Southerners much of the 47 percent

Moderated by Rick Badie

How valid is the statement that 47 percent of Americans pay no income tax? Very true, writes one of today’s guest writers, who says the number of non-payers sits at an all-time high with Southern states on top. Georgia has the second-highest percentage of non-payers at 42.5 percent, next to Mississippi’s 44.5 percent. And a local fiscal analyst says numbers are often cherry-picked and misused to bolster the argument that too many people depend on government. He suggests that everybody has “skin in the game” when it comes to taxes.

Commenting is open below following Alan Essig’s column.

By Scott Hodge

It may have been “inelegant,” but Mitt Romney’s comments about the 47 percent of Americans who pay no income taxes has ignited an overdue conversation about who should pay income taxes and how much our lawmakers should use the IRS to deliver social benefits.

Georgia, like many Southern states, finds itself squarely in the middle of this debate. It has the second-highest percentage of non-payers in the country, next to Mississippi. Before we get into what this means, let’s lay down a few facts.

The “47 percent” is actually comprised of two groups, people who file a tax return and those whose incomes are below the threshold required to file (which is $9,700 for a single individual). In 2010, about 143 million filed a tax return. Of this group, 58 million, or about 41 percent, had no income tax liability after taking advantage of tax code credits and deductions.

We now have more non-payers than at any time since 1940 when the income tax was expanded to include all workers. Before World War II, the income tax only applied to upper-income families.

In the past 20 years, lawmakers have turned the tax code into a vehicle for delivering social programs. There are tax credits for having children, putting them in day care, buying your first home, replacing the home’s windows, buying a hybrid car and going to college, for example.

All of these tax credits not only help reduce the amount of taxes people owe, but in many cases they enable people to get a check back from the IRS even if they don’t owe income taxes (these are called “refundable” tax credits). Today these credits total $224 billion, half of which are refundable.

Whether or not someone is a non-payer is a function of two things, theirincome and how theirlifestyles match the tax code. The majority of non-payers earn less than $50,000 and are eligible for programs like the Earned Income Tax Credit and the Child Tax Credit.

Lots of taxpayers fit this description in Georgia and in many states in the South, Southwest, and West. Mississippi has the highest percentage of non-payers at 44.5 percent, largely due to its low average income. Georgia is No. 2 at 42.5 percent of filers for the same reason. Alaska and North Dakota – which have relatively high median incomes and low unemployment – have the lowest percentage of non-payers at 22 percent and 26.3 percent, respectively.

Does this mean that Georgia has a lot of deadbeats? No, but it has lots of people who are eligible for these new tax programs and who are becoming disconnected from the basic cost of government.

A new Tax Foundation study has found that the growth of non-payers over the past 20 years is associated with as much as $213 billion in higher transfer spending this year. The study also found a linkage between the growth of non-payers and the federal debt.

Can we afford to have so many people off the income tax rolls at a time when the government is running trillion-dollar deficits? Is it good for our democracy to have only half the population shouldering the cost of government while everyone enjoys its benefits?

Scott A. Hodge is president of the Tax Foundation, a nonpartisan tax research organization in Washington, DC.

Misused Numbers

By Alan Essig

It’s time to put an end to the rumor that nearly half of Americans don’t have any “skin in the game” when it comes to paying taxes.

This popular claim of late among politicians both in Georgia and on the national stage is part of a broader narrative that government is creating a class of Americans overly dependent on public help, too lazy to work, and unwilling to shoulder responsibility. At the heart of this falsehood is a terrible misuse of cherry-picked numbers. The truth tells a very different story.

First, some quick background: the “nearly half of Americans don’t pay taxes” claim is based on a recent study from the nonpartisan and highly respected Tax Policy Center of the Brookings Institution, which estimates nearly 47 percent of Americans paid no federal income tax in 2011. A separate study by the right-leaning Tax Foundation found that the percentage of Georgians not paying federal income tax is particularly high, second only to Mississippi as of 2009. While these numbers are technically correct, they can also be misleading and easy to manipulate. As one of the authors of the original Brookings report later said, “rarely has a bit of data been so misunderstood or so misused.”

There are several reasons why. First, the number only refers to federal income taxes as opposed to all the other taxes people pay. Everyone pays sales taxes. Anyone with a job pays payroll taxes for Social Security and Medicare. Homeowners pay state and local property taxes regardless of whether they’re rich or poor. Anyone who drives a car gets taxed on gas.

Take all of those federal, state, and local taxes into account, and it’s clear that everyone has skin in the game. Our tax system is not divided between half who pay and half who mooch. Everyone pays something and most pay between 20 and 30 percent of their income, according to the nonpartisan Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy.

