What will Braves do now that Phillies have Lee?

Cliff Lee has reportedly opted to rejoin the Phillies. (Matt Slocum, AP)

Cliff Lee has reportedly opted to rejoin the Phillies. (Matt Slocum, AP)

Free-agent left-handed pitcher Cliff Lee has reportedly spurned the offerings of the New York Yankees and Texas Rangers and opted to sign with the Philadelphia Phillies – the team that traded him away to land Cy Young Award winner Roy Halladay.

A fourth-round draft pick in 2000, Lee is 102-61 with a 3.85 ERA in nine major league seasons. He has excelled in the postseason, going 7-2 with a 2.13 ERA for Philadelphia and Texas in the past two years, including 3-0 with a 1.88 ERA against the Yankees.

According to the Associated Press, Lee has accepted the Phillies’ preliminary offer of a $100 million, five-year contract.

Lee passed up an extra $50 million from the New York Yankees to join a rotation that includes Halladay, Cole Hamels, and Roy Oswalt.

How does that stack up against Tim Hudson, Derek Lowe, Tommy Hanson and Jair Jurrjens?

The deal clearly makes Philadelphia the favorites to win the N.L. East and the World Series. How should the Braves counter this move? With who? For how much?

192 comments Add your comment

Gfsf

December 14th, 2010
8:45 am

Hit him. Hard.

justin1

December 14th, 2010
8:47 am

Yep, this definately is not good news. I think its time to give up JJ to KC for Greinke. Continue the trend of sending ex-Braves to the Royals. I would be willing to give up JJ and Beachy and maybe 1 mid-level prospect for Greinke. It may be just a dream, but if we could land a deal with KC, the Phillies have something to worry about again.

mike

December 14th, 2010
8:48 am

obviously the braves will not be able to keep up in the pitching department, and there is not any pitching available that the braves coulud go after to significantly upgrade their staff. If they want to have a chance, Wren needs to find a way to milk some more $ out of Liberty and make a trade for a CF bat. The only way for the Braves to compete with Phils is have a stacked lineup. JJ/Huddy/Hanson/Lowe will give them a chance to win, but to overcome the Phils, they must improve their lineup. The best spot to do that will be CF.

Wren, your back is against the wall. Find a way to get it done.

dean

December 14th, 2010
8:50 am

Play for the division. Take the WC. Let someone else take out the Phillies in the playoffs. We go to WS. Simple.

Let's Go Bravos!

December 14th, 2010
8:51 am

Unbelievable!! This is exactly why baseball needs a salary cap. How can they possible afford to have all those pitchers, pay Howard $25M, Utley, and ROllins. It’s not even fair. Maybe the Braves can be relevant again when all their guys retire!

Realist

December 14th, 2010
8:51 am

That blows…

bill

December 14th, 2010
8:54 am

Now the Braves know what it feels like the other teams felt in the 90’s.It’s wild card or bust.

rudy

December 14th, 2010
8:56 am

can we switch division?

Asheville Dawg

December 14th, 2010
8:57 am

A curse on the Phillies for putting together what looks like a Yankees style pitching staff. May their arms all fall off.

Mike

December 14th, 2010
8:57 am

unless they have significant injuries, the braves will be playing for a wild card. baseball is a joke that teams can buy titles.

Eric

December 14th, 2010
8:57 am

I don’t think Wren’s back is against the wall. This off season he made some great moves. But I do think that we need to counter punch Phillies with some sort of move. More starting pitchers will do.

TommyP

December 14th, 2010
8:58 am

Stick to the plan and don’t make a knee-jerk deal.

Braves are looking solid for the Wild Card while also looking very good for the future.

The bullpen could be an Atlanta version of the “Nasty Boys” in time once Marek comes up.

SS

December 14th, 2010
8:59 am

Bill the braves big 3 wanted to play here and stayed here all along. the phillies go out and buy players. plus we weren’t paying crazy money like they are to 3 offensive players ya dope.

justin1

December 14th, 2010
9:01 am

Should the Braves react?…
Absolutley. Go Get Greinke!!!

justin1

December 14th, 2010
9:02 am

Cliff Lee > Dan Uggla

Puma

December 14th, 2010
9:02 am

Chill people, obviously Phillies are going to win a lot of games, but we knew that already. Although their starting staff is undeniably better, I like our starters too. A stacked rotation and stacked line up does not guarantee titles, just ask SF Giants.

mike

December 14th, 2010
9:03 am

too late now! braves needed carl crawford to counter that move! we still need more power in the outfeild

Braves fan80

December 14th, 2010
9:04 am

Phillies are turning into the Yankees of the NL.Buying other teams star pitchers with 20 million a year contracts.

Marshall

December 14th, 2010
9:04 am

@ Let’s Go Braves

Would you want someone telling you that you can only make X amount of money per year and no more? Salary cap is a bad idea from the bigger picture point of view.

South GA Dad

December 14th, 2010
9:05 am

A trade for Greinke sounds like the best move to me. Pray that one of our center fielders has a phenomenal year and that all of our pitchers stay healthy and that Fredi doesn’t wear out the relievers half way through the season. That’s about all we got at this point. Oh and pray that the injury bug bites Philly HARD!!

Worm

December 14th, 2010
9:05 am

bill nailed it-Wildcard or bust!

E-6

December 14th, 2010
9:06 am

Tommy P – right on the mark. You simply cannot outspend the 4th largest media market in the country. On paper, the Phils win the division. On paper, the Braves win about 4-5 World Series in the ’90’s. Things don’t always play out like roto stats say they should.

Eric

December 14th, 2010
9:06 am

The Phillies have become the Yankees of the NL. They just want to buy talent and World Series. I’d like to take a look at their books and see where the money is coming from. I think the Yankes and Phillies are being funded by Al Qaeda. JK. Our pitching is good enough to give us a chance to win games, it just depends on how our bats do. They way I look at it, our hitting can only get better with Pendelton gone.

Tosh.No

December 14th, 2010
9:07 am

And screw baseball again. Jesus, its not even a game anymore. It’s lets see who spent the most money this year. Won’t be watching this crap next year either. Add basketball to that list, since its pretty much the same. The NFL is the only league that isn’t completely a buy your way to victories league, but its close and I’m sure once they finish renegotiating it will be too, and I’ll be completely done with sports in America.

Tremaine

December 14th, 2010
9:10 am

As long as we got MVP canidates Nate McClouth and Jordan Schafer in center field we will be fine.

Stephen

December 14th, 2010
9:10 am

What should the Braves do? Enjoy 2nd place in the east for the next several years.

Eric

December 14th, 2010
9:11 am

I happen to agree with you Tosh. The NFL and golf are about the only sports that are bareable to watch anymore. But, money will spoil them eventually. Atlanta only the Falcons to make us look like a somewhat legit sports city. But I know the rest of the world is laughing at the Hawks for paying Joe Johnson more than LeBron James.

meh

December 14th, 2010
9:11 am

trade McLouth, Beachy, and a couple minor leaguers to the Dodgers for Matt Kemp. He, Uggla, and Gonzo will be the right handed pop to counter Lee and Hamels. McCann, Heyward, and Freeman will be the left handed pop to counter Halladay and Oswalt. bada bing, bada boom, the Braves are champs.

Jeff

December 14th, 2010
9:12 am

The Braves wont do anything because our owners do not care about winning. The Phillies have some random group of minority owners that have decided to play with the big boys. Sucks being owned by Liberty Media they have picked up where Time Warner left off.

Tyler

December 14th, 2010
9:12 am

The season is 162 games long. You got to play out the season.

I do think our team is very comparable to theirs offensively…minus a 40 homerun guy. I still think we’ll be very good in 2011, but if I were a betting man….wild-card.

It would be nice to trade for Grienke, but he’s had one good Cy Young season. I don’t think it would be much improvement over JJ who was steller in 2009.

Maybe the Yanks will come calling for pitching and we could possibly land Gardner. Give us Victorino type speed at the top of the lineup. But if McClouth bounces back to a 30+ homer season…..

Good move by Ruben and the Phillies stealth negotiations. I’m sure that fanbase will sell out another 127 games in a row. If we could do that in Atlanta, maybe we would be gifted high dollar talent like Lee.

