for now. Of course once the weather gets better and I finish the Circle, then we’ll be meeting up there as much as possible. Just try to keep a good relationship with your Chaplains, and work with your leadership to see if there’s another place where you and your group can meet.
And if all else fails, look me up and we can discuss your options.
Deanna Deal
February 18th, 2010
5:26 pm
Shame on you. Freedom of religion means freedom for ALL religions, not just yours. You have a lot of growing left to do. Making fun of one’s sacred space is not a very Christian thing to do. You would have fits if someone called your favorite church building “truly hilarious”. SHAME on you.
J. A. Simonsson
February 18th, 2010
5:27 pm
Thank you, Mr. Barr. Thank you for once again opening your mouth, and confiming that I made the right decision in 2008, to vote Republican and cast my ballot, so that I, among many, helped send you back into the private sector, where you are FAR from the levers of power in this great nation. I note with amusement the tag line at the top of this web page regarding The Barr Code… but shouldn’t it read instead: “Where willful ignorance, bigotry, and self-serving ideology reveal that Bob’s talking out of his @$$ AGAIN!”
To all veterans and active duty personnel of the Army, Navy, Marines, Air Force, and Coast Guard, regardless of your religious or spiritual affiliation, or the lack thereof… thank you for your service to this great nation, thank you for your sacrifice of your time with your families, for your defense of Liberty, for willingly stepping into harm’s way so that every American can say what they wish, worship how they wish, and do what they wish for a living without having to get anyone’s of Bob Barr’s ilks approval or sanction of those decisions. Thank you, from the bottom of my heart for defending my life, and the lives of every member of my family. Words fail me now…
Bob
February 18th, 2010
5:42 pm
I would rather have a wide eyed realist in a leadership position rather than someone relying on a non-existent god and who might be stupid enough to put faith in and therefore might falsely ascribe military success to belief in this non-entity.
Nanonano
February 18th, 2010
6:18 pm
Worried about following a neo-pagan into battle? Stop and think: Norse berserkers and the pre-Christian Celts were considered some ominous foes in their time. And they were basically pagan cultures, just to add to many examples of this already. I wish people would just stop and THINK about history.
Personally, I don’t care what someone believes if they’re competent and respect my right to my own personal beliefs as I respect theirs. The military is no place for religion, in my opinion, in terms of dictated policy that soldiers should believe one thing or another. That is a slippery slope to becoming some of the very things our founders rejected outright, not to mention the foes we are fighting who are using twisted religious rhetoric.
From what I’ve read, there has been basic support for neopagan/Wiccan worship in the military for quite a long time (Army Chaplain’s book has information, for instance). These folks may have a space for worship and there has certainly been backlash about that–I seem to remember a Fort Hood incident where a newly installed altar was destroyed by presumed Christians. An outrageous and intolerant act that would have been all over the news had this been a Christian altar.
Neopagan worship is no big deal, just different. It is protected by the First Amendment, plain and simple. To my mind, this is more a case of that which some don’t understand soon becomes demonized, kind of like the Dark Ages.
These are people who find strength and sustenance in their worship and understand people have a personal relationship to their god. As one acquaintance once said, “Polytheism includes monotheism, but monotheism doesn’t include polytheism.” Therein lies the problem. Neopagans by their very nature WILL be tolerant of others who worship differently. If only the monotheists weren’t so busy making sure everyone knew they were right.
Chris Broe
February 18th, 2010
7:27 pm
Why is it so surprising that there is Pagan worship at the Air Force Academy? After all, they teach flight dynamics at Wiccan School, where broom riding is serious biz. Watch those landings, ladies.
bwa
Anonymous
February 18th, 2010
8:31 pm
I’m actually very conservative on most issues, and consider myself a Libertarian based on my views. Religion, however, is one of the three issues I am not conservative on, being a practicing pagan myself. This is exactly the attitude that contributed to me not voting for you in the last presidential election.
No one has an issue with providing a church or chapel for Christian soldiers to worship in. If there is a significant number of pagans on a particular base, I see no reason why their requests for a place to practice their religion shouldn’t be accommodated. Pagans are citizens, voters, and taxpayers to.
paganman
February 18th, 2010
10:14 pm
wiccans are pagan. asatru are pagan. druids are pagan. many hindus consider themselves pagan. many native americans consider themselves pagan. some buddhists consider themselves pagan. practitioners of african traditional religions often consider themselves pagan. practically every indigenous “shamanic” or “earth based” religious group in the world, is considered pagan.
what makes us a religion? tolerance of each other, and a shared sense of kinship not inspite of, but “because of” our differences. if creating a worship space for non-abrahamic religions will allow pagans freedom from persecution by the proselytizations of the arrogant and ignorant, I say go for it! I’m sure the “deist” founding fathers (and mothers) of the USA would be all for it, if not right in step in our sacred dances and celebrations!
Drew
February 18th, 2010
10:27 pm
Bobby boy, you have not a clue what you are talking about and to use the Air Force Academy as an example?? Have you not been paying attention of past coercive CHRISTIAN proselytizing there? Yes, please read up on what the Pagan religions really are…and, oh yes, study the horrific and brutish ways your Christian ancestors did away with them as Christianity was FORCED into central and northern Europe. Your diatribe here is an ill-informed joke.
Ken JP Stuczynski
February 18th, 2010
11:02 pm
Sorry but the author lacks both knowledge and wisdom on this subject. It also leans towards the attitude of neo-atheism — the world’s newest and most prolific bigotry. Ritual, regardless of rational belief, is an important aspect of human expression, spiritually and psycho emotionally, not just culturally as a mainstream or even fringe practice.
Bob Hubbard
February 18th, 2010
11:07 pm
Bob, you might want to educate yourself on a topic before you open mouth and insert foot. I echo those who stated they are ashamed to have supported your run in 2008.
buttboy
February 18th, 2010
11:12 pm
apparently the comment posting filters won’t allow a person to point out that bob barr looks like a flaming homo? no offense, and never mind if it’s truth or just a stereotype presumption (irony there). I have a couple real and mutually loyal friends who are quite homo. just saying. if it’s stereotypes we’re all discussing, let’s get down to the heart of it. wasn’t this too a point for military discrimination not so long ago? that of course, assuming it still isn’t… bob barr, you look like a flaming homo… maybe appearances and ignorant presumptions alone are enough to formulate judgments about a person’s (or a group’s) character… ? and so what if you (may or may not) keep a wife for appearances sake…
M. J. Fowlie
February 18th, 2010
11:18 pm
I’m not going to bark out Bob Barr’s unfortunate stupidity, since so many others have already done it. Instead, I’m going to do what I’ve read only one other person did, and I don’t recall their name (sorry about that).
To you who put your morals aside-regardless of your religion- to protect me, my daughter, and my rights as an American citizen, thank-you. With all that I am, thank-you for the personal sacrifice you must make whenever you’re forced to use your weapon; thank-you for the emotional pain of being away from your families, thank-you for the physical pain of your injuries, and here’s a thank-you to the dead who have given your lives throughout the history of this country so that I, today, may wear my pentagram openly. Because of these brave men and women, I don’t have to lie to my child and tell her “this is just a different way of attending Church” when I cast a circle, I can walk out my front door without a cowl and not fear being stoned or beaten to death, I can drive and have a car in my name, my daughter can recieve the best education I can afford to give her, she’ll someday be able to drive, vote, hold a job, own a house, and practise any religion that best fits her if one at all. Thank-you to all branches of the US Military.
