12:33 pm October 16, 2012, by David O'Brien
October 16th, 201212:45 pm
Get well soon BMAC!
October 16th, 201212:48 pm
Good luck, B-Mac. Hope everything goes well.
If the Braves decide to not pick up MacCann’s option, does that mean he has to pay for the surgery himself?
October 16th, 201212:54 pm
I’d be more concerned with this news if we didn’t have David Ross.
Braves catcher McCann to have shoulder surgery – Atlanta Journal Constitution (blog) | Cosmetic Surgery
[...] Braves catcher McCann to have shoulder surgeryAtlanta Journal Constitution (blog)After playing while hurt for much of a career-worst season, Braves catcher Brian McCann will have shoulder surgery today that will likely require a recovery of four to six months and could affect his availability for the beginning of the season. The …Report: Braves catcher Brian McCann to have shoulder surgeryCBSSports.com (blog)Brian McCann to Undergo Shoulder Surgery, Expected to Miss 4 to 5 MonthsBleacher ReportMcCann undergoes right shoulder surgery TuesdayAtlantaBraves.comKFFL -Talking Chop -NBCSports.comall 10 news articles » [...]
October 16th, 201212:55 pm
Something tells me this won’t end well for all parties involved.
October 16th, 201212:56 pm
Hey DOB, thanks for the update. Does this mean he will come back better than ever, like after TJ surgery for a pitcher?
Either way, best of luck for speedy recovery. Get back soon.
October 16th, 20121:03 pm
GET WELL SOON. HEURRY BACK B-MAC!
October 16th, 20121:07 pm
McCann is a toe injury away from being a children’s song:
“Head, shoulders, knees and toes (knees and toes)
Head, shoulders, knees and toes (knees and toes)
and eyes and ears and mouth and nose,
Head, shoulders, knees and toes, knees and toes!”
Steve, we don’t have David Ross. He is a free agent, unless we re-sign him. There is a very short window that teams have to re-sign their free agents after the World Series, after that they are free to sign with any team. Here is an excerpt from the mlb site:
Immediately after the World Series
Eligible players become free agents
Sixth day after completion of World Series
First day that Major League and Minor League free agents may sign contracts with teams other than their former clubs
October 16th, 20121:10 pm
If the Braves _do_ have to pay for MacCann’s surgery, is there some kind of money back guarantee if he doesn’t perform well in 2013? With a healthy shoulder he should at least hit .320 with 25 homers and 100 RBI’s right?
October 16th, 20121:11 pm
Do not pick up the option. Over weight and a bad defensive catcher.
October 16th, 20121:17 pm
Get well Big Mac,we need ya brother!!!
October 16th, 20121:18 pm
Hey bball fan we’re not sure of your opinion on the matter could you repeat it again for us haha lol!
October 16th, 20121:32 pm
David Ross will be re-signed. Especially now.
October 16th, 20121:36 pm
They knew what was wrong with him a couple of months ago. We all saw the results of it in his performance continually. One wishes he ” didn’t go to work every single day”. “He wanted to see this through to the end” and ” he was willing to do this”. Don’t do us any more favors. If he’d been willing to go under the knife months ago we wouldn’t have suffered his poor production and he’d be ready for next spring. I still contend that the performance of McCann, Uggla and Hanson cost us the division.
October 16th, 20121:37 pm
What FA catchers are on the market this winter? Wren likley has a list bc this does not sound like a good situation.
4-6 mos recovery, then getting your swing back in shape. Could be May before the Braves know what they have in Mac.
Ross and some write in behind the plate for the whole month of April (with no Chipper) could put them in an early hole.
October 16th, 20121:38 pm
Just don’t resign Bourn
October 16th, 20121:39 pm
Pick-up the option…. He is young; hits like crazy when healthy and Rossy can handle it until B-Mac is back full time…
Ask the Angels for a trade. Give them some young arms for Mike Trout. The trade will help both teams.
October 16th, 20121:45 pm
Ask the Angels for a trade. Give them some young arms for Mike Trout. The trade will help both teams. — Hose
Congrats. That made me laugh out loud.