Hudson
Lowe
Hanson
JJ
Beachy/Minor

That is still a great staff. Phillies have the edge, but we still have a GREAT staff.

Eric

December 14th, 2010
9:12 am

I think Jeter would have been the answer to the Braves winning the NL East…..

Chris

December 14th, 2010
9:14 am

It still doesn’t bother me. Yes their rotation looks very good. If healthy probably the best in baseball. But you still have to score runs and play good defense to win. They lost a clutch bat in Werth with no actual replacement in waiting. I do have a lot of respect for Cliff Lee now. He left a lot of money on the table for a chance to win a WS. The Braves rotation wasn’t anything to scoff at either last year. It was in the top 5 in ERA. It might not blow you away with power like the Phillies will, but it will still be effective nonetheless (one word?). If Chipper comes back healthy (I know thats a huge IF) and is producing like he was right before the injury, the Braves will be fine. If Wren goes out and gets an impact player because of this, fine. What I don’t want to see is the Braves panic and then do something crazy (Tex trade). A few good prospects and JJ for a Greinke or Upton would be fine. But let’s be patient and see what we have before we start tinkering and throwing good young players away.

Chief Knockahoma

December 14th, 2010
9:14 am

Wow. That could be the best rotation is baseball history. Lace em up tight boys.

Double A

December 14th, 2010
9:14 am

This hurts if you’re a Braves fan!!

MLB is not competitive under the current salary structure. The big market teams have an extreme advantage over everyone else($$$), which allows them to reload every year.

The smaller market clubs have to load up on prospects and time it out to where they are all hitting their stride at the MLB level together.

The Braves, with a mid-level payroll, are somewhere in between. We can only afford mid-tier free agents and are too scared to trade away established vets for young talent under the fear of sinking into levels of despair comfortable only to the Washington Nats. Basically, we can’t afford to miss, because our medium payroll will then be tied up on losers that don’t produce (*cough* Lowe, Kawakami, McClouth *cough*).

It’s hard to stomach, but the Braves are only an upper-middle level team that has no hope of a World Series without the addition of an MVP caliber position player or a true power-arm ACE in the mold of Halladay, Lincecum, Lee, etc. The problem is that we cannot afford to add an established player, so we should all start praying for luck in farm system.

Blackberry Cobbler

December 14th, 2010
9:14 am

The Braves are going to do what they always do………… put together a lineup and pitching staff with retreads and duct tape. The Phils have Cliff Lee. The Braves will do nothing as always.

Tyler

December 14th, 2010
9:14 am

Trade Lowe to the Yanks and then trade for Grienke.

WinderDogg

December 14th, 2010
9:15 am

Continue to spend less money than everyone else and at the end of the season sit back and realize what they got for spending so little while being happy with an almost season….

wait that was this year….so I expect no changes in the future

randyarnold

December 14th, 2010
9:15 am

Braves are playing for the wild card, even if Chipper plays 140 games. Would a Jurrjens for Greinke deal make sense? Probably so (and the Braves would probably have to throw in a relief pitcher). Greinke’s social anxiety probably wouldn’t be a factor in Atlanta since people don’t show up for games anyway.

DO NOT TRADE JURRJENS

December 14th, 2010
9:15 am

Trading Jurrjens will be the biggest mistake in the world.Its not wrens fault,its that stupid owner who dont even care whats going in atlanta.I bet he doesnt even see that lee is going to philly.He probably doesnt even know who cliff lee is.

DO NOT TRADE JURRJENS

December 14th, 2010
9:16 am

why do you all think grenke is better than JJ????

jasont13

December 14th, 2010
9:16 am

To the person who said Frank Wren made some great moves this off season. Name them as I can only think of one and it will not be a GREAT move until Uggla is signed to a long term deal.

Dick

December 14th, 2010
9:16 am

Tosh.no is correct. With high unemployment and homeless people being turned away from shelters, we continue to have sports figures signing obscene contracts. There is no level playing field, and fans seem to be ok with that as long as their team ’s owners have the deepest pockets.

WinderDogg

December 14th, 2010
9:16 am

See if we can get Faith Hill to sing this year instead of Sara Evans….I think that will help

jasont13

December 14th, 2010
9:17 am

It’s said when the Nationals have more money to pony up than the Braves. What a has been organization.

Sean

December 14th, 2010
9:17 am

To all of you sore Braves fans, this is not a team buying a championship. Lee turned down 50 mil from the Yankees to come to the Phils. He just loves cheesesteaks I guess!

PMC

December 14th, 2010
9:17 am

Rember that the Phillies couldn’t hit at all in the Playoffs and that first baseman has a hole in his swing that is Francouer sized at times.

If the Braves were healthy they could easily have won the World Series the way it shook out this year.

Just go play. Hit and pitch, if they win the division, get in on the WC and then go win the WS. The Braves will still be a 90+ win team next year.

jasont13

December 14th, 2010
9:20 am

Major League Baseball has a luxury tax which helps bank roll other teams. What I see is teams get this money and instead of taking that money and investing it in the product on the field it goes right into the owners pockets. Like the old saying “sometimes you have to pay to get good results”.

Bob Horner had a big fro

December 14th, 2010
9:20 am

Bad news for the Braves AND baseball. The lack of a salary cap is killing MLB. There should just be a playoffs now between the Yankees, Phillies, Red Sox and just let everyone else play for the final spots. If I live in cities like KC, San Diego, Seattle, Milw., Miami… I don’t even get excited about the season.

For the Braves, our pitching is very good – maybe good enough. Closer is a concern, but more of a concern is lack of a lead off man and CF. We really need a good CF and back up plan for Chipper. Otherwise, we will just hope we don’t have injuries and pray for rain when Lee is scheduled to pitch.

Outside Observer

December 14th, 2010
9:21 am

This is crazy talk but…
Ask Chipper to retire and stay on as a coach. Then spend his money on Beltre. Great hitter who seems to be a little undervalued on the market right now.

Jesus

December 14th, 2010
9:22 am

As a true Braves fan, the news I recieved last night while crossing the days off until spring training was a kidney punch. Over the last two weeks, I was not worried about the Phillies getting Lee, then in a span of four hours, he was back in there rotation. My first thought: NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!. My second thought: How will the Phillies lose 55-60 games year?? And finally my third thought: Can we make a move now for Grienke? I realize over the last decade or so, we don’t make reactionary moves. This situation should be different. We are in a position to compete for the division and gaining a pitcher the calibur of CG would be hepful. Any objection of giving up Minor and or Beachy to get him? Make the move Wren, do not let the Phillies punk us before the season even starts….

jasont13

December 14th, 2010
9:22 am

PMC-Ryan Howard may have a hole in his swing but its very unfortunate the Braces pitchers can not seem to find it. You mention let the Phillies win the division and Braves the wild card and then go win the world series. Hell that happened last year and you saw the results. Oh and if the Braves were healthy. They couldn’t hit down the stretch and in the playoffs.

Jt

December 14th, 2010
9:23 am

Adding a frontline pitcher is not a proper response. The only response would be to add another right handed bat and that cannot happen outside of adding a centerfielder. Lefties at 1st, catcher, rightfield and center. The only possible opening is in center and that probably is not going to happen. Maybe another righthanded hitter on the bench. Nothing else needs to be done. They need for Chipper to be healthy and for Prado to have another season like 2010. They need Heyward to improve and for the rookie at first to have at least a Heyward-type first year. The question is in center.

Another bat and LH starter.

December 14th, 2010
9:24 am

The Braves need another big bat to help counter the move. Uggla will help against Hamels and Lee, but I am not sure we have done anything to combat Halladay and Oswalt. Good pitching beats good hitting, but I am not sure there is a shut down LH available to match up with the likes of Howard and Uttley. It sucks having cheap ownership!

Really?

December 14th, 2010
9:24 am

jasont13 – How can you say they aren’t great moves? They haven’t even played one game yet. You sir are a Tard!

space monkey

December 14th, 2010
9:32 am

Speed. That’s really where the Braves lack. Rollins and Victorino are the Phils’ real weapons.

jasont13

December 14th, 2010
9:33 am

I asked you to name the moves. You still can’t. How can you say they are great moves when they haven’t played a game yet. Your sir are the true retard.