I’m talking out my ass, but this is something I believe: when war stops being ugly to you, you are damned (religion has nothing to do with this). Because of this particular belief of mine, for all of your sakes I hope war will forever be ugly, and I also hope that there will someday be no need for it. Another thank-you to those who witness and commit the ugliness of war so pussies like me don’t have to. *hugs*
As far as the sacred circle in Ft. Hood…. Sure, tear it down for all I care, so long as you tear down the monotheistic chapel as well. If you won’t tear down the chapel, then you shouldn’t tear down the sacred circle.
~M. J. Fowlie
Ieuan
February 18th, 2010
11:41 pm
“However, one might legitimately wonder just how far such tolerance should extend.”
It should extend precisely as far as my tolerance for Christianity extends: until its fist meets my face. Which is precisely what has occurred at the Air Force Academy.
Grow up, Bob. Other faiths are just as legitimate as yours.
Erik
February 18th, 2010
11:49 pm
Couldn’t disagree with you more Bob, you un-American prick.
B.A.
February 19th, 2010
12:15 am
How dare you ridicule the rituals of someone else’s religion (when you obviously know nothing about them) as a backhanded way of knocking down a straw man. The Great Rite is a symbolic form of the hieros gamos (its later ancient Greek name), a New Year Ritual from Mesopotamia at least 5,000 years old. Pagan means “of the countryside”, not hedonism, you idiot. How magnanimous of you to admit that Neopagan religions are “not necessarily incompatible with the good order and discipline essential to a military lifestyle”. How far should tolerance extend? you ask. To the same extent as tolerance of Christianity. To the extent that you don’t break the highest law of the land, the Constitution of the United States whose First Amendment stands between you and religious war. (Or do you think theocracy works so well in the Middle East, after all). You’re a libertarian so long as it’s freedom of YOUR beliefs but not when it comes to those of others (hypocrite).
drmondo
February 19th, 2010
12:24 am
What a waste of space! Isn’t there ANYTHING more important to talk about?!! This is a Jerry Springer Show topic, not something newsworthy…
AllQuackedUp
February 19th, 2010
1:04 am
So, Mr. Barr, and all you “the U.S. is a Christian nation” parrots, tell us all — are we all to publicly profess a belief in “God” before we are allowed to even be a part of the U.S. military? Are we now required to all worship the exact same “God”? And what, exactly, is God’s actual name — Is it Yeshua, Jehova, Odin, Allah, or perhaps Bing Crosby? (Oh, right…God’s name is actually George W. Bush! or is it Dick Cheney, or perhaps Donald Rumsfeld?) Until you can PROVE that ONLY your own version of “God” is the “correct” version, perhaps you should just shut your pie-holes. Oh, wait…you can’t prove any such thing.
As for the USAF Academy pushing ONE religion on ALL Cadets, that’s covered in the first section of the 1st Amendment to the Constitution of The United States of America: “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.” As an OFFICIAL representative of Congress, which has established it as a Military Academy, the United States Air Force Academy is NOT allowed to push one religious belief, to the exclusion of all others, on its Cadets. In fact, the USAF Academy shouldn’t even have any kind of stance, official or otherwise, on any religious beliefs whatsoever.
When it comes to religious beliefs being represented by, at and in Federal Institutions (and the USAF Academy IS a Federal Institution), it is all or none. The Law is the Law.
Jeff Gantery
February 19th, 2010
2:30 am
Bob Barr is yet ANOTHER Republican Chicken Hawk who has NEVER served a day in the military. As a former USAFA Cadet with over 20 years in the Air Force; Dear Bob really has little to say about the silly circle of rocks on the Academy Grounds. Here is my idea: Call in Controlled Demolition to implode the Cadet Chapel and GET RELIGION OUT of the military!
People like Bob Barr have too much time on their hands with their “Do as I say and not as I do” mentality.
Bob Barr is damaged goods.
Moonlion
February 19th, 2010
5:02 am
Before someone writes an article, he should first investigate. Mr Barr article demonstrate a total lack of what he is writing about as well as a lack of religious tolerance. I would like to know where Mr Barr found this definition of Paganism: “has little or no religion and delights in sensual pleasures and material goods” as well as “hedonism”. Resuming: if you do not know what you are writing about, don’t write it.
Jay
February 19th, 2010
8:54 am
Bob Barr’s failed libertarianism:
http://open.salon.com/blog/jay_nunenkamp/2010/02/18/bob_barrs_failed_libertarianism
Magenta
February 19th, 2010
8:57 am
My take: Given the rising cost of treating soldiers for PTSD and the frequency of mental health problems concurrent with “re-entry,” I say, if US military personnel find peace and solace in a personal religious practice — something that gets them through the day and keeps them on an even keel so that they don’t hurl grenades at their comrades or attack their spouses upon returning to civilian life — then by all means, bring it on. Is there really a difference between a wooden pew, or a tallis, or a prayer rug, or a circle of stones? That’s what religion is! It’s attaching symbolism to an inanimate object, to gain some understanding of things that are basically impossible to understand. Leave the pagans alone. Leave the Christians, Jews, Buddhists and Muslims alone, too, as long as their contemplations help them to do some GOOD in the world, while they’re making crappy wages for doing a job that could get them killed anytime.
John Nelson
February 19th, 2010
9:10 am
Mr. Barr,
You seem like an intelligent man, but you would have be deliberately ignoring reality to equate paganism (a slippery thing to define, I’ll grant you) with hedonism. In other words, you are being deliberately disingenuous. The moral tenets that underpin Wicca, for example place far more of a burden on the individual than those of Christianity, for example. No, there isn’t a set list of things “thou shalt not” do, but there is an all encompassing charge to be mindful of the consequences of once’s actions. No doctrine of forgiveness by being “washed in the blood of the lamb”, no get out of hell free card. You are responsible, always, for what you do or fail to do. Now, does that sound anything like the carefree “hedonistic” life that you have painted paganism to be?
J. M. Cornwell
February 19th, 2010
9:29 am
The thing about religious freedom and freedom of speech, both of which are at the heart of this discussion, is that freedom doesn’t exist for the popular but for the unpopular. You cannot in all good faith expect religious freedom or freedom of speech for yourself and then deny the same for those who do not practice, believe or speak as you do. That is only freedom for you and not for your opponent. This is obviously something you didn’t learn from the Constitution or from being an American.
How much tolerance is too much tolerance? According to Jesus Christ in the Bible, it’s the same as the measure of forgiveness, 70 x 7, which is a benchmark. It is actually supposed to be without measure. Nice to know you follow those principles as closely as you follow the Constitution. It’s a good thing you weren’t elected since you cannot uphold or defend something about which you know absolutely nothing — in theory or in practice.