October 16th, 20121:55 pm
OOPS, MAKE THAT HURRY BACK!
October 16th, 20121:58 pm
I doubt the Angels would trade Trout under any scenario. He could be the next Mikey Mantle.
Mac will not be here past 2013 nor is he all that young for a catcher. He needs to move to the AL to get a long term big money deal and he will. Mac has catcher/DH/back 1B written all over him.
The question is will the Braves benefit by that move via a 2013 trade or will they watch him walk out the door with nothing to show for it.
Also let Bourn walk and stay away from Pagan and Willingham. Two guys in or moving into their mid 30s having career years. That is not how you build a winner or properly leverage trade prospects.
Cody Ross does not want to be a Brave nor should the Braves want him. He is a decoy and like Willingham in MN is very happy with his current team.
October 16th, 20121:59 pm
Free Agent Catchers:
* – player whose current contract includes 2013 option.
Rod Barajas, PIT *
Henry Blanco, ARI *
Koyie Hill, TEX
Gerald Laird, DET
Russell Martin, NYY
Brian McCann, ATL *
Jose Molina, TB *
Mike Napoli, TEX
Wil Nieves, ARI
Miguel Olivo, SEA *
Ronny Paulino, BAL
A.J. Pierzynski, CWS
Humberto Quintero, MIL
David Ross, ATL
Carlos Ruiz, PHI *
Brian Schneider, PHI
Kelly Shoppach, NYM
Chris Snyder, HOU *
Yorvit Torrealba, MIL
Matt Treanor, LAD *
October 16th, 20122:03 pm
Considering his non-injured history as a hitter, you pick up the option.
October 16th, 20122:05 pm
Wow hose, REALLY?!? Maybe while frank is at it he can trade the bats and balls we threw away for Kerry lightenberg to Washington for Bryce Harper and Steven strasburgh…
October 16th, 20122:06 pm
Hope all goes well for Brian he played hurt busted his tail all year.. He is pure class when he heals he will be back on his game. Hope braves pick up option and take it from there.
October 16th, 20122:07 pm
BMac has given the Braves a lot over the years and during that time was the best overall at his position, it would be stupid not to go with him in 2013 and see where he stands, hell, look at the money we shelled out on Lowe and KK alone with little or no return at least we know Bryan is capable, use the option.
The Angels would never trade Mike Trout. That…. is the most absurd thing I’ve heard on the blog in a long time.
Hope Mac gets healthy and we can resign Ross as well. Mac would be out until March at the latest. Don’t know how he’ll do, but if he’s FINALLY healthy, then hopefully he can put together another good year. Health is the thing that has plagued him over the last two years.
He needs to drop some weight, and get into shape so that the excess weight doesn’t put more stress on his body. Nothing wrong with being a big guy, especially if you’re a catcher, but he can definitely be more fit. Pulling for you B Mac! Get better soon!
Homer the Brave
October 16th, 20122:11 pm
Keep Ross. Dump McCann. Sign Napoli.
Too Big Mac
October 16th, 20122:26 pm
Maybe a little liposuction while you’re in there.
blaine with the blue scarf
October 16th, 20122:29 pm
bring back that big, fine, handsome muscular hunk Javier Lopez!
October 16th, 20122:30 pm
Well, if we’re going to trade for Trout, we should have the Angels throw in Pujols while they’re at it. Think they’d take Hanson, Martinez, and Jurrjens?
NO MORE FREDI
October 16th, 20122:38 pm
I wish mac well but if Braves want to show they are serious about winning they let him walk or trade the guy. he is on the downside of his career and is not on a Chipper level for reason to keep him. Hope Frank makes the right move for this TEAM and not another individual.
If Mac is on the 6mo end of the recovery you are looking at mid April for his return. I don’t know if that means he is ready to start or ready to go to extended ST. If it is the latter he won’t be back until late April.
October 16th, 20122:40 pm
This is probably a dumb question: Anybody on the farm who might be able to handle the call up?