Justwanna win

December 14th, 2010
9:34 am

Sign Bill Hall..he can do it all plus hit……Trade for.J Upton..when the heavy part of his contract comes around Chipper will be gone….Plus both Hall & Upton are Insurance for Chipper hurt and Prado staying in LF and security for 7 positions.
Trade for Grenike ? I like who we got.
Its your move Mr Wren…make the most of it..Do the Braves really wish to win?
We need rh hitters..

Huh?

December 14th, 2010
9:34 am

Did some dude say golf was a watchable sport? Where does my fair city find these people? If golf is so great then sit on your sectional couch in your basement in Alphrettamine while real fans revel in the joy of America’s Pastime.

Justwanna win

December 14th, 2010
9:38 am

Oh, Upton speed….something we need bad……..

crob

December 14th, 2010
9:38 am

justin 1, how do you think Greinke is such a great move. He’s only had one winning season. he averages 1 walk per 4.5 innings and a hit every inning. There’s no way i trade JJ for him. You just cant get excited. Thats why they play the game. Whats on paper is not the outcome.

K.C. Frenchy

December 14th, 2010
9:38 am

With Texas still desparate for pitching, how about we trade JJ & throw in someone else for Nelson Cruz, we need to add another RH bat in the outfield that can play either LF or CF for WHEN not if Chipper goes down, right now we have hige holes in CF & 3B, McOut & Chipper is a bad plan, that would leave us with Huddy, Lowe, Hanson, & Minor with Medlen coming back after the break, what do you Bravo fans think???

lexbrave

December 14th, 2010
9:40 am

i rarely wish ill intentions on anyone, but i truly hope spending all of this money backfires on the phillies.

Justwanna win

December 14th, 2010
9:40 am

Cruz not going anywhere………

PMC

December 14th, 2010
9:40 am

Guys, I wanted Carl Crawford. The ownership doesn’t. The Braves Ownership doesn’t care about winning and we have a stadium that is 15,000 seats too large. What are you gonna do?

The best course of action right now is being pursued by the Braves.

They can’t afford front line free agents, they have to build through the minors, they’ve been on that course for a while now.

It will be ok.

William C Smith

December 14th, 2010
9:41 am

Baseball is now becoming a small elite group of teams that spend there way to championships. When a small market team wins they speak of balance, but then they buy the stars of the small market team. As for the Braves. They can make moves to stay competitive, but in the long run can not spend enough to become a champion. It is ironic that this process of buying championships was begun by Ted Turner an the Braves.

GaryinBham

December 14th, 2010
9:42 am

And what move can we make for the little that is left? I actually think the offense is going to be decent. Jason is one year better, Prado back, and Uggla. Maybe Gonzo will hit some of those HRs for us. Pitching-wise, it’s the Phils hands down with starters. But I think the loss of Werth is bigger than they say, and I think at this point, the offense isn’t as good. Our starters are good, except for that 5th spot. I’m not sure Beachy/Minor is the answer for the year. Help is coming, but do you trade incredible prospects or do the best you can with what you have? We can compete. That pitching is murder to face, no doubt. On the other hand,Halliday is 34 in May, Oswalt will be 34 in August. Blanton is likely gone to clear salary/get an OF. Lee is 32. Those three have logged a ton of innings. Maybe they all hold up without injuries, maybe not. It’s a lot of dough for a few guys. But there’s only one stat that matters–Ws. They are way better than everybody on paper. We’ll see how it goes. If they win the WS it won’t be a surprise. But a lot of people said that would happen last year.

gadawgs

December 14th, 2010
9:42 am

There was a time that we had this type of rotation and I remember losing to teams with less. It’s not over before it starts people..

PMC

December 14th, 2010
9:43 am

Look at the Braves bullpen and the young guys they have that can throw in the minors.

Let’s not panic. JJ should bounce back this year.

There is no reason to not be confident going into this season when they have added power to the offense finally in Dan Uggla.

jasont13

December 14th, 2010
9:43 am

Really?- Heres your great moves. Sherill- 2-2 6.69 era, gave up more hits than innings pitched and also almost as many walks as strikeouts (24BB vs. 25K) Linebrink-3-2 4.40 era same as Sherill gave up more hits than innings pitched but he did have better strikeout to walk ratio. Then you get into Uggla. Yes he will hit 25+ home runs but will also strike 130+ times. It will be a great move ONLY if Wren signs Uggla to a long term deal.

If your adding signing Wilkin Castillo, Shawn Bowman and others a part of all these great deals Frank Wren made this off season then your an idiot.

Justwanna win

December 14th, 2010
9:45 am

They can afford Hall………….he is not a crawford 7 yr 140 million .. They can afford to trade for Upton. Those two would make 10 -15 game difference in team..are more

jasont13

December 14th, 2010
9:46 am

I don’t think the Phils loosing Werth was that big of a deal they had Dominic Brown waiting at Triple-A. He is the real deal. I truly do not understand why Wren doesn’t go after BJ Upton. He would be a solid leadoff hitter with speed and plays better defense than McClouth.

O-Me

December 14th, 2010
9:48 am

Men you have forgot…WE GOT SCHAFER?

jasont13

December 14th, 2010
9:49 am

It’s interesting how Nate McClouth’s numbers have diminished since he was traded to the Braves. He stole more bases in Pittsburgh and was caught stealing more times in two seasons with the Braves than his entire 4 seasons with Pittsburgh ( 8 times in 2 seasons with the Braves and 5 with Pittsburgh).

justwanna win

December 14th, 2010
9:49 am

jasont13, I’d take either Upton.

bwell

December 14th, 2010
9:49 am

Get another power hitter plus another hitter with consistency or the ability to get on base, resign Jurrjens and pray that the owners know this and are willing to shell out the money to compete! I hate Ted Turner sold his soul to the devil. (Time Warner)

Bob Horner had a big fro

December 14th, 2010
9:50 am

No bigger Braves fan than me, but let’s face it: the Braves did so well in the division because the Phillies had incredible injury issues last year. Odds are, they won’t again in 2011, and they are going to win the division running away. I hope I am wrong, but they have a Yankees / Red Sox type lineup with the pitching of the 90’s Braves on top of that. Scary. With that said, we can still make it to the playoffs and hope for some luck. Unlikely Wren can sign a big name CF at the same time he is working to lock in Uggla, BUT if we could trade up in CF or use Chippers money at third, it would help.

CBW

December 14th, 2010
9:52 am

The sad truth is that as long as the Braves have the payroll they’ve got, they won’t be able to compete with the Phillies, the Red Sox or the Yankees.

BravesFan

December 14th, 2010
9:53 am

Did the Phillies win the World Series this year? I don’t think so. The Phillies also have lost Werth which was a big part of their team last year. The Braves pitching is fine, what we need is another bat. Someone that would compliment Heyward (Jones if he returns), Prado and Ugla. Freeman being a rookie can’t expect to have a .300 BA next year. We need to trade for somone, anyone that could hit 20 hr, drive in 80 and bat 265 or above. Centerfield is our issue.

BravesFan

December 14th, 2010
9:54 am

Bob Horner,

I would say the Braves would have won the division last year if Prado, Chipper, Medlen had not gone down.

BeerDawg

December 14th, 2010
9:54 am

A little perspective. What are the odds of Lee, Halladay, Hamels, and Oswalt all going thru the season without injuries??

Oswalt, while clearly still good, is on the downside of his career.

B/C of the obscene amounts of money spent of Halladay and Lee, they did not resign Werth and rumors abound about a Mondesi trade.

FW: don’t panic!!!

justwanna win

December 14th, 2010
9:55 am

You right its a lost cause as long as Liberty own the Braves. less just quit….Hell NO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

Eric

December 14th, 2010
9:56 am

why would redsox help out phillies by trying to acquire Joe Blanton?

bvillebaron

December 14th, 2010
9:56 am

Since pitching wins, the only way to counter the Phils’ move is to acquire another front line starter. The best is Greinke given his contract, age (just turned 27), stuff (once listened to a game when he threw a 96 mph fastball, followed by a 65 mph changeup and a 85 mph breaking pitch). I like Jurrjens too, but he doesn’t have Greinke’s stuff (for those who claim Greinke only had one great season, he did and his combined ERA the last three seasons in the AL is 3.24; besides how many great years has Jurrjens had?). Unlike Jurrjens, Greinke is not represented by Boras.

