MARTA change absolutely necessary

Moderated by Tom Sabulis

Today, MARTA’s new leader Keith Parker writes about his first months on the job, what he’s been doing, and where the transit agency is heading. That includes the new five-year “road map” outlining privatization opportunities that could reduce its annual deficits. He has also indicated in public presentations that he’s intent on boosting morale of employees and customer service. The latter problem is something I address in a column below, the message being, it’s worth sweating the small stuff, too.

Commenting is open below my column on MARTA’s customer service.

All options are on the table

By Keith T. Parker

In almost two months on the job as MARTA’s general manager and CEO, I have been highlighting the serious challenges and exciting opportunities our transit agency is facing over the next several years.

Even more valuable to me, however, is the time I’m spending listening to our customers, employees, elected officials, business leaders, the media and the metro Atlanta community about transforming MARTA for the future.

And, make no mistake: MARTA must be transformed.

It’s no secret that the agency is confronting an annual “structural deficit” of roughly $25 million that requires us to fundamentally change the way we do business.

Since the early 1990s, MARTA’s day-to-day operations have been funded primarily by customer fares and sales tax revenues collected in DeKalb and Fulton counties and the city of Atlanta, sources that are often volatile and unpredictable. With the onset of the recession of 2008, MARTA’s revenues have been dramatically reduced, requiring the agency to cut expenses by almost $100 million, eliminate 700 positions, institute fare increases and service cuts, etc. Unfortunately, these measures are still not enough.

MARTA’s current business model – requiring spending from its depleting reserve account to balance annual budgets – is unsustainable. It must be replaced with one that recognizes our new reality.

For that reason, two years ago, the MARTA Board of Directors charged the firm KPMG with conducting a comprehensive review of the system’s operations and finances. KPMG’s initial review broadly outlined strategic transformation opportunities where MARTA could reduce costs, increase efficiencies and generate new revenues. The latest phase of KPMG’s work, a draft “road map” MARTA received last month, details an aggressive plan for the agency to achieve those objectives within the next five years.

KPMG’s road map summarizes opportunities into 12 key areas — including potentially outsourcing functions such as human resources, payroll, accounts payable, cleaning services, customer call centers, information technology and our paratransit service.

KPMG also recommends automating our procurement processes, identifying new streams of paid advertising and adopting policies to address workers compensation claims and unacceptable levels of employee absenteeism.

The MARTA board and staff are evaluating every recommendation in the KPMG report. We will determine which recommendations promise to deliver the most significant benefits at the lowest cost, and then begin implementing them. We will make every effort to ensure insurehigh-quality service for our customers, fair treatment for our employees and respect for taxpayers who fund our system.

I know that change can be very difficult to accept. But for MARTA, change is absolutely necessary, and every viable option to make us more efficient and effective is on the table.

As we move forward, I will continue meeting with any individual or group who supports MARTA’s mission of providing high-quality transit service that promotes economic development and enhances the quality of life for all of us.

I’m also eager to hear from those who harbor unfavorable perceptions about MARTA. Those conversations will give us an opportunity to talk about how public transportation — just like good schools, roads, libraries or fire departments — add value to our community, even if you never need to use them.

I also see many opportunities. We will be completing installation of cameras on buses in the next few months and begin installation on our trains. We will be investing in low-cost, high-impact technological advancements that will improve our efficiency while enhancing the overall customer experience. We are strategically investigating how transit-oriented developments and public-private partnerships can bring new revenues while creating jobs and reinvigorating communities.

We have a lot of work ahead of us, and the KPMG road map has given MARTA a good running start. At every step of the way, my commitment is to continue listening to all stakeholders — and learning from them — so we can do whatever is necessary to make our transit system the very best it can be.

To read the KPMG road map: www.itsmarta.com/reports.aspx.

Keith T. Parker is MARTA’s CEO and General Manager.

Customer service could use some work

By Tom Sabulis

New MARTA CEO and General Manager Keith Parker says he wants to build morale within the ranks and improve customer service on the rails and roads. That’s a worthy goal for the transit agency.

For starters, reducing wait times is a huge key to retaining choice riders — folks like me, who have the option of commuting by car but would prefer to make an urban transit system work within the framework of their lives. Business people simply don’t want to hang around a ghost-town station waiting 15 minutes in the middle of the day for a train, and nearly 30 minutes for a bus. The dead time spent on isolated platforms or benches is when hassles are most likely to occur.