Joel Monka
February 19th, 2010
10:39 am
My comments ran overlong for this space, so I put them in the form of an open letter to Bob Barr here: http://cuumbaya.blogspot.com/2010/02/open-letter-to-bob-barr.html
Brandon Longcrier
February 19th, 2010
10:40 am
Mr. Barr, maybe you should take some notes and learn some lessons from the Christian minister who wrote http://www.dailynews-record.com/opinion_details.php?AID=44701&CHID=32 in response to someone else like you.
Slaughter
February 19th, 2010
11:51 am
Barr needs an editor. He has extraneous commas after military leaders in the first graf, in “witchcraft, was” also in the first graf, in “new level, in” in the second graf, and after the parentheses in the third graf.
I think Bob Barr’s worst nightmare would be a gay Wiccan Arab as a general.
Michael Eric Berube
February 19th, 2010
11:53 am
Thank you Mr. Barr for proving that my decision to NOT support the LP candidate for the first time in two decades this last election was the correct choice. I tried to educate my fellow libertarians that a leopard does not easily change his spots so easily and that you sir, are yet another failed GOP would be Theocrat and no true supporter of Individual Liberty, but many bought into the spin about your ‘conversion’ and sadly many voted for you rather than supporting a truer advocate of liberty whom we had in the race in Dr. Paul.
CK
February 19th, 2010
12:50 pm
Mr. Barr, whatever happened to religious freedom, one of the founding principles of our country? Why should having a pagan circle (by the way, you incorrectly defined “pagan”) threaten anyone? Wouldn’t the Christians who desecrated the pagan circle be the threatening ones? Would you have the same response if someone desecrated a Christian church? Or is there only freedom of religion if you happen to agree with that religion. Mr. Barr, why do you hate America and it’s freedoms so much?
Comrade Laissez Faire
February 19th, 2010
2:08 pm
Bob Barr was never a libertarian in the first place. He like, Wayne Allen Root, are dishonest paleoconservatives trying to mascarade themselves as libtertarians. This lastest rant about Wiccans and Pagans in the military reinforces what a phony libertarian Barr is.
Justin G.
February 19th, 2010
2:17 pm
I voted for (and volunteered for the campaign of) Mr. Barr in ‘08- and I would do it again. The above post shows the difference between tolerance and agreement- and is totally libertarian (big and little L!). Just because I tolerate your silly religions (any of them) doesn’t mean I can’t think they aree, well, silly.
The Wild Hunt » Jonathan Sharkey Goes Over the Edge and other Pagan News of Note
February 19th, 2010
2:36 pm
[...] Something tells me folks, especially Libertarian folks (and military folks), won’t get fooled [...]
wth
February 19th, 2010
4:05 pm
Frankly any and all religion should be “barred” from government expenditures. Pun intended. I don’t think this was on my approved list of tax expenditures. WTH? Keep christianity out as well. People should practice these things at home…not a work environment, paid for compliments of the american taxpayer.
j. White
February 19th, 2010
5:52 pm
Thomas Jefferson said “neither Pagan nor Mahomedan nor Jew ought to be excluded from the civil rights of the Commonwealth because of his religion.’ Shall we suffer a Pagan to deal with us and not suffer him to pray to his god? Why have Christians been distinguished above all people who have ever lived, for persecutions? Is it because it is the genius of their religion? No, it’s genius is the reverse. It is the refusing toleration to those of a different opinion which has produced all the bustles and wars on account of religion. It was the misfortune of mankind that during the darker centuries the Christian priests following their ambition and avarice combining with the magistrate to divide the spoils of the people, could establish the notion that schismatics might be ousted of their possessions & destroyed. This notion we have not yet cleared ourselves from.”
There are many Pagans in the Armed Services. My husband is a Pagan Marine. Semper Fi. There are Pagan Chaplains. Get a clue. If you were ACTUALLY a Libertarian, this would not matter to you.
Raven Shepherd
February 19th, 2010
11:02 pm
I have one thing to say. If you are going to allow Christians to have “places of worship” on military bases, in the line of “all men are created EQUAL” by default, you have to allow ALL religions the same opportunity to worship…Oh and it might say “One Nation Under God” but it never specifies which one. If you expect everyone to acknowledge and tolerate YOUR religion, shouldn’t you do the right thing and respect someone else’s?
Raven Shepherd
February 19th, 2010
11:17 pm
I have an even simpler answer to your idiocy, taken from your own “holy” book.”Let ye who is without sin cast the first stone.” Yeah, at least us pagans take the time to learn about something other than bowing down to a divine zombie and then cannibalizing his body.
Dr. O. P. Sudrania
February 20th, 2010
10:02 am
I feel perhaps the words Pagan, Hedonism, Wicca is used contemptuously and pejoratively by the Western religionists, practicing some form of “Desert Religions”. It is a misfortune. As it portrays the complete ignorance of the Eastern Religious practices which is the mother of all the religions of the World. Secondly, it also appears that the organised form of ‘Religions’ practiced today is more a business than a religion, which is the root cause of all these evils in the name of ‘Religion’. Therefore the ‘Religion’ is transformed into a cult of Politics preached in complicity with Religion. That is where the things are going wrong.
Dr. O. P. Sudrania
Christopher Aldridge
February 20th, 2010
4:41 pm
Barr, you’re an idiot, and you should have been thrown out of office. You say that the definition of Pagan is having little or no religion? We have more religious writings than that Bible of yours, I’ll tell you that much. And we are not just people who delight in our lives on Earth, we are also very spiritual as well. It’s clear you have no idea what you’re talking about and you need to get out of Sunday school and get educated. The Constitution says we have the right to the religion we choose, we are not a Christian nation, nor were we founded on Christian beliefs and values. Our founding fathers made many quotes against Christianity. I would be more worried about being commanded by an officer who thinks that the Christian God told him to do it, because so many wars and horrific acts have been committed in the name of Christianity. History has certianly shown that there’s nothing more dangerous than a Christian who thinks their God told them to do it. Your mentality is dying, my friend. Trust me. Your hatred and biggotry is dying.
Heathen in NC
February 21st, 2010
2:46 am
I would like the Christofascists who agree with Mr. Barr to answer me one question:
Since this is a “Christian nation”, what should be done with all of us non-Christians? Seriously, I want you to actually exercise those higher cognitive processes that you neglected on the orders of your god and actually explain to me in detail what you think needs to be done to enforce the “Christian nation” mindset…since you apparently feel that such was intended to be the law of the land, I’m genuinely curious to know what you think should be done about those of us who are citizens and happen to worship other gods.
Note please that I am not holding my breath waiting for your reply, because I know that it will never come.
Brandon Longcrier
February 21st, 2010
9:51 am
“Frankly any and all religion should be “barred” from government expenditures.”
You can’t do that in the military because there are times when we are in training environments that we are not allowed to leave the Base, Post, Camp, Ship, etc… to seak out the spiritual preference of our choice. So if the military is going to continue these practices (which are totally necessary at times) and can’t let us go to our faiths, then they have to do everything in their power (Chaplains, Lay Leaders, etc…) to bring those faiths to us.
Brandon Longcrier
February 21st, 2010
12:01 pm
I run the Pagan group at the AF Academy and even though Bob Barr probably hasn’t read any of our comments, I’ll go ahead and post this anyway.
The following is the working description of Paganism that I’ve come up with from the research that I’ve done over the past few years.