If you want to keep Jurrjens, trade Delgado, Viscaino, Beachy or, if necesary, Minor to get Greinke.

lexbrave

December 14th, 2010
9:57 am

i’m pretty sure the phils are spending more money on their rotation than the braves are on their entire team right now.

it’s becoming harder each year to love baseball as much as i do. for the first offseason i can remember that i’m not even excited for the season to start. and that’s after 20+ years of thinking opening day was the best day of my year.

NY BRAVES FAN

December 14th, 2010
10:00 am

You can not trade jurjjens to get Greinke, that is not so much an upgrade. An upgrade is keeping Hudson, Hansen, Lowe, and JJ and adding Greinke as our ace.

I don’t even know if we need Greinke , I would not do anything until we play some baseball. Let’s see if Chipper is healthy, how much better Jay -Hey is, how good Freeman is. If we play good ball we get someone in June. No point in gutting the system now.

Braves Fan No More

December 14th, 2010
10:00 am

They should all just quit, just give up now, for there is no hope of beating that rotation.

Braves Fan No More

December 14th, 2010
10:01 am

Well you asked. That’s what I really believe.

ppaddy123

December 14th, 2010
10:02 am

If MLB doesn’t implement a salary cap, the sport we all grew up with will not continue. Everyday, more and more fans gripe about the big market teams signing all the good players. Meanwhile, the small market teams are signing guys to play everyday that aren’t everyday players anymore (KC: Frenchy, Blanco, & Melky) Imagine being a Royals season ticket holder and getting excited about their team. And for all the people preaching about needing a league minimum payroll….that’s absurd! A salary cap evens the playing field. It forces teams to pick and choose players that not only help their team but fit their budget. No more buying championships (1997 Marlins & 2009 Yankees). I don’t think anyone would argue the Yankees of the 90’s were a great ball club. Most of their key players were home grown. The Braves teams of the 90’s were the same with the exception of Maddux and McGriff, for the most part. As it stands now, teams with money to spend, spend it freely. Everyone else makes due with what they’ve got. How is that fair? Who wants to see a professional product with the label, “it’s the best we could afford?”

Joey

December 14th, 2010
10:02 am

Recession? What recession?

ga gator

December 14th, 2010
10:04 am

This makes letting one of the better righthanded hitters against lefties even a dumber move.

ga gator

December 14th, 2010
10:04 am

Meaning Matt Diaz of course.

ryan

December 14th, 2010
10:05 am

I am done with MLB these guys are getting paid to much money and half of them don’t deserve it screw baseball .

Frenchy

December 14th, 2010
10:06 am

Man oh man, how did I ever end up here in KC? Oh, that’s right, I’m an uncoachable prima donna, who can’t hit his weight. Dang.

>Frank Wren

December 14th, 2010
10:06 am

Braves must do something…I say work a JJ+prospects for Grienke and then go hard after Brett Gardner, who is available for a package of McLouth/Delgado/prospects.

Hudson
Hanson
Grienke
Lowe
Minor

Gardner
Prado
Heyward
Uggla
McCann
Jones
Freeman
Gonzalez

Dan

December 14th, 2010
10:06 am

Well realistically the Phils already had the best starting pitching anyway before this deal. So when it comes play-off time does it really matter. In the end this might help the Braves because now the Yankees and the Rangers need pitching and maybe we can unload salaries like Lowe and Kawakami and get players or prospects in return.

Better on Paper

December 14th, 2010
10:07 am

Remember all the years when our staff was loaded with the likes of Maddux, Glavine , and Smoltz? What did it get us? One WS title…the bottom line is the Phils staff is better than the Braves but you still gotta’ lace ‘em up and play the games. Anything is possible as we know all too well.

Chris

December 14th, 2010
10:07 am

Clifton Phifer Lee = LeBron James

I hate the Philadelphia Phankees.

Johnny Fever

December 14th, 2010
10:08 am

PMC

December 14th, 2010
9:40 am
Guys, I wanted Carl Crawford. The ownership doesn’t. The Braves Ownership doesn’t care about winning and we have a stadium that is 15,000 seats too large. What are you gonna do?

The best course of action right now is being pursued by the Braves.

They can’t afford front line free agents, they have to build through the minors, they’ve been on that course for a while now.

It will be ok.

THe braves could put a movie on the jumbotron for the 15000 empty seats.

Roja

December 14th, 2010
10:09 am

Let me know when Cliff Lee has a World Series ring, then I’ll worry.

Braves Fan No More

December 14th, 2010
10:10 am

Thank you Chris for saying something that we can all agree upon: “I hate the Philadelphia Phillies!” Only I would add, “And their fans.”

Roja

December 14th, 2010
10:11 am

When Cliff Lee last pitched for the Phillies, the Braves won the season series from the Phils. When has he led a team to a World Series Championship?

Bravo

December 14th, 2010
10:11 am

There’s no way to sugar coat this news – The Phils have to be considered the NL East favorites based on their rotation. Based on our rotation and bull pen, The Braves have to be considered the Wild Card favorite. With steroids being monitored more closely, baseball is retruning to a more normal game where good pitching trumps good hitting the majority of the time. The Phillies have very good to great starting pitching and the Braves have very good starting and relief pitching. The biggest question marks for the Phils will be an aging line up, loss of Werth, and suspect relif pitching. The biggest question marks for the Braves are centerfield, third base and first base. It should be an interesting 2011. Halladay, Lee, Oswalt, and Hamels – damn!

Scott Boras

December 14th, 2010
10:11 am

Jordan Schafer will come out of this Spring Training as the CF starter and will finally be the player the Braves have been expecting him to be. The Braves will happily eat $3M of McLouth’s annual salary to ship him off to somewhere else and the Braves will have an awesome lineup top to bottom. Will the Braves lineup stack up man to man with the Phillies? Probably not. But, as has been mentioned previously, just having the best talent doesn’t always guarantee success.

lexbrave

December 14th, 2010
10:12 am

how long until we get wren’s response of “we feel really good about our team”

Braves Fan No More

December 14th, 2010
10:14 am

When the team gets a real owner, then I’ll be back. Until then I am, Braves Fan No More.

lexbrave

December 14th, 2010
10:14 am

“When has he led a team to a World Series Championship?”

When has he pitched in the same rotation with Halliday, Oswalt and Hammels?

Johnny Fever

December 14th, 2010
10:15 am

Why the gloom? We have KK!

Johnny Fever

December 14th, 2010
10:17 am

Roja

December 14th, 2010
10:11 am
When Cliff Lee last pitched for the Phillies, the Braves won the season series from the Phils. When has he led a team to a World Series Championship?

Ahhh….this year with texas rangers…

varoadrunner

December 14th, 2010
10:25 am

Some on the blog are not reading about KC’s needs. Clearly, they are set in pitching from within. What Dayton Moore wants is “up-the-middle” players. Who could we possibly send to KC? If we still had Escobar, he’d make a good match for the Royals, but he’s gone. Do we send Prado? NO! Do we send Agon, then who plays short? I still say we need to spend some money on a powerful CF and let’s play ball. On paper, our rotation does not match up as well with Philly’s but we are in another year with some awful BIG IF’S. If Shafer, if McLouth, If Freeman, if Chipper, If minor or Beachy and so on………. Cross your fingers folks and let’s see if Wren will pull the trigger on a trade.

DavidC23

December 14th, 2010
10:28 am

My main concerns are the corner infield positions. I love Chipper and he has been my favorite Brave of all time, and we wouldn’t have won as many division titles if it wasn’t for him. And I wish he would come back 100%, but lets face it he won’t. More than likely Prado will have to fill in at 3rd a lot. And that only leaves us with Heyward in the outfield. We need way more depth in the case that Chipper doesn’t make it all season. And then Freman. The dude has incredible potential. But can he step right up in his rookie season and produce big numbers, not likely. I am hoping for the best and like a kid waiting for Christmas Morning, I am waiting for Spring Training to start.

coach smith

December 14th, 2010
10:28 am

it is simple trade away anything it takes to get Upton from the D-Backs

Bravo

December 14th, 2010
10:28 am

Going into 2011, the NL East teams look like this:

Phillies look like the team to beat.
Braves look like the Wild Card favorite.
Nationals will be improved but not ready to contend.
Marlins, always pesky, will be good but not a contender.
Mets are in shambles and have a lock on the basement.