October 16th, 20122:42 pm
Hey Hose! Why not ask Seattle about King Felix as well.
October 16th, 20123:00 pm
While the Angels do have a crowded house in the OF, trading Trout is laughable. 2 guys without a position as the result of signing Pujols are Trumbo & Morales. It would take more than Braves could or should offer for Trumbo but I suspect Morales could be trade bait for pitching. Not sure if he can play LF though.
October 16th, 20123:05 pm
I’ve had shoulder issues that got so bad I couldn’t use my right arm and thus ended up in the OR. Shoulder pain is no fun folks and I can’t imagine playing baseball with a bum shoulder. Mac doesn’t need to convince me that he’s tough. No wonder he had an off season.
Don’t trade him now FW as next year he will likely return back to being his normal self – or better.
My best to Brian. Get well soon!!
October 16th, 20123:09 pm
DUMP HIM ! MOVE ON ! DAMAGED GOODS !
I appreciate Brian’s commitment to the team and think the Braves should absolutely pick up the option year. He’s earned the right to play out this contract with the Braves.
That said, I wonder why the Braves did not go ahead and get the dye-based MRI done in season. The Braves were almost certain to be one of the WC teams and, player dedication or not, there’s a time for the organization to step up and figure out what the heck is going on with the shoulder.
I know hindsight is 20/20, but it’s not like BMac was hitting much in September anyway.
October 16th, 20123:11 pm
Just let him go. I know, I know, local kid, he’s performed well in the past, but honestly, even IF the guy recovers from this reasonably well he’s a DH at this point. We’d be far better off with a platoon of something like Ross/Gattis, Ross/Boscan, etc. than to watch McCann struggle through yet another sub-par defensive season behind the plate. Just let him go, it’s not like the American League won’t come knocking at his door…
He couldn’t throw anybody out before he injured his arm.
Pass on the 2013 option and let McCann go to the AL and be a DH.
Warm & Cuddly
October 16th, 20123:15 pm
“Don’t trade him now FW as next year he will likely return back to being his normal self – or better” – Skeezix
You gotta love the dreamers !
October 16th, 20123:18 pm
You have to decline that option. And not because you think there is a better catcher on the market but because you can take that money and think much bigger for LF and CF. Go with solid defense behind the plate and put the money into some solid outfielders, who will play more than a catcher, and make an impact. McCann has been solid but even if they pick up that option he won’t be back long term. Time to move on.
Hey, YEAH Hose! Great idea! We could re-sign Hinske, Overbay and Batista. Then, throw in McCann to the Angels for Trout. That’s a 4-for-1 deal. Heck, we’ll even pay half of Trout’s salary. Great deal!
You know, if that works, maybe we could re-sign Smoltz and Glavine and trade them to Detroit for Verlander. Wow! You’re a genius!
October 16th, 20123:30 pm
The smart move is to pick up the option, let insurance cover time missed and then see how he is. Perhaps a trade in July if neccesary.
October 16th, 20123:31 pm
Enter your comments here
Do not pick up the option. It is too much to pay for someone so damaged.
October 16th, 20123:36 pm
We wish you the very best with your surgery today Brian. Looking forward to you and David Ross returning next year. Go Braves!
October 16th, 20123:37 pm
I’m still trying to figure out why so many were so surprised at the defensive misques in the “play-in” game. I realize we supposedly had the “best defense” in the NL, but seriously, our infield consisted of a 40 yr old with basically one leg under him, a season-long revolving door at SS, a muscle-bound boob at 2B, and the pillsbury doughboy behind the plate. Either there was some hell-acious home town scoring helping them out exponentially, or MLB has REALLY tightened up the criteria for what can now be scored an error. It was no surprise what happened in that game to me at all…
October 16th, 20123:38 pm
I’m betting “a fan” knows what he (assumption) speaks of.
Brave New World
October 16th, 20123:39 pm
Hope all goes well, B-Mac!
October 16th, 20123:41 pm
I heard a rumor we are trading Hansen and Jurrjens to the Angels for Trout!