Disclaimer: One can never speak for all Pagans due to the wide range of beliefs and I’m no exception. I’m only posting about what many or most believe in.
Earth-Centered spirituality (Paganism) has been around since the beginning of time and has been practiced by cultures the world over. It is unclear when the term “Pagan” (Latin “Paganus”) was first used, but according to historians, the 4th Century seems most plausible. Even though the term is fairly new in terms of how old the Earth is (~4 billion yeas old), the spiritual aspect is not. For example, the oldest evidence of supernatural worship comes from the remains of what archeologist are calling a female Shaman who was found in what is now the Czech Republic and dates back to ~30,000 BCE. You heard correct, I did say “female Shaman”. It is actually thought that females may have been the spiritual leaders before men. This was most likely due to the fact that women were (and still are by many) seen as magical beings. They were seen as such because they had cycles, their bellies grew, and then they created life. Modern Earth-Centered spirituality is very similar to ancient and modern-day Shamanism and Native American spirituality and it would not be uncommon to find Earth-Centered practitioners (Pagans) who incorporate Shamanism and/or Native American practices into their own practice. Each (Shamanism, Native American, and Earth-Centered) have their own way of doing things, but are similar because they all see the Earth, Plants, Trees, Animals, and every other living thing as spiritual or divine.
Like many other faiths out there, Earth-Centered spirituality is also made up of many different traditions (denominations). Take Christianity for example. Christianity is the umbrella term that many different denominations such as Catholic, Baptist, Church of Christ, Lutheran, etc… fall under. The same is true for Earth-Centered spirituality. Paganism is the umbrella and various traditions including but not limited to Wicca, Druidism, Heathenism, Celtic, Egyptian, Stregheria, and many others fall under that umbrella.
Most Pagan traditions involve the worship of both Gods and Goddesses, but not all. Some traditions of Paganism only worship one God or Goddess and others may not worship Gods or Goddesses at all. Instead, they may find that they have more of a conneciton with nature, the Earth, the Universe, or just energy in general. Pagans may be all over the board with the way they all worship, but being able to worship whoever or whatever works for you is what makes Paganism so wonderful. This path is a very personal path, but many still choose to gather in groups to add a sense of community to their worship practices.
Mythology, folklore, and legends are very common among Earth-Centered practitioners and the psychology of spirituality plays a very important role as well. For example: Many believe that Gods and Goddesses aren’t “real”. Their energy and what they stand for is real, but they themselves are not. Meaning that many don’t believe that there are these puppetmaster like beings in the heavens pulling our stings. Instead, many of us believe that in order for the ancients to better relate to the things happening around them, they created myths to help expalin things more clearly. This is when Gods and Goddesses were created. And when they were created, they were given names and faces, which personified them so that people could better realate to them. These faces and names still remain today and many of those ancient Gods and/or Goddesses are still called upon by Pagans all over the world. A large number of Pagans believe also believe that the Gods and/or Goddesses reside within every human being and that calling upon them is basically looking within yourself for the answers that you seek. Accessing the Gods / Goddesses can be tricky though and is where vehicles such as medition, prayer, ritual, etc… come into play.
Many people believe that Pagans worship the Devil, but that couldn’t be further from the truth. Then again, I guess that all depends on what you think is the Devil. Do Pagans worship the Devil described in Christian mythology? No. But if you’re Christian and you believe that people are Devil Worshippers just because they worship anything (Mother Earth, Nature Spirits, etc…) other than the God of Abraham, then I guess in your own little world that you’re right. We believe that the Devil is just another myth created by a faith group to personify evil. Is the Devil real? Definitely, but only to those who believe in it. Some traditions of Paganism (Egyptian) do have concepts of final judgment like in Christianity, but others do not. Most Pagans believe in rebirth and/or reincarnation of some kind vs. final judgement, so eternal salvation and/or damnation isn’t really talked about that much in the Pagan community.
Some faiths claim to be the “Truth”, the “Way”, etc…, but not Paganism. We do not claim to have all the answers. We only worship in ways that feel right and good to us and if that should ever change, then chances are, so will our practices.
As you probably gathered already, Earth-Centered spirituality involves having a connection with the Earth. Many also strive to have a similar connection with the rest of the Universe as well. Each tradition under the umbrella of Paganism practices differently, but having a connection with and seeing all things as blessed and interconnected could be seen as a common theme that is shared between most Earth-Centered traditions. This connection with all things is many times accomplished by incorporating the sacred Elements of Earth, Air, Fire, and Water into one’s spiritual practice. There are many Gods, Goddesses, Spirits, Animals, etc… associated with each of the four Elements. Becoming one with those Elements is how many connect with the fifth Element, which is Spirit. These five Elements are represented in the Pentacle (Upward pointing Star with Circle around it). Many assume that the Pentacle is a symbol of Devil worship, but again, that would be an extremely wrong assumption to make. Each of the five points of the Pentacle represents one of the five Elements and the circle surrounding the Pentacle represents the connection between the Elements and eternal life; much like what a wedding band represents. It is no coincidence that the Star is a perfectly balanced object.
The Wheel of the Year is a modern term used to describe the cycles of the Earth over a year. It is made up of eight holy days that many refer to as Sabbats. It is debated which Sabbats were celebrated by whom and how far back, but many modern-day Pagans choose to celebrate them all. Two of the Sabbats are Solstices (Yule and Midsummer/Litha), two are Equinoxes (Ostara and Mabon), and the other four (Beltane, Lughnasadh, Samhain, and Imbolc) mark other important and sacred times of the year. Sabbats follow myths that explain how the seasons come and go and may even be acted out like a Play during rituals. The rituals that are performed by Pagans to celebrate the Sabbats can be very elaborate or very simple. Some people choose to practice alone, where others may form small to large groups called Covens, Groves, Circles, etc…
Circles represent infinity, interconnectedness, and even protection. For these reasons, Earth-Centered practitioners have been using Circles as places of worship for thousands of years. Prior to starting a ritual, many Earth-Centered practitioners will cast a Circle, which is done to symbolically create a sacred place for worship and protection against all things (energy, spirits, etc…)negative or unwanted. Other faiths perform similar rituals using sensors with incense or maybe even holy water to “cleanse” their places of worship.
Outdoor worship circles have been used since ancient times in many places around the world and by those of many spiritual traditions. Some of these ancient circles, such as Stonehenge, Castlerigg, and Avebury in England, are among the outdoor worship circles used for present day spiritual services. Many of these outdoor worship circles are found throughout the United States. Some, such as the Bighorn Medicine Wheel in Wyoming, Cahokia Henge in Missouri, and Newark Circle in Ohio, are pre-historic and have astronomical alignments as is the case with many of the stone circles of old Europe. Most outdoor worship circles presently in use in the USA have been created within the past one hundred years and are used for congregate worship services and passage rites, including weddings, baby blessings, and funerals. There are several types of outdoor worship circles, including stone circles, woodhenges, sacred groves, and labyrinth circles. Some outdoor worship circles are part of facilities of religious institutions, some are part of private homes and estates, and others are part of institutions serving the public, including campuses, prisons, hospitals, military installations, art centers, and botanical gardens. Virtually every tribe of the Native American Nations has or had its own tribal sanctuary or sacred landscape. In virtually every country in Europe, our ancestors erected megaliths and constructed stone circles as places of worship and religious celebration. As we study, adopt, and bring the religious practices of our ancestors into contemporary relevance; we too have begun building sanctuaries in natural settings.