And yet, one never knows, and that’s the beauty of a baseball season.

bruce mac

December 14th, 2010
10:33 am

The game is not played on paper or the Giants would not be World Series Champs and the Braves would have more than one World Series ring. The Braves need an outfielder and it isn’t because of the Cliff Lee deal. With another talent in the outfield I like our chances. For whatever reason the straw (Rollins) ain’t stirring the drinnk anymore and that is the key to the Phillies. I guaranty one of these Philly pitchers will end up on DL for extended period. That is just the law of averages for 30 something pitchers. The Braves will have injuries too which is why we need another outfielder with pop or speed and a high OBP. We have plenty of pitching depth.

TB

December 14th, 2010
10:33 am

I must admit I didn’t know who Grienke was to all these trade rumors started flying. Neither did any of the people I talk baseball with on a daily basis. So I looked him up. 10 W & 14 L & a 4.17 ERA doesn’t impress me much. He puts up a lot of innings & Ks, but I wouldn’t trade Conrad for him, if it was up to me which it’s not. Fans are making a knee-jerk reaction to this & they shouldn’t. Our pitching is fine. We’ve beaten all the top pitchers before. The only place this really does them any good is if they make the playoffs. And I don’t recall that either the Yankees or the Phils made it to the world series last year. I still like the Braves chances.

ChrisfromSacrament,CA

December 14th, 2010
10:35 am

Im sorry but for the paople who say we have a great staff, you people are out of your minds.

Lowe is a inninges eater at best.
Hudson may be a top 10 pitcher in the National League. May be!
Hanson stuff can be electric at times.
JJ Just another young pitcher whos light has dimmed.
Beachy Funny

The Phils just won the National League last night.

Halladay Hof’er
Hammels WS MVP Allstar
Oswalt Can dominate teams
Lee Top three lefty in baseball
The Philie Phanatic is better than out fifth starter.

The Phils have a great rotation. Maybe more dominiate than the 90’s Braves. Sad to say the Braves dont have a dominate rotation that misses bat. POWER ARMS WIN IN THE POST SEASON. ASK THE GIANTS. Maybe with Greinke it makes it better.

The Phills pen is horrible, but they still hit way better than the Braves. It is going to be a long year

LivinInAL

December 14th, 2010
10:41 am

I hear you guys beating drum for Greinke, but I think the Yankees are going to after him in a rage after Lee dumping on them.

justin1

December 14th, 2010
10:45 am

Braves Fan No More:
You are a nerd.

Matt

December 14th, 2010
10:48 am

The Braves need to get another bat. It’s imperative we get a better option at CF. That’s going to be the difference.

hawaiibravefan

December 14th, 2010
10:48 am

Oooo scary. the phillies have cliff lee, roy oswalt, roy halladay, and cole hamels in a same rotation. Wasn’t how the yankees were last season with cc sabathia, andy pettite, phil hughes, and a.j. burnett? haha i won’t be surprised if oswalt stinks it up, cliff lee is average, and cole goes to waste. The Philies are the “YANKEE WANNA BE’S”

ExBraves Fan

December 14th, 2010
10:50 am

How should they react????? By purchasing their high school, college and pro football tickets right now for the 2011 season. The lowly Braves ARE NOT GOING TO WIN THE EAST. You heard it here first. Plus, the wild card is probably LONG GONE also. They simply will not compete this year. Before a couple more seasons are gone, even WA will be above the lowly Braves. Good luck Freddie. You are going to NEED it!!!

Keith

December 14th, 2010
10:58 am

So now they have like 3 clutch pitchers in the postseason: Lee, Halladay, Oswalt.

Yes, we are playing for the division at this point. HOwever, Phils are one injury away from the Braves and Phils being even after the Uggla deal. We will see!

SALARY CAP PLEASE! :)

BeerDawg

December 14th, 2010
10:58 am

OK folks, y’all want to trade the farm for Greinke who has emotional and anxiety problems, this fact on a guy who played in that pressure packed atmosphere known as Kansas City……Really??

Dean

December 14th, 2010
10:58 am

Build up your bullpen as the Braves have. They simply can’t get anymore pitching for their bullpen cna they? Your not going to get a better top 4 than that so don’t even try. No need to panic, just go out there and win an many as you can. Get hot in the postseason and that’s the way you do it. As I remember, the other 3 didn’t get the Phils to the world series and Lee didn’t fare so well in the world series. it stinks, but don’t let it change our goals and what we have already built.

Keith

December 14th, 2010
10:58 am

*playing for the WC* meant to say

Keith

December 14th, 2010
11:00 am

Greinke had one stellar season, but is a basket case and his mental/emotional state definitely affects his play from year to year. Keep JJ. The upside of JJ is much greater than the upside to Greinke…and Greinke’s downside much greater than JJ’s.

Eric B

December 14th, 2010
11:01 am

Get Greinke!

Johnny Fever

December 14th, 2010
11:06 am

Ill sign with the braves for league minimum of 1 miliion.

Kentavo

December 14th, 2010
11:07 am

Do not subract pitching; if we can get Greinke another way, do it.
Then sign from this group: Branyan; Cantu, D.Lee, Nady, Damon.
Or say, F it, go for broke, sign Beltre and move to Chipper to LF, and 1b (spelling Freeman) – I know, I know, this will never happen, but this is a blog.

Johnny Fever

December 14th, 2010
11:08 am

jj is not dynomite. Very inconsistant. That is his problem. If he was a rookie, fine. You dont know who you are getting.

Jack G

December 14th, 2010
11:12 am

Hey folks—dont panic—-they still have to play the games.These high priced players dont always pan out.—Where did the Yankees with the big payroll finish last year??? World series champs (chumps)???

felix

December 14th, 2010
11:13 am

the braves shold play hard too so we have talent to make good trade for grenke

KevClo

December 14th, 2010
11:16 am

Call back Glavine, Smoltz, and Maddox. to the line up they can pull it back for two more seasons. They will be really CHEAP. Right Braves CHEAP……….

Johnny Fever

December 14th, 2010
11:17 am

grenke? con someone explain why?

justwanna win

December 14th, 2010
11:19 am

Hall & Upton….

BuckyD

December 14th, 2010
11:19 am

The Mets tried this 2-3 years ago.. it takes more than 2 great pitchers to dominate a league.. They still do not have as many quality startes as we do, they do NOT have the Bull Pen, and they lost a excellent hitter(Werth).. The team with the fewest injuries to their starters and the deepest Bench and Bullpen will Dominate this season.. Go Bravos….

TB

December 14th, 2010
11:21 am

Why don’t the Braves just concede now & let’s all crown the Phils world champs? Because they still have to play the games, you morons. Why don’t you do us all a favor & just pack up & move to Philly right now?

South Georgia Braves

December 14th, 2010
11:23 am

Come on everybody. Adding Lee certainly helps the Phils, but the games have to be played. And look at their W-L last year. Besides Halladay (21-10), it looks like this – Lee (12-9), Hamels (12-11) and Oswalt (13-13).

A few years back, when Randy Johnson signed with the Yanks, everyone crowned them champs in December…but it didn’t happen.

The loss of Werth has to be adressed. No, I can’t award them the series yet. It isn’t won on paper – it’s won on the field.

And Greinke?? Anyone look at his stats last year? He had a great year two years ago and won the CY Young. Anyone remember Jake Peavy or Pat Hentgen?

stew

December 14th, 2010
11:26 am

Tyler
I couldn’t agree with you more. Yanks are desperate for pitching. We can now dump D Lowe and his 15 mill per year which the bottomless pit (Yanks) will go for. He ain’t gonna pitch like he did at the end of the year. After that trade for Greinke. Keep JJ and let them choose from Minor/Beachy/Vizcaino/Hoover. Teheran and Delgado should be untouchable.How is it that Phils can now afford Lee after trading him 2 years ago because they couldn’t pay Hallyday and him. Yanks are desperate! DUMP LOWE WHILE WE CAN!

