Maglev test line for Atlanta?

Moderated by Tom Sabulis

One of our guest opinion columnists has an out-of-the-box idea for a transportation experiment in the city – a maglev line running from MARTA’s Arts Center station to the Atlantic Station area. What do you think?

Commenting is open below.

By Dave Henson

After the failure of the metro Atlanta transportation referendum last year, Gov. Nathan Deal said it “slams the door on further expansion of our rail network any time soon.” Despite this understandable sentiment, I think commuter rail can get back on track.

It’s important to remember that the governor supported the referendum to the end, nobly going down with the rickety ship he inherited. The business community was grateful for his support, but other pro-transit groups undercut him by loudly opposing the plan. I believe a business-backed rail initiative could still pique Deal’s interest.

In addition to benefiting the business community, new rail would have to serve a large number of potential riders and come with a low price tag. All of the above can be had with a demonstration line from the MARTA Arts Center Station to the state-owned property at 17th Street and Northside Drive, which is being eyed for future Amtrak and Greyhound stations.

The rail line — state-operated, by the Georgia Regional Transportation Authority — could form the spine of a “transportation innovation zone” in the progressive, up-and-coming West Midtown/“Westoma” (west of Midtown Atlanta) area. Many cutting-edge startup companies are based here, and AT&T is scouting the vicinity for one of its acclaimed Foundry innovation centers. Ridership would not be a problem.

As for low cost, the answer might lie with American Maglev Technologies, a Marietta company that builds magnetic levitation (maglev) transit propulsion systems. Maglev vehicles travel on a magnetic field, about a centimeter above elevated guideway rails, and are propelled by small onboard, electronic, emission-free engines. Unlike those found in conventional maglev systems, American Maglev’s guideways have no moving parts and require only a 5-foot-wide footprint.

Based on American Maglev’s per-mile projections, building the 1.2-mile demonstration line would cost $30 million to $35 million, a relatively low amount compared to other rail options. Currently, the company is bidding for commuter projects in Colorado and Florida. Seeing futuristic maglev trains streaking across the Downtown Connector could make a grand impression here as well.

Although maglev transit systems aren’t eligible for federal construction funding, they are covered under the recently passed “America Fast Forward Financing Innovation Act,” which offers a federally backed, low-interest loan program and a unique bond program that provides annual tax credits to bond investors in lieu of transportation agency interest payments.

Atlanta Mayor Kasim Reed seems to have a fairly amicable relationship with President Barack Obama and might just have a shooter’s chance at landing one of those America Fast Forward loans or bonds for the maglev project.

It would be a win for the business community, and a win for Gov. Deal.

Dave Henson is a digital marketing executive and founder of Georgia Policy Solutions.

37 comments Add your comment

MANGLER

March 5th, 2013
3:12 pm

As much as people who already balk at such things would balk even more about such things with a certain level of “style” or creativity to them, in order to get the private sector involved in these projects, ideas like this need to be seen and heard as well. “Hey Bill, you know if we hold the convention in Atlanta they have that neat floating train downtown – and we can all ride their train from the airport to the hotel unlike Orlando where we’d need to charter buses for the whole company”.
Besides, Shanghai has a maglev train that goes 300 mph for 50 miles. Think we can build one that travels 1 mile? At least with this idea the proposed line would connect to a location people actually go, Atlantic Station and Midtown, as compared to the trolley which goes from a fountain to a park and misses everything in between.

Shamehia

March 5th, 2013
3:09 pm

You knew it would be just a matter of time until the policy wonks started in with new “ideas” to end run the TSPLAT no vote. Here it is.

melshop

March 5th, 2013
3:06 pm

Always liked the Maglev idea, but what Atlanta really needs is a commuter rail system (either Marta or tied to the Marta line in some way to access all of Atlanta) going up the west side of town, Marietta, Acworth, Cartersville..maybe a spur off to Douglasville and Hiram, maybe a stop at Six Flags. There are tons of people who live up this way and work in Atlanta..I think it would be a great money generator.

SAWB

March 5th, 2013
3:05 pm

Regardless of what technology we choose right of way must be acquired for the project, so that is a fixed cost. However, instead of developing Maglev, light rail, heavy rail, etc. we just simply pave it and run electric shuttle buses. This would seem an effective way to move people on the much needed spur routes like the one described here or the Lindbergh to Emory project.

Urban Lick

March 5th, 2013
3:01 pm

Big city transit cost money and this is less than light or heavy rail. Go live on a farm in the country with your dirt roads and lack of employment.

tammy

March 5th, 2013
2:44 pm

What about building a simple people mover type system like the airport has? Tried and true and not that much $$$.

Pete

March 5th, 2013
2:42 pm

“building the 1.2-mile demonstration line would cost $30 million to $35 million”…now factor in cost overruns, environment impact statements, lawsuits etc and closer to 90 – to 105 million.

Thanks but no thanks

Common Sense

March 5th, 2013
2:26 pm

That’s $5,524 per foot, btw.

Common Sense

March 5th, 2013
2:23 pm

“Based on American Maglev’s per-mile projections, building the 1.2-mile demonstration line would cost $30 million to $35 million, a relatively low amount compared to other rail options.”

Hard to believe we have not given it the go ahead! What a bargain!

Jenn

March 5th, 2013
2:04 pm

NOW WE’RE TALKING!!!