Brandon Longcrier -
Toran Korshnah
February 21st, 2010
3:53 pm
Bob, Bob. I read your biography, as I have no idea who you are. I’m astonished mr Privacy (your nickname,sic!), having such a background, takes such words against such a great religion as Wicca (and paganism in general) in the mouth. My only conclusion is you have been nothing less than the wrong person on the right place. You are not a libertarian, nor a Christian. I have no idea who you are, actually. And I think the people who voted for you, had no idea either…But I will not judge you. I leave judgement to my US friends, as I am European. Blessed Be!
Barbara Talbott
February 21st, 2010
11:25 pm
Mr. Barr, I find it sad you are willing to belittle so many faiths while demonstrating a knowledge pool consisting of stereotypes. “Pagan” is an umbrella term for many (typically) earth-centered faiths, such as Wicca, shamanism, etc. When we come together with open minds and mutual respect, we are able to see and appreciate the inherent similarities in all our various traditions and faiths. When our minds are closed , it’s all too easy to treat others outside of our religion with disdain and mockery; however, we then condemn ourselves to perpetual ignorance.
Our soldiers who choose to utilize the worship area for followers of Earth-centered religions participate in religious rituals that are no “stranger” than Christian rituals. One reason Christians were initially persecuted in Rome: their fellow Romans thought they were cannibals – eating the flesh and drinking the blood of Christ. It’s a shame those Romans hadn’t been open-minded enough to learn from the Christians what they were doing and why. I hope one day you will allow yourself to learn about Earth-centered religions.
My (Earth-centered) faith teaches me to have compassion for all beings. It can be difficult, I fall short. But I practice it daily and find I am a happier person for it. I thank you, Mr. Barr, for today’s lesson.
Harry B
February 22nd, 2010
10:50 am
I thought Bob Barr stood up for the rights of everyone’s privacy infringed upon by the US government, now you are making fun of one group because they happen to have different views than the majority.
This article is inconsistent with your privacy-rights themed pieces that I have admittedly enjoyed over the past few years.
craig14
February 22nd, 2010
2:31 pm
These comments go on and on! has anyone discussed the inherent conflict of being a christian and being a soldier? or being an adherent to any religion for that matter? last time i checked most religions explicitly point that killing is a sin/wrong/shouldn’t be done. And isn’t killing people the main purpose of an army?
A Real Libertarian (TM)
February 22nd, 2010
8:34 pm
Real Libertarians (TM) don’t claim Bob Barr.
janel
February 23rd, 2010
9:08 am
I am in disbelief that someone who claims to be a “christian” is so forthright in the public eye with VERY UN-CHRISTIAN views! Point- lying is a sin, right? Well, “hedonism” is not nor has it ever been part of the definition of “pagan”! Matter of fact- “pagan” , since time immortal, has ONLY referred to – country dwellers who were not among whichever mainstream religion was prominent at that point in time. Christians were in the realm of pagan worship during old testament days! And really- is worship in a circle outdoors really worse that putting a grown man in a dress, having him walk around ( like a god) placing hands on people to “bless” them, and lighting incense while observing a cannibalistic ritual ( necessary for redemption) ? Have you forgotten the primary tenet of Biblical teaching— Do unto others as you would have them do unto you?
Bruce
February 23rd, 2010
9:30 am
Dear sir, if this is Libertarianism, then I am embarassed about by you and your attitudes toward religion. According to the credo of libertarianism we are free to be who we are as long we are not hurting another person. These attitudes toward Wicca are intolerant and prejudicial. I feel the deepest sense of shame that you were a actually a candidate for the presidency of this great country. My age if 56 and I have not grown as cold – and – old as you are showing yourself to be at this time in your life. Open your closed eyes, sir, and see the people who inhabitant this great experiement of 1776. Now is the time to be inclusive and not the other way around.
HighPriestessChar
February 23rd, 2010
10:24 am
You can take you ideas and stuff them. I’ve been quite enough and all wiccan/pagans have.Christians got in a prominent place by speaking up,force and scare tactics. Its all true, look it up. Its in history records. The country was founded not that only Christians could be the only religion, but to have freedom, of religion, ideas, and so forth. I for one like that some people value the old religions. everyone but the higher power was given free will. To tell good law-abiding persons that they must not think for them selves, be sacred, and under control of only religion is a sad, sick and scary thought. I love differences in things, if we were all the somehow sad the world would be. Everyone has a right, no duty to be them selves and love what they love with a passion. I happen to be a High Priestess of an eclectic wican/pagan coven. Everyone is different here, but even love all of my coveners just the same. I also, love and respect my family members who are other faiths for the are human. everyone one weather they are wiccan or Christian are this and should all be thought of as our bothers and sisters. We as people should not look at each other and define each other as a color, a religion, a sex, a whatever, but as a unique human being who needs shelter, water, food, and love.and then peace who speed along the lands. For we would have nothing to fight about. its a petty and sad. Let go of the hate, embrace the change, let love in and you’ll see how good the world can be.
Blessed Be…High Priestess Char Norton
Stephanie
February 23rd, 2010
10:56 am
I find it rather pitiful that a man can be so convinced of his own opinion on a subject of which he knows so little. Let me define for you what my pagan path means.
I believe in the existence of all gods, including the Christian god, though he’s not one that I choose to worship, and though I find many Judeo-Christian-Islamic traditions appalling. I believe that, rather than temptation by some eternal force of evil, my errors in life are the result of my own selfish choices, and that by taking responsibility for myself and learning to make better decisions, I can improve not only myself but the world around me. I believe in respect for all life and for all people, whether they believe what I do or not, which is an improvement over Mr. Barr’s so-called “ethics” of religious bigotry and forced conversion of all people to his religion. I believe that all people are connected to each other and to the earth, so that if I harm one person, I’ve harmed everyone, including myself. I believe in enlightenment through learning rather than through blind, unquestioning obedience to a central dogma.
I do believe in a universal code of ethics, one that is common to most, if not all, religions–one that teaches peace, love, and understanding. I feel that the Founding Fathers’ relationship to that ethical code was within the context of Christianity, so it is natural that they would assume others’ connection would be as well. However, I think that those who play the “Christian nation” card forget that the original European settlers in what is now the United States came here not to establish a state religion but to escape it.
As for the poster who keeps parroting the phrase “God is not mocked,” let’s look for a minute at what that means. Your god, like mine, is a spirit in a much higher state than our own. The gods have better things to do than care what one person says about them. Brighid and Inanna and Mictecacihuatl don’t care that you’re trying to marginalize people of my faith, either. (Well, Brighid might–she tends to get a bit protective when her people’s feelings have been hurt.) Your god is bigger than anything I might say about him or about you, just as my gods are bigger than the insults you offer me.