Panhandlers who ask commuters for money are a corresponding concern, particularly of women I’ve interviewed at various stations regarding public safety. Personally, I don’t find the in-car, on-bus cadging all that prevalent, and when it does show up, it’s usually more sad and unfortunate than threatening. To its credit, MARTA has started a marketing campaign targeted to various nuisances (begging, loud cellphone talkers).

But Mr. Parker seems to understand that MARTA may have as much impact coaching up its own employees. That can go a long way.

In the last two-plus years that I’ve been riding a MARTA bus, I find it to be efficient, generally on schedule and a lot more personal than the train experience, at least on the No. 12 route, which travels from Cumberland Mall to Midtown station. Regulars become familiar with fellow route riders. The bus operators, while busy, are usually courteous and accommodating.

But those same drivers are obviously able to freelance more than their train counterparts, for good and bad. One recent example: A few weeks ago, around 8:45 a.m., I was at my stop early and noticed the bus parked 50 yards down the road, with flashers engaged. No big deal. The operator was early, and he was killing a minute or two before arriving at my stop — a major intersection — on time. That’s routine.

What wasn’t routine was when he stopped a half-mile farther south on Howell Mill Road, where he parked and turned the bus off on a busy commercial stretch, partially blocking a lane, and left the vehicle without saying a word. Minutes went by. Soon enough, I was impatient to get going. About five minutes lapsed before the driver reappeared from a gas station-convenience store with a large drink and what looked like a bag of food. Without a word — again, no communication — he started the bus and moved on. I was pretty annoyed. After all, when you get to the train station late and miss your connection, you end up having to deal with long wait times.

According to a 2010 internal MARTA memo, the agency had received complaints about buses stopping and blocking traffic and operators ducking into stores to buy “lottery tickets” and other things. A policy stressed in that memo states that drivers are prohibited from making unauthorized stops any time between 6 and 9 a.m. and 2:30 and 6:30 p.m. “In all cases the bus must not prohibit the flow of traffic.” I’m not sure why “unauthorized stops” are not prohibited at all times, rather than just rush hour. Is this a business — part of “a $6 billion public asset,” as former CEO Beverly Scott used to say — or a jitney service?

When I relayed this story to MARTA, chief spokesman Lyle V. Harris asked me for follow-up information. But questioning or chastising this particular operator isn’t the point; it’s more what it says about MARTA’s culture (and the union’s) and what feels like casual disregard for paying passengers. Harris said MARTA is reviewing its policy and investigating this incident.

Maybe there’s more to the story: I could understand a bathroom break, an emergency pit stop. But if that’s the case, how about telling your customers what’s going on? Or even, you know, “I’m going to run inside for a Coke and a hot dog. Can I get anybody anything?”

22 comments Add your comment

The Last Democrat in Georgia

February 6th, 2013
1:03 am

Nicko

February 5th, 2013
12:46 pm

Really good suggestions.

IVO

February 5th, 2013
4:20 pm

Also I never see white people on MARTA>

IVO

February 5th, 2013
4:18 pm

We have better train service in Zagreb. Where are the police when the morning rush ends? I never see them. Also noone under 18 without a parent or guardian should be allowed in the system. To many bums and kids with either ADHD or lead posioning.

marta rider

February 5th, 2013
3:39 pm

Perception is reality……If I see a beggar, I think they are there all of the time. (And the truth is, they are there way too much) I emailed about a broken hand rail almost a year ago and ask if some duct tape could be placed on the rail to keep people safe from being poked in the stomach…..well, guess what…the duct tape is still there, in two places now! Escalators squeaking loudly, loud music, no police presence (although they do ride in cars from station to station)….really, I love riding the train to work, but I am a man and can manage myself…..MARTA has a long way to go…..good luck!

MANGLER

February 5th, 2013
1:11 pm

I’m not sure how routes are planned. Are they based on traffic volumes on the roads they travel, or based on employment centers along those routes, or based on historical passenger volumes on those routes, or a little of all of that?
Has MARTA asked people where they need to go for work? For school? For leisure? Where they’d park and ride if certain routes were offered or the timing was changed? Having everything point towards downtown or the airport may not accurately reflect the public will, but rather the riders are forced to make due with what’s on the plate. I’m wondering if they had a way to overlay the public’s actual commute and route needs or wants with the one’s that are offered. The trains follow their tracks, but the buses and vans can meander. What makes sense on paper based on density may not exactly overlap where people who do ride or who would ride actually live, work, and play. Moving a low volume route 1 to 2 city blocks or adding one more stop 1 mile past where the route currently turns around can have a dramatic effect. I think people will gladly click on a map what they would like to see – and that info can be aggregated into the route models.

tsabulis

February 5th, 2013
1:00 pm

Excellent points, Nicko.