Evan Gettis deserves a shot hits for average monster power and good defensively as well. He is playing winter ball and doing great.
October 16th, 20123:43 pm
a fan, I agree 100%. I think the Braves will pick up the options on McCann, Hudson, and Maholm, and all three could be trade bait at next year’s deadline if the Braves are out of it.
But I HOPE we are a better team next year, and I think with the cash that we will free up, the potential is there.
October 16th, 20123:44 pm
Who paid for his surgery? If the Braves did then obviously they are planning on picking up the option.
October 16th, 20123:49 pm
DOB – Thanks as always for all the hard work and very extensive coverage…it’s very much appreciated…hope you have a great offseason…
Just for some clarification on Mac’s surgery, you mentioned that the procedure today was in the posterior portion of the shoulder and would prevent some of the subluxation issues Mac was having. Do you know if the procedure today repaired the frayed labrum and/or addressed the cyst that was found in the MRI he had in August. Just wanted to get some clarity since you specified that any procedure that went into the front part of the shoulder could have jeopardized part or most of his 2013, so I wasn’t sure if the frayed labrum could have been in the front part and it was decided that it was too extensive a procedure to address that based on the extent of his damage. Thanks.
October 16th, 20123:50 pm
What is wrong with the collective memory? No mention of the heralded defensive prospect in the farm system. Use Bethancourt to alternate with Rossy until Mac returns and tell him no worries about his hitting. He is already fabulous defensively and will throw out opposition runners. Then send him back to AA or AAA to work more on the hitting stroke. He would be the catching equivalent of Paul Janish.
October 16th, 20123:54 pm
dean: you do realize that while in the minors and still trying to play SS, Chipper’s team had to hand out hard hats to fans not protected by the screen behind 1B because he was so prone to let throws sail into the stands? After a 19 yr career, it’s not like we didn’t know what we had there. Don’t get me wrong, I’m a huge Chipper fan, but let’s call a spade a spade. The guy was never that great on D. He lead all NL third basemen in errors more than once if I recall correctly, back when he could still move well enough to TRY to get to more balls. Ugly Dan is what Ugly Dan is, a LF who insanely insists on playing 2B, once again, we knew what we had there. SS was primarily handled throughout the year by 2 good glovemen, but the almost constant switching around due to inconsistent hitting and/or injuries is never a good thing for a well-gelled infield. McCann was a very average defensive catcher at his absolute best, and that we ain’t seen in about 3 yrs now. Like I said, that play-in game just proved a microcosm of all the problems the Braves have refused to deal with for the past 2 yrs and they all came home to roost at once…
Well, BravesFan, so glad there were no surprises in the wild card game for you. Since Ross played a lot of the last two months behind the plate, not sure if you are calling him doughboy. Sorry you’re so very upset over the Braves’ loss, but there’s always next year. Maybe they’ll play to your expectations.
October 16th, 20123:58 pm
Bethancourt isn’t projected to be part of the big league club’s plans that soon, he’s still too raw in his hitting approach is the word out on him to date…
October 16th, 20124:01 pm
Ross was one of the bright spots in that game and he didn’t play THAT much last year. McCann still played the lion’s share of the games even when it became horribly obvious he shouldn’t have…
October 16th, 20124:03 pm
I say let him walk with this length of injury rehab. Shoppach would be a good option with Ross. Rumors also have Soto being non tendered by Tex. Seattle also may be willing to deal Jaso. Plenty of options out there that will be a lot cheaper and provide better defense and cut down on the running game. Other than Ross I can see the Braves resigning Johnson, possibly Dubin, Moylan to a minor league deal. I also expect big plays for Headley, Pagan to be signed for CF, and offers for a strong LF. Prado? With the funds saved this off season and the fact Wren has now shown the willingness to change previous bad moves, I would not be surprised if Uggla is pushed on and most of his contract absorbed by the Braves. Hey, anything is possible.