As for whether Mr. Barr would follow a modern pagan into battle, I’d say that the odds are good that he wouldn’t have to…at least not the pagans who follow the path I’ve chosen. Maybe into a march protesting the torture of prisoners at Guantanamo Bay, or into a fundraiser for the Boys and Girl’s Club. But my path has led me in the opposite direction from the battlefield, because while I believe that it is right and fair to defend the helpless, I also feel that America is the aggressor in the current war. If it were an international manhunt for individual criminals, that would make sense. But to invade whole countries, turn entire nations upside down, using the excuse of the actions of a handful, most of whom are either dead or in US custody already, is an act of unnecessary violence in which my spirituality forbids me from taking part.
I leave you with a quote from Mohandas Karamchad Ghandi: “I like your Christ. I do not like your Christians. Your Christians are so unlike your Christ.”
Troy
February 23rd, 2010
11:00 am
Sir, Your own fears and ignorance of something you know nothing about is scary. Having served for 27 years now in the US Army as a Pagan I believe this is a right that we should all fight for. Who are you to suggest that your religion is superior to another? It will be a great day when bigots such as yourself are absent from the face of the earth. What scares me more than anything is to have to go into battle with some self righteous bigot as yourself.
Ellen
February 23rd, 2010
11:07 am
Is this actually happening?
hahaha.
You’re level of ignorance is amusing to me.
Putting a cap on tolerance. Setting a limit on how accepting people should be. Simply hilarious. “little or no religion”. You clearly have no idea what a pagan actually is. Maybe you should pick up a book or, hell, even talk to a real one. If you’re not too scared.
chuck
February 23rd, 2010
11:10 am
Mr. Barr
I am not a pagan, and find the entire belief system a bit silly. However your post demonstrates a depth of ignorance that is simply shocking, but I guess since you were in congress I should expect you to be clueless about things you ponitificate on.
Pagan literally means mutliple deities. Like the Romans and Greeks. It does not mean ‘“has little or no religion and delights in sensual pleasures and material goods’ nor does it mean ‘hedonism’. I know being in congress you were never required to actually know what you are talking about, but sure you (or an assistant) can find a dictionary?
http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/pagan
Rebecca
February 23rd, 2010
11:22 am
Amazed yet again by the people of this world. The ones who claim to want the world to live in peace, the ones who claim to be educated, the ones who claim and vow to rid this world of prejudice. HA!! What a joke! Have you ever done any “research” on ANY religion and how it came to be? How Chirst’s divintity had to be voted on by CHRISTIANS?! So from my comment you will assume Iam what ever you believe I’am. Again HA! At least you BELIEVE. Grow up! Act accordingly! Or have you forgotten…”love thy neighbor”? ohhhh my…forgot that one didnt ya!? Be blessed…
feces for jesus
February 23rd, 2010
11:41 am
What a moron!!! The guy doesn’t even have a clue what the word pagan means.
natalie
February 23rd, 2010
11:50 am
I am appalled at the ignorance of some people. I happen to be Wiccan and I do not hate any person who does not believe as I do. What I do hate however is ignorant people who have no ideas what my religion is and still find it in their heart to bash it. I have many friends that are christian and they all love me for who I am not what I believe. If more people found the time to get to know us, you might find that we are very loving, caring people who are devoted to making our earth a more friendly place. There are pagans out there who bash christianity because they feel turn about is fair play. Paganism is a real religion and most of us are accepting of all religions, I being one of them, but there are times when I find myself getting angry with the ingnorance of certain groups, not because of the religion they follow but for their intolerance of those different than them. I was recently verbally attacked by a christian and by the time we parted ways, we were communicating as friends. I didn’t let the anger get in the way of explaining what I do believe and now I have a new christian friend who is one of the kindest people I know. We can live in harmony if people would stop judging and just get along. I know this is a tall order because ignorance is contagious, and we have an epidemic in this country. My son is a veteran, as is every male in my family, and they fought and fight for my right to be and believe what makes my happy. I have morals and rules to live by just like other religions. I cannot stress enough that we are all made from the same cloth, and bleed the same color. What we believe does not change the fact that we are human beings who deserve respect just as you feel you do. It gets difficult to be nice to people who constantly tell you your beliefs are wrong. Educate yourself and you may find paganism interesting, as it was the religion of the masses long before christianity was made marshall law.
WiccanWarrior
February 23rd, 2010
12:35 pm
So Mr. Barr wouldn’t follow a Wiccan into battle because he thinks they’re too flaky. Just who WOULD you follow to war, Bob? You came of military age during the height of the Vietnam War, when there were lots of good, solid, white Christian men in the officer corps.
Where are all the pictures of you toting your M-16 around the jungles and rice paddies? Oh, that’s right, you were back in California in college flip-flopping between the Young Democrats and the Ayn Rand crowd, then the CIA. You must have had some hair-raising encounters with bad coffee in those situation rooms, things that would chill the blood of any Tet or Hanoi Hilton survivor.
As always, the draft dodgers feel the most compelled to speak about warriorhood….
Doubting Thomas
February 23rd, 2010
1:33 pm
I’m also sorry I voted for you in 2008, Bob. I thought being a Libertarian means you have tolerance for other people, that is, allowing them to live their lives how they want as long as it doesn’t violate anyone else’s rights. I really don’t think that the pagan worship you describe is any sillier than a bunch of people going into a large, opulent building dedicated to a man who was poor and glorified being poor, lighting up candles in front of a statue of a dead guy nailed to a piece of wood, and then symbolically eating the flesh and drinking the blood of this dead guy so they think they can live forever. See, Christian rituals can sound silly too.
I was debating whether or not to register as a Libertarian or an independent, and after reading this post I’m thinking about shying away from the Libertarian party. If this is what they truly are all about rather than accepting people for their differences, then I don’t want to have any part of it. If I were to join, I would only hope that you’re not their nominee for president again.
Kirsten
February 23rd, 2010
1:52 pm
Umm… I’m not in the military…. heck, I’m not even American (and honestly, people like you make me more and more grateful for the fact by the day)… but if I WAS in the military, American or otherwise, I’d honestly follow anyone who proved themselves to be a good leader, even if they were of the type who partook in symbolic canabalism every week (seriously, you think us pagans dancing round a circle is creepy, have you ever taken the time to consider that Christian take bread and wine, call it the blood and flesh of the demi-god they worship and then EAT it? Dude, that’s actually kinda sick).
I’m being facetious, I realise that. There’s no call for it, really. But seriously, stop being a hypocrite. Live and let live, as you say, and let it not be empty words. Belief systems have no bearing whatsoever on the leadership qualities of any particular person.
Sorceress Morrin
February 23rd, 2010
2:03 pm
Freedom of Religion means ALL Religions. Not to pick and choose which religions get recognized just because of any book. By the way Jesus wasn’t christian either.
Shannon
February 23rd, 2010
2:09 pm
I knew before I voted that you were a bigot posing as a progressive. I am so glad now that I didn’t waste my vote.