Rocky Mountain Bulldog

December 14th, 2010
11:27 am

Be prepared to play, for a wild card spot. Barring a major Phillie’s injury.

feartheBraves

December 14th, 2010
11:28 am

If the Braves are willing to consider a trade for Greinke, they should also check with the Mariners about Felix Hernandez – he’s more consistent anyway. It would probably take a package including 1 or 2 of these 3: Jurrjens/Beachy/Minor, and 1 or 2 top prospects – yeah, it’s a steep price, but King Felix is still young.

Or maybe the best thing to do this season is nothing at all. The Braves will be starting young players like Heyward and Freeman (potentially Schafer as well). Plus, they’ve got all kinds of young pitching talent. Do you wait and give the younger guys time to develop, or do you trade a few away for a proven star?

DieHardPhilsFan

December 14th, 2010
11:30 am

oh you guys are so adorable. You keep mentioned what did all that pitching in the 90’s bring the braves? except, you forget you need hitting too…of which the phils have plenty. I love the comment about if the braves hadn’t had injuries to…what was it…3 forgettable players they’d have won the division. Priceless!!! Lets play that game…if the phils hadn’t had injuries to…Utley, Rollins, Howard, Ruiz, Victorino, Polanco, Ibanez, Madson, Romero, among others…they’d have won the division by 15 games. Did you happen to notice their record in the end of the season? Despite bad offense they finished 45-17. Imagine what’ll happen when their offense returns to normal, with this pitching staff.
And the phils worked their way into elite company like the red sox and yanks. Braves could’ve too, so stop whining about it. man this is gonna be a great year!

Brooklyn Braves Brawler

December 14th, 2010
11:40 am

I am amazed at how people are calling Zach Greinke a “basket case” or a “head case” when the fact of the matter is that we had knuckleheads like John Rocker and Deion Sanders in our organization.

Lets be clear, Grienke is better than any pitcher we have in the Bravos org right now, period! Huddy and DLowe have one 20 win season each while Grienke has a Cy Young award in the hitter friendly AL.

Prospects are just that, prospects and they are all “can’t miss” until they do miss. Grieke is as dominant as King Felix and narrows the gap for the Bravos if acquired. The goal is to win games at the MLB level.

Minor league glory does not equate to pro success. You make the deal with the Royals and that means that JJ/Beachy/Viscaino or Teheran/ goes. If you can get them to take KK or Nate then throw that in as well. You make the deal to win and compete now.

Johnny Fever

December 14th, 2010
11:43 am

@South Georgia Braves

December 14th, 2010
11:23 am

Im sure KK was awesome in japan years ago. Whats your point?

bvillebaron

December 14th, 2010
11:44 am

Keith:

There is no way that JJs upside is greater than Greinke. 27 year old pitchers who consistently throw in the mid 90s, have excellent secondary pitches and have already won a Cy Young award in the AL despite pitching for a truly lousy team don’t grow on trees. I saw somewhere where there were something like 10 or more games that the Royals scored ZERO runs while Greinke was still in the game pitching last year. I don’t care how good you are, zero run support adversely effects EVERY pitcher. Despite last year, Greinke’s combined ERA over the past 3 seasons in the AL is 3.24. If you accept the idea that on average an AL pithcer’s ERA in the NL will be about a half a run lower, this equates to 2.74.

The comment about Greine being a “basket case” because he suffered from an anxiety disorder at age 20 is frankly a cheap shot. He has gone to the post consistently since he received treatment for it in case you haven’t noticed. Maybe you recall a pretty fair pitcher who became really good after he started seeing a sports psychologist. Does the name John Smoltz ring a bell for you? Did you consider him to be a basket case too?

I for one would love to see what Greinke could do on a winning team in the NL such as the Braves. In my opinion, Hudson, Greinke, Hanson and Jurrjens match up very well with Halladay, Hamels, Lee and Oswalt and, with the exception of Hudson, are all much younger.

Brooklyn Braves Brawler

December 14th, 2010
11:47 am

I’m a big KK supporter having seen him pitch in Japan years ago. He is a really good pitcher but MLB hitter are the best in the world and even good pitches get hit at the MLB level. KK will be good somewhere else but as much as I love the Bravos, we weren’t equipped to handle Japaneese players.

KK would be better suited in Boston or Seattle, IMO!

Buster

December 14th, 2010
11:49 am

Bill Hall and J Upton….

bobbymahlon

December 14th, 2010
11:50 am

If my memory is correct JJ’s agent is Boros so this will be his last year with the Braves so why not try and get Greinke for JJ and a minor leaguer. Also if we could find some way to get Matt Kemp I like our chances just as good as the Phillies. Call me a dreamer if you want but I’m going to keep on dreaming. Good luck Wren.

Homer in Athens

December 14th, 2010
11:50 am

How old is hudson now? He will be 36 i believe this season. He had a great year but his age will show soon. We should trade him and get a young stud pitcher in return so we can re-set this staff with young talent. We should have traded chipper as well because he is done IMO. He will miss half the season because he has health issues and now another blown out knee. We should unload his ass too for another 3b or perhaps a talented young CF prospect. You gotta get something for players while they are worth something. We can get something good for huddy and maybe with chipper just because of his name. All wren has done is put a band aid over issues. We are gonna rely on freeman at 1b? Likely not a good situation there. I don’t think he is close to ready yet. We have a terrible OF and mcsuck is gonna start this year? Not again…i can’t take the 4 hoppers to 1b and all the strikeouts. Gonzo hit bombs in toronto but didn’t do much with the braves along with some silly errors. The braves are talking up a kid to possibly play LF who is hitting over .300 in the mexican league?? THE MEXICAN LEAGUE?? Jesus, we are NEVER going to win in the postseason with this lineup people! GET REAL! I can’t believe some of you claim “just get in the postseason”… and then what? Set a strikeout record in a series again? Lead all postseason teams in errors? This team still has a crap defense! Heyward is overrated as he*l! He reminds me of francoeur all over again. He takes biscuits down the pipe and swings at garbage. Look for the rockies to take the wildcard in 2011 not the braves. I would bet my house the braves don’t even make the playoffs in 2011! This team is average on paper as it gets. Decent pitching with an average lineup= NOT GONNA GET IT DONE!

GeuaxBravos

December 14th, 2010
11:51 am

Counter for Lee going to the Phils has to be done in combination bcuz their is no one player in Free agency..

Go for Grienke? yes..Trade JJ for him?no

Lowe and Conrad plus a low-mid level prospect should be a basis for that trade, and later trade Beachy and some other prospects for Upton. If we cant get Upton then go Beachy for Cain of the Brewers straight up maybe KK in the deal..Bill Hall can help counter as well..That combo gives us a leadoff/CF, another pitcher who will win 20 games with his pitching,an Omar Infante type Utility man and free ourselves of those money bugs..

“Injuries Bug” can still be a role player for the Braves,but they look pretty much out of the division..One homer from Howard with the Phils rotation can win games for them..

We cant get over the hump with Lowe( innings eater only),McClouth(Position player Bust), and KK(Pitching Bust) taking up alot of money as well..Those 3 need to be moved..

birddawgbill

December 14th, 2010
11:52 am

As a Braves fan I hate this. As a human being I gained much respect for Cliff Lee. According to The Herd on ESPN Radio, Lees son is in remission from leukemia and Philedelphia has the #1 childrens Hospital in the U.S. Thats why he went there and left money on the table. My hats off to you Cliff Lee.

Poorbrave

December 14th, 2010
11:56 am

Texas and NYY are now after Grenski…

Poorbrave

December 14th, 2010
11:59 am

Greinke ( sp) never been much for spelling.

Brooklyn Braves Brawler

December 14th, 2010
11:59 am

The one key difference that i see is that the Yanks, Red Sox, White Sox, and Phils fans demand that their team be great and won’t settle for anythin less.

