
Associated Press photo of Victoria Beckham, guest judge
Welcome folks! Here we are for season nine!
There was definitely some talent out of Boston, though many of the 31 singers who made it to Hollywood were from New York or elsewhere. We’ll see if New England can break its futility streak soon enough.
After the requisite beginning, including the “news” of Paula Abdul’s departure, we start with Janet, who is clearly godawful without having to hear her sing. But she is sure excitable. Of course, when we do finally hear “Pocketful of Sunshine,” we found only darkness — and a muffin top!
Maddy Curtis, 16, has several siblings with Down’s Syndrome. Tears alert! “I’ve been watching the show since I was eight,” she said. (Time flies!) She does “Hallelujah” by Leonard Cohen. At least she doesn’t sound at all like Jason Castro. She’s a bit raw but there is potential. And she seems sweet in a genuine way.
Pat Ford is a “deluded” one, the type producers love. Full of (holla!) spice, Pat is energetic and positively awful doing Britney Spears’ “Womanizer.” “Stop singing forever,” Randy said. “I’m going to see you next season,” Pat told the judges after he was canned. “That’s going to be special,” said Simon, who won’t actually be there if they bring Pat back.
Ryan notes that the woman are hot this season (or the producers simply snuffed out any decent guys in the early rounds and focused on the women.) Jennifer Hirsh from Manhattan did a bit of jazz and was enchanting. Claire Fuller from Philadelphia goes all Mr. Big and Miss Wonderful. Jess Wolfe from New York is a bit old-fashioned but pretty darn good.
Check out the nice guy Italian-American bartender Amadeo Diricco from Rhode Island. He’s someone who we’ve never quite seen before. And he has some serious blues chops. “I feel like I’m home with my cousin,” said Kara DioGuardi. ”In a strange way, it was my favorite audition of the day,” Simon said. I hope this guy goes far.
Derek Hilton, a Bellingham MA landscaper, is very very nasal. Way too nasal. Like the hair. Deluded, too. After the break, Mere Doyle, anime freak, screams Janis Joplin. And I mean screams. She’s rejected but didn’t go without a fight. Yawn.
Luke Shaffer, a waiter from New York, is a bit theatrical but not bad. I presume since he’s a New York City waiter, he’s probably a struggling actor. Benjamin Bright, an elementary music teacher from Rome NY is cute and has a sweet voice.
Grouchy Smart Ass Clark Kent, err… Andrew Fenlon (unemployed musician) … finally makes it to the audition room. He hated waiting around, he said. He’s quite amusing with his obnoxious statements. He’s not bad but he’s so unlikable, it’s hard to imagine anyone wanting to watch him. “Are you angry?” Kara said. “Just from waiting,” Andrew said. “For you to have a bad attitude kind of pisses me off,” Kara said. “I don’t like you AT ALL.”
“You have very bad energy,” Simon said. Kind of the oppositve of Amadeo. Simon is the only one who says yes. He’s bemused by the guy. As Kara said, “You need a spanking!” She also said he’s like Simon, minus the charm.
Ryan notes the many students of music in Boston, especially Berkeley School of Music. Two examples: Bill Bloom, a music teacher and Michael Ryan, a college student, are over the top. Ashley Rodriguez is pretty and is a decent singer to boot. “Very sultry,” Kara said. “You may have IT,” Simon said. She’s clearly someone the producers will pimp out in Hollywood.
Tyler Grady, the Nazareth, Pa. drummer who broke his wrists falling out of a tree, sexed it up with “Let’s Get It On.” The women loved him. He is vibrant, packed with personality. “You have good taste,” Simon said. “This is an audition I will remember.” (And he often say he quickly forgets 99% of them.)
Bo Bice is doing a Moe’s ad! Good for him!
Back story time! Lisa Olivero is a waitress with no singing background. She really needs singing lessons. She has some potential but went for too difficult of a song (Mariah Carey!) Then a bunch of wack jobs on day two. Mike Davis, an actor, entertains on a “Codzilla” boat on the water, doing all sorts of whirls and turns. He does a pretty good “Yesterday.”