October 16th, 20124:07 pm
I for one, would like to have seen Chipper moved to 1B about 5-6 years ago, and Freddie Freeman should have then been developed as a 3B in the minors (the guy has great hands and one of the strongest arms in the organization). Hell, if MC can “play” 3B for Detroit, just how fleet of foot do you really have to be?
October 16th, 20124:09 pm
Possibly, you misinterpreted my question. Because I really don’t know, I was asking if there was anybody who might be able to handle the job.
October 16th, 20124:10 pm
Exercise the Option.
Those of you who say “let him go” will be the same ones saying “Fire Frank Wren for letting BMac go”
when he hits 25-30 homers, gets 90+RBI’s, and leads his team through the playoffs while the Braves sit at home & watch.
October 16th, 20124:12 pm
Tom if McCann hits for those kinds of numbers EVER again, it will be as a DH…
October 16th, 20124:14 pm
Quick!!! Where is Biff Porcoroba???
October 16th, 20124:20 pm
Dean – No, there isn’t anyone in the system currently who would be able to help at the major league level next year. Bethancourt could very well be ready defensively right now and even be an asset shutting down the running game, but just turned 21 and has only had maybe 250 AB’s above A ball. He needs more AB’s at the AA/AAA level to further develop offensively and so the FO will be able to assess whether he will be able to hit enough at the big league level.
Gattis bat is very, very intriguing (huge RH power bat) and there’s an outside shot he could help offensively as soon as in the spring. However, it definitely appears he’s going to be moved from behind the plate (he kinda even has already – prob LF). He is off to great start in VZ winter league (he’s been DHing down there).
October 16th, 20124:23 pm
So to further address, anyone who was talking about Ross/Boscan or Ross/Gattis platoons next year that just isn’t realistic, if you were thinking Mac’s option should be declined in favor of one of those scenarios.
October 16th, 20124:28 pm
what would be so bad about Ross/Boscan? Both are great defensively and Ross when hot hits for as good a power as McCann. We’ve been too relient on C for offense for too long, going all the way back to Javy. Good defense up the middle, power on the corners, that’s how you win and that’s what we need to get back to (sorry Ugly Dan)…
October 16th, 20124:35 pm
Good luck Brian. We need you in Atlanta! You’re a great player.
October 16th, 20124:36 pm
Heap. Thanks..from a lifelong casual, rabid (if there can be such a thing) baseball fan.
October 16th, 20124:40 pm
Get a rent-a-catcher for 2013 to allow time for Bethancourt to season in the minors.
Picking up McCann’s option after major arm surgery is a disaster in the making !
October 16th, 20124:42 pm
I agree Big John, especially when you consider what that extra money might mean for a big bat for 3B or LF…
October 16th, 20124:43 pm
I guess if I follow the illogic of this blog, San Francisco should have dumped Posey because he broke his leg and would never again be what he was???? Get serious, McCann when healthy is one of the top catchers in baseball and in the prime of his career turning 29 in Feb.
October 16th, 20124:48 pm
Posey was what? 22 or 23 when he broke his leg? Stupid comparison, not even remotely the same thing, plus Posey is an ATHLETE, he could play anywhere on the field. Illogical, geez…
October 16th, 20124:49 pm
This is good news, big confirmation that something was physiologically wrong and cause of Macs hitting woes. Anyone who says not to pick up option needs to take another look at that FA list above, and don’t say “sign Ruiz.”
October 16th, 20124:54 pm
Puma, whay do we need a big bat behind the plate? What IF, that freed up money not signing McCann meant the difference in landing somebody like Wright for 3B of Hamilton for LF? Not saying either of those 2 will happen, but still, hypothetically, what if?
October 16th, 20124:57 pm
It’s a great thing BRIAN McCANN is having his shoulder surgery now instead of later because this way he will be TOTALLY READY by OPENING DAY in 2013.Speaking of the POSTSEASON,tonight’s GAME is a MUST-WIN GAME for the yankees,ESPECIALLY about the FACT that the yankees have a ZERO SHOT at WINNING the FALL CLASSIC or even getting to the FALL CLASSIC–not to mention they no longer even have derek jeter available in their lineup.