Jon
February 23rd, 2010
2:12 pm
Mr Barr, what you have posted here offends me to the nth degree. I am currently serving in the US Navy. Have been for almost 5 years with no trouble whatsoever. The fact that you are an AMERICAN above all else, and are basically calling for Wiccanism/Paganism to be denounced by today’s military is blantant ignorance. I was part of a pagan/wiccan group onboard the USS John C. Stennis back in 2007, and the group of us were some of the most qualified at our respective jobs onboard the entire ship. We as wiccans/pagans DESERVE to be amongst the fighting men and women of our country. We have earned at least that much by giving up our time, leaving our families for months (sometimes up to a year) defending YOUR right to say we don’t belong in the military. Show some tolerance before you post another “blog” such as this.
Lil Bit Fey
February 23rd, 2010
2:47 pm
For all of you out there hitting the “this is a nation of god” track… god is a concept or ideal not a title. Pagans are not godless, we are god-ful (and goddess-ful) as we recognize deity is revealed according to spiritual need and not all of us have our spritual needs met on the same path. And for those worried about who paid for the stone circle… who paid for the chapels and other Christ-centric worship places?
Lil Bit Fey
February 23rd, 2010
2:56 pm
BTW Bob, on a less academic note… you look like a tool.
William A. Baldwin
February 23rd, 2010
3:13 pm
Perhaps Mr. Barr should ask a few self-defined religious Pagans what “Pagan” means — instead of pulling up bias definitions from who-knows-where (and not providing references…..).
Perhaps he should stop calling people and practices “hilarious” without bothering to talk to practitioners and trying to understand them.
Perhaps he should learn to show a little respect for his fellow human beings — especially ones serving in our armed forces.
Katelyn C.Millins
February 23rd, 2010
3:21 pm
You are a complete joke. Do you realize that these Pagans you so called are an actuall people and race? My family is celtic, sure we dont prance around the woods holding candels.. where you can see us at least, we dont offened as the way you have just done. We are a people, we have a history, we have our religion. You my dear Bob are in much need for a history lesson. People can pray to a god, A goddess, or a spirit. same thing you are still praying to a dieity, something for protection. every religion has ways of dealing with things, sure some would light a candel in a window for those they have lost, or to have herbs and stones adorning there houses as to ward off evil. I belive christians have a cross no?
Please do not write about of which you do not understand, you just embaressed yourself, may I say congratz to your foppish attitude. If I had to follow a comander I wouldnt care what religion as long as he/she knew what was going on, we where taught not to discriminate against race, religion, ethnicity. You just insulted one of the oldest religions in history, I must ask, are you proud of yourself?
Jarred
February 23rd, 2010
4:46 pm
You disgust me. I am a PAGAN, and I think you area complete idiot moron who dosen’t know the first thing about Paganism or life for that matter. You need to either get a brain or stop this stupid blog.
Can you believe this jerk? « Carolinas to the Caribbean
February 23rd, 2010
5:33 pm
[...] Can you believe this jerk? Bob Barr speaks his “mind” on Pagan worship at the Air Force Academy [...]
TaraLynn
February 23rd, 2010
9:10 pm
“I’m sorry, but this truly is hilarious. Don’t get me wrong, if someone “has little or no religion and delights in sensual pleasures and material goods,” which is the definition of a “pagan,” then I say live and let live” Bob Barr
R U SERIOUS??? It seems to me that political types like YOURSELF are more materialistic than any pagan i know. For someone who has tried to run for president or even has any involvement in our American Government should possible get more education before opening one’s mouth, or at least get a proper dictionary. I have to agree 100% with Natalie.
Colleen P. Williams
February 23rd, 2010
9:57 pm
You are a traitor to the Constitution of the United States. Flat out. Traitor, Bob Barr. We have this thing called a Constitution, you know, the thing that the last administration tried to wipe their butts with, and it allows freedom of religion. Thank GODDESS that you are no longer in a position to further subvert the Constitution that my PAGAN grandfather fought for. He knew all about the evils of Christianity unregulated. I think we should rename you Torquemada.
You are a TRAITOR!!!! If you cannot live with the freedoms gauranteed by our Constitution and our priceless Bill of Rights, MOVE! Go to Afghanistan, you traitor. I hear that Al Queda could use more fanatics just like you.
Katie Alexander
February 24th, 2010
9:39 am
Mr. Barr, what is this? A wolf in sheep’s clothing, a Republican disguised as a Liberatarian. What, since you think yourself a walking dictionary, is the definition for liberty, then? The US Constitution was built under freedom of intolerance to religion, and for freedom to practice any religion of your choosing-NOT the freedom to practice any religion that is only a branch of Christianity. I disagree with other religions, too-Scientology, Catholicism, and Chritianity, but I would never twist around the actions of these followers to make it look as if it were something that these practices are not, and I would never look down on them for the religion that they practice when leading a soldier into battle (or being that soldier) when they are defending my right to be free, and your right to put your feet in your mouth-and I mean that literally. You, sir, have placed both feet in your mouth, with such a derrogatory comment toward the majority of the votes in your party. Forming everywhere are facebook pages and petitions to make sure that you no longer are able to run for president. Anyone displaying so much hate and intolerance has no leg to stand on. You have set people’s images and tolerance of us back at least one hundred years-shame on you.
At least these pagans ARE serving in the military, you may want to consider what you’ve done to have the right to say something like that.
Furthermore, the definition of pagan is not “devoid of religion” (I believe you were referring to atheism-that was what you were looking for, not paganism), although it may say this in the bible; it does, however, refer to those of us that are devoid of Christ, that we practice the old religion in which we appreciate the life and beauty and lessons in everything around us. We have Gods, Goddesses-we are not devoid of religion, it is just unlike your own, in that we believe in love, we belive in respect for everyone and everything around us, and we believe that there is no need to bash another’s religion (especially-and not because-they do a good enough job bashing it themselves, such as yourself, Mr. Barr). To be so closed-minded and blind to the fact that at least these people are serving-if they were so inclined to be nothing more than a tree hugger, then they wouldn’t even be there in the first place-when the entire nation to this day is still pissed at Bush for this “needless” war. At least they are there and defending you and your rights.
Shame on you. The Liberatarian Party deserves a voice that isn’t so mocking, such as your own. Someone that is not so arrogant and ignorant. You are not the face of the party that I believe in, the one that believes in liberty and justice and fairness to all, under whichever god they choose to serve. The Republican in sheep’s clothing MUST be silenced before his words are known to the wrong person, before the libel and slander suits are filed, because they can be. How montrous and disasterous of you to be so unkind, so shameful. To be so hurtful to a mass of this country that supported you and your efforts, that believes in your party. What’s next, gay bashing? Jew hating? You disgust me, sir.
Katie O
February 24th, 2010
10:58 am
The whole definition provided of paganism is simply ludicrous. Maybe that’s how Christians define Pagans, but that is not how Pagans define it!
Regardless of whether or not someone agrees with the practice of Paganism, those in the military who identify with that religion and want to practice it have the right to. They are still protecting our country, and protecting your right to spout off this nonsense, and protecting our freedoms. They are not forcing anyone to practice Paganism, and one could even argue that they are not even really encouraging it, just allowing it and providing a space for it. It’s not like they had to build a church and pay for construction of a building and all of the costs that go along with it, including electricity, etc. It’s circles of ROCKS! And frankly, if I were in the military I would be more nervous about following someone into battle that devalues a person just because of their religious beliefs than I would be about following a Pagan into battle. At least pagans (at least as a general rule) value all life and respect all life, and true pagans respect the religious beliefs of others, and their freedom of choice in religion. You don’t see military Pagans upset that people are allowed to go to Mass, do you?