9:20 p.m.: sob story time part two! Katie Stevens has a grandmother with Alzheimer’s. “She’s not going to remember me for much longer so I want her to see me succeed in my dream before she forgets who I am,” Katie said. Sniff. She takes the Idol auditon staple “At Last” and blows it out. She could use a little work in the image department but she has skills. “For 16 to be able to sing like that is amazing,” Kara said.
Joshua Blaylock, 28, from New York, is on the other end of the age limit. He does a decent version of Rascal Flatts even with a couple of bum notes. I like this guy and the judges do feel a warmth about him. Simon first castigates him: “That voice would have been great if you were 14… no presence, no power, no originality. Unfortunately, Joshua, forgettable.” Joshua admits he needs to be more assertive. When Randy tells him to say, “Shut up Simon!” He says “Shut up Simon–please!” He ultimately gets a yes – even from Simon! Simon is clearly getting a little soft, eh?
A couple of lousy singers open the next segment, including bad country dude and clueless quiet Asian guy. That leads to sob story #3 of the night. Justin Williams got cancer while serving a mission in Spain when he was 20. “It’s an interesting, humbling experience,” he said. He is now cancer free. (They don’t identify what cancer–given his age, it’s probably testicular.) He’s a vocal coach all the way from Utah. He has personality and charm. You can tell immediately he’s off to Hollywood. Victoria uses the word “nice” plenty of times. “I’m going to remember you,” Kara said.
The second-to-last break: Norberto Guerrero of Reading PA mauls Cascada. Looks like someone threw a skinned cat on his head. And he swallowed the rest of the cat.
Next! Bosa Mora, whose parents are from Nigeria, gets a bit of back story. He’s decent. I’m not sure how far he’d get in Hollywood. Victoria gets combative with Simon and his eye rolling. Simon says no. Victoria says yes. “Based on the voice,” Kara said, “I have to say yes.” Randy gives him the ticket.
Final break and final contestant. Long Island native Leah Lorenti, 22, who grew up in church and couldn’t listen to secular music. She’s adorable. Obviously being the last one we see tonight, she’s good, too. Great tone and vocal control. Yowza! She could use a bit more stage presence but that didn’t hurt Carrie or Jordin. “One of the best I’ve seen in Boston,” Randy said.
Random observations: New sign in the back, which no longer includes ALL the winners. It simply features Kris Allen. I also noticed that they are more willing to show the booms, the camera people and the production staff. Stunning Boston harbor backdrop.
Victoria Beckham looks more like Scary Spice. Or Plastique Spice. Or Keep Away From Me Spice. Bleh…
And I saw the promo for Atlanta. Holly Hardin, the Rockmart, GA gal I met at the auditions and was on “America’s Got Talent,” shows up for a millisecond. I figured she’d make it to the judges.
Join my Facebook fan page and Twitter.
226 comments Add your comment
Bud
January 13th, 2010
12:17 pm
You been smoking weed american mom?
Nana
January 13th, 2010
12:23 pm
They would probably say Atlanta. She lives in the Between community. I so hope they will show her, but I’m not getting my hopes up since she had to cancel. BTW, so far her and both babies are still doing good. She has already been put on bed rest and she’s not due till April.
veemmmgee
January 13th, 2010
12:24 pm
It’s time for this show to go with Simon – it is getting very tired…
Nana
January 13th, 2010
12:29 pm
You know what gets me here is that all the posters that supposely dosen’t care for Idol will take the time to read the comments and then POST their own. Go figure!
JTesla
January 13th, 2010
12:30 pm
So Deirdre, when Rodney is gone will someone behind the curtain be creating a new entry for each show or are we going to have one that hits page 10? That actually could be kind of fun.
Rickster
January 13th, 2010
12:35 pm
That’s one of my favorite city names, Nana.
“Where ya from?”
“Between”
“Between what?”
“Between Ga.”