Additionally, there are serious misconceptions about who those Americans not paying federal income tax actually are. Rather than being the stereotypical freeloader unwilling to work, more than half of non-payers are working adults who simply aren’t paid enough to owe federal income taxes. Ask them if they’d rather make enough to support their families even if it means paying income tax and the answer would definitely be a resounding yes.”

About one in five not paying federal income tax are retired workers. Most of the rest are college students, unemployed, or disabled (including many veterans with combat injuries).

Furthermore, because someone isn’t paying federal income tax today doesn’t mean they never did or never will. Working families get a break when their paychecks are down so they can get back on their feet and start paying again when their incomes improve. Students have low tax bills while they’re in school so they can get the skills to be gainfully employed taxpayers later. And the elderly paid their fair share for decades so they could live with dignity in retirement.

There are more Americans not paying federal income tax than in the past. That’s because of the massive shock of the Great Recession: when people lose their jobs and incomes go down, income tax liability drops.

That’s as it should be. With bipartisan support, federal tax laws have been changed over the years to make sure people don’t pay income tax until they can afford to. That’s a formula for making people independent, not dependent.

Alan Essig is executive director of the Georgia Budget and Policy Institute.

27 comments Add your comment

Retired Vet

October 2nd, 2012
7:12 pm

Don’t Tread

October 2nd, 2012
4:36 pm

Do you seriously intend to suggest that welfare recipients make up the majority of the 47%? Seriously? You are aware that there is a two year cap on receiving welfare without working? Even people collecting unemployment benefits pay taxes on those benefits, both state and federal.


October 2nd, 2012
7:02 pm

sadly most here in georgia will vote for Romney even though he insulted the crap out of them..sad and ignorant,rednecks…they are so uninformed

Not Blind

October 2nd, 2012
5:53 pm

Markie mark, I have VERY bad news for you. You contribute WAY more than 30% of your income to some government entity or the other. I have had people far more well versed in these things tell me it’s more like 50%. Think of everything that is taxed [ sales tax, gas tax, the taxes on cars-boats-campers-trailers , every "fee" you pay [ stormwater runoff is my favorite {or is my favorite the tax on rental cars to help pay for the Gwinnett Braves stadium??} ], Lexus lane fees, fees to park at the lake that was built with taxpayer funds, etc etc etc.

Now think of this – How much of the price you pay for an object actually goes to paying the seller’s taxes ??

It’s absolutely absurd. The politicians and bureaucrats are running amok.

markie mark

October 2nd, 2012
5:19 pm

Doesn’t the fact that we pay between 20 and 30% of our incomes bother anybody? Thats what all the talk about taxation is about. Its not just income tax….its thousands of small bites that end up holding the average family back. But nobody seems concerned. Folks, we are closing in on paying about 1/3 of our incomes in taxes….and everybody is complacent about that.

I think we are having the wrong discussion/argument/etc.


October 2nd, 2012
4:56 pm

It was just on Yahoo, the fella that picks up the garbage at Mitt Romneys $12,000,000 California home said Mitt did not care about him. That he, someday, will be in the 47% non contributors. He claims that every day he lifts about 15 tons of garbage and when he has to retire his body will be broke down from all the lifting and he will not be contributing and Mitt would not care. As you may have surmised this was a democratic political ad.
There has to be an act of desperation blaming this all on Mitt. He is contributing plenty, and i am sure he cares about people. Let us ask the President who requires 1 billion and onehalf dollars annually for his maintenance,the Queen of England and the royal family only require $60,000,000. How much does he care. I know this may be a little off of center, but are the fellas picking up the garbage at the White House fairly compensated, and maybe asked in for a mid day break.


October 2nd, 2012
4:45 pm

You can’t cite statistics that show those who pay no (net Federal) income taxes cross all age, educational, service, and socioeconomic levels. That will cause brain malfunctions to the GOPers who like to think of every single “freeloader” as an unemployed minority lesbian high school dropout single mom with 6 kids on food stamps demanding free abortions while burning flags and bibles.

Raisin Toast Fanatic

October 2nd, 2012
4:44 pm

I would post a comment here, but I’ve got to get back to work to support those who don’t want to. :(

Don't Tread

October 2nd, 2012
4:36 pm

If you don’t have a job and are dependent on welfare, you don’t have any skin in the game, because you are getting something for nothing.

When the welfare recipients pick up trash, sort recyclables, maintain parks, or do some other task of value in exchange for their welfare money, THEN they will have “skin in the game”.

[...] small business taxes using individual tax rates. If individual tax rates are raised, so …Southerners much of the 47 percentAtlanta Journal Constitution (blog)Romney floats $ 17000 deduction cap as Obama camp demands [...]


October 2nd, 2012
4:18 pm

The reason Georgians don’t pay taxes is because slavery in this God-forsaken place never ended. Business owners do everything they can not to pay. Jobs in Georgia are of the most worthless in the US.