And yes, this country was founded by people raised in the Christian belief system, with admittedly Christian morals, but the founding fathers were deists, and purposely included that church and state would be separated, which they could have very easily just left out, were that unimportant.
Lisa D
February 24th, 2010
11:48 am
That’s fine if you don’t practice another’s religion, but what gives you the right to impede on their freedom to do so? Your ignorance is both astounding and deeply saddening.
Linda
February 24th, 2010
4:43 pm
You are so pathetic, Bob! My son, a pagan, served in the military over in Iraq. To think that someone as small-minded as you at one time wanted to be president…..scares the crap out of me. Thank goodness you didn’t win. Pagans have as much right to their religion as anyone else. Our constitution protects religious freedom, among other freedoms. People like you (small-minded), need to get with the times and see that Pagans have a lot to offer our glorious country. Pagans are in all walks of life here in the States and around the world.
Get with the time, sir! Open your mind & heart to those around you. Pagans are people and have rights. Maybe we should take away your rights to freedom of speech since you don’t seem to actually know what you’re talking about
David
February 25th, 2010
8:43 pm
AMAZING!!! Yet ANOTHER “ex-congressman” who has never BEEN in the military!!! Imagine that!!! Lets see…I presume, being a “congressman” that you are even “college educated”. Which means you took a class on world religion. Which would have taught you that PAGANISM, Heathenism, whatever you wanna call it, existed WAY before Christianity. I bet you even celebrate “christian holidays” never wondering what a rabbit and eggs has to do with “Easter”…what a christmas tree has to do with the birth of a “savior”. Before you trip over your ” my religion is the ONLY religion ethos”, do consider that, you might actually be incorrect in your thoughts and/or misguided opinions. By the way…I AM PAGAN…I DID serve my country for 21 years in THE United States Air Force..AND my supervisors did NOT criticize me because I “danced around fires”. They ADMIRED me for my beliefs and told me thats why I was in the military…to protect religious freedoms.
WORLD NEWS « Northern Tribes
February 27th, 2010
12:40 pm
[...] take on this story, including former U.S. Congressman and self proclaimed “Libertarian” Bob Barr. At first glance, one would believe that the Air Force Academy is quite obviously a model of [...]
Politician Very Unhappy About Pagan Stone Circle at Air Force Academy « DOGMATRON
February 27th, 2010
5:16 pm
[...] Full story. [...]
LAST CHANCE TO GET A HUMMER: New Old News Feed (March 8, 2010) « THESE NEW OLD TRADITIONS
March 8th, 2010
5:04 am
[...] “If I were in the Air Force and was being commanded by an officer who practices hedonism as a … [...]
Kasey
March 16th, 2010
7:11 pm
This post is hopelessly offensive. You are obviously ignorant to what a pagan is and what we believe.
Jessica
March 21st, 2010
11:08 pm
How can you as a politician voice such politically incorrect garbage!!! I served in the Army, my family is a long line of military all though we are Christian we are also tolerant. I have personally began to study paganism again…my beliefs I put on the shelf due to moronic people like you taking away by constitutional freedom of religion and causing fear to my family. Those people that placed fear on my family were Die hard Christians…and we should be feared? Every religion has ritual, prayer, and is based on mythology…how dare you believe you are above any one and laugh at people SHAME ON YOU…AND YOUR WARPED SENSE OF HUMOR!
SeanBoxx
March 23rd, 2010
11:04 pm
Pagan, wiccan, blahblahblah. Don’t you people ever touch down to reality? Scientology has more credibility than you kooks. Why don’t you just call it The Divine Church of Renaissance Faire Dungeons and Dragons for the Overweight and Underbrained? If you weren’t so damned funny you’d be sad.
Nunnehi
April 4th, 2010
10:41 pm
Many think Pagans are “godless,” but they are wrong, we have many gods. You have but one,how sad. I would be happy to loan you one of mine.
Traditional Cherokee and former USAF officer.
Micheal j Chard U.S.M.C. and Pagan
April 18th, 2010
3:27 pm
I had an individual like you in my platoon once. I was reassured of the Marine Corps values while watching my Christian Marine BROTHERS police their own ranks and force this maggot to do push-ups untill his heart exploded. You insult Christiandom, and my Brothers and Sisters in the Armed Services. You’ve never served, I fail to see the relevance of your opinion. Can a Pagan make a good commander ? Oh, I don’t know, ask every Roman General before 33 AD. I suggest you get a library card.
Jennifer L.
April 18th, 2010
8:24 pm
I disagree with you immensly! Who are you to judge a religon? Im a wiccan. Its 2010 man! Its time to get off of your predjudice butt and get over the fact that their are pagans and wiccans in the military. Do you see us acting immature about Christains or Catholics??? I have friends that are Christains and Catholics, they dont judge me and i dont judge them. So how can you judge pagans in the army? If they want to practice their religon they should have the right to. 1st amendment! Freedom of Religon, Press, Petition, and Speech! You need to go over the Bill of Rights. Its the United States! So who cares if pagans and wiccans want to celebrate their religon. If it doesnt harm anyone i see nothing wrong with it. And dont try to single out one religon, theyre other religons satanists, buddist, hindus, christains, catholics, muslims, mormons, etc. Acknowledge those as well. I have nothing against any religon, but if you want to single out my religons mother? I have something to say about it. Their is nothing wrong with practicing your religon. So do i think the military should let the men and women practice their religon while serving our nation. ABSOLUTELY!
Female SrA
May 15th, 2010
4:47 pm
I’m 23, I’m in the Air Force, and I’m Wiccan. My shop has no problems with me, my friends and family know and dispite some being dedicated Christians I am completely accepted. I have many Earth Based and Pagan friends who are ALSO in the military (all branches). Also, the younger troops in my shop come to me and look to me for sound information on how to make a repair. Are you reading this properly? I AM IN THE USAF AND COMPLETLY RESPECTED DISPITE MY RELIGION. We are united as one nation under God. No wheres in there is “Christain God” “Muslim God” “American God” etc. Just “…under God”. It’s a two hundred year old quote, remember why we seperated from England.
Janus Blume
August 6th, 2010
3:41 pm
You go, Bob Barr! Our national motto is “In God we trust,” and we truly are “one nation under God” as our founding fathers saw fit to write into our…uh, oh yeah, salute to the flag. Well, some may point out that the “…under God” part wasn’t added until the middle of the twentieth century, but don’t we really know that they all served the Judeo-Christian God, and founded this country to be dedicated to Him? If you don’t believe in and serve Him, then you should have no religious rights in this land of the free. OMG, can you feel my sarcasm? How can people think this way?
Ed
August 21st, 2010
6:46 am
I am both surprised and amazed at how tolerance and diversity are our new religions. I’m a non-evangelical Christian and “tolerate” other religions, but I fully believe in Christianity. Overall, I’m not a tolerant person and why should I be? When you start dividing the country into multicultural, multiracial, mulit-religious factions, you no longer have a country…but, a Babylon of sorts. Diversity is NOT our strength, but homogenity is.