In-state tuition for illegal immigrants?

Moderated by Rick Badie

Illegal immigrants are required to pay out-of-state tuition to attend Georgia’s colleges and universities, even if they have graduated from a state high school. Moreover, such students are denied admission to certain schools if those schools have turned down academically-qualified U.S. citizens the past two years. Today, an immigration advocate says the policies hurt promising youth, while a supporter upholds them.

Grant admission to selective schools

By Azadeh Shahshahani

Georgia just lost another young talent to another state.

Needa Virani arrived in the U.S. at age seven. A year later she moved to Georgia . She attended Brookwood High, where she was a distinguished member of the Math Honors Society and regional science fair participant.

After graduating in 2010 with a 3.97 GPA, Needa attended Georgia Tech and earned a bachelor’s of science degree in biomedical engineering. Needa graduated with high honors, maintained a 3.56 GPA and was a research assistant in an engineering lab. She made plans to pursue a doctoral degree at Georgia Tech under the supervision of a professor who offered her a position in her chosen program.

Little did she know she would be prevented from pursuing her dreams. Earlier this year, the Georgia Tech admissions office informed her that, because of Board of Regents Policy 4.1.6 – which bans undocumented students from attending selective schools – she couldn’t enroll, despite the fact Needa had been granted “deferred action” by the federal government.

The U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services has confirmed that individuals who are granted deferred action, including grantees of the federal Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA), are authorized to be present in the United States. Despite this, the Board of Regents refuses to allow DACA grantees admission to selective schools and requires them to pay out-of-state tuition to attend other colleges and universities.

Needa will now have to leave the state she considers home. The Board of Regents policy drove her to search for educational opportunities elsewhere. She just accepted an offer at the University of Oklahoma.

Since the implementation of the Board of Regents’ ban, several gifted students have left for other states. This policy has harmed Georgia by depriving its higher learning institutions of the vibrancy and contributions of some of its most promising youth.

Georgia stands alone in not allowing young immigrants granted deferred action under DACA admission to selective universities. An increasing number of states are now allowing DACA grantees in-state tuition.

Last week at a rally in front of the State Capitol, Raymond Partolan, president of the Student Government Association at Mercer University who came to the U.S. when he was one, described his state of despair in high school:

“I was at the bottom of a very deep and dark well…I, the salutatorian of our high school, could quite possibly not be able to go to college…I felt I had so much potential but the prospect of college was bleak. That fall I tried to kill myself.”

Raymond survived. Now he is one of the leaders in the student movement for equal access to higher education.

Raymond, Needa and students like them are children of Georgia. They have so much to contribute to our communities. Rather than erect barriers, the state should support these exemplary young people and open the way for them to fulfill their potential.

Azadeh Shahshahani is the director of the National Security/Immigrants’ Rights Project at the ACLU of Georgia.

Deferred action not lawful status

By John Litland

In 2010, the Democrat-controlled U.S. Senate rejected the 2001 DREAM Act amnesty legislation again. Last year, in cooperation with the illegal alien lobby, President Barack Obama bypassed Congress and declared a “temporary” delay in deportation for a group of illegal aliens who can claim to have been illegally brought to the U.S. as children. He calls his administrative amnesty “Delayed Action for Childhood Arrivals” or “DACA.”

The illegal alien lobby is now howling in Atlanta streets that illegals who have had their deportations delayed are somehow legal residents. And that in Georgia’s universities, they are eligible for the rights and privileges of citizens and legal immigrants who obeyed the law.

The truth is that, according to the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services Website,deferred action does not provide an individual with lawful status. The White House blog also makes it clear that the DACA process “does not provide lawful status or a pathway to permanent residence or citizenship.”

My (legal) immigrant wife and I look forward to immigration lawyer Charles Kuck trying to redefine the English language to convince a court that an illegal alien under DACA is somehow no longer an illegal alien. Kuck is also vice-chairman of the Georgia Association of Latino Elected Officials,  a lobbying group that marches in the streets of Georgia demanding an end to enforcement of American immigration laws that don’t benefit illegals.

At least three federal laws (8USC1611, 8USC1621 and 8USC 1623) clearly address illegal aliens and taxpayer-funded post secondary education, including in-state tuition. So does existing state law.

