Eat healthier on a budget

When it comes to nutritious food, anthropologists might say this country has a cultural narrative — a story line for how we frame our lives — and it goes like this:

It costs more money to eat healthy.

But this isn’t necessarily true, and it’s pushing us into a spiral of malnutrition.

healthyeats.1013“Sometimes we use that as an excuse,” says nutrition specialist Ricia Taylor, with health plan giant Kaiser Permanente’s Georgia region. “Ounce for ounce, it’s actually cheaper to eat an apple than it is a bag of chips. Oftentimes, for what we pay for french fries, we could get two pieces of fruit.”

There are common-sense exceptions, Taylor says, such as not buying every thing on your grocery list at a high-end natural foods store when some items can be found cheaper elsewhere. Or not buying produce that’s out of season — and, thus, more expensive .

But when it comes to convenience foods, she says, most of the time those products “are always going to cost you more money.”

And some of the most nutrient-rich foods are also the cheapest, says Trulie Ankerberg, a nutritionist whose website, AtlantaNutrition.com, offers advice on healthy living.

“Most of the year you can get collard greens very cheaply,” she says. “Their growing season is very long here.

“The DeKalb Farmers Market has a 10-pound bushel of collard greens for $2. So you can get many meals out of that $2 and still get the most bang for your buck.”

Also, she says, consider planning some meals around a different protein source: legumes.

“They have high amounts of protein and also good-quality carbohydrates because they’re slow-glucose response. Those are probably the cheapest source of protein around,” Ankerberg says. “So you can still throw together dinner in 30 minutes with a 49-cent bag of lentils.”

And forget the old myths about eggs and embrace their protein powers when , Taylor says.

“It is not the cholesterol in eggs that’s driving our health to pieces,” she says. “It’s the saturated and trans fat [from other sources].”

Both nutritionists say buying in bulk or family-size is a great way to save. Taylor says another strategy is to buy meat that’s discounted because its expiration date is approaching. Just take it home, portion it out and put it in the freezer for up to one year, depending on the type of meat.

Take a fresh view

Another myth that can mislead would-be healthy eaters is the reputations consumers attach to certain grocery chains. Try throwing your biases out the window about which one has the more nutritious food or which one’s more expensive.

For example, Taylor touts the enormous containers of spices you can buy at farmers markets — at a fraction of the cost for sizes usually found at major grocery chains.

“You will get lemon pepper seasoning, and the first ingredient is salt,” she says. “But at the farmers market it’s not going to have the sodium in there.

“I love the lemon pepper because of the twang of the lemon, and it tastes like you’ve added salt even though you haven’t.”

And discount chain Walmart has begun offering higher-quality fresh produce and a better range of frozen foods, Ankerberg says.

“You’re not going to get everything there, but for getting the basics and meeting your nutrient needs in the cheapest possible way, it’s a good option.”

She also recommends specialty foods chain Trader Joe’s for organic frozen fruit, nuts and seeds. For instance, a particular brand of almond butter, which can cost up to $15, sells at Trader Joe’s for $4.99, Ankerberg says.

“It’s really just keeping an eye out for your basic staples at different stores.”

Speaking of organic, how important is it to eat pesticide-free food?

“Personally, if I’m going to buy something organic, it’s something that I’m going to be eating the skin off of,” Taylor says. “In terms of overall health, if I’m on a budget, I pick my battles.”

Ankerberg says she’s seen people get so exasperated at buying expensive organic apples that they throw in the towel and buy potato chips.

“If budget is your No. 1 concern, then getting produce, period, should be your top priority. It’s still going to be tons better for your health, even if it’s not pesticide-free.”

Planning ahead

When it comes to meals, a little preparation goes a long way, says Bill Mitchell, an Atlanta resident who’s lost 42 pounds in the past three years.

“Some people think you can’t be healthy and be cost-conscious,” Mitchell says. “But you can be both.”

He totes a packed lunch to his job as a senior director at Hotel SystemsPro, an Atlanta technology firm, spending about $15 a week on food. That saves him an estimated $600 to $700 a year, in addition to keeping his waistline trim.

“I know there’s 900 calories in that bag,” Mitchell says. “That’s all I need from 8 a.m. to 6 p.m.”

Taylor agrees preparation is key when buying groceries. Determining a budget, making a list and then sticking to it will set you up for success.

“Proper planning prevents poor performance,” she says. “Once we get hungry and go to the grocery store, it’s all over.”

More: Inexpensive mealsStock up on these healthy staplesTry this healthy recipe

– By Lauren Davidson, Atlanta Bargain Hunter

Follow me on Facebook | Twitter | Email

13 comments Add your comment

[...] This post is a sidebar to “Eat healthier on a budget.” [...]