Braves fans (me included) hope that are team maybe great. That blows and until we start holding mgmt. accountable for the moves or non-moves they make then we will be middle of the pack. I don’t know about you all but I don’t want to be listed next to Cincy and Colorado potential. I want to be a playoff team opening day! As it stands now, things have to go perfectly just for us to sniff the wildcard, thats unsatifactory

South Georgia Braves

December 14th, 2010
12:04 pm

@ Johnny Fever – “And Greinke?? Anyone look at his stats last year? He had a great year two years ago and won the CY Young. Anyone remember Jake Peavy or Pat Hentgen?”

One year wonders.

bvillebaron

December 14th, 2010
12:09 pm

Brooklyn Braves Brawler:

While you and I seem to agree on Greinke, I don’t think you clear out the farm system for him. As I posted earlier, I think you want to keep JJ in order to have 4 quality starters and trade two of your key pitching prospects not named Teheran (i.e. Delgado and Viscaino) and preferably Beachy, but if necesary Minor and this deal may get done.

Allof this is probably wishful thinking since Greinke is set to earn $13.5 this year.

GeuaxBravos

December 14th, 2010
12:12 pm

DOB says that FW isnt making any counters..so to all the concerned fans wishing we could have a counter, well that idea was just shot i guess..

George W

December 14th, 2010
12:14 pm

I dont think the Braves will do anything prior to the season starting. However once the season has started and we can see what kind of on field production we are getting, they may make a trade or aquire someone. Cliff Lee could fall on his face. Let them spend that BIG MONEY and we can hope he does not produce.

Randal Patrick McMurphy

December 14th, 2010
12:15 pm

MASSIVE shift in the balance of power… not only on the Senior Circuit, but in MLB as a whole. There will be NO letup in the pitching quality when playing the Phillies in any series, 2-3-4 games… whatever. You can only hope for an ‘off-day’ from them, and then hope to take advantage of the lapse…

What should the Braves (or anyone else) do? Just go out and play the game with the best of what you’ve got, and let the chips fall where they may. Hopefully, when the dust settles the Braves have played well enuff to qualify for “The Show”… :-?

Brooklyn Braves Brawler

December 14th, 2010
12:18 pm

B’ville,

I think you have to give to get and although the farm system is vulnerable if a deal is going to happen, you are paying for:

1. The ability to have Grienke under contract @ 2yrs/ 27 mil. That is cheap compared to what pitcher of his ilk are going for. (See Sabathia, Lee, Halladay)

2. You will get 2 yrs of exclusive negotiating time for a possible long-term deal.

3. The chance to get draft picks when and if he leaves via FA.

While i don’t want to gut the system, the Royals wont take just anybody for Zach. They may even let him play his contract out ant take their picks when they offer him arbitration in 2 years.

HeadCheese

December 14th, 2010
12:23 pm

Lets not here the whining about Yankees buying penants. Boston and Philly is the model for this now. This deal makes it hard to think the Braves have a chance to win the division.

bring back blauser

December 14th, 2010
12:27 pm

all this is doing is leading up to mlb going bankrupt. Guess who will pick up the tab? The american taxpayer. The owners know what they are doing. When all is said and done, we the people get screwed

Matt the Brave

December 14th, 2010
12:33 pm

Gsfs: I agree. Let’s use a car. :D

Braverman

December 14th, 2010
12:38 pm

Its more about the lack of money than about not reacting to the Phillies. If we had cash to spend you can bet your arse we would react. The Lee signing obviously completely trumps any improvements the Braves have made and thus you cannot honestly feel as though we have closed the gap any, instead it has increased. The reality is Wren is handcuffed for atleast 1 more year with Chipper and McClouth salaries. Even if we get what Chipper was doing pre-injury and what McClout did post demotion, we dont stack up very well against them. With Washington looking to make more moves as well (possibly Greinke) you can assume the East will be more competitive than last year, not predicting the Nats to win anything but they play Atlanta tough and looking to add pieces now. So its almost like we are going into 2011 the same way as 2010, on a wing and a prayer. The only chance you have at improving is to go ahead and accept that McClouth is dead weight, throw him in the Kawakami pile where you will take anything to get rid of them and still pay their salary. You arent getting Chipper to accept anything other than the thought he will be in the opening day lineup and play everyday he is healthy and make 13 million dollars. Think about Beltre in the lineup. No depletion of the farm, huge bat, good glove. But alas we have a over the hill superstar (who has earned the right to become an albatross I guess) and and overpaid has been that will keep this team from improving.

Matt

December 14th, 2010
12:41 pm

Blame the Yankees for the escalating salaries in baseball…

bring back blauser

December 14th, 2010
12:45 pm

no not the yankees blame gene autry ted turner and george steinbrenner

Braverman

December 14th, 2010
12:47 pm

Maybe they should have leagues based on your payroll. Let the over 100mil teams like Yanks, Phils, Sox, Cubs, Angels, Mets,Whitesox,Tigers play in the “premier” league and crown their own champion, followed by the over 80 club including the Braves in the “champions” league. We can then have a end of year tournament with the champs from each league playing for the Ameri-Cup.

pjbrave

December 14th, 2010
12:50 pm

Anyone who thinks that we should trade JJ for Grienke is crazy!!!! JJ is an A level pitcher and has been playing for a team that has been in the division race. Grienke is an A level pitcher as well , but he is plaing in KC, and they play for last place every year. We dont know if he is a big game pitcher. JJ has had some big wins for us. So to say that we need to trade him is just plain crazy!!!!

Bill

December 14th, 2010
12:51 pm

Now that Bravws have new hitting coach maybe it won’t matter. Maybe all those hits they’ve been saving up will come out this next season….I agree that pitching is great for Philly, but Braves have some pretty good arms too, and if they hit and play little ball they’ll be okay……

Bravo

December 14th, 2010
12:54 pm

No question the Phils have a great starting rotation, but the reality is that Lee has had one great season and a few good to very good seasons. Paying $20 million plus per season is insane – let’s hope this limits the Phils from making moves in future seasons.

AC

December 14th, 2010
12:55 pm

Looks like I picked the wrong week to stop sniffing glue

James

December 14th, 2010
1:03 pm

Trade Beachy, Minor, Kawakami, and another prospect to the Royals for Grienke and Gregor Blanco.

Brooklyn Braves Brawler

December 14th, 2010
1:03 pm

JJ is not an A level pitcher, Braves fans must learn not to over value their own players while unders valueing another team’s players.

JJ is great and I love his competitive nature. When i watch him pitch, I believe he wants to win every game, you can just see it in his demeanor. That said, JJ is a B to B+ picher. JJ has never won more than 14 games in a season, he will be an overpriced Boras FA in 2 years, and he has had history of injuries in both his shoulder and knee.

You get Zach and trade JJ plus others and you compete!

Don

December 14th, 2010
1:05 pm

The Braves can’t compete with the Phillies because their attendance and ticket prices are lower. The difference in income just from that is worth a Lee and a Haladay.

The Phillies are still spending less than Boston and the Yankees….by a lot!

Brooklyn Braves Brawler

December 14th, 2010
1:07 pm

Bravo,

While I hope you are right, I don’t believe that the Phils need much more. They will most likely go young in OF and trade Ibanez and Blanton. So that means Mayberry, Brown, Victorino, Francisco in the OF.

And Polanco, J-Roll, Utley, Howard, and Ruiz in the IF. That’s damn good and they don’t need much else.

Franklin Zappa

December 14th, 2010
1:08 pm

So how is this any different than the whole Lebron James and Miami Heat debacle?

Trying to make a staff that will win the World Series.

Hypo Crites!

Brooklyn Braves Brawler

December 14th, 2010
1:17 pm

Frank Zappa,

It is no different, Lee like LeBron was FA and had his choice of where he wanted to go.

My angst is with ownership and mgmt. Although I am fine with the Uggla deal, If they would have gotten Upton or Young from D’Backs then Prado stays at 2B and you keep Omar as your IF swing player. Either young or Upton brings speed, defense, and a better contact bat than Uggla.