“Between Georgia and what?”
etc etc etc
Rickster
January 13th, 2010
12:35 pm
And it’s great to hear good news about the babies. Do they know the gender(s) yet?
Deirdre
January 13th, 2010
12:38 pm
Hey guys, I took a nap.
JT, Rodney has given me a list of about 5 ajc people who I will email the blog entries for the week. It’s up to them to post the entries. I have no idea why they wouldn’t trust me with the password and other really essential powers. Does anyone else know?
I bet I could get a 10 pager going next week! I’ll have to give it a try.
Heather MacDonald
January 13th, 2010
12:56 pm
Deirde, All you’ll have to do is post something about Archie or Adam and you’ll be off and running with it!
Tinactin
January 13th, 2010
12:59 pm
Bananas…You gotta get down with the drivebys and chill. Some are just curious as to how many biters will be chokin the phone lines this year. Keeping it real and seeing who’s phat-free and by the comments made here, aint’ no place for koolios.
Rickster
January 13th, 2010
1:00 pm
Geez, your highness…. other than sending their entire legal staff into comas… I can’t think of any reason.
Rickster
January 13th, 2010
1:17 pm
Tinactic.. I have absolutely NO idea what you just wrote.
I guess I am as much of a middle-aged white guy as I feared.
Rickster
January 13th, 2010
1:21 pm
Or “Tinactin” even. Sorry about that.
Nana
January 13th, 2010
1:23 pm
Rickster she has one each. Getting two for the price of one.
I know what you mean about Between. Her mom used to live there and people would ask her the same questions. Nearly 30 years ago, Between was between Split Silk and Monroe or Loganville, depending which way you were headed. Now, the Spilt Silk community is no longer there.
Deirdre, it would be something if you generated more action here than Rodney does. You may have to come out of retirement if that happen!
kelly&carriefan
January 13th, 2010
1:34 pm
Hey y’all,
I’m moving tomorrow so I semi watched. There were some really good (the girls with the brothers and the nana) and some terrible. The usual Idol fare. Hoping I can squeeze in some of the Atlanta auditions, but not sure. Seems live blogging last night was up and running.
D, can’t wait to see you subbing for Rodney. Hope you’re feeling better.
Nana, Carla’s story would make great TV, so maybe they will show her.
Rickster
January 13th, 2010
1:44 pm
I used to think that Between was between Atlanta and Athens. Now I know better.
Heck, I can remember when Snellville was in “the country.”
Rickster
January 13th, 2010
1:45 pm
Deidre, do you get to wear a hat like Rodney’s?
Rickster
January 13th, 2010
1:47 pm
Hey Nana, If (there’s a season 10) AI comes to Atlanta again, will Carla be eligible to try out again? Or will the demands of twins keep her close to home?
Nana
January 13th, 2010
1:59 pm
Just received an email from linnie and she asked that I let it be known that her home computer is fried and she can access anything at the present time. But, she misses being here and will be back asap.
JTesla
January 13th, 2010
2:05 pm
Poor Linny… the world is conspiring against her as far as the real important stuff (Idol blogging).
Magenta
January 13th, 2010
2:05 pm
Rodney, it sure doesn’t sound as though cancer has ever struck you or a loved one; otherwise, you wouldn’t be making trashy speculative comments about what sort of cancer Justin Williams has.
Nana
January 13th, 2010
2:05 pm
I don’t know what her plans will be. She may have her hands full with two babies. She would be able to try out again, if she does choose to so.
Harm
January 13th, 2010
2:08 pm
Sorry Linny, that is not good news with idol just starting up! I’ts even worse that you can’t know that we miss you!
Rodney Ho
January 13th, 2010
2:09 pm
New blog entry up with ratings numbers. 2% drop in overall ratings vs. 2009 opener, up 1 percent 18-49.
Harm
January 13th, 2010
2:11 pm
Nana, I like the Ally girl on the Bachelor, the one who is scared to fly.
Wendy
January 13th, 2010
2:53 pm
It’s the Berklee College of Music, not BerkleY School of Music.