Nicko

February 5th, 2013
12:46 pm

1) Install train arrival time monitors, like you have on the platforms, at the ENTRANCE of every MARTA station.
2) Retool the current red LED scrolling marquee signs that are a complete waste of money and space. What good are 10 signs that continuously read WELCOME TO MARTA? Why not key in messages such as delays, date, time, emergency delays, weather, traffic snarls etc etc. This is so simple.
3) Get more revenue through better ads and better mediums to deliver those ads. What good is the monitor in the train that doesn’t work?
4) Allow private entities to lease concession stands at the platforms selling candy, gum, newspapers, magazines, etc.
5) Institute a variable pricing schedule based on distance traveled. It shouldn’t cost the same to go from Airport to North Springs as it does to go from Midtown to Buckhead.
6) Privatizing janitorial, IT, A/P, payroll etc. is a really great start. Act like a private entity. Most private entities do not do these things in-house. There are plenty of private entities that make their living providing these services to institutions so those institutions can instead focus more time, energy and money on their core competencies.
7) Clean the stations, they are gross. Arts Center is an abomination.

Van Jones

February 5th, 2013
11:08 am

When a bus driver can make $92,000/year and a MARTA police officer can make $132,500/year is it any wonder they are over-budget. Get real MARTA!!!!

blackbird13

February 5th, 2013
10:28 am

A couple of minor but easy to implement solutions:

Stop using the loudspeakers for alerts in the train stations. What’s being said over them is completely unintelligible. Instead, key the alerts in and send them to the status screens and a MARTA twitter account. Can’t be all that difficult to do, and there would be no need to keep the loudspeakers repaired.

Allow licensed vendors inside stations. This seems a no-brainer to me for adding revenue, especially is stations with no nearby merchants outside. I’m thinking Doraville, Lindberg, possibly North Springs…

About the panhandling: Personally they don’t bother me either as I ignore them (much worse are the ranting preacher types polluting the trains with nonsense), but I know that some people are bothered by them. Some of those people have a choice about whether to use MARTA, and if they choose not to because of beggars it hurts the system financially and politically. Harsh as it sounds, begging IS against the law on MARTA. Enforce the law.

Praveen

February 5th, 2013
7:14 am

My suggesstions/complaints
1) I agree with the above comment about using minivans on some routes at certain times to make it more cost efficient when passenger traffic dictates so. Maybe you can have a messaging system at bus stops where certain low frequency routes can have suggested times and the vans can even operate as a shuttle service picking up passengers only at necessary stops. This can serve the purpose of consolidating different bus routes in low frequency time periods but providing service to everyone on all the routes based on who clicks a button at the bus stand or messages the station. These are just off the cuff suggestions. With some careful thought, one can come up with a creative solution.

2) How about a convenience store on the platform at most MARTA stations? Could generate revenue and enhance security by having an extra person there.
3) No excuse for MARTA trains not to be on time even at the origin and destination stations. I take MARTA to the airport 10 times a year and it is not the most punctual thing.
4) Also airport MARTA employees are useless and rude. Whenever I ask them when the next train is, they shrug their shoulders. At least MARTA for the past couple of years, finally put up those displays where it countsdown the minutes for the next train. The only problem is the times alternate with other messages on those display signs and if you are in a hurry, it would be nice to pace yourself knowing if you are about to miss a train. In fact, I think all MARTA stations should have countdown timers at the entrance.
5) If you are in North Springs, the frequency has been cut down in recent years. Not really that convenient.
6) If you want ad revenue, how about stores which are near the MARTA stops advertise on the monitors in the trains? Not only is it advertising, it will give riders an idea of where to eat before they get down the train. Don’t go crazy and demand super high advertising rates from the merchants.
7) 50 cents for a MARTA breeze card is unnecessary and seems like a ploy to get some easy money from tourists.
8) Why the hell do we have to scan the breeze card at the station we arrive at? It’s not like we have zone based variable pricing.
9) Teach MARTA employees to speak clearly. Seriously, the slurring of words is disrespectful to customers. I took the subway in Japan and the english was better.
10) Who is the idiot who designed the front two seats in each side of the cabin? The sideways oriented front seat severly minimizes leg room for the next seat.