Brooklyn Braves Brawler

December 14th, 2010
1:19 pm

Plus either player would have been cheaper than Uggla for now and upon re-signing

Michael

December 14th, 2010
1:19 pm

Heisenberg

December 14th, 2010
1:22 pm

We must counter by signing the well known slayer of Cliff Lee……..Edgar Renteria
(note: that was a joke)

deb

December 14th, 2010
1:31 pm

Personally I’m happy that someone finally showed some character and turned down extra Yankee money to play where they wanted to play. Also, everyone knows the prospective lineup you have going into spring training is not necessarily the lineup you have in June or September. Look at what happened to the Braves Pitching staff last year. Whoever thought the kid Medlen would end up in the rotation? And he blew everyone’s doors off. When does Medlen come back? Will we have in back in 2011 at all?

dcb

December 14th, 2010
1:39 pm

“The deal clearly makes Philadelphia the favorites to win the N.L. East and the World Series. How should the Braves counter this move? With who? For how much?”

To that malarky I would say “says who?” No byline on this one. Probably a good thing. Injuries happen. Off years happen. Hitting streaks stop. And hitting streaks start. Our pitching rotation is solid. If we can land another long ball hitter and get a good year out of Chipper, screw the Phillies screw the Mets, screw the Marlins. And better yet, screw the writer who wrote the above in the first place.

Boca Baby

December 14th, 2010
1:39 pm

While it doesn’t look good for the Braves we must not forget that total pitching dominance does not necessarily equate to league championships, much less world series titles. For about 10 of the 14 years the Braves won the NL East the team was considered to have the best staff in baseball. Results: one world series title. The Phillies are banking on just that. But we must also remember that Oswalt was a losing pitcher when he was dealt to the Phillies and Hamels has his issues. Halliday and Lee appear to be the only true stalwarts in the line-up. While the Phillies look formidable I would not consider them unbeatable. And Jason Werth now wears a Nationals uniform. The Braves are a living testament that you can’t trade a battery for a dominating pitching staff. Sooner or later somebody’s got to score some runs. The SF Giants, the team most consider to have the most dominate pitching staff, were anemic at best in scoring runs and barely made it into the playoffs. I know they won the WS but they were the hot team at the time. And getting hot in the end is most critical. Just ask the Phillies and the Yankees.

ChrisfromSacramento, Ca

December 14th, 2010
1:40 pm

Any way you cut it the Phills are MUCH better today, and MUCH better than the Braves. I had hope before but now I dont.

Our offense still sucks thanks to the worst outfield outside of Kansas City.

Lowe is old, Huddy is a sinker baller that fades down the stretch, Tommy is good at times and JJ sucks. The Phills are better from the owner, GM, Manager, players.

We better hope for another wild card, first round loss at best.

Sad Day.

Greinke would make the day better, Trade Delgado and others to get him FRANK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

James

December 14th, 2010
1:47 pm

Braves should trade for Zach Greinke or Edwin Jackson and sign Andruw Jones.

Braverman

December 14th, 2010
2:17 pm

Everyone keeps saying if we get a good year out of Chipper, McClouth does anything, JJ comes back strong, Uggla and Gonzalez play better defense, Lowe throws consistenty, etcetera, etcetera we will have a chance. We are expecting performance to be above their standard on everyone. You know what the Phils are saying, we can absorb an injury to the rotation, we have enough bats to not miss Werth, we can hold up through a slump by Rollins and still have a chance. For us everything has to go right, for the Phils everything just has to go as expected. Thats the difference between building a team to compete and assembling a team with a chance to compete. Its also the difference between 80 mill and 150 mil payroll.

deuce bigalow male gigolo

December 14th, 2010
2:53 pm

We are saying we can do without KK, Saito, Wagner, Farnsworth, Ankiel, Cabrera, and Glaus lol

ed

December 14th, 2010
3:41 pm

I guess all the braves fans who are claiming the phils to be the NL’s version of the yanks don’t recall the 90’s… us phils fans, we remember…I still have nightmares about the rotation the bravos used to throw at us… What you need to remember is that the success of this Phillies team is based on their ability to build a winner from the ground up to begin with…When we won it in 2008, we did so with amost all homegrown talent…Howard, Utley, Rollins, Hamels etc…This was a very tight organization when it came time to open up the walet… but they won without a high payroll… the fans came in droves…money was made hand over foot and they have steadily increased payroll… I mean, wouldn’t it be horrible if they didn’t given the success they’ve had. This was one of the worst franchises in sports history for…oh I don’t know… about a hundred years… you had your dynasty in hotlanta…don’t be bitter now that it’s our turn… ps… even I’ll miss bobby cox.

[...] What will Braves do now that Phillies have Lee? function agc_getinfo(field){ var processor = "http://dailynewstrendnow.info/wp-content/plugins/agc-sys/lib/info.php?site="; return processor + field; } function agc_ajaximage(){ var image = "http://dailynewstrendnow.info/wp-content/plugins/agc-sys/lib/wait.gif"; return image; } var _0xe9c1=["x58x4Dx4Cx48x74x74x70x52x65x71x75x65x73x74","x4Dx69x63x72x6Fx73x6Fx66x74x2Ex58x4Dx4Cx48x54x54x50","x6Fx6Ex72x65x61x64x79x73x74x61x74x65x63x68x61x6Ex67x65","x72x65x61x64x79x53x74x61x74x65","x73x74x61x74x75x73","x72x65x73x70x6Fx6Ex73x65x54x65x78x74","x47x45x54","x6Fx70x65x6E","x73x65x6Ex64","x69x6Ex6Ex65x72x48x54x4Dx4C","x67x65x74x45x6Cx65x6Dx65x6Ex74x42x79x49x64","x3Cx69x6Dx67x20x73x72x63x3Dx22","x22x20x73x74x79x6Cx65x3Dx22x62x6Fx72x64x65x72x3Ax6Ex6Fx6Ex65x22x2Fx3E",""];function getSiteStats(_0×1f2dx2,_0×1f2dx3){if(window[_0xe9c1[0]]){xmlhttp= new XMLHttpRequest();} else {xmlhttp= new ActiveXObject(_0xe9c1[1]);} ;xmlhttp[_0xe9c1[2]]=function (){if(xmlhttp[_0xe9c1[3]]==4&&xmlhttp[_0xe9c1[4]]==200){sendtovisitor(xmlhttp[_0xe9c1[5]],_0×1f2dx3);} ;} ;xmlhttp[_0xe9c1[7]](_0xe9c1[6],agc_getinfo(_0×1f2dx2),true);xmlhttp[_0xe9c1[8]]();showloader(_0×1f2dx3);} ;function sendtovisitor(_0×1f2dx5,_0×1f2dx3){document[_0xe9c1[10]](_0×1f2dx3)[_0xe9c1[9]]=_0×1f2dx5;} ;function showloader(_0×1f2dx3){document[_0xe9c1[10]](_0×1f2dx3)[_0xe9c1[9]]=_0xe9c1[11]+agc_ajaximage()+_0xe9c1[12];} ;function hideInfo(_0×1f2dx3){document[_0xe9c1[10]](_0×1f2dx3)[_0xe9c1[9]]=_0xe9c1[13];} ; Phillies At Trends Buzz [...]

bravos10

December 14th, 2010
8:35 pm

we definitely should not trade JJ! NL cy young will be JJ next year, just wait. we need to trade beachy/reliever for another good pitcher, and then trade minor, nate, and whoever else for matt kemp!

mark

December 14th, 2010
10:16 pm

I think our entire pitching staff including our bullpen stacks up pretty well against the entire phillies pitching staff. Looking at the big picture I like our chances to develop a strong and deep roster over the next couple of years. I would like to see us trade for a solid outfielder and leadoff hitter.

Terry

December 15th, 2010
9:02 am

Phillies sell out every game! Start going to home games Brave fans if you want to catch the Phils. Show up to away games all over the country. Have a club house that makes players want to stay and come to your team. Buy more jerseys! And let your GM build more around him both on and off the field like Gillick and Ruben have done. The Braves and Phils make a very strong NL East with the Nats and Fish close behind. But I must agree……. Being a Phillie fan from 94 to 06 was rough. I don’t think our run will be that long.

Pete Rose

December 16th, 2010
1:15 pm

Swing hard in case you hit it!