In 2006, Georgia passed the Georgia Security and Immigration Compliance Act.

That law excludes illegals from Georgia’s public universities and technical schools and rightfully denies them in-state tuition. In 2010, the Board of Regents adopted a ban on illegal aliens attending certain Georgia schools – like the University of Georgia – that have turned away academically-qualified students.

Recently, Hugo Da Silva claimed the Regents’ policy “ is motivated by racism.” He does not, however, enlighten us as to what race “illegal” actually is in Obama’s America.

A 2010 Mason-Dixon poll Polling & Research for the Georgia Newspaper Partnership showed that two-thirds of Georgians favor barring illegal aliens from attending UGA and other public colleges. Even if they pay out-of-state tuition.

Whatever sympathy we may have for the youngsters who are victims of their parents’ crimes, it’s doubtful most voting Georgians would sit silently if the Regents were to revert to allowing illegal aliens to attend UGA while that school turns away qualified American student applicants.

The good news at our house is that the current demand for even more special privileges for illegal aliens seems to demonstrate a profound doubt that another amnesty will pass in Washington, D.C.

John Litland of Marietta is a member of the advisory board of the Georgia-based Dustin Inman Society .


47 comments Add your comment


August 8th, 2013
9:48 am

I wonder why these highly intelligent young “illegals” have not applied for legal citizenship. Most of them have known for years that they were not legal citizens of America. They knew. Their ;parents knew.

If we let everybody in this country decide which laws they will obey and which they won’t, we will no longer be a country but an outlaw post. That is “stretching” it a bit but true nevertheless.

We could just burn our constitution and start over. I prefer to keep the one we have now and follow the laws of our country.


August 8th, 2013
9:38 am


Van Jones

August 8th, 2013
9:28 am

@Azadeh Shahshahani, your sentence “Little did she know she would be prevented from pursuing her dreams” should be changed to more accuately reflect the truth… Little did she know the citizens of Georgia would no longer subsidize her education.
Let’s see, she arrived at age 7 so she has already sucked up about 15 years of GA taxpayer assistance.


August 8th, 2013
9:14 am

Oklahoma? That’s a State that welcomes people with last names like Veerani with open arms. Was Ole Miss’ Bio Med program full or something?


August 8th, 2013
8:39 am


Please pull your head out of the sand. Do you not watch and read the news?
1) Go to any emergency room and count the number of illegals there getting treatment and then not paying the bill. Who gets stuck paying for it later? That’s right, tax paying citizens.

2) Go to the grocery store and watch illegals paying with goverment assistance. Who pays for that? That’s right, tax paying citizens.

3) Turn on your T.V. and watch the Democrats and Republicans fighting over an amnesty bill to allow the illegals here to stay legally. Once that happens, they won’t need to live in the shadow anymore and will proudly go get goverment assistance. And that’s right, we pay for it.

Shall I go on?


August 8th, 2013
8:33 am

@agent – oh really? what do you already bend over and give them?


August 8th, 2013
8:29 am

Illegal immigrants and the “undocumented” belong in near-BANKRUPT California, not Georgia.

Let Needa “Government Handout” Veerani to study at Cal Tech and be their parasitic problem.


August 8th, 2013
8:28 am

The entitlement mentality is clearly out of control. OK, so some young people are in a bind because their parents deliberately chose to break several laws and somehow that’s my fault? No, I don’t think so. Any damage to these young people’s lives is a direct result of their parent’s choices, and that’s where the fault lies. Blaming uninvolved people, demanding so-called “justice” by continuing to ignore the laws, and showing contempt for the country and disrespect to the tax-paying citizens just shows that these aren’t the kind of people I want coming into the country in the first place.


August 8th, 2013
8:06 am

Illegal immigrant students should not get in state tuition. In Georgia, in state tuition is for Legal Permanent Residents (Green card holders) and US citizens. This is the way it should be. DACA recipients only have legal presence for two years at a time. This program can be terminated at any time and the recipients will then revert back to becoming illegal immigrants. I think Charles Kuck is going to lose this one.


August 8th, 2013
7:53 am

Might as well, we already bend over and give them everything else they want.