October 16th, 20124:58 pm
6 time allstar, 5 time Silver Slugger turning 29, his career is not over and we have NO ONE to replace him. Not an athlete???
October 16th, 20125:04 pm
BravesFan – because it makes more sense to have Mac next year at $13 mil vs someone like Hamilton for $20-25 million. If they could get Wright…well that’s may be a different matter. Plus, picking up option for 1 year is not a huge risk vs. signing Mac to extension. If they bring in someone like Hamilton or Wright they will have to extend 6+ years to get them…now that is what I call risk @ $20mil+ per year.
October 16th, 20125:06 pm
Where else on the diamond, with the current team in place, could McCann play other than catcher(which is obviously wearing him down and shortening his career)? That’s what I mean by athlete. Posey could play either corner outfield spot, or either first or third. Athlete. In fact, they didn’t know for sure what they were gonna do with him when he first came up because he could play any of those on top of catching and they weren’t sure about the wear and tear and his body from catching, but Posey got a bug in his ear about catching and then after breaking his leg, didn’t want the entire league thinking he was a pansy by moving to 1B or wherever, so there you go. He’s an athlete, McCann is a DH…
You’re very welcome, Dean
October 16th, 20125:08 pm
ordinarily I wouldn’t go in for a big contract, especially after the Ugly Dan fiasco, but if David Wright were willing to play in Atlanta for 5-6 years, I say, where’s the dotted line!!!!!!!!!!
October 16th, 20125:10 pm
Mikey, how many gold gloves are there on McCann’s shelf?
October 16th, 20125:13 pm
Would you sign Wright for 8 years $160 mil? That is a long time. 5-6 years at $100-$120, I could see that, maybe, but still an awful lot for a team with <$100 mil in payroll.
October 16th, 20125:17 pm
no, not for that much, if closer to the 120 figure, yes, in spades…
October 16th, 20125:20 pm
This might be it for Mac in ATL. He had a heck of a run, but honestly he’s got health problems already and he’s only 28! I think it might be best off for everyone to skip his option and let him sign with an AL team next season. He could switch to a part time catcher role and hit in the DH spot when he’s hurt which is way too often for his age.
I wish the stupid National League would just adopt the DH, guys like Chipper who can’t field very well anymore but still have some offensive production left in the tank could stick around another couple years. The way its set up now, all the aging stars sign with the AL to extend their careers a couple years and the NL gets shafted.
Bravos just need to start locking up some guys headed towards arbitration and we’ll be set for years. The Gnats claim they are going to be good for quite some time and they almost expect to win the Division every season from here on out, well we might have something to say about that and I hope we prove them WRONG! We have a whole lot of young guys like Heyward and Freeman who can play as good as anyone. Also, Uggla needs to get his stuff together and snap out of this 2 year slump next season.
Get well B-Mac and no matter what, good luck bud.
October 16th, 20125:22 pm
Just for some clarification on Mac’s surgery, you mentioned that the procedure today was in the posterior portion of the shoulder and would prevent some of the subluxation issues Mac was having. Do you know if the procedure today repaired the frayed labrum and/or addressed the cyst that was found in the MRI he had in August. — Heap 16
Haven’t gotten specifics yet, but I’m sure they wouldn’t go in without removing cyst or getting rid of it in whatever manner. Fraying of labrum isn’t fixed like a torn labrum, not stitched together. From what I’m told, at least. But I’ll let you know what they say after the procedure, and make sure that was what the dye-contrast MRI showed last week.
October 16th, 20126:08 pm
“Who paid for his surgery? If the Braves did then obviously they are planning on picking up the option.”
We should assume that the injury was incurred while in the employ of the Braves. So, I don’t expect that much can be concluded from the fact the team is paying for his medical care. OK?
We talk baseball, other sports, music, movies, BBQ and whatever (except politics or religion)
Atlanta Braves RSS feed
Previous entries »
Send a feedback technical issue
Vacation stops, manage subscriptions and more
Visitor Agreement | Privacy Statement© 2013 The Atlanta Journal-Constitution