Li

October 19th, 2011
11:15 am

I totally agree with this story. I hate eating at school because I always feel like I’m getting the shorter end of the stick paying $5 for 1 chicken sandwich and upwards of $10 for 1 meal (that’s drink and side included). Dollars for calories, the price is probably correct, but not only is my stomach not fuller than the usual, my wallet is feeling lighter. I like the convenience especially on those busy days when I’m frantically running out of the door, but I would trade it to have more time to put together my lunches any day. But I do honestly hate the selection at the school cafe.

Kar

October 19th, 2011
12:31 pm

I’m curious where they buy their fruit. Even in the “cheap” stores, fruit is ridiculously expensive. On average even a nectarine is more than a dollar a piece. Meanwhile, a huge bag of chips are still less than a dollar or less in a lot of stores.

Faye Lewis

October 19th, 2011
1:34 pm

I live in South Georgia and our Farmer’s markets are very high priced. I paid $8 for a lb of peas the last time I was in one. Yes, they were in season. Also, Lentils are about 2 dollars in a supermarket and about a dollar at Walmart. I buy them regularly and have never paid 50 cents a bag. Black beans are very expensive. I buy them too.

Owl in the ATL

October 19th, 2011
3:01 pm

Great article! I think a lot of tips were good; especially the one about planning ahead. Most all of us could improve in that area. For instance, I have no clue what I would do with a 10 lb bushel of greens, even though we eat greens almost every night! But maybe if I planned ahead and split them with a neighbor that would turn into a spectacular idea.
I do often like to find out what is seasonal from this calendar published by GA Organics and plan my week’s worth of meals around it: http://www.georgiaorganics.org/Calendars/harvestcalendar.pdf

John

October 19th, 2011
3:15 pm

There is another exception. That is when one lives in a food “swamp” where unhealthy choices are essentially the only accessible options. People in poorer neighborhoods and without good transportation don’t have access to full blown grocery stores and instead have to rely on corner stores or convenience stores. People eat not only what is affordable, but also what is accessible.

Eric

October 20th, 2011
12:32 pm

I really wanted to chime in here. I am a new found believer in this article. I’m a single guy who has eaten healthy my entire life, and I am one of those people that have always thought you have to spend a great deal more money to eat healthy. Up until about a month ago, my weekly grocery bill would be around $140 for just me. Then I read an interesting article/blog on AJC a few weeks ago about the woman that wanted to see if she could live on what is given in food stamps. While I totally understood her perspective, what I really found interesting where the responses. Many folks chimed in and said that they very easily feed their families on this lesser amount and that they eat a lot of fruits and veggies. I found this damn near impossible to believe, so I took the challenge. Instead of shopping strictly at my favorite store, I stopped into a produce store on my way to the grocery store. I picked up my fruits and veggies (and even my deli meats) at drastically lower prices. I then shopped the grocery store to get the best food I could – overlooking the healthy convenience foods – sticking with the healthy versions that I had to prepare at home. While I was unable to maintain my healthy diet on what someone gets in food stamps ($30 per week according to the article), I was able to cut my food shopping from $140 per week to about $75 per week. When you do the math, that saves me over $3,000 annually. It really is all about smart shopping and being willing to do a little extra food prep. While I will never be the one that shops at 5 different stores to save a bit of money (makes no sense when you consider the cost in time and gas), I will definitely stick to what I’ve been doing the last few weeks. I am now a believer.

GFMom

October 22nd, 2011
6:22 pm

Try doing Gluten Free cheap….It’s near impossible.

Sam

October 22nd, 2011
7:49 pm

Excellent point, John, about the “food swamp.” Would love to see an article that takes into consideration the realities of geography, income, transportation, and work schedule. What would be an ideal grocery list for $30/week for a person (not even family) working two jobs, taking public transportation, with no Trader Joe’s, Costco, Whole Foods, etc. in a 15 mile radius?

Lyle Mandrake

October 22nd, 2011
8:21 pm

Foods are not “healthy”; they are “healthful”.

Lyle Mandrake

October 22nd, 2011
8:22 pm

Enter your comments here

...

October 22nd, 2011
8:23 pm

I disagree with the “food swamp.” Low income Hispanics with no transportation have access to fresh produce and bakery items. There’s one down the street from me that’s small, but clean… and it’s *always* busy. It’s all a matter of priority.

Frugalady

October 22nd, 2011
8:31 pm

My family of 6 spends an average of $150/week on groceries, which is frugal but not restrictive… We eat plenty of meat & fresh produce, plus some splurges :) We could cut back a LOT before we’d hit starvation levels or literal beans-and-rice.

If a single person finds it difficult to live on $30/week, then maybe they could try pooling their resources to buy in bulk or sharing their cooking with a friend… Just a thought.